Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Comm Reports/1992/01/08 (11) City Planning Commission Agenda Item for Meeting of January 8, 1992 Page 1 4. PUBLIC HEARING: PCS-91-07 - Consideration of tentative subdivision map for Park Wav Place Townhomes. Chula Vista Tract 91-07 - Juan and Noelia Sanchez A. BACKGROUND The applicant has submitted a tentative subdivision map known as Park Way Place Townhomes, Chula Vista Tract 91-07, in order to convert an 8-unit apartment project into a one-lot 7-unit condominium on 0.32 acres at 364-368 Park Way. The project is exempt from environmental review as a Class l(k) exemption. B. RECOMMENDATION Based on the fi ndi ngs conta i ned inSect ion "En of thi s report, adopt a motion to approve the tentative subdivision map for Park Way Place Townhomes, Chula Vista Tract 91-07, subject to the following conditions: 1. The conversion of two 2-bedroom units to a single 4-bedroom unit (designated as Unit 7 on the tentative map) shall be completed prior to the consideration or approval of a final map by the City Council. 2. Park Acquisition and development fees currently estimated at $3,810 per unit shall be paid prior to the approval of a final map. 3. The amount of any fees applicable to the project, including but not 1 imited to PAD fees, shall be those in effect at the time they are collected. 4. The subdivider shall file with the City a copy of the CC&R's applicable to the property. The CC&R's shall include: a. Proh i bit i pn of 1. V. antennas, garage convers ions and parking outside designated areas. b. Maintenance of common areas and driveways. 5. The applicant shall submit evidence that each of the tenants of the proposed condomi ni urn convers ion project has recei ved the foll owi ng written notifications: a. The subdivider shall provide proof to the satisfaction of the City Engineer that the tenants have been notified at least 10 days prior to City Council consideration of the Final Map. City Planning Commission Agenda Items for Meeting of January B, 1991 Page 2 b. Ten days' notification that an appl ication for a publ ic report will be, or has been, submitted to the State Department of Real Estate, and that such report will be available on request. c. One hundred eighty days' written notice of intention to convert pri or to termi nat i on of tenancy due to convers i on or proposed conversion. 6. Prior to approval of the final map the applicant shall submit evidence that each of the tenants of the proposed condominium, has been, or will be, given notice of an exclusive right to contract for the purchase of his or her respective unit upon the same terms and conditions that such unit will be initially offered to the general public or terms more favorable to the tenant. The right shall run for a period of not less than 90 days from the date of issuance of the subdivision public report pursuant to Section 1101B.2 of the Business and Professions Code, unless the tenant gives prior written notice of his or her intention not to exercise the right. 7. All monuments of the subdivision shall be in place prior to approval of the final map. B. The owner shall comply with all applicable sections of Vista Municipal Code prior to approval of the final map. map shall be prepared in accordance with the Subdivision the City of Chula Vista. the Chul a The final Manua 1 of C. DISCUSSION Adiacent zoninq and 1 and use. North R-3 Memorial Park South R-3 Single-family East R-3 Single-family West R-3 Mult i-family Existinq site characteristics. The project is located on the south side of Park Way, east of Fourth Avenue. The site is developed with an B-unit apartment project consisting of two structures, each containing four 2-story townhouse type units. A central driveway separates the two structures and provides access to a total of 14 on-site parking spaces. Tentative map. The purpose of the subdivision map is to convert the project from rental apartments to for-sale condominiums. The project was designed with 400 cu. ft. of private storage per unit within each of the eight garage parking spaces. The requirement for private storage is the only additional standard for condominiums versus apartments. City Planning Commission Agenda Items for Meeting of January 8, 1991 Page 3 The project was constructed under previous parking standards which allowed for a certain number of the required spaces -- in this case two spaces -- to be accommodated with on-street spaces contiguous to the site. In order to convert the project it must meet the current parking standards of two spaces per unit, all on-site. The proposal, therefore, is to convert two of the un its into a s i ngl e unit. Thi s results in a total of seven units and 14 on-site parking spaces. E. FINDINGS Pursuant to Section 66473.5 of the Subdivision Map Act, the tentative subdivision map for Park Way Place Townhomes, Chula Vista Tract 91-07, is found to be in conformance wi th the vari ous el ements of the City's General Plan based on the following: 1. The site is physically suitable for residential development and the proposal conforms to all standards establ ished by the City for such projects. 2. The design of the subdivision will not affect the existing improvements -- streets, sewers, etc. -- which have been designed to avoid any serious problems. 3. The project is in substantial conformance with the Chula Vista General Plan Elements as follows: a. land Use - The project dens ity of 22 du/ac is cons i stent with the General Plan designation of High Density Residential (18-27 du/ac) . b. Ci rcul at i on - The convers i on does not impact the General Pl an circulation network. c. Housing - The conversion will provide a for-sale product at the low end of the range for ownership housing. d. Conservation The site is presently developed, and thus approval of the map will not impact conservation issues. e. Park and Recreat ion, Open Space - The proposal wi 11 be requi red to contribute PAD fees to provide for park and recreation facil ities in the central area. f. Sei smi c Safety - There are no concerns with sei smi c safety on the site that were not addressed with original construction. g. Safety - The project is within acceptable response times for all public safety agencies. h. Noise - The project is in conformance with City noise standards. City Planning Commission Agenda Items for Meeting of January 8, 1991 Page 4 i. Scenic Highway - The project site is not on a scenic highway. j. Bicycle Routes - The project site is not adjoining a designated scenic route. k. Publ i c Buil di ngs contributions toward tentative map. 4. Pursuant to Section 66412.2 of the Subdivision Map Act, the Commission certifies that it has considered the effect of this approva 1 on the hous i ng needs of the regi on and has balanced those needs against the public service needs of the residents of the City and the available fiscal and environmental resources. The proposal is financing public not responsible buildings with for the WPC 9990P/1648P , f- I : - ....; -~ o c: ::c ~ ::E: " L. - - --., - . - -- T' - - - - -- -- - - I r , E0 .. '--.J J / PRl>J~i / L()(.A IltiN. "" I I I 1 I I ~~ I I I I I I I / /: I _.' I I I I I . I tifl~f'I1~lu"i\.lfllr' f" ~ f:rl0f ----- PARK Hf I 1 I 1 I G) I I , I I :I> I I I I I ~ i-^F- 1f'.F- 'St' I",~ '\-IF- ISf ", ..... ..... f\F- ,1'\1' SF- Sf HI' \J\f \.IF \-IF' @) I,{t:Ji!D k..l ~t.- ~\::. WO!1blolS c.l.vE 1<\ F \I\f Sf fj,f Sf- "G" SF Sf I 1 I I I I I I I I , 1 I , I I I I I I _L_ --'- - VANCE ~---~ i : :::;@: I I I t?J1 I I I I I rl I I I I I - _l_L ul ~ , I I , , I I I I I I ST. 1 I : :1 : I ,J ( PAA~ ~y Pl.At-a. T~ ~~ ) ~c::..4 - ~~~ FAP-I<:. 'Iv$:( KORTH [ pc" - "1 H'l I I I 1..__ I I I I I I I I I , 1 I I I I I ! : ROOSEVELT : ; : : : ; I I . I f_1 I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I ~ "- - WAY I I I I , 1 1 1 , I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ! : : : I I I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I I I I I , ' ST , I I I I I , o ~-- --- ~ ::E: - --- ::0 o -,.. e ---.., - - -- LOCATOR ~Vf:/Z.71t'N t'I= '1 LlNIT~ INfo U'N.DO~INIUM7 ) ~ " - - -- - - - - - .-- - '--. '-- I- _. - -- - - , -- - - . - -r ! -1 I - ~ !I ) :1- ~- 11: j , ); I~ , I~ I 'I I~ J to , ..... Glu ci~ ZO ...a: II. U II. C C:IE :IE 11:::1 ...- W C Z > ...- ~ !!!~ C > Q ... C Z Z ... 0 W ::I U ... :1:- UC II) w :E o ::Ci Z ~. o ... w ~ ~ (,) , CI:, ~ .... II. )0' , ;01 :c a: CI: II. ,II !1fi1i "'", 6~ giJd3 .' I';I!\ II 53 IS "I,~i 8j"IO ~ H;~ j >it, !M, )~'o j I ~o,' I' j~ '01,1 fHiH - -0;>:- ~ ~~ ~~ I'll I~ ,~, ." I ill '1! i ~i III1 ~ !;~! pt'" fl! >?" ~~: 'V I ~ ,.,. i , :i ':, 1'0 , i ~ ~ 'I ,. ~ .e ~::".; E~: a- t ~ .: I" 5 e '1 1;!! d:, ! I :!;; Iii ^ . ....::1 .. II I rl ~ -M It. , ' ! i" d L.; ,; , .. ~. L m: "iiij " I H 1, :, 1,1, .:1 ~~ ~ ~.~ ~.. .~" ~~ ~!~c .~~i~ _ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ..g .!;.... ~~..8" :I. iii .. ~!' J ~ , !. "": ''''', · i' I; ,~. r. ~. ; i ~=t ~;;~ ~.y;.. ~ : i ~ i ~II~ " ~ I\- P. '" L ! , ;; ii~1 :::ii" .j5 ,~ ;, i P,L '!q;l~ ~ ~I~ ~d f J"" i :J.. =~:I: 51-. If ~ - i ~ ~ = E= 11 It ,.. ~ i: ~ fir.r ~ =i ;;:~:~ !:!:h t ~ 5 I" ~ a '5 u,; r-,{E ~ fIi.... ~~ !" " "'I !;". i "I'" "1 ., . 11 U1 u~ U1 .~ ~~ ,;s .:' .~H'" '; . " ". i ! ~ > "., z ",,' ~j m! Ii.!! ~i ~ ',~, i ,I i!~ ,! ' ~ ~~~ ~ .~~ ;~ :" = :: =:: = -.. ~ .. ~ .. It> 'i" ~,..\i ~ ,,,-I. ..:r,J. . 0 , , , ! ,... i~ Ii i !~ ! ; IO;! j,. ~~ e P1i I Ii . P '; j , . j- i 5.... .: n ~, E",.:I ~ ." ! .' j iH' ~I ipHII, ; i! L 1! ~ ~. . . ,0 ~ :I ~ ~ e i Ii; ~ - i ~. ~ 1,0 i ! i 'I' I .. , 3 I! ! ! ';, , I '." 3,1 ;.; oj , 1" Ii" i! "~'I! !;! i 3-. ~ .- ~2 !E~3! J i ii '; ; "'!!' ",. J' E'h, ~ ~;_;i :j'" ~ ; 'I i, i.," .g"E~ t . t. ~~ i~3=5 ~ ~ 5~ ai - - ',; j~rfl\ 19 ~! !il ,2 ~ L1 ~jl "~I ' , ! - ~ ~ 9 ~ L~ IIJ'11 !! 1 , " !d .1~[ "'~ ~h~, ;I'~!' ~n:11 'Itl' ~ ,!::",~ \ ,.' I , " , , f " o ,J} )~ , I( i I I I 'j I " p !, ~:ll . , "'I' ! .. . , ~- , J 1-___ I,] o. t, ) ,1 . , I , ~ ~ ~ , . ;:t ~ ", " t e II " ~s~ ~ 't'- 1\ ! :~~i ~ !iM U1 ,ttj< IQ !lh. I ~ I " Jj -;- II ~, " II ! ' , :0' t ~: ~ip~~L.( +- H I i~ ~ , I, I! : ~- j:~ j; I , , I " .' , -+.--.~-~:,~._----...--_.--+--..---- ,,<;;-,~I ---I-- T- -------.-_+__.~_2.__+.-~.?.::.c.\1_+___ ~'-k- ..- ~ " " -;'o!- ; ~ ~ . .:. . ; ., 1 ~ ~ ;; 1 " ~ . .. ~ " ,") ~,r;1 ,t.,/- "?-.r~ ,l..~ ,,1>-,1'" "Q-n "9_'_~+ ..~ti .."i>'; -. -+~,+- j""'.''i. ,,0-,'" -----.---- -'"--_. --~ --+---..::::!:...~-- +-"---~'!! ---..-._-- __,,____u____ - -; I l '" " ~ , , " , . ;;; " " -------/'" ~~~ I . ; . a ,- + ~>?::;z , " r . '" " ~ " \' ~ ~ f :0 0 ~ I ~-7-,'" I ------:;-i~~.., - =_-~=__-~=_~~-.; -,i-i-- .~=- : ----r----~----_ ---.- -- ~-:r- ______ f~ .~~ t~,j ... ~ , r-- 'T ~ ~ 1-' ~-:S \;:~ '1' ~ ~:"t~~ ~"\\j ljj'.".."'...."'" . '., .. ~In. 'A"," '"~''''''' ,., ~ '__..-;-'~ .,,!...S.,...,.,,"'.....,.. / ,~_.;,J .I.Q....~:~.,"I..W '.Y ......aN.. ..'.....H::I , , ..".......'^..'nt1n 10..""...'...."...,,,.., oolJ'IO r .. , f ! i: I '''-i~W ' 'lk:.IUM8, ~.," ,.. ~, ~ ..~........"..,?,<:ne!Bi I 6J..NeW.l.t::t'\:f~'\:f J..t-iElI!J A'\:fM >ltH1d ii! <I .J 11 ""Tw~' .r,.... IIi ,1',JI' I '..~ D fjJ,r--, ,- ~.," "'f" T.. (~"" D, .J ,: I 1 II. ~i ' ') .J, W H j I ~ @ @ > J i' w, j: hI! .J rJ I a, t"; ~ I' a ( w, Ii fUf! S f I D 3t 1 .J ( ft ;fiU ) ootl r I < <I l~ 4- f f I CI , I I " Q. f~ , .J! 'l Ihi} I , . ( m::. L 1 ., e -......... ~~ , .J,'ffo , I i ii! I I <I I ! .J 11 a D " D .J .. II. .J W > W .J I a w I 11 11 :J ,f.~ ,,'1101 .,t <I ,,1 ,~I- "J,.,.. CI """'-.~,14 iI. f ..J~ k-- P-..:J m~ ..' " .., ---- -, - ffrt;r:q~~t > cL!~ Ii ;I, ~ B i'~ , 1J ! I " " -..------;'"I[ -., -T-. r;>d:<'i+:",--t ~' .. I ' ' -.--- -" tJ~t ~j' I' ; I, 1'1: i;'\ -J~I ::Hi [8. !1..,I ',I L :.I:. 1! 0 1. i~ - ;t. E . H ,,~ ! : " ..p~'J -:--~, -.r:".,.r ....,'--r ~"'~.::~,."""'''''' W ' , I~IJ' , ',' ~~_:::' '",.j.Y ',' -i l' ',,": ,,- +qu,""." I B.j.Na,^,.L~"d" +H~I" A"IIII ,,,...,.. "'" I '_ .....,,"".. ".'.WHQ, ! .! r~T I I .,1,,,-- ~ I I I " , " ..,.,,- ;1" ;- I f nHIIHlIlIl !f 1';'H~lutH n H-II:;, 'I'.', j.' t'.. =: 6 .,. '" t "- t: 0.: If. ~ _ t .. ...'...... ............ .. '" ~ W! f' 5Jnnill un~ H ~~lH!jJt.lIHi n u j~ : ~i:j:jUl "- m ~~ "; _~. ~~~~~ ~i ~ ~~(~~.~.~. :'!',~. .:~,~.~, :~~:~~ g i~iifti~Tii~~~i~,i 0=" ~i; ~ :; -;:'. ... ;- "" ~ ~-; ~I~ .",..~"" ...-;:w P,-, . LJ ~..=:3 CJ , [8'8B8] ,",~ I" ~ I i . dB!! !j1J ~i ~ ~ ~ : ~ J - \ W . ~ ~ ., . ~ . ~ ' oJ ,12 - ~ .. ~n tj- M IHH. ~ ') D """'j"I@ C J' ~ ...," ~ :' _~ ) I ~ -\1 ~ ~ ~.9 T, ~ - ~ : ... ~ ~ ---- () 4. '" .J !:I '" /r,"'-I' I ~, n Iht :U~ I' l t. : ,!~ , 'l~ , . f 'h q;1 ! i;11 It'" ,~~ ~f~ ", . i~ ".~;o ", '~~~ ,....',,;."'T_I.Ii] ,II; . "~""""",,,,'ct1':Il i z os: oJ a. II D 9 II. oJ W > W oJ II W ~ D oJ m I!I b., oJ '_ ~ -;. -:' ' ~,~:, ., ~ ,:j' iT s.t f. .. r: ~ H t! ". ; 1'0 ~~!!~ ~j Ii' !, !'! I'j ',I " i,. so t....J"; .. '" r ~ 'l ,." 1_-,::..: .'.' jl"~ a.. .' '!'.k' I .. ~ 0' J ~ i :j ~ ;: 't ~_ ji! i it 11"0 I. ~j., !g "1 !'!ji! r~j - :>~ ~. 1-" !'''Ij ';' i1~!~h hi ~~ ,"':' t .r- J hit"r.. ..[- ~j:j;i; i~..: :!f~H! i"E ::UB,.1 _if h" il ~ oJ a. II D D oJ II. oJ W > W oJ II W, A., D. :J m I!I, b., oJ': m~ >'1'''1'' I j'/' ji . : t f: I~ f . I t Ii'. 'ii'", I. -~ J~ II E . ... lil:jj!,;J ;i , I~ !" .. !! f Lif ," -I,. i !/I,;i!;11 ii' -I. ,I !i ~;Jlj !. I,!t It h..;:; !I I!'. 11"j I' d!~ il.) ~' I .1 n r:i~~il!:I'.1 . '111'1 . l1-h~!!!_1 I. . ) a_,:;~' I.Uh.mmJ. .!- mil! J -....- ~ .""...-.-- >~n. .~ ~., -.'.~ 1 " I " ! " 1 , , J , ~ ~ i I ~ 7 f h' f ~ j , ~ ~! ~' !. d~, ~ I~ ~ &i I i ~ i:P ;~ i h t i ~ 3:jc~~(<'::i J:~ t , ".\l'!I' . '1'~ I I iI':< ~ ~I ~ ~ 1~~;"1 t ~[ t ~Jli i W'II 1 ffi I ~~n~:,','~,i ,\ i1}1 I I- i L~ i ~ i ~ ! 6JI I ~~, ~'Itdli! ~f !h1~ j os: IIi a i i ~/ h H t' II fn ;r .\11 !. }fU 1 ~ B htf ilil gl tJ~;! ~ !t ~ ~!! !,~ ~.,!~tl! 1:[ _ ~ I "',:...,'C," I ,',;,,,.,." "...,.. ....ll2J I YO ...... ","' ..~ .... "."" '~ . .- ;>-' '-\ ....'... ,..., ......'u I ~ ' " .; \_~\ ' :5 :; t __ '- 'W"'W ! ii . ~ . -"'-. ~"'-; "':;I"~IHgM'" 1_..NBW....t:lVctV.....HEUa A"fIM >U::::I'(fd "i: ~~ :'/. ...A........ ..,.........::. !: ,j .. T ~ II h iJ ~ y.;t ~Jil:; ~.c '1 !J~$~ -1 "" ~ ,,! 'oil ~! ~ .1"1 &ll ~.I,'rllIF...... ~ ! ~ ~ ~ '" ~ <Ii CJ /I - "1 D h ~ J ", f l~ ~" ~~k 'I Iz II I . {i, LL Ul L. i i l.11 If ;) W .J W l- II) c( W m I!I ~ D m (~. > W .J W I- 11)" w, ~ ; i I '1 '~/1i hJ, ) (L.ot~~ '~~~; I " ~:! 3 $ ~ IH.~~ U~.,.. 'H'~' . ~ ! -~ ,.;! J bI ~ 1. f -: f i~~ .: II. -t .:.~( ~ . .H\ I I I \I ~'I ,,~ . ~, · f~' ~ ; ,H ~ l "!'I > ~1 !:i~i! ~ ---1 I C}~ ~ ,~ J !.t , ! , > 1 ~~ ! ~ ~ q- ! ~ . I' . . 1'1 " :J,. IL -.-1 f 11 !h ,h drt , , h~r~t ~.JLj ~) ~ I -I' !i ! :i .1{-t- ~H m I!I iiJ '.J !II ;) W .J III l- II) ~~ W.' . N T fo " r i~ ~ . ~< ~:~::I ~UJ ,"., f' ,., (. <'I ". ~ ~~ m I ~ .ih 111~! ", 1 ~ hU i l~i,J !! j '~ i~~~ IIUl ~f f x it "i3j . h<2~ h 1 ~ ~ j,< ~ s' -~ I Ii ~ ~c( !U! ~ iLi ~~ h ~., :E e s 0 ~ 0 , c i : 2 '"":: 3 .w -..... J :ffi 1 i .: ~ n I o < . i .J ~ 1 , D U 6) ,@ Gi> I: I II l' I I '1 . I , -' J' -' ' - ---.-. \ [iJ",,:.:>, ~'::,~:':":,;::::'.~.: I ':,\':::~'. ....,.... 1::\,- .NDN~"~~ ~ .~:'~/ ,La':~:~"'allnr r '~WU.W "m~;. . , '''III ',,+.!~ !1"1t1t ... ~II'Y. "".I~~' ;~II]Jl1 ~IU[ ,~=1~1':S! Ii 1 j j " BJ.NElW.LI::IYdV J,HElIB A'tIM >ltlVd :I '~ . < , i " :;0: ~ ~ j :! < < c' ~ ~ tj ]! h , H :a II IM.'~I M I \ '~ ~i II r ~ 1 I I I I I L_ _..j. ~T , I I , I I I :j J I ,J .' I , .j L___ J 3 -, j J .., ~ j I 1 I , " .-. ~ 1:: . E . ] Ii 1 Iz <I ..I '0. I W i-I 0. I;' e <I ,0 U UI I-n D , Z <I , ,'" .,..1 ~ ,1. i .j . , 1;1 I " I, , -~---j , \ ~, \ I, \ t ! ~ ; t ,1 :1 ~ l p t~1 iQ ~ ~ n :~,I ~iL! U i11m i~ ! -if . ~ ~f i;;1 tlj"j f!~ ~ 11 h;. JEI" ",!I ~H ~;;! ~ ::" ! !!! ! i i I (' ,. ~ i' , . t , ~ i i '- , , ,~ - ,. ',,\, nIECIT. IN 500349 ) CHULA. VISTA PARTY DlSCLO~_~ STATEMENT '<~:' Po ,/, ~. Statement of disclosure of certain ownership interests, payments, or campaign contributions, on all matters which will require discretionary action on the part of the City Council, Planning Commission, and all other official bodies. The following information must be disclosed: 1. List the names of all persons having a financial interest in the contract, i.e., contractor, subcontractor, material supplier. 2. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a corporation or partnership, list the names of all individuals owning more than 10% of the shares in the corporation or owning any partnership interest in the partnership. 3. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is non-profit organization or a trust, list the names of any person serving as director of the non-profit organization or as trustee or beneficiary or trustor of the trust. 4. Have you had more than $250 worth of business transacted with any member of the City staff, Boards, Commissions, Committees and Council within the past twelve months? Yes No ~ If yes, please indicate person(s): 5. Please identify each and every person, including any agents, employees, consultants or independent contractors who you have assigned to represent you before the City in this matter. Robert Bein, William Frost & Associates Karla Beckman, Real Estate Broker Amy Corton, Esq. 6. Have you and/or your officers or agents, in the aggregate, contributed more than $1,000 to a Councilmember in the current or preceding election period? Yes _ No -L If yes, state which Councilmember( s): Person is defined as: "Any individual, fiml, co+partnership, joint vennlre, association, social club, fraternal organization, Corporation, eSlate, inIS!, receiver, syndicate, this and any other county, city and counf1J~ city, nrwzicipnliry, district or other political sUbdivisioll, or allY olher group or combination aCling as a unil." (NOTE: Attach additional pages as necessary) Date: (0 - f 9 - 9/ 1,\,' 1;,\,OISCLOSE.D:Tj , Juan Manuel Sanchez Garcia and Noelia S. Sanchez Print or type name of contractor/applicant {Revised: 11/30,1)0] ,