HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009/01/27 Item 8CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA STATEMENT
~~~~~ CITY OF
'~" CHULA VISTA
1/27/09, Item
ITEM TITLE: RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA SUPPORTING THE EXTENSION OF THE
CALIFORNIA HIGH SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY (CHSRA) HIGH
SPEED TRAIN ALIGNMENT, SOUTH OF THE SANTA FE
STATION IN SAN DIEGO TO THE~~:.H BAY REGION
SUBMITTED BY: DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS ~`+e, t
REVIEWED BY: ASSISTANT CITY NAGER S j
CITY MANAGER
4/STHS VOTE: YES ^ NO
SUMMARY
Established in 1996, the California High-Speed Rail Authority (Authority) is the state entity
responsible for planning, constructing and operating aHigh-Speed Train (HST) system serving
California's major metropolitan areas. With the certification of the Statewide Final Program-
Level Environmental Impact Report (EIR)/Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), the Authority
has begun implementation of the 800-mile high-speed train system serving Sacramento, the San
Francisco Bay Area, the Central Valley, Los Angeles, the Inland Empire, Orange County and
San Diego. The HST alignment presently being studied terminates at the Santa Fe train station in
downtown San Diego. The City would like to pursue studying extending the alignment of the
HST into the South Bay.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The Environmental Review Coordinator has reviewed the proposed activity for compliance with
the Califomia Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and has determined that the activity is not a
"Project" as defined under Section 15378 of the State CEQA Guidelines therefore, pursuant to
Section 15060(c)(3) of the State CEQA Guidelines the activity is not subject to CEQA. Thus, no
environmental review is necessary.
RECOMMENDATION
Council adopt the resolution.
BOARDS/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
Not applicable.
8-1
1/27/09, Item~_
Page 2 of 3
DISCUSSION
Over the last 10 years, the Authority has completed the studies necessary to prepare for the
implementation of high=speed trains in California. The findings indicate that high speed trains
improve our travel opportunities, create jobs, remove greenhouse gases from the air, save energy
and the economy in general. Voter approval of Proposition lA on the November 4 ballot
provided $9 billion in bond funding for the 800-mile statewide HST network and $950 million to
finance capital improvements to commuter and intercity rail as well as local transit lines that will
connect existing infrastructure to the HST system.
The following discussion was taken in part from www.cahi~hspeedrail.ca.~ov.
The proposed system stretches over 800 miles and would connect San Diego, Los Angeles, the
Central Valley, San Francisco, and Sacramento. San Diego would be connected from Los
Angeles via the Inland Empire. High-speed train (HST) service along the Inland Corridor would
parallel Interstates 215 and 15 and extend south to downtown San Diego. HST service on the
coastal comdor would extend no further south than Irvine, as a result of environmental
constraints along the coast and in coastal communities between South Orange County and San
Diego.
The high-speed train system would lower the number of intercity automobile passengers on
highways by up to 70 million annually. What's more. it will cost less than half the cost of
expanding freeways and airports to meet future intercity travel demand and would eliminate the
need to construct 3000 lane miles of highways, 91 airport gates and five additional airport
runways.
High-speed trains will be capable of maximum speeds of 220 miles per hour with an expected
trip time from San Francisco to Los Angeles in 2 hours and 40 minutes. Forecasts indicate the
system could potentially carry over 100 million passengers per year by 2030.
What makes high-speed trains so safe?
High-speed trains are considered to be the safest and most reliable form of transportation. High-
speed trains operate on grade separated tracks designed for high-speeds. Most train accidents are
the consequence of passenger and freight trains using the same tracks and with a signaling and
switching system that depends on humans. Approximately 87% of California's 800-mile route
will be on new completely separate track reserved for the exclusive use of high-speed trains. The
key distinguishing reasons for the near perfect safety record of high-speed train travel in Europe
and Asia are summarized below. (The California High-Speed Rail Project will incorporate all of
these safety features, building upon the proven safety and design criteria used for existing high-
speed train systems in Europe and Asia):
The entire high-speed train system is fully access controlled and grade-separated
(there are no at grade crossings with roads, pedestrians, or other rail services),
eliminating pedestrian and motor vehicle conflicts.
The high-speed train systems are completely double-tracked with additional tracks at
intermediate stations to support express operations.
The trains are centrally monitored and controlled, effectively preventing operators
from making serious errors, stopping or slowing trains automatically in the event of
external problem such as earthquakes, objects falling on the tracks, or gale force
winds. High-speed train traffic control and communications systems are state-of-the-
8-2
1/27/09, Item
Page 3 of 3
art, regulated, and managed during all hours of operation. These systems monitor and
limit the train's speed, schedule, routing, and headway (following distance behind
another train). These systems, combined with the operator, have integral redundancy
and ensure safety.
• Heavy, conventional freight trains do not share infrastructure designed for high-speed
operations.
• High-speed trains use a cab signaling system that transmits commands directly to the
driver. This technology makes high-speed operation possible in darkness, rain, and
fog. In Japan, even moderate snowfall does not slow the Shinkansen because of
special ice-melting equipment built into the rail bed.
• Unlike aircraft, high-speed train systems are not subject to turbulence. Passengers
may sit without seat restraints and may stand and walk comfortably even at maximum
speeds and around curves.
DECISION MAKER CONFLICT
Staff has reviewed the property holdings of the City Council and has found no property holdings
within 500 feet of the boundaries of the property, which is the subject of this action.
FISCAL IMPACT
There is no impact to the General Fund as a result of this action.
ATTACHMENTS
1. California High Speed Rail Authority Flyer
Prepared by: David Kaplan, Transportation Engineer, Engineering Dept.
M: IEngineerlAGENDAICAS2009101-27-091CHSRA CAS 1-I 5-09 dek.doc
8-3
ATTACI-~rt~NT ~
CALIFORNIA HIGH-SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY -'
A Better Option for Southern California
.With voter approval of the
high-speed train bond in
November 2008,construction
is likely to begin as early as 2011
on an 800-mile statewide system
of high-speed trains that will move
people and goods like never before.
California High-Speed Train Proposed Route
Sacramento
fhe Problem;: Congestion
;;r California's population will grow to 50 million
people in 20 years, much of it in Southern
California. Already, Southern California has two
of the top five most congested urban areas in
the United States-Los Angeles and San Diego.
Traffic congestion costs California $20 billion
per year in wasted fuel and lost time.
California is the 12th largest source of
greenhouse gases on the planet.
i& 41%of California emissions come
from our transportation system.
+v High-speed trains will reduce congestion on
freeways and surface streets by creating high-
speed options for travelers, improved freight
movement and enhanced local commuter transit.
_= Los Angeles International Airport is quickly
reaching capacity. Heigh-speed trains are the
best means for moving passengers to and
from the Palmdale and Ontario airports.
High-speed trains use 1/3 the energy of air
travel and 1/5 the energy of auto travel.
t High-speed trains will reduce dependence
on foreign oil by up to 12.7 million barrels
per year.
8-5
SanFrancisco
Transbay Stc
Terminal•..oawan° ~
Millbrae-SFO ~.
Redwood City ~:
or Palo Alto
San Jose Diridon
Gilroy •
"High-speed rail holds the potential to
be a viable alternative to driving, to
help reduce traffic congestion, improve
air quality, and make getting to and
from the airport easier for everyone."
Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa
High-speed trains will eliminate over
12 billion pounds of the greenhouse gas
emissions that cause global warming
each year. That's equivalent to removing
more than one million vehicles from our
roads annually.
s;~ High-speed trains will be separated from
all crossing auto and pedestrian traffic.
and the system will be fenced to prevent
intrusion. High-speed trains will not share
tracks with freight services, but will be
immediately adjacent to existing tracks.
~ckton '
Downtown
' Modesto
Downtown
Merced
Fresno
Visalia/TUlare/Hanford
(potential)
•
Bakersfield
Palmdale Airport
Sylmar
- Burbank -~ Industry Ontario Airport
-LOS Angeles ~ ~ '-
f ~. Riverside
Norwalk ~,
.Anaheim ~.
livine
~ Murrieta
'. HST Preferred Alignmen65
Pmpesed High-Speed Commuter
Rail /HST Overlay
~ Stations
~ Potential Station
Map oYSetl On 3005 $Ifl[dviltln P,o~,ammtltic
t Nut anN eo3rtl caeen c ly, 2ep""/ 1aWn
Los Angeles Union
Station to Orange County
The existing rail corridor will be
used to bring high-speed train
service to Orange County with
a terminal at Anaheim (ARTIC
station), and later could be
extended as far south as Irvine
with a station at the Irvine
Transportation Center.
Los Angeles Union Station to
Riverside and San Diego
Existing rail corridors will be used
to bring direct high-speed train
service from Los Angeles to
Riverside with links to stations at
Ontario Airport and Riverside. From
Riverside to San Diego, the system
will follow the I-215/1-15 freeway
corridors with a station at Murrieta/
Temecula. To bring the trains to the
heart of downtown San Diego, the
train line will use the existing rail
corridor immediately adjacent to
the existing rail tracks.
Los Angeles Union Station
to Palmdale
Direct high-speed train service from
Palmdale to Los Angeles with multi-
modal stations at L.A. Union Station,
Burbank, Sylmar/San Fernando and
Palmdale Airport.
. ,..,
TY8V01 ROUte TravemTnine
~a,~,,.
Anaheim to San Francisco 2:57
Los Angeles to San Francisco 2:38
Los Angeles to San Diego 1:18
Burbank to Bakersfield :49
Ontario to San Francisco 3:02
Riverside to Merced 2:11
Anaheim to Modesto 2:09
Anaheim to Sacramento 2:36
Riverside to Palmdale :59
San Diego to Sacramento 3:35
San Diego to San Francisco 3:56
"A 20-minute high-speed train
ride from Anaheim to downtown
Los Angeles is a great way not
only to relieve traffic congestion
on freeways, but to also address
future needs."
- Anaheim Mayor Curt Pringle
CALIFORNfA HIGH-SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY
925 L Street, Suite 1425, Sacramento, CA 95814
www. cah i ghs peed rai I.ca. gov
RESOLUTION NO. 2009-
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA SUPPORTING THE EXTENSION OF THE
CALIFORNIA HIGH SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY (CHSRA)
HIGH SPEED TRAIN ALIGNMENT, SOUTH OF THE SANTA
FE STATION IN SAN DIEGO TO THE SOUTH BAY REGION
WHEREAS, the voters in the State of California passed proposition lA supporting the
issuance of bonds for a high speed train/rail system that runs from San Francisco to San Diego;
and
WHEREAS, the State of California High Speed Rail Authority has begun to solicit input
on the route the high speed train will take; and
WHEREAS, current plans for the high speed train are currently planned to terminate in
downtown San Diego; and
WHEREAS, this high speed train will act as an economic engine offering alternative
transportation for tourist and employees alike; and
WHEREAS, South San Diego County has tourism amenities, over 7,200 private sector
firms providing jobs to 88,600 residents; and
WHEREAS, South San Diego County is the location for the busiest border crossing in
the world, is the site of a newly approved port of entry and is the location for the proposed cross
border terminal.
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Chula Vista does
hereby support the extension of the California High Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) high speed
train alignment, south of the Santa Fe Station in San Diego to the South Bay region.
Presented by Approved as to form by
Richard A. Hopkins
Director of Public Works
~ 1~fr~zy
Bart C. Miesfe
City Attorney
8-8