The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2008/07/08 Additional information 07/07/2008 Customer Information 752078014 38807004 66566201 669478017 68516209 67531809 675332011 39656900 39656607 74751403 747422011 39644202 39641801 39662602 66765804 66756206 37626603 67172606 64923006 67733806 38613802 64235809 37337005 61525807 41409403 437198010 43723802 74736208 38836204 67521006 681246018 66721805 64534603 64529002 64528602 37008602 60519809 61536602 62626201 47527804 83823408 37351401 33247810 368530012 36455001 Total due $ 316.70 $ 309.39 $ 274.32 $ 418.33 $ 365.48 $ 477.25 $ 179.39 $ 488.86 $ 1,198.35 $ 284.50 $ 409.63 $ 679.26 $ 343.06 $ 360.32 $ 493.83 $ 614.55 $ 193.61 $ 205.72 $ 168.46 $ 382.55 $ 556.11 $ 338.57 $ 309.21 $ 369.38 $ 266.80 $ 160.97 $ 789.67 $ 354.63 $ 195.28 $ 187.74 $ 367.32 $ 646.61 $ 721.62 $ 494.78 $ 457.98 $ 388.87 $ 389.88 $645.15 $ 323.47 $731.57 $ 255.69 $ 201.54 $ 395.55 $ 177.40 $ 1,145.99 ~{f? ~ ~~zF.;E OlY OF CHULA VISfA Finance Department Collections Unit DELINQUENT SEWER LISTING ITEM# 9 Page: 1 Customer Information 36451001 240126011 392382013 37723402 36817006 61522605 623210014 623182013 37629000 757822011 692426013 34911402 34907801 360066021 360258031 75705809 75734204 39231407 39209807 681398016 48121007 48122604 435498015 43538208 66543401 665490027 62308606 36619400 64459201 649130016 46718209 48109808 414230025 437526010 447614016 419110014 41134208 40928207 39263006 39048203 39047407 45424607 621694014 62427805 62432205 69219802 41625402 66563001 39007802 25031604 48309404 37228608 37309002 47506206 43506603 43745405 64443002 67941004 Total due $ 1,507.85 $ 842.57 $ 360.32 $ 355.42 $ 438.21 $ 479.31 $ 333.16 $ 229.62 $ 360.32 $ 302.74 $ 803.29 $ 446.76 $ 201.54 $ 787.10 $ 659.77 $ 414.66 $ 325.47 $ 614.44 $ 441.76 $ 257.79 $ 314.75 $ 418.37 $ 851.48 $ 223.67 $ 435.74 $ 274.32 $ 274.32 $ 743.28 $ 448.50 $ 654.63 $ 751.76 $ 155.14 $ 275.52 $ 500.59 $ 242.69 $ 764.38 $ 149.38 $ 518.95 $ 947.64 $ 819.48 $ 305.15 $ 478.41 $ 521.63 $ 197.67 $ 401.88 $ 590.66 $ 146.41 $ 196.83 $ 220.54 $ 964.68 $ 603.32 $ 598.72 $ 551.16 $ 201.87 $ 179.18 $ 171.62 $ 555.32 $ 829.68 Page: 2 . - Customer Information 38257409 382546017 63433405 64224201 38237802 63427806 69358603 43528606 37244203 62460203 66714602 68337406 479086022 47926607 479090010 67161402 42527800 42525403 454354041 41653806 414138013 75237403 75428603 40217402 402158010 403276014 69146601 68113405 43739406 42505401 49617403 68726602 671426016 46739802 47724207 40325401 47018608 471158011 47117007 424258016 49631401 40317005 35811402 35811007 35807400 36216206 41364607 40607804 675366012 67737802 74740207 67135000 67752204 435146014 45443807 45439806 657330024 38221407 Total due $ 315.69 $ 503.29 $ 369.09 $ 198.25 $ 305.36 $ 400.98 $ 510.14 $ 286.66 $ 229.51 $ 500.47 $ 358.05 $ 350.73 $ 464.68 $ 189.74 $ 265.87 $ 400.89 $ 286.08 $ 468.29 $ 201.86 $ 545.04 $ 146.41 $ 342.92 $ 188.75 $ 209.92 $ 628.88 $719.03 $ 210.81 $ 360.74 $ 129.90 $ 181.92 $ 314.61 $ 240.74 $ 399.94 $ 435.86 $ 432.49 $351.21 $ 341.12 $413.13 $ 286.62 $ 331.94 $ 285.91 $ 276.52 $ 313.07 $ 315.73 $ 323.98 $ 455.83 $ 179.88 $ 422.62 $ 350.43 $ 250.37 $ 345.39 $ 188.13 $ 188.99 $ 360.29 $ 146.40 $ 245.25 $ 470.54 $ 325.50 Page: 3 . - Customer Information 636218014 42412207 39711802 ib5Z006J066E252G2 416358012 47339801 47936209 33214609 32942604 60527804 36428602 36420601 36435005 364386012 47113401 44531406 39215803 48509402 23631004 40433806 41945404 69580608 68710606 467294012 47311804 39612603 39635000 38826206 39623003 40826604 422414010 69509802 68540602 419590016 41038603 410374020 49806605 47108605 74729003 44527008 44713003 67119402 41905404 47031005 470242010 44513805 41026609 41030203 42043807 42416606 416122014 42409003 74711802 420522015 40823808 47308602 422066014 422086012 Total due $ 374.67 $ 561.89 $ 178.02 $ 209.18 $ 339.73 $ 655.28 $ 343.06 $ 660.67 $ 873.53 $ 261.35 $ 168.69 $ 412.04 $ 252.43 $ 474.63 $ 176.10 $ 178.44 $ 392.54 $ 1,337.64 $233.31 $ 566.28 $ 711.69 $ 318.54 $ 157.96 $ 238.00 $ 702.92 $ 348.56 $ 150.65 $ 248.33 $ 739.08 $ 262.53 $ 388.63 $ 657.77 $ 246.07 $ 156.50 $ 348.32 $ 320.94 $ 351.64 $ 181.52 $ 306.67 $ 438.55 $ 628.13 $ 526.80 $ 493.97 $ 762.85 $ 159.47 $ 146.41 $ 439.42 $ 149.72 $ 540.12 $ 468.87 $ 403.21 $ 399.56 $ 503.31 $ 1,424.44 $ 212.34 $ 198.50 $ 407.69 Page: 4 Customer Information 37817801 447206017 33225401 34738206 34737003 355254013 360534022 36052607 360506015 490282012 490378010 49029801 49036602 490386025 49046608 49805007 41227809 41312202 412170014 411206018 413470011 41117803 41245804 41307004 49063008 41459004 40918207 409542012 46105406 709122012 744138014 40907406 40957001 412616012 66941807 40405802 40935001 75217405 75217809 40421007 754254012 752650010 40419402 407138010 23839407 24416206 24411005 40256202 402498012 358730011 64712609 69435008 69538209 753126011 75320201 46123004 65724600 366378023 Total due $ 352.87 $ 633.09 $ 706.18 $ 740.81 $ 399.58 $ 328.75 $ 488.03 $ 348.40 $ 348.80 $ 242.19 $ 214.98 $ 285.61 $ 199.83 $ 310.85 $ 324.91 $ 451.57 $ 201.80 $ 1,096.22 $423.10 $ 413.94 $ 360.27 $ 556.83 $ 1,264.32 $ 966.37 $ 645.64 $ 342.45 $ 506.59 $ 588.79 $ 255.34 $ 728.32 $ 440.23 $ 711.37 $ 190.15 $ 375.34 $ 592.38 $ 535.23 $ 381.76 $ 485.55 $ 229.87 $ 131.48 $ 306.87 $ 644.43 $ 255.23 $ 146.41 $ 373.63 $ 492.83 $ 257.22 $ 685.68 $ 458.72 $ 266.41 $ 380.42 $ 183.88 $ 192.67 $ 267.25 $ 357.18 $ 277.84 $ 205.72 $ 802.91 Page: 5 Customer Information 236098012 236118016 23806206 23849403 48326209 48327003 75043300 403298010 65151404 65149004 65147101 38215806 63244608 609458015 24608207 37818301 39252602 68523002 64733803 48320608 48318205 34967404 36040606 36038206 32906602 23649004 302 Grand Totals Total due $ 475.11 $ 254.43 $ 612.03 $ 264.25 $ 437.99 $ 130.20 $ 475.66 $311.32 $ 229.87 $ 382.25 $ 182.09 $ 212.12 $ 783.65 $ 205.72 $ 403.37 $ 313.45 $ 375.95 $ 305.66 $ 501.88 $ 259.99 $ 584.92 $ 915.04 $ 548.31 $ 358.29 $ 196.33 $ 492.83 $ 125,296.16 Page: 6 . - ~~lt- ~...- - --- ~~=':-.;:;E" DELINQUENT TRASH LISTING ITEM# 10 CITY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 191413 5933601000 $139.60 187771 6220202700 $234.66 163933 6220122000 $10.00 192298 6435141400 $360.35 169824 6404301012 S206.54 103805 6404300808 $107.30 113785 8411113700 $229.76 152488 5692410700 $120.76 123860 6426001400 $230.30 192124 5943410700 $146.32 166746 5742611500 $229.76 184724 6433800920 $223.06 152285 6400215800 $115.00 164125 6433802019 $226.84 166777 6434301100 $95.83 145972 6435205317 $110.77 134970 6396200500 $158.51 180402 5913000800 S206.54 104738 6411123400 $122.65 179921 5913100500 $311.99 104513 6425010500 $126.61 184334 6411424800 $209.93 192037 6291202200 $198.79 168429 6436500435 $176.56 191142 5436510913 $238.21 173976 6436510801 $176.56 181457 5954200923 $92.98 134768 5954200315 '$126.60 174861 5954200310 $48.37 190299 5958211000 $229.76 20319 6205412400 $124.78 153852 6420803518 $197.55 180090 6420803207 $110.77 183806 6420802707 $207.71 191348 6403304402 $126.60 136570 6403300302 $110.77 189378 5931700100 $170.82 191410 5397024400 $225.50 104139 6411210800 $122.95 Page 1 of 8 ~~l?- ---..- ~~--~~ ~~~~ CllY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. ~areel No. Balance Due 154274 6426320600 $126.61 179917 6412114800 $110.77 146172 6435131500 $251.94 142574 6180510300 $274.86 159494 5958051300 $108.10 159493 5958051200 $229.76 68638 6402220700 $189.89 10584 5941220400 $139.72 150746 6233141500 $110.77 182940 6430514948 $176.56 190453 6425203500 $215.00 148748 6435604700 $111.29 182993 6424822300 $206.54 165050 5957320100 $146.25 183791 6233150300 $117.49 63029 6233425000 $206.54 157405 6437003000 $106.36 191218 5957913000 $230.18 84439 5693020300 $126.61 128134 6433912300 $238.22 157642 5940715500 $132.21 171045 6436915400 $120.77 170011 6436905200 $122.17 173283 5952803900 $110.77 157380 6437000700 $115.00 114588 6410924700 $215.00 183086 5680111400 $115.00 192118 6411411300 $110.77 182250 6191211500 $206.54 132705 6191720500 $11 0.77 160486 5680730700 $110.77 91830 5732600300 $126.61 192120 5732502300 $294.56 190995 5733322500 $229.14 191905 5733410500 $148.70 188353 5733721700 $191.36 137839 6192011000 $396.74 21797 6193203600 $229.76 155484 6403810800 $127.45 Page 2 of 8 . ~{~ ---..- . - --- ~~:=:-~ CITY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 191268 8220720900 $156.53 191935 6436103350 $195.04 191895 5662503100 $301.54 179523 5953603500 $206.54 144838 5953600400 $110.77 147219 6435415000 $126.61 156165 5952220413 $226.64 182733 6434303500 $206.54 189544 6191411200 $122.38 119665 5733520500 $115.00 186473 6403106500 $112.91 187176 6403100600 $220.81 145758 6436724700 $206.54 168193 6426901700 $126.61 123706 6395601200 $122.38 191114 6181620700 $165.89 166994 6182300100 $95.78 1 84928 6183310100 $283.34 14129 5722931300 $110.77 166325 5722601200 $142.68 174695 6434901100 $214.78 103432 5741200700 $115.00 108130 5750201900 $120.65 175896 6395701500 $206.54 172448 6184100100 $132.64 99805 5682632700 $469.62 169174 5957332300 $230.77 103689 5692410100 $215.00 98947 5943621100 $119.23 192040 5722604600 $250.49 159360 5730820400 $585.36 191864 6425903100 $301.54 191412 6421202800 $174.97 14661 6421200500 $115.00 122722 5951660200 $110.77 188251 5951711600 $206.54 126640 6432322900 $235.27 137317 6432810200 $117.81 188882 5730501600 $149.66 Page 3 of 8 - ~~f?- --..- ~~=-~~ ~~~~ CITY OF CHULA VISfA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No, Balance Due 192098 5743911900 $294.56 192097 5743911800 $294.56 191885 6435061008 $205.77 96399 6432304800 $223.46 145489 6436610400 $212.29 191206 6193204600 $426.40 15098 5702000300 $161.39 191150 5740502300 $288.49 85296 6431501000 $139.31 76841 5752711400 $174.83 8221 6422402500 $220.06 191266 6403814500 $136.91 190932 5722330100 $110.77 166770 5742811900 $206.54 191718 6183031000 $93.09 73670 5951641200 $215.00 144670 5922102200 $146.91 25267 5752110100 $222.86 190278 5734902000 $150.15 124545 5953215401 $209.97 77380 5953215302 $110.16 78832 5944321800 $110.77 118713 5955100208 $122.38 185995 5954102604 $101.84 191221 6434900100 $147.73 191886 6434902200 $154.64 132069 6434901800 $215.00 141077 6205003100 $215.00 190988 5661211400 $161.99 145047 6433801216 $95.78 176895 6426910900 $176.56 55599 6395920800 $128.61 191665 6435025100 $231.85 191493 5710802000 $248.70 191496 5710802000 $182.40 186387 5712810900 $88.23 191780 5650521200 $101.24 191873 5711210800 $301.54 191549 5711520300 $159.32 Page40f 8 . CITY OF CHULA VlSfA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 188444 6435161500 $229.75 146425 6435171100 $205.54 169274 5425403700 $238.22 182911 6241401900 $265.87 87638 5954900300 $208.54 158727 5954503400 $392.96 191290 5932711400 $271.38 170878 6201121000 $115.00 134567 6201120800 $237.78 192205 6432620100 $122.80 191657 6434004300 $221.43 27012 6205106800 $237.42 145293 6441110700 $221.12 188642 5402714300 $141.53 94452 5662512600 $151.37 162346 5690520600 $153.10 180790 6202220300 $206.54 94005 5732220200 $110.77 119376 5741202100 $186.59 73506 6200940100 $252.64 179650 6201230300 $105.97 185597 6391401000 $206.54 119167 6391101500 $96.16 107963 6391200700 $185.50 149886 6424312300 $206.54 110625 6231624700 $206.54 192122 6232015400 $149.59 148559 6433700405 $176.56 153138 6436102714 $131.88 17474 6190900100 $284.32 190914 6436805416 $248.38 191764 6243401300 $238.80 187645 6431613900 $232.19 130069 6190810300 $229.76 165106 6434863400 $252.66 170821 6204300800 $250.06 147285 6436510723 $229.76 144836 5956102300 $102.44 191376 6181311700 $283.54 Page 5 of 8 C1lY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 79174 5651520800 $176.54 94966 5712920400 $245.82 151027 6435430600 $132.17 26625 6204901200 $284.32 191932 5954005800 $301.54 180620 6204800500 $253.16 134889 6242401000 $126.61 186078 6231003100 $229.15 58314 6202730900 $115.00 174648 6193701200 $177.74 105060 6411212800 $206.54 135257 6192211000 $206.54 83732 6191721300 $229.76 169984 6192210900 $206.64 191349 6400313600 $251.45 115672 6203030300 $291.58 121058 6193504300 $102.35 18983 6200710400 $112.91 145429 6436211700 $247.65 101837 6401941900 $122.38 191545 5957714300 $245.06 150585 5693420600 $215.00 191859 5954407600 $210.70 170203 6437302000 $113.25 136627 6425902000 $145.43 142219 6432710700 $206.54 191053 5957500500 $152.02 140265 6425800100 $122.38 114940 6442110700 $206.54 114526 6432300100 $110.77 185033 6435205111 $132.63 171433 5956601000 $215.00 34183 5755201200 $250.06 157564 6437332400 $206.54 192156 6411421100 $264.70 182063 6402000400 $242.49 169799 6206513200 $284.32 132136 6206512400 $215.00 108193 5956603300 $194.25 Page 6 of 8 - ~~~ --..- .~-~~~ .~~~~ CITY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2008 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 190958 6203302700 $258.18 191814 5712811600 $206.54 122081 6401710600 $238.22 122453 6434815600 $266.39 163961 5952610700 $238.22 172673 5956301500 $135.71 106448 5955305600 $106.54 130966 5955304300 $110.77 188195 6426402000 $110.77 186957 6426914000 $213.30 191918 6412602800 $118.70 64988 6190820300 $206.54 105457 6193505200 $110.77 172306 7762307062 $176.56 172389 7762307103 $176.56 174007 5683321300 $206.54 191653 6434801200 $236.50 153330 6183421100 $206.54 79928 6431614800 $238.17 149051 5958031200 $279.73 187447 6436903400 $110.77 162546 6205101700 $249.43 159895 6411925000 $215.00 157955 6437210300 $238.22 157952 6437202700 $126.61 132516 6412013100 $115.00 181119 6242902300 $149.66 173685 6206041000 $110.77 176279 6241902700 $275.86 191026 5943622500 $238.21 145703 6436720300 $176.56 120230 6231525100 $93.59 192267 6436004700 $104.55 121211 6432321200 $122.38 125011 5944311100 $254.04 190874 6425501401 $110.72 192266 6425501604 $202.50 114558 8425500105 $250.06 162539 5952113700 $215.24 Page 7 of 8 ~~tc- ~..- '--=-~~ """-~~~ CITY OF CHULA VISTA Finance Department Collections Unit Delinquent Trash Accounts With Notice Of Public Hearing Sent July 08, 2D08 Account No. Parcel No. Balance Due 66388 5952114100 $206.54 189319 5952911100 $110.77 73900 6206022100 $134.90 191714 6426814600 $119.10 99426 5922314600 $238.22 191286 6436911600 $263.67 186690 6436904300 $115.00 192155 5956104100 $205.22 187941 6411132100 $215.00 159512 59580341 DO $206.54 117936 5731100700 $115.00 75924 5730530400 $115.00 108141 5921715200 $115.00 156855 6436621100 $115.73 191924 6205303900 $229.76 160826 6434604100 $206.54 185226 6436800300 $206.54 58265 5940704400 $238.22 183509 6435163600 $180.56 174216 5957633100 $229.76 166002 6232123300 $275.86 Accounts: 294 Total Due: $54,642.64 Page 8 of 8 - 5&I-tJ f(;L.ke/J'jY l!__-:::~">....-~__1CIW1I I~~~I ;b~; THE OTAY RANCH COMPANY July 10,2008 The Honorable Cheryl Cox City of Chula Vista 276 Fourth A venue Chula Vista, CA 91910 Re: Climate Change Working Group Final Implementation Plan Measure #4 Dear Mayor Cox, The Otay Ranch Company agrees global wanning is real and greenhouse gas emission reductions should be addressed by both public and private sectors. We support the City's goal of achieving emissions levels 20% below 1990 greenhouse gas emission levels. We support the enactment of reasonable new standards that are effective (reduce emissions in an appreciable manner, not just for show), and efficient (reasonable costs relative to emissions reduced), and we are committed to working with the City to reach these goals. However; new burdens placed on new construction should be placed in context. The new construction real estate market is in a recession and very few building pennits will be issued over the next year, so there is no need to rush to judgment. The City will issue maybe I/Sth of the permits it issued a few years ago (approximately 600 this year vs. 3,000). In this market it is very difficult to make new homes "pencil," so any added cost is a deterrent to recovery. When it comes to land use and greenhouse gas emissions, experts a!,'Tee that the greatest opportunity for achieving emission reductions is "community design," as opposed to greater construction standards. This is because most !,'Teenhouse gas emissions arc tied to vehicle miles traveled. Simply stated, reduce trips and you reduce emissions. Now, up and down the state many communities are trying to figure out how to amend their land plans to reduce vehiele miles traveled. Chula Vista has already accomplished this goal! It is critical to rcmemhcr that Chula Vista has been a leader in specifically designing communities to reduce vehiele miles traveled since 1993. Long before any other city in the state, Chula Vista enacted pedestrian friendly, transit- oriented land plans in Otay Ranch. Other communities arc just now trying to catch up to what you have already accomplished. When it comes to greenhouse gas emissions, Chula Vista should take credit for your Otay Ranch plans. 610 W. ASH STREET, SUITE 1500, SAN DIEGO, CA 92101 . PH: (619) 234-4050 . FX: (619) 234-4088 . WWW.OTAYRANCH.COM Those plans- . Consolidated development into more compact fOlms, . Created walkable Village Cores with schools, parks, retail, and multifamily homes all within walking distance of each other and the Villages' transit stop, . Created pedestrian bridges connecting all the Otay Ranch Village Cores, so that thcre are options to jumping in a car, · Included a transit/bus rapid transit system, the rights of way for which have been set aside with each Otay Ranch Village as it has been devclopcd; and the construction of which is funded through TRANSNET, · Crcated an unparalleled, pemlanent, managed 17 square mile Preserve system, which is in itself, is a tool in reducing greenhouse gas cmissions. Chula Vista has also been a leader in building (actually requiring new development to build) an arterial system which minimizcs congestion, thus avoiding cloggcd arterials with cars waiting for a light to change. For years Chula Vista has required Air Quality Improvement, Energy Conservation and Watcr Conscrvation Plans as a condition of new dcvelopmcnt. Thcsc plans impose requirements beyond those of other communities. In other words, it is a mistake for anyone to think that Chula Vista is new to strategies and regulations to improve air quality and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. I repeat, other communities are just now trying to catch up to what you have already accomplished. Not only has Chula Vista been a leader, but the state of Cali fomi a has also been a leader. As a result, a homc built today in Chula Vista has a carbon footprint 24% smaller than a home built in 1990. Thus, when it comcs to community design and building standards, new homes in Chula Vista already meet your goal of achieving 20% below 1990 greenhouse gas emissions levels. [n addition, the energy usage of a new home in Chula Vista declined 26% between 1990 and 2005. Thc new state building code will require new single family homcs to be 22(i'o more efficient than the cxisting code. This means a new home built next ycar will usc 35% less energy than a home built in 1990. We do not object to bcing on the cutting edge ofrcducing grcenhouse gas cmissions, we do not want to be on the blccding cdge. Your considcration and rcview of Measure #4 of the Climate Change Working Group Final Implementation Plan is greatly appreciated. Sincerely, G:.- /Lf.,'] ~Ikemrt- r Planning Assistant 1990 Energy Usage Current Code 11l Ql "0 o U 2008 Pending Code Chula Vista Proposal Comparison of Energy Efficienty of New Homes o Percent of 1990 Energy Usage 40 60 80 120 20 100 I I I I I . . . I I I t!1/f'~ &.-ve-.be 77D ~IY~!l~~p ~ahna~~~~ ~II' '........oodOllioo',_'" rr-ra July 10, 2008 Honorable Cheryl Cox, Mayor City of Chula Vista 276 Fourth Avenue Chula Vista, CA 91910 RE: Report on Climate Change Working Group Measures Implementation Plans Dear Mayor Cox: On behalf of the San Diego Chapters of the Building Owners and Managers Association and the National Association of Industrial and Office Properties, I would respectfully ask that the following comments be placed into the record regarding the City's proposed implementation plans drafted in response the Climate Change Working Group recommendations recently reviewed by the Council. Our organizations remain concerned about the process of seeking public input for the implementation measures. While we have sought and received a briefing by city staff, it was our understanding that there would be a more collaborative process with impacted stakeholders prior to the drafting of any implementation plans. This was not the case, and, in fact, we were directed to provide input on these draft plans directly to council. Specifically, to the plans themselves, we are, in general, concerned about the lack of scientific basis for the arbitrary decision to exceed Title 24 standards, as they are being proposed under the draft California "Green Building Code", by 15%. There is yet to be generated any logical basis for this particular target, which appears excessive, given the .new GBC is intended to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions from deveiopment governed by the code beyond current levels. It would seem to our organizations that these new GBC standards are more than stringent and consistent with the goals and objectives of both the Climate Change Working Group, as well as the City Council. Please accept these additional comments for consideration by the Council: 1. Measure 3 - Business Energy Assessments At first blush, these assessments appear to be an innocuous inspection procedure to be done at no cost to the business licensee. In fact, it is similar to the voluntary inspections currently done upon request by SDG&E. Our primary concern is that should the grant which is currently paying for the program expire and not be renewed the city will be in a position to force the costs of these assessments on the general business community. Given that the vast majority of businesses in Chula Vista are small businesses and given the difficult economic times most businesses are facing, passing along these costs will have an adverse impact. The bottom line is that the proposed "Fee Authority" and the elimination of the grant program by 2011 creates the very real probability that the formerly free inspectio I 11 wi I become yet . another cost-recovery service fee (e.g. tax on businesses). 2. Measure 4 - Green Building Standard We appreciate the proposal to move beyond LEED as the only standard by which ~ construct' . can create "green" efficiencies. As we have said previously, LEED is simply a brant::::j and d'o~ project man atmg the use of LEED would be like mandating the use of Kleenex. There are other standar~s that . . " eXIst, and the use of the proposed TItle 24 changes, as noted above and known as the draft Cal :ifornia G . . . . reen BUlldmg Code," makes sense to our orgaOlzatlons. Our organizations, as noted above, are concerned about the proposal to move be~ond th . . . . . ese new draft standards by an additional 15%. The 15% reductIon 10 energy consumptIon beyollod the . h I. I" I d hi' b h' d hi' f h fi reqUirement of t e new Tit e 24 IS an unrea IstlC goa an t e oglc e In t e se ectlon 0 t at Ig '-'re has not b provided. In fact, the draft plan actually states (on page 19) that ". . . there is not ~ straight-lin een relationship between green program certification or Title 24 performance and carl::>on red t' e . " . uc Ions. For thiS reason, we recommend an approach that focuses dIrectly on carbon emIssIon reductio " ns. Additionally, on page 21, the report goes on to note that "at present there are not:: well establi h d metrics" for equating energy efficiency with carbon savings. s e Finally, there has been no analysis provided of the cost to business to comply wit!) these n d . . .. ew stan ards. Our orgaOlzatlOns' members know the cost of Implementing these types of measu I"es and can assume that the cost will be significant. The Council should carefully weigh those costs agq;nst the . . . . .. perceIved PR value of exceeding what IS already expected to be an onerous new Cahfornla BUIld ing Code. In the discussion of carbon reduction, staff mentions using software to "calculate ~nergy g .. ffi . ." h PI' d B 'Id' '11 "d . h' h' f eneratlOn and e IClency options; owever, anOlng an UI Ing WI etermlne w IC IS pre er-able fo ". ruse - It would be preferable to have a menu of options to achieve energy efficiency rather- than a t ff s a mandate. 3. Implementation Costs Staff has estimated their own costs for implementation at a one-time cost of almOst $1 million and annual costs of $2.7 million; the numbers are significant. Given the current fiscal difficulties fa db Chula Vista, it does not seem realistic to fund additional programs out of the Gener-al Fund. An~e h y various bond and fee proposals outlined in the financing options all amount to one thing' t e . . a measurably greater burden on the taxpayers of Chula Vista. 4. Environmental Review and CEQA Analysis According to the draft materials, a new development or significant retrofits would need to d h I excee t e new Green Building Code's "carbon footprint' standards by 15%. Otherwise, a mitigat'lon f f $ . . ee 0 2.50 per pound of carbon (Draft ImplementatIon Plan at 22) would be charged to apphcants Th . . ere IS an issue whether such a fee is reasonably related and proportional to the stated impact as required b U.S. Constitution and the California Mitigation Fee Act. Specifically, climate change is a gl b I' y the the City's Implementation Plan is a local ordinance; therefore, how does the City intend t: 1~ Issue: yet the adverse impact of a project and 2) document a "nexus" between a local project's impact aq~a~'fy global issue of climate change in order to calculate and justify a proportional fee. n t e Second, there is an issue as to what role Measure NO.4 will play into CEQA analysis. As you know, AB 32 of 2006 recognizes a threat to the "economic well-being, public health, natural resources, and the environment of California" resulting from climate change. Subsequently, lead agencies have been struggling how and to what extent they are required to incorporate climate change in the CEQA process (e.g. analyzing and quantifying carbon impacts from new development, establishing mitigation measures, etc). How Chula Vista's plan fits into this undefined scheme remains very ambiguous. Specifically, the Draft Implementation Plan only states that it will "implement a process to align the Green Building Standards program with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) environmental review process." These questions need to be answered before the council adopts these implementation plans. In closing, we appreciate the Council's goal to be a leader in the fight against global warming. Our members have also been leaders by spending tens of millions of dollars here locally to improve the energy, water and GHG efficiency of their properties. While it is easy to target new construction with these potential mandates, it is clear from staffs presentation to our organizations that the real solution to any meaningful effort to fight global warming resides in existing residential development. Obviously, targeting existing homeowners comes with some political risk, but if the goal is saving the planet, then some political risk should be acceptable to those promoting these measures. On behalf of both of our organizations, we wish to continue our involvement in these and other issues impacting our members in the City of Chula Vista. We thank you for this opportunity. Sincerely, to v()1 ~Ued~tto Legislative Advocate BOMA San Diego NAIOP San Diego t....eo ~ Vl~~ EHC Recommended Amendments/Strikeonts for Carbon Rednction Iml,lementation Plan MEASURIZ #4: GREEN BUILDING STANnARnS IMPLEMENTATION Development of a Building Carbon Reduction Benchmark Program Page 20, paragraph 2, lines 1-3 ...In coordination with stakeholders, staff would begin with developing the framework of the Building Carbon Reduction Benchmark Program to attain ~ 20% greater carbon reduction than current and preliminary 2008 Title 24 requirements... Page 21, paragraph 1, lines 2-5 ...These values will represent the approximate carbon savings achieved when exceeding Title 24 by B% 20% The Chub Vista Carbon Reduction Checklist will need to be completed by the builder for each penn;!. Page 21, paragraph 2, lines 1-2 The savings can be accomplished in two difTerent areas: (1) community/site design and (2) energy efficiency, though greater weight would be placed 011 energy efficiency as there is a greater direct connection to carbon rel/uctiol1 through ellergy elficiellcy thall COlI1J11Ulli(l'/:.dte design. The lirst typically applics to larger scale projects, and the Planning and Building DepaJ1ment will ensure that future long range plans..... Pagc22, paragraph 2 The program wttt may include a mitigation fee component should a builder choose or othorwiso not be able to effectively meet the additiomll C02 savings requirement on-site. 11Iu.\' the mitigatioll fee would OIl(V be ll1'ailableforal1wTo)ll ~'ef (~f' projects thaflwl'e pl'OI'en all ulldue han/ship ill meetil1g the 20% beyond Title 24 requil'ement or less than /,000 square fee. OR, A/terl1ative Recommenl/atioll for Jlfitigation Fee Requirements Language The program wttt lIIay include a mitigation fee component should (I builder choose or othorwise not be able to effectively meet the additional C02 savings rcquircment on-site. The mitigation fee lIIay instead take fheform (~f'an optiollto which all projects have acces.\'. Under this option, all projects must meet 20% over Title 24 with at least 15% being the minimum that el'el}' pN~jectmeets, while the rest of tlte percelltage (5%) ClIII be met through payment (~f'fhe mitigation fee. The fee will equate to the cost of exceeding the applicable edition of Title 24 by B-% ]0%. ... Preliminary estimates li'om our consultant ConSol indicate that the Ice may be but could exceed approximately $2.50 per pound or earbon....I3uilders shall also have the option or opting out orthc checklist if they demonstrate through CEC cel1ified sortware that they exceed Title 24 by B-% ]0% or 1110rc. Page 22, following paragraph 2 O/lce cpalllatio/l (~rtlte fJrr~iec/ Ita.\. been complete, tlte builder's project will he certffied hy ci~r .\'It~[rl1." """iIlK Jl1ef the checklist and achieving 20% (we,. Title 24 requirements. 11le documentatio/l and records connected to tlte project ccrt{licatioll and greenhouse gas reduction wou/d be open to public rCI,icw aut! thirdpllrty ver(!icatioll "pon reqllest. Furthermore, incentives will be drt~tfell allt! prodded to al/oJV for LEED .\'ih'cr and goltl cert~/ic(fti(11l by huilders so liS to encourage third party cert(/icatioll. MEASURE #5: SOLAR &: ENERGY EFFICIENCY CONVERSION BUDGET &: FINANCING Page 33, Following Paragraph 1 Add to the end: However, (f'thefilllllillg sources melltiollel/above lire /lot attained for measure #5, slt{tTwill pl'ovide a l1Iod(fied I'ersioll (~f'tlte program taking illto accoullt tlte Iimitell resources. A solar conversion program can take 1I11lllyforms {flld therefore, ([ lIIore cost-e.tfective streamlined version JIlill he created iftlte boud measure orfee aut/IOrio" to IlOt materialize. Add a new condition titled CARBON REDUCTION PLAN EVALUATION Progress on (Ill of these measures will be eV(lluated every two years to assess effectiveness ofthc program in reducing carbon emissions in complinnce \vith city goals and state directives. AetcL.~ enol LV\tormaftrrn l.\-e.w1 1- 7;-;'" 0108 ~~...?'.1l78.8...iB.~. Ib~~. A~..';.i\...sii. ite.5fi~:....~.,.~)~.;V-'~:.~.'!1.".: J r~'$ati!9tego:~cA;~lf2?~~~':.~~,,~~ .:;~58~?~.80?o, (~!;!n;,,,':: :c;':.~ ,.'"::.:::l. ~~)~~Bl~J!;8oZ,11(~~!?~!.~~$.~"'-1'~~~ ".',' ,Vi1NW. .sdca~.co n:Hi",1"{,",- .,~_~~.~~_~.,~.., ~ k~"" '~' .. . .,.,.... ", " '.,,', :-iU':~ ,',,~ ~ ,"" (5'1.',,1;:- '~'J;y1 ~ ',",..' ,',":'," " :-' "~Ji.~_ - ',:",:",~." _~ . ,,'~ To: Chula Vista City Clerk From: Alan Pentico Fax: (619) 585-5774 Pages: 2 including cover ,,0 g Pho",,: (619)691-5041 Il3te: 7/10/2008 ............ (-< ::0 ,,0 2: rrl He: 7.10.08 Council Item #1 CC: .--n 0 rno .- REPORT ON CLIMATE AJ_ ~ rrl ""~ ,co a - CHANGE WORKING GROUP (/) .- < MEASURES IMPLEMENTATION 01> -u iT1 =-~< ..". ......-. PLANS ....:lv: ...~..' --'-.-' ~ :0.;-, "'~l- --.J o Urgent o For Review o Please Comment 0 PIIIa"e R"ply o Please Recycle .. Comments: Please accept this letter as comment with regard to Item 1, REPORT ON CLIMATE CHANGE WORKING GROUP MEASURES IMPLEMENTATION PLANS, o/tonight's council meeting, Thank you in advance. This f8X and any fllet.l:r.a.nsmitted with It are confidential and intended solely for thi:! use of the indivIdual or entity to whom they am addressed, If you have receiv9d this fax In error please notify the Bender. Thl~ meSt3ge contBinB confidentl31 tnfom'lation and Ie Intended only for tM individual n.'lmed. If you are not the naml:!d addressee you should no! dii:iSemmate. distribute or Mpy this fax. Please notify the sender Immediately by phone orf;;sx If you /"Iav~ received this fax by mi:itakt:! and destroy this fax. If YOu are not the Intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any .action in 1"elitince on the contenUi of this infDrmatlon is strictly prohibIted, If you would lik~ to stop receiving faxes from the San Diego County Apartment Association, please call 888,762,7313, fax request to 888.871.5229 or "..mail infoliI>sdc:aa,oom with the word remove from fax list in the subjec:t nne, Please include your name, and fax number. ~"' ~DCAA L. .~..f~~~~ _ :i, :.i Son Diego County Apartment Association@ ~~~ ~- CAUFOf"'''' N.lJX::N.l.l~ ""~~'" s~ 1919 A<..'l:::CV.'IDl ..!:~OQ.O,TJmI July 10, 2008 Chula Vista Climate Change Working Group Attn: Brendan J. Reed 276 Fourth Avenue Chula Vista, CA 91910 RE; Chula Vista Climate Change Working Group Implementation Plan Dear Mr, Reed: The San Diego County Apartment Association (SDCAA) has reviewed the Draft Implementation Plans as released for stakeholder review in June 2008. As was acknowledged in our letter dated May 21, 2008 regarding the initial recommendations made by the Climate Change Working Group, the SDCAA is supportive of the city's proactive efforts to address this important issue. Several of our initial questions and concerns were addressed in the subsequent Implementation Plan, However, some questions remain: Recommendation #3; Business Enerqv Assessments o The Business Energy Assessments would only "apply to businesses with a physical storefront and/or office" - how are residential rental properties viewed in this respect? A single-family home rental haS no storefront or office, yet a larger complex may have a lobby or office. Both require business licenses for operation, What would trigger the Business Energy Assessments for residential rental properties? How much of the property would be assessed (Le, only the office/lobby or the entire property?) , o The Implementation Plan states that the Business Energy Assessments "would be offered at no cost," yet points out that a Fee Authority structure may be recommended if current and future grant funding runs out. What sort of a fee structure is proposed? Recommendation #5: Solar Conversion o The portion of the Implementation Plan regarding the Solar Conversion Assessment Districts and option to finance the conversions through one's property tax roll needs to be explained in more detail (perhaps using eXamples) for the average business owner to be encouraged to utilize it. o Staff has recommended that a combination of bond and local Fee Authority funding be pursued for this recommendation, What sort of a fee structure would be proposed? I hope these questions/comments are useful when revisiting the Implementation Plan, We feel further explanation of some of these issues may encourage community participation in the programs Again, thank you for the opportunity to provide feedback. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at (858) 751-2213. Alan P tic Director of Public Affairs B788 Balboa Avenue, Suite B . San Diego, CA 92123 . Tel: 858,278.8070 . Fax; 858,278.8071 . www.sdcaa.com D K BJ \>r= t". ,6...\,\O>'G N ~ \ 'i- \'.G."" Draft Building Efficiency Resource Options Tier 1: Minimum Requirements Notes Insulation, Envelope Sealing/Duct - Sealing/Duct Design, Ventilation (Attic Fan, Weatherization* $7,000 House Fan, Ceiling Fans), Doors Attic Insulation @ 599/sq ft $80 $0.99 per square foot Star Energv Refriaerator (<550kWh) $1,500 Low Flow Faucets/Showers $30 $10 faucet, $20 showerhead Dual/Low Flow Toilets $250 $250 per unit Programmable Thermostat $50 Waterless Urinal $350 Variable Frequency or Dual Speed Pool Motor $250 Indoor CFL or LED Equivalent $40 Outdoor CFL or LED Equivalent $40 $9,590 ,Tier. 2" C6ndition'al,;O'pticlns:);";"" ",; ;,~_:;,;"~,;..,-':', ' ,;;:: , Note's,:. ;;;;\, ',' .:,,:,-.-. ..:-.:'.".;;" '''';y;,. " k",.,."" "~..> Dual Paned Windows (lower) $5,000 Dishwasher 5700 Front Load Clothes Washer $900 SEER 19 or above HVAC $5,000 Recirculating Water Pump $300 EvapoTranspiration (ET) Water Controller $300 Tankless Water Heater 5900 Turf Removal/NatureScape 55,000 Total $13,100 ~ifit 3r:~e_ trew~atJ1e~O'ptio_nsZ:.i::it~:if~':,~<i:"~8;l;.'}J..~~~f.{<Z :'.; NQte~f(!~~&';:~~l~~~t~~ft"0~i~!f'\'~'~:".';\,--"s'. PV $42,000 Solar Thermal (Water) $65,000 Domestic Solar Water Heater $6,500 Rebates & bulk discounts included Wind (Electricty) $8,000 2kW system $5000 + Inverter and Labor 5121 ,500 *Federal Weatherization Assistance Program $2750 avg Based on 2500 sq foot residence, 2.5 bathrooms