HomeMy WebLinkAboutRDA Packet 1995/08/15
Tuesday, August 15, 1995 Council Chambers
6:00 p.m. Public Services Building
(immediately following the City Council meeting)
Joint Meeting of the RedeveloDment Agencv/Citv Council
of the CitY of Chula Vista
CALL TO ORDER
1. ROLL CALL: Agency/Council Members Alevy -' Moot -' Padilla_,
Rindone -, and Chair/Mayor Horton -
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: August I, 1995 (Joint Meeting of the Redevelopment Agency/City
Council); August I, 1995 (Special Joint Meeting of the Redevelopment
Agency/City Council)
CONSENT CALENDAR
(Items 3 through 5)
The staff recommendations regarding the following items listed under the Consent Calendar will be enacted by
the Agency by one motion without discussion unless an Agency, a member of the public or City staff requests
that the item be pulled for discussion, If you wish to speak on one of these items, please fill out a "Request to
Speak Form" available in the lobby and submit it to the Secretary of the Redevelopment Agency or the City Clerk
prior to the meeting. (Complete the green form to speak in favor of the staff recommendation; complete the pink
form to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation,) Items pulled from the Consent Calendar will be
discussed after Action Items. Items pulled by the public will be the first items of business.
3. WRITfEN COMMUNICATIONS:
4. COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 18001
and
AGENCY
RESOLUTION 1466 APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO A THREE-PARTY
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA,
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, AND CHULA VISTA BAYFRONT
CONSERVANCY TRUST FOR A LEASE, LOAN AND OPERATING
AGREEMENT FOR THE CHULA VISTA NATURE CENTER--The
Agreement approved on 5/4/93 by the Council/Agency provided the City with
specified controls and oversight of the Nature Center until the loans provided
to the Bayfront Conservancy Trust had been repaid. The lease and loan parts
of the Agreement expired in May 1995. Staff is recommending the lease and
loan aspects of the Agreement be extended until the end of July 1997. Staff
recommends approval of the resolutions. (Administration)
"I declare under penalty of perjury that 1 8m
employed by the City of Chula Vista In the
Community Development Department and that I posted
this Agenda/Notice on the Bulletin Board at the
Public lr5BUdin;;)2ty;t~ -
DATE. go, SIGNE .
Agenda -2- August 15, 1995
5. AGENCY
RESOLUTION 1467 APPROVING FINAL RESIDENTIAL MOVING EXPENSE CLAIMS
TOTALING $5,274.56 PURSUANT TO THE ADOPTED RELOCATION
PLAN FOR TWO HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY LOCATED AT 459 F
STREET--In accordance with State law and the Purchase and Sale Agreement
with the Adamo to purchase the property at 459 F Street as part of the Civic
Center Expansion Project the City and Agency requires various relocation
payments for households formerly residing at that location. Final Residential
Moving Expense claims need to be processed for the tenant of Unit B and Mrs.
Adamo, the former owner. Staff recommends approval of the resolutions.
(Community Development Director)
COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 18002 AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF $5,274.56 FROM THE CIVIC
CENTER EXPANSION PROJECT (GG-130) FOR TWO FINAL
RESIDENTIAL MOVING CLAIMS PURSUANT TO THE ADOPTED
RELOCATION PLAN FOR HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY RESIDING AT
459 F STREET
. . END OF CONSENT CALENDAR' .
PUBLIC HEARINGS AND RELATED RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES
The following items have been advertised and/or posted as public hearings as required by law. If you wish to
speak to any item, please fill out the "Request to Speak Form" available in the lobby and submit it to the
Secretary of the Redevelopment Agency or the City Clerk prior to the meeting. (Complete the green form to speak
in favor of the staffrecommendation; complete the pinkform to speak in opposition to the staffrecommendation.)
Comments are limited to five minutes per individual.
6. PUBLIC HEARING: SALE OF AGENCY PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315 FOURTH AVENUE
WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE 1 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA
TO THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, WITHOUT PUBLIC
BIDDING--Staff informed the Agency at its 5/23/95 meeting the three
proposals received for purchase of the building were unacceptable. The Agency
directed staff to prepare a Purchase and Sale Agreement for Agency/Council
review and approval. Staff recommends the Dublic hearing be continued to
SeDtember 5. 1995. Continued from the meeting of August 1, 1995,
(Community Development Director)
A. AGENCY
RESOLUTION 1458 APPROVING SALE OF CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315
FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I
REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA TO THE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA, CALIFORNIA WITHOUT PUBLIC BIDDING, APPROVING
PURCHASE AND SALE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA, CALIFORNIA, AND AUTHORIZING THE CHAIRMAN TO
EXECUTE SAME
B. COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 17926 APPROVING THE PURCHASE OF CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED
AT 315 FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I
REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA FROM THE REDEVELOPMENT
AGENCY, APPROVING A PURCHASE AND SALE AGREEMENT WITH
THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA,
CALIFORNIA, AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE
SAME
Agenda -3- August 15, 1995
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
This is an opportunity for the general public to address the Redevelopment Agency on any subject matter within
the Agency's jurisdiction that is not an item on this agenda. (State law, however, generally prohibits the
Redevelopment Agency from taking action on any issues not included on the posted agenda.) If you wish to
address the Council on such a subject, please complete the yellow "Request to Speak Under Oral Communications
Form" available in the lobby and submit it to the Secretary to the Redevelopment Agency or City Clerk prior to
the meeting. Those who wish to speak, please give your name and address for record purposes and follow up
action. Your time is limited to three minutes per speaker.
ACTION ITEMS
The items listed in this section of the agenda are expected to elicit substantial discussitms alld deliberations by
the Agency, staff, or members of the general public. The items will be considered individually by the Agency
and staff recommendations may in certain Cases be presented in the alternative. Those who wish to speak, please
fill out a "Request to Speak" form available in the lobby and submit it to the Secretary to the Redevelopment
Agency or the City Clerk prior to the meeting. Public comments are limited to five minutes.
None submitted.
ITEMS PULLED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR
This is the time the Redevelopment Agency will discuss items which have been removed from the Consent
Calendar. Agenda items pulled at the request of the public will be considered prior to those pulled by Agency
Members. Public comments are limited to five minutes per individual.
OTHER BUSINESS
7. DIRECTOR'S/CITY MANAGER'S REPORTlS)
8. CHAIR'SIMAYOR'S REPORT(S)
9. AGENCY/COUNCIL MEMBER COMMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting will adjourn to the Regular Redevelopment Agency Meeting on September 5, 1995 at 4:00 p.m.,
immediately following the City Council meeting, in the City Council Chambers.
......
COMPLIANCE WITH THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT
The City of Chula Vista, in complying with the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA), request
individuals who require special accommodations to access, attend, and/or participate in a City meeting,
activity, or service request such accommodation at least forty-eight hours in advance for meetings and
five days for scheduled services and activities. Please contact the Secretary to the Redevelopment
Agency for specific information at 619.691.5047 or Telecommunications Devices for the Deaf (TDD)
at 619.585.5647. California Relay Service is also available for the hearing impaired.
MINUTES OF A JOINT MEETING OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
Tuesday, August], 1995 Council Chambers
5:13 p.m. Public Services Building
CALL TO ORDER
1. ROLL CALL:
PRESENT: AgencylCouncil Memhers, Alevy, Moot, Padilla, Rindone, and
Chair/Mayor Horton
ALSO PRESENT: John D. Goss. Director/City Manager; Bruce M. Boogaard,
AgencylClty Attorney: and Beverly A. Aulhelet, City Clerk
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: July 25, 1995
MSUC (Horton/Moot) to approve the minutes of July 25, 1995 as presented.
CONSENT CALENDAR
(Item pulled: 4)
3. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: None.
4. RESOLUTION 1464 APPROVING LEASE BETWEEN OT A Y VISTA ASSOCIATES AND THE
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY FOR OFFICE SPACE FOR TIlE OT A Y RANCH PROJECT--The current
lease agreement between the Agency and Otay Vista Associates (Otay Ranch Projecl) will expire 8/2/95. A revised
lease has been prepared and is before th" Ageocy t(>r consideration. Staff recommends approval of the resolution.
(Community Development Director) Pulled from the Consent Calendar,
Member Moot questioned the relationship hetween Otay Vista Associates and the Baldwin Company and to what
extent that entity was related to the entities that were m hankruptcy. He agreed with the Agency Attorney's notation
that the banklllptcy issue did affect the potential ability of the City to evict a non-paying tenant.
Mr. Goss stated it was his understanding that Otay Vista was a partnership and nol currenlly subject to the
banklllptcy with its source of revenue coming from the company that was suhject to bankruptcy, i.e. the Baldwin
Company.
Member Mool questioned who the general partner was.
Chair Horton responded that it was Jim Baldwin and his brother.
Member Moot felt it was importanl to know who th" gen"ral partn"r was hecause Ihey were Ihe ultimate person
liable for the d"ht. If that was not a person or entity likely to go inlo bankruptcy th"n he felt they did not have any
real concern. However, if the g"neral partner was a partnership that could easily he taken into bankruptcy he would
have more concern about having a t"nanl in the space. Under the terms of Ihe hanklllptcy laws the Agency may
not be able to easily evict.
Chair Horton stated it was her understanding that over the last several weeks the Banknlptcy Court had allowed
approximately $85,OOO/week 10 now through to Otay Vista Associates to help keep Ihem current.
Mr. Goss stated Ihey had been approved for their processing or "go tÒrward" costs of $85,000/week. It was not
just Chula Vista and Otay Ranch, it also includ"d other projects.
Mr. Boogaard recommended that the proposed resolution he amended to eliminate any risk by saying that the
Agency approved the three month lease wjlh Otay Vista with the advance writlen approval of the banklllPtcy trustee.
Minutes
August 1, 1995
Page 2
That way it would be a clearly current cost of the Ranch prnject anJ the Agency wnulJ be protecteJ.
Member Rindone stated he wanted claritication nf Member Mnnt's cnncerns. He qnestinneJ if tbe item was time
sensitive.
Mr. Goss did not feel there would be a problem with a 0."" week Jelay.
Member Moot stated the lease expired 8/2/95 and that nnrmally leases proviJeJ Ihal they wnuld renew autamatically
on a month-to-month basis.
Mr. Boogaard stated he would be leery about evicting a manlh-tn-mnnth tenant prntected unJer bankruptcy laws
than a term tenant. He had researched the bankruptcy issue and was cnnvinceJ by cnunsel in thase areas that if Ihe
Agency had the written approval of the bankruptcy trustee that the Agency wnuld be prnteeled. Staff felt they also
mitigated the risk by recommending a three mnnth lease rather than a twelve mnnth lease. He did nal feel the
Agency would be well served by lelting it go. to. a mnnth-tn-mnnth tenancy because Ibe Agency may Ihen be subject
to the automatic stay that would prevent any evictinn prnceedings.
Member Rindone stated he was comf(>rtable with that mndificatinn. He requesteJ tbat after Joing that if staff haJ
any further concerns that it be brought back lu Ihe Agency. He feit the Agency needed tbe answers to Member
Moot's questions.
RESOLUTION 1464, AS AMENDED, OFFERED BY MEMBER RINDONE, reading of the text was waived.
Staff to return next week with a written report regarding the fiduciary relationship between Otay Vista
Associates and the Baldwin Company,
Member Moot felt it would be helpful for the Agency to. understand the relatIonshIp between the different BalJwm
entities. There were several entities that were nnt in bankruptcy which the Agency dlJ nnt neeJ to. be overly
concerned about. He felt that waulJ help 10. clear up much of the public cnnfusinn.
VOTE ON MOTION: approved unanimously.
. . END OF CONSENT CALENDAR * *
PUBLIC HEARINGS AND RELATED RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES
5. PUBLIC HEARING SALE OF AGENCY PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315 FOURTH AVENUE
WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA TO TilE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA, CALIFORNIA, WITHOUT PUBLIC BIDDING--Staff infonneJ the Agency at its 5123195 meeting the
three proposals received for purchase nf the building were unacceptable. Tbe Agency directeJ slaff to. prepare a
Purchase and Sale Agreement far AgencylCauncii review anJ approval. Staff re<luests continuance of the Puhlic
Hearing to the Agencv meeting of August 15. 1995. Continued frnm the meeting of June 20, 1995.
(Community Development Director)
A. RESOLUTION 1458 APPROVING SALE OF CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315
FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA TO THE
CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA WITHOUT PUBLIC BIDDING, APPROVING PURCHASE AND
SALE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, AND AUTHORIZING THE
CHAIRMAN TO EXECUTE SAME
B. RESOLUTION ]7926 APPROVING TilE PURCHASE OF CERTAIN PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 315 FOURTH A VENUE WIT1I1N TilE TOWN CENTRE I REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT
AREA FROM THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, APPROVING A PURCHASE AND SALE
AGREEMENT WITH THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CllULA VISTA,
CALIFORNIA, AND AUTHORIZING THE ~IA YOR TO EXECUTE SMIE
Minutes
August I, 1995
Page 3
MSUC (Rindone/Alevy) to continue the puhlic hearin~ to the 8/15/95 l1Ieetin~.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Nooe
ACTION ITEMS
6. RESOLUTION 1465 AND RESOLUTION 17985 APPROVING SUBSTITUTION OF
PROJECT UNDER A LEASE AGREEMENT (TOWN CENTRE II PARKING PROJECT - PHASE TWO)
AND AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING CERTAIN ACTIONS TIIEREWITH--The Agency aod City issued
$3.1 million in Certificates of Participalion in 1993 to pay the Agency's share of costs related to the construction
of the parking structure at Chula Vista Center. For Ihe purpose of issuing the honds, three City-owned properties
were leased to Ihe Agency and leased hack hy Ihe City. The City now wishes to sell one of those properties,
Marina View Park, to the San Diego Unitied Port DIStrict, which will necessitate suhstituting a property of equal
or greater value in the Site Lease Agreement. Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Community
Development Director)
Member Rindone questioned where the line of demarcation was t(Jr the eastem portion of the park.
Fred Kassman, Redevelopmenl Coordinator, stated it tdlowed a ootch in Ihe park and was just about the center.
The City's section of "J" Street Marioa View Park was presently in Ihe hond documents and and staff was
recouuuendin Ihe suhstitution of one-half of Memorial Park, which was approximately the same size, hut would have
a greater value. Siaff had ordered a CL TA policy which would map il oul and legally descrihe the parcel.
RESOLUTIONS 1465 AND 17985 OFFERED BY MEMBER RINDONE, readin~ of the text was waived,
passed and approved unanimously.
ITEMS PULLED FROM TilE CONSENT CALENDAR
Item pulled: 4. The minutes will ret1ect the puhlished agenda order.
OTIIER BUSINESS
7. DrRECTOR'S/CiTY MANAGER'S REPORTfSI - None
8. CHAIR'S/MA YOR'S REPORT(S) - None
9. AGENCY/COUNCIL MEMBER CmlMENTS
Member Rindone
a. Member Rindone stated the concept of the approval of Ihe Bayfront project had heen hrought before the
Agency and was conceplually approved on a 4-1 vote and from there it went hetÓre Ihe Coastal Commission fÓr
approval. He questioned if there was a condition that herore a Bayfronl plan was approved thai a DDA had to he
approved by the Agency.
Fred Kassman, Redevelopment Coordinalor, responded Ihallt had always heen staff's understanding that a DDA
was required for the project. There was more planning that was required and a Specific Plan had to be brought
back to the Agency.
Minutes
August I, 1995
Page 4
Member Rindone questioned if it was approprialè to say Ihal the Agency did nol haw an approved Bayfront plan
since the DDA was part of the condition.
Mr. Goss stated he was not certain technically whal il would mean. There was a plan that was approwd by the
Agency and Coastal Commission. It was not in a positIon In go forward and he implemenlèd because there was
no DDA or Specific Plan and additional approvals were needed.
Member Rindone stated he had received an inquiry from a consliluent and he wanlèd 10 provide claritication. There
was conceptual approval, but not an ofticially adopted Specific Plan t<>r the Bayfront.
Mr. Goss stated there was an approved plan.
Mr. Boogaard stated he concurred with Mr. Goss' assessment Ihat the first level of enlillements had been granted.
The last level had not been reached. One of the conditions was the requirement of a DDA and thai tÜrther planning
bad to occur before building permits could be drawn. They could not go forward, hut il could not be put in a use
that required new planning. If they wanted a new use, other than what was planned, they would have to get
approval of the first level on entitlements, i.e. General Plan amendments and Coaslal Commission approval.
ADJOURNMENT
ADJOURNMENT AT 5:30 P.M. to a Joint Redevelopment Agency/City Council Meeting on Augusl 15, 1995 at
6:00 p.m., immediately following the City Council meeting. in the City Council Chambers.
Respectfully suhmitlèd.
BEVERLY A. AUTHELET, CMCIAAE, City Clerk
by:
MINUTES OF A SPECIAL JOINT MEETING OF TilE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/
CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
Tuesday, August I, 1995 Council Chambers
5:30 p.m. Public Services Building
CALL TO ORDER
1. ROLL CALL:
PRESENT: Agency/Council Memhers Alevy, Moot, Padilla, Rindone, and Chair/Mayor
Horton
ALSO PRESENT: John D. Goss, Director/Cily Manager; Bruce M. Boogaard, Agency/Council
Attorney; and Beverly A. Autheld, City Clerk
2. APPRO V AL OF MINUTES: None.
BUSINESS
3. Written Communications: None.
4. PUBLIC HEARING JOINT REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/CITY COUNCIL HEARING
PURSUANT TO THE CHULA VISTA MUNICIPAL CODE AND CALIFORNIA HEALTH AND SAFETY
CODE SECTION 33431 AND 33433 REGARDING TilE PROPOSED DISPOSITION BY THE AGENCY OF
CERT AINREAL PROPERTY LOCA TED AT 760 BROADWAY COMPRISED OF APPROXIMA TEL Y 2,53
ACRES TO BROADWAY VILLAGE BUSINESS HOMES, L. P, AND THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
OF SAID PROPERTY INTO A 36-UNIT MIXED-USE BUSINESS HOMES PROJECT, SUCH PUBLIC
HEARING TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING SPECIFIC PROPOSED ACTiONS:--The City Council and
Redevelopment Agency are requesled to hold the requisite public hearings and take the actions necessary to approve
the Broadway Business Homes pf(~ject and authorize execution of a Disposition and Development Agreement with
Joelen Enterprises (Josef and Lenore Cilron) t(" the development of the project. Actions required include a zoning
change for the project from Thoroughfare Commercial 10 Central Commercial-Precise Plan; a Special Use Permit
with Shared Parking Agreemenl to estahlish the mixed-use project; and approval of a Precise Plan with Conditions
for development of the Project and approval of the DDA, and sale of Ihe properly without public bidding. Staff
recommends the Council and Agency approve Ihe reso!ulions and place the Ordinance on tirst reading. (Community
Development Director)
I. Review and adoption of Miti~ated Ne~ative Declaration and Addendum IS-95-03
2. Approval of an amendment to the znnin~ map or maps estahlished hy Section 19.18.010 of
the Chula Vista Municipal Code hy reznnin~ the 2.532 aue parcel Incated at 760 Broadway
within the Southwest Redevelopment Projed Area from CoT (Commercial Thoroughfare) to
C-C-P (Central Commercial with PnÚse Plan)
3. Issuance of a Special Use Permit to construd a 36-unit commercial/residential mixed-use
project with Shared Parkin~ A~reement
4, Approval of a Precise Plan to allow construction nf a 36-unit mixed-use project including
associated site improvements
5. Approval of a Disposition and Development Agreement between the A~ency and Joelen
Enterprises
A. RESOLUTION 17964 AND RESOLUTION 1460 ADOIYfING MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION AND ADDENDUM IS-95-03 FOR A 36-UNIT BUSINESS HOMES PROJECT AT 760
BROADWAY
B. ORDINANCE 2636 AMENDING THE ZONING MAP OR MAPS ESTABLISHED BY SECTION
19.18,010 OF THE CHULA VISTA MUNICIPAL CODE BY REZONING THE 2.53 ACRE PARCEL
LOCATED AT 760 BROADWA Y WITHIN TilE SOUTHWEST REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA
FROM CoT (COMMERCIAL THOROUGHFARE) TO C-C-P, CENTRAL COMMERCIAL WITH PRECISE
PLAN (First Readin2)
-
Minutes
August 1, 1995
Page 2
C. RESOLUTION 1461 MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS AND GRANTING A SPECIAL USE
PERMIT FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF A MIXED-USE PROJECT KNOWN AS THE BROADWAY
BUSINESS HOMES PROJECT, LOCATED AT 760 BROADWAY WITHIN THE SOUTHWEST
REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA TO BROADWAY VILLAGE BUSINESS HOMES, LP.
D. RESOLUTION 1462 AND RESOLUTION 17965 APPROVING A PRECISE PLAN FOR THE
BROADWAY BUSINESS HOMES PROJECT AND A DISPOSITION AND DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
WITH BROADWAY BUSINESS HOMES, LP., AND AUTHORIZING THE CHAIR TO EXECUTE SAME
E. RESOLUTION 1463 WAIVING THE CONSULT ANTSELECTION PROCESS, AUTHORIZING
EXECUTION OF A TWO-PARTY AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY AND
WOODWARD-CLYDE CONSULTANTS FOR SOIL TESTING AI'ID REMEDIATION CONSULTING
SERVICES AT 760 BROADWAY, AND APPROPRIATING FUNDS THEREFOR--Demolilion of buildings
at the Fuller Ford site will necessilale removal of contaminated soils. It will he necessary to have a qualified
hazardous materials consultant present during demolition. Staff recommends this item he withdrawn from
consideration. The item will be brought forward at a future date contingent upon approval of a Disposition
and Development Agreement. (Not a part of the Puhlic Hearing, hut a related item.) (Community Development
Director)
Chair/Mayor Horton noted that the public hearing was open.
Dave Gustafson, Deputy Director of Communily Development, stated the issue was brought back to the
Agency/Council from the public hearing of 7/25/95. At that meeting there was clear direction given 10 staff on the
key issue associated with the project, i.e. the terms of Ihe disposition of the Agency owned property 10 the
developer. The developer's response came close to the Agency's position, hut differed in the area of the timing
of the demolition. A memo had been placed on the dais which identified the developer's proposal on Ihe demolition
issue. The developer was present and prepared 10 address the Agency/Council on the issue. Staff had done an
analysis of the developers position, together with the Agency/City Attorney's office, and he believed the Attorney
would recommend that if the Agency/Council wanted to contemplate the developer's proposal any tÜrther that it be
done in Closed Session.
Mr. Boogaard stated that was correct.
Member Rindone questioned if there was concurrence by the applicant to the exacl conditions authorized by the
Agency/Council for negotiation.
Mr. Gustafson responded that they did except for the issue of when demolition would occur and what would be
secured. There was also some tIne tuning of elements he felt were consislent with the direction from the
Agency/Council. Direction had heen given that the developer take down the property in two phases, roughly equal,
and to pay $275,000 each up fronl for those acquisitions. The minor moditicalion Ihat made ilmore rational was
that because the property might not be taken down in exactly two phases of equal square t()otage, the amount of
payment for of the parcels would be calculated on a proportional square t()()t hasis. It was effectively Ihe same
thing, but could result in a minor modification in the purchase price of each parcel.
Memher Rindone questioned if slaff was ready to indicate to the Agency/Council that the full intention and
modifications met the direction of the Agency/CounCIl in the agreement.
Mr. Gustafson replied staff was not. The developer had approached the position the Agency/Council articulated
at the last meeting, but he did not feel they were enlirely there. He felt the Agency/Council would be well served
to consider the differences in Closed Session.
Member Rindone stated if the full conditions of the Agency/Council had not heen concurred upon he wanted to
review those differences.
Mr. Boogaard stated he was prepared to articulate those differences in Closed Session.
* * * Council met in Closed Session at 5:35 p.m. and reconvened at 6: 10 p.m. * * *
Minutes
August I, 1995
Page 3
. Josef Citron, 761 Golden Park, S,m Diego, CA, representing Joelen Enterprises, stated they were prepared
to go forward and accept the Council's manda"', the City Attorney's wording, and Ihe Council's wishes so the
project could go forward.
There being no further puhlic testimony, the public bearing was declared closed.
Mr. Boogaard stated Resolutions 1462 and 17965, Item D, needed to be amended to autborize the City Attorney
and City Manager to prepare the moditicalions 10 Ibe DDA in the manner the Agency/Council previously directed
on 7/25/95; and, consistent with that, authorize the Mayor to execute a DDA and adopt all resolutions and
ordinances on the agenda.
Member Rindone requested thai the Agency/City Attorney review the terms agreed upon.
Mr. Boogaard stated the terms in contention would be that escrow was to be opened, the Agency/Council would
tolerate the six unit financing conlingency as a condilion 10 closing Ihat escrow, unless the applicant wished to waive
it, the escrow would be closed and the City would receive $275,000 for the tïrsl half of the project, demolition
would proceed and the remediation would take place, and Ihen they would take down the olher half of the property
for $275,000.
RESOLUTIONS 17964, 1460, 1461, 17965, AS AMENDED, AND 1462, AS AMENDED, OFFERED AND
ORDINANCE 26'36 PLACED ON FIRST READING BY MEMBER RINDONE, reading of the text was
waived,
Mr. Boogaard questioned if Hem E, Resolution 1463, required aclion.
Mr. Gustafson responded that Ihe issue was not critical to the actIOn being taken by Ihe Agency/Council and staff
requested the ilem be deferred because it was nol time sensitive.
VOTE ON MOTION: approved 4-1 with Alevy opposed.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
. Bill Ayers, 44 East Mankato Street, Chula Vista, CA, informed Council that Ihe U.S. House of
Representatives had approved the federal t[¡nding of the Chula Vista veterans home.
OTHER BUSINESS
5. DTRECTOR'S/CITY MANAGER'S REPORT(S) - None
6. CHAIR'S/MA YOR'S REPORT(S) - None
7. AGENCY/COUNCIL MEMBER COMMENTS - None
AD 10URNMENT
ADJOURNMENT AT 6: 19 P.M. to the Regular Redevelopment Agency Meeling on August 15, 1995 at 6:00 p.m.,
immediately following the City Council meeting, in the City Council Cbambers.
by:
This page blank.
-.u - -
JOINT COUNCIL/AGENCY AGENDA STATEMENT 1
Item
Meeting Date 8/15/95
ITEM TITLE: A. Council Resolution /ð'ðo / Approving First
Amendment to the Three Party Agreement between the
city of Chula Vista, Redevelopment Agency, and
Chula vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust for a Lease,
Loan and Operating Agreement for the Chula vista
Nature Center
B. Agency Resolution /11.0 1.0 Approving First
Amendment to the Three Party Agreement between the
City of Chula vista, Redevelopment Agency, and
Chula vista Bayfront conservancy Trust for a Lease,
Loan and operating Agreement for the Chula vista
Nature Center ~,
'SUBMITTED BY: Deputy city Manager Thomson ;;'. '. ~\
REVIEWED BY: City Manager/Executive Director~~~I\¿1.~
,~
(4/Sths Vote: Yes- No_X_J
At the joint Council/Agency meeting on May 4, 1993, the city
Council and Redevelopment Agency approved a three party agreement
between the City, Redevelopment Agency, and Bayfront Conservancy
Trust (BCT) for a Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement for the
operation of the Chula vista Nature Center. The components of that
Agreement which provide the city with specified controls and
oversight of the Nature Center operations will continue in effect
until the loans that the City and the Agency have provided to the
BCT have been repaid, but the lease and loan components of the
Agreement expired in May 1995.
When the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement was approved in May
1993, two year terms were provided for the lease and loan
components of the agreement with the anticipation that during that
two year period, City and Agency negotiations with the bayfront
developer would be completed and either a benefit assessment
district or some other funding mechanism to pay for ongoing
operations and maintenance of the Nature Center would be
established. As the Council is aware, negotiations with the
bay front developer have not been completed, and a Council
subcommittee was recently established to review issues related to
the Disposition and Development Agreement with the bayfront
developer, which could include the issue of the benefit assessment
district for the ongoing operations and maintenance at the Nature
Center. Staff is therefore recommending that the lease and loan
components of the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement be extended
until the end of July 1997.
if-I
-
~ #'(
Meeting Date 8/15/95
Page 2
RECOMMENDATION: That Council and Agency adopt the resolutions
approving the First Amendment to the Lease, Loan and Operating
Agreement for the Chula vista Nature Center.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: The BCT Board of Directors has
approved in concept the proposed First Amendment to the Lease, Loan
and Operating Agreement and authorized the Executive Director of
the BCT to finalize its provisions.
DISCUSSION:
Attached to this report is a copy of the Lease, Loan and operating
Agreement approved in May 1993. The only changes to the May 1993
Agreement included in the proposed Amendment are to extend the term
of the lease and loan components of the Agreement from May 1995 to
July 31, 1997, and to update the existing loan amounts to reflect
the new loans that have been made to the BCT since May 1993 as well
as the accrued interest through FY 1994-95. As of June 30, 1995,
the loan amounts, including accrued interest, are $1,754,285 that
the Redevelopment Agency has loaned to the BCT, and $1,874,392 that
the city has loaned to the BCT ($46,607 from the Sewer Income Fund
and the remainder from the. General Fund), for a total loan amount
of $3,628,677.
Similar to the May 1993 Agreement, the amendment calls for the
parties to meet and confer during the next two years to establish
a mutually agreeable repayment schedule and terms, and includes
provisions requiring payment in full of the outstanding loan amount
at the end of the loan term if agreement on a repayment schedule is
not reached. It also provides for repayment terms the city and
Agency would accept unless modified during negotiations: 8%
interest, 3D-year fully amortized repayment schedule, with payments
increasing by 5% each year.
It is hoped that during this two year period, city/Agency
negotiations with the bayfront developer will be completed and that
either a benefit assessment district or some other funding
mechanism to pay for ongoing operations and maintenance of the
Nature Center will be established. At that time, a new lease,
rental payments and a repayment schedule for outstanding loans to
the City and Agency would be determined. Staff proposes to keep
the rent at $1 per year for this two year period, until the
long-term funding mechanism is established.
In the last several years, the city and the BCT have taken steps to
try to minimize the BCT's annual deficits and resulting need to
obtain loans from the city and Redevelopment Agency. These steps
have included instituting admission fees to the Nature Center and
tf~2-
.- -.. --
~ -#1
Meeting Date 8/15/95
Page 3
reducing its costs where feasible, such as by reducing the
frequency its newsletter is produced. Nonetheless, the annual
operating deficit for the BCT is over $375,000.
The loan section of the Agreement therefore allows for future city
and Agency loans to the BCT for operating budget expenses and
capital improvements. For FY 1995-96 it is anticipated that the
City will loan the BCT an additional $181,679 and the Agency will
loan the BCT an additional $196,466, as was approved by the Council
and Agency during the recent budget review process.
While these additional loan amounts, as well as the existing loans,
are all being booked as loans and accruing interest, it should be
emphasized that at this point, it is hard to envision the BCT being
able to repay the loans that are being booked. At some point, the
City and Agency may want to consider forgiving part of the loans,
but staff is not recommending such action at this time.
At least until the loans have been repaid (or the Agreement is
further amended to provide otherwise), the Lease, Loan and
Operating Agreement includes the following City/Agency operational
controls over the Nature Center:
-- The city Council has the authority to ratify or
disapprove any future changes to the BCT Articles of
Incorporation or By-Laws.
-- The city Manager will be the appointing authority for the
BCT staff, with input from the BCT Board of Directors or
its Executive Director, and the city will determine the
salaries of the BCT staff.
-- The city Manager will supervise the Executive Director of
the BCT and oversee its staff and operations, with input
from the BCT Board.
-- The City's Finance Director or Assistant Finance Director
will serve as the Treasurer of the BCT and oversee its
expenditures and purchasing procedures.
-- The City will determine the annual budget of the Nature
Center with input from the BCT.
-- The BCT is required to use the City's purchasing system
and procedures when spending funds from its operating
budget and special donation accounts.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Þ/~3
~ ill
Meeting Date 8/15/95
Page 4
The recommended Amendment updates and formalizes the existing City
and Redevelopment Agency loans to the BCT. Including accrued
interest, as of June 30, 1995, the existing loan amounts to the BCT
are:
~ Loaned By
$1,827,785 City General Fund
46,607 City Sewer Income Fund
$1.754.285 Redevelopment Agency
$3,628,677 TOTAL
The Amendment calls for the repayment of these loans in July 1997
or under a repayment schedule to be negotiated by July 1997.
However, the BCT is unlikely to be able to repay these loans, and
at some future point, the City and Agency may want to consider
forgiving part of the loans.
until a long-term funding mechanism is established, the City and
Agency may need to continue to help financially support the
maintenance and operations of the Nature Center. In FY 1995-96, it
is anticipated that the City will loan the BCT an additional
$181,679 and the Agency will loan the BCT an additional $196,466,
as approved by the Council and Agency in June 1995.
The Agreement also provides operational controls over the Nature
Center to help protect the City and Agency's investments in the
Nature Center.
Attachments:
- Proposed Amendment
- original May 1993 Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement
"' \SHARED\IoDMIN\Al13. BCT
'-l~'-I-
_... _.
First Amendment
to the Three Party Agreement
Between
City of Chula Vista,
Redevelopment Agency of the City of Chu1a Vista, and
Chu1a vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
for a Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement
for the Chula Vista Nature Center
This Amendment, dated July 25, 1995, for purposes of
reference only, and effective as of the date last executed by the
parties hereto, is between the city of Chula vista ("city"), a
municipal corporation of the state of California, the
Redevelopment Agency of the City of Chula vista ("Agency"), a
political subdivision of the state of California, and the Chula
vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust ("BCT"), a California non-profit
corporation, and is made with reference to the following facts:
WHEREAS, the City, Agency and BCT entered into a three-
party agreement ("Original Agreement") on May 26, 1993 for a
Lease, Loan, and Operating Agreement for the Chula vista Nature
Interpretive Center; and
WHEREAS, the name of the Chula vista Nature
Interpretive Center has been subsequently changed to the Chula
vista Nature Center ("Nature Center"); and
WHEREAS, the Original Agreement included separate terms
for its Lease Term (Section 1.3), its Loan Term (Section 2.3.1),
its Operating Term (Section 3.1), and its General provisions Term
(Section 4.1); and
WHEREAS, section 1.3 of the Original Agreement provided
that the Lease Term was for a period of two years through April
30, 1995, and provided that the intent of the parties was to
negotiate a new lease prior to April 30, 1995 for an extended
period of time, when the long-term financing mechanisms for the
Chula vista Nature Center are clarified; and
WHEREAS, section 2.3.1 of the Original Agreement
provided that the Loan Term was for two years after the execution
of the Original Agreement, and provided that the parties agreed
to meet and confer in good faith to develop a loan repayment
schedule and terms when the long-term financing mechanisms for
the Nature Center are clarified; and
WHEREAS, section 3.1 of the Original Agreement provided
that the Operating Term shall be until the loans referenced in
section 2 are fully repaid, or until the termination of the Lease
Term, whichever is later; and
WHEREAS, section 4.1 of the Original Agreement provides
that the General Provisions Term shall be until the Lease Term,
Loan Term or Operating Term has expired, whichever comes later;
and
WHEREAS, the long-term financing mechanisms for the
Nature Center have still not been resolved; and
'-1-.5
-2-
WHEREAS, the BCT not only has been unable to repay any
of the loans from the city and Agency that were outstanding at
the time the Original Agreement was executed, but also has
received additional loans from the City and Agency to cover its
operating budget and other expenses; and
WHEREAS, this First Amendment will permit the BCT to
continue to operate the Nature Center by extending the Lease
Term; and
WHEREAS, this First Amendment will provide a mechanism
for the city and Agency to continue to make loans to the BCT to
cover its operating budget and other expenses until the BCT
secures independent financing, and to negotiate loan repayment
terms and schedule.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of their mutual
promises, the City, Agency and BCT hereby agree that the original
Agreement is hereby amended in the following respects only:
A. Section 1. 3 (Lease Term) is amended to read as follows:
The lease shall be in effect from May 1, 1995 through
July 31, 1997 ("Lease Term"). It is the intent of the parties to
negotiate a new lease prior to July 31, 1997 for an extended
period of time, when the long-term financing mechanisms for the
Nature Center are clarified. At that time, a longer lease term
may then be established.
B. section 1. 4 (Rental Payment) is amended to read as
follows:
The BCT agrees to pay Agency as rental payment for the
use of the Nature Center facilities the sum of $1 (one dollar)
per year for the Lease Term provided in the First Amendment. The
negotiations referenced in section 1.3 will determine the rental
payments for any lease terms subsequent to July 31, 1997, and
whether they should be increased to fair market rental value.
C. A new section 2.2.3 (Updated Existing Loan Amounts) is
added to the Agreement as follows:
As of June 30, 1995, the outstanding loans to the BCT,
including interest accrued through June 30, 1995, are
$1,874,392.32 from the city ($1,827,784.93 from the City's
General Fund and $46,607.39 from the City's Sewer Income Fund)
and $1,754,284.50 from the Agency, for a total of $3,628,676.82.
Attached as Exhibit E is a table which lists the annual loan
amounts and interest accrued through June 30, 1995. These loans
shall continue to accrue interest during the Loan Term at the
interest rates as shown in Exhibit E, subject to the provisions
of section 2.3. These amounts include the amounts shown in
sections 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 of the Original Agreement.
D. section 2.3 (Loan Repayment Schedule and Terms) is
amended to read as follows: 1-~
.-. -
-3-
2.3.1 The parties agree to meet and confer in good
faith to develop a loan repayment schedule and terms by
July 31, 1997 ("Loan Term"). It is the intent of the
parties that this loan repayment schedule and terms be
determined when the long-term financing mechanisms for
the Nature Center are clarified.
2.3.2 Should the parties fail to reach agreement
during said time, then the outstanding loans plus
interest shall be due and payable in full at the end of
the Loan Term.
2.3.3 Should good faith negotiations be completed
and agreement be reached on a loan repayment schedule
and terms during the Loan Term, then a new loan
agreement will be established prior to or at the end of
the Loan Term.
2.3.4 The City and Agency stipulate that they will
accept a loan repayment schedule and terms as follows:
a fully amortized thirty year loan at an annual
interest rate of 8%, beginning in FY 1997-98. If the
BCT chooses, the city and Agency will allow the annual
payments to start at a lower amount and gradually
increase by 5% per year, with the present value of the
graduated payments equal to the fully amortized loan
repayments with flat annual payments. However, the
parties, by mutual agreement, may formulate an
alternate repayment schedule and terms.
E. Except as herein provided, all other terms and
conditions of the Original Agreement, not expressly or indirectly
amended by the terms of this Amendment, shall remain in full
force and effect and shall otherwise govern the terms of this
Amendment.
(End of Page. Next Page is Signature Page.)
tf-7
-
-4-
Signature Page
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, city, Agency and BCT have executed
this First Amendment as of the date indicated adjacent to their
signature.
Dated: CITY OF CHULA VISTA
by:
Mayor
Attest:
city Clerk
Approved as to Form:
City Attorney
Dated: REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA
by:
Chairman
Attest:
Secretary to the Redevelopment Agency
Approved as to Form:
Agency Attorney
Dated: CHULA VISTA BAYFRONT CONSERVANCY
TRUST:
by:
Chairman
Attest:
Executive Director-Chula vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
M ,ISIIAREDIAD MIN\AMEND .Bet
+_ð'
Exhibit E
f $i~S~~~~~~:~ ~ 88~~~~=~:~ ~ ~I
wr ~~iI'Ñ~~~~~~:~ ~ 2~Ñci~~~:i è ~.
- -=~~~ ~- ~~~~~-e:~ $ ~~~~~~~~:N ~ ~I
e s~~~~ i~~~~i~~~~¡Ñ i ~i~~~iiR¡1 ~ ~I
~8 N~~~IC -N j~ ~NNICNN ~!~ ~i
~ e $i~S~~~~~~:~ ~ 88~~~~=~:~ ~ ~.
~ =gS~ ~~~å¿~~~~~:~ ~ 2~~~~~~ci:~ ~ ~!
-x-«o ~~~~~N~~~ .N ~ ~~~~o-~_.$
8 ~¡;~i ~ii~~~~~~ :: Ñ iiiiii~~¡f - ~I
-!!- - : -- ¡ !
: 8 : 8 8 I
=' ; : 0 : 0 0 !
u h . .!
:¡¡ i
~~~~~~~~~~:~ ~ ~~~~~~~~:~ ~ ~:
-«~w i~~~~~~~~~:~ ~ !!~~~6~~~:~ ~ ~I
ê~!~~ ii;ii}~~~ !§ Ñ ~iii~~~~!~ ~ ~I
---000-- 0 ---00- 0
~ ~~O----- ~ ~~o---
_u__uu_- ------
u iลก ~~~!~!!!~~ ! ~~~~~!!~ !
88~g~li!~ :II! 8 88~~Pi~$:1;; 121
15, ~i~ici2~ :1 å 2~2~88~:1i! ~!
e - «, ~..~..~.. .15 ~-"'N--'" 8.
: ~ ~5 i~iii~ i~ ~~i~~~ ii ii
e::J ~ . .
- ~~! ~~~~~~~~~~¡~ ~ ~~~~~~~~:~ ~ ~!
~i8- ~e~ å;~~~~~~~~:~ ~ g~~~~~g~:~ ~ ~.
S ~ ~ii åi~~!~ii~~!~ ~ iiii~~i~!~ i ~.
88:8 8:8 81
H ~-~.¡~- ~:~- ~-¡
;¡ ~ Pi ~ : ~ ,. 1
.. eN! N C i
88888888 :8 8 8888888 :8 8 81
~='~ ~§~~~~~~ i! ~ §~~~~~~ i~ ~ ii
~!I!:::-~-~':'8:~-i:;; '-~$¡;;-~-ii8-~- :!!'~.;:!
~I~ ---N- - -----N i~ ~i
~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~
0 ---------- --------
~~~ccccccc C ~~~ccccc
.
~~ !!!!!!!!!! ~ ~~~~~~~~ !
- R: ~
!I! \;1, ~ t; \;1'~ ~~
~ ¡¡a ¡ ~ ~~ ~ ~ 1 i
~ ~~~ ~N - C ¡¡ ¡ 0 «
~ ~ ~11 R:l~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ! =
~ ; -~~~~~~ i - i 11-1 ~ i ~
w R = 1::~1:. ~ cc ~~~~ i I ~
~ ~ ! ~~ ~ii:.i{ ~ : ~~ ~:::: ~ ~
= ~- :;i: i1 ~ E i :;¡:iiii ~ . ~
~ ~~ ~.>i]]ii]; ~ i ~.>i_-i- . . .
~ we .~~~-- --f ~ .~~-~~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~;~i ~~~~!!~~s= !! ~ ~~~eee~e !! i 0
ï~~~ wi..~~~;'ff~ f ..~~~~ff f
w~ii i:~~!~~~~~~: ~ ~~!~~~~~ ~
~2~2 :~~~~2~~~*~ ~ ~~~~22~* ~
1- 9
. Exhibit E
ล -=
~ i
.. '"
;¡ .
.. ..
.! . 11
~ :: a
.!: ~ j
I iò
¡¡ fi ~
- ~ 0
~ :: ~
I! ¡¡ ¡¡
:: ,~} ..;
:a ~ ...
c .. ....
1i: i-.: õ
t ~ti ~
~ '¡¡' ..: ~
- é ~ . -
"'5! ...co ~
!I .... ~ I:
:. : Ii . :::
- Ii ~E~ ".
" .- '" ..
.c ...... - on
~ !i5~ .;
).. ~,,¡ ,;:
ล ¡:¡ i ~
~I - ~ I ~!i
II] ~ ~
, . !i"
"-8." ._.~.,
E ;lliE . ..~I~~~
J: a~¡J: .1£:::-:--
ill :;;!II"Ii ill I! - 2 II ~ ¡¡ ¡: IS:
" . ->-:gN I,~"
.s :8::¡'::_~&!>-S!.=~¡:
!' =~1i:';:¡;:¡;:';:~!i;¡!i!i
.;¡ .J:".:!c.!icli",::"" c
~ fiill.. ... ol~Q.~~ w
¡ ,,:I!!i;~e-~~~~ ~
~ =~~=~~f8~;¡~~ ¡¡¡
¡j ~ .¡r¡if:::;:!'¡¡';:¡¡¡¡ ~ a~ ~
;¡ :~"lI:;:~¡f'ii~i!~~ ::; e ~f~ ~
u ¡¡ 15"::~~¡¡-:l'-- e 5 ~~~ ~
.. ~ ....-cz""" i! ~ z......
.. c-¡r¡."M- on~..on 5" w ~ww w
= ;;::' ~.~"'S'~.o._.o"; ~ æ ~ ~ ~~a ¡¡¡
" ~0Ilf..1-~¡:'¡¡ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~f Q.
~ .... C>N"OalNV>NN ..§lv> e ~ Q.~" ..
15 "O~~--" - -- w~~ 5z wi! wz Z
J: .c~ ~ "N""¡"" V>~.. ~.. ~5""~ Ii!
ill ~ Ii ~ ~ i ~ -.: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.. ! ~ ~ ~ Z~ ~ ~ ~ ~
" "'5!~~~~;~i~!~¡¡; ~z~ _w Õ¡ -~~~
~ ;....c...~....'- . c~::¡ ~¡¡¡~ ~ ~
.! to .¡¡:.-~..i"i"i"'R; Q::w>~~:;;õ::: ~~w;w
~ ¡ol~Ñ"'> N;!: æ!!.""~;!z~..w"'fiJ...fiJ
!i ii~ .....,- .,..Ie i)...i",o""'-Q."iE"~"
4~I"N;="';~;; ili!..~.!~~~=~~e-~..
~ -~.! ..".. æB!!I>¡;¡~ cc...z ~- ...
f 6~_~~!!i.s!!i!! ~~i;..a!S¡~~:;;~~;~
: "6fi>-";~8~~~~ ~..w..~i~~~~i~~"'_>
c fi &!i-~"-~-- "'!!I!!!I~ W-5~ ~~iE ..
- - ~-_oõ~Sõ z........"::;~:::~ c "e~~
.. ~ I:: - ~ :: ::"'5! " : ~ ~ "~V>.. V> ~ aI Q."" ~ i ~.. ~ 0
i ~~¡¡2;~"!~"~~ i ,
~ :¡~::;:.::~¡¡.::~.::.:: ~ 8~~~~~~~Ñ~~~~~~1
i .....-...................... ~ -NNN444"""iiI......¡s;¡s;...¡s;
~ =S6 ~;~S;โฌ~§ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.;;
5
z
/f--If)
\'A TT AC.HMEtJT "
Three Party Agreement
Between
City of Chula Vista,
Redevelopment Agency of the City of Chula Vista, and
Chula Vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
for a Lease, Loan, and Operating Agreement
for the Chula Vista Nature Interpretive Center
This Agreement, dated May 4, 1993, for the purposes of
reference only, and effective as of the date last executed by the
parties hereto, is executed between the City of'Chula Vista
("City"), a municipal corporation of the state of California, the
Redevelopment Agency of the City of Chula Vista ("Agency"), a
political subdivision of the State of California, and the Chula
Vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust ("BCT"), a California non-profit
corporation, for a lease, loan, and operating agreement for the
Chula Vista Nature Interpretive Center ("NIC"): and is made with
reference to the following facts:
Whereas, Agency warrants that Agency is the owner of the
Nature Interpretive Center ("NIC") building generally located as
described in Exhibit A hereto: and
Whereas, Agency owns a grant of easement to the property on
which the NIC is sited and a License for Access and Utility Line
Purposes for the NIC, as described in Exhibit B hereto: and
Whereas, the BCT was incorporated as a non-profit public
corporation to oversee the NIC and to implement the City's Local
Coastal Plan's environmental management provisions, including,
but not limited to: preserving land for scientific, ecological,
recreational, scenic and open space opportunities: engaging in
the restoration, enhancement and preservation of the Sweetwater
Marsh: receiving and holding dedications of land, and increasing
public knowledge of and support for natural resource
conservation: and
Whereas, Agency and BCT entered into a five year lease
agreement on February 24, 1987 for the lease of said NIC property
for the operation of the NIC. Said lease expired on February 24,
1992: and
Whereas, city and BCT entered into a cooperation agreement
on January 6, 1987 for the hiring of City employees for the NIC
and for the provision of other employee services by the City to
the BCT: and
Whereas, City has loaned the BCT $1,129,469 to date
(includes interest accrued through June 30, 1993) to fund the BCT
operating budget since the opening of the NIC: and
ni c8gmt2 .wp-'/22/93
t-f-/I fZ. ,"Io9c
... -. . ~
2
Whereas, Agency has loaned the BCT $1,107,963 to date
(includes interest accrued through June 30,1993) to fund the BCT
operating budget since the opening of the NIC: and
Whereas, Agency was responsible for construction of the NIC
and provided $1.8 million of its $2.25 million construction cost
and is therefore entitled to collect rent: and
Whereas, the City, at a regular City Council meeting of June
30, 1992 directed staff to prepare a Lease, Loan, and Operating
Agreement for consideration by the City, Agency and BCT: and
Whereas, outside negotiations have begun to consider ongoing
funding of the NIC, via a financing mechanism separate from this
Agreement, which will be completed at an indeterminate time in
the future: and
Whereas, because these negotiations involve development of
an ongoing financing mechanism for the NIC, final resolution
regarding repayment of the outstanding loans from the City and
Agency and a final decision regarding future payment of rent
cannot yet be determined: and
Whereas, development of an Agreement which covers all
operating items, recognizes these outstanding loans and allows
for the parties to meet and confer on a loan repayment schedule
and future rental payments is desirable: and
Whereas, this Agreement will permit BCT to continue to.
operate the NIC by renting the facility from the Agency: and
Whereas, this Agreement will' allow BCT to continue to
utilize City employees to operate the NIC, receive continued
assistance for supervision, administration, purchásinq, .
accounting and other areas as needed from the City: and
Whereas, this Agreement provides a mechanism for the City
and Agency to continue to make loans to the BCT to cover its
operating budget and other expenses until BCT secures independent
financing and to negotiate loan repayment terms and schedule.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of their mutual promises,
the Parties agree as follows:
1. Lease Provisions.
1.1 Grant of Lease.
The Agency hereby leases the NIC to BCT on the terms and
conditions herein set forth.
n;c.gmt2.wp-~/22/93
¿.¡.-Iv
3
1.2. Purpose.
BCT shall use the premises solely for the following pur-
poses: maintaining and operating thereon a building and other
facilities for use as a Nature Interpretive Center for the
general public and for all reasonable and lawful purposes
incidental thereto. BCT ag:ees to use said pre~ises solely for
the purposes herein stated.
1.3. Lease Term.
The lease shall be in effect for a period of two years, from
May 4, 1993 through April 30,1995 ("LeaBe Term"). It is the
intent of the parties to negotiate a new lease prior to April 30,
1995 for an extended period of time, when the long-term financing
mechanisms for the NIC are clarified. At that time, a longer
lease term may then be established.
1.4. Rental Payment.
BCT agrees to pay Agency as rental payment for the use of
the NIC facilities the sum of $1 (one dollar) per year for the
initial two-year Lease Term. The negotiations referenced in
Section 1.3 will determine the rental payments for any lease
terms subsequent to April 30, 1995, and whether they should be
increased to fair market rental value.
1.5. Rights Granted.
In exchange for said rental payment, BCT is granted the
right to have exclusive use of the 12,000 square foot NIC
building and 3.4 acres of grounds, operate the NIC, and determine
the programming and scheduling of the NIC's activities,
consistent with any restrictions and purposes provided herein,
and subject to the provisions of Section 1.6.
L6. Subrental of NIC Facility.
L6.1. Subleases.
With the exception of Sections 1.6.2 and 1.6.3 listed
below, BCT shall not sublease any portion of the building or
premises without prior written approval of the City Council and
the Redevelopment Agency.
1.6.2. Conditions under which rentals will be allowed.
The BCT may rent out on a temporary basis all or
portions of the NIC to various individuals or groups, subject to
the approval of the Executive Director of the BCT, and policies
n; cegmtZ. wp-4/22/93
if - 15
-
4
established by the BCT Board of Directors for such use, such that
said rentals shall not impede or interfere with the stated
purposes or operations of the NIC.
1.6.2.1. The entire NIC, or a portion thereof, may
be rented on a day-to-day basis according to the rates, policies
and procedures established by the BCT.
1.6.2.2. The City and Agency shall have the right
to monitor said rentals and terminate any temporary rentals
should they interfere with the operations of the NIC.
1.6.3. City and Agency Usage.
The City or Agency departments may use the NIC for
official functions free of charge on a first-come, first-served
basis.
1. 7. Liens.
BCT shall keep the premises, building and the property upon
which the building is situated, free from any liens arising out
of the work performed, materials furnished, or obligations
incurred by BCT. Failure to keep said premises free of liens
shall constitute a major breach of the covenants of this
Agreement and grounds for termination by City or Agency, at
City's or Agency's sole option.
1.8. Utilities.
BCT hereby covenants and agrees that all utilities and
services necessary for the use and occupation of said premises
shall be provided and paid for by BCT, including but not limited
to, water, sewer, electricity, gas, telephone and trash disposal.
1.9. Major Improvements.
BCT shall not make any major improvements or additions to
the NIC and premises without prior written approval of the City
Manager or his/her representative. Said improvements and
additions shall include, but not be limited to, changes to the
exterior or interior, room additions, signs, new plantings and
new indoor or outdoor exhibits. Major is defined as structural
alteration or repair: or an expense of $5,000 or more on a single
interior or exterior project, such as a new exhibit.
1.10. Payment of Taxes.
BCT shall be liable for and shall pay, at least ten days
before delinquency, taxes levied against any personal property or
n¡..gmt2.wp-~/22193
tJ-/Cf
5
fixtures placed by BCT in or about the premises. Further, BCT
shall be obligated to pay any and all other taxes, including but
not limited to possessory interest tax, which may be from time to
time assessed upon the facility. The failure of BCT to pay such
levied tax, resulting in the establishment of a tax lien by any
taxing agency, shall constitute a major breach of this lease and
constitute grounds for recovery of possession by Agency, in
addition to immediate payment of such taxes, including any
interest or penalties incurred as a result of such failure.
1.11. Maintenance and Repair of NIC.
1.11.1. BCT agrees to accept full responsibility for
the maintenance and repair of the NIC, including but not limited
to, the interior and exterior of the building, roof, exhibits,
fixtures, furnishings, plumbing, utility systems, landscaping,
walkways, entryways and patios, temporary paved parking lot at
Bay Boulevard, water line to NIC, septic tank, and sewer line to
NIC. BCT shall pay all costs associated with future connection
to said sewer line, including capacity charges, connection fees
and sewer permit fees and ongoing sewer service charges. BCT
shall also reimburse City for its costs for installation of said
sewer line.
1.11.2. BCT shall, at BCT's sole cost and expense,
keep the premises and every part thereof in good condition and
repair, comparable to other property held by the City and Agency,
such as the Civic Center.
1.11.3. BCT shall, upon the expiration or sooner
termination of the Lease Term he~eof surrender the premises to
the City and Agency in the same condition as when received. The
City and Agency shall have no obligations to alter, remodel,
repair, decorate, or paint the NIC structures. Agency and city
reserve the right to enter and inspect the premises, at
reasonable times.
1.12. Destruction of NIC.
In the event that the NIC is destroyed in whole or in part
during the Lease Term, the BCT's interest shall forthwith cease,
and they shall not be entitled to either occupancy or the pro-
ceeds of city or Agency insurance. The Agency shall have the
sole discretion to rebuild.
1.13. Eminent Domain.
In the event that the NIC is condemned in whole or in part,
the lease shall terminate as to that part. BCT shall be entitled
to no portion of any proceeds of a condemnation award.
nic.gmt2.wp'~/22/93
~~r5
6
1.14. Termination of the Lease Provisions.
1.14.1. Failure to Maintain Premises.
In the event that BCT fails to maintain and operate
said premises for the principal purpose for which the same are
hereby demised or fails to maintain reasonable and adequate
supervision and maintenance of said premises or further fails to
remedy any such faults or defects within 30 days after written
notice to do so from the City or Agency, then City or Agency may
elect to terminate and cancel the lease provisions of this
Agreement.
1.14.2. Default in Conditions.
All of the conditions and covenants contained herein to
be performed by BCT shall be deemed to be conditions of BCT's
right to possession of the premises, and if after 30 days written
notice to BCT, any default in said conditions is not remedied or
corrected or performed to City or Agency satisfaction, City or
Agency shall have the right to terminate and cancel this lease,
re-enter the premises, remove BCT and retake possession thereof.
1.14.3. Abandonment.
In the event that BCT abandons said premises, the City
or Agency may elect to terminate the lease provisions of this
Agreement. Abandonment is herein defined to include, but is not
limited to, any absence of BCT from the premises for fifteen (15)
days or longer while in default of any provision of this lease
except where excused by law or circumstances beyond BCT's
control.
1.14.4. Failure to Pay Rent, Pay for Ci~y.Services or"
Make Loan Repayments.
The City or Agency may terminate the lease provisions of
this Agreement should BCT fail to make any rental payment as set
forth in this Agreement, either in full or in part, or should BCT
fail to reimburse City for City employee services provided per
this Agreement, or should BCT fail to reimburse city or Agency
for loans made to the BCT pursuant to the provisions of this
Agreement. City and Agency in their sole discretion may agree to
permit payment of delinquent payments at the prevailing interest
rate, without prejudice to any other rights of the City or
Agency, including the right to institute termination proceedings.
1.15. Condit¿on of Premises upon Termination.
In the event of termination of the lease provisions of this
nic.gmt2.wp-~J22/93
t.f- It:,
7
Agreement, BCT shall leave said premises intact, with all
fixtures, exhibits, improvements, plantings, appurtenances,
documents, files and plans to remain, as they will be considered
property of the City and Agency until such time as the
outstanding loans referred to in Section 2 are repaid by the BCT
to the City and Agency.
1.16. Waiver of Claims or Compensation.
The BCT hereby expressly waives any and all claims for
damage or compensation arising under this Agreement, except as
set forth herein, in the event of such termination.
2. Loan Provisions.
2.1. New Loans to the BCT.
The BCT may need to seek loans from the City and Agency to
cover all or a portion of the cost of the NIC operating budget,
and minor and major capital improvements. Said loans, if
granted, shall be approved upon the adoption of the annual City
and Agency budgets and shall carry interest rates as set by the
City Council for each fiscal year. A schedule for repayment of
said loans shall be established by mutual agreement of all
parties, and shall be incorporated as part of this Agreement.
2.2. Recognition of Existing City and Agency Loans to the
BCT.
2.2.1. Operating Budget Loans.
Upon adoption of this Agreement, all existing City and
Agency loans to the BCT to cover its operating budget expenses
shall be recognized. - Said amounts, including interest accrued
through June 30, 1993, are $1,129,469 from the City and
$1,107,963 from the Agency, for a total of $2,237,432. Attached
as Exhibit C is a table which lists the annual loan amounts and
interest accrued through June 30, 1993. These loans shall
continue to accrue interest during the Loan Term at the interest
rates as shown in Exhibit C, subject to the provisions of Section
2.3.
2.2.2. Capital Improvement Project (CIP) Loans.
Upon adoption of this Agreement, all existing City and
Agency loans to the BCT through June 30,1993 to cover its minor
and major CIPs shall be recognized. Said amounts are $63,484
from the City and $60,099 from the Agency, for a total of
$123,583. Attached as Exhibit D is a listing of the projects and
corresponding costs through June 30, 1993. As of the adoption of
nic8gmt2.wp-4/22193
l-{--17
-
8
this Agreement, these loans shall begin accruing interest at the
interest rate for FY1992-93, as shown on Exhibit C. These loans
shall then continue to accrue interest. during the Loan Term at
said interest rate, subject to the provisions of section 2.3.
2.3. Loan Repayment Schedule and Terms.
2.3.1. The parties agree to meet and confer in good
faith to develop a loan repayment schedule and terms within two
years of the execution of this Agreement ("Loan Term"). It is
the intent of the parties that this loan repayment schedule and
terms be determined when the long-term financing mechanisms for
the NIC are clarified.
2.3.2. Should the parties fail to reach agreement
during said time, then the outstanding loans plus interest shall
be due and payable in full at the end of the two-year Loan Term.
2.3.3. Should good faith negotiations be completed
and agreement be reached on a repayment schedule and terms during
this two year Loan Term, then a new loan agreement will be
established prior to or at the end of the Loan Term.
2.3.4. The City and Agency stipulate that they will
accept a loan repayment schedule and terms as follows: a fully
amortized 30 year loan at an annual interest rate of 8%,
beginning in FY1995-96. If the BCT chooses, the City and Agency
will allow the annual payments to start at a lower amount and
gradually increase by 5% per year, with the present value of the
graduated payments equal to the fully amortized loan repayments
with flat annual payments. However, the parties by mutual
agreement may formulate an alternate repayment schedule and
terms.
2.3.5 Loan Repayments Due and Payable upon Termination
or Breach
Should any portion of this Agreement be terminated
prior to expiration of the Loan Term, or if BCT is otherwise in
breach of its obligations hereunder, all outstanding loans and
interest as stated in this Section 2 shall become due and payable
immediately upon termination or breach.
3. Operatina Provisions.
3.1. Operating Term.
Until the loans refer~:'1ced in Section 2 are fully repaid, or
until termination of the Lease Term, whichever is later, the
provisions of this Section shall apply ("Operating Term").
ni cI;mt2 .wp'~/22/93
~- (R
9
3.2. City Manager.
The City Manager shall oversee the staff and operations of
the BCT, with input from the BCT Board of Directors. .
3.3. City Finance Director.
The City Finance Director shall serve as Treasurer of the
BCT and oversee its expenditures, purchasing procedures, and
revenue accounting as detailed in Section 3.7 below. The City
Finance Director shall verify and report in writing as soon as
possible after the first day of January and July of each fiscal
year, to the BCT the amount of BCT funds the City holds, the
amount of receipts since the Director's last report, and the
amount paid out since the Director's last report. The City
Finance Director shall either make or shall contract with a
certified public accountant to make an annual audit of those
accounts and records of the BCT within 180 days after the end of
each fiscal year. All costs of the audit shall be borne by the
BCT and shall be charged against any unencumbered funds of the
BCT available for that purpose.
3.4. Annual Budget.
The City shall determine the annual operating budget and
capital improvement budget of the NIC, with input from the BCT
Executive Director and BCT Board of Directors.
3.5. City Council.
The City Council of the City shall have the authority to
ratify or disapprove any future changes or amendments to the BCT
Articles and By-Laws, especially as these may affect this
Agreement. .
3.6. Employees of BCT and other Employee Services.
3.6.1. Executive Director.
The Executive Director of the BCT shall be a non-civil
service, unclassified employee of the City. Said director shall
be supervised, hired and terminated by the City Ma~~ger, with
input from BCT Board of Directors. The City shall determine the
salary and benefits of said director. The BCT Board of Directors
shall conduct an annual performance and salary review of the
Executive Director every July and forward the results to the City
Manager. The City Manager shall consider those findings in an
annual performance and salary review of the Executive Director.
Said director shall be granted City employee benefits as provided
by the City for other similar positions.
nicagmt2.wp-'/22/93
4--/~
10
3.6.2. Other NIC Employees.
All other employees specifically assigned to the BCT
shall also be City employees in appropriate classifications. The
City Manager shall be the appointing authority for all BCT
employees, and shall oversee the BCT staff. The City shall
determine the salaries and benefits of the BCT staff. Said
employees may be granted City employee benefits as provided by
the City for other similar classifications.
3.6.3. city Staff Services.
On request from the Executive Director of the BCT, the
City may provide services of such City officers and employees as
are necessary for the BCT to carry out its activities. Such use
by the BCT of City services shall be subject to the approval of
the City Manager and shall be payable by the BCT, through the
Staff Services account of the Operating Budget of the NIC.
3.6.4. Other City Employee Services.
The BCT may from time to time subject to the approval
of the City Manager, utilize other City employee services which
were not planned nor budgeted in the Operating Budget of the NIC.
However, the BCT will be responsible for payment, due and
payable upon receipt of a City invoice.
3.7. Budgetary Approval, Accounting and Purchasing Approval.
3.7.1. Budgetary Approval.
3.7.1.1. The city Council, with input from the
BCT Executive Director and the BCT Board of Directors, shall
approve the annual BCT operating budget, and any capital
improvement projects (CIP) for the NIC.
3.7.1.2. The BCT operating budget, which includes
the salaries and benefits of the BCT employees, and any CIPs for
the BCT are the financial responsibility of the BCT.
3.7.1.3. Any transfers of funds between accounts
in the BCT operating budget, regardless of the dollar amount,
must follow the City's standard budget transfer procedures.
3.7.1.4. The BCT may receive funds from new
grants, private or corporate donations which have not been
planned or previously accounted for by the city. The City
Finance Director sùall appropriate said funds in special donation
accounts, outside of the BCT operating budget.
n;c.gmt2.wp.~/2Z193
tf,,2D
11
3.7.1.5. All expenditures from the special
donation accounts shall be subject to the following:
- The Executive Director of the 'BCT shall
obtain prior approval of the BCT Board of Directors for those
expenditures exceeding the Director's approval limits as
established by said Board.
- The Executive Director of the BCT shall
obtain prior approval of the City Manager to spend in excess of a
cumulative total of $2,500 for any project.
- For any specified or unspecified grants and
donations under $2,500, the Executive Director of the ~CT shall
have discretion to spend those funds subject to the City's
purchasing procedures.
3.7.2. Accounting.
All revenues and expenditures of the BCT shall be
accounted for through the City's established accounting system.
3.7.3. Purchasing Approval.
The BCT shall use the City's purchasing system and
procedures, as outlined in Section 2.56, Purchasing of Supplies,
Services and Equipment, of the City Còde, when spending funds in
all cases, including expenditures from its operating budget,
capital improvement project budget, and special donation
accounts.
4. General Provisions.
4.1. General provisions Term.
The General Provisions shall remain in effect until the
Lease Term, Loan Term or Operating Term has expired, whichever
comes later ("General Provisions Term").
4.2. Representatives of Parties to Agreement.
Each party designates the individuals ("Representatives")
indicated below as said party's administrative representative who
is authorized by said party to represent it in the routine
administration of this Agreement.
nica;mtZ.wp-'I2Z/93
1-)[
12
4.2.1. City designates the City Manager as its
representative in all matters under this Agreement (except
execution thereof) and all notices given to City shall be so
addressed to the above designated representative at 276 Fourth
Avenue, Chula Vista, CA 91910.
4.2.2. Agency designates the Director of Community
Development as its representative in all matters under this
Agreement (except execution thereof) and all notices given to
Agency shall be so addressed to the above designated
representative at 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA 91910.
4.2.3. The BCT designates Executive Director as its
representative in all matters under this Agreement (except
execution thereof) and all notices given to BCT shall be so
addressed to the above designated representative at 1000
Gunpowder Point Drive, Chula Vista, CA 91910.
4.3. Keeping of necords.
BCT agrees that it will keep and maintain detailed records
of all receipts and expenditures by the BCT as well as detailed
records of all time spent and services performed by City and
Agency officers and employees on behalf of the BCT pursuant to
this Agreement.
4.4. Annual Report.
BCT agrees to submit an annual report to the city and Agency
describing the BCT operations, including, but not limited to, the
records described herein. This annual report shall also include
amounts and sources of revenue: private and corporate donations
and grants: strategies to improve revenues, increase attendance
and provide additional services and exhibits.
4.5. Insurance Requirements.
4.5.1. Insurance Coverages.
BCT agrees to obtain and maintain throughout the General
Provisions Term of this Agreement the following insurance
coverages, in the following categories, and to the limits
specified, policies of which are issued by Insurance Companies
that have a Best's Rating of "A,. Class V" or better, or meets
with the approval of the City:
4.5.1.1. Package insurance policy that provides
Property Insurance for the building contents and General
Commercial Liability Insurance in the amount of $ 3,000,000,
which names City and Agency as an Additional Insured, and which
nit.gmtZ.wp-~/Z2/93
tf - '). ?--
13
is primary to any policy which the City may otherwise càrry
("Primary Coverage"), and which treats the employees of the NIC
in the same manner as members of the caeneral public ("Cross-
liability Coverage").
4.5.1.2. Excess Health and Accident Policy for
all NIC volunteers in the amount of $25,000, and which is
secondary to any policy which said volunteers may otherwise
carry.
4.5.1.3. Excess Automobile Liability Insurance
for those NIC volunteers using their personal vehicles to conduct
NIC business, in the amount of $500,000, and which is secondary
to any policy which said volunteers may otherwise carry.
4.5.1.4. A Certificate of Insurance in sufficient
amount to protect the City and Agency, and which names the City
and Agency as Additional Insured must be provided by any non-City
or -Agency group that rents the NIC facilities.
4.5.1.5. The amount of insurance coverage
required of the BCT pursuant to this Agreement may be amended by
the City upon 90 days notice to BCT.
4.5.2. Proof of Insurance Coverage.
4.5.2.1. Certificates of Insurance. The BCT
shall demonstrate proof of coverage herein required, upon
commencement of this Agreement, by delivery of Certificates.of
Insurance demonstrating same, and further indicating that the
policies may not be canceled without at least thirty (30) days
written notice to the City.
4.5.2.2. Policy Endorsements Required. In order
to demonstrate the Additional Insured Coverage, Primary Coverage
and Cross-liability Coverage required under BCT's Commercial
General Liability Insurance Policy, BeT shall deliver a policy
endorsement to the City demonstrating same.
4.5.2.3 Failure of the BCT to maintain said
policies may be grounds for termination of the lease provisions
of this Agreement.
4.5.2.4. BCT shall be solely liable for any
damages, injuries, or causes of action which occur during any
period in which BeT fails to maintain insurance, in addition to
its obligation under this Agreement to indemnify City and Agency.
n; C89mt2. WP-'/22/93
1-23
14
4.6. Compliance with Laws and Regulations.
BCT agrees to maintain and operate said premises in
compliance with all laws, rules and regulations applicable
thereto.
4.7. Administrative Claims Requirement and Procedures.
No suit shall be brought arising out of this Agreement,
against the City or Agency, unless a claim has first been
presented in writing and filed with the City of Chula Vista or
Redevelopment Agency of same City and acted upon by the City of
Chula Vista or Redevelopment Agency of same in accordance with
the procedures set forth in Chapter 1.34 of the Chula Vista
Municipal Code, the provisions of which are incorporated by this
reference as if set fully set forth herein.
4.8. Hold Harmless and Indemnification.
BCT agrees to indemnify and hold the City and Agency
harmless against and from any and all damages to property or
injuries to or death of any person or persons, including
officers, employees, agents, or representatives of the City or
Agency, and shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless the City
and Agency, their elected officials, officers, agents and
employees and representatives, from any and all claims, demands,
suits, actions or proceedings of any kind or nature, of or by
anyone whomsoever, in any way resulting from or arising out of
the negligent or intentional acts, errors or omissions of the BCT
or any of its officers, agents, employees, or representatives,
committed in or which should have been committed in the
performance of this Agreement.
4.9. Assignment.
Neither this Agreement nor any duties or obligations
hereunder shall be assignable by BCT without prior written
consent of the City or Agency. In the event of an assignment by
BCT to which the city or Agency has consented, the assignee or
its legal representative shall agree in writing with the City or
Agency to assume, perform, and be bound by the covenants,
obligations, and agreement contained herein.
4.10. Successors and Assigns.
subject to the provision regarding assigment, this
Agreement shall be binding on the heirs, executors,
administrators, successors, and assigns of the respec~ive
parties.
n;c8gmt2.wp-'/22/93
t!-J-'f
15
4.11. BCT not authorized to Represent City nor Agency.
Unless specifically authorized in writing by City or Agency,
BCT shall have no authority to act as City's or Agency's agent to
bind City or Agency to'any contractual agreements whatsoever.
4.12. Notices.
All notices, demands or requests provided £or or permitted
to be given pursuant to this Agreement must be in writing, unless
stated otherwise in this Agreement. All notices, demands and
requests to be sent to any party shall be deemed to have been
properly given or served if personally served or deposited in the
United States mail, addressed to such party, postage prepaid,
registered or certified, with return receipt requested, at
addresses identified for the parties in Section 4.2.
4.13. Entitlement to Subsequent Notices.
No notice to or demand on the parties for notice of an event
not herein legally required to be given shall in itself create
the right in the parties to any other or further notice or demand
in the same, similar or other circumstances.
4.14. Entire Agreement.
This Agreement, together with any other written document
referred to or contemplated herein, embody the entire Agreement
and understanding between the parties relating to the subject
matter hereof. Neither this Agreement nor any provision hereof
may be amended, modified, waived or discharged except by an
instrument in writing executed by the party against which
enforcement of such amendment, waiver or discharge is sought.
This Agreement specifically supercedes the prior Cooperation
Agreement between the City and BCT of January 6, 1987, such that
the prior agreement is no longer of any force and effect.
4.15. Capacity of Parties.
Each signatory and party hereto warrants and represents to
the other party that it has legal authority and capacity and
direction from its principal to enter into this Agreement; that
all resolutions or other actions.have been taken so as to enable
it to enter into this Agreement.
4.16. Governing Law/Venue.
This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in
accordance with the laws of the State of California. Any action
arising under or relating to this Agreement shall be brought only
nicagmt2.wp.'/22/93
1-2.5
16
in the federal or state courts located in San Diego County, State
of California, and if applicable, the City of Chula Vista, or as
close thereto as possible. Venue for this Agreement, and
performance hereunder, shall be the city of Chula Vista.
4.17. Modification of Agreement.
No modification or waiver of any provision of this
Agreement shall be effective unless the same shall be in writing
and signed by the parties hereto, and then shall be valid only in
the specific instance and for the purpose for which given.
4.18. Counterparts.
This Agreement may be executed in more than one counterpart,
each of which shall be deemed to be an original but all of which,
when taken together shall constitute but one instrument.
4.19. Severability.
In the event that any provision of this Agreement shall for
any reason, be determined to be invalid, illegal, or
unenforceable in any respect, the parties hereto shall negotiate
in good faith and agree to such amendments, modifications, or
supplements to this Agreement or such other appropriate action as
shall, to the maximum extent practicable in light of such
determination, implement and give effect to the intentions of the
parties as reflected herein.
4.20. Headings.
The captions and headings in this Agreement are for
convenience only and shall not define or limit the provisions
hereof.
4.21. No Strict Construction.
This Agreement shall not be strictly construed against any
party hereto.
4.22. Time.
Time is of the essence in the performance of the Parties'
respective obligations herein contained.
4.23. Exhibits.
All exhibits to which reference is made are deemed
incorporated in this Agreement, whether or not actually attached.
n;c.gmt2.wp'~/22/93
1- 2 t:,
17
4.24. Waiver.
No course of dealing or failure or delay, nor the single
failure or delay, or the partial exercise of any right, power or
privilege, on the part of the parties shall operate as a waiver
of any rights herein contained. The making or the acceptance of
a payment by either party with knowledge of the existence of a
breach shall not operate or be construed to operate as a waiver
of any such breach.
4.25. Remedies.
The rights of the parties under this Agreement are
cumulative and not exclusive of any rights or remedies which the
parties might otherwise have unless this Agreement provides to
the contrary.
4.26. No Additional Beneficiaries.
Despite the fact that the required performance under this
Agreement may have an affect upon persons not parties hereto, the
parties specifically intend no benefit therefrom, and agree that
no performance hereunder may be enforced by any person not a
party to this Agreement. Notwithstanding the foregoing, this is
a three party Agreement and the City and the Agency are express
thir~ party beneficiaries of the promises of BCT to provide
serv~ces.
4.27. Nondiscrimination.
BCT agrees not to discriminate in any manner against any
person or persons on account of race, marital status, sex,
religion, color, ancestry, national origin, age, sexual
preference or disability in BCT's use of premises, including,-but--
not limited to, the providing of goods, services, facilities,
privileges, advantages, and accommodations, and the obtaining and
holding of employment.
4.28. Incorporation of Prior Agreements.
This Agreement contains all agreements of the BCT, City and
Agency with respect to any matter mentioned herein, No prior
agreement or understanding pertaining to any such matter shall be
in effect.
n; c8gmt2. wp'4/22/93
1-27
18
4.29. Best Efforts and Cooperation.
The Parties promise to use their best efforts to satisfy all
conditions of this Agreement and to take all further steps and
execute all further documents reasonably necessary to put this
Agreement into effect.
(End of Page. Next Page is Signature Page.)
nic.gmt2.wp'~/22/93
tf-J-t
19
Signature Page
Now therefore, the parties hereto, having read and
understood the terms and conditions of this Agreement, do hereby
express their consent to the terms hereof by setting their hand
hereto on the date set forth adjacent thereto.
Dated: ~l J-~ 1711 City of Chula ~sta
by: .-L /~/&~.
Dated: ¡i1/!,~ J./" Iff) Redevelopment Agency of the City of
/ / Chula Vista!
by:~b/-
Agency
Dated: Chula Vista Bayfront Conservancy
Trust:
by: ?- 7~,--
At~~
~cuti e Director-Chula Vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
nic8gmt2.wp-4/22/93
q--27
20
LIST OF EXHIBITS
,
Exhibit A: Property Description of the Chula Vista Nature
Interpretive Center (NIC)
Exhibit B: Grant of Easement to the Agency for NIC site
Exhibit C: List of Operating Budget Loans made to the BCT
through June 30, 1993
Exhibit D: List of Capital Improvement Project Loans made to the
BCT through June 30, 1993
nic.gmt2.wp.~/22/93
tf_3Ð
EXHIBIT A Property -Description of NIC
:
Location: .A certain parcel of real property situated in the City
of Chula Vlsta, County of San Diego, State of California and more
particularly described as follows: '
.
Along a nontangent Hne I~orth 80"12'58" West
39.05 feet; thence North 00"15' 26" East 195.23
feet; thence North OS836's4" West SS.2S feet;
thence North 50852'22" West .221.67 feet: thence
North 34833' OS" East 159.09 feet: thence North
72844'57" East 75.24 feet; thence South 56"08'50"
East 283.08 fee~ thence South 74"56'10" East
141.62 feet to a .1nt on the arc of a nontangent
900.00 foot radi~. curve concave Northwesterly, a
radial line to said point bears South 71"55'52"
East: thence Southwesterly along said curve
through a central angle of 11"31'34" an arc
distance of 181.05 feet; thence along a
nontangent 11 ne South 47"52'32" West 293.90 feet:
thence North 80"'2 '58" West 24.98 feet to the
TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING.
..
1~3/
This page blank.
1-32-
-. -.....-
RECORDING REQUESTED BY: 1633 86-267505
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA G RECOi\D(O II~::--J
When Recorded, Please Mail _CFFiCIAI. H::cúi>:;": ,
This Instrument To: 0, S~H DiEGO (C';~; y. i" I
1986 JUN 30 All 8 05 I
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
City of Chula Vista ~VERAL.LYL~
P.o. Box 1087 COUNTY RECORDER
Chula Vista, CA 92012
NO TRANSFER TAX DUE Exhibit B Grant of Easement to the Agency for the
Nature Center
Assessor's Parcel No.:
Space above thIs lIne for Recorder's use only
NO FEE
EASEMENT FOR NATURE INTERPRETIVE CENTER AND
A LICENSE FOR ACCESS AND UTILITY LINE PURPOSES
FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of which is hereby
acknowledged, SANTA FE LAND IMPROVEMENT COMPANY, a corporation
organized under the laws of the State of California hereby grants
to the REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA an ease-
ment, to be used for the purpose specified herein and no other,
upon, over and across the real property located in the City of
Chula Vista, County of San Diego, State of California, more par-
ticularly described in Exhibit A attached hereto and initialed and
by this reference incorporated herein.
This easement is granted solely for the construction, opera-
tion, maintenance, repair, renewal and replacement from time to
time of a Nature Interpretive Center open to the public containing
approximately ten thousand (10,000) square feet under roof, in
addition to associated and ancillary parking facilities, landscap-
ing, within the area above described in Exhibit A. In addition,
this easement is granted for all Phase 1 and Phase 2 on and
off-site grading work for said Nature Interpretive Center,
including, but not limi ted to, off-site drainage and utility
facilities required to serve the subject Center project shown on
Exhibit "B" attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference
and more particularly described on City of Chura Vista Plan Nos.
86-59 through and including 86-64 revised April 28,1986.
In addition to the above-referenced easement, Grantor hereby
grants to Grantee a license over and across the land hereinafter
described for vehicular and pedestrian ingress and egress to and
from the Nature Interpretive Center area. Grantor also grants a
license to Grantee for the purpose of installing a water line to
serve the Nature Interpretive Center site, the nature and type of
which to be determined by Grantee. Grantor shall have the right
to relocate said access and water line in the event that said
R¡::J¿;~8 1-33
1634
access and water line obstructs or interferes with the development
of adjacent and/or underlying property owned by the Grantorr pro- I
vided that reasonable alternative access and water line relocation I
are thereafter allowed to and for the Nature Interpretive Center.
The cost of moving the water line or other utilities serving the
Nature Interpretive Center shall be borne equally by the Grantor
and Grantee. Grantor further grants to Grantee a license to
install util,ity lines that Grantee may require for the Nature
Interpretive Center site.
The initial locations of the above-referenced li censes for
roadway and utility lines is as designated on Exhibit B attached
hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
Grantee, by accepting this easement and license, agrees to
the following:
1) Grantee agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless
Grantor from all liability arising from actions of Grantee or its
agents and contractors, and persons using, visiting and in transit
to or from Grantee's facilities over the property described in
Exhibits A and B.
2) Grantee shall, prior to beginning any grading or other
work on or related to construction of the Nature Interpretive
Center project, install sand bags at the limi ts of grading as
shown on City of Chula Vista Plan Nos. 86-59 through and including
86-64 referenced hereinabove, said limits having been established
and clearly marked on the ground by a Registered Civil Engineer
authorized to practice land surveying or a licensed land surveyor
who shall work for and at the expense of Grantee. Grantee shall
also, prior to beginning construction of the Nature Interpretive
Center project, install a fence around the perimeter of Parcel A,
as described in Exhibit A, of a type reasonably designed to
prevent unauthorized persons from going onto or leaving the site
during construction. Grantee hereby warrants to Grantor that it
shall not permi t or suffer any debris or demolition materials or
other waste of any kind to be placed, buried, stored or abandoned
within any area subject to this easement in favor of Grantee, or
subject to control or use by Grantee for pu rposes of grading or
construction.
3) Grantee shall, prior to beginning any grading or other
work on or related to construction of the Nature Interpretive
Center project, submit to Grantor for its review any and all
contracts for grading or other construction work on or related to
the Nature Interpretive Center project. Grantor's review shall be
solely for the purpose of assuring itself that job specifications
and contract documents adequately protect Grantor and Grantor's
property from damage or misuse.
~ 4-3+
~19 (;~,f
H_~~~
1635
Grantor shall have the right of reasonable access to and over
any of these areas, burdened by the easement or subject to the I
license, for ingress and egress to and from the real property of I
Grantor.
Grantor hereby further grants to the City of Chula Vista the
privilege and right to extend reasonable drainage structures and
excavat ion and embankment slopes beyond the limits of the right-
of-way described in Exhibit B where required for the construction
and maintenance of said access road. RESERVING unto Grantor of
the above-described parcel of land, its successors or assigns, the
right to eliminate such slopes and/or drainage structures or por-
tions thereof, when in the written opinion of the City Engineer of
Grantee, the necessity therefor is removed by substituting other
protection, support and/or drainage facility, provided such sub-
stitution is first approved in writing by said City Engineer.
Grantor hereby further grants to Grantee all trees, growths
(growing or that may hereafter grow), and road building materials
within the real property described in Exhibits A and B, including
the right to take water, together with the right to use the same
in such manner and at such locations as said Grantee may deem
proper, needful or necessary, in the construction, reconstruction,
improvement or maintenance of said Grantee's improvements.
In addition, Grantor anticipates allowing a license to
continue for roadway, drainage, and utility line purposes until 5-
socb ti~ .s . ~c~"en< co.. is bo1H '0 secve Cbe N.'OC~
Interpretive Center area, which road ~-' be ~icated as ~
permanent public, city street and which ~ ~tain those z
utilities requisite for service of the Nature Interpretive Center'
facility.
This Grant of Easement shall exist until such time as there
is an agreement entered into between Grantor and Grantee and the
Chula Vista Redevelopment Agency and City of Chula Vista relating
to the Bay Front Project, and through which it is anticipated the
area shown in Exhibit A will be conveyed to Grantee in fee. In
addition, Grantor anticipates allowing a license to continue for
roadway and utility line purposes until such time as a permanent
~ tf - 35
;eA ¿ t.!
----
.~ 1636
road is built to serve the Nature Interpretive Center area, at I
which time said road will be dedicated as a permanent public, city I
street.
Dated this 2. 'i Ú-day of ~ r 1986.
SANTA FE LAND IMPROVEMENT COMPANY,
a California corporation
~ ' ';"P. ¿§ C! n-.
The terms of this Easement and License Agreement are accepted
by the City of Chula Vista
By: jl'ST'
I~RP; ~ h7 ~
(Acknowledgement)
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
) ss
COUNTY OF J"" F;-ç:..",¡U) )
On M6 .:<!" , 19Jb, before me,
the unã'erslgned, a Notary Public in and
for said State, personally appeared
,ío,,>,-< 6. O.Gt:r"'-
personally known to me or proved to me
to be the person whose name
subscribed to the-within instFüment and
acknowledged that Ae executed the
same.
WITNESS my hand and official seal.
Signature 9- V ~~./
Name, 7. t.. - Li(,""J
( yped or Prlnted)
~ 1--3¿'
£17 ¿; ¿; ¡
u
...
,.Q
~
~
z
~~ § ~I ~ ~! ~ ~. ~ 6
--!- ã1¡- "" '" '" M ;g- r-.:- r-.:-
t:;~ a~ fè ~::; ~ "'~. ~
::J::¡¡ .... '"
~~
>-~!;j 0 ~ ~ 0 "if. '"
uGJ'" "'I ~ ~;¡ ~ ~ ¡;¡
z ~. 0 ":' ~. ol:i.... ",' ol:i ....'
><::J '" '" 00""
"cc "'.... ....
!ì50~
zz¡::
8« ","if. 8 o"if...,
00;: "'I 08", "'8 t'!:
!- Z t..ù '" "'-" ~.-
z::>Q.. ,..:. ¡::¡ ~::¡: ~ ~ ~
0"" 0 '" '" ....
~~~
CCz 0 "if. '" ot.., I
2;.:¿ 0::1 ~,~ ~ ~,~ ~
r"" , ,,0 '" ..,00
C,/) Ì"" 0 ".... '" .."", '"
~ t: "'.... .... ....
gU +
~ ot.... 8~ 00 ~
fJ: ~I ~,~::1, ~~ ~Ig
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
00.... "".... ffi
I + ~
'" 8 § ~ ~ § § § j ~
001 .' 00 ..," J ë!
' '" '" ~ j >- 0 '" ..,
00 """, " u..,"" '" +
co.... ffi ....
... ~ '5 ~
§ 8 ~
!=~ ¡ i=~ f~
g~ ~5 ~g~ ~1ffi
E ..,1.5 E ..,c::"
< - -.., < - -..,
" i ; ~ ~2 ~ g; ~ ~2 g ~
" S] ]P ~ ë! S ] ]P I- ~
~ ~. 1----31
This page blank.
tf-3~
- -, .-.., -'
EXHIBIT D
CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT LOANS TO THE BCT
General Fund:
Exterior painting and handicapped ramp $ 4,850
Repair of lights in auditorium and sidewalks $ 4,000
Replacement of compressor $ 6,800
Recoating of petting pool interior $ 5,000
Laying of new sewer line (Sewer Fund) $ 42.834
TOTAL: $ 63,484
Redevelooment Aaencv Funds:
Construction of temporary parking lot $ 24,267
Construction of Burrowing Owl exhibit $ 19,234
Installation of emergency generator/housing $ 10,576
Improvements to access road $ 6.022
TOTAL: $ 60,099
TOTAL OF CITY AND REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY FUNDING: $123,583
,f
I..f --51
-
This page blank.
J{- 40
RESOLUTION NO. /[/00/
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE
THREE PARTY AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA, REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, AND CHULA
VISTA BAYFRONT CONSERVANCY TRUST FOR A LEASE,
LOAN AND OPERATING AGREEMENT FOR THE CHULA
VISTA NATURE CENTER
WHEREAS, at the joint Council/Agency meeting on May 4,
1993, the city Council and Redevelopment Agency approved a three
party agreement between the City, Redevelopment Agency, and
Bayfront Conservancy Trust (BCT) for a Lease, Loan and Operating
Agreement for the operation of the Chula vista Nature Center; and
WHEREAS, the components of that Agreement which provide
the city with specified controls and oversight of the Nature Center
operations will continue in effect until the loans that the City
and the Agency have provided to the BCT have been repaid, but the
lease and loan components of the Agreement expired in May 1995; and
WHEREAS, when the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement
were approved in May 1993, two year terms were provided for the
lease and loan components of the agreement with the anticipation
that during that two year period, City and Agency negotiations with
the bayfront developer would be completed and either a benefit
assessment district or some other funding mechanism to pay for
ongoing operations and maintenance of the Nature Center would be
established; and
WHEREAS, negotiations with the bayfront developer have
not been completed, and a Council subcommittee was recently
established to review issues related to the Disposition and
Development Agreement with the bay front developer, which could
include the issue of the benefit assessment district for the
ongoing operations and maintenance at the Nature Center; and
WHEREAS, staff is recommending that the lease and loan
components of the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement be extended
until the end of July 1997.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the city Council of the
city of Chula vista does hereby approve First Amendment to the
Three Party Agreement between the City of Chula Vista,
Redevelopment Agency, and Chula vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
for a Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement for the Chula vista
Nature Center.
Jf_t{-I
-
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Mayor of e City of
Chula vista is hereby authorized and directe 0 execu e said First
Amendment for and on behalf of the City of Ch la vist
Presented by
James R. Thomson, Deputy
City Manager
c: \ rsUstA.end. bct
Jj-tf2-
--
RESOLUTION NO. /1 ~(P
RESOLUTION OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE
CITY OF CHULA VISTA APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT
TO THE THREE PARTY AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY
OF CHULA VISTA, REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, AND
CHULA VISTA BAY FRONT CONSERVANCY TRUST FOR A
LEASE, LOAN AND OPERATING AGREEMENT FOR THE
CHULA VISTA NATURE CENTER
WHEREAS, at the joint Council/Agency meeting on May 4,
1993, the city Council and Redevelopment Agency approved a three
party agreement between the City, Redevelopment Agency, and
Bayfront Conservancy Trust (BCT) for a Lease, Loan and Operating
Agreement for the operation of the Chula vista Nature Center; and
WHEREAS, the components of that Agreement which provide
the City with specified controls and oversight of the Nature Center
operations will continue in effect until the loans that the City
and the Agency have provided to the BCT have been repaid, but the
lease and loan components of the Agreement expired in May 1995; and
WHEREAS, when the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement
were approved in May 1993, two year terms were provided for the
lease and loan components of the agreement with the anticipation
that during that two year period, City and Agency negotiations with
the bay front developer would be completed and either a benefit
assessment district or some other funding mechanism to pay for
ongoing operations and maintenance of the Nature Center would be
established; and
WHEREAS, negotiations with the bayfront developer have
not been completed, and a Council subcommittee was recently
established to review issues related to the Disposition and
Development Agreement with the bayfront developer, which could
include the issue of the benefit assessment district for the
ongoing operations and maintenance at the Nature Center; and
WHEREAS, staff is recommending that the lease and loan
components of the Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement be extended
until the end of July 1997.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the Redevelopment Agency
of the city of Chula Vista does hereby approve First Amendment to
the Three Party Agreement between the city of Chula Vista,
Redevelopment Agency, and Chula Vista Bayfront Conservancy Trust
for a Lease, Loan and Operating Agreement for the Chula Vista
Nature Center.
tf-Lf'3
-
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Chairman of the
Redevelopment Agency is hereby authorized and directed to execute
said First Amendment for and on behalf of the R elo ent Agency
of the city of Chula vista.
Presented by 'J)
James R. Thomson, Deputy
City Manager
C:\rs\lstAoend.bct
4-41
_. -
JOINT REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/CITY COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item 5
Meeting Date 08/15/95
ITEM TITLE: AGENCY RESOLUTION /1(; 7 APPROVING FINAL RESIDENTIAL
.
MOVING EXPENSE CLAIMS TOTALING $5,274.56 PURSUANT TO THE
ADOPTED RELOCATION PLAN FOR TWO HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY
LOCATED AT 459 F STREET
COUNCIL RESOLUTION ~UTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF
$5,274.56 FROM THE CIVIC TER EXPANSION PROJECT (GG-130)
FOR TWO FINAL RESIDENTIAL MOVING CLAIMS PURSUANT TO THE
ADOPTED RELOCATION PLAN FOR HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY
RESIDING AT 459 F STREET ~
SUBMITTED BV, Commoo'" D'.""~"","' .'
REVIEWED BY: City ManagecJ4 ~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes..x. No_)
.-1'-
BACKGROUND: As Council is aware, th ity and Agency approved for execution a Purchase
and Sale Agreement with Jean and Ignazio Adamo at the Council meeting of November 9,
1993, to purchase the property at 459 F Street as part of the Civic Center Expansion Project.
Subsequently, the City and Agency have approved claims and authorized expenditures for
various relocation payments for the five rental households formerly residing at that location.
At this time, the City's relocation consultant has brought forward the final Residential Moving
Expense claims associated with the acquisition.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Redevelopment Agency adopt the resolution approving Final
Residential Moving Expense claims totaling $5,274.56 pursuant to the adopted Relocation
Plan for 459 F Street.
That the City Council adopt the resolution authorizing the expenditure of $5,274.56 from the
Civic Center Expansion Project (GG-130) for the payment of the final Residential Moving
Expense claims for 459 F Street.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable,
DISCUSSION:
The Final Residential Moving Expense claims are the last claims to be processed for the 459
F Street project. As you may recall from the other items brought before the Council/Agency,
the purpose of the relocation assistance law is to provide that households and businesses
relocated as a result of public action, are provided specific forms of relocation assistance in
order to make them "whole". In the case of Ms. Mancini, the Advance Assistance was
provided in order to allow her the funds up front to pay for the security deposit and down
payment at her replacement rental unit, The Rental Assistance is determined by a formula
which represents the amount of assistance necessary to make the individual "whole" between
the difference in the rent they were previously paying and the new rent at the new location.
Additionally, applicants have the option to either receive moving expense payments based
upon an allowance on a per room basis, or for actual moving expenses incurred, Most
applicants choose to receive the "per room" rate; however, Mrs. Adamo and Ms, Mancini
elected the "actual moving expenses" option for the convenience of having movers come in,
S-!
Page 2, Item ~
Meeting Date 08/15/95
pack their belongs, relocate, and unpack.
Attached are copies of the Final Residential Moving Expense claims received from Pacific
Relocation Consultants on June 5, 1995, Listed below are the claims,
Residential
Moving
Exoenses
Mary Mancini (Unit B) $1,316.92
Jean Adamo (Former Owner) $3,957,64
TOTAL $5,274.56
The attached claims have been reviewed and approved by Pacific Relocation Consultants and
are judged by staff to be correct and in accordance with relocation law. Pursuant to the
property Purchase and Sale Agreement identified above, Mrs. Adamo waived all of their
relocation payments except for actual and documented moving expenses, Therefore, this is
the only claim processed for Mrs, Adamo. The table below identifies the previous relocation
claims approved for Ms. Mancini.
Advance Assistance $1,500
Rental Assistance $3,300
TOTAL $4,800
FISCAL IMPACT: As part of the property acquisition, $910,500 was encumbered in order to
purchase the property and relocate all the tenants under CIP Account #GG-130. The previous
budget for relocation benefits estimated $73,500 would be necessary. The Council/Agency
has previously authorized $49,333.28; therefore, with this current request of $5,274.56, the
total of all relocation claims for this project is $54,607.84. Since these funds have already
been encumbered for purposes of paying the note on the property and relocating the tenants,
there is no additional impact beyond the original encumbrance. The relocations will have been
concluded at $18,892.19 less than estimated and budgeted for the projected.
M: HOM E\COMM D EV\HA YNESIREPORTSIMOVEXPSE. RA4
S-'J--
PACIFIC RELOCATION CONSULTANTS. LETIER OF TRANSMITrAL
Date: September 1, 1994
TO: Lyle Haynes FROM: Pacific Relocation Consultants
Principal Community 100 West Broadway, Suite 300
Development Specialist Long Beach, California 90802
City of Chula Vista Phone: (310) 590-8564
276 Fourth Avenue Fax: (310) 495-0889
Chula Vista, California 92010
THIS CORRESPONDENCE REFERS TO:
Name: Marv Mancini
Address: 459-Ð F Street
Chula vista, CA 91910
File # or Project: Civic Center Expansion 00459-Ð02
ATTACHED ARE DOCUMENTS TO SUPPORT THE FOLLOWING PAYMENT REQUEST(S):
Advance Assistance Residential Moving Expense
Rental Assistance Business Moving Expense
Downpayment Assistance Business In-lieu
Replacement Housing Assistance Last Resort Housing
Fixtures and Equipment Other:
COMMENTS:
THIS CHECK SHOULD BE MADE PAYABLE TO: IN THE AMOUNT OF:
I Sullivan Moving &: Storage Company I $1,316.92 I
Your prompt attention in this matter is appreciated.
Sincerely,
y.,... ""I L CJ' Jì'~ 5-3
Mary K O'Toole
Pacific Relocation Consultants
Claim for Moving and Related Expenses
Families and Individuals (State)
2
PRIVACY ACT NOTICE: You are asked to provide tnis information in order to determine whether you are eligible to receive a rental or downpayment
assistance payment. You are not required by law to fumish this information, but if you do not provide it, you may not receive this payment or it may take
longer to pay you. This intormation is being collected under tne authority of tne Cal~omia Relocation Assistance Act (Government Coda Section 7260, et. seq.)
INSTRUCTIONS: This claim form is for the use of families aI1d Individuals applying for a payment of moving and related expenses. You may apply for either
(1) a fixed allowance, or (2) an amount to cover the actual moving and related expenses incurred, as described on page 2 of this form. A claim for actuai
expenses must be supported by receipts or other evidence. A representative of the displacing Agency will explain the difference between t!1e two types
of payments and will help you complete the lorm. It the full amount ot your claim is not approved, the Agency will provide you with a written explaI1atlon
of the reason. If you are not satisfied with the Agency's determination, you may appeal that determination. The Agency will explain how to make an appeal.
1. Your Name(s) (You are the Claimant(s)) la. Present Mailing Address(es) of Claimant(s) tb. Telephone Number(s)
Mary Mancini 354 Oxford, 113
Chula Vista, CA 91910 (619) 420-û858
2. Have all members of the household moved to the same dwelling? ~YES _NO
(If 'NO', list the names of all members and the addresses to which they moved in tne Remarks Section.)
Dwelling Address How Many Rooma Was n Furnished With When Old You Movs
Old You Occupy?' Your Own Furniture? To This Unit?
3. UnitThat 459-Ð F Street --X. YES _NO
You Moved From Chula Vista, CA 91910 5 1/1/85
4. Unit That . Excluding bathrooms, hallways and closels.
You Moved To 91910 7/30/94
5. Is This a Final Claim:
6b. Actual Moving FOR AGENCY USE
Item Expenses ONLY
(t) Moving Cost $ 1,316.92 $
(2) Transportation Cost - Families and Individuals $ $
(3) Cost of Insurance Covering Move and/or Storage $ $
(4) Storage Cost (Complete Item 10 on page 2) $ $
(5) Other (Explain in Remarns Section) $ $
(6) Total Amount ot Claim (Consult Agency tor amount of fixed allowance) $ $ 1 316.92 $
(7) Amount Previously Paid (If any) $ $ 0 $
(6) Amount Requested (Une (6) minus Une (7») $ $
7. Certification by Clslmant(s)
WARNING: "you knowingly or dellberetely make false stetementB on tnls fom1, you may be subject to civil or criminal penalties under Section 1001 of TItle 18 of
tne United States Code. In addition you may not recsIve any of 1118 smountB claimed on tnls form. I CERTIFY lI18t tnls claim and auP\>Ol1ing information are true
and oomplete, lI18t I have not submitted any other claim for 1118 expenses listed and that I have not been paid for tne expenses by any other source. I ask that
tne amount on Une (8) of Item (8) be paid directly to: - ME, or ---X... THE CONTRACTOR(S) (as specIIIed In 1118 Rem8I1c8 SectIon). My ehoIcs of fixed payme
In Sa or actual moving expenses In 6b was based on 1118 explanation by 1118 agency representative of tne difference be1wøen these types of payments.
Signature(s) of Claimant(s) Date
X ,"'-/II~ -p~' L~ X 9/1 ll'-1
SIgnature Name (Type or Pr1nt) D8I8
8. I, () 'J7'~ 9194
Pacific Relocation Consultants S -4- PRe""'"
Page 1 of 2
~--~_...__.-
INVOICE
?ULLIVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO. AGENT FOR
4660 ALVARADO CANYON ROAD UNITED
P.O. BOX 600100
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92160 UNITED
TELEPHONE: (619) 283-2146 = == "'~"
TOLL FREE: (800) 854-2600 UØ!iii ii p= =
FAX (619) 283-0527 = -= '" '" ifEEE ã1!!ii'@
Van Lines
AMERICA'S #1 FAMILY MOVER
TO INVOICE NUMBER
PACIFIC RELOCATICN 3233
ATI'N: MARY 0 I TOOLE INVOICE DATE
3732 45TH STREET 7/28/94
SAN DIEGO, CA 90802 po. NUMBER
FROM TO
~CHUIA VIsrA, CA CHUIA VISTA, CA
AMOUNT QUANTITY % CHARGES &
OR WEIGHT CREDITS
602 VAN AND THREE MEN 4,00 115.85HR 463.40
613 P l\CKJNG LABOR 489.05
611 PACKING MATERIAL 221. 00
634 SALES TAX 221. 00 7.00% 15.47
631 DECIARED VALUATICN CHARGE 10000.00 0.8OC$ 80.00
3RD PARrY SERVICE - R MJVERS 48.00
INVOICE ~ 1316.92
5-5
SULLIVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO. 1316.92
4660 ALVARADO CANYON ROAD
PO. BOX 600100
SAN DIEGO. CALIFORNIA 92160
TELEPHONE, (619) 283-2146
roLL FREE, (800) 884-2600
-
_u.._---
R MOVERS SERVICE N«! 3586
1380 E. Washington #37W
ORIGIN EI Caioo, CA 92019 ~
-- (619) 441-9355 ~- 9 I
- ~ /~
SHIPPER ,4Ø-,4Ø1fC/~I/ -.. CARRIER.~ - :..
ADDRESS YS'l þ~, ~RDERNO'
,
CITY, STATE ~. MOVING DATE
TELEPHONE - CHARGE CARRIER 0 COLLECT FROM SHIPPER
APPLIANCE MAKE BASIC OPERATING CONDITION CHARGE
AT TIME OF SERVICE
C LEAKS WATER
WASHER CLEAKSOIL 0 CYCLES OKAY
C GAS 0 RUNS
DRYER C ELECTRIC 0 HEATS
u WIICE MAKER 0 WET
REFRIGERATOR C OPERATES OKAY 0 DRY
co WIICE MAKER 0 WET
REFRIGERATOR C OPERATES OKAY 0 DRY
GAS ~ 'GJ OVEN WORKS ;;¥V
RANGE c- ELECTRIC ~ BURNERS WORK 15> ---
CLOCK C SERVICED 0 CRATED
POOL TABLE 0 DISASSEMSLED 0 CRATED
OTHER
CRATING DIMENSIONS CU, FT.
TRIP CHARGE
REMARKS
MATERIAL
DIRECTIONS & SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
S - ~ SERVICEMAN
~r=; AC~; AND SATlSFACTO
SULLIVAN MOVING 6. STORAGE CO. JI': ¡~¡¡
1~ ~~~~~AC~9~~YON RD. ~~~~~~~9:iJ~f WNf ::::,:::: 7/1/94-
TElEPHONE. (619) 283.2'46 TElEP~ONE, 16191 599.2600 ,~"."
CAL P.U.C..T.'69'" AGENTS FOR UNITED VAN LINES, INC. 0""'0",.1/1/94
:":'."':::':,:,:,""""'" 1:~::'" CHRIS
. . MARY MANCINI 'lOOA MOA
459 "F" 8TRE"" m.NO 354 OXFORD 113 m"o.
CHULA VISTA, CA 91\1~E CHULA VISTA, CA 91911 PHONE
--p..-,,¿
Ie
:,:';::;: 6~7-8-----':"9-10-11-----12::: 1-2-3-4-S-6 ~:='o:;:;"'"
""" 1""""",1"""", ,I"""", """""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1 ~::.'::,
""""""".""".""""::',::.:'::,":;:';;:;::::':::-::;;::;::~~-:=~ - -,. "'~~;;. 0
, - -
,., , .. ,. ,
BARREL D'SH-PACK DRUM ETC. --1-- ..
CARTONS: LESS THAN 3OU"C "'T ~ ,~
3OUFT.
<lncu.FT. .:2. ~
6CU. FT
W'","'BECAA""""'~'~""on
MATTRESS CARTON: CRIB
NOTEXCEEDING39'X'"
NDTEXCEEDING".X'"
EXCEEDING ". X ".
39'XBO'
"ATTRESSCDVER PlASTlCDRPAPER
CDRRUGATEDCD"T"NERS:2- ¿.
CRATESDVER""'"U" -
RA"""'THAN""'"""
-
'" O' '. . , ::-.='::::::,~,":::':,::==,:¡::;,~.:,=.~,:,~::::::::.::::::::: TOTALPACKlN"HARGES 489 ~
".0. PACIFIC 'RËi:.ลii:rÏâi I~~'---_. --____0- TDTALeDNTAINERCHARGES 221 a
"",."."....." ::::_-~._-_o~,." SALES TAX 7.00"SAN D=<J C'""" --rs- T
, 0" :'~:',~~~~:;""'" 0 ~,~,:~:;:~;:, 0 ~:'::=:'::;1 :FD PACKEAS NA"E 1 HDUAS DATE
""""""""""""""""""....,,,. 0 m 0"
I
, ., " ~.. I '00'" I ,~,.. I -,.. I -,.. I -.. I
,oW, ..". ,-", ,-,..
I I I I TOTAlHOURS@$.
N,. ,fp".." CJ 0" " 0 O.sI. TOTALPACXlNG
,.»""". ,,¡"""'."'" J""""""'" .u=./-----,.. APPL'ANCE' b . d
"":I~"" """'_Y"Æ<'Ð"'" ..m".
~ '" :':;,":0:: ". i:.;:..:.."..::"~' ~~ 1- v,".. G"ssWI. lb,. T",WI. lb,.
2 87 75 .1 22 1~'- ","" +--Y~ \.L".. N"W"D"! lb,'" P"CwI
"",,' ""',, ",. . ,. ~ ... P,,",. E~
I "°"""""'.-, I: o".,,~ý O"""IJ'JIN zJm J M ,.00= P"H, 60 40
..." "::- """";?",,,wI...,, E,'" M," . , "",,@$,," n" p" Ho.
'"'~",' ~~.I:::: I:::~ "" "","wr7. '" hIGh.. 0ILo""C..~' C ""CwI.
.'~. "'~,+ V,"N'8'ð.3 3RD PARrY SERVICE - R M:1JERS 48 00
~~;'::l"".,"::::"" I ~..- I -
S.IT.,"..,.
V,'oa""CI"".S..A",.m,"II"S'Nlco ~10 000 @ .8oe 80 00
TOTALCHAAGESASSESSED "" lq?
""'.'.","OOSTO"'AVI"'""." ,
TOTALeHARGES ONCHANGE ORDER S ,
NOT TO EXCEED PRICE
""""" 0"," 0""""",",,, 0,""""""0"""""""""","",0",,,,, ""'m~,".""~,,~.O TOTALPAIO
CUSW"ER 'G"" '"" "'" W '" "C""'O ""'A'" "SSES '0 CUSW"ER
""0" '" USE 0' SUCH "mA""'",O< 'ALANCE DUE
~:,::;::: ~:::;;: ::::~:::;::;~: :~~~:~:';;:";:o"~~':~,:,: :::::."~'~:':::,:;:o':~,:,,~o;',:::::;:.:~:~~',:;:,:::~;~~:':.:;;~:;:;;:;::';;;:::" '::':~",,;::::;;::,~:;~::;,: ,::-::; ~,:,m""
'""""""]' ", .,"'"". 'X eo""" ""..:'~"~""'" m'~ o,m,.. "moo' ..""',, """" ""'::,~::',::.:"""'" ..~m::~,~~~::~:::;: ;0: :0:::::""°"""'" ,...., "d"
c¡;¡;¡;"s -~---- '"~O .-.TõIPí'" èo.--------- "CE"" " ~ ~ .
"0"'"" ----------------------- C,~~C',O~" -- -----_u --- ----~ -
""""""""""""""",00""""""'" 5-7
, ".C"" """ ,-"" ,,' ,. .".. ,. 1 d ""'d' "-..\' "'",.. ...."",..;....- .. ".¡. ."., d.. ,-!.
....---. - - --.-.---..
I
SULLIVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO.
PACKING TICKET
CA STATE RATES
SHIPPER, MANCINI, MARY
ORDER #: 3233
I
I
PACKING MATERIALS PACKING IJIBOR I
DISHPACK 9 5.35 48.15 9 17.45 157.05 !
1.5 13 1. 20 15.60 13 4.10 53.30
3,0 10 1.60 16.00 10 5.40 54.00
4.5 23 1.95 44.85 23 6.20 142.60
6.0 0 2.55 0.00 0 7.00 0.00
6.5 0 2.55 0.00 0 7.50 0.00
WARDROBE 11 7.80 85.80 11 6.30 69.30
CRIB 0 4.20 0.00 0 0.85 0.Ø0
SINGLE 0 7.40 0.00 0 1.05 0.00
DOUBLE 0 9.70 0.00 0 1. 75 0.00
KNG/QUEEN 0 11. 70 0.00 0 3.60 0.00
KNG SPLIT 0 7,75 0.00 0 1. 55 0.00
MIRROR 2 5.30 10.60 2 6.40 12.80
TOTALS 68 221.00 489.05
s-?
-
PACIFIC RELOCATION CONSULTANTS. LETIER OF TRANSMI1TAL
Date: December 10. 1994
TO: Lyle Haynes FROM: Pacific Relocation Consultants
Principal Community 100 West Broadway, Suite 300
Development Specialist Long Beach, California 90802
City of Chula Vista Phone: (310) 590-8564
276 Fourth Avenue Fax: (310) 495-0889
Chula Vista, California 92010
THIS CORRESPONDENCE REFERS TO:
Name: Jean Adamo
Address: 459-A F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
File # or Project: Civic Center ExDansion 00459-{)00
ATTACHED ARE DOCUMENTS TO SUPPORT THE FOLLOWING PAYMENT REQUEST(S):
Advance Assistance Residential Moving Expense
Rental Assistance Business Moving Expense
Downpayment Assistance Business In-lieu
Replacement Housing Assistance Last Resort Housing
FIXtures and Equipment Other:
COMMENTS:
THIS CHECK SHOULD BE MADE PAYABLE TO: IN THE AMOUNT OF:
I Sullivan Moving &: Storage Company I $3,957.64 I
Your prompt attention in this matter is appreciated.
Sincerely,
""'-/1<, 0 I m....-tL/" 5'-9
Mary K O'Toole
Pacific Relocation Consultants
Oaim for Moving and Related Expenses
Families and Individuals (State)
TICE: You are asked to provide this Information In order to determine whether you are eligible to receive a rental or downpayment
assistance payment. You are not required by law to fumlsh this information, but II you do not provide it, you may not receive this payment or It may take
longer to pay you. ms information is being collected under the authority of the Califomia Relocation Assistance Act (Govemment Code Section 7260, at. seq.)
INSTRUCTIONS: This claim form is for the use of families and individuals applying for a payment of moving and related expenses. You may apply for either
(1) a fixed allowance, or (2) an amount to cover the actual moving and related expenaes incurred, as described on page 2 of this form. A claim for actual
expenses must be supported by receipts or other evidence. A representative of the displacing Agency wíll explain the difference between the two types
of payments and will help you complete the form. If the full amount of your claim is not approved, the Agency wíll provide you with a written explanation
of the reason. If you are not satisfied with the Agency's determination, you may appeal that determination. The Agency wíll explain how to make an appeal.
1. Your Name(s) (You are the Claimant(s» 1a. Present Mailing Address(es) of Claimant(s) 1b. Telephone Numbe~s)
Jean Adamo 1178 Camino Biscay (619) 420--9685
Chula Vista, CA 91910
2. Have all members of the household moved to the same dwelling? Ã- YES _NO
(If 'NO', list the names of all members and the addresses to which they moved in the Remarks Section.)
Dwelling Address How Many Rooms Was ft Fumlshed WIth When Did You Move
Did You Oc:cupy? . Your Own Fumitut8? To This Unit?
3. Un" That 459-A F street --X YES _NO
You Moved From Chula Vista, CA 91910 6 1960
4. Unit That 1178 Camino Biscay . Excluding bathrooms, hailways and closets.
You Moved To Chula Vista, CA 91910 10/30/94
5. Is This a Final Claim: YES NO (If 'NO', Explain in Remarks Section)
6, Computation of Payment (Complete Item 6a or 61»
61>, Actual Moving
Item Expenses
(1) Moving Cost $ 3 957.64 $
(2) Transportation Cost. Famiiies and Individuals $ $
(3) Cost of Insurance Covering Move and/or Storage $ $
(4) Storage Cost (Complete Item 10 on page 2) $ $
(5) Other (Explain in Remarks Section) $ $
(6) Total Amount of Claim (Consult Agency for amount of fixed allowance) $ $ 3,957.64 $
(7) Amount Previously Paid (If any) $ $ 0 $
(8) Amount Requested (Une (6) minus Line (7)) $ $ 3,957.64 $
7. CertIfIcatIon by C-.m¡s)
WARNING: If you Imwtngly or dellbet8tely mak8 false -- on this form. you may be subJect to ciYil or criminal penaJties under Section 1001 of me 16 of
the United States Code, In addition you may not -any of the amountll _ad on this form, I CERTIFY that this claim and supporting Information Bt8 true
and complete. that I have not submitted any other claim for the _1- and that I have not been paid for the e- by any other OOUIล, I ask that
the amount on Uno (8) of 118m (S) be paid dlt8Ctly to: - ME, or ...x.... THE CONTRACTOR(S) (u 8>OCiIIed In the Remartล Section), My - of - paym
In 6a or aduaI moving e- In 61> W88 - on the explanation by the ageney "",ressntative 01 the dltlet8nล - - types of _.
Signature(s) of Claimant(s) Date
Dole
""0 12/10/9.L ,. i
Pacific Relocation Consultants S-/ð PAC""""
Page 1 of 2
-------------' '~
..INVð'ICE '~1
-,- ..
SULUVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO. AGENT FOR ;1
4660 ALVARADO CANYON ROAD UNITED
P.O. BOX 600100
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92160 UNITED I
TELEPHONE: (619) 283-2146 U'lITED@ I
TOll FREE: (800) 854-2600 I
FAX (619) 283-0527 Van Lines I
I
AMERICA'S #1 FAMilY MOVER I
TO !
PACIFIC RELOCATION CONSULTANT INVOICE NUM8Elt600
ATTN: MARY O'TOOLE
3732 45TH STREET INVOICE DATIJ.0/24/94
SAN DIEGO. CA 90802
P.O. NUMBER
CUSTOMER NUMBEijPAC I F I C
"TO~'. SALESMAN-:'J"i"o~
CHULA VISTA 55
AMOUNT QUANTITY °Al CHARGES &
OR WEIGHT CREDITS
602 LOCAL MOVES 10.75 943.31
602 EXTRA MEN (2) 10.75 604.15
613 PACKING LABOR 1600.10
611 PACKING MATERIAL 498.50
634 SALES TAX 498.50 7.00% 34.90
631 DECLARED VALUATION CHARGE 25000 0.95C$ 237.50
INVOICE TOTAL 3918.46
CREDIT SERVICE CHARGE 39.18
. .
BY ORDER OF ICC :!>. PUC, $39.18 WILL BI!!ULLIVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO. 3957.64
CHARGED IF NOT PAID BY 11/07/94 4660AL-:~A~gX<:~NROAD
BASED ON 1.0% AND A MINIMUM OF $10.00 SANDIEGO,CALIFORNIA92160 5-1/
PAY $ 3918.46 IF POSTMARKED BY 11/07/94TELEPHONE:(619)283-2146
PAY $ 3957.64 AFTER 11/07/94 TOLL FREE: (800) 854-2600
-.
D~"moo"..""" Sh'pplngOrderend Fre'ghtS"'. --- -. --
SULLIVAN MOVING &. STORAGE CO. N~ - 3600
4660 ALVARADO CANYON RD. 2611'SLAND VIEW WAY D".~..
SAN DIEGO, CA 92120 VISTA, CA 92083 """"-lO,lJ.4,l94-_.
TElEPHONE, 16191 283,2146 TElEPHONE, 16191 599.2600 '...",...l0/.l4/9L-..
CAL P.U.C.. T. 16"" AGENTS FOR UNITED VAN LINES, INC. """,""10,l14,l94-___-
:::::" ลRIS LmD
. e
"OOR e SAME FLOOR
459 "P" 8'1'REm' APT. NO A 1178 CAMINO BISCAY APT "O.
ลUIA VISrA, CA 9191OPHON,420-9685 ลUIA VISTA, CA 91910
"e ' PHON'
Ht--7 8 9 10-11----12 i!!---1-2-3-4-5--6 ~::::::;:,:;.
I"""""""",'"",I"",'"",I""""",I"",'"",I"",'"",I",,~',""1""""",1""""",1""""",1""""",1"""..,,,1 ~:::,:::
'11""""."""",."",...~n....__';'__.._-..~ - "'~':::.
"'.'.""'d "-'~-"._'" =- i:::..'
BARREL OISH.PACK DRUM ETC. 17 45 --
CARTONS, LESS THAN' CUBIC FEET - - '-- 4 10 - .. -
'cU.FT, '" '.- :.- 5.40
"12 cu. FT. -=1-;-' 6 20
6 CU. FT. 2 5 . 7. 00
W'RORO" CARTOIfHOH'" T"^, "'" " I N/r
MATTRESS CARTON, CRIB
NOlEXCEEDING ". m' ."'"~h
NOT EXCEEDING 54"".
EXCfEDlNG 54"".
'39""0'
MATTRESS COVER PLASTIC OR PAPER
CORRUGATED CONTAINERS
CRAT"OVERM' 'MUM
T " UM
<Lon'ti'1' 7.5
GIASSPA<"'<S .30 LI b.4U ..-
'" "., ~=:~,;;:;:~:!:::::=.':::;::,:;...:,:.:=~~:,::::'.:.-.::::::::::::: TOTAL PACKING CHARGES 1
".", PJ\CIFIC REW:::ATIOO I~:;'_e_,- TOTAL CONTAINER CHARCES AOO ~
""".."~",,,..M'ß". , ::_,-_.. SALES TAX 7.00 % SAN DIEro Counh 3 :'
1='" .-
, " ;'"00"" ~m~'".J,\::',.D ,.:0,-,,' PACKERBHAM' HOURB DATE
"""'~""""""""""",,",c""" a... a"
~~ I I' .. I 1 I
"1 1'1""1 TOTALHOURS"S::-
No.o"aco", o 011 In 00.... TOTAL PACKING
i~!:;;:::'" ,~;¡~~I:;-.'-" J""".'.:~:~:",'1' H.APPLIANCESto'..mlc" "..
"" .1'.,::::::,::,:",-"" H"G..SSW.. Lbs, T",WI Lb,.
~ " .,'"'7~.~~U""..q. HNslWslahi Lbs.OS P"CwI.
"-, ," :"',""." "",uIO)-"""",I\J"""I""'¡";¡OSR7.7~ P"HI. n,
I ..~.,. I, Or",,;?; OvertIme H". os POI HI.
". "":;' H""Jt.~ '""Msn 0' '""'Hou."S on "'Hr- 604]
-,~O.. :::-1:::: I::~ H'" '" hlCh..'e/Lon c..~ 0 ""Cw!.
~_. ...,,1, VsnNo-l;!;t~;,!¡,
~ ".._~. I -,-" -'
, .,
S..T.Ch..,..
Val"'tlonCh"",S..A,'..m"II"S'~". ".nnn. O"'< ?"r ,.
TOTAL CHARGES ASSESS'O 391",
'STIMATEOCOSTOFSERVICESlllsny ,
TOTALCHARG'SONCHANGEOROERS .
NOTTOEXC"OPRlC'
""""BY Oc,," a C"",,'" CHECK °""""",°""""""00',"'"""'°"",,, ..."",~.."""",~,O TOTA' 'AID
~~~~~~¡~:~:¡'o', '.H~¿HT~¡i,TR~'~"~':¡;¡"O MATE"^, ".." TO CUSTOM'R ""NCEDU'
",. "..".." ""~~m."'. W"", ,"ceOD," "" CD,",,"O", ""'" O,"'~" "',",D', ..,,~.oo'"' ....",. "~"... '-""- ~"""..., "...,. "." ,"'"",'..' '" ""'". '"'
w""~""""""""'""""""""""""""',m""","r"'.."",,~~,,~,",.,,,,"..""""""",-""",.",""",,,ct,,"o"""~""""""""'"'""""""""""".,"'.
'"'."'.~.."., "',',"'.'."""'.""'.""'""""""""",."",,.,""mo" "'""""""""""""."""'"""""",m,". "'D'",""""'C'O'o,""""""~"""""""",,,
1..:::::.- . ~--a~_--___._[;..=I)--D""'""""" o "<C<"<o "'M""D" 'D""" -'--
--;;,\,¡¡e¡ """""""","c"w,c,co ",CE""" ~ -. (l"., /}¡;7,~--~ ._-
t- D~"mo"' ""'0'" -------- Sh'pplng O,de, end F'.'ght B"'.
SULLIVAN MOVING &.STORAGE CO. N9 3601
~~ ~~~~~Ac".."9~~~YON RD. ~~~~~~~D9i¿:f WAY ~::~:::lD/14/9L__-
TElEPHONE, 1619) 283.2146 TElEPHONE, 1619) 599.2600 OK""W¡+87:¡'1Ý:¡t----
CAt P.U.C.. T .1691<' AGENTS FOR UNITED VAN LINES. INC. DO"" f.~!!D/14-15/~
?::.",': " ลRIS IJND
.,' .
Iii1iIi!iI ADI\M). JEAN FeOOR 1m SlIME FeOOR
459 "F" STREEr APT. HO A 1178 CI\MINO BISCAY APT HO.
CHUIA VISTA. CA 9191O'HoHE 420-9685 CHUIA VISTA. CA 91910 'HOHE
. 1"""""'1""'1""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1"""""'1 ,-........"",..
6tt---7-8-~-10--11---12 ""----":--2----3--4--5-1 "°"",.,""
I"",'"",I"",'"",I""'I"",I,""'"",I"",'"""""""",¡,,:;~,,,",1."""",.1""""",1""""".1"".,.""1."",.",, ~::::,::
iiiiil"""""".""""""""~""_"h""Q_'_"""'. '~":::..
n--d._'_~",.,~- :::'" ¡:~" i
BARRel D/SH-PACK ORUM. ETC. .. .,
CARTONS, LESS THAN' CUBIC FEET
3OUFT.
41I2CU.FT.
'CU FT. -
W'RDRD"CAATOH"'m~rn"","n
MATTRESSCARTOH, CRIB
HOT EXCEEDING ". X ".
NOTEXCEED/HG 54' X ".
EXCEED/HG54'X'"
"'XiO'
MATTAESSCO,," PlASTlCO"APEA
CORRUGATEDCOHTAIHEAS
CRATES OVER MIHIMUM
CAATESlESSTHAH I IMUM
,
0" 0'" ""_'~'-"...._-,....".._..~..~.._~
:';:"::";::::::;:~~::::;;'"'--"""...".m"_._"~"-m TOTAlPACKlHGCHAAGES
....., n'~~T~ I¡~', 0 - TOTAL COHTAINER CHAAGES
"",..""..."". , ~~~.m 0 '-:::;SAlESTAX7_00%SANDIEroC"""
, .. 0 , :'""~",:;-" 0 ~,;;;;;' :J,~\"D ,:'.::::":~j 0 PACKERS NAME NOURS om
""""""""""""""".""".'" a", a"
., .... I ~ I ,~, I I - I
'" ,. ""' '"
I I I I TOTAL HOURS es h.
No. 01 Packers a 0" In a 0..1. TOTAL PACKING
~~:~:." '~i¡¡¡I~:~~."-' .1"""""""'" Loadl", H" APPUANCEBtob..mlce' ..,. ".....
,.. '""""'I~' ,,"~g= H"G"ssWt lbl. "..WI. lbl
,,","J.VAN/3MEN,.,115.85..".I"~,~-~;::U"'OOd H"N"Welhl lbs.OS P"Cw!. -
. ..' .. ....,. .. ,"'" ,'" I",.U "",,,., I.,,"'i.'" OS P"Ho.
I .....,,_... I: D"',,7i, /I. O"rtlme Ho",IOS P"Ho.
..., 11:.~' H" ,,1.I.t>...., E.I" Moo H"rlOS P"Ho.
~:=o.. ~:-iE I::" Hel "r>-<..,~ FII hlChlO ""o",CIO. 0 P"Cw!.
:=::::0.. ~~"I, VOOH°t",{.,Á.
~ I ~,- I -
,
StJChlO'. . ~ .-
VII"aIlooChlO,.S"A,..emeolf"Se.'ce S25 000 FULL '. 200 00
VI\I1JE ProrEX::rICN TOTAL CHARGES ASSESSED
ESTIMATEOCOSTOFSERVICESlllany¡ ,
TOTAL CHARGES ON CHANGE OROER S .
NOT TO EXCEEO PRICE
',""",",0,...O"""""",,, o ""'T',"O O""",,",,",",,,"'" °"".0 ~~'" ~ """,..a TOTAPAIO
;~~~~~¡~;~:¡i,";,"ú'ci"'~;~E~~,~',~':,c;tO M"En'" 'Asm W COSWMER BALANCE DUE
~:,::;::: ~:;;;;; ::::~:,~;::~;,~ ::,;~~~:,:,~',;~'~~'~:,: :::~,~'ge~~.~:~,:~;.:'. ~~~,,~o;"::~~~;h:~:'~::':';:::;::~::',;':;-';:;;;;::';:,~:~ ~:'~;::;:~~~o';:;;;;;::;,: ;;::':; :::,....,.
""'"""""".."",..",. "" """"""'""""""""" " m".', "" " ".. ,""" ""'"""""""""""","'s~""""",m'" AOCD""'"lESAAECOD.",,"""""."""""""""
1.-- (7, I- - - t" ..... l? D"..."..... aAE""""'M'""O",OM""____-------
~"'¡;'"~CovÂk~o:-----.;}"" - --JEQ£""o ,"__I__¡J~~J~-
-~
4
SULLIVAN MOVING & STORAGE CO.
PACKING TICKET
CA STATE RATES
SHIPPER: ADAMO, JEAN
ORDER #, 3600
PACKING MATERIALS PACKING LABOR
DISHPACK 42 5.35 224.70 42 17.45 732.90
1.5 37 1.20 44.40 37 4.10 151. 70
3.0 51 1.60 81. 60 51 5.40 275.40
4.5 30 1.95 58.50 30 6.20 186.00
6.0 5 2.55 12.75 5 7.00 35.00
6.5 3 2.55 7.65 3 7.50 22.50
WARD\{OBE 0 7.80 0.00 18 6.30 113.40
CRIB 0 4.20 0.00 0 0.85 0.00
SINGLE 0 7.40 0.00 0 1.05 0.00
DOUBLE 0 9.70 0.00 0 1. 75 0.00
KNG/QUEEN ø 11.70 0.00 0 3.60 0.00
KNG SPLIT 0 7.75 0,00 0 1. 55 0.00
H!H.ROR 13 5.30 68.90 13 6.40 83.20
CRATES 0 0 7.00 0.00
TOTALS 181 498.50 1600.10
-' ~ ¡If-
-
"
:
J
) .'
....
.1 ..
...
. 0 -
J '" - - ..- - .. ---' _0-- -- .. -.
) .'- ...
, ~.
,
. It> It> It> It> It> It> It> 0 It> It> It> 0 0 0
~ M r- M N M M <XI N N ... '" .... N <XI
0 ' ..i y:::>
) M ""¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡
) ì
4 ---
J
It> It> It> It> It> It> 0 0 It> 10 It> It> 0 It>
J ¡¡ <XI <XI It> .... It> It> 0 N M 10 0 .... .... '"
~ ~ '" . ' ..i ~
i M ""¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ -
.
J ~
4 §
~ ~ CO It> It> 0 It> 0 0 0 0 0 0 It> It> 0 0
:J. It> 0 <XI r- <XI <XI N N .... r- N It> "' ,...¡
U ~ :z:-: . .' -
" ..i ..i
J 2. w .... ,...¡. -,...¡- ,...¡ .,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡ ,...¡
'-- 0
..:
, ~t
"
~ 0
\: ~
....
..
...
J 0
...
.\ -..:
0 It> It> It> on It> It> It> 10 0 0 It> Q
It> It>
u""'" 0 0 '" M 0 .... M r- '" 10 "'; N 10 0 =
.. ~ .n ..; ..; ~ ..i ..i .n 0
It> .... .... M '" ...:
;t' % 0 .."'
t ,...¡ 010::
~ -
.~ ' "'0
.L 0;",
III 0 0 0 0 0 0 III III 10 0 III 0 0 o::!ël
.... ,..; .... N 0 III M <XI 0 ": '" III .... 0 :>...f<
... "'
'" r- ... III ..; r- r- '" ..i ,..; M ..i ..; r- ..: =.tJ
:;:; ,...¡ ลกí::!'"
0 CO ~W
~ :z: ~f<
Eo .. 0 III III 0 0 III 0 III 0 10 0 0 0 0
.0: w III r- M M N <XI .... '" M 0 N <XI III N 0= =
0
0 f..: ò ,,; ..i ..i ' ""'",
~ .... r- <XI <XI r- N ... r- <XI !ë~¡g
ro. N
~ 00::
ø: -~ ~OW
;; ...«11'.
> ... r 1--, ( '\~ ~ : fiHi! ::
c ~~
ø: " h~ ~f' ~¡gg¡
0 ~(\J
;; ~ -.J '"~
:;:;
~ f< .0
.0: =r.¡=
Eo Wf<W
CI":'"
:z; .... . oCO:>
0 .. ..0
0 ... o::~=
0 0 ê;-;'
Q ... ,',
( Q'"
~<'I- 0: ><
111M - ",=0
III'" Q.....:I
'" 0 rt...... I. ... III 0 0 III III III 0 0 0 0 0 III 0 à..~
c
..¡:z; ,..; n:! 0 M N '" '" III III <XI N .... r- r- r- M =f<"'
= ~ ,...... ° .n ..i ..i ..i . . ,..¡ ¡g~~
"'~rtr- tJ N N r- .... r- 0\ r- III
00 ,..; Ê~..:
.... .0: ><. Q ~ r' I =Of<
-t ~,.; > !it ~ 0'"
-tZ::I Q ~ .....'" \. ~\ K ~0::0
"'::I~ ~ 8 '6 n.. r "'" "'f' /5
J ~ - Ix ><",f<
......;;.o: ~ ~ ...) -~ì /'1(-..) ~ ..:! 3i~
.... > .0: .0: '
OO~'" Eo Eo< '" 0
:Z;E<N ' ;; r..:I -- !/ 0 : ¡:¡ 0
Q)~OO i c ..;¡,..:¡ Z Eo< r..:I ø: Eo< !/ ,..:¡.
+Jtoo:;;,..; % c.. III 0 0 0 III ~Eo<O In r..:IO !-tO ~ r..:I r..:I.o:- W M-
<0 tJ ro. t ...... .ö -- !-t Eo< ~ ::J, r..:IZ ,..:¡z 110 :I:: ~ :¡J '~i ...r.¡
..i ":f<
+J .o:ro. !/ '5 Q M '" '" ø:~;..; 0 ::J!-t 1Io!-t - ...... Eo< ::I ...0
~ ~-;;_O ü_- -----. 1-.-_- ~-- -- ---~ C,J, - ~-~-- or;.:; 11);':; '0 u 0 !/ II) Eo<. ..=
--- ------ ----- -- ----- -- --~- ---' -------
This page blank.
5~1(¿,
RESOLUTION /tf4>1
RESOLUTION OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA APPROVING FINAL RESIDENTIAL MOVING EXPENSE CLAIMS
TOTALING $5,274,56 PURSUANT TO THE ADOPTED RELOCATION PLAN FOR
TWO HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY LOCATED AT 459 F STREET
WHEREAS, the Redevelopment Agency adopted a Relocation Plan for 459 F
Street on October 19, 1993, which required the relocation of five (5) rental unit households
pursuant to the California Relocation Assistance Act; and
WHEREAS. the City of Chula Vista and the Redevelopment Agency approved
the Purchase and Sale Agreement for the property as part of the Civic Center Expansion
, Project on November 9, 1993, and authorized the encumbrance of $910,500 from CIP
Account #GG-130 for the purposes of purchasing the property and relocating the tenants;
WHEREAS, a former residential tenant (Unit B) filed and received Advance
Assistance ($1,500) and Rental Assistance ($3,300) claims pursuant to the California
Relocation and Assistance Act; and
WHEREAS. the former property owners (Owner) waived all of their relocation
payments except for actual and documented moving expenses as settlement for the
acquisition of their property; and
WHEREAS. two (2) final Residential Moving Expense claims have been filed
totaling $5,274.56 as follows:
Mary Mancini (Unit B) $1,316.92
Jean Adamo (Owner) $3.957.64
TOTAL $5,274.56
NOW THEREFORE. THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA does hereby find. order. determine and resolve that the final residential moving expense
claims for the former owner's household at 459 F Street, and the rental unit (Unit B) are
approved pursuant to the adopted Relocation Plan and Civic Center Expansion Project.
PR;rl::ï BY' ~-
Chris Salomone, Executive Secr tary and
Community Development Direct r
M :\HOM E\COMMD EV\HA YNES\REPORTS\MOVEXPS E .RES 5 - J7
-... ._.
This page blank.
S _/8
H____..----..
RESOLUTION I !tJo 2-
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF $5.274.56 FROM THE CIVIC CENTER
EXPANSION PROJECT (GG #130) FOR TWO FINAL RESIDENTIAL MOVING
CLAIMS PURSUANT TO THE ADOPTED RELOCATION PLAN FOR
HOUSEHOLDS FORMERLY LOCATED AT 459 F STREET
WHEREAS, the Redevelopment Agency adopted a Relocation Plan for 459 F
Street on October 19. 1993, which required the relocation of five (5) rental unit households
pursuant to the California Relocation Assistance Act; and
WHEREAS, the City of Chula Vista and the Redevelopment Agency approved
the Purchase and Sale Agreement for the property as part of the Civic Center Expansion
Project on November 9, 1993, and authorized the encumbrance of $910,500 from CIP
Account #GG-1 30 for the purposes of purchasing the property and relocating the tenants;
WHEREAS, a former residential tenant (Unit B) filed and received Advance
Assistance ($1,500) and Rental Assistance ($3,300) claims pursuant to the California
Relocation and Assistance Act; and
WHEREAS, the former property owners (Owner) waived all of their relocation
payments except for actual and documented moving expenses as settlement for the
acquisition of their property; and
WHEREAS. two (2) final Residential Moving Expense claims have been filed
totaling $5,274.56 as follows:
Mary Mancini (Unit B) $1,316.92
Jean Adamo (Owner) $3.957.64
TOTAL $5,274.56
NOW THEREFORE. THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA does
hereby find, order, determine, resolve and authorize the expenditure of $5,274.56 from the
Civic Center Parking Lot Expansion Project CIP (GG#130) for final residential moving expense
claims for Mary Mancini, a former tenant, and Mrs. Jean Adamo, e ormer property owner.
PRES¿J;;:
Chris Salomone
Community Development Director
M :IHOMEICO M M DEVIHA YN ESIREPORTSIMOVEXPSE. COU 5 -/9
-
This page blank.
5' ,.. :2-°
- ----- -- --- .--- --- -"
JOINT REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/CITY COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item /¡;
Meeting Date 6t2Ot9&
OB/Q1/Qé
08/15/95
ITEM TITLE: PUBLIC HEARING: SALE OF AGENCY PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315
FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I REDEVELOPMENT
PROJECT AREA TO THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, WITHOUT
PUBLIC BIDDING
AGENCY RESOLUTION 1458 APPROVING SALE OF CERTAIN PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 315 FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN CENTRE I
REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA TO THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA,
CALIFORNIA WITHOUT PUBLIC BIDDING, APPROVING PURCHASE AND
SALE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA,
AND AUTHORIZING THE CHAIRMAN TO EXECUTE SAME
COUNCIL RESOLUTION 17926 APPROVING THE PURCHASE OF CERTAIN
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 315 FOURTH AVENUE WITHIN THE TOWN
CENTRE I REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA FROM THE
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, APPROVING A PURCHASE AND SALE
AGREEMENT WITH THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO
EXECUTE THE SAME ø
SUBMITTED BY: Community Development Director
REVIEWED BY: Executive Directoff
(4/5ths Vote: Yes - No lU
BACKGROUND: On March 17, 1995, a Request For Proposals was issued for the purchase
of Agency property known as the EI Dorado Plaza Building located at 31 5 Fourth Avenue. On
May 23, 1995, staff presented a report to the Agency indicating that the three bids received
were too low and unacceptable. Staff recommended that the Agency sell the property to the
City. The Redevelopment Agency directed staff to prepare a purchase and sale agreement
for Agency/Council review and approval pursuant to terms outlined in the 5/23/95 report and
further described in this report,
Staff has prepared the Agency and City Council resolutions and agreement for Council/Agency
review and approval. A Grant Deed to transfer the property from the Agency to the City will
be prepared, processed administratively and recorded after the agreement is executed by all
parties.
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends continuance of the item to the September 5, 1995
meetinQ.
[BB\Co\ WP51 \AGENCY\RA4S\315SALE4.RA4]
~ - (
._.
This page blank.
¿ ~ þ-
- -------, .- -'-'