HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Packet 1994/10/11
Tuesday. October 11. 1994
6:00 p.m.
"I declare under penalty of perjury that I alii
employed by the City of Chula Vista in the
Office of the City Clerk and that I posted
this Agenda/Notice on the Bulletin B~ard at
the Public ~v~s Building an at City all on
DATED. I';,' ~ 1SIGNED
Rel!Ular Meetin2 of the Citv of Chula Vista Citv
'.
Council Chambers
Public Services Building
CALL TO ORDER
1.
ROLL CALL:
Councilmembers Fox _. Horton _. Moore _. Rindone _. and
Mayor Nader _
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG. SILENT PRAYER
3.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
October 4. 1994 (City Council) and October 4. 1994 (Joint Meeting of
the City Council/Redevelopment Agency)
4. SPECIAL ORDERS OF THE DAY:
a. Oath of OlTice: International Friendship Commission - Carol Dysart.
b. Cultural Arts Commissioner Bill Virchis will introduce Onstage Productions in recognition
of "National Arts & Hwnanities Month."
*****
Effective April I, 1994, there have been new amendments to the Brown Act. The CiJy Council must now
reconvene into open session to report any final actions taken in closed session and to iufJoum the meeting.
Because of the cost involved, there will be no videotaping of the reconvened portion of the meeting. However,
final actions reported wiU be recorded in the minutes which will be available in the CiJy Clerk's Office.
*""***
CONSENT CALENDAR
(Items 5 through 13)
The staff recommendations re,arding the foUowing items listed under the Consent Calendar wUl be enacted bl
the Council by one motion without discussion unless a Councilmember, a member of the public or CiJy staff
requests that the item be puUed for discussion. 1/ you wish to speak on one of these items, please fill out a
"Request to Speak Fonn" available in the lobby and submit it to the City Clerk prior to the meeting. (Complete
the green fonn to speak in favor of the staff recommendation; complete the pink fonn to speak in opposition to
the sta!f recommeiulation.) Items pulled from the Consent Calendar will be discussed after Board and
CommISsion Recommendations and Action Items. Items pulled by the public will be the first items of business.
5. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
a.
Letter from the City Attorney stating that there was no reportable actioll$ taken from the
Closed Session of 10/4/94. It is recommended that the letter be received and filed.
6.
ORDINANCE 2606
AMENDING SECTION 10.48.030 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE -
INCREASING STATE LAW MAXIMUM SPEED LIMITS IN CERTAIN
ZONES, SCHEDULE IX - 600 BLOCK OF NAPLES STREET AND
AFFIRMING TRIAL TRAFFIC REGULATION (first readiDl') - The City
Engineer has determined the need to establish a posted speed limit in the 600
block of Naples Street. A traffic and engineering study. as required by State
law. was conducted by staff. It was determined that the 85th percentile speed
on Naples Street is 35 mph between Industrial Boulevard and Broadway. Staff
recommends Council place the ordinance on first reading. (Director of Public
Works)
Agenda
-2-
October 11, 1994
7. RESOLUTION 17683 ACCEYfING CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ADULT
BASIC EDUCATION SECTION 321 GRANT FUNDS AWARDED TO THE
CIllJLA VISTA LITERACY TEAM, APPROPRIATING FUNDS, AND
AMENDING FISCAL YEAR 1994/95 BUDGET TO INCLUDE A .03 FULL
TIME EQUIVALENT POSITION - In March 1993, the Council ratified the
Library's application for Adult Basic Education Section 321 grant funds to be
awarded over a three-year period to the Chula Vista Literacy Team. The third-
year award of $7,100 will be used to provide staff development and training for
the Adult Literacy Coordinator, tutor trainer and staff. It will also be used to
upgrade the computer system, add a few hours a week for evening support staff,
and improve the program's ability to network with other adult education
programs. Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Library Director)
4/5th's vote required.
8. RESOLUTION 17684 ACCEYfING BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE OF
CAB & CHASSIS WITH MOUNTED HYDRAULIC SEWER FLUSHING
MACHINE, AND APPROPRIATING ADDITIONAL FUNDS THEREFOR
The 1994/95 Equipment Replacement Fund provides for the purchase of a sewer
flushing machine to replace a 1987 International Truck with Sreco Sewer
Flusher in Public Works Operations. Bids were received and opened on
9/19/94. Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Director of Public
Works and Director of Finance) 4/5th's vote required.
9. RESOLUTION 17685 REAPPROPRIATING FUNDS, RATIFYING CHANGE ORDER NUMBER
SIX AND ACCEYfING CONTRACT WORK FOR THE MAIN STREET
WIDENING PROJECT FROM 1-5 TO INDUSTRIAL BLVD - On 6/30/92,
Council awarded a contract in the amount of $341,381 to Granite Construction
for the widening of Main Street between 1-5 and Industrial Blvd. The
construction work for the project was completed in October 1993. In July 1993,
Granite Construction Company submitted a claim in the amount of$104,741.85.
Engineering staff, working with the City Attorney's office, has reached a
settlement with Granite Construction concerning the claim. Staff recommends
approval of the resolution. (Director of Public Works) 4/5th's vote required.
10.A. REPORT CONSIDERATION OF REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF CONDUCTING
AUTHORITY (CITY COUNCIL) PROCEEDINGS FOR THE PENDING
"TffiBETT REORGANIZATION," BONITA CAR WASH PROJECT, 3048
BONITA ROAD - LAFCO AND CHARLES TffiBETT, APPLICANT -
Changes in State law brought about by AB 1335, and effective 1/1/94, provide
that LAFCO may waive conducting authority (City Council) proceedings for a
change of organization or reorganization when certain conditions exist. As
stated in their 9/2/94 letter, LAFCO has determined those conditions exist for
the subject reorganization and that conducting authority proceedings will be
waived. Council must now grant its consent for the waiver to occur. Staff
recommends Council accept the report, approve the resolution, and direct staff
to formulate and return with a Council Policy to establish a standard procedure
for considering such future requests. (Director of Planning)
B. RESOLUTION 17686 CONSENTING TO THE WAIVER OF CONDUCTING AUTHORITY
PROCEEDINGS FOR THE PROPOSED "TffiBETTREORGANIZATION"
(R094-29)
Agenda
-3-
October 11, 1994
II.
REPORT
PALA/PAUMA AREA LANDFILL INITIATIVE - On 9/6/94, Council
directed staff to evaluate a written communication from Supervisor Pam Slater
asking Council to adopt a resolution in opposition to a November 1994 ballot
initiative that would amend the County's General Plan and Zoning Ordinance.
This would allow a landfill in the Pala/Pauma area of Northern San Diego
County and make a recommendation to Council as to a City position. Staff
recommends Council take no position regarding the request and file the report.
(Director of Planning)
12.
REPORT
APPLICATION FOR GRANT FUNDS FROM THE FEDERAL
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, LffiRARY SERVICES AND
CONSTRUCTION ACT FOR THE PURCHASE OF SPECIFIC LffiRARY
REFERENCE RESOURCES AS A MAJOR URBAN RESOURCE
LffiRARY - As the Chula Vista Public Library is a City agency serving a
resident population of over 100,000, it bas been designated a Major Urban
Resource Library by the U.S. Department of Education and is eligible to apply
for a grant of $11,670 for the purchase of business and job-seeking materials for
library users. Staff recommends Council accept the report and ratify the
Library's application for $11,670 of Library Services and Construction Act
Funds for the purchase of library materials. (Library Director)
13.
REPORT
APPLICATION BY THE CHULA VISTA PUBLIC LffiRARY TO THE
CALIFORNIA STATE LffiRARY FOR CALIFORNIA LffiRARY
SERVICES ACT (CLSA) FISCAL YEAR 1994/95 MATCHING FUNDS
FOR LITERACY - The Chula Vista Literacy Team is applying for CLSA
matching funds in order to supplement general funds used to support the
Literacy Program. Staff recommends Council accept the report. (Library
Director)
* * END OF CONSENT CALENDAR * *
PUBLIC HEARINGS AND RELATED RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES
The following items have been advertised and/or posted as public hearings as required by law. 1/you wish to
speale to any item, please fill out the "Request to Speak Form" available in the lobby and submit it to the City
Clerk prior to the meeting. (Complete the green form to speak in favor of the staff recommendation; complete
the pink form to speale in opposition to the staff recommendation.) Comments are limited to five minutes per
individual.
14.A. PUBLIC HEARING
PCZ-91-D - CONSIDERATION OF PREZONlNG 14.23 ACRES
LOCATED NORTH OF THE TERMINUS OF MOONVIEW DRIVE
FROM RR-l (COUNTY) TO RE-P (8.37 ACRES) AND RE-40 (5.86
ACRES) - MICHAEL DEMlCH - The item involves a prezone of 14.23 acres
to the City's RE-P and RE-40 zones, and the subdivision of 8.37 acres of the
14.23 acres into 12 residential and 2 open space lots. The parcel to be
subdivided is proposed to be prezoned to RE-P. Two adjoining parcels to the
east owned by the Sweetwater Authority are proposed to be prezoned to RE-40.
All parcels are located north of the terminus of Moonview Drive in the County
of San Diego. Staff recommends Council place the ordinance on first reading
and approve the resolution. (Director of Planning)
Agenda
-4-
October 11, 1994
B. PUBLIC HEARING PCS-91-02 - CONSIDERATION OF TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION MAP
FOR BONITA HD..LS EXECUTIVE ESTATES, TRACT PCS-91-02 -
MICHAEL DEMICH
C. ORDINANCE 2607 PREZOl'o'ING 14.23 ACRES OF LAND LOCATED NORTH OF THE
TERMINUS OF MOONVIEW DRIVE TO RE-P (8.37 ACRES) AND RE-40
(5.86 ACRES) (first readin!!)
D. RESOLUTION 17687 APPROVING THE TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION MAP FOR BONITA
HD..LS EXECUTIVE ESTATES, TRACT PCS 91-02, MAKING THE
NECESSARY FINDINGS AND ADOPTING THE MITIGATED
NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND THE MITIGATION MONITORING
PROGRAM FOR 18-91-15
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
This is an opportunity for the general public to address the City Council on any subject matter within the
Council's jurisdiction that is !l!l1 an item on this agenda for public discussion. (State law, however, generally
prohibits the City Councilfrom taking action on any issues not included on the posted agenda.) lfyou wish to
address the Council on such a subject, please complete the yellow "Request to Speak Under Oral Communications
Form" availDble in the lobby and submit it to the City Clerk prior to the meeting. Those who wish to speak,
please give your name and address for record purposes and follow up action. Your time is limited to three
minutes per speaker.
BOARD AND COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONS
This is the time the City Council will consider items which have been forwarded to them for consideration by one
of the City's Boards, Commissions and/or Committees.
None submitted.
ACTION ITEMS
The items listed in this section of the agenda are expected to elicit substantiol discussions and deliberations by
the Council, staff, or members of the general public. The items will be considered individually by the Council
and staflrecommendations may in certain cases be presented in the alternative. Those who wish to speak, please
fill out a "Request to Speak" form availDble in the lobby and submit it to the City Clerk prior to the meeting.
Public comments are limited to five minutes.
1S.A. REPORT
LffiRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES RECOMMENDATION OF SOUTH
CHULA VISTA LffiRARY AS THE NAME OF THE NEW LffiRARY
BEING CONSTRUCTED AT 389 ORANGE AVENUE - On 9/28/94, the
Library Board of Trustees voted to recommend the name South Chula Vista
Library as the name of the new library being constructed at 389 Orange Avenue.
Staff recommends Council accept the report. (Library Director)
B. REPORT
LffiRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES RECOMMENDATION TO NAME
THE YOUNG ADULT ROOM AT THE NEW LffiRARY FOR ARTURO
BARRIOS - On 9/28/94, the Library Board of Trustees voted to recommend
that the Young Adult Room at the new library be named in honor of Arturo
Barrios. Staff recommends Council accept the report. (Library Director)
Agenda
-5-
October 11, 1994
16.
REPORT
UPDATE ON SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ISSUES - An oral report will be
given by staff.
17
REPORT
UPDATE ON REGIONAL SEWER ISSUES - An oral report will be given
by staff.
ITEMS PULLED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR
This is the time the City CouncU will discuss items which have been removed from the Consent Calendar.
Agenda items pulled at the request of the pubUc wUl be considered prior to those pulled by Councilmembers.
PubUc comments are Umited to five minutes per individual.
OTHER BUSINESS
18. CITY MANAGER'S REPORTCSl
a. Scheduling of meetings.
19. MAYOR'S REPORTCSl
a. Site for Kidz Biz Program - discussion and possible direction.
20. COUNCIL COMMENTS
CLOSED SESSION
Unless the City Attomey, the City Manager or the City CouncU states otherwise at this time, the CouncU will
discuss and deUberate on the foUowing items of business which are pennitted by law ta be the subject of a closed
session discussion, and which the CouncU is ndvised should be discussed in closed session to best protect the
interests of the City. The CouncU is required by low to retum to open session, issue any repons of JiJJJJl action
taken in closed session, and the votes taken. However, due to the typical length of time taken up by closed
sessions, the videotaping will be tenninated at this point in order to save costs so that the CouncU's retum from
closed session, repons of JiJJJJl action taken, and a4joumment will not be videotaped. Nevenheless, the repon
of final action taken wiU be recorded in the minutes which will be available in the City Clerk's Office.
21. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - Anticioated litigation pursuant to Govenunent Code
Section 54956.9
. Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 54956.9: 1.
. City vs. Solid Waste Management IPA (differential rate structure and transfer station
legal issues).
. Metro Sewer Adjustment Billing.
. County of San Diego regarding Daley Rock Quarry CUP.
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION - Pursuant to Govenunent Code Section
54957
. Title: City Attorney
Agenda
-{)-
October 11, 1994
22. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATOR - Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6
. Agency negotiator: John Goss or designee for CVEA, WCE, IAFF, Executive
Management, Mid-Management, and Unrepresented.
Employee organization: Chula Vista Employees Association (CVEA), Western Council
of Engineers (WCE), and International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF).
Unrepresented employee: Executive Management, Mid-Management, and Unrepresented.
23. CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATOR - Pursuant to Government Code Section
54956.8
. Property: School District property next to Community Hospital Medical Center.
Negotiating parties: John Goss.
Under negotiation: Potential acquisition of site for Veterans Home.
24. REPORT OF ACTIONS TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting will adjourn to (a closed session and thence to) the Regular City Council Meeting on October 18, 1994
at 6:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers.
A Special Joint Meeting of the City CouncillRedevelopment Agency will be held immediately following the City
Council Meeting.
October 6, 1994
SUBJECT:
The Honorable Mayor and Ci~ COU~1
John D. Goss, City Manage.J':\ ~:>>~
City Council Meeting of October 11, 1994
TO:
FROM:
This will transmit the agenda and related materials for the regular City Council
meeting of Tuesday, October 11, 1994. Comments regarding the Written
Communications are as follows:
5a. This is a letter from the City Attorney stating that there were no
reportable actions taken at the closed session of October 4, 1994. IT IS
RECOMMENDED THAT THIS LETTER BE RECEIVED AND
FILED.
JDG:mab
~~I.t-
~
,~~~
CllY OF
CHUlA VISTA
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Date:
October 6, 1994
From:
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
Bruce M. Boogaard, City Attorney~
Report Regarding Actions Taken in Closed Session
for the Meeting of 10/4/94
To:
Re:
The City Attorney hereby reports to the best of my knowledge from
observance of actions taken in the Closed Session in which the City
Attorney participated, that there were no actions taken in the
Closed Session of 10/4/94 which are required under the Brown Act to
be reported.
BMB:lgk
C:\lt\clo8s8s8.927
S~-)
276 FOURTH AVE/CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA 91910/(619) 691-5037
~. --""---
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
ITEM TITLE:
Item (,
Meeting Date 10/11/94
Ordinance -< t; " "* Amending Municipal Code Section
10.48.030, Increased Speed Limits in Certain Zones, Schedule IX - 600
Block of Naples Street and Firming trial traffic regulation
Director of Public Wn~
City Manager.}. ~~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes_NoX)
SUBMHIED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
In February 1994, the City Engineer has determined the need to establish a 35 MPH posted
speed limit, via Trial Traffic Regulation, in the 600 Block of Naples Street. A traffic and
engineering study, as required by State Law, was conducted by staff and it was determined that
the 85th percentile speed on Naples Streets is 35 M.P.H. between Industrial Boulevard and
Broadway Prior to this Trial Traffic Regulation the speed limit in the 600 block of Naples
Street was not posted.
RECOMMENDATION: That Council place the ordinance on first reading amending the
Municipal Code for Increased Speed Limits in Certain Zones, Schedule IX - 600 Block of
Naples Street.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: The Safety Commission at its meeting
of September 8, 1994 voted 7-0 to approve the affirmation of the trial traffic regulation for
increased speed on the 600 block of Naples Street.
DISCUSSION:
Naples Street is a 40' curb to curb residential collector street with residences on the north side
and commercial and an elementary school on the south side. Near Broadway it is 46' curb to
curb in width and near Industrial Blvd it is 28' from edge of pavement to edge of pavement.
Based on the above-mentioned traffic studies and an accident rate of 2.22 accidents per million
vehicle miles which is slightly lower than the statewide average of 2.28 for similar roadways
in the State of California, and the presence of single family residences fronting on this street,
the school, and commercial property access, it has been determined that the speed limit shall
be posted at 35 M.P.H.
10.48.030 Increased Speed Limits in Certain Zones - Schedule IX
Declared Prima Facie
Name of Street Beginning At Ending At Speed Limit
Naples Street Industrial Blvd. Broadway 35 M.P.H.
Said regulation became effective when the appropriate posting of signs and pavement markings
were put in place on February 7, 1994 The regulation has run for a trial period of 8 months
t,.. )
Page 2, Item ~
Meeting Date 10/11/94
from the date of such posting, at which time a review of said regulation has been made to
determine if it should be made permanent.
A review of the traffic conditions by staff and the Police Department show that this Trial
Traffic Regulation is operating effectively Therefore, staff recommends that this Trial Traffic
Regulation be made permanent. In the vicinity of the school frontage, there are "25 miles per
hour when children are present" signs and other appropriate school crossing signs and
pavement legends.
Henry Manriquez, Principal of Harborside Elementary School has been notified of tonight's
meeting.
FISCAL IMPACT: The costs of the signs and pavement markings are estimated at $327 00,
includes full cost recovery This work was performed as a part of the current operating budget
of the Operations Division of Public Works.
Attachments:
Exhibit A - Area Plat 'SCANNED
Exhibit B - Engineering/Traffic surv. ;~~
Exhibit C - Trial Traffic #138 ...C'.~'>--
Exhibit D - Safety Commi~at1WMutes dated 9/8/94 (excerpt)
DMW:CY-<l27
m:'hom,longmoctlagcnda\noplca.ttr
",~
ORDINANCE NO.
~"J?/,
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTION 10.48.030 OF THE
CHULA VISTA MUNICIPAL CODE - INCREASING STATE
LAW MAXIMUM SPEED LIMITS IN CERTAIN ZONES,
SCHEDULE IX - 600 BLOCK OF NAPLES STREET AND
AFFIRMING TRIAL TRAFFIC REGULATION
WHEREAS, in February
determined the need to establish
Trial Traffic Regulation, in the
1994, the city Engineer has
a 35 MPH posted speed limit, via
600 Block of Naples Street; and
WHEREAS, a traffic and engineering study, as required by
State Law, was conducted by staff and it was determined that the
85th percentile speed on Naples Streets is 35 M.P.H. between
Industrial Boulevard and Broadway; and
WHEREAS, the Safety Commission at its meeting of
September 8, 1994 voted 7-0 to approve the affirmation of the trial
traffic regulation for increased speed on the 600 block of Naples
Street.
NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Chula vista
does ordain as follows:
SECTION I: That Schedule IX of Section 10.48.030 of the Chula
vista Municipal Code, Increasing State Law Maximum Speed Limits in
certain Areas, is hereby amended to include the following changes:
10.48.030 Increased speed Limits in Certain Zones - Schedule IX
Declared Prima
Name of Street , Beginning At Ending At Facie Speed Limit
Naples Street Industrial Broadway 35 M.P.H.
Blvd.
SECTION II: This ordinance shall take effec and be in full
force on the thirtieth day from and af its adqp ion.
John P. Lippitt, Director of
Public Works
z~ fO~:.o
CJ.ty
Presented by
c: \or\speed. toe
~-:J
11 \ \: .'
.'
....
,
I
\
.\ \ \~ .....~~\\\;~~~ '~~.:.,.\\:~~~~~'-, ~~ ~ y
" --:""~.~)' \~ ~ ~\'Q ~ ~\.\~~
'I'?\ :\~ .............-r"\\Q1~ ~p.-~ }: ~A", ;:\VJ\ ~
~ '\ \,--,~,?\'" ~~ . ~~~~~
~~\p~\ ~ ~ ~~) \~ ~~~ \.
, . '~ ...,...) -- \:.: ~ \.1..,1 , .\ ~ ~ \ ~
. '-~.i " " ~ r ~ ~
:".. \1 \, -ru2 a. ~~ "~ ~
III ' ~t"':'1\\\Ul. ~~~ '*' ~~ ,:A "
.I.f!. I ".. -~.. \ ~',
........-.A:~~~- \, ~ ~ ~ rA~ ~5
,... ~I~ 1'0 ....~ ~:~:ii ~ --- ~ ~ :..\
~. ~~...~ ~~r\' \ ~~~~ ~ ~
~ ~'K~~~. F;.;. \\\\. ~
~ff~~ ~'~',
'\ ~ ~ .... - tV'\'\~ .~~
i;::;;. .. I' \-(~ 1
:;::... ~'~~ ~
...~,... J ~,\,. ~ ~ ~ ~\
o ..~~':.J \1 ,'c: (\ \..
.~e>'c -- \\ ~~
~y~
\\\~~~~
'. ~ ,~.
~ '~
~ . \:\ \r r ' L.-J
~:e:L.. t \\ ........~
!' ,I, \ ~ LI ,....\.l\ l"~...........
l .... ....."..,,\ \
\ :J-.. :
::1 '" _::... ;.....,: \\ \ -
. ~ ~..- :,.. t-1 -; ~ \"
L .
.,'
.'
........
" ~
,
. .
.
I
-.. --~,
\~ "\
. I~ !~~~,
f,~\\\\ 'l7Arrn \\ ~\
I '.11 ~ \ I V ',., I I\..' \
! III . " ~~
, ,~JJ u...u,
L-' -- ,
~ '-I- ... \
I- n- :1111 lit I~'
~ I,
It
\~ I
-"
0.".11
II ~
D.M. Wolf.
, . , ~ I
." A~~'I'~ A.
PLAT
---_-.---...--
.. TI 4-20-11
-..---..----
.
" '
S'EED LlKIT -- INGINEE1INGIt1A1FIC SU1V!Y~
smETI
J.lKlTS I
N.~l.. f:t"..t
lnduatrial Blvd. - Broadwav
'.'
lxi.tiDl 'o.t.d 'p..d J.1a1tl
*
KPH
. unpo.t.d .nd IS KPS'.h.n children
an pnllnt
'JlKKA:lY Or.. SPEED StntVEYS
.....ntl
D.u t.k.nl
Juablr 'Ihicl.. on S.mplll
ISth '.rc.ntil. Splld:
lan.1 of 'p..d. I.cordldl
Indultrl.l Ilvd. . Iro.dv'l
11/8/93
100
35 KPH
20 . 45 KPH
"
<.1.""n"",.,,'" J.,. ,. '."
1-OIJJWAY CiAlAml1S~lCS
, ,Ave. I' to I'
Width 40-46 .nd 28' w/o Color.dof..t Numb.r of lan.. for ~oth dir.ction. 2
lori.ont.l Allanm.nt Tan~ent
,.rtical Alianmlnt Max Rude Ius than 2% - ", ., ,,-.
~TFIC CHAlACTEllSTICS
,
','
. '.
Av.r... D.ily tr.ffic 6.510
~.Str..t 'arkina No .toPPln& .llowed on louth curb ..,t of Woodl.wn Av.nu. to
Ir_,."w.;,.,~.v_~,...:.",""-"',, .,." ""r" ';..,''''.'f:''!.'',f/.>J.'1.:,....,.,.,:.:.c~.~.'r.I',,::.,. ~.
,. .,~.-,
Sp.ci.l Condition. No curb. Rutter Ind .ldewalk Welt of Color.do AVlnul. H.rbor.idl
School list of Colorado Avenue on the southslde. Trolley tracks vest 01 ~Olor'dO
A"ll Qn" ~hll ~~.rt~,;rl"t'filff>:~\,,?stlv reliidenti.l~,~~~, ,direct driveway .cc.~~:
.
Accidlnt littory
I lowe th.n the .v.ra . rat.
CalHornl..
!..,:~ <. ...... ..' , :: .~. "'\':-:'f"'i,"-' ,1."""~-, ...~,~.~~"',.~ 'f.:~__.:r~i"l' or< ~,:, d'~"':<< .'
. 2 .ccid.nt. Ir million v.hicl.
. m .r roe w. I n a . I 0
".',.,
.,!.""'_,'_1!'.\" ". ',.'.,
1'J'.m ~t.
..
'tudJ ... Pr.p.r.d ~1.
SUva S.Uh
Data
11/10/93
Ilc_nd.Uon
Narharaid. S~hool
KPH ..d limlt wh.n childrln .rl rl.,nt in the v1cinit of
.n~ J,t,bliah 35 MPH p~..d limit everyv .re I lion t I lesm.nt.
"""""'. ,p ,~,
- .." ,'..co .,,~,' ,. .~, " .~.~,
Data ~'c_ndaU01l approv.d I ,I" / 'If
I, ~.",.,<:.-~..o X. e..,~
&'~f
'. .
.
Approv.d .p." l1a1U
3S MPI
'.r evc 40803, 'urY', IKpir"1
11/8(98
~
~1~gIIA:r~gl ~:rll
u~, . (
~~
, / V4:u-p"
I t.$' 1'1 , 1994 r f
rUe: C'f-021
.~
'10: "I'be BoDorable Kayor aD4 City ~il
VIA: John Go.., City llaDager~ ~~
noM: . JobD .. Lippitt, Director ofu..ml1e ~
8OBJBC'1': . ..tabl18hiD9 a '!'rial '!'raffie ~ation
rur.uant to the prodai0D8 of Section .' o. , 2.030 of the Chula
Vi.ta lluDic1pal C:OCSe, adopteeS by OrdiDaDce 110. '625 on Kay 21,
'915, the City Engineer, with the CODcurrence of the Chula Vi.ta
Safety eo..i..ion, baa deteraineeS that in the intere.t of
ainiai&1ng traffic hazarda end traffic conge.tion, and for the
p~tion of public aafety, there i. beraby e.tabli.bed :
10. C8. 030 SCHEDULE IX - IHCRBASBD SPEED LIMITS IR CDTAIR AREAS
..I:~ed
Spee4 Liait
.... of Street
Be91nning At
lEnding At
"ple. Street
Induatrial Blvd.
Broadway
35 II...H.
"I'be City Engineer baa deteraineeS the neeeS to e.tabli.b a po.teeS
apeed lialt in the 600 block of lIaple. Street. A traffic and
engineering .tudy, a. required by state Law, wa. OODducteeS by
.taff and it was deteraineeS that the 15th percentile apeed on
lIaple. Street i. 35 II.P.H. between ID4uatrial Boulevard and
Broadway.
lIaple. Street i. a CO' curb to curb re.idential collector atreet,
with re.idence. on the north aide aD4 c- .reial and an
el...nt&ry acbool on the aouth aide. ...ed on the above aentioneeS
traffic atudie. aD4 an accident rete of 2.22 accident. per
aillion vehicle aile. which i. alightly lower than the atatewide
average of 2.28 for 81ailar zoadway. in the state of California,
the pre.ence of re.idence., Cl ' .reial, aD4 the a~l, it has
been deteraiDed that the apeed lia1t 8hallbe posted at IS .....B.
..id ~atiOD to beCtl.. effective apon the posting of 8igna.
"I'be regulation 8hall run for a trial period of S ..tba frea the
date of .ucb po.ting, at which t1.ae a review of ..id ~tion
,,111 be ..de to detera1ne if it abouJ.cJ be aaae ~t.
. ~
AttachMDta :
.
Area Plat
SngineeriD9 and '!'raffie surver
(, ,t,
~1al Ifrafflc '138
~ . ---.----.- ......,
Safety Commission Minutes
September 8, 1994
Page 6
8. REPORT AftIrming Trial Traffic Regulation #138 - Increased Speed Limits in Certain Zones - 600
Block of Naples Street
Frank Rivera presented staff's report.
Commissioner Liken asked if the elementary school had any comments on the increased speed limit.
Frank Rivera said the school principal had been notified eight months ago before the trial traffic
regulation was installed and he was nO,t heard from.
Commissioner Miller had received a call from the principal of Harborside a few months back and he was
concerned about the speed on Naples Street. The principal had indicated that speed was a problem and
he wanted to address the Commission about installing speed humps in the area. She said when the
original request was submitted, Broadway was being re-surfaced and that caused many problems. She
asked staff if they had informed the principal that the item was scheduled for the Safety Commission
meeting.
Frank Rivera said he believed that the principal had been informed but he could not be sure.
Commissioner Miller said motorists were supposed to decrease speed when children were present, but
the principal said that was not happening.
MSUC (Smith/Pitts) to recommend to the City Councll that Councll paas an ordinance
affirming the trial traffic regulation and make the speed limit permanent.
9. REPORT on request for time limited parking 500 block of Del Mar Avenue and 200 blocks of
Shasta Street and Whitney Avenue
Frank Rivera presented staff's report.
Chair Thomas asked staff if they verified that Sharp Reese Stea1y (sas) had met conditions of their
Condition Use Permit (CUP).
Frank Rivera responded that the conditions of the CUP had been met.
Commissioner Smith said as he viewed the random counts of on-site parking spaces for sas, there were
always parking spaces available throughout the day. He asked how many spaces were occupied by
employees versus patients.
Frank Rivera said it was difficult to distinguish. After July 1994, the employees were given permits for
parking; however, before July 1, there was no way to distinguish the cars. Since there were spaces
available through the day, staff concluded that it was not only sas employees impacting the
surrounding streets, but other businesses as well.
Commissioner Smith felt that sas was being singled out and it could be the courthouse that was also
causing problems.
Carmen Aria8, Site Manager, Sharp Reese Stealy, 626 Third Alienus, Chula Vista, CA 91910,
said she was neutral on the two hour parking limits. sas encouraged employees to park on H Street
t.~/
UNOFFICIAL MINUTES
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
ITEM 7
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
Resolution 17/, r~ccePting California Department
of Education Adult Basic Education section 321
grant funds awarded to the Chula vista Literacy
Team, appropriating funds, and amending FY 1994-95
budget to include a .03 FTE position
SUBMITTED BY: Library Director~\~
REVIEWED BY: City Manageu~ ~~\ (4/5ths Vote: Yes-1LNo_)
In 1992 the Chula vista Public L~rary applied for ABE section 321
funds in a California Department of Education three-year grant
cycle. The primary purpose of these grant funds is to improve the
quality and responsiveness of programs which enable adults to
acquire basic literacy skills. The third year grant of $7,100 has
now been awarded to the Library. The award is divided into two
parts. The base grant ($3,500) must be used for supplemental staff
development, assessment, and/or networking. Additional funds
($3,600) are calculated based on the number of learner attendance
hours, and these may be used for staff development and/or other
enhancements to program quality.
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMENDATION:
That Council adopt the resolution accepting California Department
of Education Adult Basic Education section 321 grant funds awarded
to the Chula vista Literacy Team, appropriating funds, and amending
the FY 1994-95 budget to include a .03 FTE position.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
On March 23, 1994 the Library Board of Trustees voted to support
the Library's application for ABE section 321 grant funds for the
three-year period through June 1995. (ATTACHMENT A)
DISCUSSION
On March 16, 1993 Council ratified the Library'S application for
ABE 321 grant funds to be awarded over a three-year period.
(ATTACHMENT B) These third year grant funds will be used to
provide staff development and training to the Adult Literacy
Coordinator, tutor trainer and staff. Additional funds will be
used to upgrade the Literacy Team's office computer used to track
learner records and progress, to pay for access to OTAN, (an on-
line computer network for adult educators), and to cover 3 hours a
week for a Clerical Aide to conduct learner post-evaluation
interviews.
7"/
ITEM 7 PAGE TWO
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
FISCAL IMPACT:
Accepting this grant will provide $7,100 to implement this program
in FY 1994-95 through the Chula vista Literacy Team. The grant has
been approved for a three-year period, based upon submission of an
annual continuation request. The fiscal portion is approved for a
one-year period but is renewable annually through FY 1994-95.
Funds cannot be used to supplant the current volunteer tutor
program. These funds will be appropriated into fund 260-2619.
(ATTACHMENT C)
7'~
RESOLUTION NO. /7/-11..3
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA ACCEPTING CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
EDUCATION ADULT BASIC EDUCATION SECTION 321
GRANT FUNDS AWARDED TO THE CHULA VISTA
LITERACY TEAM, APPROPRIATING FUNDS, AND
AMENDING FY 1994-95 BUDGET TO INCLUDE A .03
FTE POSITION
WHEREAS, in 1992 the Chula vista Public Library applied
for ABE section 321 funds in a California Department of Education
three-year grant cycle in order to improve the quality and
responsiveness of programs which enable adults to acquire basic
literacy skills; and
WHEREAS, the third year grant of $7,100 has now been
awarded to the Library and is divided into two parts: the base
grant ($3,500) must be used for supplemental staff development,
assessment, and/or networking and additional funds ($3,600) are
calculated based on the number of learner attendance hours, and
these may be used for staff development and/or other enhancements
to program quality; and
WHEREAS, on March 23, 1994 the Library Board of Trustees
voted to support the Library'S application for ABE section 321
grant funds for the three-year period through June 1995.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the city council of the
City of Chula vista does hereby accept California Department of
Education Adult Basic Education section 321 grant funds awarded to
the Chula vista Literacy Team.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council does hereby
appropriate the $7,100 grant funds into Account 260-2619 as
follows:
$ 575
9
22
4,060
1,434
1.000
$7,100
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the FY 1994-95
hereby amended to include a .03 FTE position in the Lite
- 260-2619-5105.
5105 Hourly Wages
5143 Medicare
5145 PARS
5224 Training
5298 Other Contractual
5324 Equipment
Bruce M.
/ Attorney
7'3 7-b
budget is
y Office
Presented by
O~:Y
David Palmer, Library
Director
c:\r.\library.abe
ity
.
I
.
.
ATTACHMENT A
Library Board of Trustees
March 23, 1994
B. Coffee Cart at civic Center Library
Mrs. Blue reported that the Library has been approached
by two vendors who wish to place a coffee cart in the
civic Center Library. This concession would be open to
bid by other vendors and could possibly bring in revenue
between six to fifteen percent of sales. The Library
would like to see profits earmarked to upgrade computers
and equipment at the civic Center Library to the level
that will be available at the South Chula Vista Library.
Chair viesca
location and
areas.
stated concerns of liability, hours,
the issue of bringing coffee into book
C. Literacy Grants
l.
2.
3 .
Families for Literacy Grant
Literacy ABE 321
Community Development Block Grant
MSC (Donovan/Clover-Byram) the Library Board supports the
Literacy Team's application for three literacy grants,
Families for Literacy, AB32l and community Block Grant.
Approved 3-0-2 with Trustees Alexander and Williams not
in attendance.
Mrs. Blue
Schofield
time of
training.
Library''S
(Director
relayed a request by Literacy Coordinator Meg
to use Conference Room One on April 27th, the
the Trustee's next meeting, for literacy
The Library Board agreed to meet in the
Lower Level Conference Room on April 27th.
Palmer arrived at 4:12 pm)
IV. LIBRARY DIRECTOR'S REPORT
Director Palmer reported that during his meeting with the City
Manager the opening date for the South Chula vista Library was
tentatively scheduled in late January with a dedication in
December. staffing, hours, budget cuts, revenue projections
and other issues regarding the Library budget were also
discussed. (Trustee Williams arrived at 4:23 pm) Trustee
Clover-Byram asked Mr. Palmer to prepare a one page synopsis
of the status of the Library's budget before the next meeting.
3
/'
7,}/
Minutes
March 16, 1993
.e2
ATTACHMENT B
considered five propositions. The final cost of the election exceeded the estimates. Staff recommends
approval of the resolution. (City Clerk) 4/5th's vote required.
7 RESOLlJIlON 17032 ESTABUSHING TER/vIS AND CONDITIONS FOR FINAL PRICING AND
DEl1VERY OF BONDS IN ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NUMBER 90-2 (OTAY VALLEY ROAD) . On 6/30/92,
Council approved bonds for Assessment District Number 90-2, Otav Valley Road. Delays in the project make
it necessary for Council to re-authorize issuance of bonds. Staff recommends approval of the resolution.
(Director of Finance and Director of Public Works)
City Attorney Boogaard informed Council that a revised resolution had been read as part of the Consent
Calendar The difference between the resolutions was that it was unnecessary to authorize the re.issuance
of bonds and terms but Council needed to extend the previously granted authority to the Finance Director
to set final pricing of the bonds.
8. RESOLlJIlON 17034 APPROVING A JOINT USE AGREEMENT WITI-l SAN DIEGO GAS AND
ELECTRIC COMPANY (SDG&E) TO ALLOW TI-lE ClTI TO MAIt.'TAlN A STORM DRAIN WITI-lIN SDG&E'S
EASEMENT AND AUTIiORIZlNG TI-lE MAYOR TO EXEClITE SAID AGREEMENT - Development of property
owned by R.E. Hazard, at the northeast comer of "C" Street and North !'ifth Avenue, required the
consauction of a double-reinforced, concrete box culvert as part of the improvements. The alignment of the
new storm drain required crossing an existing SDG&E Company easement. Since SDG&E has senior rights,
the City is required by SDG&E to enter into a Joint Use Agreement in order to maintain the storm drain
facilities. Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Director of Public Works)
.
RESOLlJIlON 17034 ACCEPTING CAUFORNIA Sf ATE UBRARY SIXIH-YEAR MATCHING FUNDS
AWARDED TO TI-lE CHULA VISTA UTERACY TEAM, APPROPRIATING FUNDS, AND AMENDING FISCAL
YEAR (FY) 1992-93 BUDGET - The California State Library has announced that California Library Services
Act funds are available to continue funding on a limited bosis ror programs which were awarded five-year
grants through the California Literacy Campaign. Accepting the grant extension will provide $23,309 in FY
1992-93 to Chula Vista Literacy Team. The funds cannot supplant existing funds. Staff recommends
approval of the resolution. (Acting Library Director) 4/5th's vote required.
lOA REPORT APPUCATION OF TI-lE CHULA VISTA PUBUC UBRARY FOR CAUFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ADULT BASIC EDUCATION SECTION 321 FIJNDING FOR FY 1992-93
TIiROUGH 1994-95 FOR TIIE CHULA VISTA UTERACY TrAM - The Public Library has applied for ABE
Section 321 funds in a new California Department of Education t:oree-year gram cycle. Accepting the grant
will provide $5,645 in FY 1992-93 to implement a staff development program and to purchase instructional
materials. The grant has been approved for a three-year period, the fiscal ponion is approved for a one-year
period but is renewable annually through FY 1994-95 Funds cannot be used to supplant the current
volunteer tutor program. Staff recommends acceptance of the repon and approval of the resolution. (Acting
Library Director)
B. RESOLlJIlON 17035 ACCEPTING CAUFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ADULT BASIC
EDUCATION (ABE) SECTION 321 GRANT F/JNDS AWARDED TO TI-JE CHULA VISTA UTERACY TEAM,
APPROPRIATING FIJNDS, AND AMENDING TI-JE FISCAL YEAR (FY) 1992-93 BUDGET - 4/5th's vote
required.
. . END OF CONSENT C.'\LE:\DAR . .
PUBUC HEARINGS AND RELATED RESOLlJIlONS AND ORDINANCES
. PUBUC HEARING CONSlDERATION OF MASTER FEE SCHEDULE UPDATE AND RELATED
CHANGES TO TI-JE MUNICIPAL CODE - The second phase of the Master Fee Schedule update will. (1) make
several administrative and technical changes in the Municipal Code relating to the assessment of fees; (2)
?~?
ATTACHMENT C
ABE SECTION 321 FUNDS
FY 1994-95
9/30/1994
BUDGET ACCOUNT: 260-2619
5105 Hourly Wages $575.
5143 Medicare $9.
5145 PARS $22.
5224 Training $4,060.
5298 Other Contractual $1,434.
5324 Equipment $1,000.
TOTAL: $7,100.
7'/
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item 8
Meeting Date 10/11/94
Resolution J 71, IIi Accepting bids and awarding
contract for purchase of Cab & Chassis w/mounted
Hydraulic Sewer Flushing Machine, and appropriating
additional funds therefore.
SUBMITTED BY: Directo~ Public Works~
Director of Financ~
REVIEWED BY: City ManagerJ~ ~ ~n (4/5THS vote: Yes-1LNo_)
The 1994-95 Equipment Replacement Fund provides for the purchase of a sewer
flushing machine to replace a 1987 Internationl Truck with Sreco Sewer
Flusher in Public Works Operations. Bids were received and opened at 3:00 pm
on September 19, 1994, in the office of the Purchasing Agent for the purchase
of the sewer flusher.
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMENDATION: That Council award the bid for the sewer flusher to the
lowest responsible bidder, Sreco-Flexible and appropriate an additional
$6,140 from the unappropriated fund balance in the sewer fund.
BOARDS & COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
Not applicable.
DISCUSSION:
Bid packages were mailed
Bonita did not respond.
to 5 vendors: only one vendor, Owens Equipment of
The following is a summary of bids opened:
Bidder
Unit 7% Sales Tax Trade-in Net
Price Included Allowance Amount
$79,350 $ 5,554.50 $ 3,500 $81,404 50
$87,987 $ 6,159 09 $12,000 $82,146.09
$92,658 $ 6,486.06 $12,000 $87,144.06
Road Machinery Inc.
Chino, CA
Sreco-Flexible
Lima, OH
Sewer Equip. Co
of America
Glenview, IL
Nixon-Egli Equip.
Santa Fe Springs, CA
$87,861
$ 6,150 27
$ 3,000
$91,011 12
Owens Equipment
Bonita, CA
No Bid
The low bid of Road Machinery does not meet specifications and is not
acceptable. Breco-F1exible is the lowest responsible bidder
?',/
Page 2, Item 8
Meeting Date 10/11/94
meeting all specifications with no exceptions. Specifically the required
specifications not met by Road Machinery are as follows:
Truck Cab
The specifications require that there be a full width, full depth, foam seat
and three (3) seat belts. Road Machinery specified bucket seats which do not
seat 3 people therefore not meeting specifications.
Water Tank Fill Svstem
The specifications require the water tank fill opening be located at the rear
center of the vehicle in a lockable storage compartment large enough for fill
hose. Road Machinery's flusher fills at the right side not from the rear as
specified and more importantly does not include a lockable secure storage
space for fill hose.
Flusher Pump Compartment
The specifications require a flusher compartment. Road Machinery's Flusher
rear mount is open, which exposes air hoses and operational controls.
Flusher Hose and Hose Reel
The specifications require the hose reel capacity to be 1,000 feet of hose,
and that the hose reel contain 800 feet of hose. Road Machinery does not
meet the hose capacity of 1,000 feet or minimum hose requirement of 800 feet.
The capacity and hose specified is 650 feet. This is not acceptable. There
are situations such as on Telegraph Canyon Road in Chula Vista where the
specified 800 feet of hose is needed to reach between sewer manholes. Both
existing flushers in Public Works Operations have 800 feet of hose.
In addition to the required specifications not met by Road Machinery the
following are other concerns cited by our Fleet Manager:
Flusher Pump
The design of the Road Machinery flusher is to mount the pump under the
truck chassis in a cantilever fashion heavy to the curb side. The pump
is in constant movement during pumping. Since the pump is securely
fastened to the truck frame, any pump movement is from the flexing of
the truck frame itself. The Fleet Manager believes that this flexing
will result in repair costs to the frame over the life of the unit that
will be greater than the cost differential of the two sewer flushing
machines.
8")..,
Page 3, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
Flusher Hose Reel
The Road Machinery hose reel assembly places the hose reel on a swivel
behind the truck as opposed to frame mounting withing the flusher pump
enclosure. Based on past experience when a full length of hose has
become stuck in a sewer this design will not withstand the effort
required to extricate the hose. Al though this is not an everyday
occurrence, the fleet manager believes that repair costs to the swivel
assembly over the life of the sewer flusher from these chance happenings
will be greater than the cost differential of the machines. In
addition, Road Machinery's hose reel requires more set-up and shut down
time.
Cab to Axle Dimension
The specifications state that cab to axle dimension be approximately 84
inches. Road Machinery has specified a cab to axle dimension of 119
inches. The distance from the cab to the axle determines the turning
radius. Therefore, a smaller number is better for maneuvering and
making a turn at an intersection.
ALTERNATE FUEL
Due to its size, weight, and continuous all day operation, this vehicle is
not appropriate for consideration of conversion to alternate fuel.
FISCAL IMPACT:
During the Fiscal Year 1994-95 budget process, the City Council appropriated
$76,006 for the purchase of the sewer flusher. The budgeted amount was based
on funds collected for replacement and a preliminary estimate of replacement.
The actual cost of the unit ($82,146 including tax) exceeds the budgeted
amount and will require an additional appropriation of $6,140 from the
unappropriated balance of the sewer fund.
The existing sewer flusher has an annual maintenance cost of $11,143 and
operating cost of $1,578. We estimate the ongoing maintenance costs will
drop significantly while operating cost will remain about the same. The
savings will be reflected in equipment maintenance charges, account 100-1460-
5269.
(SWRFLSH. CAG)
K" .J
RESOLUTION NO. 17 ~ y(
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA ACCEPTING BIDS AND AWARDING
CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE OF CAB & CHASSIS
W/MOUNTED HYDRAULIC SEWER FLUSHING MACHINE,
AND APPROPRIATING ADDITIONAL FUNDS THEREFOR
WHEREAS, the 1994-95 Equipment Replacement Fund provides
for the purchase of a sewer flushing machine to replace a 1987
International Truck with Sreco Sewer Flusher in Public Works
Operations; and
WHEREAS, bids were received and opened at 2:00 p.m. on
September 19, 1994, in the office of the Purchasing Agent for the
purchase of the sewer flusher and the following four bids were
received:
Road MaChinery Inc.
Chino, CA.
$81,404.50
Sreco-Flexible
Lima, OH
$82,146.09
Nixon-Egli Equip.
Santa Fe Springs, CA
$91,011.12
Sewer Equip. Co. of America
Glenview, IL.
$87,144.06
WHEREAS, the low bid of Road Machinery does not meet
specifications and is not acceptable; and
WHEREAS, Sreco-Flexible is the lowest responsible bidder
meeting all specifications.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the city council of the
City of Chula vista does hereby accept said four bids and awards
the contract to Sreco-Flexible in the amount of $82,146.09.
John P. Lippitt, Director
of Public Works
$6,140 is
Sewer Fund
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the amount
hereby appropriated from the unappropriated balance
25 into Account 705-7050-5565.
Presented by
C:\r8\flu8hing.bid
y..'I
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Iremi
Meeting Date 10/11/94
SUBl\un'ED BY:
Resolution ) ? I, r 5 Reappropriating Funds, approving Change
Order #6, and Accepting Contract Work for the Main Street Widening
Project from 1-5 to Industrial Blvd
Director of Public wor~
City Manager~ ~ '@
(4/5ths Vote: Yes X No_)
ITEM TITLE:
REVIEWED BY:
On June 30, 1992, City Council by Resolution #16693 awarded a contract in the amount of
$341,381 to Granite Construction Company for the widening of Main Street between the 1-5
freeway and Industrial Blvd. The construction work for this project was completed in October
1993 In July 1993, Granite Construction Company submitted a claim in the amount of
$104,741.85 Engineering staff, working with the City Attorney's office, has reached a
settlement of $42,000 with Granite Construction Company concerning this claim.
The total cost for the Main Street Widening Project, including all Change Orders and
settlement of Granite Construction Company's claim, caused the overall project costs to exceed
the appropriated funds by approximately $25,220
RECOMMENDATION: That Council adopt a resolution approving the following:
1 Reappropriate $25,220.00 from 603-6030-STl04, Broadway Improvement Project from
F to I Street to 603-6030-ST137B, Main Street Widening Project.
2. Approve Change Order #6 for the amount of $42,000 (copy attached) for all damages
and claims submitted by Granite Construction Company associated with the Main Street
widening project and authorize the Director of Public Works to sign this Change Order
on behalf of the City of Chula Vista.
3 Accept the contract work completed by Granite Construction Company for the Main
Street widening project from 1-5 to Industrial Blvd.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable.
DISCUSSION:
Change Order #6 is a claim from Granite Construction Company for disputed work and
construction delays. A copy of this claim is attached as Exhibit C. The negotiated and agreed
lump sum settlement for this claim is $42,000 and was approved by Council in closed session
on April 5, 1994. Concurrent with this settlement Granite Construction Company agreed not
to challenge the City's liquidated damages on the project which amounted to $27,500 which
will be deducted from the total amount due Granite Construction Company. The net increase
of $14,500 to the contract is based on payment in full for schedule A and D of Granites claim
,~/
Page 2, Item~
Meeting Date 10/11/94
and partial payment of schedule F Schedule A totaled $1,401.50 and was for 3 hours of delay
caused by a conflict with the proposed 33" storm drain. Schedule D was for $1,502.56 and
was for reconstruction of a sewer lateral which was not shown on the plans. The partial
payment of Schedule F of this claim is based on delays in work which were caused by the
contract documents incorrectly indicating the type of electrical service meter pedestal, which
was required for the Caltrans freeway lighting system on Interstate 5. The contract documents
specified a San Diego Gas & Electric meter pedestal. This delay not only caused the stoppage
of storm drain facilities work, it also delayed the undergrounding of utilities, because the
existing meter pedestal which was to be taken out of service was located on a power pole
which could not be removed and undergrounded as planned. The total delay caused by this
item of work resulted in 47 working days. The Schedule F of the contractor's claim requested
compensation for office overhead for the down time. Compensation for increased maintenance
(Schedule C) throughout the project to facilitate drainage during periods of rain and for a
change in conditions in the construction (Schedule E) of the drainage facilities in which the
contractor was required to start and stop his operations were denied.
Granite Construction Company was charged liquidated damages in the amount of $500 per day
for failure to complete the project within the specified 75 working days. The contractor did
not finish the project on time because of the asphalt pavement used on the project did not meet
specification. The asphalt concrete pavement which was placed near the end of the contract
time failed to meet the project specification for stability Because of the heavy truck traffic
on this street the contractor was directed to remove and replace all asphalt concrete pavement
on the project. The contractor conducted his own investigation and testing and subsequently
replaced all asphalt concrete with new material. This work was completed and accepted 55
days after the expiration of the contract time. Liquidated damages amounted to $27,500.
The total cost of the items listed above resulted in a project overrun of approximately $25,220.
A sufficient amount of unencumbered funds remain in the Broadway, F to I Street widening
project, of about $152,000. Staff requests that $25,220 be reappropriated to the Main Street
Widening Project, ST137B.
'1 ' )..
iD
Page 3, ItemL
Meeting Date 10/11/94
Financial Statement:
I. Appropriated Funds* (ST137B) $637,421 13
II. Contract Amount $375,51900
includes contingencies
m. Actual Expenditures
a. Original contract plus change order costs $374,636.26
Water relocation expense (Sweetwater Authority) $ 98,768.49
Soil Testing (Law Crandell) $ 5,355 49
b. Staff Costs** $139,34743
c. Consultant Design $ 44,530.00
Total Expenditures $662,637 67
IV Total Funds Required $ 25,216.54
*
Includes reappropriation from Main Street Bridge Widening Project, STl53 in the
amount of $91,771
Includes 2.5% full cost recovery factor
**
FISCAL IMP ACT: Upon acceptance only routine maintenance shall be required.
Attachments: Exhibit A - Resolution #16693 and m~"9
Exhibit B - Change Order #6 ..~ P"~
Exhibit C - Granite Constructi~~mpany Claim
~
DCD:rb (AO-060)
WPC M:\HOME\ENGINEERIAGENDAIGRANIlEC.9ol
9,3
I))
'.'
Agenda Item 9
Revised 10/10/94
RESOLUTION NO. 17685
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA REAPPROPRIATING FUNDS, APPROVING
CHANGE ORDER #6 AND ACCEPTING CONTRACT WORK
FOR THE MAIN STREET WIDENING PROJECT FROM 1-5
TO INDUSTRIAL BOULEVARD
WHEREAS, on June 30, 1992, City Council by Resolution
#16693 awarded a contract in the amount of $341,381 to Granite
Construction Company for the widening of Main Street between the 1-
5 freeway and Industrial Blvd which construction work for this
project was completed in October 1993; and
WHEREAS, in July 1993, Granite Construction Company
submitted a claim in the amount of $104,741. 85 and Engineering
staff, working with the city Attorney's office, has reached a
settlement, subject to Council approval, of $42,000 with Granite
Construction Company concerning this claim; and
WHEREAS, when the City Council awarded the contract,
funds which were originally appropriated for the new trolley bridge
at Main Street and Industrial Blvd, CIP project number ST153, were
included as a portion of the funds set aside for the widening of
Main Street; and
WHEREAS, both of these projects were constructed
concurrently and The Metropolitan Transit Development Board (MTDB)
awarded the contract for the new trolley bridge over Main Street
with the City participating in its cost; and
WHEREAS, the total cost for the Main Street Widening
Project, including all Change Orders and settlement of Granite
Construction Company's claim, caused the overall project costs to
exceed the appropriated funds by approximately $25,220.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the City Council of the
City of Chula vista does hereby approve the following:
1. Reappropriate $25,220.00 from 603-6030-ST104,
Broadway Improvement project from F to I Street to
603-6030-ST137B, Main street Widening Project.
2. Approve Change Order #6 for the amount of $42,000
for all damages and claims submitted by Granite
Construction Company associated with the Main
Street widening project and authorize the Director
of Public Works to sign this Change Order on behalf
of the City of Chula vista.
q-q
Agenda Item 9
Revised 10/10/94
..
RESOLUTION NO. 17685
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CHULA VISTA REAPPROPRIATING FUNDS, APPROVING
CHANGE ORDER #6 AND ACCEPTING CONTRACT WORK
FOR THE MAIN STREET WIDENING PROJECT FROM I-5
TO INDUSTRIAL BOULEVARD
WHEREAS, on June 30, 1992, City Council by Resolution
#16693 awarded a contract in the amount of $341,381 to Granite
Construction company for the widening of Main Street between the I-
5 freeway and Industrial Blvd which construction work for this
project was completed in October 1993; and
WHEREAS, in July 1993, Granite Construction Company
submitted a claim in the amount of $104,741. 85 and Engineering
staff, working with the city Attorney's office, has reached a
settlement, subject to Council approval, of $42,000 with Granite
Construction Company concerning this claim; and
WHEREAS, when the city Council awarded the contract,
funds which were originally appropriated for the new trolley bridge
at Main Street and Industrial Blvd, CIP project number ST153, were
included as a portion of the funds set aside for the widening of
Main Street; and
WHEREAS, both of these projects were constructed
concurrently and The Metropolitan Transit Development Board (MTDB)
awarded the contract for the new trolley bridge over Main Street
with the City participating in its cost; and
WHEREAS, the total cost for the Main street Widening
Project, including all Change Orders and settlement of Granite
Construction Company's claim, caused the overall project costs to
exceed the appropriated funds by approximately $25,220.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the city Council of the
City of Chula vista does hereby approve the following:
1. Reappropriate $25,220.00 from 603-6030-ST104,
Broadway Improvement Project from F to I street to
603-6030-ST137B, Main street Widening Project.
2. Approve Change Order #6 for the amount of $42,000
for all damages and claims submitted by Granite
Construction company associated with the Main
Street widening project and authorize the Director
of Public Works to sign this Change Order on behalf
of the City of Chula vista.
9-5
Presented by
Accept the contract work completed by Granite
Construction Company for the Main treet widening
project from I-5 to Industrial Bl ~
3.
John P. Lippitt, Director
of Public Works
C:\rs\granite.co6
q.,6
"X
City
RESOLUTION NO. 16693
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA
VISTA ACCEPTING BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACT FOR
CONSTRUCTION OF MAIN STREET WIDENING FROM INDUSTRIAL
BOULEVARD TO INTERSTATE 5 IN THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA,
CALI FORNIA
WHEREAS, at 2:00 p.m. on June 10, 1992, in the Public Services Building,
the Director of Public Works received the sealed bids for the construction of
Main Street widening from Industrial Boulevard to Interstate 5 in the City of
Chula Vista; and,
WHEREAS, the following four bids were received who had the option to submit
bids on Alternate A, Alternate B, or both with Alternate A based on a premise
that contractors would not pay their laborers prevailing wages and Alternate B
based on a premises that they would pay their laborers prevailing wage scale:
Alternate A Alternate B
1. Granite Construction Company None $341,381.00
San Diego
2. Southland Paving, Inc. - Escondidio $3n,358.67 $398,653.45
3. L. R. Hubbard Construction Co., Inc. $382,951.34 $410,714.41
San Diego
4. Caves, Inc., San Diego $394,211.00 $394,211.00
WHEREAS, the low bid by Granite Construction Company for Alternate B is
below the Engineer's estimate by 28% and is the lowest of all bids submitted for
either alternative and staff has reviewed the low bid and recommends awarding the
contract to Granite Construction Company for Alternate B.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Chula
Vista does hereby accept said four bids and awards the contract for construction
of Main Street widening from Industrial Boulevard to Interstate 5 in the City of
Chula Vista to Granite Construction Company, known as document number C092-091,
a copy of which is on file in the office of the City Clerk, for Alternate B in
the amount of $341,381.00 to be completed in accordance with the specifications
approved by the Director of Public Works.
i2-yh-i bl+ A
9-7
Resolution No. 16693
Page 2
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Mayor of the City of Chula Vista is hereby
authorized and directed to execute said contract for and on behalf of the City
of Chula Vista.
I
Jo P. Lippi t
Di ector of Public Works
as to 0
~
Presented by
? .. g--
Resolution No. 16693
Page 3
PASSED, APPROVED and ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Chula
Vista, California, this 30th day of June, 1992, by the following vote:
YES: Councilmembers: Grasser Horton, Malcolm, Moore,
Rindone, Nader
NOES: Counci 1 members: None
ABSENT: Councilmembers: None
ABSTAIN: Councilmembers: None
~--~ ./
......-- /;"~?
Tim Nader, Mayor
ATTEST:
"1- /7 -'
/< " f / !. -/ ('
,)u ~)<c. ({ , lid.//-, i..J
Beverly A~ Authelet, City Clerk
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO) ss.
CITY OF CHULA VISTA )
I, Beverly A. Authelet, City Clerk of the City of Chula Vista, California, do
hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution No. 16693 was duly passed, approved,
and adopted by the City Council held on the 30th day of June, 1992.
Executed this 30th day of June, 1992.
t/)"
..i~
. Authelet, City Clerk
'1,1
ANITA ST.
;a <@
~
~
PROJECT SITE ~
~ MAIN ST.
-
~
0
CHARLES ~
:ti
~
r-
~
~
.
LOCA nON MAP
~
"'<
-
Z
-t
""
;0
VI
~
M
l!!
~
TITLE:
~
Q::
C
~
sr.
MAIN STREET PROJECT 9-k,J
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Itell /2
ITEM TITLE:
Meeting Date 6/30/92
Resolution liD\.,ct~ Accepting bids and awarding contract
for construction of Main Street widening from Industrial
Boulevard to Interstate 5 in the City of Chula Vista,
California 11.11/
Director of Public Works~Y
City Manager J~ 1->-'0 ~'i\ (4/5ths Vote: Yes_No..!..)
SUBMITTED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
BACKGROUND:
At 2:00 p.m. on June 10, 1992 in the Public Services Building, the Director of
Public Works received sealed bids for the "Main Street Widening Project from
Industrial Boulevard to Interstate 5 in the City of Chula Vista, California".
The project is funded by Transnet and is intended to improve the drainage
system, traffic flow and safety by widening and improving the northerly
portion of Main Street.
RECOMMENDATION: That Council accept bids and award contract to Granite
Construction Company in the amount of $341,381.00 for alternative B which pays
prevailing wages.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable.
DISCUSSION:
Main Street widening from Industrial Boulevard to Interstate 5 was budgeted in
the Capital Improvement Program. The project is the first portion of the
planned overall widening of Main Street. This project is being coordinated
with MTDB's project currently under construction which replaces the old
trolley bridge over Main Street with a new bridge which widens the street to
80 feet curb-to-curb beneath the new bridge.
This project was advertised for a period of five weeks. During that period,
plans were purchased by 30 contractors and, on the opening date, bids were
submitted by four contractors. Each contractor had the option of bidding
either or both of two alternatives, A or B. Alternative A provides that the
contractors are not required by the bid specifications to pay the prevail ing
wage (NOT .prevailing Wage Rate") to persons employed by them for work under
this contract. Alternative B requires the contractor to pay the general
prevailing wage rates.
A summary of the four bids received are as follows:
Granite Construction Company, San Diego
Southland Paving, Inc., San Diego
L. R. Hubbard Construction, San Diego
Caves, Inc., San Diego
Alternative A
None
$377,358.67
$382,951. 34
$394,211.00
Alternative B
1.
2.
3.
4.
$341,381.00
$398,653.45
$410,714.41
$394,211.00
~ 9'1/
Page 2, Item I~
Meeting Date 6/30/92
The low bid by Granite Construction Company for alternative B is below the
engineer's estimate of $474,095.00 by $132,714.00 or 28%., and is the lowest
of all bids submitted for either alternative. As we indicated last week,
staff is revising our cost items in an attempt to reflect the great downturn
in construction costs.
We have reviewed the low bid and recommend awarding the contract to Granite
Construction Company for alternative B.
Staff has conducted a past performance evaluation of the low bidder and has
determined that Granite Construction Company is an excellent contractor and
that they have successfully completed similar projects in the San Diego area
in the past.
The project specifications require the contractor to have 15% of the work
performed by Disadvantage Business Enterprise sub-contractors (DBE). The
project is subject to part 23, Title 49, Code of Federal Regulations and
CalTrans Disadvantage business program. These regulations require the prime
contractor to meet the DBE goal by using eligible sub-contractors, or making a
good faith effort to solicit such participation.
Staff concluded that Granite Construction Company does meet our DBE goal.
Granite Construction Company has met the DBE requirements by using el igible
sub-contractors for 22% of the work or $76,260. This participation exceeds
our minimum target of 15% and therefore the low bidder has compl ied with the
project specifications and related regulations.
Attached is a copy of the contractor's disclosure statement.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT:
FUNDS REOUIRED FOR CONSTRUCTION:
A. Contract Amount
B. Staff Inspection
C. Contingencies
TOTAL FUNDS FOR CONSTRUCTION
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CONSTRUCTION:
A. 603-6030-STI37 Transnet
B. 603-6030-STI37B Transnet
C. 603-6030-STI53 Transnet
TOTAL FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CONSTRUCTION
$341,381.00
17 ,069.00
34.138.00
$392,588.00
$291,462.27
9,354.60
91. 771.13
$392,588.00
FISCAL IMPACT: The project is funded by Transnet program financed by
Proposition A 1-1/2 percent sales tax. Main Street widening is in cycle III
of the SB 300 program. The city will qualify for an estimated 10%
reimbursement of the construction cost or approximately $39,000. This
expenditure of funds was authorized in the CIP budget as indicated. Upon
completion of the project, it will require routine City maintenance.
SA:AX-099
WPC 6032E
~
,,/~
MEMORANDUM
June 15, 1992
File 41 AX-099
TO:
John Goss, City Manager
Bruce Boogaard, City Attorney
Lyman Christopher, Director of Finance
Beverly Authelet, city Clerk
Roberto saucedo, Senior civil Engineer
John Lippitt, Director of Public Works ~
FROM:
SUBJECT: Resolution - Accepting bids and awarding contract for
"The Widening of Main Street from Industrial Blvd to
Interstate 5 in the City of Chula vista"
Funds reauired for construction
A. Contract Amount $ 341,381.00
B. Staff $ 17,069.00
C. contingencies $ 34,138.00
Total Funds for Construction $ 392,588.00
Funds available for Construction
A.
B.
C.
Account No. 603-6030-ST137
Account No. 603-6030-ST137B
Account No. 603-6030-ST153
$ 291,462.27
$ 9,354.60
$ 91,771.13
$ 392,588.00
Total
SA:rb
(SA\RESOAX99.MEM)
~ 9-/3
THE CITY OF CHUL.4 YISTA PAR7l'DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
'Iement of disclosure of certain ownership interests, payments, or campaign contnbutions, on all matters
,ich will require discretionary action on the part of the City Councl1, Planning Commission, and all other
icial bodies. The following information must be disclosed:
Ust the names of all persons having a financial interest in the contract, i.e., contractor,
subcontractor, material supplier.
Granit~structio'l,~~mp~~ V .
6!4Zi~"A~ (/(2 .fo4'Z/~-i>
If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a corpo~ershiP,list names of all
individuals owning more than 10% of the shares in the corporation or owning any partnership
interest in the partnership. ~
G<~ti~~="d ~'d~ 4:~
If ~ person identified pursuant to (1) above is non-profit organization or a trust, list the names
of any person serving as director of the non-profit organization or as trustee or beneficiary or
trustor of the t~~'A
/#J\J
\
Have you ad more than $250 worth of business transacted with any member of the City staff,
Boards, ommissions, Committees and Council within the past twelve months? Yes_
No If yes, please indicate person(s):
Please identify each and every person, including any agents, employees, consultants or independent
contractors who you ve assigned to represent you before the City in this matter.
.4
Have you and/or your o~_cers or agents, in the aggregate, contnbuted more than $1,000 to a
Councilmember in the current or preceding election period? Yes _ No -aL If yes, state which
Councilmember(s):
'tln is defined as: "Any individual, jiml, co-partnership, joint venture, association, sociol club, fratunal organization, corporation,
'te. nust, receiver, syndicate, this and any other counl)l, cil)l and country, city, municipalil)l, district or other political subdMsion,
.II)' Other group or combination acting as a unit..
OTE: Anach additional pages 8S necessary)
.Ie: June 10. 1992
B: Y
Sign ture of contractor/applicant
:). \;DISCLOSE.TXT)
R.C. Allbritton. Vice President
Print or type name of contractor/applicant
~ ,. / '/ (Rtvised: 11130190)
Minutes
June 30, 1992
Page 3
contract to Granite ConstrUction Company in the amount of$341,381 for Alternative B which pays prevailing
wages. (Director of Public Works)
13. RESOUTnON 16694 APPROVING nm SUBMITTAL 01' AN APPlJCATION FOR I'ouam CYa.E
FUNDS 01' nm STA'IF,/LOCAL TRANSPORTATION PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM (SLTPP) - Senate Bill 300
created the State/LOCaI 'transportation Partnership Program to identify and constrUct locally supported
projects with a minimum of State planning and review. Staff has prepared an application package to
CalTrans, the agency administering the SL TPP, and is submitting said package to Council for approval. Staff
recommends approval of the resolution. (Director of Public Works) Pulled from the Consent Calendar.
Mayor Nader questioned whether the item was time sensitive and if funding would be jeopardized if
continued. He further questioned whether some of the funds were available for public transit, pedestrian
improvements, and other transportation related items, i.e. bike paths, that would help enhance the quality
of life and help with the clean air problem. He requested that staff look more broadly next year at other
transportation related needs of the City as opposed to just street projects.
John Lippitt, Director of Public Works, responded that it was time sensitive and funding would be
jeopardized. Funding was for transportation facilities, not operations .funded by gas tax or non-state funds.
Most of those mentioned by the Mayor were funded by gas taxes. .
RESOUTnON 16694 OFFERED BY COUNCLMAN MOORE, reading of the tal was waived, passed and
approved unanimously.
14. RESOLU110N 16695 APPROVING nm l'INAL CHANGE ORDER FOR nm RENOVATION OF
"NORMAN PARK SENIOR CENl'ER.", AlITHORIZlNG nm DIRECl"OR 01' PUBlJC WORKS TO EXECUTE SAID
CHANGE ORDER ON BEHALF 01' nm Cl1Y - Proposed Change Order No. 10 is the final contract change
order with Davidson ConstrUction Co. and includes various revisions, additions to the scope of the project,
and provisions for additional work not defined in the original contract documents. Staff recommends
approval of the resolution. (Director of Public Works)
1S.A. RESOLU110N 16696 INl11AllNG PROCEEDINGS FOR nm FORMATION 01' OPEN SPACE
DISTRlCl" NUMBER TWENTY-FOUR., CANYON VIEW HOMES AND ORDERING nm Cl1Y ENGINEER TO
PREPARE AND FILE REPORT nmREFORE - In order to initiate the proceedings for the formation of open
space districts, the City Engineer must prepare and me a report in accordance with the Streets and Highways
Code. The resolution will begin the process for the formation of the open space district for Canyon View
Homes. Staff recommends approval of the resolutions and set July 21, 1992 at 6:00 p.m. as the date and
time for public hearing. (Director of Public Works)
B. RESOUTnON 166V7 ACCI!PTING REPORT AND DECLARING nm CTY'S 1NTENl10N TO
fSTABlJSH aroLA VISTA OPEN SPACE DISTRICl" NUMBER TWENTY-FOUR AND SETTING nm TIME AND
PLACE FOR HEARING mEREON
16. RESOUTnON 16l!?8 APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT WITIi BASMACYAN-
DARNEIJ., INC. (BOI) TO PREPARE TRAF'FlC SIGNAL PLANS FOR 1-5 AND PALOMAR STREET AND I~
AND OTAY VMlEl ROAD INTERCHANGES AND PROJECl" CONCEPT REPORT FOR 1-805 AND OTAY
VMlEl ROAD INTERCHANGE IMPROVEMENTS - On 10/2/90, Council approved an agreement with BDI
to prepare signal design plans. Additionally, BOI was to prepare a Project Concept Report for the 1-805 and
C}~ I>
..-.. ~.
Minutes
June 30, 1992
Page 2
7. ORDINANCE 2520 ADDING SECTION 19.14.270 TO TIlE CHULA VISTA MUNlCPAL CODE
AOOP11NG PROCEDURES FOR TIlE ENFORCEMENT OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS AND VARlANCIlS
(second readin2 and adoDtionl . The City currently enCorces variances and conditional use permits (CUP's)
through its implied powers to modify and revoke permits or as an express condition of the permit itself. The
ordinance codifies existing procedures and criteria used to enCorce variances and CUP's. Staff recommends
Council place ordinance on second reading and adoption. (City Attorney)
8. ORDINANCE 2521 AMENDING SECTION 12.20 Of TIlE MUNlCPAL CODE REGARDING
IMPOSING A PEE FOR CONSTRUCTION PERMITS ISSUED TO UTIIJ1Y COMPANIES (second readinsr and
adoDtionl . Historically, the City has not charged a fee to utility companies for permits to do work within
the City's rights.of.way. It is the intent of the City to impose a flat fee for each minor permit and full cost
recovery for larger jobs. Staff recommends Council place ordinance on second reading and adoption.
(Director of Public Works)
9. RESOLtmON 16690 APPROVING A MODIPlCATION TO TIlE AGR.EEMENf WITH IEnlI!lU.
MCINTYRE AND ASSOCIATES, PRO.JI!CI' MANAGER AND TIlE BAlDWIN VISTA ASSOCIATES FOR
PROPESSlONAL SERVlCIlS TO ASSIST TIlE CYfAY RANOiTEAM GENERAL MANAGER, AND AUTHORIZING
TIlE MAYOR TO EXECUTE SAID AGREEMENT . The Otay Ranch Project is entering the final processing
phases and additional assistance is needed in specific areas. The request will allocate one additional Lettieri.
Mcintyre & Assoc. staff person to assist in coordination of such projects as the General Development Plan
text, Sphere of Influence Study, an the Public Participation Program. Staff recommends approval of the
resolution. (Deputy City Manager Krempl)
10. RESOLUTION 16691 APPROVING A REVISION Of A THREE PARTY AGREEMENT FOR CYfAY
RANOi DEVELOPMENT PROCIlSSING BETWEEN TIlE CTY OF CHULA VISTA, ROBERT BEIN, WIWAM
PROST AND ASSOCIATES, AND BAlDWIN VISTA ASSOCIATES, LP., AND AUTHORIZING TIlE MAYOR TO
EXECUTE SAID AGREEMENT. Additional development processing work is being requested of Robert Bein,
William Frost and Associated (RBP) over and above the original scope.of.work for the Otay Ranch Project.
Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Deputy City Manager Krempl)
C-ity Attorney Boogaard referred to a memorandum distributed to Council indicating a recalculation of the
security in the model homes to secure the RBF payment from Baldwin. He felt it was still adequate at
$660,000.
11. RESOLUTION 16692 ACCEP11NG CONTRACl" WORK, TRAPPlC SIGNAL MODIFICATION AND
UPGRADE (FISCAL YEAR 1991/92) AT VARIOUS LOCATIONS IN ntE CTY OF CHULA VISTA AND
APPROPRIATING FUNDS nmREPORE . On 2/12/92, Council awarded a contract in the amount of $82,400
(including contingencies) for the modification and upgrade of traffic signals at various locations in the City.
The contract was awarded to Knox Electric, Inc. The work is now completed. Staff recommends approval
of the resolution. (Director of Public Works) 4/5th's vote required.
12. RESOLUTION 16693 ACCEPTING BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACl" FOR CONSTRUCTION OF
MAIN STREET WIDENING PROM INDUSTRIAL BOUI..IWARD TO INTERSTATE PIVE . On 6/10192, bids were
received for the 'Main Street Widening Project from Industrial Boulevard to Interstate 5'. The project is
funded by Transnet and is intended to improve the drainage system, traffic flow, and safety by widening and
improving the northerly pottion of Main Street. Staff recommends approval of the resolution and award
9-/~
...
.
.
.
CHANGE IN CONTRACT
ORDER NO: 6
DATE: 8/14/94
FILE: AX-099
CONTRACT:
MAIN STREET WIDENING FROM INDUSTRIAL BOULEVARD
TO INTERSTATE 5, IN THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CA
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
CONTRACTOR:
The following changes shall be made to increase the contract
dated June 10, 1992, between the City of Chula Vista and GRANITE
CONSTRUCTION COMPANY.
REMARKS AND DETAILS:
The agreed lump sum price given is considered to be full
compensation for all delays, lost productivity and work completed
by Granite Construction associated with their claim dated 7/21/93.
Total agreed price: $42,000.00.
Granite Construction also agrees not to challenge the City's
liquidated damages in the amount of $27,500.00.
ORIGINAL CONTRACT PRICE:
PREVIOUS CHANGE ORDERS:
THIS CHANGE ORDER:
REVISED TOTAL CONTRACT PRICE:
$ 341,381.00
$ 21,233.32
$ 42,000 00
$ 404,614.32
It is agreed by the undersigned that all extra work shall be
performed and materials furnished in accordance with the original
contract and in accordance with the statement, if any, attached
hereto.
John P. Lippitt
DIRECTOR OF
PUBLIC WORKS
BY
APPROVED
CO.
ord L. Swanson
P. DIR. OF
PUBLIC WORKS/
CITY ENGINEER
(CAANITE CONST ,CQ,1It6.fAX-099,CIC)
APPROVED BY COUNCIL RESOLUTION:
Elh.I'b,'+- 13
9-17
SUMMARY OF COSTS - CLAIM TOTAL ---r
SCHEDULE A $1 .401 .50
SCHEDULE B $4,002.98
SCHEDULE C $6.233.88
SCHEDULE D $1,502.56
SCHEDULE E $25,133.41,
SCHEDULE F $59,967.53
" SCHEDULE G _ $6.500.00 ~
,
I TOTAL- - - - - - - > > > $104,741.851
-...-.....-
E 'f-h\ ~\-\ L-
9--1 Y
Contract No.:
Job No.: 26-085
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
STATE OFCAUPORNlA CONTRAcrOR'S UCBNSB NO. 89
MAIN STREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA, CA
SCHEDULE A
Date Performed 09/03/92 ceo NO.
Date of Report 01/11/93 Report No.
1
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: ENCOUNTERED COX CABLE CONDUIJ" FOUND IN WAY OF PIPE PLACEMEN1
CONDUIT WAS CRACKED, BUT NO DAMAGE TO CABLE; WAITING FOR CREW TO REPAIR
HRLY XTNDED HRLY XTNDED
EQUIPMENT HRS RATE AMOUNT LABOR HRS RATE AMOUNT
PICKUP 3.00 $7.00 $21 .00 FOREMAN 3.00 $32.60 $97.80
PICKUP 3.00 $7.00 $21 .00 LBR FOREMAN 3.00 $32.60 $97.80
966 LOADER 3.00 $85.00 $255.00 OPERATOR 3.00 $31 .48 $94.44
FLATRACK 3.00 $12.00 $36.00 PIPELAYER 3.00 $24.75 $74.25
446 BACKHOE 3.00 $32.00 $96.00 OPERATOR 3.00 $31 .48 $94.44
$0.00 LABORER 3.00 $24.45 $73.35
$0.00 FLAGGERS (3) 3.00 $24.45 $73.35
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
~ sO.OO sO.OO
!lag.OO; I SUBTOTAL ';/$605.431
DESCRIPTION NO. COST EXT Burden 25.00% $151.36
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
~o.oo
I SUBTOTAL .H'H$OjX\1 TOTAL COST OF LABOR A ~50.19
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL --------------------> 8 ">;$42900
... ...,...,..!
(A) ,,,:-,,,",,,..,..,., ".,.,
% ON LABOR ,-.-.-.,.,..,.'"
20.00% .
,.".., .'. ,
." ,. '" ....
% ON EQ & MTL 15.00% (8)
CONTRATOR'S RBPRESENTATIVB TOTAL THIS REPORT ~,~t ::;~
9~,1'
"
,,'
~/ .;'J
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
STATE OPC'ALIFORNlA CONTRACTOR'S UCENSE NO. 89
MAIN SlREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA. CA
SCHEDULE B
Cootract No.:
.Job No.: 26-085
Date Performed 09/04/92 CCO NO.
Date of Report 01/11/93 Report No.
2
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: STOPPED PLACEMENT OF 33" RCP DUE TO SDG&E CONDUIT WHICH HAD
BEEN LOWERED, BUT NOT ENOUGH; ALSO FOUND BUST IN ALIGNMENT OF RCP TO B-1 INLET
! HRLY !XTNDED
I HRS RATE I AMOUNT LABOR
8 $7.00 $56.00 FOREMAN
8 $7.00 $56.00 LBR FOREMAN I
I 8 $32.00 $256.00 I OPERATOR
I 8 $85.00 I $680.00 OPERATOR
8 $12.00 $96.00 PIPELAYER
8 $22.00 $176.00 TEAMSTER
$0.00 LABORER
$0.00
$0.00
$0.0(2
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
SO.OO
$1'320.00 I SUBTOTAL _
EXT
$50.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
SO.OO
I SUBTOTAL "'i'~.Q21 TOTAL COST OF LABOR i
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL --------------------> !
% ON LABOR 20.00%
I % ON EQ & MTL 15.00%
I-TOTAL niTS REPORT
EQUIPMENT
PICKUP
PICKUP
446 BACKHOE
966E LOADER
FLAlRACK
TEN WHEELER
+-
~V~
DESCRIPTION
COLD MIX
NO. COST
2 $25.00
CONTRATOR'S REPRESENTATIVE
I
I
I
HRL Y XTNDED
HRS ,RATE AMOUNT
8.00 $32.60 $260.80
8.00 $30.60 $244.80
8.00 $31.48 $251.84
8.00 $31 48 $251.84
8.00 $24.75 $198.00
8.00 I $26.93 $215.44
8.00 $24.45 $195.60
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
'1.018.321
$404.58
Burden 25.00%
A
8
(A)
(8)
'$.~.bc""".''''''.
.':0'.'22<.:.0
. ,I. ,.
$V~70;QO
':$404.18
..:i.....,.,......
--
q ':LP
Contract No.:
Job No.: 26-085
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
STATE OPCALIFORNIA CONTRACl'OR'S UCIlNSB NO. 89
MAIN STREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA, CA
SCHEDULE C - PAGE 1
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: MAINTENANCE WHICH WAS FORCED TO BE COMPLETED WHICH WOULD
HAVE NOT BEEN REQUIRED DUE TO CONTRACT COMPLETION
Date Performed VARIES CCO NO.
Date of Repoct 01/11/93 Report No.
3
HRLY XTNt)EO I IHRLY XTNOEO --
EQUIPMENT HRS RATE AMOUNT LABOR HRS RATE AMOUNT
DEC4 -
$0.00 . $0.00
PICKUP 4.00 $7.00 $28.00 FOREMAN 4.00 $32.60 $130.40
DEC8 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 2.00 $7.00 $14.00 FOREMAN 2.00 $32.60 $65.20
DEC 11 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 3.00 $7.00 $21 .00 LBR FOREMAN 3.00 $25.60 $76.80
PICKUP 3.00 $7.001 $21 .00 LABORER 3.00 $24.45 $73.35
$0.00 LABORER 2.00 $24.45 $48.90
~ANSFER 13.Q~ $28.00 $84.00 TEAMSTER 3.00 $26.93 $80.79
DEC 18 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 2.00 $7.00 $14.00 FOREMAN 2.00 ,$32.60 $65.20
DEC 28 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 4.00 $7.00 $28.00 FOREMAN 4.00 $32.60 $130.40
DEC 31 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 8.00 $7.00 $56.00 FOREMAN 8.00 $32.60 $260.80
FLA TRACK 8.00 510.00 =- LABORER 8.00 $25.60 ~204.80
MA~ ' . , ' . . , : . I SUBTOTAL $1"3$.$41
-_.- I
DESCRIPTION NO. COST EXT Burden 25.00% $284.1 6
PENHALL JD71 0 12/4 1 $367.50 $367.50
AC (12/8) 4 $25.00 $100.00
1 "FDN112!31) 24.4 $8.54 $208.72
PLANT MIX (1/12/93) 5.03 $24.00 $120.72
$0.00
~O.OO
I SUBTOTAL ':$?NiMI TOTAL COST OF LABOR A 'j[':""":'.""'"
. 1420.80
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL --------------------> 8 1]1' '42"94
,.hl,..;,.,
% ON LABOR 20.00% (A) "":":sa4,;1~
% ON EQ & MTL 15.00% (8) $lIfi14
,.,-,- ......
...,_,_ on .... .
:,,), ,"".:" ,I, "n"
I TOTAL THIS REPORT iII-'"
CONTRATOR'S REPRESENTATIVE ~"!: ,', ,:;
q,;./
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Contract No.:
lob No.: 26-065
STATE OFCAUPORNIA CONTRACrOR'S UCBNSB NO. 89
MAIN STREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA, CA
SCHEDULE C - PAGE 2
Date Performed VARIES ceo NO.
Date of Report 01/11/93 Report No.
4
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: MAINTENANCE WHICH WAS FORCED TO BE COMPLETED WHICH WOULD
HAVE NOT BEEN REQUIRED DUE TO CONTRACT COMPLETION
HRLY XTNDED 1 -"--- ---.-- I HRLY XTNDED --
EQUIPMENT HRS RATE AMOUNT LABOR HRS IRATE AMOUNT
JAN 4, 1993 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 2.00 $7.00 $14.00 FOREMAN 2.00 $32.60 $65.20
..
JAN 6, 1993 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 4.00 $7.00 $28.00 FOREMAN 4.00 $32.60 $130.40
JAN 7,1993 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 6.00 $7.00 $42.00 FOREMAN 6.00 $32.60 $195.60
JAN 8.1993 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 4.00 $7.00 $28.00 FOREMAN 4.00 $32.60 $130.40
JAN 11,1993 $0.00 -'$32.60 $0.00
PICKUP 2.00 $7.00 $14.00 FOREMAN 2.00 $65.20
JAN 12, 1993 $0.00 $0.00
PICKUP 4.00 $7.00 $28.00 FOREMAN 4.00 $32 .60 $130.40
BOBTAIL 6.00 $22.00 $132.00 TEAMSTER 6.00 $26.93 $161.58
JAN 13-15, 1993 $0.00 I $0.00
PICKUP 5.00 $7.00 $35.00 FOREMAN 5.00 $32.60 $163.00
SU~AL . . SO.OO
. .... '. '. '1 SUBTOTAL '$1.041:;;;11
DESCRIPTION NO. COST EXT Burden 25.00% $260.45
TOILET 101 $2.50 $252.50
FENCE 101 $2.90 $292.90
TRAFFIC CONTROL 101 $4.00 $404.00
ALLIED BARRICADE 1 $166.00 $166.00
$0.00
so.oo
$111:5.40 A ..$:.......... .
SUBTOTAL TOTAL COST QF LABOR '1.302'.23
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL I 8 $143&.4<)
--------------------> i .."". ',.:,;;,.
- .. -.-----T % ON LABOR (A) S2~4S
20.00% ;,";:::::- ",' :~.:, :.
..., n. ..
% ON EQ & MTL 15.00% (8) \tii~~'=1
OONTRATOR'S REPRBSBNTATIVE TOTAL THIS REPORT
9'.)'--.
"
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Contract No.:
Job No.: 26-085
STATBOPCAUFORNIA OONTRACI'OR'S UCENSE NO, 89
MAIN STREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA, CA
SCHEDULE D
Date Perfocmed 10/16/92 ceo NO.
Date of Report 01/11/93 Report No.
5
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: ENCOUNTERED SEWER CLEANOUT IN GRADE OF STORM DRAIN. FORCED
TO POUR LUG; HAD TO CUT A 12' SECTION OF 33"RCP IN HALF IN ORDER TO HIT INLET
HRLY XTNDED IHRLY XTNDED
EQUIPMENT HRS RATE AMOUNT LABOR HRS iRATE AMOUNT
PICKUP 3 $7.00 $21 .00 FOREMAN 3.00 $32.60 $97.80
PICKUP 3 $7.00 $21 ,00 LBR FOREMAN 3.00 $30.60 $91 .80
446 BACKHOE 3 $32.00 $96.00 OPERATOR 3.00 $31 .48 $94.44
1950 LOADER 3 $75.00 $225.00 OPERATOR 3.00 $31 .48 $94.44
FLATRACK 3 $12.00 $36.00 PIPELAYER 3.00 $24.75 $74.25
TEN WHEELER 3 $22.00 I $66.00 TEAMSTER + 3.00 $26.93 $80.79
$0.00 LABORER 3.00 $24.45 $73.35
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
$0.00 $0.00
SO.OO SO.OO
~ '405,00' I SUBTOTAL """"""',$600,&7'1
DESCRIPTION NO. COST EXT Burden 25.00% $151.72
SACK PCC 1 $50.00 $50.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
I SUBTOTAL '''''$9Q.QQI TOTAL COST OF LABOR A ,~
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - > B $!S16.()()
% ON LABOR 20.00% (A) ":"$1051':;72
(B) ,.......".,.............,.......".
"................,..........-..,..",
% ON EQ & MTL 15.00% -
---
CONTRATOR'S REPRESENTATIVE TOTAL THIS REPORT
9",2 J"
,
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
STATBOPCALIFORNIA <X>NTRACfOR:S UCBNSBNO. 89
MAIN STREET WIDENING - CHULA VISTA. CA
SCHEDULE E
Call1'act No.:
Job No.: 26-085
Date Performed VARIES ceo NO.
Date of Report 01/11/93 Report No.
6
Work Performed by: Granite Construction Company
Description of Work: ALL 33' RCP PLACEMENT FIGURED AT FORCE ACCOUNT LESS CREDIT
FOR BID COSTS - THIS EQUALS TOTAL ADDITIONAL AMOUNT
XTNDED
AMOUNT
$0.00
$0.00 FORCE ACCNT.
$0.00 BID AMOUNT
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
0.00
...,.... 0,00 [SUBTOTAL
EXT
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
!to.oo
.
I SUBTOTAL:~ TOTAL COST OF LABOR
TOTAL COST OF EQUIP & MTRL - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - >
% ON LABOR 0.00%
% ON EQ & MTL 0.00%
TOTAL THIS REPORT
EQUIPMENT
HRLY
HRS RATE
~AI
DESCRIPTION
NO. COST
CONTRATOR:S REPRESENTATIVE
LABOR
HRLY
HRS RATE
Burden
0.00%
'1,;.lj
A
B
(A)
(B)
XTNDED
AMOUNT
$0.00
$97,271.41
11$72,138.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
!to.OO
{25,13a.41!
,
$0.00
~.'.".;;'.'.'.'i'.'.""""'."'.''''.'.'.'''.
~5 133.41
..... ........$Qoo
. .,.'" ,.., .,-, . ' .
....".., '" ...
......,......... .....
....". .
'-'-'-. .'
....,- ",...'.'"''
...,..........."."..,..........
""",'$O,Qo
SCHEDULE F
GRANITE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
BASIC OVERHEAD RATES
BASED ON YIE 12/31/92 CALCULATIONS AND AUDIT
SAN DIEGO BRANCH OVERHEAD
ADMINISTRATION OVERHEAD
BRANCH ADMINISTRATION
EQUIPMENT ADMINISTRATION
ADMINISTRATION
TOTAL ADMINISTRATIVE OVERHEAD
TOTAL OVERHEAD
JOB COST
JOB OVERHEAD COSTS
OVERHEAD PER DAY ~WORKiNG DAYS) .
DAYS DELAYED
ADDITIONAL OVERHEAD DUE TO DELAYS
11.83%
0.31%
0.24%
3.25%
3.80%
...... U'''1jiiH~.""",,,. ..'::.'..'.
:,,,:::.;~~iiijI~'1
$306,823.00
$47,342.79
$631.24
J.0f
$60,754.961
Cf ".2. b
_..,-~~-
I
/'
,
I
.,
i
,.
I'
i
SCHEDULE G
DISPUTED WORKING DAYS
9 WORKING DAYS
13 CHARGED UQUIDATED DAMAGES DAYS
CITY COMPLETION DATE: APRIL 14. 1993
GRANITE COMPLETION DATE: ,APRIL 27, 1993
13 DAYS
$1500.00 PER DAY
$6,500.00 TOTAL UQUIDATED DAMAGES IN DISPUTE
9"~ t
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item Id
Meeting Date 10/11/94
ITEM TITLE: 11. Report: Consideration of request for waiver of conducting authority (City
Council) proceedings for the pending "Tibbett Reorganization", Bonita
Car Wash project, 3048 Bonita Rd.- LAFCO and Charles Tibbett,
applicant.
)7"'9'''
lJ. Resolution granting consent to the waiver and authorizing the City
Manager to sign the associated LAFCO form.
SUBMITTED BY: Director of Planning ~.{(
REVIEWED BY: City ManageU~ ~ ~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes_ No..xJ
On July 12, 1994, the City Council approved a General Plan Amendment and Prezoning to allow
for construction of a car wash at the southwest comer of Bonita Rd. and Lynwood Dr The site
is presently in the unincorporated county, and annexation is necessary to facilitate extension of
City sewers to serve the project (please refer to Attachment A) The applicant is presently
proceeding with annexation through LAFCO.
Changes in State law brought about by AB 1335, and effective January 1 ,1994, provide that
LAFCO may waive conducting authority (City Council) proceedings for a change of organization
or reorganization when certain conditions exist. As stated in their September 2, 1994, letter
(Attachment B), LAFCO has determined those conditions exist for the subject reorganization,
and that conducting authority proceedings will be waived. Council must now grant its consent
for the waiver to occur
RECOMMENDATION: That Council:
1. Adopt the attached resolution consenting to the waiver and authorizing the City Manager
to sign the LAFCO consent form contained in Attachment B; and,
2. Direct staff to formulate and return with a Council Policy to establish a standard
procedure for considering future such requests.
BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable.
IP/J"/
Page 2, Item / IJ
Meeting Date 10/11/94
DISCUSSION:
Background
Major changes were made to the Cortese/Knox Local Government Reorganization Act in 1993,
through the enactment of AB 1335. The Cortese/Knox Act provides authoritative and operating
frameworks for the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO). Staff previously apprised
Council on the potential local implications of AB 1335, and a copy of that 12/8/93 Information
Memo is contained in Attachment D
One of AB 1335's changes is the establishment methods to streamline the conducting authority
proceedings for changes of organization or reorganization. When territory is to be annexed to
Chula Vista, "conducting authority proceedings" refers to the City Council's hearing process to
consider and act on the proposal after it has been acted upon by LAFCO
The noted provisions for streamlining involve waiving the conducting authority proceedings
entirely, and thereby allowing LAFCO's action to approve and order the change of organization
or reorganization. To avoid complications when proposals may involve intricate issues, and it
is thereby necessary and/or desirable for the City Council to also consider the proposal, waivers
under AB 1335 may only be considered when all of the following conditions are present:
(1) the subject area is uninhabited (less than 12 registered voters),
(2) all owners of land within the affected territory have given their written consent, and
(3) all annexing agencies have given their written consent to the waiver.
The rationale behind these conditions is that they are reflective of non-complicated, non-
controversial proposals where lands are vacant, and involved parties are all in agreement and
consenting to the proposed reorganization. In such circumstances, LAFCO and the City
(conducting authority) are typically not required to hold public hearings, and the proposal is
acted upon as a consent calendar item. As alluded to in the applicant's letter (Attachment B),
when proposals meet the criteria for consideration as consent items, their processing before the
City Council (conducting authority) is essentially a matter of formality which has proven to be
cumbersome, repetitious and time consuming. Therefore, in the spirit of streamlining, LAFCO
procedures now provide for the noted waiver for proposals where review by the conducting
authority is not materially necessary
It should be noted that such waivers do not lessen, jeopardize or otherwise negatively impact the
review process, or public and/or agency input, but rather solely provide that the formal review
and approval process will reside with LAFCO
/IJ/)'.;J..
Page 3, Item I P
Meeting Date 10/11/94
"Tibbett Reorganization" Reauest
As mentioned earlier, LAFCO has taken the above factors into consideration for the proposed
"Tibbett Reorganization", and as a result, has determined that conducting authority proceedings
can be waived since the proposal meets all three criteria. In addition to the proposal meeting
all the waiver criteria, City staff is in agreement with LAFCO's determination given the
following:
. Processing of the GP A, prezone and project proposal was relatively non-
controversial, except for some concerns regarding existing traffic conditions at the
intersection of Bonita Rd. and Plaza Bonita Rd. Those concerns were
satisfactorily resolved through the traffic study and public hearing process. The
project received the support of the Sweetwater Community Planning Group.
. The proposal falls under the auspices of the existing Master Property Tax
Transfer Agreement (MPTTA) with the County, and further specialized forms of
revenue negotiation are not necessary. In addition to the MPTTA, the City has
a standing agreement with the Bonita Sunnyside Fire Protection District which
amortizes their revenue loss as a result of reorganizations over a ten-year period.
. City staff has worked with County staff in the development of the proposed
annexation boundaries as they related to Bonita Rd., Plaza Bonita Rd., and
Lynwood Dr., and both agencies have reached concurrence.
. There are no other known or perceived circumstances or issues which would
materially affect the proposal, and for which conducting authority proceedings by
the Council would be warranted.
Furthermore, and as presented in the September 9, 1994 letter from Cox and Associates on the
applicant's behalf (Attachment C), granting the waiver will save considerable time and money
for the applicant. Typically, 2 to 3 months are involved in completing the conducting authority
phase and related filings, all of which must be completed before building permits can be issued.
Although the letter originally stressed meeting an October 3 LAFCO consideration date, for a
variety of reasons that date is now November 11, 1994. The applicant is aware, and is in
agreement with this. Regardless, granting the waiver will still shorten the annexation process
by 2 to 3 months.
ProDosed Council Policv Formulation
In order to address such requests for waivers in the future, staff proposes to develop a Council
Policy Preparation of such a policy in conjunction with the Tibbett proposal was not feasible
given timetables, workloads, and the need to consult with LAFCO since the waiver process is
still in its infancy, having only become effective July 1, 1994 In fact, the Tibbett
/IlA'3
(
Page 4, Item / p
Meeting Date 10/11/94
Reorganization will be the first waiver considered by the San Diego LAFCO under the new
legislation.
Toward developing a Policy for consistently handling future such requests, staff is proposing to
keep the spirit of streamlining, and to focus on coordinating consideration of waivers as part of
the review and public hearing process for prezoning.
The prezoning process represents one of the first and most significant roles of the City in the
annexation / reorganization process. Typically, applicants are presenting a project in order to
support the request for prezoning, and the ultimate annexation of the project site to the City
Given this, the City is typically conducting project-level environmental evaluation and review
at the time of prezoning, and is aware of the full range of issues surrounding the proposal and
their relative bearing on the annexation / reorganization process, including whether the proposal
will meet with LAFCO's criteria for waiver. Furthermore, the prezoning process requires a
public hearing, and thereby offers opportunity for the Council, public and other interested parties
to openly discuss any annexation / reorganization concerns, and whether a conducting authority
proceedings waiver is appropriate. Council action on the waiver of proceedings as part of the
prezoning process will avoid the necessity to separately docket the waiver for Council
consideration, thereby enhancing the goal of streamlining not only for the overall annexation
process, but for the waiver process itself.
Staff is asking for Council authorization to proceed with formulation of such a policy to be
returned in the near future for Council action.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. The applicant is reimbursing staff time for reorganization processing
through a deposit account.
.
Attachments:
A. Locator Map I /
B. LAFCO letter and consent form
C. Leller from Cox & Associates NOT SCANNED
D. 12/8/93 Council Info Memo .NOT SCANNED
M:\home\planning\tibbett.A13
IdA''! /;0/1-5
PROPOSED "TIBBETT RE RGANIZATION"
"
,
;-
;-
....'
./
,,-
./
./
./
~il--
-
-
..........
.....
I
-_ I
-
-....J
..,
ATTACHMENT A
""""I
CHULA VISTA PLANNING DEPARTMENT
C) APPLICANT: Charles Tibbit PROJECT DESCRIPTION:
CPA_Amend from ~ &: I'Hldl!lltlat to
ADDRESS SW eomer of Bonita Rd. f'ftIftmerclal
and L)'JlWood Dr. PCz...Premne to CVP. Cnmlllerclat Vlaltor
SCALE: FJ;,#, N~'~S: pee .. CoaditlonaJ Ute Permit to "Derate ·
1" = 100' A-9 1. Cz,,94-B fuD tervk:e earwub.
NORTH PCC-94-13
/()A...." //011-1
'LAFCO
1600 Pacific Highway' Room 452
San Diego, CA 92101 · (619) 531-5400
San Diego Local Agency Formation Commission
September 2, 1994
: ~.
\....:
Chairperson
Dr. Wlllan M. Child.
Helix Water C1str1ct
Members
C1anne Jacob
County Boord af
Supervisors
Ed Batchelder
Planning Department
City of Chula Vista
P. O. Box 1087
Chula Vista, California 91912
John MacDonald
County Board of
Supervisors
Subject: Proposed "Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29)
Leonard M. Moore
Councllmember, City of
Chula Vista
Alternate Members
Brian P Bllbray
County Board of
Supervisors
Effective January 1, 1994, LAFCO may waive conducting authority
proceedings for a change of organization or reorganization if all the
following conditions apply: (1) the subject area is uninhabited (less than
12 registered voters), (2) all owners of land within the affected territory
have given their written consent, and (3) all annexing agencies have
given written consent to the waiver (Government Code Section 56837
(c)). If conducting authority proceedings are waived, LAFCO's
resolution would simultaneously approve and order the change of
organization or reorganization, be recorded, and be filed with the
Assessor and the State Board of Equalization. Certification of terms and
conditions will be the responsibility of the subject agency or agencies.
Collection of the State Board of Equalization fee and submittal of city
annexation documents required by the State Board would remain the
responsibility of the annexing agency.
Joan Shoemaker
Mayor, City of
E1 Cajon
George Stevens
Deputy Mayor, City of
San Diego
JohnSaaso
President, Borrego
Water C1str1ct
Or. Unell Fromm
Public Member
Julianne Nygaard
Councllmember, City of
Carlsbad
After review, it has been decided that conducting authority proceedings
will be waived for the above-referenced proposal. If you concur with this
decision, please complete and return the attached consent form. Please
call the analyst named below if you have any questions.
Juan VllIllas
Councllmember, CIty of
San C1ego
Ronald W. Wootton
Vista Rre Protecllon C1strlct
MICHAEL D. orr
Executive Officer
MDO:na
David A. Porkln.
Public Member
executive Officer
Michael O. OIl
By: Shirley Whaley
Local Governmental Analyst
Counsel
UOyd M. Harmon, Jr.
/p/I..r
CONSENT TO WAIVER OF
CONDUCTING AUTHORITY PROCEEDINGS
Proposed "Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29)
The City of Chula Vista is an affected agency that will gain territory as a result of the
above-referenced change of organization or reorganization, and hereby consents to a
waiver of the conducting authority proceedings.
Authorized Signature
Title
Date:
1&/1- ,
ATTACHMENT C
)~/1 '/0
Cox & Associates
3130 Bonita Road, Suite 200, Chula Vista, CA 91910-3263
(619) 585.7007 Fax (619) 691.9854
September 9, 1994
Mr. Robert A. Leiter
Director of Planning
City of Chula Vista
276 Fourth Avenue
Chula Vista, CA 91910
SEP (\ 9 1S':',
rv ,"
c..
,
..; '~ ~
Dear Mr. Leiter,
On behalf of the Bonita Carwash, represented by Charles Tibbett and Paul
Magnotto, I would like your help in scheduling City Council action on' waiving
the City Council's final Conducting Authority Proceedings on the "Tibbett
Reorganization." I understand that the City of Chula Vista is developing a policy
that would allow the City routinely to waive their opportunity to give a final
decision on annexation in favor of LAFCO making the final decision. I also
understand that this policy may be some weeks away from being scheduled for
Council consideration.
Shirley Whaley, the LAFCO staff member working on the "Tibbett
Reorganization," is willing to schedule this item for their October 3rd meeting
contingent upon receiving the "Waiver of Conducting Authority Proceedings"
from the City of Chula Vista prior to the beginning of the LAFCO meeting. The
rationale for this request to have the City Council consider waiving final
Conducting Authority Proceedings is predicated on the following:
. The Bonita Carwash has worked with City of Chula Vista
staff since November 1993;
. The proponents of this project have invested over $ 625,000 in
land acquisition, processing fees, and required
environmental, architectural, and traffic studies;
. Carrying costs on this project are over $15,000 per month;
. This project has already been reviewed and approved by the
Design Review Board, Planning Commission, and City
Council; and
. The City Council and stafTwill have an additional opportunity
to review this project when the Conditional Use Permit is filed
for City review.
Current requirements forcing an applicant to receive Council approval on a
prezone, approach LAFCO for approval of annexation, then return to the City for
final approval is cumbersome, repetitious, and time consuming. A recent
change in State law allows final review by the annexing agency to be waived.
I~/I '1/
If this 'Waiver" is not approved by the September 27 City Council meeting, the
reorganization proposal will be delayed at LAFCO until at least November 4 or
later. This process has been long, arduous, and expensive for Mr. Tibbett and Mr.
Magnotto. Your cooperation in scheduling Council action on the "Waiver" by
September 27 is appreciated.
Sincerely,
G~l Cr
copy to:
John Goss
Ed Batchelder
Charles Tibbett
Paul Magnotto
1"/1.1:1..
ATTACHMENT D
J()/I~/:J
COUNCn. INFORMATION MEMO
December 8, 1993
TO: The Honorable Mayor and City Council
VIA: John Goss, City Manager
FROM: Robert A. Leiter, Director of Planning ~
SUBJECT: Impacts - AB 1335, Out-of-Agency Service Agreement Review Procedures for
LAFCO
Pursuant to Council request, the following discussions provide a brief overview of the above
legislation's potential impacts on the City. Although lengthy and involved, AB 1335 is
essentially comprised of two major components establishing new LAFCO authority and review
procedures:
Out-or-A,encv Service Agreements - (effective January I, 1994)
AB 1335 specifies that a city or district may provide new or extended services by contract or
agreement outside its boundaries, only if it requests and receives written approval from LAFCO.
The affected territory must be within the agency's sphere of influence, and the extension of the
service must be in anticipation of a later change of organization (such as annexation).
Exceptions to this new provision are (1) contracts or agreements between two or more public
agencies, (2) contracts for the transfer of nonpotable or nontreated water, and (3) contracts or
agreements solely involving the provision of surplus water to agricultural1ands for conservation
purposes or to directly support agricultural industries. However, extending surplus water to
support or induce development will require the extendi'1g agellCy to receive advance written
approval from LAFCO.
LAFCO procedures to implement the new provisions are also established, along with new fees.
The procedures add new paperwork and a LAFCO Board consideration. The new fees amount
to a 30% surcharge on the associated annexationldetatchment application, and are born by the
applicant.
E...."'Plcs of situations which would and would not impact the City are:
sewer service extensions to private plopertics under existing Council Policy
570-02, where annexation is not a concurrent requirement, would be affected.
Advance authorization would be needed from LAFCO, and the property owner
would pay the additional 30% surcharge.
)tJ~ ,/ t/
The Honorable Mayor
and City Council
-2-
December 8, 1993
In cases of demonstrated public health, safety or welfare impacts (failing septic),
LAFCO's Executive Officer may administratively approve the out-of-agency
agreement, thereby stteamlining the process.
Any other agreements/contracts for sewer service in the greater Bonita area
between the City and the Spring Valley Sanitation District meet the public agency
exemption.
automatic aid agreements for police and fire service would not be affected as they
involve two or more public agencies, and therefore meet the exemption.
services such as animal control do not entai1 future changes of organization (i.e.
a service district does not have to be formed, etc.) and fall outside the scope of
the legislation.
Beyond these examples, historically, the City has not provided other services outside its
municipal boundary, nor outside our sphere of influence, that would be impacted by the
legislation.
~ew LAFCO InItiatorv Authoritv - Effective July I, 1994
AB 1335 also creates new LAFCO authority to initiate proceedings regarding independent special
districts including consolidations, dissolutions, mergers, or establishment of subsidiary districts.
The new initiatory powers also apply to reorganizations that include any of these changes of
organization. LAFCO's initiation may only occur, however, subsequent to and consistent with
the recommendation / conclusions of a study. Furthermore, any alternate proposal submitted
which could affect LAFCO's special district proposal, must flJ'St be considered.
It is unlikely that these provisions will impact Chula Vista in that the only such districts that
exist within our planning Area are the two water districts, and the Spring Valley Sanitation
District which was discussed in the previous section.
Additionally, as the provisions are not effective for another six months, LAFCO staff is still in
the process of reviewing this part of the legislation in esta\l1i~hing an implementation plan. The
City will therefore be afforded an oppor1Unity for further review OIICC that implementation plan
is drafted, likely in April-May 1994.
Other
AB 1335 also provides that where a subject area is uninhabited, all owners within the area have
consented to the organizational changes, and the affected agencies that will gain territory as a
/0/1-/.->'
.
The Honorable Mayor
and City Council
-3-
December 8, 1993
result of the proposed change of organization or reorganization have also consented, that the
'conducting authority" (in our case the City Council) proceMings may be waived by LAFCO.
Many of the annexations / reorganizations which the City processes could meet these criteria.
A3 a result, the overall process could be streamlined without impact; typically the conducting
authority proceedings are entirely procedural in nature and require a considerable amount of
staff/applicant time in processing paperwork.
f:onclusions
A3 the full legislative provisions do not become effective until July 1994, LAFCO staff is still
in the process of conducting an extensive review, and in devising a comprehensive
implementation plan(s). A3 such, the procedures adopted for the out-of-agency service
agreements are interim, and subject to change when a comprehensive plan is presented in June-
July.
Therefore, should the Council have additional concerns or questions, opportunity will be present
to more fully address those concerns over the next several months, prior to LAFCO's adoption
of comprehensive implementation provisions in July 1994.
(ob1335cc.iIlf)
J~/I 'l "
RESOLUTION NO. I '1~ g't
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
CONSENTING TO THE WAIVER OF CONDUCTING AUTHORITY PROCEEDINGS
FOR THE PROPOSED "TIBBETT REORGANIZATION" (R094-29)
WHEREAS, on July 1, 1994, certain provisions of AB 1335 regarding the
authority of Local Agency Formation Conunission (LAFCO) in the conduct of processing
requests for changes of organization or reorganizations became effective; and,
WHEREAS, one of those provisions provides that LAFCO may waive conducting
authority proceedings for a change of organization or reorganization if all of the following
conditions apply: (1) the subject area is uninhabited (less than 12 registered voters), (2) all
owners of land within the affected territory have given their written consent, and, (3) all
annexing agencies have given their written consent to the waiver; and,
WHEREAS, by their letter of September 2, 1994, LAFCO has determined that
said conditions exist for the proposed "Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29), and that conducting
authority proceedings will be waived pending the City's concurrence to such waiver; and,
WHEREAS, on October 11, 1994, the City Council considered such waiver.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the City Council of the City
of Chula Vista does hereby fmd, determine, resolve and order as follows:
1. That the City Council concurs with the determinations of LAFCO in this instance, and
grants its consent to the waiver of conducting authority proceedings for the proposed
"Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29)
2. That the City Manager is authorized to sign the related LAFCO consent form attached
hereto as Exhibit A and made a part hereof.
3. That the Planning Director shall provide a certified copy of this resolution, including
Exhibit A, to LAFCO and the applicant.
lrr~ J)
Bruce M. Boogaar
City Attorney
Presented by
Robert A. Leiter
Director of Planning
(M:\HOME\PLANNINGlTIBBETI.RSO)
Ipg-j
CONSENT TO WAIVER OF
CONDUCTING AUTHORITY PROCEEDINGS
Proposed "Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29)
The City of Chula Vista is an affected agency that will gain territory as a result of the
above-referenced change of organization or reorganization. and hereby consents to a
waiver of the conducting authority proceedings.
Authorized Signature
Title
Date:
IPB,:J-
EXll181T 'A.
CONSENT TO WAIVER OF
CONDUCTING AUTHORITY PROCEEDINGS
Proposed 'Tibbett Reorganization" (R094-29)
The City of Chula Vista is an affected agency that will gain territory as a result of the
above-referenced change of organization or reorganization, and hereby consents to a
waiver of the conducting authority proceedings.
~JL4--
Authorized Signature
Mayor
Title
Date: October 18, 1994
EXHIBIT A
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item
JI
Meeting Date 10/11/94
SUBMITTED BY:
Report on Pala / Pauma Area Landfill Initiative
Director of Planning 7/J{
Deputy City Manager KfefuPI~
City ManagerJ~ ~ ~
(4/5ths Vote: Yes_No.lO
Council Referral No. 2922
ITEM TITLE:
REVIEWED BY:
On August 10, 1994, Mayor Nader received the attached letter from County Board of
Supervisors Chairwoman Pam Slater, requesting that the City of Chula Vista take a position in
opposition to the Gregory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Collection Center Initiative (see
attached), which is on the November ballot in San Diego County The proposed initiative would
allow "by right" (i.e., without a conditional use permit) a landfill in the Pala/Pauma area of
North San Diego County.
Chairwoman Slater has requested that the City oppose this initiative on the basis that amending
the local General Plan and Zoning Ordinance by initiative is not consistent with the responsibility
of elected officials in making land use decisions, and that circumvention of the conditional use
permit process does not allow for adequate analysis of the potential impacts of such a decision.
RECOMMENDATION: That City Council take no action regarding the request by County
Board Chairwoman Slater to oppose the Gregory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Collection
Center Initiative, and file this report.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable.
DISCUSSION:
In analyzing this request, staff agrees that major facilities such as landfills should be subject to
the conditional use permit process. While the County would still be able to require an
environmental impact report on the project in compliance with the California Environmental
Quality Act, and could impose appropriate mitigation measures on the project to mitigate any
adverse environmental impacts of the project, the conditional use permit process allows a local
government greater flexibility in applying conditions which would regulate the operation of the
facility in order to protect the public, and to require remediation of the site once the landfill is
closed.
However, staff would raise a concern that by taking a position in opposition to the initiative on
the basis that it circumvents the conditional use permit process, this could be construed as taking
II,!
Page 2, Item II
Meeting Date 10/11/94
a position regarding the merits of this particular site as a landfill site. Staff has not analyzed this
issue, and questions whether the City of Chula Vista should be evaluating or taking a position
regarding the merits of any particular landfill site in North County. Furthermore, the City's
position could also be interpreted as somehow being interrelated to its position regarding the
regional solid waste authority; to our knowledge, these issues are totally separate.
Therefore, staff recommends that the City take no position regarding the County initiative on
Gregory Canyon landfill, and that this report be filed.
FISCAL IMPACT: None.
(F: \home\planning\pala.al1)
"
LEn-e/l. 'I
NOTSCANNED
Il).
-
'PAM SLATER
CHAIRWOMAN
SUPERV1$OI, 'HIID OISTltC1
SAN DIEGO COUNTY 10...D Of SUPEIVlSORS
I
August 10, 1994 as ~
-<-<
Tim Nader, Mayor i~ I ~
City of Chula Vista cnP tl !!!
276 4th Avenue
Chula Vista, CA 91910 ~~ ~ ~
~ ..0
RE: GREGORY CANYON LANDnLL AND RECYCUNG COLLECI'I~ (;~TER
INTITlATIVE -
Dear Mayor Nader:
As you may be aware, Servcon-San Marcos, Inc. has qualified an initiative for the Fall ballot
that would amend the County's General Plan and Zoning Ordinance to allow a landfill by
right in the Pala/pauma area of Northern San Diego County.
As Chairwoman of the Board of Supervisors for San Diego County, I ask that your City
Council adopt a resolution in opposition to this initiative. Regardless of the merits of the
proposed project, amending the local General Plan and Zoning Ordinance by initiative to
support a private project is not consistent with our responsibility for land use decisions as
elected officials. This circumvention of the process does Dot provide for adequate analysis
of the potential impacts of such a decision.
I am asking for your support in informing the voters of this County that sucb initiatives
circumvent a process developed specifically to protect the people. 1ban1c you for your
consideration of this issue.
Z~
PAM SLAlER
Chairwoman
PS/JM/jb
-C: Cii~ (t./) WRlnEN COMMUNICATIONS
i.1t~rz--:r~- -r.- /- ?4/9i
. L ~~~%i.c
C' ..' .4~ hr~G. ~:=:'~ji":j-.-
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO
Proposition C
(Thll propolRlon will "_r on thl blllolln thl following form.)
O C GREGORY CANYON lANDFILL AND RECYCLING
COLLECTION CENTER ORDINANCE. Shall the Greg-
P R P ory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Center Initiative
Ordinance be adopted?
NORTH COUNTY RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL INITIATIVE
The People of San Diego County Do Hereby Ordain as Follows:
SECTION 1. INTENT
It is the intent of this initiative measure:
A. To provide for the siting of a new recycling collection center and class III solid waste landfill
to allow the residents and businesses in northern San Diego County to dispose of their solid waste
in an environmentally sound and economically competitive manner.
B. To ensure that the recycling collection center and landfill are designed, constructed, and
operated in a safe and efficient manner by requiring that they fully comply with all environmental
laws and regulations. The Project will be monitored during its life on a regular basis by regulatory
agencies including, but not limited to, the Integrated Waste Management Board, the San Diego
County Air Pollution Control District and the Ragional Water Quality Control Board.
C. To amend the General Plan. Zoning Ordinance and other ordinances and pOlicies of the
County of San Diego to allow the construction and operation of a recycling collection center and
class III solid wasta landfill on approximately 270 acres of land wnhin the 1683 acra Gregory
Canyon sne located off State Route 76 approximately 3 1/2 mllas aast of tha intarsaction of
Interstate 15 and State Route 76 in San Diago County. Tha genarallocalion of the Gregory Canyon
site is shown on Figure 1 attached to this measure.
D. To provide that at least 1313 acres of the Gregory Canyon site will be dedicated as
permanent open space to create a substantiaJ preservation area for sensitive habitat and species.
SECTION 2. FINDINGS AND PURPOSE.
A. Tha San Marcos landfill is tha only remaining landfill serving nOr1ham San Diago County
which includes the cnias of Carisbld, EnclnRaa, Del Mar, Solana Basch, Escondido, Oceansida,
San Marcos and Vista. and the unincorporated areas of northern San Diego County including
Pauma, Bonsall, Valley Center, and Fallbrook.
B. The 1986 San Diego County Ragional Solid Waste Management Plan and studias pariormed
by tha County of San Diago have documented the ",nicsl naed for new solid wasta facUnias to
seNa the growing nOr1h San Diago County population.
C. The County of San Diego has been unsuccessful in siting any landfills in northern San Diego
County since the San Marcos landfill was approved in 19n This has occurred as a result of local
opposition and the County of San Diego not proceeding with acceptable sites which have been
extensively studied.
D. The condnional use perrnn issued in 1992 by the City of San Marcos for expanaion of the
San Marcos landfill requires the County of San Diago to aggressively pursue aRamBliva north
county landfill sites, and will expire by or before the year 1999, unless the City of San Marcoe
agrees to extend the term of the permit.
E. Local oppoenion to landfill snes and disagreamenl balwaan north county cIlles and tha
County of San Diago over the hendling of the solid wille system has craBled a solid wasta crisis
involving disputes balweon the cities and the County of San Diago.
PR-12QO-3 so 00l).0Cl0
//-'/
F The Gregory Canyon site was selected as one of three preferred landfill sites by the County
of San Diego based upon a 1987 study which evaluated 168 alternative sites in northern San Diego
County covering a study area of 1150 square miles. Subsequently, one of these sites, Blue
Canyon, was dropped by the County of San Diego and two new landfill sites have been added,
The Gregory Canyon site is now one of four finalist sites.
G. In 1990 the County of San Diego prepared an environmental impact report evaluating the
environmental impacts of operating a landfill at the Gregory Canyon site, This Environmental
Impact Report concluded that a landfill could be operated at the Gregory Canyon site consistent
with all federal and state regulations governing landfill operations.
H. All of the San Diego County landfills have been successfully operated by a private party for
the County of San Diego since 1982.
I. The Gregory Canyon site is located in a sparsely populated area of San Diego Count~. Solid
waste operations will occur on approximately 270 acres of the Gregory Canyon site. At least 1313
acres will be dedicated as permanent open space to provide an important habitat and sensitive
species preserve.
J. The voters hereby find and determine that the project will be compatible with other uses in
the area and the County's general plan for uses in the area upon implementation of the mitigation
measures required by this measure.
K. The voters hereby reaffirm the policy of the County of San Diego that each sub-region of
the County shall be responsible for providing sufficient solid waste facilities to handle the solid
waste generated in each sub-region and solid waste shall not be shipped from one sub-region
to any other sub-region except where an emergency exists.
SECTION 3. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT.
The Project will include the following components:
A. General Description of the Project.
The recycling collection center and landfill will occupy approximately 270 acres of the Gregory
Canyon site. The landfill footprint containing refuse will cover approximately 150 acres of the site.
The main features of the Project include a lined landfill, construction of a new access road and
bridge providing access to the site from Highway 76, a scale area, a recycling collection canter,
a facilities and operation area, a borrow and stockpile area, a leachate collection system, and
storm.water retention facilities. The facilities and operation area will include a visitors' center, an
office building, a maintenance office, a shop and yard, a fueling station/storage area, a water tdtlk
truck wash and wash-water treatment area, a water supply well, groundwater monitoring wells,
a landfill gas collection and recovery system, and a leachate collection tank. The Applicant shell
be entitled to adjust the size and location of solid waste operations and to alter the proposed
facilities based on a detailed site plan to be submitted to the Integrated Waste Management Board
for its rev~ and approval as part of the solid waste facilities permit.
B. Dedicated Open Space.
The remaining 1413 acres of Gregory Canyon sne shall be dediceted as permanent open space
to the County of San Diego, the Pala Band of Mission Indians, another public agency, or a
Resource Conservation Group for long.term preservation of sensitive habitat and species. The
actual amount of acreage dedicated may be adjusted as n8C8888ry to accommodate construction
and operation of the Project. The open space area shall not be 1888 than 1313 acres as a result
of any adjustment.
C. Access Road.
The Project includes construction of a new access route and bridge from Highway 76 to the
Gregory Canyon sne.
D. Relocation of San Diego Gas & Electric Power Unes.
The project includes relocation of San Diego Gas & Electric transmission lines that are located
within the area for the proposed landfill and recycling collection center. All such relocation will
occur in accordance with plans reviewed and approved by San Diego Gas & Electric.
PR-1200-4 SD .........
I/..f
E. Realignment of Highway 76.
The Project includes the widening and realignment-of State Road 76 on either side of the new
access road to improve sight distance and to facilitate truck movements. The realigned segment
would provide approximately 1000 feet of sight distance in both directions for traffic leaving the
landfill. The Applicant shall contribute on a fair share basis to the widening of State Route 76 west
of the access road to applicable state standards. The fair share shall be based upon the state
standard average daily trips. This realigned portion of Highway 76 will be restriped to provide for
acceleration/deceleration lanes and an over-take lane for through traffic. Detailed plans for the
realignment of Highway 76 will be submitted to CalTrans for review and approval prior to
commencing any realignment work.
F Bridge.
The Project will include a bridge over the San Luis Rey River to provide separate roadways for
access to and from the landfill, and to and from the topsoil stockpile area. This will facilitate
adequate internal circulation for the landfill operations.
G. Protection of San Diego Aqueduct.
The Project will include work required to protect any San Diego Aqueduct pipelines to the extent
and in the manner required by the San Diego County Water Authority.
A map showing the Project elements is shown on Figure 2 attached to this measure. The
Applicant shall be entitled to alter or change these elements based upon a detailed site plan to
be submitted to the Integrated Waste Management Board for review and approval in conjunction
with the solid waste facilities permit.
SECTION 4. PERMITS.
To ensure that the Project is designed, constructed and operated In a safe and efficient manner,
the Project shall be required to secure all of the following permits and approvals to the extent
required by state or federal law:
A. Environmental Review.
The Project shall complete any additional environmental review required by federal or state law
to secure the remaining permits and approvals.
B. Consultation with Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.
The Applicant shall consult with the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation in accordance
with 5106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.
C. 404 Permit.
The Applicant shall secure e permit relating to 1404 of the Clean Water Act from the Department
of the Army Corps of Engineers.
D. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service.
The Applicant shall conduct a 57 consultation with the Depertment of Interior, U.S. Fish & Wildlne
Service in compliance with the Endangered Species Act and shall coordinate the 1404 permit with
the U.S.Fish & Wildl"e Service es required by federellew.
E. Calnomoe Department of Fish end Geme.
The Applicant shall secure a 51601 Streambed A~eration Agreement with the Calnomia
Department of Fish & Geme and any other permits required by the Calnomia Department of Fish
& Game.
F State Water Resources Control Board.
The Applicant shall secure a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit from the
State Water Resources Control Board.
G. Regional Water Quality Control Board.
The Applicant shall secure a Waste Discharge Permit from the Regional Water Quality Centrol
Board.
PR.1200.5 SD QOG.OOO
//,,;,
H. California Integrated Waste Management Board.
The Applicant shall obtain a Solid Wasta Faoility Perm~ from the Cal~omia Integrated Waste
Management Board and from the local enforcement agency for the California Integrated Waste
Management Board.
I. California Department of Transportation.
The Applicant shall secure an encroachment permit from the California Department of
Transportation 8S necessary for improvements to Highway 76.
J. State Office of Historic Preservation.
The Applicant shall review cultural sites within the Gregory Canyon site with the State Office
of Historic Preservation for eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places.
K. County of San Diego.
The Applicant shall secure a Water Course Alteration Permit, Bridge Permit, Grading Permit and
Building Permit from the County of San Diego. The County of San Diego is hereby authorized and
directed to include the Project in its Integrated Waste Management Plan as required by State law
and to make any findings required for issuance of any necessary permits.
L. San Diego Air Pollution Control District.
The Applicant shall secure all permits required by the San Diego Air Pollution Control District
to construct and operate the solid waste facilities authorized by this measure.
M. San Diego Local Agency Formation Commission.
The Applicant shall obtain approval from the San Diego Local Agency Formation Commission
for any possible annexation into 109B.1 water districts as required by the rules and regulations of
the San Diego Local Agency Formation Commission.
N. Utilities Services.
The Project shall comply with the requirements of local utility suppliers in securing electric,
telephone, water and fire protection services. Sewer service will be provided by chemical toilets
used by wor1(ers at the landfill. The Applicant will be required to provide the sewage disposal
service, removing effluent once per week by pumper truck from the chemical toilets for treatment
and disposal away from the site.
o. Other Permits and Approvals.
The Applicant shall secure all other permits and approvals as required by federal or state law.
SECTION 5. MITIGATION MEASURES.
To ensure that the Project is constructed and operated in a manner which minimizes ita
environmental impacts, the following mitigation measures are hereby adopted as a condition of
voter approval of the Project:
A. Days of Operation.
The solid waste faoil~ies shall remain open for the receipt of refuse a minimum of eight (8) hours
a day. six (6) days a week, excapting those holidays observed by county-owned landfills.
B. Hours of Operation.
Solid waste operation shall ooour only between the hours of 7:00 AM and 8:00 PM, Monday
through Friday. end 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM on Saturday unle.. diffenent houra are established by
the Integrated Waste Management Board. For the purposes of this mitigation measure "solid waate
operations- shall inoiude the receipt, hendling, prooeeaing. end/or diapoaaJ of solid waste or
recyclable meterials; cover operations; sKe grading andlor excavation, including blasting and rock
crushing; and heavy equipment operation. Other s~e activities such as the operation of gas end
leachate collaction and treatment systems, remedial activities required by a regulstory agency,
maintenance within the maintenance yard, and activities conducted in a completety enclosed
building shall not be limited to these hours of operation.
PR-12DO-6 SD ~
)/-7
C. Litter and Illegal Dumping.
At least five (5) days each week, the Applicant shall inspect for I and clean up, all litter and illegal
dumping which occurs on, or adjacent to, the landfill access road and that portion of Highway
76 between the intersection with Interstate 15 and the site. The clean up team shall consist of at
least one truck with a minimum crew of two persons.
D. Hazardous Waste Exclusion Program.
The Applicant shall maintain trained. full.time personnel engaged exclusively and continuously
in the inspection of incoming refuse loads for hazardous waste. These personnel shall be stationed
at the working face of the landfill whenever the landfill is open to accept waste and shall inspect
loads as they are tipped. Hazardous wastes encountered in this fashion shall be handled and
disposed of in accordance with state regulations.
E. Uner and Leachate Collection System.
A liner and leachate collection system shall be installed and monitored as required by the
Regional Water Quality Control Board.
F Landfill Gas System.
The Projec.1 shall include a network of vertical extraction wells, lateral transmission pipes to a
gas recovery facility, and perimeter gas monitoring probes. With this system, the landfill gas will
be extracted from the landfill and com busted in an enclosed flare.
G. Water Quality.
The Project shall comply with all requirements of the Regional Water Quality Control Board to
ensure protection of surface and underground water quality.
H. Earthquakes.
All structures located at the Gregory Canyon site shall be designed by a qualified engineer to
withstand the maximum probable earthquake to avoid potential impacts associated with
earthquakes and ground shaking.
I. Traffic Impacts.
In order to mitigate traffic impacts, the Applicant shall widen and realign State Route 76 on either
side of the access road to improve sight distance and to facilitate truck movements. The realigned
segment will provide approximately 1000 feet of sight distance in both directions for traffic leaving
the landfill. The Applicant shall contribute on a fair share basis to the. widening of State Route 76
west of the access road to applicable state standards. The leir share shall be based upon the state
standard average daily trips. Striping will be provided for acceleration/deceleration lanes and an
over-take lane for through traffic. These realignment plans may be modified as necessary to meet
CalTrans requirements.
J. Air Quaiity.
/>Jr quality impacts asaociated with the Project shall be mnigated by meeting all requirements
imposed by the San Diego County />Jr Pollution Control District for the Authority to Construct and
Authority to Operete permits.
K. Noise Abatement.
The Applicant shall prepare a Noise Abatement Plan to include:
1. Physical design provisions to ensure that ambient noise levels do not exceed 65 CNEL
at the boundaries of the Gregory Canyon site;
2. Installation of landfill equipment and vehicles with noise suppressing equipment to essist
in meeting the above restrictions:
3. Provisions for at least 24 hour In advance written notice of any blasting on-site to reslaenta
within a one-mile radius of the blast site.
4. Where ambient noise levels exceed 65 CNEL at the boundartes of the Gregory Canycn
site, the Applicant shall retain a qualified noise expert to evaluate the problem and recommend
mitigation measures. These mitigation measures shall be implemented by the Applicant.
Pll.12QO.7 SO ooo-ooa
/I..g/
L. Odor Control.
To control odors on-site, the Applicant shall submit an Odor Control Plan to the San Diego
County Air Pollution Control District for review and approval.
M. Dust Control Plan.
To control dust from Project operations, the Applicant shall submit a Dust Control Plan to the
San Diego County Air Pollution Control District for review and approval.
N. Biological Impacts.
All sensitive species and habitat impacted by the Project shall be mitigated in accordance with
requirements imposed by the United States Fish & Wildlife Service as part of the 57 consultation.
O. Visual Impacts.
In order to mitigate visual impacts associated with the Project, the Applicant shalt employ
extensive use of landscaping emphasizing native vegetation, and rounding/undulation of slopes
on the refuse column and changes in slope angles. All landscaping shall be performed by a
licensed landscape architect in the State of Califomia. This licensed architect shall prepare a
detailed landscape plan designed to minimize visual impact associated with the Project to the
maximum feasible extent. The plan prepared the licensed architect shall be implemented by the
Applicant upon completion.
P Cultural Impacts.
Impacts to Native American resources impacted by the Project shall be mitigated through the
development of a Memorandum of Agreement between the Applicant and the appropriate
regulatory agencies in accordance with 5106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, To mitigate
archaeological impacts caused by the Project, the Applicant shall retain a qualified archaeologist
to investigate and recommend appropriate mitigation measures. These mitigation measures shall
be implemented by the Applicant.
a. Citizen Environmental Review Board.
A Citizen Environmental Review Board (the "Board-) shall be established by agreement
between the Applicant and the cities or other governmental entities agreeing to supply waste to
the Project. The members of such Board shall be appointed by each such city or entity and'shall
be individual caizens who are not employees or officials of such city or entity. The Board shall
have the authority to inspect and review all reports submitted by the Project to any other regulatory
agency and to make recommendations to any 8uch regulatory agency with respect to the
operation of the Project, including any enforcement actions the Board may deem appropriate. The
Board shall establish an environmental review team consisting of qualified personnel to monitor
the operations of the landfill which team 8hall have reasonable access to the landfill during all
hours of operation of the landfill.
R. Additional Mitigation Measures.
Mitigation measures included as part of any subsequent environmental review of the Project
shall be included as additional mitigation measures for the Project. The Applicant shall submit a
mitigation and monitoring program meeting state and federal law to the Integrated Waste
Management Board for review and approval 88 part of the solid waste facilities permit.
SECTION 8. TIPPING FEE AND FINANCIAL GUARANTEES.
A. Tipping Fee.
It is the intention of the voters to ensure that the tipping fee charged by the Project to any public
agency supplying waste to the project does not exceed the tipping fee currently cherged at
county-owned landfills as adjusted for inflation. This fee is currently $43 per ton. For calendar year
1994. this tipping fee shell be $43 per ton. Commencing January 1, 1994, and continuing on
January 1 of each year thereafter, this tipping fee may be increased by the percentage charge
in the Consumer's Price Index, All Urban Consumer's for the Los Angela. Anaheim * Riverside
Area (1967 = 100) for December of the prior year to December of the year the price increase Ie
to occur.
PR-1200-S
SD 000-00o
J /.. 9
.
The tipping fee as set in this section shall be subject to changes or adjustments based upon
tipping fees negotiated between the Applicant and various public agencies agreeing to provide
solid waste to the Project.
B. Financial Guarantees.
The Applicant shall provide a closure and post-clo8ure plan complying with federal and state
law and shall provide bonds or other financial guarantees to ensure performance as required by
federal and state law.
SECTION 7. IMPLEMENTATION.
A. Amendments to County General Plan.
Upon the effective date of this initiative. the land use element of the County General Plan and
all sub-regional and community plans which apply to the Gregory Canyon site and any related
maps shall be amended to designate the Gregory Canyon site Public/Semi-public lands with a
Solid Waste Facility Designator. Notwithstanding the Public/Semi-public designation, the Gregory
Canyon site shall remain private lands unless purchased or condemned by a public agency.
B. Amendments to County Zoning Ordinance.
Upon the effective date of this initiative, the County Zoning Ordinance shall be amended to
create a new zoning classification designated Solid Waste Facility ("SWF"). This SWF zoning
classification shall be applied only to the Gregory Canyon site and shall allow the Project without
the need for any permits from the County of San Diego except the Water Course Alteration Permit,
Bridge Permit, Grading Permit and Building Permit.
C. Amendments to Other County Ordinances and Policies.
All other County ordinances, rules and regulations which constitute legislative acts shall be
amended 86 necessary to accommodate the Project as set forth in this initiative.
0, County Cooperation,
The County of San Diego shall cooperate with the Applicant wherever possible in issuil"g
permits and approvals so Ihal the Project can proceed in a timely fashion.
The County of San Diego is hereby authorized and directed to amend other elements of the
General Plan, sub-regional plans, community plans, Zoning Ordinance, and other ordinances and
policies affected by this initiative as 800n as poasible and in the manner and time required by State
Law to ensure consistency between this initiative and other elements of the County's General Plan,
sutrregional and community plans, Zoning Ordinance and other County ordinances and policies.
SECTION 8. DEFINITIONS.
For the p"rpose of thie measure. the following words and phrases shall have the following
meanings:
A. "Applleant" shall mean Servcon-San Marcos, Inc. or itl alsignee or authorized
representatives.
B. "Gregory Cenyon s~e" shall mean the approximately 1683 acres of land located off State
Route 76 approximately 3 1/2 miles east of the intersection of Interstate 15 and State Route 76
occupying portions of Sections 4 and 5 ofTownship 10 South and Sections 32 and 33 of Township
9 South Range 2 West of the San Bemardino Principle Meridian.
C. "Integrated Waste Management Board" shall mean the State of California Integrated Waste
Management Board,
D. "Project" shall mean the recycling collection center and landfill and associated structures
and improvements as described in Section 3 of this initiative measure 88 8ubsequently modified
by a detailed s~e plan submitted by Applicant to the Integrated Waste Management Board as part
of the solid waste facilities permit.
E, "Recycling collection center" shall mean a facility for the buy-back of sourca saparated
materials but not the processing of mixed waste.
PR-12QO-9 SD OOC>OOO
/1'11)
SECTION 9. PURCHASE BY PUBLIC AGENCY
The Gregory Canyon site shall remain private land until purchased by a public agency or Joint
Powers Authority for its fair market value. Nothing contained herein shall restrict the right of any
public agency to exercise its eminent domain power as authorized by law to acquire the Gregory
Canyon site.
SECTION 10. AMENDMENT OR REPEAL.
This measure may be amended or repealed only by a majority of the voters voting in an election
thereon.
SECTION 11. INTERPRETATION AND SEVERABILITY.
This measure shall be interpreted 80 as to be consistent with all federal and state laws, rules
and regulations. If any section, sub~section. sentence, clause, phrase, part or portion of this
measure is held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a final judgment of court of competent
jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this measure.
The voters hereby declare that this measure, and each section, sub~8ection, sentence, clause,
phrase, part or portion thereof would have adopted or passed irrespective of the fact that anyone
or more sections, sub-sections, sentences, clauses, phrases, parts or portions are declared invalid
or unconstitutional.
SECTION 12. CONSISTENCY WITH OTHER BALLOT MEASURES.
In the event that another ballot measure is placed on the same ballot as this measure purporting
to deal with the same subject matter, and if both measures should pass, the voters expressly
declare their intent that both measures shall be put into effect except to the extent that specific
provisions of such measures are in direct conflict. In the event of such a direct conflict, the measure
which obtained more votes will control as to the conflicting provisions only. The voters expressly
declare this to be their intent, notwithstanding any language to the contrary in any other ballot
measure.
PR-12OQ-l0
SD DCX>OOCl
//..//
Idll5 II . ~.I
N i
i tll'1lii I . '11p
.
I
! II II n U~ . >
.
. .
.
. >
I I~~.~~~~.~~ ~ i: I III
.
I
.
"
PR.'2lJO.ll
SO QOG.OOO
/ /../,,-
r.:eet:.IC"unry
ll.J
a:
:J_
"
u::
..
.
,
.
.
.
;
,
o
~
A~
~
,
,
.
,
j
.
'i
:;;
.
.
~
!:
:
;;
<J
~
.
"
"
.
.
o
..
e
Co
. ~ n
"
~z ~;j 5
"
t~t
~"e
i~1:J
PR.1200-12
SD 0Cl0-000
/1'1.3
COUNTY COUNSEL'S IMPARTIAL ANALYSIS
You are asked to vote on the Gregory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Collection Center Initiative.
The declared intent of this measure is to permit the siting of a new recycling collection center and
Class III solid waste landfill at Gregory Canyon ("Project") to allow residents and businesses of
northern San Diego County to dispose of their solid waste in an environmentally sound and
commercially competitive manner Gregory Canyon is located off State Route 76 approximately
three and one-half miles east of the intersection of Interstate 15 and State Route 76 in northern San
Diego County.
This measure would amend the San Diego County General Plan and Zoning Ordinance to
'permit the development of the Project on approximately 270 acres at Gregory Canyon without the
need for additional permits from the County except 8S specified in the initiative. The Project would
be subject to any applicable State or federal permits and any environmental review needed to
obtain those permits. The Project would remain private land unless purchased or condemned by
a public agency.
The measure would provide that. if the Project is approved, at least 1313 acres of the Gregory
Canyon site must be dedicated as permanent open space to create a preservation area for
sensitive habitat and species. It would provide for the establishment of a Citizen Environmental
Review Board to monitor the Project, sets forth tipping fee provisions and contains certain
operating rules and other provisions as a condition of voter approval intended to mitigate the
environmental impacts of the Project.
The Project, as described in the measure, would require the construction of a new access route
and bridge, the relocation of gas and electric powerlines, the protection of any San Diego
Aqueduct pipelines and the widening and realignment of State Route 76 with the Project Applicant
contributing its fair share based upon average daily trips. The Applicant is defined to mean
Servcon San Marcos, Inc., its designee or authorized representatives.
The measure contains findings concerning the neecl for a landfill in north San Diego County and
reaffirming County policy that each subregion of the County provide for its own waste disposal.
The measure may be amended or repealed only by vote of the people and contains various
provisions relating to implementation and interpretation.
IMPARTIAL FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
The regional solid waste disposal system w~hin San Diego County (except the City of San Diego
solid waste disposal system) is administered by the County of San Diego. The governance of the
assets, liabilities and obligations of the solid waste disposal system is being transferred to the Solid
Waste Joint Powers Authority (Authority). This is an independent govemmental agency which is
composed of various cities within the region and the County of San Diego representing the
unincorporated area. The system is administered like a busine88 through a Solid Waste Enterprise
fund whiCh charges a system user fee to recover the cost of maintaining a financially solvent solid
waste disposal system. These revenues (tipping fees) and expend~ures (costs) are solely the
responsibility of the solid waste disposal system and not the County of San Diego.
The revenues and expenses created by this initiative will be the responsibility of the Authority upon
the transfer of all assets, liabil~ies and obligations to the Authority. Acoordingly, this In~iative doas
not have an effect on the revenueS and expenditures of the County of San Diego. The effect of this
in~iative on the fees charged by the Authority for usa of the solid waste disposal system are
incalculable at this time due to the unknown variables which effect the charges such as solid waste
tonnage, cost of permitting such a facility, construction coat and other systemwide costs.
PR.121lO-13
SD o00-ooo
/1'/ 'I
ARGUMENT IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION C
Gregory Canyon Solve. North County'. Tr..h Problem.
Why a now North County landfill?
Every month, San Diego County ganerates enough trash to fill Jack Murphy Stadium twice, North
County's trash goes to the San Marcos landfill, which will close in two years. Without a new landfill,
North County trash will be trucked to South Bay, East County, and the City of San Diego,
Why h..n't thi. problem been eolved?
After spending 12 years and millions of dollars, the Board of Supervisors failed to site a North
County landfill. When the county identified Gregory Canyon as a landfill, pressure from NIMBYs
(Not In My Backyard) prevented pol~icians from deciding,
Why are we voting on thi.?
Citizens put this initiative on the ballot 80 voters could end political paraJysis. Your vote ensures
North County will take care of its own trash.
Who Pay.?
Private enterprise will construct the landfill. No tax dollars are involved. Usars will pay to dump their
trash, with rates set by government agencies. East County, South Bay and the City of San Diego
wili NOT pay for North County trash disposal.
Will water quality be protected?
Yes. California has the nation's strictest environmental regulations. The State Water Quality Control
Board and County Water Authoritv will subject Gregory Canyon to rigorous review. Gregory
Canyon will .MQ! be allowed to open if there is any danger to water quality.
Are there economic benefits?
Ves, A privately-owned landfili will pay milliona in property taxes and will keep trash rates low,
Private landfills are a growing solution to trash problems throughout Southern California.
What about anvlronmantalllllfaguard.?
Gregory Canyon wili need perm~ from 1 t Federal, State and local agencies. including U,S, Fiah
and Wildlife and S.D. Air Pollution ContrOl District. There will be an Independent Citizen
Environmental Review Board.
What If Propo.lllon C folia?
North County trash will be trucked to South Bay, East County and the C~ of San Diego, at great
cost, increased traffic and air pollution.
Join Ua - Vata Ve. on Pr_1I1on CI
JUDV McCARTY
Former Chair, Regional Recycling
Strategy Committee
San Diego C~ Councilmember
DR, ROBERT SIMMONS
Profesaor, Environmental Law
University of San Diego
DR. UONEL BURTON, M,D,
Past President
Valiec~os Water District
CAROL HOPKINS
Co-Foreperoon, 1991-112 County Grand Jury
that reviewed County tresh operations
DAVID SOSSAMAN
Citizen Taxpayer Advocate
PR-1200-,4
SD 000-00o
/I'/.f'
REBUTTAL TO THE ARGUMENT IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION C
The proponents of Proposition C say that North County trash will be trucked to other parts of the
County if this measure fails. Not true.
First, the San Marcos Landfill has yaRd permits to operate for another five years. This landfill
could operate even longer if San Diego County residents continue to recycle at record rates.
Second. two other sites are still under consideration as a future replacement for San Marcos.
Their viability should be determined alongside Gregory Canyon through the normal public
hearing process.
Proponents say their plan utilizes no tax dollars. The existing trash disposal system doesn't use
tax dollars either. It's supported by fees paid for each ton of trash that's disposed, just like
Gregory Canyon would be.
Proponents say there is an Independent Citizens Review Board. Unfortunately this Board has
no power to mandate changes in the operation or construction of the landfill.
Proponents say rates will be set by public agencies. Not true. No public agency has authority
to set rates at a private landfilL
Proponents say the County Water Authority will review the propoeed landfill. Not true. The
landfill doesn't need any permits or review by the County Water Authority.
A safe, sanitary site for a garbage dump should not be identified through the ballot box in a
popularity contestl Vote no on CI
BARRY HITE
Chair, Sierra Club
San Diego Chapter
FRED E. BUCK
Chairman, Rainbow
Community Planning Group
JOE CHISHOLM
Chairman, San Luis Rey River
Citizens Advisory Committee
DR. EUGENE W. GREENFIELD
Assietant Dean
School of Engineering
Washington State University (ReI.)
PR-1200.15
SD o00.ooo
I/*-/~
ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION C
This is a dangerous initiative on several counts: it assumes that the Gregory Canyon landfill will
not contaminate vital water resources; It eliminates local authority to regulate landfill operations;
and it opens the door for private parties with enough money to buy their own zoning classification.
The Gregory Canyon site is immediately adjacent to the San Luis Rey River and its aquifer
system which is a high-quality groundwater resource. Even with recent stringent rules regarding
groundwater and surface water contamination from landfills, the best way to prevent
contamination is to site a landfill in an area where it would do the least harm. Let's wait until we
have completed environmental studies on all North County landfill sites and know the risks, at each
site, before choosing a new site. This is much better than first deciding where to put a landfill and
later learning about environmental impacts.
Another reason to vote "no" on this initiative is that it takes away local authority to regulate the
operation of the landfill or to require that noise, dust, and odor standards be adhered to.
There is only one reason this initiative is on the ballot. Certain private companies want to make
a huge profit on their investment. Private corporations have already spent $235,325 to buy
signatures and will be spending hundreds of thousands more to buy votes. Your "no" vote says
they cannot trespass on the pUblic by buying their way onto the ballot and past local land use
protection.
JOHN MACDONALD
Supervisor I Fifth District
County of San Diego
ALAN FERGUSON
President, Board of Directors
Rainbow Municipal Water Di~trict
PAUL S. TOMPKINS
Mayor
City of Solana Baach
JIM RUSSELL
Chairman
Fallbrook Community Planning Group
ROBERT SMITH
Tribal Chairman
Pala Band of Mission Indians
PR.12O().16
SD 0CJ000Cl0
//"/?
REBUTTAL TO THE ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION C
Gregory Canyon's Opponents sre Just Plein Wrongl
The State of California wtll NOT allow Gregory Canyon to open If th.... II any danger to water
quality.
California has the toughest environmentallsws in the nation - and everyone will be watching to
insure they are strictlv enforced. Gregory Canyon will undergo rigorous environmental review by
all Stste, Federal and local agencies, including Calijomla's Woler Quality Board, the Army Corp.
01 Englnee.., County Watar Authority and the Air Pollution Control Dlatrlel.
.North County'. tra.h problam. ara building.
The existing North County landfill CIOS88 in 2 years. North County is growing and generating more
and more trash. It has to go somewhere. Gregory Canyon was identified by the County as a landfill
site, but NIMBYs killed the idee. Wllhout a n_ landfill, North County traah will be trucked to
Eest County, South Bay and the City of San Diego.
Gregory Canyon'. opponenta ar. the ..me bureaucrat. and polltlclana who failed tor 12
yora to aolve North County'. tra.h problem. -
Every solution is opposed by NIMBYs (Not-In-My-Backyard). After wasting millions, ell they
propose is millions more for studies and consultants. Propoaltlon C bruke thll atal.mate,
giving voter. control.
Propo.ltlon C wlllosva tsxpayer money.
Gregory Canyon will be built without tax dollars. Private enterprise takes the risk. A privately-owned
landfiil will pay millions in property taxes; operete more efficiently; and still be strictly regulated. Ail
government contracts will beaudned annually. The reot of San Diego will not pay for North
County tre.h dl.poosl end North County will heve a aoluUon fo lie treeh problem.
YES ON C - A COMMON SENSE SOLUTION
MIKE BIXLER
Mayor, Imperial Baach
ART MADRID
Mayor, La Mesa
sye NOTKlN
Chairman, Citizens for
Environmental Solutions
UONEL G. BURTON, M.D.
Former Meyor
City of San Marcos
PR.1200-1T
SD 000-00o
//'I$"
ITEM
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
I~
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
ITEM TITLE: Report on the application for grant funds from the
Federal Department of Education, Library Services
and Construction Act (LSCA) for the purchase of
specific library reference resources as a Major
Urban Resource Library
SUBMITTED BY: Library Directon(,J~-
REVIEWED BY: city Manager~~~(4/5ths Vote: Yes__ No-X-)
On September 9, 1994, the Chula~ista Public Library submitted an
application for LSCA funds for the purchase of specific library
reference resources.
As the Chula vista Public Library is a City agency serving a
resident population of over 100,000, it has been designated a Major
Urban Resource Library (MURL) by the united States Department of
Education and is eligible to apply for a grant of $11,670 for
needed library materials.
For four consecutive years Chula vista Public Library, as a MURL
library, has applied and been awarded these LSCA funds through the
California State Library . The funds are awarded for the purpose of
supporting and expanding library resources in subject areas of
regional need.
RECOMMENDATION:
application.
That Council accept the report and ratify the
BOARD AND COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
The Library Board voted to support the Library's application for FY
1994-95 MURL grant funds at their meeting of September 28, 1994.
(Attachment A)
DISCUSSION:
If awarded, the Library intends to use the 1994-95 MURL funds to
continue Business Collection, a product accessing 400 business
periodicals and journals, and to strengthen the collection of
career and job-seeking materials for the users of the Chula vista
Public Library.
FISCAL IMPACT:
If awarded, the grant will provide $11,670 to purchase reference
materials for the Library at 365 F Street. These funds will
augment book accounts that were cut during the FY 1993-94 and 1994-
95 budget process. If awarded, the grant will be brought back to
Council to be appropriated.
).1-/
ATTACHMENT A
DRAFT MINUTES
LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
September 28, 1994
III. NEW BUSINESS
C. 94/95 MURL Grant
MSUC (Alexander/Clover-Byram) that the Library Board
supports the Library's application for MURL funds.
1,2-;2..
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
ITEM 1.:1
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
ITEM TITLE: Report on the application by the Chula vista Public
Library to the California state Library for
California Library Services Act (CLSA) FY 1994-95
Matching Funds for Literacy
SUBMITTED BY: Library Director
REVIEWED BY: City Manager~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes___No-X-)
In 1987 the library received a e-year California state Library
grant to establish the Chula vista Literacy Team. The fifth and
final year of this funding was FY 1991-92. The California state
Library has announced the availability of California Library
Services Act Matching Funds for programs which were awarded the
original five-year grants. The amount of this year's match has not
yet been determined, however, funding last year was $1 for every
$4.51 raised locally and spent during the fiscal year.
RECOMMENDATION:
That Council accept the report and approve the application by the
Chula vista Public Library to the California state Library for
California Library Services Act (CLSA) FY 1994-95 Matching Funds
for Literacy.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: On September 28, 1994 the Library
Board of Trustees voted to support the Library's application for
CLSA 1994-95 MatChing Funds for Literacy (Attachment A)licr.r~~1dJ
DISCUSSION
As an extension of the original CLSA literacy grant, these funds
are intended to supplement monies raised locally to support library
adult literacy programs. The funds awarded must be spent in FY
'94-95. They may be used in a variety of ways, which could include
hiring additional support personnel, purchasing equipment, suppl ies
and instructional resources, or providing staff development. The
Chula vista Literacy Team is eligible for matching funds based on
our expected expenditure of $148,000 this fiscal year.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Once the California State Library determines the exact amount of
matching dollars available, they will inform the Chula vista Public
Library of the award amount. At that time a detailed plan of
service will be developed and submitted to the state Library for
approval. If the State Library funds at the same level as FY 1993-
94, the City will receive approximately $32,800. If awarded, the
grant will be brought back to Council to be appropriated.
):!>-/
ATTACHMENT A
DRAFT MINUTES
LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
September 28, 1994
III. NEW BUSINESS
A. Application for sixth and subsequent year Literacy
Funding
MSUC (Alexander/Clover-Byram)
supports the Literacy Team 's
Trustee Williams absent)
that the Library Board
application. (4-0-1 with
/:J---e2..
ITEM TITLE:
c.
{J.
;p
SUBMITTED BY:
REVffiWED BY:
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
Item 1'1
Meeting Date 10/11/94
/I.
PUBLIC HEARING: (A) PCZ-91-D - Consideration of prezoning 14.23
acres located north of the terminus of Moonview Drive from RR-1
(County) to RE-P (8.37 acres) and RE-40 (5 86 acres) - Michael Demich
ORDINANCE .2 ~ ~lrdinance of the City of Chula Vista City Council
prezoning 14.23 acres of land located north of the terminus of Moonview
Drive to RE-P (8.37 Acres) and RE-40 (5 86 Acres)
PUBLIC HEARING' (B) PCS-91-02 - Consideration of tentative
subdivision map for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, Chula Vista Tract
PCS-91-02 - Michael Demich
RESOLUTION I ~~ ~Zolution of the City of Chula Vista City Council
approving the Tentative Subdivision Map for Bonita Hills Executive
Estates, Chula Vista Tract PCS 91-02, making the necessary fmdings and
adopting the Mitigated Negative Declaration and the Mitigation
Monitoring Program for IS-91-15
Director of Planning M
City Manager~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes_NoX)
1. This item involves a prezone of 14.23 acres to the City's RE-P (Residential Estates-
Precise Plan) and RE-40 (Residential Estates-40,OOO square foot minimuni lot size)
zones, and the subdivision of 8.37 acres of the 14.23 acres into 12 residential and 2 open
space lots. The parcel to be subdivided is proposed to be pre-zoned to RE-P. Two
adjoining parcels to the east owned by the Sweetwater Authority are proposed to be pre-
zoned to RE-40 All parcels are located north of the terminus of Moonview Drive in the
County of San Diego (see Exhibits A and B).
2. An Initial Study, IS-91-15, of possible adverse environmental impacts of the project was
conducted by the Environmental Review Coordinator (ERC) The ERC concluded that
there would be no significant environmental effects and recommends adoption of the
Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Program (see Exhibit C)
1'1" I
Page 2, Item ~
Meeting Date 10/11/94
RECOMMENDATION:
That City Council adopt the Ordinance and Resolution approving the prezoning and Tentative
Subdivision Map based on the findings and subject to the guidelines and conditions contained
therein.
BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION:
1. On September 14, 1994, the Planning Commission voted 5-to-l recommending approval
of the Prezoning, and 4-to-2 recommending approval of the Tentative Subdivision Map
(see attached minutes).
2. On September 26, 1994, the Resource Conservation Commission reviewed the Mitigated
Negative Declaration for IS-91-15 and the associated Coastal Sage Scrub Loss Permit for
CS-95-03 (see attached minutes). A motion to approve these items failed with 3 votes
in favor, two opposed, and two absent (four affIrmative votes being necessary to approve
the motion.)
DISCUSSION:
Backe:round
1 Proposed development.
The applicant is proposing the subdivision of 8.37 acres into 12 residential and 2 open space
lots. The residential lots are proposed to contain single family detached homes on minimum
10,000 square foot acre parcels. The subdivision will be gated, the streets and open spaces lots
private. A homeowners association will be established to maintain the private streets, open
space lots and re-vegetated areas.
As a residential development, the homes will be custom built and, according to the applicant,
will sell in the range of $300,000 to $500,000 Development must be constructed in accordance
with the precise plan guidelines established as part of the prezone related to density and lot size,
and RE standards.
In addition, the two adjoining parcels owned by the Sweetwater Authority are proposed to be
pre-zoned and annexed in conjunction with the subdivision, in order to provide logical
annexation boundaries. These parcels total 5.86 acres and contain an 18 million gallon
underground reservoir and control building. In a letter dated September 29, 1994, the
Sweetwater Authority agreed to the annexation of these two parcels (see Exhibit D)
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A\9102A.113
I'I~~
Page 3, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
11
2. Zoning and Land Use.
Site
North
South
East
West
ZONING
RR-l (Rural Residential-l du/ac)(County)
RR-l/RR-5 (Rural Residential-4.3 du/ac)(County)
PC (Planned Community)(Chula Vista)
RR-l (County)
RR-5 (County)
LAND USE
Vacant
Residential
Residential
Vacant
Vacant/Residential
The site is bounded by existing single family residences at the northwestern, northern and
northeastern boundaries, water storage facilities at the southern boundary, an improved access
road entering at the northeast boundary, Moonview Drive entering at the south central boundary,
and undeveloped land at the southwestern and eastern boundaries. The project is compatible
with surrounding land uses.
The properties to the north, east and west are in the County of San Diego and designated
Residential-Low (0-3 du/ac), Residential 1 and Residential 5, respectively, on the Sweetwater
Community Plan. The property to the south (Terra Nova) is in the City of Chula Vista and is
designated Residential-Low Medium (3-6 du/ac) on the City's General Plan.
3. Existing site characteristics.
The 8.37 acre tentative map parcel slopes to the west with an average natural slope of 15% and
a maximum natural slope of 40%. The southern end of the property features a north-facing
slope with disturbed vegetation Which gradually drops into a drainage course with sage scrub.
The terrain rises again to the north onto a barren ridge line, before dropping steeply into Bonita
Valley.
The 5.86 acre Sweetwater parcels are bounded on the west by the tentative map parcel, to the
north by a single family residence, to the south by a parcel containing a water tank and another
vacant parcel, and to the east by vacant land. Access is from Randy Lane off Bonita Road or
from Moonview Drive through Terra Nova via East "H" Street. A pump house sits at the east
central portion of the property
Drainage from the tentative map area is to the west and flows toward the center of the project,
which then follows the natural drainage course westward off-site, then northward and eventually
ends up in the Sweetwater River. On the eastern boundary near the center of the site is a
disturbed fill slope'. The maximum elevation is 308 feet at the south end of the property,
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102A.113
p.l3
Page 4, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
/1
whereas the low elevation is approximately 116 feet in the extreme northwestern comer of the
property .
The 18.7 million gallon reinforced concrete Bonita Valley Reservoir on the Sweetwater parcels
includes a pump house and a two foot earthen "blanket" placed over the concrete tank, on which
sage scrub was seeded. Although these parcels are proposed for annexation concurrently with
the tentative map area, they will not be developed because of the presence of gnatcatchers and
sensitive habitat.
4 Prezone.
The prezone will establish City zoning prior to annexation. The subdivision map area will be
pre-zoned RE-P, Residential Estate - Precise Plan, while the Sweetwater Authority parcels will
be pre-zoned to RE-40, Residential Estate - 40,000 sq. ft minimum lot size. With City zoning,
the project will be subject to the standards contained in Chapter 19.22, R-E - Residential Estates
Zone, and any precise plan standards established under the "P" Precise Plan modifying district.
Lot sizes vary in size from the smallest of 13,168 sq. ft. (Lot 5) to the largest of 20,255 sq. ft.
(Lot 10)
5. Tentative map.
As noted earlier, the tentative subdivision map proposes to divide the 8.37 acres into twelve
residential parcels. Lots 1 to 6 will be placed on the ridge line between Open Space Lots "A"
and "B," while Lots 7 to 12 will be placed along the southern portion of the project. Lots 10
to 12 will abut the present City boundary
Because of its excessive slope, Open Space Lot "A" will not be developed. Open Space Lot "B"
will also not be developed as a result of a biology study carried out under the Initial Study which
identified several important issues (see the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15,
Attachment "B") Open Space Lot "B" contains the storm drain and the sewer line. The
subdivision will be accessed from Moonview Drive, which is proposed to be gated.
6 Annexation.
The annexation request has been submitted by the applicant and will be considered at a later
date. All three parcels are conditioned to be annexed prior to approval of the Final Map.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102A.113
/1- 0/
Page 5, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
If
7. Environmental Review
An environmental "initial study" was required by the Environmental Review Coordinator (IS-91-
15) for this project. However, in March 25, 1993 prior to the issuance of a Mitigated Negative
Declaration, the California Gnatcatcher was listed as a threatened species under the Endangered
Species Act, thus delaying the posting of the Negative Declaration. A biology study was then
necessary to address the loss of Coastal Sage Scrub, which is habitat for the Gnatcatcher The
biology study found that there are several California Gnatcatchers just off the subdivision
property to the east and west, and that there would be a loss of 1.5 acres of Coastal Sage Scrub.
As mitigation for the loss of Coastal Sage Scrub, the applicant is required to re-vegetate the
Sweetwater tank parcel (APN 592-171-61), irrigate the re-vegetated areas, and fence off the
parcel to ensure that, to the extent possible, domesticated animals do not threaten any nesting
gnatcatchers. In addition, the applicant is required to re-vegetate any disturbed areas in Open
Space Lot "B" resulting from the project, and along the bank adjacent to Street "B," and any
areas disturbed as a result of grading activities adjoining the subdivision.
In addition, all re-vegetated areas are to be monitored for a period of five years to ensure that
the native plants thrive and are capable of supporting themselves. If after five years the plants
are not thriving, the Environmental Review Coordinator has the option of extending the
monitoring period.
8. Coastal Sage Scrub Loss Permit.
When the Coastal California Gnatcatcher was listed as threatened by the Federal Government
under the provisions of the Endangered Species Act, a "special rule" was adopted pursuant to
Section 4(d) of the Act which gave local governments the ability to issue permits for limited loss
of Coastal Sage Habitat. Subsequently, the City of Chula Vista adopted an ordinance authorizing
it to issue Interim Loss Permits in the City The Project site includes areas of Coastal Sage
Scrub habitat, and, therefore, a Coastal Sage Scrub loss permit will be necessary for
development of the project. The draft findings for this loss permit are included in the Mitigated
Negative Declaration. The loss permit will be considered for issuance by the Director of
Planning prior to issuance of a grading permit.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102A.113
1'1" ...$'
Page 6, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
It!
Analvsis
1. General Plan Conformance.
The General Plan designation in the County of San Diego is Residential-Low (0-3 du/ac) The
City of Chula Vista General Plan designation for the both parcels is Residential-Low (0-3 du/ac)
The proposed prezoning to RE-P and RE-40 are consistent with these designations.
2. Zoning Ordinance Conformance.
The current zoning, under the County of San Diego is RR-I (I acre minimum lot size). The
proposed City of Chula Vista zoning for the subdivision is RE-P (minimum lot size of 20,000
square feet). The application of the "P" modifier to this project will allow parcels of less than
20,000 sq. ft., along with the retention of the permanent open spaces, provided the overall
density does not exceed the maximum allowable under the RE Zone.
The Sweetwater Authority site will be pre-zoned RE-40 which requires a minimum 40,000
square foot lot per dwelling. This is in keeping with the existing County zoning and General
Plan designation.
3. Grading 1 Landform Modification.
The project conforms with the City's landform grading policies as specified in Sections 6.2 and
77 of the Land Use Element of the General Plan. The proposed grading pattern conforms to
the policies mentioned above.
4. Circulation 1 Access.
Access to the project will be from Moonview Drive to the southeast of the project, which will
be gated. Access to the project from Randy Lane off Bonita Road will be provided, but will be
gated and restricted to emergency access only.
The proposed street names for the project are:
Street "A" - Moonview Drive
Street "B" - Moonview Way
Street "C" - Moonview Court
Bonita Hills Executive Estates is proposed to be a gated community from Moonview Drive. At
the Planning Commission public hearing, several Commission members had concerns regarding
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONITA \9102A.113
/o/.,~
Page 7, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
11/
this aspect of the project. It is staff's position that the gating proposal for this project is
acceptable for the following reasons:
1) There is no through access from Moonview Drive to Bonita Road. The project is
isolated and not interconnected to the overall street network. Direct access to Bonita
Road from Moonview Drive via Randy Lane is prohibited, except for emergencies, and
will be blocked by a crash gate, thus precluding direct access from Terra Nova to Bonita
Road, even for subdivision residents.
2) The streets in the subdivision will be constructed to a private street standard and will be
maintained by the homeowner's association.
3) Open Space Lots "A" and "B" and both Sweetwater Authority parcels are considered
environmentally sensitive and should not be disturbed. If the subdivision is open to the
public there is a higher likelihood that people will disturb these areas.
4) No trail systems connect in a north-south or east-west direction through the subdivision
or to the Sweetwater Parcels so there would be no need for hiker/pedestrian access.
Based on discussion of these factors, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the
proposed Tentative Subdivision Map with the gating proposal being retained.
4 Drainage.
Drainage from the site will be to the west from the center of the site. Streets" A" and "C" will
drain down to approximately the center of the project in Open Space Lot "B" where it will then
follow the natural drainage pattern out of the subdivision. The drainage structures will not allow
a greater volume or velocity of water to surface drain off the site than does so at present.
Several residents to the north and below (downslope ot) the project on Glen Abbey Boulevard
raised concerns regarding increased drainage onto their properties. Apparently, these properties
are subject to flooding under existing conditions in the County According to the applicant's
engineer and the City Engineer, the development and grading of this site will actually reduce the
overall amount of runoff. A small amount of runoff which currently flows down the hillside will
be diverted to the storm drain. In addition, the applicant is required to re-vegetate certain slopes
and hillsides in the vicinity which currently drain onto Glen Abbey Boulevard. Once the re-
vegetation of the hillsides and slopes is complete, there will be an overall decrease in the amount
of runoff.
P:IHOMEIPLANNINGlMARTINlBONIT A 19102A.113
/l1-?
Page 8, Item
Meeting Date 10/11/94
it(
Subsequent to the Planning Commission hearing, Mr. I.H. McGowan wrote to the City Council
regarding the drainage from the subdivision and relating his concerns that negative impacts
would occur as a result of the development of the subject parcel. His concerns were responded
to by the Engineering Division in a memo dated October 3, 1994 (see Exhibit E).
5. Public Services / Utilities.
A sewer line serving Lots 7 to 12 in Street "C" will flow into a line in Street "B" then to Street
"A." An easement running down the lot line separating Lots 4 and 5 will take the sewer line
off-site to the west. Approximately 460 feet to the west, the line turns north where, after
approximately 430 more feet, it will connect to Glen Abbey Boulevard.
FISCAL IMPACT: Development Impact Fees, Park and Recreation fees and property taxes
are applicable to this project. However, because the streets will be privately maintained, there
will be no City outlay for maintaining the subdivision's streets.
ATTACHMENTS.
NOT SCA1iIfED Exhibit A - Locator map showing the area of the prezone for PCZ-91-D
NOT SCANNED Exhibit B - Reduction of Tentative Subdivision Map PCS-91-02 (full scale blue lines included in each packet
to the City Council).
3. Exhibit C - Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Program for IS-91-15.
NOT SC H,"An.: D Exhibit D - Sweetwater Authority letter dated September 29, 1994 agreeing to the annexation of their two
~""'.IlI parcels.
NOT SCANNED Exhibit E - 10/3/94 memo responding to Mr. McGowan's 9/23/94 letter.
'>I OT SC&~[!J Planning Commission Resolution PCZ-91-D.
,. ':~: :~~:~AJ';}l.u.f.'!l Planning Commission Resolution PCS-91-02.
NOT SCANNED Minutes from the Planning Comntission meeting of September 14, 1994.
NOT SCAN'NED Minutes from the Resource Conservation Commission meeting of September 26, 1994
NOT SC~ Disclosure Statement.
F:\HOME\PLANNlNGIMARTINlBONIT A \9102A.113
1J.j.,,~
/
\":
~, .
eXHIBIT C
.Itiated Negative Declaratlo
.
.'
PIlOJECT NAME:
PIlOJECT LOCATION:
ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NO.:
PIlOJECT APPUCAN'l':
CASE NO: IS-91-15
Bonita Hills Executive Estates
Norlh of 1he Terminus of Moonview Drive
APN: 592.030-58. 592.030-57 aud 592.030-60
Michael AD1hony 1)en'lit'-b
DATE: August 26. 1994 .
.
A. Pro;ect Settin2
The proposed project consists of 1he annexation. prezoning aud processing of · tentative
subdivision map on a 8.37 acre parcel currently located in 1he County of San Diego to 1he
City of Cbula Vista and 1he annexation and prezoniDg of adjoining 5.86 acre parcels owned
by 1he Sweetwater Authority. The tentative subdivision map proposes to divide 1he 8.37 acre
property into 12 single family lots and two open space lots. The 8.37 acre site consists
primarily of a rectaDgUlar tract of land abutting Ibe Bonita Valley Reaervoir on 1he west.
oorth of the terminus of Moonview Drive. The 5:86 acre parcel to 1he eastCODtlIinc 1he 18.7
million gallon concrete Bonita Valley Reservoir covered wilb a two foot ear1heD -blanket"
over Ibe concrete tank on which sage scrub was seeded. Allbough 1his parcel is proposed for
annexation concurrently wilb 1he tentative map area. it will not be developed bee"'se of 1he
18.7 million because of Ibe presence of patcatchers and habitat. The IOU1herD end of 1he
subdivision property features a nor1h-facing slopes wi1h disturbed veptation which lfIdually
drops into a drainage wilb sage scrub. The terrain rises apin to Ibe nor1h 0Dt0 · barren
ridge1iDe. before dropping steeply. into Bonita Valley. On 1he eastern bol......ry aear 1he
center of Ibe site is a disturbed fill slope abutting a buried reservoir. The bi&b elevation is
308 feet at 1he south end of Ibe property. on a hillside below 1he existin& water tIDk while
1he low elevation is approximately 116 feet in 1he p,treme nortbwwllall c:oruer of 1he
property on . steep slope overk>>1mt& Bonita Valley.
.
.
.-
B.
Pro;eet Dest!rifttion
The ~ project is aD -...atitm to 1he City of CIula Vista aud prezonifll of
appro...m....ly eight acres aud subdivision of 1be" site iDto 14 loCI ill .....- to 1he ,-ution
aud ~I of 5.86 acres owued by 1he SweetWater Au1hority. TMlve of 1he aubdiviaion
lots will be for cleVeluyiJlelll of c:ustDID bomeS. twO of 1he'1ots will be dedu..tM opeD space
for plateetiOD of sensitive ..iruQ,.....nlll.l reIClIlIrCeI. SilIe accea will be Yia MooDYieW Drive
which will be pled at 1he enuance to 1he site.
--
The area of the tentative map is bounded by e~ting single family residences at the """'
northeastern and southwestern corners, water storage facilities at the eastern and southern
portions, a partially improved road at the northwest boundaries, Moon View Drive at the
southeastern corner, and undeveloped land at the remaining boundaries.
The Sweetwater parcels are bounded on the west by the tentative map parcel, to the north
by a single family residence, to the south partly by a parcel containing a water tmk and
another vacant parcel, and to the east by vacant land. Access is from Randy Lane off of
Bonita Road or from Moonview Drive through Terra Nova via East "H" Street. A pumping
house structure sits at the east central portion of the property.
The property to the north, east and west of both parcels is in the County of San Diego and
designated Residential-Low (0-3 dulac), Residential 1 and Residential S, respectively, on the
Sweetwater Community Plan. The property to the south (Terra Nova) is in the City of Chula
Vista and is designated Residential-Low Medium (3-6 du/ac) on the City's General Plan.
Zoning for the property to the north, east and west is RR-l (to the north and east) and RS-4
(to east and west). Terra Nova is zoned PC (planned Community) by the City of Chula
Vista.
The approximate areas for Lots 1 to 12 have been partly cleared. To tnitigate the "taking"
of coastal sage, the applicant is to conditioned to vegetate any disturbed areas and the parcel
immediately to the south containing the water tmk. This will also include irrigation. All
revegetated areas are to be monitored for a period of five years to ensure that native plants
develop into thriving plants capable of supporting themselves. The City of Chula Vista bas
posted a notice of proposal to issue a 4 (d) Coastal Sage Scrub Loss Pertnit in accordance
with the Endangered Species Act and the tnitigation plans and findings for that pertnit are
attached as part of this tnitigated negative declaration.
"""
C. Comoatibilitv with Zoninl! and Plans
The project site's General Plan designation in the County of San Diego is Residential-Low
(0-3 du/ac). The proposed City of Cbula Vista General Plan designation for the site is
Residential-Low (0-3 du/ac). The current zoning, under the County of San Diego is RR-l
(1 acre tninimum lot size). The proposed City of Cbula Vista zoning is RE-P for the
subdivision and RE-40 for the Sweetwater sites.
D.
Identification of Environmental Effects
.-
An initial study conducted by the City of Cbula Vista (including the attl'ch~ Enviromnental
Checklist Form) detertnined that the proposed project could have one or more significant
environmental effects. Subsequent revisions in the project design and/or specific tnitigation
measures will be implemented to reduce these effects to a level below significant. With
project revisions and/or mitigation, no significant environmental effects will occur, IDd the
preparation of an Environmental Impact Report will DOt be required. This Mitigated
Negative Declaration bas been prepared in accordance with Section 15070 of the State CEQA
C,INANCY\\DEMICH.JS\
Page 2
1
(11- It)
--'7-
.
.
.
Guidelines. Specific mitigation measures are set forth in the Mitigation Monitoring Program
which is attached as Attachment . A . .
The following impacts are those that were determined to be potentially signiflCa11t and are
required to be mitigated to a level below significant. A disc1lssion of each of these
potentially significant but mitigatable impacts from the proposed project follows.
JUOlnGICAL RESOURCES
'nstin2 Conditions:
A biological survey was performed on the 8.37-acre Bonita Hi11s Executive Esta1e site to identify
sensitive biological resources and constraints for future development of the site. The Biological
Assessment for the site is on file in the City of Chula Vista p1anni"g DeparttneDt. The survey
revealed that !he site is utilized by both Coastal Cactus Wrens and !he California Gnatcatcher. The
former inhabits sage scrub and cactus near !he ravine along !he western fenceline. and territories
extend off-site into higher quality habitat immediately west. The gnatcatchers were noted at the same
locale; as well as in sage scrub now growing on !he eastern boundary of the site and further into the
ear1hen seal for !he reservoir. Two easements of 1.21 and 1.50 acres. which represent
approximately 30% of the area of the tentative subdivision map is proposed as dedicated biological
open space to protect these sensitive birds and their habitat.
Two plants of limited sensitivity were noted: several California Adolphia grow near the ravine along
the western boundary, and eight San Diego Viguiera occur further upslope to the north. Habitat
quality varies widely on the property. with disturbed grasslands in the south aDd north, and fair to
good quality Diegan Sage Scrub covering much of the canyon's flanks in the center of the property.
Two vegetation types were present on the property: Diegan Sage Scrub and a very disturbed Annual
Grassland. Shrub diversity at !he Bonita Hills site is relatively limited. The more diverse sage scrub
is concentrated near the drainage along the western boundary. Unusual for the region is the high
incidence of California Encelia. which although a common plant. is rarely the dominant cover. Also
occurring is Coastal Sagebrush. Lemonadeberry in the more mesic canyon bottom. -Flat-top
Buckwheat. Spanish Bayonet and Black Sage. Near the wmern boundary. by the drainage. grows
some Jojoba. Coast Cholla. aDd further upslope San Diego viguiera in limited IlUlDbers.
The understory is relatively limited. Native elements include the late-flowering San Diego Want
Chicory. Bicolored Cudweed. Ocean Locoweed aDd California Filago. At ODe llt1fttlal1y moist
locale. along the southern boundary. near an irrigated residenrilll yard. is ODe Arroyo Willow and
a Great Marsh Evening Primrose. No other wetland species were seen on the property.
The disturbed ADDual GrasslandlDisturbed habitat includes an ~l"""'- of the DOxiouS Tecolote aDd
Wild Mustard. The overall quality of this grassland is considered poor. Much of the grassland
babitat in the south may have been c:reated during c:onsuuction of the adjacent buried reservoir.
Grassy areas on the ridge1ine in the north are likely the result of perIpberal resid-rill1 cIistL1rbaDCe.
PI&e 3
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-~.-
/ J/ - II
Of the species of plants that were recorded on the site, thirty-seven are non-native invasive elements.
None of these additional species is expected to be listed as sensitive.
"""'\
The Diegan Sage Scrub and Annual Grassland are habitat types for wildlife on the site. A small
canyon with a few large shrubs at the western end of the property is kept moist by suburban runoff.
This is an attractive area for Animal-life in an otherwise arid environment. Two sensitive species
of birds were observed utilizing the available sage scrub habitat, Coast Cactus Wren and California
Gnatcatcher.
No amphibian were observed. Only one species of reptile were observed. Fifteen species of birds
were observed on the site. Most of the species were associated with the natural sage scrub habitat.
As many as six Coastal Cactus Wrens were observed. One pair of California Gnatcatchers utilize
1his property. No nesting activity was detected, but the quality of the available sage scrub habitat
is rather good. A separate single gnatcatcher was seen and heard briefly to the northeast of 1his
property along Randy Lane, indicating their presence there as well. Another pair of gnatcatchers
uses the revegetated sage scrub covering the adjacent underground reservoir and the small tract of
sage scrub in the southeast (south of Moonview Drive).
Desert Cottontail was observed. Coyote was detected from its scat. California Ground Squirrel
burrows were found, and they undoubtedly occur on-site, particularly within the disturbed terrain.
Potential Environmental ImDacts:
Both the Riversidian phase and the Diegan phase of Coastal Sage Scrub have been severely reduced """'"
in total acreage over the last century. Along with the extensive reduction in sage scrub has come
a piecemeal fragmentation of larger tracts of such habitat. Isolation into small parcels devoid of
viable linkages to other similar lands has undercut the value of such lands.
Substantial redesign has eliminated initial significant biological impacts. Several adverse biological
impacts will result from the proposed 12-lot split.
. Loss of 1.5 acres of Diegan Sage Scrub. This habitat is severely declining in the
Bonita region due to urban development and its conservation is a focus of regional
planning for both Chula Vista and San Diego County. This highest quality sage
scrub is situated in proposed open space B. Impacted sage scrub is of lesser or
degraded quality.
. The loss of eight San Diego Viguiera are not considered biologically significant.
C,INANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
Page 4
""""
- C(-
/1-/2-
. t;:UL TURAL RESOURCES
~Dstlnl! Conditions:
An Arc:baeologica1lHistorical Assessment was prepared for d1e project lite to determine if any
significant cultural resources were present. The entire Cultural Resource Survey is on file in the
City of Chula Vista plannillg Department. Record searches were conducted at the San Diego
Museum of Man and the South Coastal Information Center at San Diego State Univetsity to identify
previously recorded archaeological sites within one mile of d1e site. No sites were recorded on the
project site, however, the record searches indicated that ten prehistoric sites have been recorded
within one mile of the property. All sites are located along ridge tops overlooking either side
drainages or the Sweetwater River.
In 1981, the project site was part of a larger survey for Sweetwater Authority for d1e Bonita Valley
Reservoir Site. As a result of the 1981 investigation, no cultural resources were recorded. The
1981 study concluded that the area had been a working farm for over thirty years. Historic maps
and aerial photographs do not reveal any pre-I942 farmsteads or activities on d1e site, although they
do reveal the farm activities mentioned in the 1981 report, occurring on the knoll top by 1944.
Although, according to the 1981 study, debris related to fanning was found on d1e site, none of it
was determined to be significant. No mitigation was required at that time.
.
The entire site was again surveyed for the current study in September, 1992. No prehistoric or
historic resources were located. Sprinkler heads were noted through the property suggesting the
possibility of past farming activities. Miscellaneous trash, asphalt and cement r1-nnb and pieces of
road gravel were noted primarily along the road. A small, abandoned area, liIcely the remnants of
a worker's camp containing trash and a wooden platform, was located in the southwest area. It was
determined to be non-significant, and therefore, no mitigation is necessary.
SOILS
Eldstlnl! Conditions:
A Soil and Geologic Reconnaissance was to prepared by Geocon,lDc. to provide preliminary
geotechnical information relative to the development of the proposed subdivision. The Geocon, Inc.
study is on file in the City of Chula Vista plannillg Department. Two geologic formations and two
surficial deposits were encountered during d1e reconnaissance. The geologic formations consisted
of Oligocene-aged Otay Formation and P1iocene-aged San Diego Faundation. The SUJfieial deposits
consisted of fill and topSOil. The Oligocene-aged Otay Formation is located near d1e northern portion
of d1e site. The Otay Formation does have contact with d1e YOUIIier (overlying) San Diego
Formation within d1e open space area of Open Space Lot . A. . The formation generally consists
of dense sandstone and claystones. Due to the formation bein& located only within the open space
area it sbould not be encolltn~ during grading for d1e proposed development.
The San Diego Formation (Tad) is a dense, 1anI1ight gray, sil1y, fine-grained (with some gravel)
associated with d1e San Diego Formation which appears to be d1e predominant formation underlying
.
Pace S
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-10_
/if-13
the site. Excavation within this unit will likely require moderate to heavy efforts with conventional
heavy-duty grading equipment. Localized cemented zqnes, if encountered, may require a very heavy ""'"
effort.
The San Diego Formation should provide suitable foundation engineering chiracteristics for proposed
ItrUCtures in either an undisturbed or properly compacted condition. Cut slopes and compacted fill
slopes constructed at 2: 1 (horizontal:vertica1) or flatter should generally be stable. These soils, when
used to construct fill slopes, are very susceptible to surficial erosion and should be properly planted
to reduce the potential for erosion.
Topsoils consisting of silty to slightly clayey, fine sands were observed overlying the formational
units and were visually classified as relatively "low" - expansive with observed thicknesses of
approximately 1 to 2 feet (where exposed) and may be as thick as 3 feet in some locations. Due to
the generally loose, unconsolidated nature of the topsoil, it should be removed and recompacted prior
to placing fill or structural loads .
There is a flU slope, on the site, associated with the underground reservoir east of the project site.
Where fills are proposed above the existing reservoir fill soils, these areas may require subsurface
investigation (trenches, etc) where structural improvements are considered. Other minor fills were
noted on, or adjacent to, the site. These soils will require additional investigation where
improvements are proposed. It is anticipated that the above-mentioned fills were derived from soils
similar to those previously discussed.
No evidence of landslides was found in previous reports or photographs and none were observed on
the site. No groundwater or seeps were observed during the reconnaissance.
""'"
The site is not located on any known active or potentially active fault trace. The Coronado Banks
Fault, which is considered to be active, lies approximately 18 miles west of the site. The Rose
Canyon Fault is located approximately 8 miles from the site and is the closest active fault to the site.
The site is located within the La Nacion Fault zone with the nearest splay approximately 1,600 feet
to the west. Regional active faults include the Elsinore Fault and the San Jacinto Fault zones, which
'lie approximately 41 and 62 miles to the northeast, respectively. In an event of a major earthquake
on these or other faults in the southern California region, the site could be subjected to moderate to
severe ground shaking. With respect to this hazard, this site is comparable to others in the general
vicinity. Due to the high density of prevailing formational soils at the site, anticipated reJDP.dial
grading of the surficial soils, and the lack of a permanent near-surface groundwater table, there does
DOt appear to be a significant risk of seiomil'.lll1y induced 1iquefaction occurring on 1he-1lroperty.
Mith~atloD Measures:
Conclusion:
No significant soil or geologic conditions have been observed or are known to exist which would
preclude development of the property. Provided the mitigation recommendations in the Geologic
Reconnaissance are adhered to there will be DO significant impact related to geology or soils.
Pase 6
"""'"
C:\NAIlCY\\DEMICH.JS\
- 11-
/~-/I
. nRAINAGEIHYDROLOGY
Jmtlnl! Conditions:
Due to the topography of the site, drainage is considered to be a poteDtially significant impact. A
Drainage Study was prepared for the site and is on file in the City of Chula Vista pJRnning
Department.
The subject property is dominated by a saddle located in the center portion of the property between
two knolls located on the northern and southern extremeS of the project. The proposed northern six
lots would be developed on the descending ridge1ine of the northern knoll. The southern six lots
would be located on the northern side of the southern knoll. The centta1 saddle descends to a canyon
and natural drainage course to the west. The northern ISO feet of the property is steep in grade and
would not be disturbed by the proposed project.
Due to the site's location in close proximity to hilltops, very little offsite land (approximately 1.1
acres) contribute to the study area's drainage basins. In a natural condition, only property to the east
would naturally drain towards the project. However, the drainage generated offsite to the east of
the site is collected in the Sweetwater Authority storm drain system and directed to the northeast
away from site.
.
The drainage study area consists of two well-i1efmed drainage areas. The area to the north of the
ridgeline of the northern knoll encompasses approximately 2.1 acres and generates 4.27 cubic
feet/second (cfs) of run-off in a l00-year storm. This water exits the project site in an even
sheetflow down the steep slope descending to the north of the site.
The second existing drainage area encompasses the majority of the project site which is located south
of the ridgeline of the northern knoll, along with a smal1 area off-site on the slope of the southern
knoll and portions of the canyon banks to the west. This basin generates an existing 18.14 cubic
feet/second (cfs) of run-off in a 100 year storm which is concentrated offsite into the flowline of the
smal1 canyon descending westerly from the central project site area.
A portion of the access road abutting the central portion of the site along its eastern boundary is part
of the proposed subdivision, however, it has not been included in the Drainage Study since the road
is already developed and its drainage is collected in the storm drainage system developed as part of
the underground reservoir. No change in this drainage is proposed as part of the proposed project.
ProDOSed Develoned ~InAI!e:
The developed drainage analysis is based on proposed site improvementS as shown on the 1entative
map for the project Chula Vista Tract Map No. 91-2 dated March 3, 1993. Tbe drainage basin areas
following site development will remain basically the same as in the existing COIIdition (see Figure
1). There would be little change in Drainage Area B. For the three lots proposed on the north side
of proposed Street .C. , the rearyards would sheet drain to the nortb and the ftontyards would drain
south to the street. Though there will be a small increase in Drainage Area B, it will be offset by
.
Paac 7
C:INAllCY\\DEMICH.JS\
~ .
,
-~ /Jf-15
the increased time of concentration due to the shallow slope of the proposed pad. Therefore, ~
although there will be a slight increase in drainage, it does not constitute a significant impact.
Figure 1 _ Drainage Basin after Development Drainage Area A will be impacted due to the
constrUCtion of a surface collection and underground drainage conveyance' system for the proposed
development. Some run-off from portions of Area A will be conveyed in a different mAnT\P.r than
in the existing condition. Drainage Subareas AI' Az, A3' ~ and A3' will be directed to the
underground storm drain system with its outlet in Lot B. Drainage Subareas ~ and A, will be
collected at the rear of the graded pads, directed to the rip rap energy dissipators to be located on
the north side of these lots, from which they will drain into the western canyon.
The Drainage Study concludes that there will be a slightly lower quantity of runoff after development
than in the existing condition, due to the drainage improvements that are proposed. This reduction
is due to the larger time of concentration caused by the change in landform and increased time for
the drainage to be routed in the street curb and gutter system prior to release in the underground
storm drains.
Erosion/Sedimentation:
There is minimal erosion currently from the site due to dense vegetation on the canyon slopes and
the sheetflow nature of the existing drainage pattern. In the developed condition, all of the drainage
subareas of Area A except for A3 will be concentrated, and thus increasing its erosive possibilities.
Drainage Subareas AI through ~ and ~ and A, have a total quantity of approximately 9.05 cfs. .........
If this quantity were released directly in a concentrated condition on the canyon sideslopes, the slopes
could erode and cause downstream siltation. This can be eliminated by extending the storm drains
to the flowline of the existing canyon and reducing the outlet velocities. The extension of the storm
drains to the flowline along with the proposed installation of rip rap and splashwalls would mitigate
the impact of the increased drainage from the proposed development.
WATER OUALITYIEROSION:
Due to the topography of the site, sedimentation could be a significant short- and long-term impact.
The long-term impact related to drainage has been addressed in the drainage section above with
appropriate mitigation measures recommended.
Erosion and sedimentation impacts during the grading and constrUCtion period would be short-term,
especially after storm events, and would be potentially signiflCllllt. These impacts woahtu:cur only
if adequate erosion control measures are not applied during and after the earthwork stage when
disturbed soil is left temporarily unprotected.
Long term erosion may occur from exposure of graded land if the area is not adequately JA""....aped
10011 after grading. These impacts are also considered to be potentially significant.
The applicant will be required to comply with the General National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (NPDES) permit issued to San Diego County by the State Water Resources Control Board
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
""""
Plse 8
- /3-
/'1-1.-6
~e;"i!};;~~~_
~ If
"
10-10-94
City of Chula Vista
City Council
1'-'.
Dear Members, We want to express our support for the
Bonita Hills Estates subdivision. We have been watching Mud come
down our way to Glen Abbe~ and Cordelle Lane for many many Years.
We are aware that most of this water and mud comes from quite a
few different parcels, Not just the Subdivision parcel that belongs
to Michael Demich. We have' been told that any and all hillsides on
the proposed subdivision site as well as any and all of the existing
slopes on the parcel adjacent to the subdivision shall be repaired'
and planted or replanted, and then monitored for a Five Year Period.
This should reduce the amounts of Mud and Water that come down to
Glen Abbey.
We are also hopeful that this subdivision will help increase
property values in the surrounding properties. The Community really
needs more High End Custom Homes like this one, rather than housing
t~acts and Condos and Apartments squeezed in on minimum lots.
"
\
Sincerely
Verne and Goldie May
.y~ jI. ~ .------
/~~, X1J7-
3365 Glen Abbey Blvd.
.-
) Lf... '1
~{:;
,
,
:tiIY
JUne 30, 1 992
Ibuglas D. Reid
City Planning Department
Post Office Box 1 087
Omla Vista, California 91912
Dear Sir:
Re: 1S-91-15
Bonita Hills Executive Estates
(Moonview Estates)
As owners of Parcel 592-030-56 we, Laurence A. & Gertrude Weisser, wrote you
on 4 Feb 1 991 regarding the proposed develo);llleIlt on this land which is iIm1ed-
iately adjacent to our property.
We stated in our 4 Feb 1 991 letter that we did not oppose the I gated entry I
as proposed by Michael Demich, the developer, but were concerned that our
access might be in jeapordy.
Since 4 Feb 1991 we have talked with Michael Demich several times, and have
been assured that he recognizes our right to ingress/egress via Moonview Dr.,
and we feel that there is no problem.
However, with vandalism and robbery continuing to in=ease at an alarming
rate we definitely are trore in favor of a gated entry system, and we trust
that the Planning Department will grant Michael Demich this feature for his
planned develoJ;JllElIlt which will afford protection to the haneowners of the new
develo);llleIlt, protection to the Bonita Valley Reservoir and will also prevent
a through traffic route fran Moonview Drive to Bonita Road.
!-Pst sincerely yours,
/ /; J,' .
;"au.t.<,,~ U" ,/(,~
.f/..t!A.t:r..u.J..L,.. ~-<-~e)
Laurence A. & Gertrude Weisser
Post Office Box 26
Bonita, California 91908
cc: Michael Demich
file
/'-I../b
October 11, 1994
TO:
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
John Goss, City Manager~
Robert A. Leiter, Director of Planning ;1jj1
VIA:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Department of Fish & Game Comments on the 4(d) Loss Permit (CS4-95-03)
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - Agenda Item No 14
The attached letter from California Department of Fish & Game was received after the Council
packet was distributed. The letter indicates basic agreement with the draft findings for the
proposed CSS loss permit, and mitigation measures as recommended by staff. However, it also
indicates the desire of California Department of Fish & Game for the City and other jurisdictions
to reach a regional consensus on the allocation of interim CSS loss within the San Diego
subregion. Staff is continuing to pursue this matter with California Department of Fish &
Game, U.S Fish & Wildlife Service, and other affected agencies. It should be noted that this
letter contains an error in referencing Open Space Lots A and B incorrectly This does not
affect the conclusions contained in the letter
(4dlosspr.rnem)
I~-/ /
STATE Of CALIfORNIA-THE RESOURCES AGENCY
PETE WILSON. Gowernor
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME
NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLANNING
8885 RIO SAN DIEGO DRIVE, SUITE 270
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92108
(619) 688-4268
@_:.'.
".
. .'
C_'
September 30, 1994
Douglas D. Reid
Environmental Review Coordinator
Planning Department
City of Chula Vista
Post Office Box 1087
Chula Vista, California 91912
Dear Mr. Reid:
The Department of Fish and Game (Department) Natural
Community Conservation Planning (NCCP) staff has reviewed the
Mitigated Negative Declaration and the findings for the issuance
of a 4(d) rule coastal sage scrub habitat loss permit for the
Bonita Hills Executive Estates, located in the Lynwood Hills area
in the City of Chula Vista. The proposed project is the
subdivision of 8.37 acres into 12 residential lots and 2 open
space lots and the pre-zoning of the remainder 5.86 acres to RE-
40.
The project as proposed will directly impact 1.5 acres of
coastal sage scrub and partially impact the use-areas of 2 pairs
of California gnatcatchers observed along the borders of the
project site, 1 to the west and the other to the east. Two pairs
of coastal cactus wrens are expected to utilize the project site
and will also suffer both the direct and indirect impacts
mentioned previously for the gnatcatchers. The project is
situated within the Core Biological Resource Areas and Linkages
"'''.p for th? M'-,ltiple Species Conservation Plan (MSCP) and is part
of the north-south connection between the Sweetwater and Otay
River drainages. The site is also within an urban area, with
remaining canyons as the current open space system.
The mitigation proposed in the Negative Declaration includes
the dedication of two open space lots on the property, Lots A and
B. The Negative Declaration states that Lot A contains 1.2 acres
of high quality coastal sage scrub and will be used as
mitigation, but the habitat map in the document identifies the
area as disturbed non-native grassland. Lot B is described as
containing 1.5 acres and being contiguous with high quality
gnatcatcher and cactus wren habitat off-site to the west. Lot B
contains primarily coastal sage scrub with some cactus patches.
Revegetation of 0.3 acres of disturbed grassland to coastal sage
scrub will also occur within Lot B as a mitigation measure.
I (j ~ /~
Mr. Douglas D. Reid
September 30, 1994
Page Two
The document mentions, but was not clear with respect to the
proposed storm drains and/or erosion control devices to be placed
in the open space or any permanent or temporary impacts on Lot B.
All impacts should be specified in the final Negative
Declaration. At a meeting held September 29, 1994 between
yourself and Terri Stewart of the NCCP Staff, it was clarified
that there will be temporary impacts from drainage out-fall
structures and that revegetation will occur. These amounts had
been calculated within the 1.5 acre figure of css loss stated in
the document.
The document references a Revegetation Plan, but none was
attached. Please provide this to the Department for review and
concurrence prior to project approval. The Negative Declaration
states the revegetation will be monitored for 3 years, while the
4(d) rule mitigation measures state the monitoring will occur for
5 years. The Final Negative Declaration should state 5 years as
the appropriate monitoring term.
The Negative Declaration did not discuss the use of any fuel
management zones for protection of homes against potential
wildfire occurring in the open space. The Department recommends
fuel zones be included in the development footprint and not in
the dedicated open space. If fuel zones are to be required
within the preserved coastal sage scrub habitat, mitigation will
be required.
The on-site mitigation (Lots A and B) totals 2.7 acres,
which is inconsistent with 4.2 acres of mitigation agreed upon
earlier by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service).
According to the Service's letter to the City of Chula Vista,
dated December 8, 1993, in addition to 1.5 acres of on-site open
space, preservation and enhancement of 3.0 acres on assessor
parcel 592-171-61 was also to be incorporated into the project's
mitigation. It is the Department's opinion that Lot A (1.2
acres) is not adequate as mitigation since it does not contain
coastal sage scrub, and that unless the 3 acres adjacent to the
project site, as agreed to by the Service, are preserved and
enhanced, the proposed mitigation does not meet 4(d) and NCCP
criteria. This was discussed at the September 29 meeting, where
you stated that property owned by the Sweetwater Authority in two
areas adjacent to the site will, in fact, be dedicated and
revegetated with coastal sage scrub species. You will be
clarifying the acreage figure, and have it included in the final
document.
11~/~
Mr. Douglas D. Reid
September 30, 1994
Page Three
The Department expects that the mitigation measures agreed
to in December, 1993 by the Service will occur if the project is
to proceed through the 4(d) rule process. These include: 1)
preservation, fencing and enhancement of the 3.0 acres of coastal
sage scrub on assessor parcel 592-171-61; 2) preservation of 1.2
acres of coastal sage scrub on-site; 3) revegetation of .3 acres
of coastal sage scrub on the project site; and 4) monitoring of
the restoration sites for a period of five years.
The Department will be able to concur with the project if
the following items (discus~ed above) are clarified and provided
to us:
1. delineation of the off-site open space lots, and
clarification of mitigation acreage;
2. delineation of the proposed revegetation area(s), and
present habitat type;
3. and detailed 5-year revegetation and monitoring plan.
In addition, the assurance that the dedication and
management of the open space will occur in perpetuity is
necessary as a condition of project approval. The City must
identify who will be the interim manager of the preserved
property. Ultimately this property may be managed as part of the
subregional MSCP preserve system.
Finally, the Department considers the project appropriate
for a Habitat Loss Permit pursuant to the California gnatcatcher
special 4(d) rule, provided that the City revise and resubmit
their 4(d) rule Habitat Loss Permit and include the above changes
in the final Negative Declaration. Additionally, the City and
surrounding jurisdictions need to resolve the issue regarding the
distribution of the 5% allowable take within the subregion prior
to the Department's final concurrence.
If you have questions or comments, please contact Terri
Stewart at the San Diego NCCP office at (619) 688-0117.
Sincerely,
fX~)\ TC./;f
William E. Tippets
NCCP Field Supervisor
cc's on next page
IL)-/~
Mr. Douglas D. Reid
September 30, 1994
Page Four
cc: Department of Fish and Game
Mr. Larry L. Eng, Ph.D.
Sacramento
Mr. Randy Botta
Mr. Tim Dillingham
San Diego
Mr. Gail Kobetich
u.S. Fish and wildlife Service
Carlsbad
File: Chron
TAS:WET:lcj
f4 -" IS
WILLIAM A HERSUM
3416 RANDY LANE
CHULA VISTA, CA. 91910
To.
City council, City of Chula Vista
From:
William A Hersum 3416 Randy Lane, Chula Vista, Calif.
Re:
Case no. PCS-91-02/ PCZ-91-D /IS-91-15
Gentlemen. I am unable to attend your public hearing regarding the above case,
however I do wish to express my support for the project and its approval. I
understand the developer proposes private roads and security gates for the project,
which the council is considering. I would also like to strongly register my support
for this concept versus public roads. I have lived very close to the project for
almost 50 years. In the old days, we never locked our doors and there was no
crime. As time has passed and with encroaching humanity, crime has increased in
the immediate area. With more and more public access, more and more criminals
are finding more and more targets of opportunity All of us in the five homes to
the immediate north and east ofthe project have been burglarized at least once..
Allowing the developer to have private roads with security gates would help limit
general, urmecessary traffic and would help us all feel just a little more secure in
our homes. Private roads and gates are frequently allowed in townhouse,
condominium, and plauned residential developments.. I strongly support their use
in this project.
Thank you.
d$..-'<-- f!
William A. Hersum
October 11, 1994
/If//h
.
for grading and construction activities. Individual projects fall under the General Permit issued to
San Diego County by filing a Notice of Intent (NOI), including a Storm Water pollution Prevention
Plan (SWPPP), with the State Water Resources Control Board prior to commencing grading
activities. The SWPPP also addresses runoff from the site after construction to ensure that the future
runoff is in compliance with the NPDES. Implementation of the recommeIided mitigation measures
will mitigate the impact of sedimf!ntation to less than significant.
E. Miti~ation NtI'~ssarv to avoid sim;fil"Jlnt effects
Specific project mitigation measures are required to reduce potei'tially signiflC811t
environmental impacts identified in the initial stUdy for this project to a level below
significant. Mitigation measures have been incorporated into the project design aDd have
been made conditions of project approval. as well as requirements of the ,ttlIlrbed Mitigation
Monitoring Program (Attachment "A").
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
.
Two dedicated open spaces are recommended, aDd have been incorporated into the tentative
map, which will include 1.2 acres of the higher quality Diegan Sage Scrub on-site in Area
A, and protect habitat for both the Coastal Cactus Wren aDd the california Gnatcatcher. The
California Adolphia will also be protected within these areas. The western open space (Area
B) is 1.5 acres and is contiguous with high quality cactuS wren aDd gnatcatcher habitat off-
site to the west. It also links the revegetated 1IIIds of the reservoir with this sage scrub-
dominated habitat (separated only by the existing paved road). Lot A covers a steep north-
facing slope with grassland habitat. SpecifIC mitigation measures to avoid specifIC significant
biological impacts are as follows:
1. No clearance of vegetation or other forms of habitat aDd soil disturbance sbal1 occur
within the dedicated open space areas (Lots A aDd B). with the exception of the
constrUction of the sewage pipes and storm drainage pipe. In such case. disturbance
sbal1 be at the minimum required to accommodate constrUCtion.
.
2. 0.3 acre of disturbed grassland Diegan Sage Scrub in Lot B sbal1 be revegetated in
accordance with the recommendations in the Pacific Southwest Biological Services
Assessment for the project dated September 4. 1992. Ntemilia ctJlifomictl. EnceUa
califomica. Eriogonumftucit:u/l1tUm. Dip1DcJls punictlU. aDd SDlvia melli/era should
be the principal shrubby components of this revegetation. A 1hree-yearmonitorin&
plan sbal1 be implemented to ensure the suc:cessful establishment of this scrub. The
0.3 acre constitutes the entire ares within Area B mapped as arassland.
Prior to consideration of any final subdivision or parcel map. issuance of a grading
permit, or issuance of a building permit for any portion of the project lite, proof of
an incidental take permit under Section 7. Section lOa of the EDdaDgered Species Act
or any other form of approval by the US Fish " Wildlife ServIce. relative to the
California GnatCl'tr.her or Coastal Sage Scrub. sbal1 be provided to the E.DviroDIDeDtal
3.
J>ase 9
C:\NANCY\\DEMlCH.IS\
- Ilf-/'7
Review Section of the Planning Department. If such permit is not required, written
verification to lhat effect from the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service shall be provided. """'\
Any project redesign required in obtaining a Section 7 or lOa permit may require
reconsideration by the appropriate City decisionmaldng body.
CULTURAL RESOURCES
No significant impacts were identified, therefore, no mitigation is necessary.
SOILS
4. All recommendations of the Soil and Geologic RecoDDaissance prepared for the
Bonita Hills Executive Estates by Geocon Incorporated, dated December, 1992, shall
be adhered to.
S. A 20- to 30- foot high near vertical slope wilhin the central drainage at the western
boundary may experience additional erosion. Consideration should be given in the
design process for future slope relation wilhin the immediate area.
6. All future geotechnical subsurface investigation for the site should include review of
the fill compaction report for the underground water reservoir at the eastern
boundary .
7.
The topsoils overlying the formational units will require remedial grading in the form
of removal and recompaction in areas of proposed improvement. A subsurface
investigation and laboratory testing will be required to determine actual depths of
removals.
"""'\
8. Existing fills in areas of proposed improvement should be evaluated during future
investigations .
9. Excavations wilhin the on-site soils should generally be possible with moderate to
heavy efforts with conventional heavy-duty grading equipment. Loc.ll1i7erl cemented
zone, if encountered, may require a very heavy effort.
10. Deleterious materials encountered during grading, such as tree roots, should be
excavated and disposed of off site.
11. Cut and fill slopes planned at inclinations of 2: 1 (horizontal:vertical) or flatter with
maximum heights of 13 feet should generally be stable against deep-seated failure.
12. Cut and f1lI slopes will be provided with an erosion-resistant ground cover and an
adequately designed and ma;nm;nf!d irrigation system as soon as practical to reduce
the erosion potential. Constructed slopes should be designed with appropriate
drainage systetns; water will not be allowed to discharge over the top of slopes.
Page 10
'""'"
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
- {$'_
/1-1 f?'
.
.
.
13. In general. the prevailing soil conditions in either a dense undisturbed or properly
compacted condition are suitable for the support of conventional isolated and
continuous spread footings. It is anticipated that .very low. expansive soils will be
encountered or will be placed as fill in the areas influencing future foundations.
Foundation design. including an allowable soil bearing 'Pressure and estimated
settlementS. should be incorporated within future geotechnical studies.
14. Prior to the fmalization of the grading and improvement plans. a detailed soil and
geologic investigation addressing the proposed development shall be performed.
DR.UNAGEIHYDROLOGY
15. All drainage improvements shown on Tentative Map 91-2 dated March 2. 1993.
including rip rap velocity dissipawrs at outlet locations on the banks of the existing
slopes. shall be implemented to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
16. Storm drains shall be extended to the flow line of the canyon. Outlets and energy
dissipators shall be designed to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
WATER OUALITYIEROSION:
17. The developer shall prepare an erosion and sedimentation control plan. in compliance
with the NPDES permit issued to San Diego County. for the proposed development
to address the impacts of short-term constrUction and grading activity. Said plan
shall be incorporated into the project's grading and construction plans and shall be
approved by the City Engineer prior to issuanCe of grading permits.
18. The project shall comply with the provisions of the State Water Resources Control
Board (State Water Board) Order Number 92-08-DWQ. National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES) General Permit Number CAS 000002. Waste Discharge
Requirements (WDRS) for Discharges of Storm Water Runoff Associated with
ConstrUction Activity including the preparation of a Storm Water Pollution Prevention
Plan.
19. All graded slopes shall be properly planted to reduce the potential for erosion.
J JlntI.,.. plans shall be subject to approval of the plAnning DireGUIr prior to
issuance of grading permits.
....ell
C:\NANCY\IIlEMICH.IS\
-liP ,
/J/-'19
F.
Consultation
"""'"
1. Individuals and Ornni7Jltions
City of ChuIa Vista: Marilyn R. F. Ponseggi, planning Consultant
Barbara Reid, planning
Roger Daoust, Engineering
Cliff Swanson, Engineering
Hal Rosenberg, Engineering
Bob Sennett, Planning
Martin Miller, Planning
Ken Larsen, Director of Building &. Housing
Carol Gove, Fire Marshal
Marylane Diosdada, Crime Prevention
Marty Schmidt, Parks &. Recreation Dept.
Rich Rudolf, Assistant City Attorney
Chula Vista City School District: Kate Shurson
Sweetwater Union High School District: Tom Silva
Applicant's Agent: Michael Anthony Demich
2.
Documents
"""'"
ChulaVista General Plan (1989) and ElR (1989)
Title 19, Chula Vista Municipal Code
Biological Assessment of the Proposed Bonita Hills Estates, City of Chula Vis ta ,
California, prepared by Pacific Southwest Biological Services, IDe., September 4,
1992, revised March 16, 1993 (Appendix "A")
Cultural Resources Survey of the Proposed 8.9 acre Demich Subdivision ChuIa ViII
Tract #91-2, ChuIa Vista, California, prepared by Roth and Associates, September,
1992 (Appendix "B")
Soil and Geologic Reconnaissance for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, ChuIa Vista,
California, prepared by Geocon,IDe., ~her, 1992
(Appendix "CO)
Drainage Study for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, prepared by XinoI-Enterprises,
Inc., March 31, 1993 (Appendix "D")
C:INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
Pase 12
~
- 1r'J-
/Jf-j},o
.
.
.
3.
Initial Studv
This environmental determination is based on the attached Initial Study as well as any
comments on the Initial Study and this Mitigated Negative Declaration. and reflects
the independent judgement of the City of Chula Vista. Further information regarding
the environmental review of the project is available from the Chula Vista planning
Department. 276 Fourth Avenue. Chula Vista. CA 91910.
fi~ ~J
ENVIRO NTAL REVIEW COORDINATOR
EN 6 (Rev 5/93)
Pale 13
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
-f{-
IJ/-';U
Case No. IS 91-15
APPENDIX I
""""
ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST FORM
(To Be Completed By Lead Agency)
Background
1. Name of Proponent: Michael Anthonv Demich
2. Address and Phone Number of Proponent: 3356 Glen Abbev Boulevard. Chula Vista.
California 92010. (619) 427-5005
3. Date of Checklist: AUl!Ust 26. 1994
4. Name of Proposal: Bonita Hills Executive Estates
5. Initial Study Number: IS-91-15
Environmentallmpacts
1. Earth. Will the proposal result in: m MAYBE liQ """"
a. Unstable earth conditions or changes in
geologic substructures? 0 . 0
b. Disruptions. displacements. compaction or
overcovering of the soil? 0 . 0
c. Change in topography or ground surface
relief features? 0 0 .
d. The destruction, covering or modification
of any unique geologic or physical features? 0 0 .
e. Any increase in wind or water erosion of
soils. either on or off the site? 0 . 0
f. Changes in deposition or erosion of beach
sands. or changes in siltation, deposition
or erosion which may modify the rlla"T1P.I of
a river or stream or the bed of the ocean or
any bay, inlet or lake? 0 0 .
""""
C:INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\ PIge 14
- (~- /422-
.
g.
Exposure of people or property to geologic
hazards such as earthquakes, landslides, mud
slides, ground failure, or similar hazards?
o
o
.
Comments:
Potential geological impacts are addressed in the Soils section of the Negative Declaration.
The Geological Reconnaissance prepared for the site concludes that if the mitigation measures
recommended in the Report are incorporated into the project the impact is mitigated to a level
of less than significant. Any potential impact due to erosion is discussed and mitigated in
the DrainagelHydrology section of the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
2.
Air. Will the proposal result in:
m MAYBE
~
a.
Substantial air emissions or deterioration
of ambient air quality?
b.
The creation of objectionable odors?
o
o
o
o
.
.
C.
Alteration of air movement, moisture, or
temperature, or any change in climate,
either locally or regionally?
o
o
.
.
Comments:
Deterioration of regional air quality would not result from the proposed subdivision. The
number of vehicle trips anticipated from the development are minimal as are potential
emissions.
3. Water. Will the Proposal result in: m MAYBE ~
a. Changes in currents, or the course or
direction of water movements, in either
marine or fresh waters? 0 0 .
b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage
patterns, or the rate and amount of
surface runoff? 0 . 0
c. Alterations to the course or flow of .-
flood waters? 0 0 .
d. Change in the amount of surface water
in lIlY water body? 0 0 .
e. Discharge into surface waters, or any
alteration of surface water quality,
. including but not limited to temperature,
dissolved oxygen or turbidity? 0 0 .
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\ Pqe 15
-~- 1~.....;;.3
f.
g.
h.
i.
Alteration of the direction or rate of
flow of ground waters?
.
o
o
~
Change in the quantity of ground waters,
either through direct additions or
withdrawals, or through interception of
an aquifer by cuts or excavations?
o
o
.
Substantial reduction in the amount of
water otherwise available for .public
water supplies?
o
o
.
Exposure of people or property to water
related hazards such as flooding or
tidal waves?
o
o
.
Comments:
Mitigation measures related to erosion and water quality have been included in the Mitigated
Negative Declaration/Initial Study. Additional drainage improvements have been designed
into the project. Landscaping must meet all City requirements regarding slope protection and
water conservation.
4.
Plant Ufe. Will the proposal result in:
m MAYBE
~
a.
Change in the diversity of species, or
number of any species of plants (including
trees, shrubs, grass, crops, and aquatic
plants)?
o
.
o
~
b.
Reduction of the numbers of any unique,
rare or endangered species of plants?
o
. 0
c.
Introduction of new species of plants into
into an area, or in a barrier to the normal
replenishment of existing species?
o
o .
d.
Reduction in acreage of any agricultural
crop?
o
o _.
Comments:
Potential biological impacts are addressed in the Biological Resources section of the Negative
Declaration. The Biological Assessment prepared for the site concludes that if the mitigation
measures recommended in lhe Repon are incorporated into the project, in addition to lhe
mitigation measure already incorporated into the project, the impact is mitigated to a level
of less lhan significant.
~
C:INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
~ .,;t. I _
Pale 16
l/f-.;?t
. S. AnImal Life. Will the proposal result in: m MAYBE HQ
a. Change in the diversity of species, or
numbers of any species of animals (birds.
land animals including reptiles. fish and
shellfISh, benthic organisms or insects)? 0 . 0
b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique,
rare or endangered species of lInimllls? 0 . 0
c. Introduction of new species of lInimllls
into an area, or result in a barrier to
the migration or movement of lInimlll~? 0 0 .
d. Deterioration to existing fish or wildlife
habitat? 0 . 0
.
Conunents:
Potential biological impacts are addressed in the Biological Resources section of the Negative
Declaration. The Biological Assessment prepared for the site concludes that if the mitigation
measures reconunended in the Report are incorporated into the project, in addition to the
mitigation measure already incorporated into the project, the impact is mitigated to a level
of less than significant. The mitigation measures include a requirement for obtAining project
approval from the U.S. Department ofFish and Wildlife due to the presence of Gnatcatchers
(recently listed as Threatened by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service) and Diego Sage Scrub
on the site and the issuance of a 4 (d) Coastal Sage Scrub (CSS) loss permit in accordance
with the Endangered Species Act.
6. Noise. Will the proposal result in: XES MAYBE HQ
a. Increases in existing noise levels? 0 0 .
b. Exposure of people to severe noise
levels? 0 0 .
Comments:
Noise levels will not change as a result of the proposed project.
m MAYBE HQ
7. LIght and Glare. Will the proposal produce
new light or glare? 0 0 .
Comments:
The proposed subdivision will not produce any IigDificant light or glare.
.
Pqe17
C:\IIAIlCY\\DEMICH.IS\
- d-~-
11f-~
m MAYBE m2
.......
8.
Land Use. Will the proposal result in a
substantial alteration of the present or
planned land use of an area?
o
o
.
Comments:
The proposed subdivision's density is compatible with the City's General Plan for the
adjacent area and the existing County Sweetwater Community Plan's land use designations
and Zoning for both parcels are equivalent to the Chula Vista's Plan density and zoning.
Annexation, prezoning and a General Plan Amendment are part of the project.
9.
Natural Resources. Will the proposal result in:
m MAYBE
m2
a.
Increase in the rate of use of any natural
resources?
o
o
.
Comments:
The proposed subdivision would not cause a change or increase in the rate of natural resource
consumption.
10. Risk of Upset. Will the proposal involve:
m MAYBE
HQ
.......
a.
A risk of an explosion or the release of
hazardous substances (including, but not
limited to oil. pesticides, chemicals or
radiation) in the event of an accident or
upset conditions?
o
o
.
b.
Possible interference with an emergency
response plan or an emergency evacuation
plan?
o
o
.
Comments:
The proposed park improvements would not cause a risk of upset in the City. The project
will not release toxic or hazardous material into the environment during up~itions.
11. Population. Will the proposal alter the location
distribution. density, or growth rate of the humAn
population or an area?
ns MAYBE
o 0
HQ
.
Comments:
Although the project does involve the future constrUction of single family homes, the twelve
homes proposed do not represent a significant increase in the population. """'I
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
Page 18
-';>-3-
/tf-,J,b
. 12. Housing. Will the proposal affect existing m MAYBE l::iQ
housing, or create a demand for additional
housing? 0 0 .
Comments:
The proposed subdivision will create rwelve new ~ingle family homes.
13. Transportation/Circulation. Will the proposal result in: m. MAYBE ~
a. Generation of substantial additional
vehicular movement? 0 0 .
b. Effects on existing parking facilities,
or demand for new parking? 0 0 .
c. Substantial impact upon existing
transportation systems? 0 0 .
d. Alterations to present patterns of
circulation or movement of people
and/or goods? 0 0 .
e. Alterations to waterborne. rail or air
. traffic? 0 0 .
f. Increase in traffic hazards to motor
vehicles, bicyclists or pedestrians? 0 0 .
g. A "large project" under the Congestion
Management Program? (An equivalent of
2400 or more average daily vehicle trips
or 200 or more peak-hour vehicle trips). 0 0 .
Comments:
The minimum number of trips that will be generated by the development of 12 single family
dwellings will not have a significant impact on traffIC. No road segments will be adversely
impacted by these additional homes.
.-
14. Public Services. Will the proposaI have an effect upon or result in a need for new or altered
governmental services in any of the following areas:
m ~AYBE l::iQ
a. Fire proteCtion? 0 0 .
b. Police protection? 0 0 .
. c. Schools? 0 0 .
d. Parks or other recreational facilities? 0 0 .
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.IS\ Pqe 19
-d- ~ ___ I Jf-:l.7
e.
Libraries?
o
o
.
f.
Maintenance of public facilities, including
roads?
~
o
o
o
.
g.
Other governmental services?
o
.
Comments:
The Fire and Police Deparunents can provide an adequate level of fire protection for the
proposed subdivision without an increase in equipment or personnel. The proposed Bonita
Hills Estates has been annexed to the Sweetwater Union High School District's Community
Facilities District No. 5 which will mitigate any impact this future development may have
had on school facilities. Adequate park, recreational and library facilities are existing in the
immediate area to serve the slight population increase from the proposed development.
15. Energy. Will the proposal result in:
m MAYBE
!:ill
a.
Use of substantial amount of fuel or energy?
o
o
.
b.
Substantial increase in demand upon
existing sources or energy, or require
the development of new sources of
energy?
o
o
.
~
Comments :
The proposed subdivision will not have any impact on energy or fuel consumption.
16.
Thresholds. WilI the proposal adversely impact
the City's Threshold Standards?
m
o
MAYBE
o
NQ
.
Comments:
As described below. the proposed project does not adversely impact any of the seven
Threshold Standards.
A. FirelEMS
The Threshold Standards requires that fire and medir.aJ units must be able to respond
to calls within 7 minutes or less in as'1li of the cases and within 5 minutes or less in
75'11i of the cases. The City of Chula Vista has indic.ated that this threshold standard
will be met, since the nearest fire station is 3 1/2 miles away and would be
associated with a 6 minute response time. The proposed project will comply with
this Threshold Standard.
B. Police
The Threshold Standards require that police units must respond to 84 '1Ii of Priority
I calls within 7 minutes or Jess and mamtll;n an average response time to a1J Priority
~
C:INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
Pase 20
--~,... -
I ~F:?8'"
.
1 calls of 4.5 minutes or less. Police units must respond to 62.10% of Priority 2
calls within 7 minutes or less and maintain an average response time to all Priority
2 calls of 7 minutes or less. The proposed project will comply with this Threshold
Standard.
C.
Traffic
The Threshold Standards require that all intersections must operate at a Level of
Service (LOS) "C" or better, with the exception that Level of Service (LOS) "D"
may occur during the peak two hours of the day at sigJ'~li71'i1 intersections.
Intersections west of I-80S are not to operate at a LOS below their 1987 LOS. No
intersection may reach LOS "E"' or "F" during the average weekday peak hour.
Intersections of arterials with freeway ramps are exempted from this Standard. The
proposed project .ElL comply with this Threshold Standard.
East "H" Street is currently over capacity. However, implementation of this project
will not significantly impact existing conditions since only 130 average daily trips will
be generated from the proposed subdivision.
D. Parks/Recreation
The Threshold Standard for Parks and Recreation is 3 acres/I ,000 population. The
proposed project ..ElL comply with this Threshold Standard.
.
E.
Drainage
The Threshold Standards require that storm water flows and volumes not exceed City
Engineering Standards. Individual projects will provide necessary imProvements
consistent with the Drainage Master Plan(s) and City Engineering Standards. The
proposed project will comply with this Threshold Standard.
A drainage study was prepared for the proposed project which is discussed in detail
in the "Drainage" section of the Initial Study /Negative Declaration.
F. Sewer
.
The Threshold Standards require that sewage flows and volumeS not eltcee<l City
Engineering Standards. Individual projects will provide ~sary imRrovements
consistent with Sewer Master Pian(s) and City Engineering Standards. The proposed
project will comply with this ThreShold Standard.
The project site is proposed to be annexed from 1be COUDly of San Diego to the City
of Chu1a Vista. The City Fng;_ will require sewer aervice to be approved by the
County of San Diego as a condition on the subdivision map. J.a. .......ents will be
required to be entered into with the COUDly by the App1icantlCity for perpetual
provision of sewer aervice and easemen~ to the subdivision as a condition of
approval on the tentative map.
C:\NANCY\\DEMlCH.JS\
Pqe11
-~~-
11-~1
,
G. Water
The Threshold Standards require that adequate storage, treatment, and transmission
facilities are constructed concurrently with planned growth and that water quality
standards are not jeopardized during growth and construction. The proposed project
will comply with this Threshold Standard.
'"""
Applicants may also be required to participate in whatever water conservation or fee
off-set program the City of Chula Vista has in effect at the time of building permit
issuance.
17. Human Health. Will the proposal result in:
ns MAYBE
~
a.
Creation of any health hazard or potential
health hazard (excluding mental health?
o
o
.
b.
Exposure of people to potential health
hazards?
o
o
.
Comments:
The proposed subdivision would not have an adverse impact on human health or safety. No
hazardous or unsafe conditions are associated with the project.
18.
Aesthetics. Will the proposal result in:
m MAYBE
~
a.
The obstruction of any scenic vista or view
open to the public, or will the proposal
result in the creation of an aesthetically
offensive site open to public view?
'"""
o
o
o
.
b.
The destruction, or modification of a scenic route? 0
.
Comments:
There are no scenic highways in the vicinity of the site that will be affected by the future
development of homes on the site.
19. ReCreation. Will the proposal result in an
impact upon the quality or quantity of existing
recreational opportunities?
m MAYBE
o 0
~
.
Comments:
No recreational facilities will be directly impacted by the proposed project. Less than fifty
new residential units would be developed and therefore, DO additional parkland dedication is
required in accordance with City thresholds. Park fees will be required at the time building
permits are issued in ICCOrdance with City (lfdinRTIC.l!S.
""'"
C,IHANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-;)., -
Page 22
PI-dO
20.
Cultural Resources.
m tdAYBE
.
a. Will the proposal result in the alteration
of or the destrUction or a prehistoric or
historic archaeological site?
o .
b.
Will the proposal result in adverse
physical or aesthetic effects to a
prehistoric or historic building, strUCture,
or object?
o
.
c.
Does the proposal have the potential to
cause a physical change which would
affect unique ethnic cultural values?
o
.
d.
Will the proposal restrict existing
religious or sacred uses within the
potential impact area?
o
o
e.
Is the area identified on the City's
General Plan EIR as an area of high
potential for archeological resources?
o
o
~
o
.
o
.
.
.
Comments:
A Cultural Resources analysis has been prepared for the project and is discussed in detail in
the Negative Declaration!1nitial Study. No significant historic or pre-historic sites were
located on the property.
21.
Paleontological Resources. Will the proposal result in the
alteration of or the destrUction of paleontological
resources?
m MAYBE
o 0
Comments:
There is no evidence of paleontological resources on the project site.
1m
.
22. Mandatory Findings of SlgDificaDce.
xu ~YBE ~
a.
Does the project have the potential to degrade the
quality of the envir()Il1DeI1t, substantially reduce
the habitat of a fish or wildlife species, cause
a fish or wildlife population to drop below self
susm;n;ng levels, threaten to eliminate a plant
or animal community, reduce the DUmber or
restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant
.nmal or eliminate importaI1t examples or the
major periods of California history or prehistory? 0
o
.
.
C,INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-~-
p-l-.J I
PqeU,
Comments:
Mitigation measures have been identified to reduce the impact to the Gnatcatcher and Diegan
Sage Scrub on the site to a level of less than significant. Open Space areas have been
included in the design of the tentative map and approval of the project by the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service will be required as a condition of approval of the Tentative Map.
b.
""'\
Does the project have the potential to achieve
short-term goals to the disadvantage of long-
term, environmental goals? (A short-term
impact on the environment is one which occurs in
a relatively brief, definitive period of time,
while long-term impacts will endure well into the
future.) 0
o
.
Comments:
All significant impacts related to the site have been mitigated to below a level of significance.
The proposed subdivision does not propose long-term risks to health and safety. The
proposed project does not have any interim use of the site while awaiting ultimate
development.
c.
Does the project have impacts which are
individually limited, but cumulatively
considerable? (A project may impact two or
more separate resources where the impact on
each resource is relatively small, but where the
effect of the total of those impacts on the
environment is significant.)
o
o
.
""""
Comments:
There are no significant cumulative impacts associated with the project.
d.
Does the project have environmental effects
which will cause substantial adverse effects on
human beings, either directly or indirectly?
o
o
.
Comments:
All significant impacts have been mitigated to a level of less than significant.
""""
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
.-;)-'f-
Pase 24
1~-32-
I~
.
A'ITACHMENT 3
Exhibit C
Mitigated Negative Declaration
and
Mitigation Monitoring Program for 18-91-15
.
.
-~--
.
.
.
IIEIIOIlANDU'1I
July 9, 1993
File No. YS-457
TO:
FROM:
Marilyn ponseggi, Bnvironmental Consultant
Samir M. Nuhaily, Civil Bnginee~~
SUBJECT: Drainage Study for Bonita Hills Bxecutive Estates,
received April 1, 1993
This memorandum is in response to your telephone discussion this
morning with Kirk Ammerman, Assistant Engineer II, with respect to
the subject drainage study. We reviewed this study in early April
and found that it adequately addresses our concerns as expressed in
Item 1.e. of the Initial Study Review, and as reiterated in our
previous memorandums dated August 25, 1992 and October 19, 1992.
If you should have any questions regarding the above, please
contact me at 691-5173 or Roger L. Daoust, Senior Civil Engineer,
at 691-5259.
KPA/kpa
cc: Roger L. Daoust, Senior Civil Engineer
William A. Ullrich, Senior Civil Engineer
Gena Franco, Civil Engineer
.-
!A.D-." ....,
- 30 ,
-
~
ROUTING FORM
RECEIVED ..: eEl V E 0
Mii ~ _, NAY 0 4 1992
- I,..:g(
Ma)' I, 199Z ..... PLANNING Pl.ANNING DEP.t.
lCen Larson, Blinding a HOllsing ,
John Lippitt, (ngineering IEIR on,y}
C1Uf Swanson, Engineering ElR only...
Hal Rosenberg, Engineering EIR only
Roger Daollst, Engineerfng IS/3, 'EIR/2) ,
Rfchard RlIdolf, Assistant City Attorney (EIR on'y)
Carol Gove, Ffre Department
Mtrty Schmfdt, 'arks a Recreation
Kefth Hawkfns, 'olfce Department
II -. I
- . "
Ed Batchelder rll~lXxttt~I, Advance Planning
lob Sennett, City Landscape Archftect
Bob Leiter, Planning Director
Chill. Vista Elementary School Distrfct, ICtte Shllrson
Sweetwater Unton H.S. Dfstrfct, Tom Sflva (IS l EIR)
Other Sweetwater Authority
DATE:
TO:
~
FROM: Marilyn Ponseg9i Environmenta' Stctfon
SUBJECT: I!!J Application for Inf~ial Stlld)' (IS- 91-15 IFA- 501 lOP 794 ,~
D Checkprint Dr.ft EIR (20 days)(EIR- Ira- lOP .
D Review of a Draft EIR (EIR- IFB- lOP )
0 Review of Environmental Review Record Fe- IERR- )
".
The prOject cons,fsts of: Resubmittal of PCS-91-0Z, now clll
Executive Estltes (formel)' cllled oonview Estltes
13 proposed custom single flmily h
gated entrlnc:e.
Locatfon: End of Moonview Drtve off of ~mok~ Circ:le
'llase revfew the c10CUllllnt and forward to .. any c....nts you IlIve .,~.
Coa.nents: Please he adviser! that the property \1!l1~h conprise t~e prop~secl r:c>r;it~ lIills
Estates ~as beer. annexe~ tQ the SI"/cetl-:ater Union high School D1Strict 5 CO~I.r.hy
Factlities District l!o. r-. This ec:tior. has t:litigater. the flntic:ipr.ted secor.roll,:"Y '""
school i!:1pacts this pro,fect \/in have on the district. lio fldditional mitigatlor. is
. necess& ... I
- 31 -
..as 1 va
Assistant Director of Planning
'.
.
.
.
"
- 13 -
Cue No. IS.q-t5
H. FIRE DEPARTMENT
--
1.
What is the distance to the nearest fire suvon and ~at is the Fire
Department6..Aa:t~ted reaction time? ~fl::J..., A-Y1:.I,.,..
'<<,4 .
IIill the Fire De artment be able to provide an adequate level of fire
protection for propose~ facili~ without an increase in equipment
or personnel?
2.
3.
Remarks
IlnOftjM )
Flre ~~~
Dat/;~/9 az-
-3:J--
, ,
.'/' s..., 01-1 i;
- ' - " ~ ..'
"IJ" lill!
TrfH.C q /-C;::J..
i
ClllILi. VI'.,lI, Hill. DLPT\IlH\!.NT
Illl:lU.U uf r I i,[ PI~[V[tfl i Ul.
-..,
r' '" -".,.,' "'I-I' . 1"'11
_L~~.!..~\!<:'~_~!.......:!~il. ._
.\d d rH t.~!.q,.'f,{1{ ;",l, f!.ttt: J
.
,.. III 'd,o,.,.Jlc;lu.' (JoJleJl.l~!fQ
:'I'Ji'j,~~ 111,1:.. r,.I'~';J____ __.___
1'1.)11 nie :ju.
Typ:- Constr,
)':'.:I;:,',II\. 't'
ih~.
The 1011"\';;09 li$~ (1"'I.~' 1l0. n(~(.I:~!..;r'~l~. i1.:..;lj.tp' ,\11 ~:-",...~. ,):"J u.d~siclI:'.
PROVI DE /.::0 SHO!~ 011 PLr,~I:
.L.J;d)tir1.~ 1..{.A~~ It I J A/I # -1(.t~!..:- '~~~!L/&ll&1!.tf. ..
C A ~. I d" r1
L.'(Jj.r.(C,f!l ,I) _lJXJftP1..-_.~~:. 1-1-[1 .j.JiL . ':dL~d_~.~$io.~,:,:"j.-,={~ ~~i
~_ _ P t /if tic! Q ~_I(l'i f.2:u,(L:...J-_. tl._.c::!..~f.~'-, .' (; ~.:[.?{~~.,j ) /,.,1, (.l/.{.y-~, ~J -
/ I 'J ~ t. '/.. jJ;' I !. ," f ~ " .rs
~tl) L,II 1'/) fi {I/(t..!~,.,(. ..)" .~ fI,;~1.Jt l' "f.:-l'/~I'J/I'1." rl..,
--" \. ~:1 .1"..:::._. J_ lL~ ..~....._- ___i':"___ ..r\-=.l........--._.-~ ~:1.:..-= .L..f._ .._
( ~ I r. ' I ,I, .'1 . ,
:J. . ' titttf. tJ' !!..:::b_.dJL'[f.Jr..IJLC.it.L~,'}:tl..AI'i. UlN.-:1:tLLf/,.__._
I}. .- I l , ,/, ()
.. r2lJ 1 UA:W ~~~:r.J ./...( f.:-l(d. _. (L!Ji:1:td_.___.________~___..
.?L _5, v<."'-c....._.s.'+:i;:::..t_~.~\~_'{:.~_'I..,..;,.'~Q c~.r 'l,A.'r' ~~.s;,~~ ,l-(.~.s.~.~!;:.
Lt'?.. ("..e., d" r:.:..~r ",,"!:!:r _.c_.;.,Jol.....~J:!J~.!."J_~q"y..!.'j,. ____..__
., _'-.J~ :...J.... 'C '... ( _~. ~,:".!..--=.i(1.!"',,,,{ I ~ .- ~i...~.L'_'J:.s- I.v, l.L b <l....l:.!tj..l.U.!:.!.J_____
S"'r O<...'1..,.t~I,I...t\,~~.~"y_l,.._t"':!!:....b.l:~...........:r. .p~,.~;..~_t:'_~_-:!:..___.
~\tr of....... t....." II c ~ ~~~\:: ~~.. c: $t:,,"''1 " S;_.~'T'" 1:"....... I ~,,' ~tu::I~._.
c;:'\..~ (lL..()(o..'t~.!........'t..~.s.!;._.:.~~_C.r,:,~:._..__..___._._. .__ _
[', ~_jl-L....CP.J"I_Lk~" <.
~11919;2 -~~-.
S!::{J.I
--
.-. .--....--
,
~.a-<4'..L -
..-.-.--..-----..-..- - ....---...-.----.....---
""'"
--
FPll-29
:3 =3.-
I
,/5."'57
. Casl No. ~
G.
.
.
1. GWw1
a.
Js thl project 11tl within a flood plain? ~
Jf .0, .tatl which FEMA Floodwl1 Fnqulnq un ar,y
~/A
,
b.
What 11 the location and dlscr1ption of
drainage facilities? - v
~
on-site
~ ."u:rs.
UT"WA--rp'
.
",~~T'V ~ AIoLr>, Sv~f: Ff.cH 'ft> Co\NYol5.
Arl thlY a equatl tG'llrvl thl project? Lln.
If not, explain briefl,y. ....'DI>,,,,,,.....L -. ..........1:: AC:I1..~- "",u.-
G!:. <II!P~IJ'~ "'I"C &lJV.EY fEU"no='l::' ~l2t>M ~......... ...~ ft~I-"T/ca.1
~ 4ioME: ~1~nlo1" ".l&.2:n.. .
What is the location and description of existing ~ff-site
drainage facn itieS? OtJT~"'U. ""'" . ~~'- ..... 'Y'blJ~
c.
d.
(J)J;;I
Vp ~
~'t c:.~ IA$ 0.. 'lte::&- I.
I. Are they adequate to lerve the proj
If not, e p'la1n briefly.
Iv .
S;~::...J:.'"'a ..J. ,~
2. ~n"mr~ l'C' - u~.
a. What roads lroVide primary acclss to the project? FAA:r' "fot.
~Tt2e:~ _w,n...-.r vli::nl DrtIIlE.
b. What is the estimatld lIumber of onl-way auto trips to be
,- generated by thl project (per day)? J3or> AY7r
c.
What is the ADT and estimated llvll
projlct completion?
Before
A.D. T. z:o.. -- If M .. or. - !ib.c.I!iR
UII>!>~ 1It~ ~._UAlu.~'AI
L.O.S. ~ "11""" - ~~ "/!!"
Plz:lO~ ,,~ ~ .-UAllt.t'w'
of lervice before and aftlr
After
~A9r.U"(1r.- Go.S"1o
~~ l'~ UZ' - IINllNbW"r
~. ." _ ~'I;"fl
JI'rJI')r:~~"c:nl. .. .-IJIJ~
Jf thl A.'O.T. or L.O.S. 11 unknown or lIot applicable, explain
brt.nj- ..,.... ....,I!:J, ~IAl''PC' Mer AVA I'" ..~.. ~a ..,,- - -, ~1C..Ta "'..1VE.
d.
Are thl primary acce.. roads adlquate to .ervl thl projlct? If
1I0t, explain brilfly. ~ "14" F' ".r loS "~"".,,..n.v rJ'-'-
~A-l!.I,.y. Uow&'Io1!!:L ;MJ>L.I!.U'IJ77&TJDAI 1# 9llE~ ..,t'~
;;; ~~'..J~...7;::;;.;.;;y )MJI'~G'" #Jl.Jc.<raM. "1>A1b'''''~C.. . .
3 cI-
_'A_
---.- -.---
.
YS-'tS7
Case No. ~~-ql-l5'
e. Are there any intersections at or "lIr the ,oint that wnl
result in an unaccephble Level of Service (LOS)? NO. 'f'I/!DJfEcr IttIII.L. Ne>T
If so, identify: Location A.f./A """VI!. fi>/~JJ,r::I'~1'T' '''''PHoT.
Cumulative L.O.S. II{/"'.
f. Is there any dedication required? r~.
If so, please specify. U:I ~_%>r::_c..., SO~ OF ~-- u ~I{~
~J JrzrrY ~~. A~'~ur 6uJ.LL. OIJ-rAIU Pr2t)PrIZ. ttt&...w-er l~Y ,to!
Gl,.It.~E:-iioI.e NlT::> TlftW ~"""'TJ;: ~. '7Jttt t:.rTY OF ~lX4 Vr~ .
g. Is there any street Widening required? Yr:;;;;.
If so, please speeify. t!1,J.JtA"-,,,,..,..,DI.J 61= f'!1..-r:rE; ~.~ ~t1'rH CF
,.~r:.-. "-,VA~ o:::.~GlJ<<1'T"Y' "-"-or.: . &h> ~lilliO P~u,1t4tb
,,~~ Cvt)$.-/s.
II. Are then any other street il1Provements required? :fEs; .
If so, please specify the general "ature of the necessary
improvements. eVICB.~,,)'rT'Uz., ~'~~': .cot:. BI/E:Mrrur, i flr'lZEI!:r ~N';'
IN ..,..-u.~ "'PJ:2bP~T'> C.Ul...-bE..~e fJ:r:tn-H c~-rJH!! ZI8~"" ~I/A-nr ~Wllrry
J:.A.~. 11-1 Am') 'rIb""".... 'r:r2JVAlTJ;" ~..,- IAIIPrlbi/Ir.~I!:Lt'7'C -
Tb
1ill.l
-.
3.
a. Are there any anticipated adverse geotechnical conditions on the
project site? VNKJ..(DWAl. ,
b. If yes, specify these conditions. ~
-.
4.
c. Is a so11s report necesslry? j'EG. CJ!3ao (ZEFt;;IZr IIh/:Z !Wtt~&.-n.l4T1EfZ..
Avnfot2.rrY ,f, J./DT ~;::F'GlEIJ'1". $ou.s. ~ MIX:r Az:>Z>IfE$
J.w1...W:m ~Po~ t> 'Z>EVE.L.D 7>f.1EN'r';)
a. What is the average natural slope of the site? -15~
b. What is the .aximum natural slope of the site? ~~
.
s.
Noise
Are there any traffic-related noise levels iapact1ng the lite that
are significant enough to justify that a noise ~nalys1s be required
of the applicant? MD.
I. VI st. C.n.ratton
flow ..uch solid and liquid (sewage) waste wnl be ,enerated by the
,roposed project ,er day?
~oHd alq~/.B./nA,!. l1auid 31/40 Q.A"....~Y'
What is the location and s.lze of existing Itwer lines on or
downstream from the site? !!I" ,CP ~MlAlflr~M /1.1 I:U~N ~
~tJ,-~vAI:t'f'}. WN/~N 1& IAI ~ (Yl,~ ~!f:AN 'Z:;ItEI':.f".:j ~
,
Are they adequate to serve the proposed project? UAlI<J.",wA!. """'t; LIIJIe
IS IN CWA/n' OF 6NJ l>/s:;e>. .
- B J-
WPC '459p .15-
'Ys- &/57
.
. .
~
. Cas. No. ':S-'1f-fS
7. JwW
'l.as. id.ntify and discuss any nmatning ,0t.nUll adv.rs. fllpach,
attigation ..asur.s, or other 1ssue~ ;:~'"!.t'!.::':. ~vtj~ lI'li'/Ir./F/C
~~Ir -rJI.If!:,/ A.1lIE IJ.1 TUE. I'tl>u, ____ _~_ _ ~1C4.
;~~[~~Jr o,UAf7V~~u,~./)~"-. ~~~~VtSf~
_ ~ _~,.~ =c~ ~ nE ~A=~'~(NJr
11;.:il=s~;;;~'Y:~UJ';;:~~-'~-''''
.
~/I~
bate
,
.
.
.
-3~-
wt' aUllD
-1&.
. ..
.
-13(a)-
-.
Case No. /5- q~-15
H-l. PARKS & RECREATION DEPARTMENT
1. Are existing neighborhood and community parks near the project
adequate to serve the population increase resulting from this
project?
Neighborhood ~
Community parks____tJ~
2. If not, are parkland dedications or other mitigation proposed
as part of the project adequate to serve the population i~rease?
Neighborhood \~ \~ ~~ Z
Community parks ~ "I II
3. Does this project exceed the Parks and Recreation Thresholds
established by City Council policies?
'-!'D
-.
~~~~
Parks and Recreation Director or
Representa t he
"5 .~-'?~
Date
-.
- ~~-
.
September 9, 1994
NOTICE OF PROPOSAL
TO ISSUE A 4(d) COASTAL SAGE SCRUB (CSS)
LOSS PERMIT IN ACCORDANCE WITH 1HE ENDANGERED
SPECIES ACT FOR BONITA lULLS EXECUTIVE ESTATES (pcS-91-02)
CASE NO.: CS 95-03
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN OF 1HE CITY OF CHULA VISTA'S INTENT TO ISSUE A
4(d) COASTAL SAGE SCRUB LOSS PERMIT IN AC~ORDANCE WITH THE
ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT. NOTICE IS FURTHER GIVEN OF 1HE A V AILABIUTY
OF THE DRAFT FINDINGS SUPPORTING ISSUANCE OF 1HE PERMIT IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 17.30.053(0) OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA
MUNICIPAL CODE.
FINDINGS PER SECTION 17.30.054(0) OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA MUNICIPAL
CODE
.
One and one-half acres of Diegan Sage Scrub will be permanently eliminated by lite grading and
development. Two dedicated open spaces are recommended for retention and have been
incorporated into the tentative map, (see attaehed biology repon) which will include 1.2 acres
of the higher quality Diegan Sage Scrub on site in Open Space Lot "A", and proteCt habitat for
both the Coastal Cactus Wren and the California Gnatcatcher. The California Adolpbia will also
be proteCted within these areas. The western open space on lite area (Open Space Lot "B") is
1.5 acres and is contiguous with high quality cactllS wren and gnatcatcher habitat off-lite to the
west. It also links the revegetated lands of the reservoir with this age acrulKlominated habitat
(separated only by the existing paved road.)
The following findings have been made based on the information cow-l1V!d in the Final
Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitorina and Report ProJram (MMRP) for
Bonita Hills Executive Estates on September I, 1994.
.-
fj~in~s:
1.
The habitat loss, as proposed for issl'-~ under the 4(d) Loss Permit, is consilteDt with
the "interim loss criteria" in the November, 1993 State NatUral CommuDity Conservation
Prop (NCCP) Conservation Guidelines (as specified in items a. tbrougb d. below)
and. if a subregional interim take process is estab1isbed in a form approved by the City
of Chula'Vista at the time of the iss".11l'''' of the Loss Permit, consilteDt with such
approved subregional interim loss process. -
.
4(d) Loss Permit Draft Findings
Bonita Hills Eucudve Estates
Page 1
- 3Y,
Appendix E
a.
The habitat loss, under the Loss Permit as proposed by the Director for issuance,
will not on the date of issuance, when considered cumulatively with all other loss
of CSS occurring since March 21, 1993, exceed S% by acreage of the then
existing CSS within the region. The regional CSS loss acreages are as follows:'
~
San Diego Region initial allowable CSS loss
Cumulative Regional CSS loss since March 21, 1993
Additional Chula Vista Loss (CS-9S-01)
Total Loss )
RemAining allowable CSS loss
Loss allowed by this permit
Rtm:lining allowable regional CSS loss
11,371.9 ac.
0.8 ac.
256.0 ac.
256.8 ac.
11,I1S.1 ac.
1.5 ac.
11,113.6 ac.
b.
The NCCP Conservation Guidelines have indicated that a S% loss of CSS is
acceptable during the preparation of a NCCP or its equivalent (i.e. MSCP Plan).
The proposed habitat loss does not cumulatively exceed the S% guidelines. The
loss of I.S acres of CSS combined with current losses of sage scrub within the
San Diego Region do not exceed S% of the existing sage scrub habitat.
The proposed Project is bordered to the north, and south by residential
development, at the eastern and also at the southern portions by water storage
facilities and a partially improved road at the northwest boundary. Moon View
Drive borders the property at the southeastern comer, and undeveloped land is
located west of the property. The habitat being impacted is of a degraded quality.
The highest quality' coastal sage is being preserved on-site. The target species do
occur on the portion of the site which is not proposed for development. The
project area is not dense DCSS and is not in close proximity to a Higher Value
DCSS, or part of a critical corridor. The Project site is already isolated by
existing development and will beconie further isolated by future development.
""'"
c. The habitat loss, under the Loss Permit as proposed by the Director for issuance,
will not preclude or prevent the preparation of the subregional NCCP.
The site is not a crucial habitat link, but is rather at tbe periphery of already
approved or constrUcted development. The Core Biological Resource Areas (see
the City of San Diego Multiple Species Conservation Program, 1SlSl4) which is
still being finAli,ed are located well south of tbe project along tbe Otay River
Valley. This site is not considered a high priority preservation area because of the
existing adjacent development which result in high edge effect (i.e., intrusion by
""mAn~. pets, weedy plant species) and habitat fr-J""""lAtion or part of a
I 1bcliC as Iou EIUICS wiI1 be RCOIIfIrmcd wiIb SANDAG prior lD Ibc fIoo.II,oNm oflbis loa permit.
......,
- 3C(-
4(d) Loss Permit Draft Findings
Bonita HiI1s Executive Estates
Page 2
.
significant wildlife corridor. For these te8Sons, the site is not considered
important in the preparation of the City cif Chula Vista's open space planning
efforts or NCCP pl~nni1'\g efforts.
d.
The habitat loss. under the Loss Permit as proposed by the Director for issuanCe.
bas been minimi71'11 and mitigated in accordance with Section 4.3 ("Interim
Mitigation") of the "Southern California Coastal Sage ScNb Natural Cnmmunities
Conservation pl~nning Process Guidelines," dated 11/5/93, and thereafter, to the
maximum extent practicable.
Two dedicated biological open spaces are recov",,-'ed which will include 1.2
acres of the higher quality Diegan Sage ScNb on-site in Open Space Lot "B. , and
proteCt habitat for both the Coastal Cactus Wren and the California GDatcatcher
(see Attachment 2). The California Adolphia will also be proteaed within these
areas. This western open space is 1.5 acres and is contiguous with high quality
cactus wren and gnatcatcher habitat off-site to the west. It also links the
revegetated lands of the reservoir with this Illge lCN~ominated habitat
(separated only by the existing paved road.) In addition the follOwing on-site and
off-site mitigation measures are proposed:
.
No clearance of vegetation or other forms of habitat and soU disturbance
shall occur within the dedicated open space ate8S (Lots A and B). with the
exception of the constrUCtion of the sewage pipes and storm drainage pipe.
In such case. disturbance sba11 be at the minimum required to
accommodate construction.
.
. 0.3 acre of disturbed grassland Diegan Sage ScNb in Lot B shall be
revegetated in accordance with the recommendations in the Pacific
Southwest Biological Services Assessment for the project dated September
4. 1992. Artemisia californica. Encelia califonica, Eriogonum
fasciculatum. DiplacuS puniceus and Salvia meUifera ahould be the
principal shNbby components of this re-vcgetation. A five-year
monitoring plan sba11 be implemented to ensure the successful
establishment of this scrub. The 0.3 acre constituteS the emire area within
Area B mapped as psland. Open Space Lots "A" and "8" will be
1"_intllined in a IIItura1ltate by the hoJDeOW1Im assoej,tlrion.JD..perpCtUitY.
. The SweetWater tank pan:elloc.tMl _.....,n.t~ly to the lIOIlth will also be
lC\'egetated as part of this project.
2. The habitat loss will not appreciably reduce the liJrt>ljhIv>d of the survival and recovery
of the Coastal California Gnatcl'''Mt (PotlDpti14 Colifomica Co1ifomica).
.
- 40 -
4(d) Loss Permit Draft Findings
Bonita Hills ElW"Jtive EstateS
Page 3
As is noted in Finding Number One above, the area of habitat loss meets the "interim
loss criteria" in the November 1993 State Natural Community Conservation Program
(NCCP) Conservation Guidelines. Therefore, the project site does not have high habitat
potential for a long-term conservation area. On -site mitigation through the preservation
of higher value habitat will increase the likelihood of the long-term success of regional
open space pJAnniT1g efforts. Due to these reasons, the proposed habitat loss would not
appreciably reduce the survival or recovery of any listed species, bIcluding the
gnatcatcher.
......\
3. The habitat loss is incidental to otherwise lawful activities.
The project is completing CEQA review simultaneOUSly and will meet all local, State,
and Federal requirements.
4. Proposed mitigation is consistent with NCCP Process Guidelines requirements.
The NCCP Process Guidelines identify several options for mitigating impacts to CSS.
These options include acquisition of habitat, dedication of land, management agreements,
restoration, etc. The dedication and long-term preservation of 2.7 acres on-site through
a mitigation monitoring program consistent with the NCCP Process Guidelines.
In accordance with the provisions of Section 17 .30.0S4(F) of the City of Chula Vista Municipal
Code, the USFWS in consultation with the CDFG, are requested to review the Draft 4(d) Loss
Permit and Draft Findings for consistency with the NCCP Conservation Guidelines and submit
comments to the City of Chula Vista Director of Planning within thirty days of the date of this
notice .
""'"
Further, in accordance with Section 17.30.0S4(F) of the City of Chula Vista Municipal Code,
the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is requested to verify that the proposed
4(d) Loss Permit does not exceed the mnimum permitted habitat loss for the subregion and
notify the Director of plAnning for the City of Chula Vista, within fifteen days of the date of
notice, of that verification.
Comments and/or regarding the Draft 4(d) Loss Permit for Bonita Hills Executive Estates should
be directed to Douglas D. Reid, Environmental Review Coordinator at (619) 691-5101 or to
plAnniT1g Department, City of Chula Vista, P. O. Box 1087, Chula Vista, CA ~.l2U.
~,!,.;I J
Director of plAnning
RAlJDDR:br
""'"
t.f( -
4(d) Loss Permit Draft Findings
Bonita Hills Executive Estates
Page 4
.
.
.
Distribution List:
City of Chula Vista Mayor and CouncUmembers
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service
California Department of Fish & Game
SANDAG
County of San Diego
I':Wdpamil.IlIlC)
-4;)--
4(d) Loss Permit Draft FiDdings
Bonita Hills E:ucutive Estates
Page 5
Mitigation Measures
(To be completed by the Applicant)
"""
I. as owner/owner in escrow'
JrlIC-/HJ.EL j)EA'f\ Ie.- tI
Print name
or
I. consultant or agent'
HEREBY AG~~"don""""""''''''''''''--'
~~O q,~~q1
Signature Date
~
,
"""
C,IIlANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-{3-
poge 2S
.
.
.
Determination
(To be completed by the Lead Agency. Check one box only.)
On the basis of this initial evaluation:
o I find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the
environment, and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.
. I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the
environment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because the mitigation
measures described on an a~"bed sheet have been added to the project. A
MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.
o I fmd the proposed project MAY have a signif1ClDt effect on the environment, and
an ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required.
sjfl '( J "'1
Da '
"If acting for a corporation, include capacity and company name.
.
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.lS\
-'f+-
Pqe26
Case No. IS 91-15
APPENDIX n
"""
DE MINIMIS FEE DETERMINATION
(Chapter 1706, Sta01tes of 1990 - AB 3158)
o It is hereby found that this project involves no potential for any adverse effect, either
individually or cumulatively on wildlife resources and that a "Certificate of Fee
Exemption" shall be prepared for this project.
. It is hereby found that this project could potentially impact wildlife, individually or
cumulatively and therefore fee in accordance with Section 711.4 (d) of the Fish and
Game Code shall be paid to the County Clerk.
~h3/1'1
Date
,
~
Page 27
C:INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-q~-
.
.
.
MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING CHECKLIST
PROJECT NAME: Bonita Hills Executive Estates
IS NO.: 91-15
Issue Area
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
Specific project mitigation measures are required to reduce potentially significant environmental
impacts identified in the Initial Study for this project to a level below significant. Mitigation
measures have been incorporated into the project design and have been made conditions of project
approval, as well as requirements of the attached Mitigation Monitoring Program (Attachment" A").
In addition to the proposed two dedicated open spaced, which have been incorporated into the
tentative map, the applicant must also refrain from clearing vegetation within the dedicated open
space areas, with the exception of some public improvements construCtion and must revegetate areas
of disturbed Diegan Sage Scrub in Lot B. Once revegetation has been completed, a three-year
monitoring plan shall be implemented to ensure the successful establishment of this scrub. The
developer shall also provide proof of an incidental take permit under Section 7. Section lOa of the
Endangered Species Act relative to the California Gnatcatcher or Coastal Sage Scrub.
PrQiect Phase (Protect Desirn~ Construction: Post Cnnstruction)
Prior to grading operations, during grading operations, and post grading after the revegetation plan
has been implemented.
Resnonsible Pan or Allencv
Engineering Department, Planning Depanment, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Verification of ComDletion:
Person:
Date:
Comments:
l'IF~
C:IMANCY\\DEMICH.JS\
--i(P,-
MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING CHECKLIST
PROJECT NAME: Bonita Hills Executive Estates
"""
IS NO.: 91-15
Issue Area
SOILS
Specific project mitigation measures are required to reduce potentially significant environmental
impacts identified in the Initial Study for this project to a level below significant. Mitigation
measures have been incorporated into the project design and have been made conditions of project
approval, as well as requirements of the attached Mitigation Monitoring Program (Attachment" A").
All recommendations of the Soil and Geologic Reconnaissance prepared for the Bonita Hills
Executive Estates by Geocon Incorporated, dated December, 1992, shall be adhered to. These
recommendations pertain to the design process for future slope relation within the immediate area;
future geotechnical subsurface investigation for the site regarding fill compaction for the underground
water reservoir; remedial grading, recompaction and subsurface investigation and laboratory testing;
re-evaluation of existing fills; disposal of deleterious materials encountered during grading; design
of cut and fill slopes; use of erosion-resistant ground cover, adequate irrigation and drainage control
for cut and fill slopes and additional geological investigation to be performed prior to completing """"
grading and improvement plans.
Proiect Phase (Proiect Desism: Construction: Post Construction)
Prior to grading operations and during grading operations.
Resnonsible Part or Al!encv
Engineering Department
Verification of ComDletion:
Person:
Date:
Comments:
MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING CHECKUST
PROJECT NAME: Bonita Hills Executive Estates
~
PIle 29
C:\NANCY\\DEMICH.JS\
- 'f 1-
.
.
.
IS NO.: 91-15
Issue Area
DRAlNAGEIHYDROLOGY
Specific project mitigation measures are required to reduce potentially significant environmental
impacts identified in lhe Initial Study for 1his project to a level below significant. Mitigation
measures have been incorporated into lhe project design aDd have been made conditions of project
approval. as well as requirements of 1he .tl"ched Mitigation Monitoring Program (AUlIchtDf'ut "A").
In addition to lhe proposed drainage improvements shown on Tentative Map 91-2 dated March 2.
1993. lhe applicant shall also extend lhe storm drains to 1he flow line of lhe canyon.
PrOtect Phase lPrQiect Desim: Construction: Post t:nn~truction)
Prior to grading operations and during grading operations.
Resoonsible Part or Al!encv
Engineering Department
Verification of Comnletion:
Person:
Date:
Comments:
Pqe30
C,INANCY\\DEMICH.IS\
-1~ -
MITIGA nON MONITORING AND REPORTING CHECKLIST
PROJECT NAME: Bonita Hills Executive Estates
""""
IS NO.: 91-15
Issue Area
WATER OUALITYIEROSION:
Specific project mitigation measures are required to reduce potentially significant environmental
impacts identified in the Initial Study for this project to a level below significant. Mitigation
measures have been incorporated into the project design and have been made conditions of project
approval. as well as.requirements of the attached Mitigation Monitoring Program (Attachment" A").
An erosion and sedimentation control plan, in compliance with NPDES will be prepared subject to
approval of the City Engineer and the project shall comply with NPDES for discharges of storm
water runoff, etc. Sedimentation shall be controlled by properly planting all graded slopes.
Proiect Phase (Proiect Desil!D: Construction: Post Construction)
Prior to grading and during grading operations.
Resoonsible Part or Al!encv
""""
Engineering Department and Planning Department
Verification of Comoletion:
Person:
Date:
Comments:
~
C:INANCY\\DEMlCH.lS\
__ 4 9-
Pqe31
.
.
.
A'ITACHMENT "A"
Mitigation Monitoring Program
IS 91-15
This Mitigation Monitoring Program is prepared for the Bonita Hills Executive Estates Tentative
Map. The legislation requires public agellCies to ensure that adequate mitigation measures are
implemented and monitored on Mitigated Negative Declarations, such as
IS 91-15.
AB 3180 requires monitoring of potentially significant and/or significant environmental impacts. The
mitigation monitoring program for this project ensures adequate implementation of mitigation for the
following potentially significant impacts: biological resources, solls, drainagelhydrology, and water
quality/erosion.
Due to the nature of the environmental issues identified, the Mitigation CompliaDCe Coordinator
(MCC), shall be the Environmental Review Coordinator (ERC) for the City of Cbula Vista. It shan
be the responsibility of the applicant to ensure that the conditions of the Mitigation Monitoring
Program are met to the satisfaction of the ERC. Comp\iaDCe with the mitigation measures specified
in Mitigated Negative Declaration 91-15 shall be provided to the ERC prior to the issuance of any
permits by the City of Chula Vista. The ERC will thus provide the ultimate verification that the
mitigation measures have been accomplished.
Pale 32
C:IIlANCY\\DEMICH.JS\
-50-
MEMORANDUM
"
September 13, 1994
SUBJECT:
William C. Tuchscher II, Chair and Members of the City of Chula
Vista Planning Commission V
Martin Miller, Associate Planner ~
PCS-91-02/IS-91-15: Revised Biological Assessment of the Proposed
Bonita Hills Estates, City of Chula Vista, California
TO:
FROM:
The attached biological study is a revised edition of the above assessment. The
original is dated 4 September 1992, while the revision is sub-dated "(Revised 16
March 1993)." The revised assessment replaces pages 1-45 to 1-67 in your packet l
for Wednesday night's meeting. Please review this information prior to the
meeting.
"
- 5/-
..
BIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
OF THE PROPOSED BONrI'A HILLS ESTATES
CITY OF eMmA VISTA. CALIFORNIA
UTM '495,500 mE; 3.612,000 mN; 11; N.
Prepared lor
City ol Chula Vista
pI.""i"S Depanment
276 Fourth Avenue
Chula Vista CA 91910
Tel (619) 691-5047
.
.'
Prepared by
Pacific Southwest Biological Services, Inc.
Post Office Box 985
Natiolll1 City CA 91951.0985
Tel f619) 477-5333
Fa (619) 477.1245
4 September 1992
(RniIed 16 March 1993)
.
/~d.
~ Mitcbe1 BaI...I.....P. Prelident
~ 5 2. -_
PSBS 1K80
PSBS 1K80
TABLE OF CONTENTS
s~Y......................................"""
...............
INTR.ODUcnON
........ ..............................................
METHODS
........ ....................................................
LOCA nON
...... .....................................................
GENERAL PJi'Y'SIOGRAPHY' ..........................................................................................
BOTANICAL RESOURCES
VEGETATION. . . . . .
DIEGAN SAGE SCRUB
A~T'lJAL GRASSLANDlDlm.JRBED
.,.
FLORA
............ ... ..... .........
ZOOLOGICAL RESOURCES
GENUAL Wn.DLlFE HABITAT
AMPHIBIANS
REPTILES
BIRDS
MAMMALS
SENSITIVE BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
SENSITIVE VEGETATION
SAGE SCRUB .. .. ..
SENSITIVE PLANTS DETECTED ON-SITE
SENSITIVE PLANT SPECIES KNOWN FROM THE REGION BUT NOT FOUND ON-SITE
SENSITIVE SPECIES OF VERTE.llRAi'ES OF VDlFlED OCCUl\.RENCE .......
SENSITIVE VERTE.llRAi'ES WHICH POSSIBLY Oil PllOBAllLY OCCUR ON-SITE
EXPECTED BIOLOGICAL IMPACTS .....................
...................
RECOMMENDA nONS TO REDUCE BIOLOGICAL IMPACTS
...................
i
'""\
1
1
1
2
2
4
4
4
4
4
6
6
6
6
6
7 .","",
7
7
7
7
11
11
12
14
14
J..I'IE,RA.TURE C'I"ED ................................................ .......... ................... ....... 15
"""'"
04/C1f9)
-S-3-
... MIhal ~ smlfU, lit.
ii
PSBS NKSO
.'.
FIGURES AND APPENDICES
FIGURE 1.
FIGURE 2.
hOJEC'I' Vl~ MA.P ........................................ 3
VEGETATION AND SENSITIVE REsoURCES ........................... 5
APPENDIX 1.
APPENDIX 2.
FLoJlAL Qma1JS'1" ........................................... 17
ANIhlAlS OBsEllvm 01 DETE-C1"ED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 20
.
-
.
04/01193
-5f~
... MIInoaIl/llp.tltmflIS, JIt.
PSBS #KID
1
BIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
OF THE PROPOSED BONITA HILLS ESTATES
CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA
'1
P.d!" Sourh'llltst BitJ/ogiuJ SnWG, Inc.
4 September 1992
(Revised 16 March 1993)
SUMMARY
A biological survey of the 1.52-acre Micbae1 Danish propeny west and lOuth of the
Bonita Valley Reservoir revealed that the site is 11ti\izecl by both Coastal CIctus Wrens
and the California Gnatcatcher. The former iDhabiu age scrub and c:actUS near the
ravine along the western fenceline, and use areas e:nend off-site into higher quality
habitat immecliately west. The gnatcatchers were Doted at the same locale; as wel\as
in sage scrub now growing on the earthen seal for the reservoir (off-site). Two
casements of 1.21 and 1.50 acres are proposed as dedicated biological open spaces to
protect these sensitive birds and their habitat.
Two planu of liIpited sensitivity were noted: Several California Adolpma grow near
the ravine along'the western boundary, and eight San Diego Viguiera OCCW' further
upslope to the nonh. Habitat quality varies widely on the propeny, with clisturbed
grasslands in the south and nonh. and fair to good quality Diegan Sage Scrub covering
much of the canyon's flanks in the center of the propeny.
'1
INTRODUCTION
A biological survey of the Demish site was performed by Pacific Southwest Biological Services,
Inc. at the request of Ms. Marilyn Ponseggi. The purpose of the survey - to identify RDSitive
biological resources and constrainu in the pl"'l;m;...'Y phases of development design for a fourteen lot
split.
METHODS
The botanical portion of the survey _ conducted by Craig R ReiIer on AIiiiiJt 10, 1992.
The on-foot survey covered all slope aspects,lOil types, and dninaps. hnicu1ar ateaUOD - pwn
to the native age scrub habitat. Vegetation and RDSitive plant loc:atiODS were *1;....."" on a 1- - 40'
topographic map. An 8dditional mornin& field date _ ,,,.m.,,,, to s.c how:IdarieI for open space
LotB.
The zoological portion of the survey was conducted by a-..d.. Edwards on Aup 6 &om 1245
hours to 1600 hours. Skies were hazy, humiclity was high; the temperature - 840 F.; and winds were
light and from the west.
.""""
- s-S" -
... IIIthd ~ IIPMI, lit.
04lOI/93
.
2
PSBS 1K80
.' . All habitat types present within the INdy _ were ~ed for wildlife. Binoculars of
10 l[ 40 power were used to observe and help in the identification of wildlife species and their habitatS.
Surface litter such as fallen lop. rocks and trash were ovenumed to locate amphibians and! or reptiles.
Attention was also pven to the identification of "'....lns1 uacks. ICI1 or other lien- Ustenin& for and
DOtin& wildlife voo,1i.....ons was also an important aspec:t of cia ptherin&.
Prior biolopca1 surveys of the 'lnln..distf region were ~"In;"..d to -- IellSitive resources
known from the vicinity of the site (pSBS 1981. 1989; BECON 1982).
Scientific IlOmenc1anue wed in this repon is from the foUowinc refereaces: WCetation.
Holland (1986); Sora, Beauchamp (1986) and Munz (1974); birds, American OnaitholociJts' Union
(1983. 1989); reptiles and amphibians. Collins (1990); and _"lnlns1" Jameson and Peeten (1988).
Wildlife habitat delineations generally foUow Mayer and Laudenslayer (1988).
.
LOCATION
The site lies within unsectioned lands of the Spanish pnt for Rancho de 1a Naci6n; Township
17 South, Range 2 West of the San Bernardino Base and Meridian; USGS Nltional City California 7.5'
Quadrangle. Access is from the north via MoonviewDrive (Ficure 1).
The 18.7 million pUon reinforced concrete Bonita Valley Reservoir to the east includes a two
foot earthen "blanket' over the concrete. on which lICe ICI'Ub was eeeded (RECON 1982). The
predominate land use surrounding the propeny is residential bomesites; 1 large uact of lICe scrub
oc:cun on the eastern boundary (including the revegetated reservoir site).
GENERAL PHYSIOGRAPHY
The site consists primarily of 1 rec:unPu uact of land ab1ming the Bonita Valley Reservoir
on the west, Icrned by 1 continuation ofMooJniew Drive (presendy pteclIE the propertY line). The
aouthem eod of the propertY fecures cIismrW IlOnMadDc elopes which ~ drop into 1
tIrainap with age ICI'Ub. The terrain riles apin to the DOrth 0Dt0 1 barreD ridp1ine. bfme dropping
.-ply iaro Bonita Valley. 011 the..-m bouDdary - the ClIIIIel' of the site is 1 cIismrW fill alope
Uua:iDa the buried & J l. 40it.
The high eJevcion is SOI_ IE the ICIIIth ead of the ,..OrJf1' 0111 "'itl.;..... Wow · 'traEeJ' lank
while the low e1evadOD is -t'r' ,,;-.....1y 116 _ ill the ...a.... _.d... JItenl CIOftI8I' of the I"o~
011 . Iteep alope overlooking Bonita Va1ley.
Soils for the site are primarily 1JDDe c1q loam 011 9-5O'!lt alopes. with 00. "'.i" cobbly loam
9-)OlII, alopes near the aouthem boundary (Bowman 1973). UacIer1ying polo&y is mapped 85 the Otay
Formcioll; SID Diego Formcioll, IMd"')Jllt pen; IIIlI Linda Vaea FOfJ"'.hf)Jl or-"e<\r 1977).
.
0l/0II9)
-sfp'_ J
.". ...... ~ ... Ill-
PSBS #1<80
FIGURE 1.
PROJECT VICINITY MAP
USGS 7.5' National City Quadrangle
~S1-
1
'""'\
N
.-
1- . aDO'
""""
4
PSBS 1K80
-:'-;~ . ,
.' .. ~. ,.,.,o;:....;':.".~.> ,. "" '
.". BOTANICAL RESOURCES
VEGETATION
.
.
Two vegetation types were present on the propertY: Diegan Sa&e 5cNb Uld a very disturbed
Annual Grassland (Figure 2).
DIEGAN SAGE SCRUB (2.89 acres; includes 0.15 acre Cactus Phase Diegan Sa&e 5cNb)
Shrub diversity at the Bonita Hills site is relatively limited. UnllSual for the region is the high
incidence of California Encelia (Encelu. ulifomia), which although a common plant, is rarely the
dominant cover. Also OCQ1rring here is Coastal Sa&ebrush (AlUmisu. ulif~). Lemonadeberry (Rhus
inregrifolu.) in the more mesic canyon bottom, Flat-tOp Buckwheat (EriogoIuml f~tllm). Spanish
Bayonet (YUCCII schidiFII), and Black Sa&e (s.JtIiIJ _llifrrll). Near the western boundary, by the
drainage, grows some Jojoba (Simmondsu. chinmsis), Coast Cholla (OpuntiIJ prolifn-II), and further
upslope San Diego Viguiera (Viguirrll L.onu.liI) in limited numbers.
The understory is relatively limited. Native e1emenu include the late-flowermg San Diego
Wand Chicory (Srepbllnomn-u. d~sis), Bicolored Cudweed (GMpbIIlium hicolor). Ocean Locoweed
(AslT.glllus tTichopodus), and California Filago (FiL.go ulifomia). At one artificially moist locale along
the southern boundary, near an irrigated residential yard, is found one Arroyo Willow (s.Jix L.siolepis)
and a Great Marsh Evening Primrose (Ornothrr. eLrlil); no other wetland species were Iee11 on the
property.
In general, the higher quality, more diverse sage IICrub is concentrated Dear the drainage along
the western boundary.
ANNUAL GllASSLANDlDlSTUIUlED (5.63 acres)
c
This disturbed habitat includes an abundance of the noxious Tec:olote (Qm.unu _lirmsis) and
Wild MUStard (BrdSsia gmiaJlJliI). Both of these weeds sometimes form such a dense. low canopy, that
little else can grow beneath. On the lOuth-facing a10pe is CODSiderable CryItaI Ice Plant
(M-~ ""rJIinMm), an intrOduced IUCCUlmt species &om South Africa. While IOme sage
ICrUb e1emmu are slowly pioneerin& within this disturbed wptation, the overall iIUJlity of this
.,.,..l...d is considered poor. Much of the crr"1......1 habitat in the IOuth may have been crated during
ClOIIItNCtioo of the lllljacent buried leservoir. GraDy -- on the riclceline in the DOnh (near another
old homesite) are 1ike1y the result of peripheral ftIi,f_i.J disturbance.
FLoRA
Seventy species of p1anu were recorded ONte of which Wrty<<YeD are DOIHIative invasive
eJeot'eDtS (Appmdix 1). An ePi-..~ 2O'lIl of the flora c:onsisu of ephemeral Dative and Don-Dative
annuals which bad decomposed by the August survey date. None of these additional species is
apeeted to be listed . IIDSitive.
CMIClI19,
-s-r-
.
... ..... IIIIrful sml#S, lit.
~
..
CI)
ID
CI)
A.
II)
~
W
~
a
w
)(
w
II)
~
i
I
+@!
'""'"
I
.
'~r:
. .
~i' .
f .
I.
.
.
r
It, ,
'. "
!f'jl'i',f
i ,f. '
.: 1/""",
iii,s!;
I ,lil'!rI i,
I I', / ",.
f.' 1..'
1Ii"',f
: Iii;:::!':
. ../,:1.1
II 'iiF i,
'-----
-,
,
I
,
,
<
'" ;
..
~ ~
~ -...
I
a:
J
~
J
0
~
-I
Iii
j
w
I
~
~
'.
.J ~i;
-:,:;
i,::
--
I
I
J 1111
I 1111,1
IlIi 111111
III fIfI
cm~ El(!:(!;[!J
.,
..,
.
~
,
~i ..
;to;. ~
,,~ "" -".- - .. .. -
.. .""," ..-- ,.
."_ , I _-__'::: _
"
" .
.
-
"..- -
,~:-... -
- 51-'
6
PSBS IKSO
.
.-.
The flora on-site is not as .complex. as what historically occurred in Rice Canyon to the south
(C. Reiser pers. obs.) prior to extensive p-ading over the last decade. Presence of Jojoba and dense
concentrations of Coast Cholla (primarily immediately off-site to the west) are indicative of the desert
W1uenccs seen in this region.
ZOOLOGICAL RESOURCES
GENERAL WILDUFE HABITAT
There are twO major habitat-types for wilcllife fO\Uld over the site, Diepn 51ce Scrub and
Annual Grassland. A small canyon with a few lar&e shrubs at the western end of the propertY is kept
moist by suburban runofr. nus is an anractive ana for animal-life in an otherwise .rid environment.
Two sensitive species of birds were observed utilizing the available sage scrub habitat, Coastal CactuS
Wren (c.mpylorhynchus brunnticapillus santliepe) and California Gnatcatcher (Poliuptila ulifomica).
AMPHIBIANS
Due to the timing and length of the survey, no species of amphibians were observed. Pacific
Chorus Frog (Pseudams regilla) and Western Toad (Bulo horus) may occur in the artificially moist
.
canyon area.
REPTILES
Only one species of reptile was observed due to humid, overcast weather conditions at the time
of the survey. The Side-blotched Lizard (Uta nanshuri;ma) is a common inhabitant of the sage scrub.
Additionally, the following reptiles may also occur on the propertY: Western Fence Lizard (Sceloporus
occitJmtalis) , Coastal Whiptail (Owmidophorus tigris wuJtisaaauu), OrangeWoat Whiptail
(Owmidophorus byperythrus) and San Diego Homed Lizard fl'hrynosoma ClIfOl'Ultsml hlainwln).
BIRDS
Fifteen species of birds were observed on the lite (Appendix 2). MOlt of the apecies were
asoci."" with the IIItUJ'al .. a:rub habitat, iDc:Ndin& California Quail (C'AllPi'- ...lifomiu),
Bewick's Wren (~ 1JfvicIm), wrentit (c:\p-.- f~), California Thrasher (TQXtlStMIIa
ndivi_), California Towhee (PipilD m-lis) and RufOUHided Towhee (Pipilo ,,/IA,fiJIhthalmus).
Anna's H..",,,,l"gbirds (c.lypfl_) fed in ~";on with Tree Tobacco ~ aU-) crowing
oIHite. Mournin& Dove (~ 1fU.,_.), Nonhero Y-'""gbird (/l;m. ~ttDS) and House
Finch (c:.rpodacru~) are asociated with utban. .otic wptation.
As many as six CoutaI Caaus Wrens were obscrJed and bard during the &eld survey on-site
llDd in aD i",,,,ecJiately adjacent area. These birds were ReD and bard in the choU. and priddy pear
QI:NI vowing in the canyon alODl the 'WelteI'D ,.......li,,1I both on and just off-site. A acparate single
.
_It1
_tpo_
... .... ~ .... lit.
PSBS 1K80
7
Cactus Wren was heard singing from si=lar habitat in the canyon off.site and north of the gate on 1
Moonview, and additional habitat is present on south-facing slopes within Diegan Sage Scrub to the
east ohhis property.
One pair of California Gnatcatchers utilize this property, and .d' acent, similar e scrub
habitat off-site. No nesting activity was detected, but the quality of the available escrub habitat is
rather good. A separate single gnatcatcher was seen and heard briefly to the northeast of this property
along Randy Lane, indicating their presence there as well. Another pair of gnatcatchers uses the
revegetated sage scrub covering the .djacent underground reservoir and the small traCt of sage scrub
off.site in the southeast (south of Moonview Drive).
MAMMALS
Desen Conontail (SylviIagus .uduboniJ) was observed. Coyote (Qznis Lrtr.ns) was detected
from iu scat. California Ground Squirrel (Spmnophilus betcMyJ) burrows were found, and they
undoubtedly occur on-site, panicularly within the distUrbed terrain.
SENSITIVE BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
SENSITIVE VEGETATION
""'\
SAG}: SCRUB
Both the Riversidian phase and the Diegan phase of Coastal Sage Scrub have been severely
reduced in total acreage over the last century. The principal reasons for this reduction were initially
overgrazing by livestock and clearance of agricultural lands, followed in many cases by urban residential
and commercial development. Some faunal elemenu heavily dependent upon sage scrub habitat have
suffered corresponding severe drops in individual numbers and distribution. Notable examples include
the California Gnatcateher, San Diego Cactus Wren, the coastal race of the Sage Sparrow, and to a
more limited extent, the San Diego Homed Lizard (which also occupies chaparral habiuu and open
r..1..,ds). Along with the extensive reduction in ace scrub bas come a pi__....l frae...entation of
larger uacu of such habitat. Isolation into small parcels devoid of viable linkages 10 other similar lands
bas undercut the value of such lands. The IalSitivity of sage scrub in southern California will
incviubJy become more acute as additional Jowland cIevelopmcnt takes place in San Diego, Orange and
Riwnide counties.
SENSITIVE PLANTS DETECTED ON-SITE
Two sensitive plant species occur on-site, California Adolpbia and San Diego Viguiera. Severa1
of the former grow near the western fence line Dear the area occupied by the Coastal Cactus Wreus. ~
Upslope, and of lime botanical significance. were seen eight San Diego Viguiera. This species is
relatively common in the region, but bas a limited u.s. ~e.
04IllI193
-f..p (-
-
... __ ~ 1mlaS. lit.
PSBS #KIO
8
...
California Adolpbia (Adolphia californica)
IJSTlNG:
D15T1UB1.TnON:
HABITAT:
KNOWN SITES:
.
.
CNPS List 2 R-E-D Code 1-2-1
StatelFed. Status - None PJiAMNACEAE
Coastal San Diego County; Baja California, Mexico
This short shrub is often intermixed WM Diegan Sage Scrub. but occasionally
occurs in peripheral chaparral habitatS. particularly hillsides near creeks. The
California Adolphia (sometimes called California Spinebush) is usually associated
with Eriogonllm-/MCiaJ.Utm and Ammisu. uJifomia in xeric locales where shrub
canop>, reaches lour or five feet in height. During late summer and fall it may be
virtually leafless, and therefore not apparent from a distance; however, iu spiny
stems are readily Doted at dose range. The San Miguel and Fnant soils are both
quite amenable to California Adolphia. .
California Adolphia is still found at a variety of coastal San Diego County locales.
Substantial populations (lCCUr south of Del Dios Highway and 1 mile southwest of
Lake Hodges Dam on steep Dorth-facing slopes, and on south-facing slopes of
Escondida Creek east of Lake Val Soreno. A very extensive colony with over 1000
shrubs was found in 1990 near the Inspiration Point Cross north of the Questhaven
Retreat. One of the largest sites noted is a football field sized colony almost
entirely composed of Ado/phil< upstream of the SweetWater Reservoir, south of the
old wooden bridge, on the south side of the river. Several thousand are found
across the river and just upstream where they are a dominant element within the
sage scrub. Scattered sites are in the hills south of the SweetWater Reservoir and
on the flanks of Mother Miguel Mountain. Another large population occurs on a
west-facing slope east of Saxony Road near Batiquitos Lagoon. This shrub was
noted in limited Dumbers at numerous other surveyed sites including the finger
canyon east of Dillon Road on southem Otay Mesa, at scattered locales in Olay
Valley east of the Interstate 805, in the sage _scrub north of Lower Otay Lake,
below Sweetwater Dam. a hillside west of Lake Murray Dam. along San Marcos
Creek below San Marcos Dam. west of Melrose Drive and south of Shadowridge
Drive in Vista, and on north-facing slopes of PeAasquitos Canyon just south of the
water ueatment plant near POWI)'. Small populations were seen near Akita Lane
in Rancho Santa Fe, at the eastern terminus of Rosemont Sueet in La Jolla, near
the Fairbanks Country Club south of San Dieguito Road, south of Aliso Canyon
Road near Rancho Santa Fe, on the Green Oaks Ranch at Agua Hedionda Creek,
on canyon slopes west of Black Mountain Road and north of PeAasquitos Canyon,
on the eastern boundary of Fairbanks Ranch, near Mercy }load east of
Interstate 15, and near the intersection of Poinsettia A veouc and Palomar Airport
Road. Also. old reportS on the periphery of iu known range are near lOuthern
Camp PendletOn at Moro Hill. as Yell as to the aoutheast of IIlOst reportS near
Barrett Junction. Old Biolocica1 survey reportS DOte sites. DOI'thwtst of Lake
Hodges Dam. near Lake Calavera. west of the Olivenhain Cemetel')'. on Rancho
Aqua Hedionda Y Los Manos near Aqua Hedionda Creek. near El Apajo Road just
IOIIth and beyond the Rancho San Dieguito boundary. 0.5 mile DOM of La Zanja
Canyon and 1 mile east of San Dieguito Valley, southwest of Sienna Canyon Drive
in EDcinitas.. Sun"'."~ Mountain near Carmel Mountain Drive, b-._ Evans
Point and Lesterbox Canyon, and near the interaecDOD of fainDODt ad
Mont~''''. Roads in the W:inity of San Die&o Scate University. Data Base records
are from the Otay River near the IIlOUth of Johnson Canyon, DOrtbeast of Agua
Hedionda LagooD west of El Catnino Real Road hctweeu Skyline Road ad
Neblina Drive, 2 miles DOrth of San Marcos Creek and east of E1 Oo...ino Rea1 to
cbe north of the colf course, 2 miles east of the San Dieguito Reservoir ad 0.6 mile
south of the San Dieguito River DOrth of. dammed ponel. the Kelly Ranch about
1.1 mile south of Calavera Lake in Carlsbad. 0.1 mile south of Highway 7. ad
CMIllI/93
-&;;..-
,.. .... ....., Im/IrI, lit.
PSBS NK.80
9
0.9 mile east of EI Camino Real in Carlsbad, betWeen Interstate 15 and Black
Mountain Road 0.5 mile north of Mira Mesa Boulevard, adjacent to Interstate 15 'i
and Cbicarita Creek from 1.0 to 1.7 miles north of Poway Road and to the
nonheast, southwest flank of Paint Mountain near Rancho Santa Fe, north of
confluence of Lusardi Creek and San Dieguito River east of Rancho Santa Fe, nonh
of Anesian Road and 1.5 miles south of the San Dieguito River, 1 mile east of the
San Dieguito Reservoir, 1 mile from San Dier;o State University oear the western
comer of Yerba Santa Drive and MonteZUma Road, one block south of Mission
Gorge Road near Margerum A venue, Alvarado Canyon 0.5 mile southwest of Lake
Murray, on Black Mountain Road about 0.4 mile nOMeast of 4-S Ranch and
0.5 mile east of Anesian Road, the east slope of Banle Mountain, nOM and south
of Paco Lago Road and west of Via Abertura Road near Fairbanks Ranch, nOM
of Manchester overlooking the San Elijo Lagoon, Lux Canyon in Enciniw,
southwest side of Evans Point Headland near Agua Hedionda Lagoon, just south
of Enciniw Road about 400 yards from the junction with Linda Vista Road, Lopez
Ridge, south of Lake Hodges and 2.5 miles west of Battle Mountain, northern
tributary canyons of La Jolla Valley on the 4-S Ranch 3.5-4.5 miles south of Lake
Hodges, 1.2 miles north of San Marcos Creek between EI Camino Real and
U.1icornio Street, 1.2 and 1.8 and 2.1 miles southwest of Lake San Marcos Dam
near Santa Fe Road realignment, north of San Marcos Creek and 0.3 mile south of
Alga Road, San Marcos Creek near Rancho de 105 Quiotes, 0.5 mile west of San
Francisco Peak and 0.4 mile northeast of Cerro de la Calavera, Evans Point east to
approximately 0.5 mile west of Mount Hinton, near Carlsbad 0.5 mile south of
Mount Hinton, southwest of Mount Hinton near the intersection of Palomar
Airport Road and EI Camino Real, west side of Green Valley on the Ecke Ranch
0.6 mile southwest of intersection of La Costa A venue and El Camino Real, 2 miles
nonh of intersection of Enciniw Boulevard with Manchester Avenue and 1 mile ~
east of El Camino Real, 1 mile southeast of La Costa Country Club east of Green
Valley, nonh of Batiquitos Lagoon and 1.2 miles northwest of La Costa Country
Club, Batiquitos Lagoon approximately 1 mile nOMeast of the intersection of
Interstate 5 and La Costa Avenue, 0.25 mile west of intersection of El Camino Real
and Arenal Road, north of bend on Lusardi Creek approximately 2-2.5 km from
confluence with San Dieguito River, 1 km south southeast of confluence of Lusardi
Creek and San Dieguito River, south of La Jolla Valley and 4.8 km due south of
Lake Hodges Dam, near Carmel Mountain, and a number of locales nOMeast and
nonhwest of intersection of Black Mountain Road and McGonigle Road on Black
Mountain Ranch.
STAroS:
Collected south in Baja California to 30. 6' NOM by Moran (SD 87216) at
Sauzalito-2. Lightly collected in Baja with 14 sp-irnftl< deposited in the San Dier;o
NatUral History Museum's herbanum.
California Adolphia is declining Nbstantially due to urban VOwth; still healthy
populations are extant. Rarely, this spiny shrub is a dominant on hillsides and Nch
lites should be protected. Although AdolPbiA is not uncommon, . clecade of
continued urbazuzation along the coast will drastically reduce the populations now
extant. California Adolpbia should be considered for native revesetation projectS
. in suitable habitat. '
1
04/01/93
&3-
PM1}t s.lhal ~ --. lit.
PSBS IKIO
10
.
.
San Diego Viguiera (VipitT. LKinwl4I)
IJS11NG: CNPS List 2 R-E-D Code 1-2-1
StateIFed. StatuS - None ASTERACEAE
DISTJUBlTTlON: San Diego County. Baja California, Mexico
HABIT" T: An arid Diegan Sage Scrub is typically me preferred habitat of this species. which
is often a co-dominant element of me shrub community where it occurs. along
with Artemisw CAlifomiCA. Generally the shrub cover is more open than It mesic,
coastal locales where sage scrub is found. This species occun on a variety of soil
types. Olivenhain cobbly loam is mapped for the large populations of Vip;"'. at
Lower Ouy Lake and SweetWater Lake; Las POIas fine sandy loam md Cimeba
very rocky coarse sandy loam are uti1iud It some sites further inland such as near
Sequan Indian Reservation.
This is a dominant shrub in southern San Diego County in Diegan Sage Scrub
habitat away from the immediate coast. It is very common in areas of the Jamul
Mountains, and found by the thousands east of Upper Ouy Lake and along the
north shore of Lower Ouy Lake. It is also abundant near Jamul Butte, Debesa,
Donohoe Mountain. at the south end of Dil10n Road on Ouy Mesa, in the hills
east of Isham Springs and Jamacha Road, as well as near the Sequan Indian
Reservation and Sloane Canyon. San Diego Vicuiera is oc:c:uional northeast of
Magnolia Avenue in Santee, in Murphy Canyon north of Clairemont Mesa
Boulevard. at Tim Street in Bonita, by LYDDdale Lane east of Interstate 805 in
Chula ViSta, around Lake Murray such as near Navajo Road. at Hidden Mountain
Drive near El Cajon, on the north-facing slopes overlooking the Otay River near
Bayer Boulevard, at the terminus of Halifax Street in the Mission Gorge area. off
Valley View Truck Trail in E1 Cajon. near Serena Road in the Eucalyptus Hills
area. by Farrell Lane in Crest, by Fuerte Valley Road in the Calavo Gardens area,
near Ivanho Street on Dictionary Hill, off Vista de Chaparros Drive in Jamul. near
Chester Grade Road in La Mesa, between Imperial Avenue and 59th Street in
Enc:anto, in Johnson Canyon on northeastern Ouy Mesa, and in La Zanja Canyon
near Rancho Santa Fe. It is rare north of Highway 78 and provesAvely more
common as one travels south. It is found in open sage scrub in Military Sec:tor
Charlie on Camp Pendleton overlooking San Mateo Creek. iu northernmost
known locale. Old reportS inc:1ude east to Pouero. at Tec:ate, and near Barrett.
Well inland it becomes unc:ommon north of Poway.
Forty-tWo collections are found It the San Diceo NItUft1 Hiato..!I....Musewn..
herbarium from Baja Califomia; south to 28- ,. North; ....here colleaed by Moran
(SO 65229) approximately 5.5 miles south....est of Rancho el Canon. _ k is common
.""""..diately south of San Diego County into Baja Ca1iIomia.
STAWS: San Diceo Viper. is tJ-'."."C but Iti11 found It -- locales ....here
occasiona11y it is a tI"'''''....... shrub. This species sho..... IOIIIC ability to colonize
areas of mild cIisturbance ad is radily p'OWD from teed. This lpecfK is
RCO'"""all!ed for de-listin& by me CNPS; it is too Clll'''''''''on ad wide-rancinc in
. San Diceo County to warrant such a listing.
KNO'IVN SITES:
.
O4ICl1193
-&cf-
... a.rhal ~ ... JIt.
PSBS 1K80
11
SENSITIVE PLANT SPECIES KNOWN FROM lHE REGION Bur NOT FOUND ON.SITE
~
Growing on a hillside approximately one half mile to the west of the stUdy site in similar sage
scrub habitat (pSBS 1989) are San Diego Barrel CactUs (Frrouaus viritkscms) and Suake ChoUa
(~ntu pnryi vaT. rnpmtillA). Both were searched for on-site but Dot seen. AlsoknoWD &om the
area are Olay Tarweed (Hrmizonu crmjugms) on day substrate Dear Olay Lakes Road and along
PrOCtor Valley Road to the east, Cleveland's Golden StarS (Mum. ckwLrndit) a bulb Dot readily seen
except during the spring, Green's Ground Cherry (PhysJis gnmn) which crows beneath age scrub in
Olay Valley, and San Diego Marsh Elder (IfNI b.ryrsUllA) in drainages such u the Olay River. San
Diego Thommint (Aunthomintba iJicifolu) is found in Pocgi Canyon in distinctive friable soils;
Orcutt's Bird's Beak (CordyLrnu,us omtttullUs) and San Diego Bur-Sage (Ambrosu chmapodiifolu) once
crew in Rice Canyon.
SENSITIVE SPECIES OF VERTEBRATES OF VERIFIED OCCURRENCE
Two species of sensitive vertebrates were deteCted on the subject property.
Coastal Cactus Wren (Otmpylorhyncbus Immneic.cpillus SAndiegense)
lJSTING: USFWS (1991) . Category 2
CDFG (1990, 1991b) - Species of Special Concern
DISTJUllUI10N: Scattered populations occur from PIano Trabuco in southern Orange County, east ~
to the Peninsular Ranges of San Diego County and south to Valle de las Palmas,
Baja California.
HABITAT: Patches of Prickly Pear or Cholla cactus in sage scrub.
STATUS: Declining. This subspecies is one of the most endangered birds in California.
Large areas of iu limited habitat has been lost and coDtinues to decline due to
urban development.
CactUs wrens nest in the Coast ChoUa in the drainage on-site and in similar habitat immediately
west. As many as six birds were seen in this area of which 2 pain are expectecI to make use of the site.
Presence of c:aaus wrens on-site is cousidered lOAto.....ely sicnificant and WUTIDUng proteetion.
California Gnatcatcher (folioptiLr c.clifomic.c)
lJSTING: USFWS (1986, 1989) .'Catecory 2. A petition to list the California Gso"'''''''''er IS
Eood2oogered was accepted in September 1991. A decision is clue by 'Pring of
1993.
CDFG (1990, 1991b) - Species of Special Concern
Everett (1979) . D-I;oo;oog
D15T1UBUT10N: San Diego County, Rivenide County, ad Orange County; Baja California,
Mexico.
HABITAT: Diegan and Riversidean Sage Scrub. Also occun in Maritime Succulent Scrub.
ST A TlJS: Seriously declining due to loss of habitat. Between 85% IDCI 9O'lb of this apecies'
habitat has been lost to urban or agricultura1 developmenL It has already been i
extirpated from Ventura, San Bernardino me! most of Los Angeles ~es. This
bird is non-migratory. The United States population is currently -i.......! to be
04101193
-flJ~~
"
... .... ~ am/tG, ....
PSBS #K80
12
.
between 1,200 and 2,000 pairs (Atwood 1990). The c:.lifornia IUbspecies (p. Co
ulifomicus) has a very IWTOW coastal range in Baja c:.lifornia, Mexico from the
United States border south to the vicinity of El RoSario. San Diqo County
appears to be the center of abundance within the United States for this species.
This bird has been proposed for Endangered aaus by the U.s. Fish IIld Wildlife
Service.
One pair of gnatcatchers was observed in the reservoir lands to the east (off-site) which have
been revqetated with Diqan Sage Scrub. The male was observed to cross the road intO the ace ICI'Ub
immediately off-site (and adjacent to disturbed grasslands on-site). A second . air was observed a10n
the western boundary near the cactUS wrens.
SENSJTIVE VERTEBRATES WHICH POSSIBLY OR PROBABLY OCCUR ON-Sm
Six additional species of sensitive vertebrates are known from the resion and may occur on-site.
San Diego Homed lizard (PhrynOSomA cororulUm bUin"illel)
LISTING:
.
DlS'BIlllmON:
HABITAT:
STAltlS:
USFWS (1991) - Catqory 2
CDFG (1990, 1991b) - Species of Special Concern
CDFG (1991a) . Fully Protected
SDHS (1980) . Endan&ered
SDNGWS (1976) . Species of Local Concern
Ashton (1976) - Threatened
ems (1976) . Cate&ory 2
IUCN (1979) - Depleted
California and Baja California, Mexico
Open chaparral, sage ICI'Ub, pinel oak woodlands, and a1011& washes.
Declinin&. primarily due to habiut destruction and habitat degradation. Pet
collection has also attributed to their decline.
This lizard is potentially present within the sage ICI'Ub. Iu OCCWTCIlce would be of limited
biolopcal import.
Orangcthroat Whiptail (c-niJDpbonu hypnytImu Wtlinfl)
LISTING:
DlSTtUBlmON:
.
HABITAT:
$TAltlS:
ftltJM Ja'l.
USFWS (1986, 1989, 1991) - Catqory 2
CDFG (1990. 1991b) - Species of Special Concern
$OHS (1980). Threatened
$ONGWS (1976) - Species of Local Concem
CITES (1976) - Ccecory 2
IUCN (1979) - Rare
Limited; found from JOUthern C>raDF County. Westenl Riwraide md San Diego
CllNI1ties IO\Ith to southern Baja California, Mexico.
Open lip lICNh. chaparral md a1on& the ecIces of riparim zo_ md -meso
This species is stil1 relatively common in areas where cood habitat occ:un; bc....'wer.
YIlt areas of former habitat in the coutaIlow1mds have been ..........- to urban
md apicu1tural development.
-~tJJ~
.
,.. ..... IIlIpd .... lit.
13
PSBS NK80
This lizard is potentially present within the sage scrub and more likely than the homed lizard
to occur on the property. Its occurrence would be of limited biological import.
Coastal Whiptail (CntmidcphoTIIJ ugris multiscut4lUS)
""""
lJSTlNG:
DISTIUBt.mON:
USFWS (1991) - Category 2
Santa Barbara County southward through the DOMeI'D two-thirds of Baja
California. Mexico.
Open sage scrub, chaparral. open woodlands md bordering 1f'eaS. along the edges
of riparim zones md washes, desert md semi-arid habitats.
This species is still relatively common in If'eaS where good habitat occurs; however.
vast areas of former habitat in the coastallowlmds have been converted to urban
and agricultural development.
This lizard is potentially present within the sage scrub; its occurrence on the site would not
be considered biologically significant.
Northern Red Diamond Rattlesnake (Crowus ,.,.her ,.,.her)
HABITAT:
ST A roS:
lJSTlNG: USFWS (1991) - Category 2
CDFG (1991b) - Species of Special Concern
DISTIUBt.mON: Within its United States range confined primarily to the Peninsular Rmges, being
found from extreme southern Los Angeles County md Morongo Valley south intO
Baja California, Mexico.
HABITAT: Frequents rocky outcrops in chaparral. sage scrub or desert scrub on both coastal """"
md desert slopes, usually below 1219 meters.
STAroS: Still fairly common where ClCtensive areas ofbabitat remain. This md other species
of rattlesnakes are frequently persecuted by humans. This species is considered
sensitive because of its limited United States range.
This snake is potentially present in the sage scrub. Occurrence on-site 'Would be of limited
biological importance.
Northv.'e5tern San Diego Pocket Mouse (PtrOgnAthus ftdln ftdln)
HABITAT:
STAroS:
USFWS (1991) . Category 2
SIn Onofre north to Claremont, DOMean to ".....;"g. dIen IOUth to JlCWXIha md
011 into Baja California to San Quentin.
Coastal sage scrub.
Unknown, believed to be dcc1ining due to extenSive llabiulloss to development.
lJSTlNG:
DISTIUBt.mON:
This pocket mouse is locally common in the Bonita area in age scrub aad may occur on-site.
Only. trapping procnm would likely indicate prescncelabseDce. 0ccurreDce 0D1itc would be of 110
biological significance.
"""'"
04/0119)
-&1-
... Mdbat ~ tmka, lit.
14
PSBS 11(80
-
San Diego Desert Woodrat (NtotomlllepiU jrat.rrmediA)
lISTING: USFWS (1991) - Category 2
DlSTRIBt1110N: Coastal Southern California and Baja California from San Luis Obispo south to San
Bemardino Mountains. Redlands. and continuing south througb Julian and Dulzura
and OD into Baja California to the Sierra San Pedro MAUr. A disjuDc:t population
.Jso is reported from the Porterville area.
HABITAT: Sage scrub and chaparral.
STATUS: Unknown but believed to be de<'Hn;ng due to loss of habitat.
This woodrat is locally common in the Bonita area in sage scrub and may occur on-site. Only
. trapping progrun 'Would likely indicate presenccl absence. ()ccurreDcc on-site would be of DO
biological significance.
EXPECTED BIOLOGICAL IMP ACTS
Substantial redesign has eliminated initial significant biological impactS. Several adverse
biological impacts will result from the proposed 12.lot split.
1. Loss of 1.5 acres of Diegan Sage Scrub. This habitat is severely declining in the
Bonita region due to urban development, and iu conservation is . focus of regional
planning for both Chula Vista and San Diego County. This highest quality sage
scrub is situated in proposed open space B (1.2 acres). Impact sage scrub is of lesser
or degraded quality.
2. The loss of eight San Diego Viguiera are not considered biologically significant.
.
.
RECOMMENDATIONS TO REDUCE BIOLOGICAL IMPACTS
Two dedicated biological open spaces are recommended which 'Will include 1.2 acres of the
higher quality Diegan Sage Scrub on-site in Area B. and protect habitat for both the Coastal Cactus
Wren and the California Gnatcatcher (see Figure 2). The California Adolphia will.!so be proteCted
within these areas. This western open IpaI:e is 1.5 acres and is coDtiguO\ll with hi&h quality cactUS
wren and cn-e-"I.er habitat off-site to the west. h.!so 1inb the nv.n..... lands of the raervoir
with this sage scrub-domioated habitat (sepll'llted ODly by die -:..;..& pned rolId). A leCOad Itl [-ent
(Lot A) covers . Iteep Dorth-facing slope with pssland habiut. No c1earance of i.~;OD or other
forms of habitat and soil disturballCC should occur within these ..w.eat..f areas with die -=eptiOD of
die _:-age pipes and storm drainage pipe.
~ mitipUOD for die loa of fair to poor qaa1it)' .. Il:Nb (Dot within OpeD Space Los B).
0.3 acre of disturbed pssland in Lot B is reco---A'" for ,,,'J:&It,.;OD aod DiepD Sace Scrub. .
..rumUill C61ifomiu. Eraalu. C61ifomiu. E'I'iopumI/~. Dipl<<tu,.,.;c-. aod s.Ivu. JMl1ifn'.
should be the priocip.J sbrvbby componentS of this ........ II";OIl. A Wee Y" monitoriDc plan is
CM/llI!93
-{p J-
,.. ..,. ~ --. lit.
PSBS 11(80
15
further recommended to ensure the successful establishment of this scrub. The 0.3 acre constitutes the
entire area within Ar~ B mapped as grassland. Completion of this revegetation program ,.,i1\ mitigate
anticipated significant biological impacts from the project to a level of less than significant.
""'"
LITERATURE CITED
American Ornithologists' Union. 1983. Checklist of North American Birds, 6th Edition. American
Ornithologists' Union.
American Ornithologists' Union. 1989. Thirty-seventh Supplement to the American Ornithologists'
Union Checklist of North American Birds. Auk 106: 532-538.
Ashton, R. E., Jr. 1976. Endangered and Thr~tened Amphibians and Reptiles in the united States.
Soc. for the Study of Amphibians and Reptiles, Herpetology Circular No.5.
Atwood,J. L. 1990. StatuS Review ofthe California Gnatcatcher (folioptiLzuIifomia). Unpublished
Technical Repon, Manomet Bird Observatory, Manomet, Massachusetts. 79 pp.
B~uchamp, R. M. 1986. A Flora of San Diego County, California. Sweetwater River Press, National
City, CA. 241 p.
Bowman, Roy H. 1973. Soil Survey of the San Diego Area, California, Pan 1. U.S. Department of
Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service and Forest Service, in cooperation with the University '"""
of California Agricultural Experiment Station, the U.s. Department of the Interior, Bu~u of
Indian Affairs, the Depanment of the Navy, United States Marine Corps, the Department of
Housing and Urban Development, and the County of San Diego Planning Department.
December, 1973.
California Depanment of Fish and Game. 1990. Special Ionim,.k California NatUral Diversity Data
Base. Apri11990.
California Depanment of Fish and Game. 1991a. Fish and Game Code of California. Gould
Publications, Altamonte Springs, Florida.
California Department ofFish and Game. 1991b. Specia1lon;...,.k California NlItIU'a1 Diversity Data
Base. August 1991.
Collins, Joseph T. 1990. Standard Common and Current Scimtific Names for North American
Amphibians and Reptiles (3rd ed.). The Society for the Study of Amphibians ad Reptiles.
Herpetological Circular No. 19.
Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild F_ ad Flora (arES). 1976.
Everett, W. T. 1979. Threatened, I\-l;n;ng ad Sensitive Bird Species in San Diego County.
Audubon Society Sketches. July 1979. 2-3.
Holland, Robert F. 1986. Preliminary Descriptions of the Temsuia1 NlItIU'a1 Communities of """'\
California. California Department of Fish and Game.
04ItIII93
- lD. 9 -
... .... ~ III'Illa, lit.
16
PSBS #K80
.
. . International Union for the Conservation of NatUre and Natural Resources.
Vol. 3: Amphibia and Reptilia.
Jameson. E.W.. Jr. and Hans J. Peeters. 1988. California Mammals. University of California Press.
Berkeley, California. .
1979. Red Data Book.
Kennedy, Michael P. 1977. Geology of National City, Imperial Beach and Ouy Mesa QIIadrangles,
Southern San Diego Metropolitan Area, California. California DivisioD of Mines and Geology.
Map Sheet 72.
Mayer, Kenneth E. IIld William F. Laudenslayer. Jr., editors. 1988. A GWde to Wildlife Habitats of
California. California Department of Forestry IIld Fire Proteetion.
Munz. P. A. 1974. A Flora of Southern California. University of California Press, Berkeley. 1086 p.
Pacific Southwest Biological Services, Inc. 1981. Report of a Biological Survey of the Various Tank
Sites W.O. A453.0. Prepared for Sweetwater Authority, Chula Vista, California. 18 March
1981.
Pacific Southwest Biological Services, Inc. 1989. Report of a Biological Assmment of the Lynndale
Hills Property. Assessor's Parcel Nos. 592.1~30 & 49. Prepared for Cameo Development
Company, San Diego. California. 21 August 1989 (Revised 8 March 1990).
.
RegiODal Environmental Consultants (RECON). 1982. Final Environmental Impact Report for the
Bonita Valley Reservoir. Prepared for the SweetWater Authority. Chwa Vista, California. May
3, 1982.
San Diego Herpetological Society. 1980. Survey IIld Statl1S of Endangered IDd Threatened Species of
Reptiles Natively Occurring in San Diego County. .
San Diego Non.Game Wildlife Subcomminee. 1976. Proposed List of Species and Habitats Reqwring
Special Protection and Study in San Diego County. MetDorandum to SID Diego County
Environmental Quality Division.
Smith. James Payne. Jr.,lIld Ken Berg. 1988. California Native Plant Society's Inventory of Rare and
Endangered Vascu1ar Plants of California. Fotuth Edition. Spec. Publ. No.1. SeptetDber
1988.
-
U.s. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1986. Endangered and 'I'hrareDed Wddlile and Planu: Code of Fed.
Regul. Title SO, Part 17.11l1ld 17.12 (revised JlDuary I, 1986).
U.s. Fish IDd Wildlife Service. 1989. Endangered and 'I'hrareDed Wi1cIlife and Planu. F-'cnl
~ster Part IV. JlDuary 6, 1989.
U.s. Fish IDd Wildlife Service. 1991. Endangered and 'I'hrareDed Wi1cIlife and PIma; Anima!
Candidate Review for Listin& . Endangered or'I'hreanecl Sped... PlopoleCl Rule. 50 CFR.
Part 17. Fcdcra1 ~er Part vm. November 21, 1991.
.
...1Illl~'
-20 -
... .... ....,. IlnIIII, JIt.
17
PSBS 1K80
.
APPENDIX 1. FLORAL CHECKLIST OF 1HE PROPOSED BONITA Hn.L5 ESTATES.
HABITAT
D _ Diegan Sage Scrub
x _ Disturbed Annual Grassland
DABIT AT
DICOTYLEDONS
AcIoxaceae - Adoxus Family
StambuClts mc:ia1Ul Presl ex DC. Desert Elderberry
Ahoaccae - Carpet-weed Family
. Oupobrorus tdulis (L.)Bolus Honentot-Fig
. Mntm"""'ntbtmum crysl411inum L. Crystal Ice Plant
D
X
X
D
X
X
D
D
X
D,X
X
X
D
X
D
D
D
X
D,x
D
X
- X
X
D
D
D
D
X
X
X
Anacardiaceae . Sumac Family
Rbus integrifoli4 (Nutt.)Benth. & Hook. Lemonade Berry
. Scbinus molle L. Pepper-tree
Araliaceae - Ginseng Family
. Hedt'l'a helix L. English Ivy
Asteraceae . Sunflower Family
.Artemisi4 califomica Less. California Sagebrush
Ba"baTis Jalicifoli4 (R. & P.)Pers. Mule-fat
Ba"baris JaTotbToides Gray Broom Baccharis
. QnI4UTU melitensis L. T ocalote
. Conyza bo1Ulriensis (L.)Cronq. Flax.Leaf Fleabane
. Conyza canadensis (L.)Cronq. Horseweed
Encelw califomica Nun. California Encelia
. Enceli4 farinoJa Gray ex Torr. Brittle-Bush
Fu.go califomica Nun. California Filago
G1UIpbalium hicoloT Bioleni Bieclor Cudweed
Htmizoni4fasciCltlal4 (DC.)T. & G. Fascicled Tarweed
Htt.eTotbeca grandifloTa Nun. Telegraph Weed
. Hypocboeris gubra L. Smooth Cat'wan
lsocoma mmziesii (Hook. & Am.)Newaom ftI'. rnmziesii
. lActuu sen-iola L. Prickly Lettuce
. Si/ybum man.num (L.)Gaertn. Milk-Wstle
. $oncbus .sper (L.)HiU Spiny-Leaf Sow-Thistle
SuplMnomen. diqensis Gottlieb San Diego Wrath-Plant
Vipin. J.cinw. Gray San Diego SuDflower
BorqiDaccac . Borage Fmu1y
Amsinck;. intnmal;. F. & M. ~U'..h--. FilJdl_lr
Oypl4nrIM inr......edi. (Gray)Greale NimtaS
Brusicaccae - Mustard Fam11y
. Br_ia geniaJllu (Desf.)J. Ball Shon-pod Mustard
. Rqb.nus ..tivus L. Wild Radish
. SUymbrium irio L. London llocket
.
.0410I/93
- '1/-
,.. IIIIIIIa ~ 1ml/rS, lie.
"'
""""
""'"\
PSBS 1K80
..
APPENDIX 1.
18
.
FLORAL CHEClWST OF TIlE PROPOSED BONITA HILLS EsTATES
(CONTINUED)
Buxaceae
Simmmulsi. thinmsis (Link)C.K.. Schneid. Jojoba
HABITAT
D
c.....o-" - CactUS Family
Opunru. littoyilIis (Engelm.)CklI. var. littO"filIis Coast Prickly-Pear
Opunti. polift'r. Engelm. Coast ChoUa
D
D
Caryopbyllaceae - Pink Family
. Silmt gilIliu L. Common Catcbfly
Chmopodiaceae . Goosefoot Family
. .Atriplex mnib.cuu R. Br. Australian Saltbush
. s./sou .usty.lis R. Br. Russian-thistle
x
x
X
CU(\Irbitaceae - Gourd Family
M.y';' 17UICYO'."Pus (Greene)Greene Manroot, Wild-Cucumber
D
.
Euphorbiaceae . Spurge Family
CJM17UItfYCt polyc.ry. (Benth.)MiI1sp. in Parish var. polyartpll Small-seed Sanclmllt
D
Fabaceae - Pea Family
· .Auci. sp. (exotic)
.Asty.g.lus tricbopodus ssp. kucopsis (1". & G.)Tbome Locoweed
. Mtlilotus inclicul (L.)AU. Indian Sweet Clover
Gcraniaceae - Geranium Family
. Eyodium cicuurium (L.)L"Her. Red.stem Filaree
Hydropbyllaceae - Waterleaf Family
Pbtaceli. cicuu~ ssp. hispid. (Gray)Beauch. Caterpillar Phace1ia
X
D
X
X
D
,_;~'!' . Mint Family
. JUrruhium .I,.n L. Horehound
s./vi.t JMllift'r. Greene Black Sace
Malvaceae - Mallow Funily
IUlMotlwn_/l.SCiaJ6rus (Nua.)GneDe ftI'. ~ IoWa 8o.0I0....now
X
D
D
.
~ . EVCDin&-Primrose FlIIIi1y
amo,.,.. ..". ssp. ~'ri_ (Gny _ "...)Dieuich Grell Marsh EwaiD&-Primrose D
PlmugiDam't . ,laDtain FlIIIi1y
. ~go ~ L. 1:"11;."'laDtain
D
PotYloaaceae . Buckwheat Family
Eriogorunn /~ Beam. ssp./Md,:,,"- Flat-cop Buc:lnvheat
D
J
..,.., ...., -..1 ~..t ......__~.
i"7 "
PSBS IKSO
19
.
APPENDIX 1. FLORAL CHECIWST OF 1HE PROPOSED BONITA Hws EsTATES ""'"
(CONTINUED)
Urtic:ateae . Nenle Family
· UrtiCA urens 1. Dwarf Nenle
IJABITAT
X
D
D
D
D
X
X
X ,
Primulaceae - Primrose Family
. 1i1lA,.J1is DW1ISis L. Scarlet Pimpernel
Bhamnaceae . Buckthorn Family
Iidolpbi4 CAlifomiCA Wats. California Adolphia
Salic:aceae - Willow Family
s.Iix I.siolepis var. Imlcelirwe Ball Brace1in's Willow
Saxifragaceae - Saxifrage Family
~oni4 parryi (Torr.)Small Coast Jepsonia
Sc:rophulariaceae - Figwort Family
Diplaais puniceus Nun. ex Taylor Coast Bush Monkeyflower
Solanaceae - Nightshade Family
Datura wrigbtii Regel Western Jimsonweed
. Niroti4na glauca Grab. Tree Tobacco
MONOC01YLEDONS
Agavaceae - Agave Family
YUCCA scbidigera Row ex Ortgies Mojave Yucca
Poac:c:ae - Grass Family
· liwna barbata 1. Slender Oat
. Bromus diltndrus Roth Ripgut Grass
· Bromus mollis L. Soft Chess
· Jrormu rubens L. Red Brame
. CorrMJma diciu (Spreng.)Speg. SeIIoa Pampas-Gnss
. <:ynodon tJ.ayIon (L.)Pers. Bermuda Grass
DistitbJis spiuta (L.)Greeue Coastal Salt Grass
· FatIICII (Vulpilt) ".,wros 1. FozW1 Fescue
. Hordeum rmerimnn ssp.1Iptmrwm (LiDk)An:aDc. Hare kIey
. PIMUris minor Iletz. Linleseed Canary Grass
· Po. __ 1. Amlua1 Bluegrass
· Polypogon rrumsptlimsis (L.)Desf. ADDua1 Beardpss
· . Denotes DOD-Dative plant axa
D
X
X
D,x
D,x
- X
X
X
D,x
X
X
X
X
"""'\
04/C1193
-13-
IWIJt MIhal ~ ImlttS, lit.
20
PSBS #KBO
." '.APPENDIX 2.
ANIMALS OBSERVED OR. DETECnD ON 1HE PROPOSED BONrI'A Hn.LS
EsTATES.
COMMON NAME
saenmc NAME
F _ ~yover
NUMlu./MEANS
OF DEnC110N HABITAT
HABITAT
D - Diepn Sace Scrub
Bw)s
Pbasianidae (Quails, Pbasanu, and Relatives)
California Quail c.Ilipepi. ,.{ifttmicA 10 D
Cohsmbiclae (piccoDS and Doves)
Mourainc Dove z-,iti. rfU('POMnt .. F
Trocbllidae (Hum!l1incbirds)
Anna's Hummincbird c.J,ptt ."... 3 D
Corvidae Oays. Maepics. and Crows)
Scrub lay Apbcloco.... cwnJesctIIS 3 D
Troclodytidae (Wrens)
. Coastal CactUS Wren CampylarltyrKhMs ~i1llU _...sis 6 D
Canyon Wren CafherpG lIIClCicAIIMS 2 D
Muscicapidae (Old World Warblers. Gnatcatchers,ltiDcleu, Thrusbes. Bluebirds. and Wrentit)
California Gnatcatcber PoliDptw. ,.{ifttmicA .. D
Wrentit CIM_I.m- .. D
Mimidae (Mockincbirds and Thrasbers)
NOl'\bern Mockincbird MimlU poIygloltOS 2 D
California Tbrasher TiMDRO.... ,.liv;wnII 3 D
Emberi&idae (Warblers, SpUTOWS, Blackbirds and Relatives)
Black-beaded Grosbeak /'haIctitIU ~IU 1 D
California Towhee PipiJo criIMlis U D
llufous-sided Towbee Pipilo I, p. -1"*'_ 2 D
FrP>C'"I1ldat (Finches)
House Finch c.'lT.I..- wrw..--gu 10 D
Lesser Goldflllch OtirJMJiI ,..zm. 2 D
MAt6Lus
I.t<<i~. ~a and Hares) ~j/... r'M'-ii D
Daen CcaoDuil 2
. ("_I..... (Foxes. Wolves. and ReIadfts) D
Coyote c-;, Iimrms Seal
DlIIlII93
-
7'f--
... IIIIhrllIlllrl-' 1mkII. lie-
SWEETWATER AUTHORITY
505 GARRETT AVENUE
POST OFFICE BOX 2328
CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA 11l112-232S
(6'1) 420-1413
FAX (811) 425-7461 ,....-, r':':"r-\
e!~rl'" i'J"......
....~;:;."-"-
PLAN,,~,,~-3
GOVERNINQ BOARO
IUD POc:KLlNGTON. CHAIRMAN
QlOfl;GI H. WATIAI. VICI CHAIRMAN
SUI JARRETT
10YnH J. IUELI
MARGARET A. WELSH
JAMB S. WOLNIEwtCZ
CAIIIY' WRIGHT
WANDA AVERY
TREASUAER
OIAN J. REIYU
IECRIT,ARY..AOMINtlTIIlATIYI AIDI
r,,-' 0 ~ 19'34
, '
September 29, 1994
Mr. Martin Miller, Associate Planner
City of Chula Vista
planning Department
276 Fourth Ave.
Chula vista, CA 91910
Subject: ANNEXATION OF AUTHORITY ADJACENT TO
DEMICH SUBDIVISION
Dear Mr. Miller:
.
This is in response to your September 12, 1994 letter requesting
annexation of two Authority parcels from the county of San Diego to
the city of Chula vista. The two parcels contain our 18 million
gallon reservoir and control building. On September 28, 1994, the
Sweetwater Authority Board of Directors approved the annexation of
Assessor's Parcel Numbers 592-030-57 and 592-030-60 to the City of
Chula Vista. A copy of the Board action can be sent to you upon
thel Board's approval of the September 28, 1994 meeting minutes,
which will occur at its October 12, 1994 meeting. Please contact
Mr. Jim Smyth and he will forward this to you.
If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Jim Smyth, or myself,
at 619-420-1413.
Very truly yours,
Richard A. Reynolds
General Manager
.
.
JLS:RAR:le
kl\l.urte\lette,.\CVInea.bd
-
.
A Public AgeIU:Y,
Serving NatiollOl City, Chu/a Vista and Surrounding Areal
- 1(P -
Exhibit D
(
~
~ v,
~
:rt~f'r) I~
~"\b.c.h",e~ 6 - ~)/h;bi+ E
ImMORANDtlM
REVISED
October 10, 1994
FILE EY-348
TO:
Susan Snyder,Senior Management Assistant,)
John P. Lippitt, Director of Public Works~
William A. Ullrich, Senior Civil Engineer~
LETI'ER FROM MR. MC GOWAN RE BONITA HILLS ESTATES.
VIA:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Mr. Mc Gowan has indicated that he has had a problem with drainage
on Glenn Abbey Blvd. The locations he mentioned are within the
County of San Diego and therefore are not controlled by the City of
Chula Vista. The project in question does drain towards Glenn
Abbey Blvd. The project will not change significantly the direction
of flow. Ultimately, all of the water from the site ends ups in
the Glen Abbey area. This is no different from the present
situation. Very little of the site as it exists today drains
towards Mr. Mc Gowan's property. As presently designed, the entire
project except for Open Space Lot "A" will drain through the
properties owned by Zurowski, Mc IlwainjDalton, Galan and Selph to
Glenn Abbey Blvd. Open Space Lot "A" will remain natural and drain
as it now does towards Mr. Mc Gowan's property. Please see the
attached Exhibit "A".
Mr. Mc Gowan's request that an underground pipe be installed to
Sweetwater River is a very onerous condition that staff feels can
not be justified by the impact associated with this project. The
pipe would be entirely within the county if it were installed and
would be an off-site requirement.
A recent court case has indicated that the City must show a nexus
in order to require improvements of a developer. The City must not
only show a nexus but any improvement required must be in a rough
proportion to the impact associated with the project. The Engineer
for the project has indicated that the peak flow from the site
would be approximately the same as before the project.
Consequently staff feels that there is little or no nexus to
require the developer to install an off-site storm drain.
The planning Conunission heard Mr. Mc Gowan's concerns and because
the majority of his comments related to problems within the County
voted to accept staff's recommendation on the project. The
Commission did direct staff to write a letter to the County
relaying Mr. Mc Gowan's concerns.
attachments - Planning Commission Minutes
article on court case
Exhibit "A"
M:\home\engineer\permitB\bonitare.wau
--;rt
<
.
\-
-
\Q
-
%
'<
111 ,
,
,
, ,
\
~
w
-
>
,
leA
\
\
\
\
\ '"
\ '"
>'"
".
.
"G..
)J~I
"/(
"',,\\
\ \
\
.
"
.'
.
.
-.-
.
::':
MINUTES OF A REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING
OF mE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF
CHULA VISTA. cAIlFORNlA
{...
CouDcil Chambers
Public Services Building
276 Fourth Avenue. Chuta Vista
,-
7:03 p.m.
Wednesdav ~~ber 14. lQ94
ROll. CAlL
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Chair Tuchlcber. C'"",miosioum Fuller, Martin.
Moot. Ray IDd Salas
COMMISSIONERS ABSENT: Commissioner Tarantino (excused)
STAFF PRESENT: Aasistanl Pl_nning Director Lee. PriDcipal PlamIer
Griffm. Environmental Review Coordinator Reid.
Aasociate PlamIer Miller. Sr. Civil Engineer
Ullrich. ContraCt Attorney Basil
MOTION TO EXCUSE
MSCI (Fu1Jer/Mart1n) 6-0 to excuse Commiuloner Tarantino who bad a business connic:t.
fLEDGE OF AT I.F.GlANCE
Chair Tucbscher led in the pledge of allegiance to the flag IDd . moment of sileDce.
lNTRODUM'ORY REMARKS
Chair Tucbscher reviewed the composition of the pI_nnillg Commission. its responsibilities IDd
the format of the meeting.
~PPROV AL OF MINUTES - None
ORAL COMMllNlCATIONS - None
ITEM 1:
PUBUC HEARING: (A) PCZ-91-D - CONSIDERATION OF PREZONING
14.23 ACRES LOCATED NORm OF THE TER.MINUS OF MOONVIEW
DRIVE FROM RR-I (COUNTY> TO RE-P (8.37 ACRES) AND RB-4O (5.86
ACRES) - Micbael Demich
- '79-
,
".
\:.:l
"""Ol
r
_.
PC Minutes
-2-
.\J
_14,'994 ~.
(B) PCS-91-02 - CONSIDERATION OF TENTATIVE SUBDMSION MAP
FOR BONITA HIIl.S EXECUTIVE ESTATES. CHULA VISTA TRACT PCS-
91-02 - Michael Demich
~..'~
:f....
Associate PlanDer Miller presented the staff repon showing the location of the project and the
Ilea to be subdivided. Mr. Miller stated that an Initial Study. IS-91-15. of possible adverse
environmental impacts for the project had been conducted by the Environmental Review
Coordinator who concluded there would be DO aignificant environmental effects and
recommended adoption by the City Council of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and the
Mitigation Monitoring Program. IS-91-15 is lCheduled to be considered by the Resource
Conservation Commission on September 26.1994. Mr. Miller. by overbead projection. showed
where the sewer line would be located, the reservoir site. the gated road. the water tank. the
area to be revegetated with new plants and an irrigation system to be installed by the applicant.
Staff recommended that the Planning Commission adopt the resolutions recommending that the
City Council approve the proposed prezoning and tentative subdivision map in accordance with
the draft City Council ordinance and resolution based on the findings and subject to the
conditions contained therein.
Environmental Review Coordinator Reid gave the background of the Coastal Sage Scrub (CSS)
loss pennit, noting that this was the fIrSt CSS loss permit to come before the Commission. The
pennit was prepared under an ordinance recently adopted by the City Council implementing
Section 4(d) of the Federal Endangered Species Act which a\lows up to a 5 ~ take of the Coastal
Sage in the region. Mr. Reid noted that this was a draft repon out for public review and also
review by the U.S. Fish &. Wildlife Service, California Depanment of Fish &. Game. and
SANDAG. These groups would get their comments back, then the repott would be fmalized.
and the Director would consider issuing the fmal repon. All of the documents would become
pan of the environmental review process. and when one is required. the Commission would see
it with a draft EIR or Negative Declaration. In this panicular case. there was a take of 1.5 acres
of CSS. which was mitigated both on and off the project site. Given the nature of the site, the
lack of quality of the CSS and the lack of concentration of JIIlItcalChen on the propeny. and the
lack of linkage to any major areas of CSS. staff felt this permit was ldequate.
Commissioner Ray asked Mr. Reid to defme the 'poor quality' of habitat. Mr. Reid stated the
poor quality could not IUStain the density of JIIlI~tcber typically aeen in the biaber quality
habitat.
'"
~
Commissioner Ray asked how that would relate to the one pair aighted on this project site. He
explained that he was trying to let I relationship between the taking of the land versus the fact
that JIIlIlC'II~""1'S habitat the project at this time.
Environmental Review Coordinator Reid replied that the CSS take permit was not directly
related to the take of JIIlItcalChen. It was I 'cover or umbrel1a' type of habitat CSS that not
""""
-go -
~
.0
,
.
.
---..
PC Minutes
-3-
September 14. 1994
ODIy aupports patcatcben which were listed as tbreateDed. but a variety of other species which
bid been IIOmiDaled for llstlna by tile Federal GovC1'DlDClll.
Commiuiooer SIlas. referring to tile area to be revegetaled aear tile water toWer. asked if tile
previous revegetation did not take because there was 110 irrigation system. Mr. Reid ..led that
bid been done by tile SweetWater Authority and be did DOt know why it did DOt take. Under
tile present procedure of the mitigation monitoring program. tbcre was a yearly inspection of the
revegetation to assure that it does take. and there would be specifIC atandards for perccDllge of
planls and coverage that bave to be ,ttJli1'll!!d each year .over a five-year period.
Mr. Dcmlch. one of the developers. was asked to step to tbc microphone. aince be bad
Information regarding the previous revegetation. He staled that during the drought. there were
many complaints by people surrounding the area that Sweetwater was reclclessly watering the
weeds or bushes. not knowing how valuable they were or wbat the purpose was. Sweetwater.
because of the complaints. turned off the irrigation system during tbc drought years and bad not
come back on line. Part of the mitigation for this project was to let back on line. fiU in the
SUllies. and rehydroseed any areas on this parcel as weUas tbc adjoining water tank site.
CommIssioner Salas asked if there was a complaint during the drought season about the watering
of the .weeds., were they looking at a more efficient way of irrigating that area, such as drip
irrigation. Mr. Reid replied that it would be part of the mitigation package. once it bad been
flllllizcd and prepared 'by a biological consultant on tbc project.
(
CommIssioner Moot queried staff regarding the laled access road. and asked if that was part of
the subdivision map being approved. or if it would come back later. Associate Planner Miller
staled it was part of the subdivision map. Since this was tile ODIy entry and exit to the
subdivision. which was ODIy 12 lots. it was IIOt a big issue.
Commissioner Moot felt tbc open space should be available to all residents. Mr. Miller replied
that the open space areas were IIOt public open space. Staff was trying to ensure that the areas
remained in as natural a state as possible even after development. There would be 110 tralls in
tbc open space. The streets would be private 1treCts. owned and mai"..i1'll!!d by tile bomeowners
association. They would DOt be public 1treCts. Staff believed tbcIe were juatifllble reasons for
the pt\n& of the project.
.,
Commiuioner Ray asked if tbc private street. belan at tbc late. Mr. Miller affirmed. and ItIted
that the residents would maiDllln up to tile crash late and the flnallocatlon of tile crash late
would be determined in COJ\iunCliOD with Sweetwater Authority and the Cbula Villi Fire
DcpartmcDt.
ADswcrina Commissioner Moot. Mr. Miller ..led there would be a cul-dc-ac on Moonview
DrIve. installed at the developer's expense, wbcre people could IUnI around in cue they took
. wrong 1UnI.
-$/-
-
r-,'.', c,
. .~~~,; .~
. .,
.'~ t
,,'
1"'0.
1'/"
PC Minutes
-4-
September 14, 1994
~
., ;1
\~
This being the time and the place as advenised, the public bearing was opened.
Joseph H. McGowan, 3441 Glen Abbey Blvd, C.V., stated that within about 1,000 yards,
from Glen Abbey Blvd. to the top of the bill there was a distance from almost sea level to 155
feet at the crest. The water rushes down the bill down to Glen Abbey Blvd. and down through
the property at 3394 Glen Abbey. From the corner of Randy Lane down to 3394 Glen Abbey
Blvd., there was one outlet wbich was 7S" long and 3" bigh. There was DO place for the water
to go. He had discussed this with the County and with Cbula VistaEnaineering and Planning.
Mr. McGowan said water backed out on Glen Abbey Blvd. They were concerned with the bank
from Randy Lane down to the canyon, wbich the County maintained that the lack of vegetation
caused the runoff down the bin onto Glen Abbey Blvd. The County had also said that in the
vicinity of 3394 that the bill had been cut and was at a 90 degree angle. This did DOt increase
the water, but brought the water down with additional force. There was DO place for the water
to go. At the top of the bin by bis house there was a 14' to 21' guny at the top of the bin,
which had washed out during the last five years. Mr. McGowan was also concerned about the
sewerage. They had annexed years before and were told that the water table in bis yard was
14'. Down the street from him, the water table was 5' to 7'. His concern was if the sewerage
would hold the sewage from the new subdivision in addition.
Chair Tuchscher asked if the jurisdiction of the propenies at Glen Abbey Lane was in the
County. Mr. Miller stated it was, and showed the Chula Vista city limits.
Chai~ Tuchscher questioned whether the grading to be done to fmish the lots would drain back
toward the internal streets. Mr. Miller conf1rllled. He showed the present ridge line and stated
that any water on the nonh side of the ridge line flowed naturally down the slope.
,
Georae E. Gocbenaur, 3436 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, stated that bis lot bordered 230+
feet directly nonh of the open space "A" lot. Mr. Gochenaur concurred that there was natural
drainage, but he was concerned that grading and taking of vegetation would stan flow in bis
direction. He had seen cars flood out on Glen Abbey Blvd. when it rained because of lack of
drainage. The proposed drainage through Lot "B" and back down on Glen Abbey Blvd. from
an IS" drain pipe would go out on Glen Abbey Blvd. They were concerned about whether or
DOt the sewage from the bill would add to Glen Abbey Blvd. Another coneem was water
pressure, wbich Mr. Gochenaur said was already a problem. Mr. Gocbenaur noted that the
minimum sized lots were supposed to be 20,000 sq..ft. Only two oftbose lots were 20,000 sq.
ft. or greater. The rest were all smaller. His main COIICCrDS were the stann drainage, the fresh
water, aDd the aewerage.
MarIe Kolb, 3401 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, said she would be in the path of all the
drainage water. With the development of "H" Street, a drainage pipe was installed which ran
down the canyon, and there was a heavy lIIit because of the damage. There 'llDuld be a heavy
law suit if the proposed drainage is installed. They should be required to put in an underground
drainage througb Bonita Road into the river rho"....). This bordered Corden Lane which had
been a benn installed in front of it. She was DOt goina to have water under her house because
""""
- <6,). -
.'
PC Minutes
-5-
September 14, 1994
of llUpidity. She tbouaht Chula Vista represeDtatives Deeded ao 10 those places affected when
it was raining 10 observe what was really aoina on. She did not object 10 houses beina built on
lop of the hill, but asked that it be doDe ri&ht the fust time and not make other people lUffer.
Walt Selph, 3394 Gleu Abbey Blvd., CV '1'10, stated his home was where all the water came
1brough. EveryoDe who spoke before him had been against the project; he had five acres which
joioed the property which Mr. Demich was tryina to develop. He had been a builder for many
years, and in all cases natural drainaae rules. He stated in all tbe years it had Dever been a
problem 10 him. He disaped with his Deighhon saYina that water on Glen Abbey I100d there.
It stands sometimes at the ODe drain for a short time, but he had aever teen . car drown out
because of standina water. Regardina sewerage, the existing sewer line would adequately take
care of the sewage from the subdivision without puuina any pressure on the existing lioe below.
He had no objection to the subdivision. Mr. Selph said that Mn. Kolb was probably in the
lowest lot in all of Glen Abbey. He felt the buildina on -lOp of the hill would help the drainage.
(The uext three speaken had an orpni7M preseDtation.)
.
Grea Cox, 647 Windsor Circle, CV '1'10, representing the applicant, asked for 15 minutes
for an organized presentation includina several speakers. With concurrence from the Chair, Mr.
Cox aave the background of the project. He noted that the applicant had the responsibility 10
not only hydroseed and maintain the open space area, but would also have to hydroseed the
adjoining Sweetwater Authority reservoir and ensure that it is beuer maintained as habitat.
Given the fact that there were requiremeDlS to hydroseed and to monitor the hydroseedina in the
open space areas, there would be a greater stand of natural vegetation that would be put in as
a result of the project which would mitigate some of the drainage that was currently occurring.
Mr. Cox stated there were parcels less than the R-E designation because the request was for a
residential estate with a precise plan, which presented tbe opportUnity 10 provide a development
which conformed to the landforms without a lot of cut and fill. The streetS would be privately
maintained by the homeownen association. and would be . aate-parded community. He asked
Mr. David Porot to respond to issues raised by the resideDlS concernina drainaae.
David Porot, the project eapneet' for Mr, Demlcb, expressed his COIICCI'II 10 the residents
arouDd the area and said that the existina ailuation on lots I, 2, and 3 on the ridgeline currently
drained 10 tbe north. The propoaed development would take about 100' of that 10 the center.
The subdivision would reduce the drainaae aolDa down the bank. Lots 4,5, and 6 and the
iDternal drainaae would be drainina 10 the center. They were propoaina 10 inata11 rock rip rap
10 reduce water flow possibly into the resideDlS' area. The cfa wou1d be reduced by 1 cta
because of the divenion of water u.o the proposed iD1ets.
CO'""'luloner Martin asked Mr. Porot 10 explain what he meant by. rip rap. Mr. Porot stated
that with the existina aituation. lots I, 2, and 3 ran north. With the padina to 1lll dooe, it would
drain into tbe catch basin and diverted into the center atOrIII drain ayatem in open space lot 'b'.
.
- &3-
-
..-
,':<('
;,/:"","
. . PC Minutes
"
-6-
September 14, 1994 .,
Commissiouer Martin questioned whether that was lilted wlter. Mr. POrol said It would be
uuisaDce water which would 'be off roofs, streets, watei- collected from tile lots tbemlelves.
Commissiouer Martin asked if tile water east of that outside of tile property would still come
down through there. Mr. Porot said pan of that would be taken, and would have silt. Using
tile appropriate chart, It had all been taken into consideration. He did not feel tIlere would be
any problem with the clralnage system.
Chair Tuchscher asked that Mr. POrol deflue .cfs.. Mr. Porot explained that it was .cublc feet
per second" and was tile amount of water that travels a certain distanee.
Commissiouer Moot asked If there were any design solutions that would improve the clralnage
situation for the downhill residents. Mr. Porotstated the proposed mitigation for the drainage
was by providing adequate rock rip rap protection with the City Engineer's approval. The
intense landscaping would absorb some of tile sheet flow and slow down the water flow.
Sr. Civil Engineer Ullrich, referring to Commissioner Moot's question regarding reduction of
impacts, stated that a retention facility could be Installed in tile lower pan where the drains were
coming out and retain the water for a longer time. There was a trade-off in that the water would
run for a longer period of time. There was not a lot of area to constrUct ~ retention facility.
Mr. Porot added that retention facilities were uaually for larger quantities of water, such as for
golf courses or desert areas where water is Deeded to perk the soil. The quantity being dealt
with in this case was not very large as compared to other areas.
At Commissiouer Ray's request, Mr. Miller indicated the City and County boundaries, the
aubdivislon area, and the location of the drainage. A IIlght portion on tile northern ridge would
be taken to the center.
Commlsslouer Ray asked Mr. Porot what percentlge of tile current runoff going down to Glen
Abbey would be eliminated or reduced. Mr. Porot answered that approximately 113 would be
. taken away.
Commisslouer Ray concluded that If tile project was developed, 113 teas water would come down
into tile same clralnage area thatltloes to today. Mr. Parot concurred. Por tile whole project
aite, tile cfs would be 1 cts leas. It would be reducecs because of tile time and ",,~ation It
would take to travel betau5" it would have a longer dialance to 10.
Commisslouer Ray was concerned beta'lse tile clralnale problem area was ill tile County and the
City had 110 jurisdiction to fIX it. In tenns of tile project lite. tile run-off could be limited by
including mitigation measures which would DOt impact the residents Delatively If it were
approved. He asked Mr. Porotlftlle cumulative effect of tile project would reauce the current
clralnage iIIto that area. Mr. Porot concurred.
~..~
~gf-
""""
!.
,.
t
"""
I,
,..\
.'
PC Minutes
-7-
September 14, 1994
.
MIke Demlch, 3356 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, one of the owoers of the project site, said
be bad met with most of the people down on Glen Abbey; the flows were being reduced to two
of the back yards. Reduction of the water flow would occur because of the planting of the
hillsides that currently erode and cause siltation aoing down the hill. Tbe water tank parcel
would be reveaelated, as well. By rehydroseeding the City of Quia Vista site, water and
ailtation would be kept from Windrose and going acroSs property down to Glen Abbey. Mr.
Demich commeDded staff on their stUdy of the drainage, the vegetation and the grading contoUrS
to come up with something that would flow, look nice, and help with the runoff. He felt it was
a win-win situation. They had cbecked with the County, and there was the caplCity to baDdle
the IICwage in Glen Abbey. Regarding the water pressure, be was not sure wbere the residents
were obtaining their water. SweetWater bad told tbem there was adequate water pressure for
their project.
Commissioner Moot asked if there was a particular reason for gating the road. Mr. Demich
stated there had been much vanda1ism, and currently Moonview was gated off with a permaoent
chainlink fence. It seemed to be an attraCtive area for people to drink beer. break beer bottles,
and a lovers lane. Sweetwater Authority and the local biologists wanted to keep the reservoir
area protected. It was designed as a natural habitat for the birds. Everyone involved, including
Planning staff. felt It would be best to have It gated with a turn-around for people to get back
out. If not gated, the problems would filter on into the residential neighborhood and onto
Sweetwater's property as well as theirs.
Mr. Cox returned to the podium to conclude the presentation, stating that tbcy thought it was
a good project; It met all City standards regarding drainage and grading. Tbe project would not
increase the drainage to the area below on Glen Abbey and would improve the problem by
reducing the flow by 1 efs. He thought the rip rap would help dissipate the speed and the
amount of the debris and silt picked up. He pointed out that given the fact that it would be
designed as a gate-guarded community, those buying the homes would have a liJDiflClllt amount
of veaetation as part of the homes which Ibould belp the retention of the water. He asked for
support of the staff reconunendations.
No one elllC wiIhin& to speak, the public bearing was c:losed.
Commissioner Moot asked where the aate at Moonview was located and the area Mr. Dimich
felt ueeded to be protected. He was vllI"nmfortable.with pting oft'the area.
AAoc:Iate Planner Miller indicated tbe location of tbe pte. and stated there was apparently a
problem with people vandalizina and liaeriDa the area. If this were a public road, the problems
would be c:arriecl over into the cuI-c1Hac:1and possibly to the reservoir site itself which is a
eensitive habitat area for the ",-'''-11"-'- and c:ac:tuI wren.
Commissioner Moot c:onfumed that it was the eensitive area by the mervolr which n~e1"" to
be free of people. He stated that every cuI-de-1IC bad a problem with people coming in. He
asked if there was some other area that DCt'*' to be protected. Mr. Miller indicated the bank
.
~g5~
......
8. .
. ..~
.-'_ .'i~~
. ."_~ u'.
.<> ~>..
t.:.:
PC Minutes
-8-
September 14. 1994
aDd other open space lots which ueeded to be protected because they weR Inteoded to be natural
areas COJllleCting with the RservOir site. TheR weR defmitely JIIlIu:atcbc:n aDd cactus WRns
in the area.
CommissioDe:r Martin asked staff to explain the diffc:reuce between a private road aDd a public
road; who was responsible for malnteDIIICC; would theR be sidewalks aDd curbs; who was
responsible for those?
~.:
Sr. Civil Engineer Ullrich ansWCRd that private streets wm typically leas in width between the:
curb faces; public ItRCts would be wider aDd Dc:ed mOR grading, private streets would be
maintained by people living in the area; public ItRCts would be maintained by the: City. The
tentative map showed that some of the: StRCts showed sidewalks on both sides. othen showed
sidewalk on ODe: side.
:~
.
Commissioner Ray asked the: rationale for putting the gate at the existing location rather than
at the entrance to the development. Mr. Miller stated the: gate as proposed would be at the
municipal boundary. Staff saw no Dc:ed to move it. Commissioner Ray asked if the:R was any
legal issue with the City by allowing a gate limiting access to County property. Mr. Miller
noted that it would be annexed. Staff had contacted LAFCO Rgarding that, who said they had
a set policy that a city stRCt could not go from a city into a county and back into the: city.
TheRfoR, the Sweetwater parcel was having to be annexed and, for continuity of oWDc:nhip.
the: smaller parcel with the pump house. .
ComimssioDe:r Ray. Rferring to a pRvious proposal for a gated community. asked if theR was
a sewerage or drainage problem. the City would be liable to fIX the: sewerage aDd drainage
problem even though it was a private ItRCt. Mr. Ullrich stated that the: sewer 1iDc: would be
public and the City would have the responsibility to Rpair the sewer lines. The drainage on the
site would be private and would be maintained by the: homcoWDc:n.
~
Chair Tuchscher stated that from a locational standpoint. it would make sense to protect the:
Sweetwater Rservoir. From a housing product standpoint, he thought It was exciting to have
some: higher end houses within the City limits; it would help from an economic Itaodpoint in that
the individuals maldl1g decisions to locate compaIIies often want to know whc:re they would live
aDd would seek these types of views. From a drainage Itaodpoint. theR was a ~xisting
condition which would be made slightly belter. ~R was a problem with the County perhaps
respooding to citizens complaints. He IlIUested that staff draft a letter to the County leUiDg
them know of the situation.
Assistant planni." Director Lee Slated staff would pass that on to the Engineering Departmc:nl
to forward on to the County. Following up on some: of the com"",nto Rgarding public versus
private. Mr. Lee reminded the Commission that theR would be 110 access dire4ly to the private
property. Extending the ItRCt as a public IIt1'eet would provide access to the subdivision itself.
DOt to open space. The City bas an open space area immediately to the east, part of a park
"""
-8'(0-
-:;:--
.... ".
.~.'
;~,~ ,~~
.~
,
.
.
PC Minutes
-9-
September 14, 1994
1)'IIteIJI, wllich abutted the County IiDe and into the cemetery. Tbere was 110 access intO the
cemetery, 10 the open space in the area as far as liDbae was limited.
Commissioner Martin commented that the residents had floodina and drainaae problems and he
asked If there was IOme way to alleviate their concern that they were belna Ipred by showina
them somelhina that was done in the put where there was floodina. but due to the developed
area, there was less.
Mr. Ullrich DOted that a dam had been installed with the c:onstrIICtion of Bonita Lona Canyon
Estates. 'There had been floodina problems downstream alona Acacia. With the clam, the
floodina subsided. Mr. Ullrich IIOted this was a much laraer project than the project under
consideration. Assistant Plann!naDirector Lee stated the similarity was that the flooded area
was previously in the County as the proposed area, and was developed by the City and the
floodina alleviated.
Commissioner Ray stated he had a areat deal of I)'mpathy for the residents, it was an existina
condition wh\ch he felt would be reduced. However, it was a County problem and the
Commissionen had no jurisdiction.
MSC (RaylFul1er) 5-1.1 (ec-mlccloners Salas aaalDSt. ~mlccloner Tarantino excused)
to approve Resolution PCZ-91.D recommendlnl that the City Council prezone 8.37 acres
of land to R-E-P and 5.36 acres of land to RE-4O.
I
MSC (RaylFul1er) 4-2-1 (CommIssioners Salas and Moot aaainst; CO"'mlccloner Tarantino
excused) to approve Resolution PC5-91.o2 recommendinl that the City Council approve the
tentative map for Bonita Hills Executive Estates. Cbuta Vista Tract 91.02.
Assistant Plann!na Director Lee IIOted that this item would move forward to the City Council
and would probably be heard durina the middle of October. possibly October 11. The residents
would be recelvina notice to remind them.
Commissioner Ray IUUested that the residents reprueDl themselves before the City Council.
Chair Tucbscber asked the radlllJ of mailina for this project. Mr. Lee stated it was DOliced at
1.000 feet.
Chair Tucbscber declared a break at 8:30 p.m. The meetlna was reconvened at 8:40.
ITEM 2:
PUBUC HEAlUNG: CONDmONAL USE PERMIT PCC-94-47; REQUEST
TO ADD A SELF-SERVICE CAR WASH TO THE EXISTING SERVICE
STATION LOCATED AT SOl TELEGRAPH CANYON ROAD, $he11 Oil
Company
- 11-
A,
8a&uda7. J...., 1994
,
. ~&""'"'
developers eaSela .
.
.
.........1)0 riabll, tile SuInme Court 1eIulq1lilt. nGectecll f-ho-w "There ue IimllI to what JOV can
,....)' placed Dew Iimita ClIl tile 6deoIo1icaI dmaioD GO a court require, aDd It.. a pretty cIeor "eo-
ablIity 01 aover-lI111 ncpdre wilen CIIItIlnI Jr.--_t JaDd.. aqe from tile Supreme Court!UJat
deveIopen to eel uide put 01 tbelr _ aatbority baa IClIlI beeD. priori- tile)' iDteDd to Impoee Umillllll pul>-
property for cwo-tal or t)' 01 tile clllleuatlYe juaticeo. lie juriIdictloao' ability to require
atber public -. Tbe cIecioiaIl did IIOt cut doubt oIf-elte Improvemenll," be uid.
Tbe 5-4 dec:iaioll. with I ~ ell tile court'. ",.cedenll apboJdiDJ .o-~~1.i~'
apiDIllIl by Cbief JIIIlice WWiam ~ ==~II''''''''':=''J.! rem ~L':~~ ~.i
~ Tbe court IleId tbat nquIriDa a .... . moot important port
pabIic . ..ft~ U a ClllDlIitioll 01 01 !be decioiOll yeotercloy Ioy in !be
.'- ' '10. to buIIcl or apIIId 10 III court'. directioao for applyina tile
. iIDcautItutioll "taIlina" l1IlIeu tile .. teat.
t pa_t CIIlIbow a "rouIb pro- Tbe juoticeo pve !be ~e
portioaIIitT' ~ tile require- !lardeD 01 juatIfyinJ III reotrictiooo.
__ aDd !be puticuIu bum poeed ID a diatiDct ud UDUPfCled obift
by tile tletelcpDeDt, IUCh u III- from cummt low UDder which tile
__ tn1Iic or a ...."'..,-1 dill- IIIldowDer -mg to cboIIenge a
... 0I1IoocIiDg. .......,. reotrictioa baa !be burden
Tbe ~ tIleD applied lllat 01 proving that tile regulatioll would
leIt to reject III Orep c:lty'1 reo _ lIII or IIIbotllltially aD --
.w-t lllat tile _ 01 a ~ VIIue from !be property::'
plumbing oupply aIore, a1tuated Juotice JoIm Paul SteveDI, fD a
witbiD I IIoad plain, .. IIlIIce 10 atraagIy worcIed cIiooeIItiDg opiniClIl.
....-m 01 ber !aDd anIIabIe for I wbicb be took !be unuoual otej> 01
dniDI&e _. IIlcycJe path aDd tIiliverinI from !be bench, uic1 !be
peal apace U I CGDditioll for lPO court bacI"otUmbled badly" in \llaC-
to double tile aile, 01 ber .. Dew ClOIlItltutiOIl hurdIeo la
__ aDd pave !be ~ lot. tile Jlth 0I1and-uae regulation~
Revaain& I cIecioiaIl by tile Sa- The dec:iaioll" Dolan ft, Ci.
pnme Court 01 Oregoo, tile ~ TIprd,.... baaed 011 tile ~p
ty fowld that tile city - TipnI, I c1auae 01 !be Fifth AmeDclment,
IlIburb 01 PartIaDd - bad 1IOtjuati- JPbito" p&lIWideo that private proper.
fied tile req'*-ll )Iritb ..., .t1 aba1l1lOt be "lakeD for pul>"lOJIIt
lIIIIl&J'""'lolftft ~ juat COIl'p""..tioll," t
- The court'l ruIiD&, lIcnrever,. III ather ruIiDp yeoten\a)'.
aIlouId bave IIttJe Impact ill SIll Die- rcourt:
10 CouDty.1oc:aI1epI apertI uid .HeId 7.2 that (edenJ ,
jeaterday.- ....t bave to be' told a criIIfIIII
"We bave to be _bIe ID .,eDdaDt wDI be ~~ a
what we require. IDd tile __ , _tal lapital lfloaDd ' by
ableg.-:;;wbetber;iR'r ~ 0 ;;~a:;.fttt teocblDc ~
ud !be ;cIIi . t .... CIIlIlOt bill tile MecIican: fro-
. trIlIl aDd fecIenI tupayero ~
AttorDe)' HI! VlIderIlalll, "SowbeD 01 doIIan for facu/ty aDd iliff It
__ cameo to develop a large diliated medical acbooIo.~
aubd!viaion, we get parb aDd II- . Ruled 7.2 tbat ..tel
Inrieo and 1CbooIo, but with - fartlid judgeo wbo bear in-
Ilouae CIII I _t Iat, we CIIl'1 do ,.., Iawouito to C!Ilpuai!ive i-
lllat. .... nuda !bey llDd....m:
I,..,d uae Ittene,. Lou WoIfUeI- Held ... -"_ ~_, .l
_ agreed. "There ue -;a;a. '. H !-~ ........ ..... t "Tve
cIictiollo ill CaIlfonlia !bat _. lllltop ""-"'1 I ouopect 1rbo
reacIlbuttbioiID't_oItbem,"be .....1Il~ requeot tOr I
aid ~. III I further lefiuement 01
Wbat die cIecioiaIllIII)' do II lift die CIlIIrt'. 1166 ruIiDg in MiraPcIo
~t ~ _ ae-- va.~. IIIIde famouo by ,-v
Ill! ill aegotiatiDg with aover-t crime ...... I
aaeIlCieo CIII "bat !bey CIIl atrICt .
from buiIden, Ia___ IUmDe)' 8lafl WIlt<< LorI.....b""ll_lribIiItd
Man Fe*- uicL to tIliI.-port. ,"""'"
,.' a. .- ,
-
"
7'HESAN DIEGO UNION.7'BIBUNE
4 _
, .
I ,- . .~
lillie-use requirements on
~rnurttighten8
rBide ccmdiMM
nc___
-----
aDNGTON -1111 aubIlIJl-
:<<)' for acMcatel 01 private
-.
~\
~ g g~
r~t,.
-
......
... 1,,;
.
.
.-
-
, GRAY CARY WARE
&FREIDENRICH
. PIlOflIIIIOtW,. ~/.noN
LAND USE ALERT
SUPREME COURT LIMITS
EXACTIONS; PROPERTY OWNERS'
RIGHTS STRENGTHENED
In rapid IIICCC$sion, the U.S. Supreme
Coun issIIed two opinions in late June which
dramatically sb'engthened the ri&l1ts of property
owners seeking development approvals from loca1
governments.
The Coun established a new lelal limit on
development exactions, rulinl in Dolan v. Tinrd
thaI mere must be a 'room D1'ODOrtionalilY'
between the impacts of a development and die
)pitiD'ation conditions imposed 10 lessen those
impacts. At the same time, the Coun increased
the burden on local lovernments to justify
exactions imposed on developments.
The ~ case expanded on the COlIn's
reasonina in the 1987 case of NaHan v. Coastal
Commission, in which the Coun had ruled thaI
there musl be a demonsb'able factual relationship,
or 'nexus,' between a development impacl and
the conditions imnnled 1ft mitir.~ it, In tiQlIaD,
the COlIn " ~tated thaI es""tians would be
invalidated if dlev did IIOt ""tuallv OBV~ tn
nntigate me iff.ft'.,...,. imPJI,..c',' but it did DOt'
defme when a mitilation meuure COlIld be
invalidated simply for beinl _sive.
The ~ decision answered dlis question of
when an exaction is excessive in cwo ways.
J
.A hbliCDIiDll of'M EnvironlM1flal.
LtzNJ U" tIIIIl &aT Es/Ql' Group
"DIy 1"4
Fint, It required localities to justify their
exactions bued on UI empirical factual basis,
rather lhan conc\usol)', unsupported usumptions.
SQldies or factual analysis now must quantify a
development's panicu1ar Impacts on the
~lnity. Second, it required 1hat the
exactions i"'I-oaed DOt exceed the IlCwly-cSefiDed
limil of 'rough proportionality' to the quantified
Impact.
'We mink a .rm such u 'rOll&l1'
proportionality' bell encapsulateS what we hold to
be the requirement of die Fifth AInendIIIent. 1Ill.
precise mathematic.l fO.Jtl""I1.';tm ~fI! ~,...... hut
t)e city must ",JIlt,.. IOIDe ann nf tnttivittll.1i,Nt
"~tl'!"";ftIltion 1hat Ibe reauired 1IMit-.""" ie
..,lated both in nalllre and extent to the _-.4
~v~l~ment .
In~, I bardwue store owner _Iti"ll
permil to expand wu required to dedicate land
for flood control. open apace and I bike pIlbway.
The city had aot shown how dedv..a\ioft of land
for flood contrOl wu ei1her DeUS"1)' or related
to mitigltin& the amall IIIIOUDI of atormwater
I1IIlOft caused by the expansion. Joct..... the city
. DCVer awde or aupponed findlnas 1hat the bike
pIlb would mitiple nffIc CODpItloIl caused by.
1he IlDre expansion, the COlIn inv.IUI...... that
exac1:ion u well.
-
<gq-
I
_~1f ~....- .- !!i_'
Because ~ and 1&Iin involved only
dedications of real properly, lhe immediate
questinn nf wh~th~r mnfVlltaQ' f~~ ..110 must
~nform In thfl! new limit nf "room
prnnnrtinn201i1:y" W:IIC arn:WlI!T'M two davs after
1&Iin. in lhe case of Ehrlich v. Culver CilV. In
Ehrlich. me lower Ippellate coun bad upheld
elW:tion fees imposed to mitigate a tennis coun
closure and to pay for public an works. The U.S.
Supreme Court ordered lhe Ippellate judgment
vacated and reconsidered in light of 1he 1&Iin
opinion.
The Ippellate court in Ehrlich bad relied on
other recent cases 1hat allowed localities more
flexibility when elW:tions were imposed in lhe
more common form of monewy fees. 1&Iin.
however, made no distinction between fees and
olher mitigation measures. In~, 1he COlIn
twice stated lhat it was determining "whelher lhe
The Court'. phrasiD& of 1he issue, as TleIl'
its action in Ehrlich, are a ItrOII& indiclliOll'
1he Supreme Court inIeuds to require 1"
constillltionally montloled minimum of "roo.."
orooortionality" in all forms of land use elW:tions: .
"invasive likings" I1/Ch as euemetIlS 1Ild;
dedications, "reauJatorY likings" IIICb as use >
restrictions, &lid ...."..,ry Impact mitigation fees.' .; .'
~.
For more information 011 1he 1&Iin cue IIld
evolving Fifth Amendment "likings" analysis,
contaCt any of Gray Cary Ware " Freldemic:h's
Environmental. Land Use and Real Estate
attorneys. or Charles Black at (619) 699.2874, or
Doug Aikins at (415) 328-6561.
'hi'" U. Aim is prodItc1Id IftCI 0lIp)'I'i..... by Cin)' c.,. WIN."""". AIry_....,.. fj... fII.. .....f1I..~U. AIM......"........ otChy
CIr) _..I: FrNeanch. A Profnetoul Car1MnUon, iI .nealy prohibMd. QrI)' CIr)' W.. I: FnidIendl',1atI U. All"".............. II...... -' frien4I. ....-
............ ___ COftIIi..... ........ a.pIlNd)' . .......; appIabiIiIy .......... ..... will........... fI.. en- facu. 0 I".. QrI)' c.,. Wn
a_ A '"-1.......-...
.,
; -
,"/ .
t~-'--'" .-
f}
J
.
,
I
,
,
-
GRAY CARY WARE
,. AFREIDENRICH
A raoFElllONItJ. ''ORPOItATlON
'?'.
",,~~<l'
~
AlIomeylll Law
401 B SIRe!. Suite 1700
San DielO. CA 92101-4297
Addreu Correction Requested
"
'/~~:,:... To:
;i :or/t.
i~t-'
,'":'( NEWSLElTER
<y. .
~-,...'t
- qo-
""'"
;'
....-
u.s, ....
'AID
..... HI, _
"-.CA
....-
Dopo .,MIioW_
'lO7 F _
Qodo v.... CA 9.9.0
~~~'-/
~
"""'\
. .
'"
.
.
- 9/-
-e- -
~
, ..:... .~) 1
(~l . ~ ! ,~ , ~ .~=0.. ; ~
-,. t ~" !' '... ~
~ ~-' ' ~
_ ~ ~l' : : " ;:. i' ~
. N ''t.'S <l . .!' , ' ' ~
. .~~()! .~ jlt~ .: ~~, ~~~
...1, ; . .....' ,! I ! . .
. ~ () ":- ' tj' i '-i. ,,' I
G: t: ~, : "'! ii' I
_\;, 'i I :! .
""
~.-
1
- 9;)-
"
.
. .
-.
- cr3~
. .
"""
r-
.
.
.
RESOLUTION NO. PCZ-91-D
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING
COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY
COUNCIL PREZONE 8.37 ACRES OF LAND TO RE-P
(RESIDENTIAL ESTATE-PRECISE PLAN), AND 5.36 ACRES
OF LAND TO RE-40 (RESIDENTIAL ESTATES-40,OOO SQ. FT.
MINIMUM LOT SIZE)
WHEREAS, a duly verified application for a prezoning was fIled with the Planning
Department of the City of Chula Vista by Mr. Michael Anthony Demich; and
WHEREAS, said application requests a prezone of 14.23 acres of land located north of
the terminus of Moonview Drive from RR-l (County of San Diego) to RE-P (8.37 acres: APN
592-030-58), and RE-40 (5.36 acres: APN's 592-030-57 and 592-030-60); and
WHEREAS, the development of the 8.37 acre APN 592-030-58 is the subject matter of
a Tentative Subdivision Map, PCS-91-02, which is being concurrently heard with this
application; and,
WHEREAS, An Initial Study, IS-91-15, of possible adverse environmental impacts of
the project was conducted by the Environmental Review Coordinator (ERC) , and the ERC
concluded that there would be no significant environmental effects and recommends adoption of
the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Program; and,
WHEREAS, the Planning Director set the time and place for a hearing on said prezoning
application and notice of said hearing, together with its purpose, was given by its publication
in a newspaper of general circulation in the City and its mailing to property owners within 1,000
feet of the exterior boundaries of the property at least twenty-one days prior to the hearing; and
WHEREAS, the hearing was held at the time and place as advertised, namely 7'00 p.m.
September 14, 1994, in the Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, before the Planning
Commission and said hearing was thereafter closed.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Commission fmds that the project
would have no significant environmental impacts and recommends that Council adopt the
Mitigated Negative Declaration and the Mitigation Monitoring Program for IS-91-15.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION hereby
recommends that the City Council prezone 8.37 acres of land to RE-P and 5.36 acres of land
to RE-40 in accordance with the attached draft City Council Ordinance and the fmdings
contained therein.
And that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the owners of the property and the
City Council.
-1~~
.
.
.
Resolution No. PCZ-91-D
Page No.2
PASSED AND APPROVED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF CHULA VISTA,
CALIFORNIA, this 14th day of September, 1994 by the following vote, to-wit:
AYES:
Fuller, Martin, Moot, Ray, Tuchscher
NOES:
Sallas
ABSENT:
Tarantino
ABSTENTIONS:
William C. Tuchscher II, Chairman
ATTEST.
Nancy Ripley, Secretary
P,\HOME\PLANNlNGIMARTIN\BONITA\91DPC.RES
-11-
.
.
.
RESOLUTION NO. PCS-91-02
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING
COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL
APPROVE THE TENTATIVE MAP FOR BONITA HILLS EXECUTIVE
ESTATES, CHULA VISTA TRACT 91-02
WHEREAS, a duly verified application for a tentative subdivision map was
filed with the Planning Department of the City of Chula Vista by Mr. Michael
Demich; and
WHEREAS, said application requests subdivision of 8.37 acres of land into
twelve (12) residential and two (2) open space lots located north of the terminus
of Moonview Drive, currently within the County of San Diego; and
WHEREAS, an Initial Study, IS-91-15, of possible adverse environmental
impacts of the project was conducted by the Environmental Review Coordinator
(ERC), and the ERC concluded that there would be no significant environmental
effects and recommends adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and
Mitigation Monitoring Program; and,
WHEREAS, the Planning Director set the time and place for a hearing on
said tentative subdivision map application and notice of said hearing, together with
its purpose, was given by its publication in a newspaper of general circulation in
the city and its mailing to property owners within 1,000 feet of the exterior
boundaries of the property at least twenty-one (21) days prior to the hearing; and
WHEREAS, the hearing was held at the time and place as advertised,
namely 7:00 p.m. September 14, 1994 in the Council Chambers, 276 Fourth
Avenue, before the Planning Commission and said hearing was thereafter closed.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE PLANNING
COMMISSION hereby finds that the project will have no significant environmental
impacts and recommends that the City Council adopted the Negative Declaration
issued on IS-91-15.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION
hereby recommends that the tentative subdivision map for Bonita Hills Executive
F:IHOMEIPLANNINGlMARTIN\BONITAI9102PC.RES
~ 9f~
.
.
.
Estates, Chula Vista Tract PCS-91-02, be approved by the City Council subject to
the findings and conditions contained in the attached draft City Council Resolution.
That a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the owners of the property
and the City Council.
PASSED AND APPROVED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF CHULA
VISTA, CALIFORNIA, this 14th day of September, 1994 by the following vote,
to-wit:
AYES:
Fuller, Martin, Ray Tuchscher
NOES:
Moot, Salas
ABSENT:
Tarantino
ABSTENTIONS:
William C. Tuchscher II,
Chairman
ATTEST:
Nancy Ripley, Secretary
P.IHOMEIPLANNINGIMARTINIBONIT AI9102PC.RES
- 1'Q -
.
MINUTES OF A REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING
OF THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION OF
CHULA VISTA, CAliFORNIA
7:03 p.m.
Wednesdav. September 14. 1994
Council Cbambers
Public Services Building
276 Fourth Avenue. Chula Vista
ROLL CALL
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Chair Tuchscher, Commi~sioners Fuller, Martin,
Moot, Ray and Salas
COMMISSIONERS ABSENT: Commissioner Tarantino (excused)
STAFF PRESENT: Assistant PIllnning Director Lee, Principal Planner
Griffm, Environmental Review Coordinator Reid,
Associate PIani1er Miller, Sr. Civil Engineer
Ullrich, Contract Attorney Basil
. MOTION TO EXCUSE
.
MSC (Fuller /Martin) 6-0 to excuse Commiltltloner Tarantino who bad a business conflict.
PI.F.DGE OF A I I .F.GlANCE
Chair Tuchscher led in the pledge of allegiance to the flag and a moment of silence.
INTRODUCTORY REMARKS
Chair Tuchscher reviewed the composition of the Plllnning Commission, its responsibilities and
the format of the meeting.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES - None
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS - None
ITEM 1:
PUBUC HEARING: (A) PCZ-91-D - CONSIDERATION OF PREZONlNG
14.23 ACRES LOCATED NORTH OF THE TERMINUS OF MOONVIEW
DRIVE FROM RR-l (COUNTY) TO RE-P (8.37 ACRES) AND RE-4O (5.86
ACRES) - Michael Demich
- (01-
.
.
.
PC Minutes
-2-
September 14, 1994
(B) PCS-91-02 - CONSIDERATION OF TENTATIVE SUBDMSION MAP
FOR BONITA HILLS EXECUTIVE ESTATES, CHULA VISTA TRACT PCS-
91-02 - Michael Demich
Associate Planner Miller presented the staff report showing the location of the project and the
area to be subdivided. Mr. Miller stated that an Initial Study, IS-91-15, of possible adverse
environmental impacts for the project had been conducted by the Environmental Review
Coordinator who concluded there would be no significant environmental effects and
recommended adoption by the City Council of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and the
Mitigation Monitoring Program. IS-91-15 is scheduled to be considered by the Resource
Conservation Commission on September 26,1994. Mr. Miller, by overhead projection, showed
where the sewer line would be located, the reservoir site, the gated road, the water tank, the
area to be revegetated with new plants and an irrigation system to be installed by the applicant.
Staff recommended that the Planning Commission adopt the resolutions recommending that the
City Council approve the proposed prezoning and tentative subdivision map in accordance with
the draft City Council ordinance and resolution based on the findings and subject to the
conditions contained therein.
Environmental Review Coordinator Reid gave the background of the Coastal Sage Scrub (CSS)
loss permit, noting that this was the fIrSt CSS loss permit to come before the Commission. The
permit was prepared under an ordinance recently adopted by the City Council implementing
Section 4(d) of the Federal Endangered Species Act which allows up to a 5 % take of the Coastal
Sage in the region. Mr. Reid noted that this was a draft report out for public review and also
review by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, California Department of Fish & Game, and
SANDAG. These groups would get their comments back, then the report would be fmalized,
and the Director would consider issuing the final report. All of the documents would become
part of the environmental review process, and when one is required, the Commission would see
it with a draft ElR or Negative Declaration. In this particular case, there was a take of 1.5 acres
of CSS, which was mitigated both on and off the project site. Given the nature of the site, the
lack of quality of the CSS and the lack of concentration of gnatcatchers on the property, and the
lack of linkage to any major areas of CSS, staff felt this permit was adequate.
Commissioner Ray asked Mr. Reid to define the "poor quality" of habitat. Mr. Reid stated the
poor quality could not sustain the density of gnatcatcher typically seen in the higher quality
habitat.
Commissioner Ray asked how that would relate to the one pair sighted on this project site. He
explained that he was trying to get a relationship between the taking of the land versus the fact
that gnatcatchers habitat the project at this time.
Environmental Review Coordinator Reid replied that the CSS take permit was not directly
related to the take of gnatcatchers. It was a "cover or umbrella" type of habitat CSS that not
-10;)-
. PC Minutes
-3-
September 14, 1994
only supports gnatcatchers which were listed as threatened, but a variety of other species which
had been nominated for listing by the Federal Government.
Commissioner Salas, referring to the area to be revegetated near the water tower, asked if the
previous revegetation did not take becaJJ'l" there was no irrigation system. Mr. Reid stated that
bad been done by the SweetWater Authority and he did not know why it did not take. Under
the present procedure of the mitigation monitoring program, there was a yearly inspection of the
revegetation to assure that it does take, and there would be specific standards for percentage of
plants and coverage that have to be attained each year over a five-y~ period.
Mr. Demich, one of the developers, was asked to step to the microphone, since he bad
information regarding the previous revegetation. He stated that during the drought, there were
many complaints by people surrounding the area that Sweetwater was recklessly watering the
weeds or bushes, not knowing how valuable they were or what the purpose was. Sweetwater,
because of the complaints, turned off the irrigation system during the drought years and had not
come back on line. Part of the mitigation for this project was to get back on line, fill in the
gullies, and rehydroseed any areas on this parcel as well as the adjoining water tank site.
.
Commissioner Salas asked if there was a complaint during the drought season about the watering
of the .weeds., were they looking at a more efficient way of irrigating that area, such as drip
irrigation. Mr. Reid replied that it would be part of the mitigation package, once it bad been
finalized and prepared by a biological consultant on the project.
Commissioner Moot queried staff regarding the gated access road, and asked if that was part of
the subdivision map being approved, or if it would come back later. Associate Planner Miller
stated it was part of the subdivision map. Since this was the only entry and exit to the
subdivision, which was only 12 lots, it was not a big issue.
Commissioner Moot felt the open space should be available to all residents. Mr. Miller replied
that the open space areas were not public open space. Staff was trying to ensure that the areas
remained in as natural a state as possible even after development. There would be no trails in
the open space. The streets would be private streets, owned and 1l'Ia;nta;ne.d by the homeowners
association. They would not be public streets. Staff believed these were justifiable reasons for
the gating of the project.
Commissioner Ray asked if the private street began at the gate. Mr. Miller affirmed, and stated
that the residents would ma;nta;n up to the crash gate and the final location of the crash gate
would be determined in conjunction with Sweetwater Authority and the CbuIa Vista Fire
Department.
.
Answering Commissioner Moot, Mr. Miller stated there would be a cul-de-sac on Moonview
Drive, installed at the developer's expense, where people could turn around in case they took
a wrong turn.
-ID.3-
. PC Minutes
-4-
September 14, 1994
This being the time and the place as advertised, the public hearing was opened.
Joseph H. McGowan, 3442 Glen Abbey Blvd, C.V., stated that within about 1,000 yards,
from Glen Abbey Blvd. to the top of the hill there was a distance from almost sea level to 2SS
feet at the crest. The water rusbes down the hill down to Glen Abbey Blvd. and down through
the property at 3394 Glen Abbey. From the comer of Randy Lane down to 3394 Glen Abbey
Blvd., there was one outlet which was 7S" long and 3" high. There was no place for the water
to go. He had discussed this with the CountY and with Chula Vista Engineering and Pl~nnl"g.
Mr. McGowan said water backed out on Glen Abbey Blvd. They were concerned with the bank
from Randy Lane down to the canyon, which the County maintained that the lack of vegetation
caused the runoff down the hill onto Glen Abbey Blvd. The County had also said that in the
vicinity of 3394 that the hill had been cut and was at a 90 degree angle. This did not increase
the water, but brought the water down with additional force. There was no place for the water
to go. At the top of the hill by his house there was a 14' to 21' gully at the top of the hill,
which had washed out during the last five years. Mr. McGowan was also concerned about the
sewerage. They had annexed years before and were told that the water table in his yard was
14'. Down the street from him, the water table was 5' to 7'. His concern was if the sewerage
would hold the sewage from the new subdivision in addition.
.
Chair Tuchscher asked if the jurisdiction of the properties at Glen Abbey Lane was in the
County. Mr. Miller stated it was, and showed the Chula Vista city limits.
Chair Tuchscher questioned whether the grading to be done to finish the lots would drain back
toward the internal streets. Mr. Miller confirmed. He showed the present ridge line and stated
that any water on the north side of the ridge line flowed naturally down the slope.
George E. Gochenaur, 3436 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, stated that his lot bordered 230+
feet directly north of the open space "A" lot. Mr. Gochenaur concurred that there was natural
drainage, but he was concerned that grading and taking of vegetation would start flow in his
direction. He had seen cars flood out on Glen Abbey Blvd. when it rained because of lack of
drainage. The proposed drainage through Lot "B" and back down on Glen Abbey Blvd. from
an IS" drain pipe would go out on Glen Abbey Blvd. They were concerned about whether or
not the sewage from the hill would add to Glen Abbey Blvd. Another concern was water
pressure, which Mr. Gochenaur said was already a problem. Mr. Gochenaur noted that the
mln;mum sized lots were supposed to be 20,000 sq. ft. Only two of those lots were 20,000 sq.
ft. or greater. The rest were all smaller. His main concerns were the storm drainage, the fresh
water, and the sewerage.
.
Marie Kolb, 3401 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, said she would be in the path of all the
drainage water. With the development of "H" Street, a drainage pipe was installed which ran
down the canyon, and there was a heavy suit because of the damage. There would be a heavy
law suit if the proposed drainage is installed. They should be required to put in an underground
drainage through Bonita Road into the river channel. This bordered Cordell Lane which had
been a berm installed in front of it. She was not going to have water under her house because
-(1)'1--
.
.
.
PC Minutes
-5-
September 14, 1994
of stupidity. She thought Chula Vista representatives needed go to those places affected when
it was raining to observe what was really going on. She did not object to houses being built on
top of the hill, but asked that it be done right the first time and not make other people suffer.
Walt Selph, 3394 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, stated his home was where all the water came
through. Everyone who spoke before him had been against the project; he had five acres which
joined the property which Mr. Demich was trying to develop. He had been a builder for many
years, and in all cases natural drainage rules. He stated in all the years it had never been a
problem to him. He disagreed with his neighbors saying that water on Glen Abbey stood there.
It stands sometimes at the one drain for a short time. but he had never seen a car drown out
because of standing water. Regarding sewerage, the existing sewer line would adequately take
care of the sewage from the subdivision without putting any pressure on the existing line below.
He had no objection to the subdivision. Mr. Selph said that Mrs. Kolb was probably in the
lowest lot in all of Glen Abbey. He felt the building on top of the hill would help the drainage.
(The next three speakers had an orgllni7e(1 presentation.)
Greg Cox, 647 Windsor Circle, CV 91910, representing the applicant, asked for 15 minutes
for an organized presentation including several speakers. With concurrence from the Chair, Mr.
Cox gave the background of the project. He noted that the applicant had the responsibility to
not only hydroseed and maintain the open space area, but would also have to hydroseed the
adjoining Sweetwater Authority reservoir and ensure that it is better maintained as habitat.
Given the fact that there were requirements to hydroseed and to monitor the hydroseeding in the
open space areas, there would be a greater stand of natural vegetation that would be put in as
a result of the project which would mitigate some of the drainage that was currently occurring.
Mr. Cox stated there were parcels less than the R-E designation because the request was for a
residential estate with a precise plan, which presented the opportunity to provide a development
which conformed to the landforms without a lot of cut and fill. The streets would be privately
maintained by the homeowners association, and would be a gate-guarded community. He asked
Mr. David Porot to respond to issues raised by the residents concerning drainage.
David Porot, the project engineer for Mr. Demich, expressed his concern to the residents
around the area and said that the existing situation on lots I, 2, and 3 on the ridgeline currently
drained to the north. The proposed development would take about 100' of that to the center.
The subdivision would reduce the drainage going down the bank. Lots 4, 5, and 6 and the
intemal drainage would be draining to the center. They were proposing to install rock rip rap
to reduce water flow possibly into the residents' area. The cfs would be reduced by 1 cfs
because of the diversion of water into the proposed inlets.
Commissioner Martin asked Mr. Porot to explain what he meant by rip rap. Mr. Porot stated
that with the existing situation, lots I, 2, and 3 ran north. With the grading to be done, it would
drain into the catch basin and diverted into the center storm drain system in open space lot 'b'.
~ IDj,
e PC Minutes
-6-
September 14, 1994
Commissioner Martin questioned whether that was silted water. Mr. Porot said it would be
nuisance water which would be off roofs, streets, water collected from the lots themselves.
Commissioner Martin asked if the water east of that outside of the property would still come
down through there. Mr. Porot said part of that would be taken, and would have silt. Using
the appropriate chart, it had all been taken into consideration. He did not feel there would be
any problem with the drainage system.
Chair Tuchscher asked that Mr. Porot define 'cfs.' Mr. Porot explained that it was 'cubic feet
per second" and was the amount of water that travels a certain distance.
Commissioner Moot asked if there were any design solutions that would improve the drainage
situation for the downhill residents. Mr. Porot stated the proposed mitigation for the drainage
was by providing adequate rock rip rap protection with the City Engineer's approval. The
intense landscaping would absorb some of the sheet flow and slow down the water flow.
Sr. Civil Engineer Ullrich, referring to Commissioner Moot's question regarding reduction of
impacts, stated that a retention facility could be installed in the lower part where the drains were
coming out and retain the water for a longer time. There was a trade-off in that the water would
run for a longer period of time. There was not a lot of area to construct a retention facility.
.
Mr. Porot added that retention facilities were usually for larger quantities of water, such as for
golf courses or desert areas where water is needed to perk the soil. The quantity being dealt
with in this case was not very large as compared to other areas.
At Commissioner Ray's request, Mr. Miller indicated the City and County boundaries, the
subdivision area, and the location of the drainage. A slight portion on the northern ridge would
be taken to the center.
Commissioner Ray asked Mr. Porot what percentage of the current runoff going down to Glen
Abbey would be eliminated or reduced. Mr. Porot answered that approximately 1/3 would be
taken away.
Commissioner Ray concluded that if the project was developed, 1/3 less water would come down
into the same drainage area that it goes to today. Mr. Porot concurred. For the whole project
site, the cfs would be 1 cfs less. It would be reduced because of the time and concentration it
would take to travel because it would have a longer distance to go.
.
Commissioner Ray was concerned because the drainage problem area was in the County and the
City had no jurisdiction to fIX it. In termS of the project site, the run-off could be limited by
including mitigation measures which would not impact the residents negatively if it were
approved. He asked Mr. Perot if the cumulative effect of the project would reduce the current
drainage into that area. Mr. Porot concurred.
- I DIP -
.
PC Minutes
-7-
September 14, 1994
Mike Demicb, 3356 Glen Abbey Blvd., CV 91910, one of the owners of the project site, said
he bad met with most of the people down on Glen Abbey; the flows were being reduced to two
of the back yards. Reduction of the water flow would occur because of the planting of the
hillsides that currently erode and cause siltation going down the hill. The water tank parcel
would be revegetated, as well. By rehydroseMing the City of Cbula Vista site, water and
siltation would be kept from Windrose and going across property down to Glen Abbey. Mr.
Demich commended staff on their snuly of the drainage, the vegetation and the grading contours
to come up with something that would flow, look nice, and help with the ronoff. He felt it was
a win-win situation. They bad checked with the County, and there was the capacity to handle
the sewage in Glen Abbey. Regarding the water pressure, he was not sure where the residents
were obtaining their water. Sweetwater bad told them there was adequate water pressure for
their project.
Commissioner Moot asked if there was a particular reason for gating the road. Mr. Demich
stated there had been much vandalism, and currently Moonview was gated off with a permaDCnt
chainlink fence. It seemed to be an attractive area for people to drink beer, break beer bottles,
and a lovers lane. Sweetwater Authority and the local biologists wanted to keep the reservoir
area protected. It was desigDCd as a natural habitat for the birds. Everyone involved, including
Planning staff, felt it would be best to have it gated with a turn-around for people to get back
out. If not gated, the problems would f1Iter on into the residential neighborhood and onto
. Sweetwater's property as well as theirs.
Mr. Cox returned to the podium to conclude the presentation, stating that they thought it was
a good project; it met all City standards regarding drainage and grading. The project would not
increase the drainage to the area below on Glen Abbey and would improve the problem by
reducing the flow by 1 cfs. He thought the rip rap would help dissipate the speed and the
amount of the debris and silt picked up. He pointed out that given the fact that it would be
designed as a gate-guarded community, those buying the homes would have a significant amount
of vegetation as part of the homes which should help the retention of the water. He asked for
support of the staff recommendations.
.
No one else wishing to speak, the public hearing was closed.
Commissioner Moot asked where the gate at Moonview was located and the area Mr. Dimich
felt needed to be protected. He was uncomfortable with gating off the area.
Associate Planner Miller indicated the location of the gate, and stated there was apparently a
problem with people vandalizing and littering the area. If this were a public road, the problems
would be carried over into the cul-de-sacs and possibly to the reservoir site itself which is a
sensitive habitat area for the l""tr"'tCMt and cactus wren.
Commissioner Moot confirmed that it was the sensitive area by the reservoir which needed to
be free of people. He stated that every cul-de-sac had a problem with people coming in. He
asked if there was some other area that needed to be protected. Mr. Miller indicated the bank
- 101-
.
PC Minutes
-8-
September 14, 1994
and other open space lots which needed to be protected because they were intended to be natural
areas connecting with the reservoir site. There were defmitely gnatcatchers and cactus wrens
in the area.
Commissioner Martin asked staff to explain the difference between a private road and a public
road; who was responsible for 11Iaintenance; would there be sidewalks and curbs; who was
responsible for those?
Sr. Civil Engineer Ullrich answered that private streets were typically less in width between the
curb faces; public streets would be wider and need more grading, private streets would be
maintained by people living in the area; public streets would be m~intainP.d by the City. The
tentative map showed that some of the streets showed sidewalks on both sides, others showed
sidewalk.on one side.
.
Commissioner Ray asked the rationale for putting the gate at the existing location rather than
at the entranCe to the development. Mr. Miller stated the gate as proposed would be at the
municipal boundary. Staff saw no need to move it. Commissioner Ray asked if there was any
legal issue with the City by allowing a gate limiting access to County property. Mr. Miller
noted that it would be annexed. Staff had contacted LAFCO regarding that, who said they had
a set policy that a city street could not go from a city into a county and back into the city.
Therefore, the Sweetwater parcel was having to be annexed and, for continuity of ownership,
the smaller parcel with the pump house.
Commissioner Ray, referring to a previous proposal for a gated community. asked if there was
a sewerage or drainage problem, the City would be liable to fIX the sewerage and drainage
problem even though it was a private street. Mr. Ullrich stated that the sewer line would be
public and the City would have the responsibility to repair the sewer lines. The drainage on the
site would be private and would be J1Iaintained by the homeowners.
Chair Tuchscher stated that from a locational standpoint, it would make sense to protect the
Sweetwater reservoir. From a housing product standpoint, he thought it was exciting to have
some higher end houses within the City limits; it would help from an economic standpoint in that
the individuals malril1g decisions to locate companies often want to know where they would live
and would seek these types of views. From a drainage standpoint, there was a pre-existing
condition which would be made slightly better. There was a problem with the County perhaps
responding to citizens complaints. He suggested that staff draft a letter to the County letting
them know of the situation.
.
Assistant Planning Director Lee stated staff would pass that on to the Engineering Department
to forward on to the County. Following up on some of the comments regarding public versus
private, Mr. Lee reminded the Commission that there would be no access directly to the private
property. Extending the street as a public street would provide access to the subdivision itself,
not to open space. The City has an open space area immediately to the east, part of a park
-I()g-
PC Minutes
-9-
September 14, 1994
. system, which abutted the County line and into the cemetery. There was no access into the
cemetery, so the open space in the area as far as linkage was limjted.
Ctunmiuioner Martin commented that the resideDtS had flooding and drainage problems and he
asked if there was some way to alleviate their concern that they were being ignored by showing
them something that was done in the past where there was flooding, but due to the developed
area, there was less.
Mr. Ullrich noted that a dam had been installed with the constrUCtion of Bonita Long Canyon
Estates. There had been flooding problems downstream along Acacia. With the dam, the
flooding subsided. Mr. Ullrich noted this was a much larger project than the project under
consideration. Assistant plAnning Director Lee stated the similarity was that the flooded area
was previously in the County as the proposed area, and was developed by the City and the
flooding alleviated.
Commissioner Ray stated be bad a great deal of sympathy for the resideDtS. it was an existing
condition which be felt would be reduced. However, it was a County problem and the
Commissioners had no jurisdiction.
.
MSC (RaylFuller) 5-1-1 (C('mmluloners Salas against, C('mmluioner Tarantino excused)
to approve Resolution PCZ-91-D recommending that the City Council prezone 8.37 acres
of land to R-E-P and 5.36 acres of land to RE-4O.
MSC (RaylFuller) 4-2-1 (Commluloners Salas and Moot against; Commluloner Tarantino
excused) to approve Resolution PC8-91-01 recommending that the City Council approve the
tentative map for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, Cbula Vista Tract 91-01.
Assistant Planning Director Lee noted that this item would move forward to the City Council
and would probably be heard during the middle of October, possibly October 11. The resideDtS
would be receiving notice to remind them.
Commissioner Ray suggested that the residcDtS represent themselves before the City Council.
Chair Tuchscber asked the radius of mAiling for this project. Mr. Lee stated it was noticed at
1,000 feet.
Chair Tuchscber declared a break at 8:30 p.m. The meeting was reconvened at 8:40.
.
- 109-
.
ATTACHMENT 9
Resource Conservation Commission Minutes
Meeting of September 26, 1994
.
.
-110 -
.
.
.
"fO':::UOOO:::
~^~~~~~ ~~~~~IH~lH~
-=,.~c r-t:J.a:::
~cr ~O ~"f 1~ 1':::
MINUl'ES OF A SC ULAR MEETING
\
Reaource Con ation Commission
Chula Vista, California
6:30 p.m.
Mondav, September 26. 1994
Conference Room #1
Public Services Buildinl
CALL MEETING TO ORDER/ROLL CALL: Meeting was called to order at 6:30 p.m. by
Chainnan BulTllSCal\o. City Staff Environmental Review Coordinator Doug Reid called roll.
Present: Commissioners Hall, Ghougassian, Marquez. [Fisher arrived late.] Absent:
Guerreiro. Staff present: Mr. Nuhaily, Engineering Department.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The minutes of the meeting of July 25, 1994 could not be
approved due to quorum from that meeting no longer on the Commission. Ghougassian and
Burrascano accepted the minutes as presented. Hall made a change under "Commission
Discussion" for the words "liquidation factor" to be changed to "liquefaction." Minutes
accepted into tho record by all members present at the July 25, 1994 meeting.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: None.
to:
NEW BUSINESS:
1.
Viviano Marquez is the new member and was introduced to the Commission. She gave a
,~rie{ history of her background.
Greg Cox was available to answer questions on Bonita Hills Executive Estates mitigated
negative declaration IS.9l.l5. Reid showed the map on the coastal sage disturbed areas.
Cox noted the applicant will rehydroseed the reservoir site on the western edge of the
underground tank.
I
2.
[Fisher arrived at 6:40 p.m.]
It was moved and SOCQnded (GhougassianlHall) to accept the negative declaration. Mr.
Reid explained that the 4(d) rule permit was also attached to the document and was
included in the motion; vote: 3.2 (no: Marquez, Fisher), motion failed. Ghougassian
asked for the reasons of the no votes. Fished'explained the disconnection of existing
plots and habitat and that no biological survey was conducted.
Ghougassian argued that Commissioners should be responsible for looking at the total
picture of any project, including the affect on the economy and the people. The amount
of land on this project is so small that it should not greatly impact the en.yironmentally
sensitive areas, but could hamper development and economic growth for'1he people.
Marquez stated her no vote because she would like to see a biological report of where
the cactus wrens are located and does not want to set a precedent for the taking of coastal
sale habitat.
-11/-
CITY OF CHULA VISTA
PARTY DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
~
Statement of disclosure of certain ownership interests. payments. or campaign
contributions. on all matters which will require discretionar,y action on the part of the
i Council. Planning Commission. 'and all other official bodies. The following
rmation must be disclosed:
..
1. List the names of all persons having a financial interest in the application. bid.
contract. or P7ro osal.
:fSLRL,1kiJ _1Ia1Al PlSJIOP ---.ftI" 1WcJ..i~
.
..JnJCJMEl oc.flt.H f:} fI')~ HA11~
If real property is involved. 1 ist the names of an persons having any ownership
interest.
S~L A.~ ~vE..
2. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a corporation or partnership. list.
the names of all individuals owning more than 101 of the shares in the corporation
or owning any partnership interest in the partnership.
~D€.I':/..H ~S"'e -5J.t1EA IMRM
~r:.~",
~,
3. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a non-profit organization or a
trust. list the names of any person serving as director of the non-profit
~OrganiZa~ion or as trustee or beneficiary or trustor of the trust.
4. Have you or any person named in (1) above had more than $250 worth of business
transacted wi th any member of Ci ty staff. Boards. COlIIDissi ons. COlIIDi ttees and'
Council within the past twelve months? Yes_ HOX If yes. please indicate
person(s)
5. Have you and/or your officers or ..gents, in the aggregate. contributed more than
$1.000 to a Councilmember ~n ~he current or preceding election period?
Yes No ~
If yes. state which Councilmember(s):
Person is defined as: -Any individual. firm. copartnership. joint venture. association.
social club. fraternal organization. corporation. estate. trust. receiver. syndicate,
this and any other county, city and county, city, municipality, district or other
'political subdivision. or any other group or combination acting as a unit.-
(NOTE:
Attach additional
<t-al-90
pages as necessar,y.)
~c~
Dat~:
W~701P
A-110
..
~l GAJm>/.J'r (Je/YIIc.JI
Print or type name of contractor/applicant
- II 3....
ORDINANCE NO .1.1, ~ ?
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA CITY COUNCIL
PREZONING 14.23 ACRES OF LAND LOCATED NORTH OF THE
TERMINUS OF MOONVIEW DRIVE TO RE-P (8.37 ACRES) AND RE-40
(5 86 ACRES)
WHEREAS, a duly verified application for a prezoning of property consisting of
approximately 14.23 acres located at the northern terminus of Moonview Drive and
diagrammatically presented on the area map attached hereto as Exhibits A and B was filed with
the Planning Department of the City of Chula Vista on August 18, 1990 by Mr. Michael
Anthony Demich; and
WHEREAS, said application requests a prezone from RR-1 (County of San Diego) to
RE-P (8.37 acres: APN 592-030-58), and RE-40 (4.36 acres: APN 592-030-57 and 1.00 acre:
APN 592-030-60); and
WHEREAS, the development of the 8.37 acre APN 592-030-58 is the subject matter of
a Tentative Subdivision Map, PCS-91-02, which is being concurrently heard with this
application; and,
WHEREAS, the Environmental Review Coordinator conducted an Initial Study, IS-91-15,
of potential environmental impacts associated with the implementation of the project and has
concluded that there would be no significant environmental impacts which could not be mitigated
to level less than significant, and recommends adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration
and Mitigation Monitoring Program issued on IS-91-15; and
WHEREAS, on September 14, 1994 the Planning Commission recommended approval
of the prezone (PCZ-91-D) to the City Council by a vote of 5 to 1 to 1, and
WHEREAS, on September 14, 1994 the Planning Commission found that the project
would have no significant environmental impacts and recommends adoption by the City Council
of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Program for IS-91-15, and
WHEREAS, on September 26, 1994, the Resource Conservation Commission reviewed
the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15 and the associated Coastal Sage Scrub Loss
Permit for CS-95-03, and
WHEREAS, a motion to approve IS-91-15 and CS-95-03 by the Resource Conservation
Commission failed with 3 votes in favor, two opposed, and two absent in that four affirmative
votes were necessary to approve said motion; and
WHEREAS, from the facts presented to the Planning Commission, the Commission has
determined that the prezone is consistent with the City of Chula Vista General Plan and that
1'/ C ' /
10..
.:
Ordinance No.
Page No 2
public necessity, convenience, and good zoning practice support the prezoning to RE-P for APN
592-030-58 and RE-40 for APN's 592-030-57 and 592-030-60; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission further recommends that the City Council
authorize the Director of Planning to issue a FinaI4(d) Loss Permit for the Project (CS-95-03),
and
WHEREAS, the City Clerk set the time and place for a hearing on said prezoning
application and notice of said hearing, together with its purpose, was given by its publication
in a newspaper of general circulation in the city and its mailing to property owners within 1,000
feet of the exterior boundaries of the property at least twenty-one days prior to the hearing; and
WHEREAS, the hearing was held at the time and place as advertised, namely 6:00 p.m.
October 11, 1994 in the Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, before the City Council and
said hearing was thereafter closed.
NOW, THEREFORE the City Council of the City of Chula Vista does hereby find,
determine, and ordain as follows:
Section 1.
Adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring
Program
The City Council hereby fmds that the Project will have no significant environmental
impacts and adopts the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring
Program for IS-91-15.
Section 2.
CEQA Findings.
The City Council hereby finds that the Project will have no new effects that were not
examined in the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15 as of the date of the
application for the initial study.
a. Adoption of Findings - After its independent review, the Council does
hereby approve, accept as its own, and incorporate as if set forth full
herein, and make each and every one of the CEQA Findings as found in
the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15.
b. Adoption of Mitigation Monitoring Program - As required by the Public
Resources Code Section 21081 6, City Council hereby adopts the
Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ("Program") incorporated
herein by reference as if set forth in full for Mitigated Negative
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \91DCC.ORD
piC ., ~
Ordinance No.
Page No.3
Declaration for IS-91-15. The City Council finds that the Program is
designed to ensure that during the project implementation and operation,
the Applicant and other responsible parties implement the project
components and comply with the feasible mitigation measures identified
in the Findings and in the Program.
Section 3.
Incorporation of All Feasible Mitigation Measures.
The City Council does hereby adopt and incorporate herein as conditions for all
approvals herein granted all mitigation measures which it has determined to be feasible
in the approval of the Prezone. Further, the City Council does hereby authorize the
Director of Planning to issue a Final 4(d) Loss Permit for the Project (CS-95-03).
Section 4.
Approval of the Coastal Sage Loss Permit Findings.
The City Council does hereby approve the Section 4(d) Coastal Sage Take Permit
Findings and authorizes the Director of Planning to issue a Final 4(d) Loss Permit for
the Project (CS-95-03)(Appendix E in the Mitigated Negative Declaration)
Section 5.
Findings.
The City Council finds that the prezoning is consistent with the City of Chula Vista
General Plan and that the public necessity, convenience, general welfare, and good
zoning practice support the prezoning to RE-P and RE-40
Further, the City Council finds that the "P" Precise Plan Modifier is appropriate for
Bonita Hills Executive Estates, PCS-91-01, in that the subject property is unique by
virtue of its topography and access, thus requiring special handling of the development
on a precise plan basis.
Further, the City Council fmds that the overall density for Bonita Hills Executive Estates
is 1.43 dwelling units per acre (12 dwellings/8.37 acres), which is consistent with the
General Plan Designation of Residential-Low (0-3 du/ac).
Section 6.
Prezoning.
The properties are hereby prezoned RE-P (APN 592-030-58) and RE-40 (APN 593-030-
57), to wit: Residential Estate-Precise Plan, and Residential Estates-40,000 sq ft.
minimum lot size.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \91DCC.ORD
IYC-J
Ordinance No.
Page No 4
With respect to the RE-P zoned area, the following guideline shall apply' Minimum lot
size shall be 10,000 square feet, provided the net project density (lots and permanent
open space areas) does not exceed one dwelling unit for every 20,000 square feet.
Development of the property shall be regulated by the RE-20 development standards.
That a copy of this ordinance be transmitted to the owners of the property.
Presented by
Robert A. Leiter
Director of Plarming
Bruce M. Boogaard
City Attorney
F,IHOMEIPLANNING\MARTINIBONlT A 191DCC.ORD
/slc-1
RESOLUTION NO. J 7 t r?
A RFSOLUTION OF TIlE CITY OF CHULA VISTA CITY
COUNCIL APPROVING THE TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION
MAP FOR BONITA HILLS EXECUTIVE ESTATES, CHULA
VISTA TRACT PeS 91-02, MAKING TIlE NECESSARY
FINDINGS AND ADOPTING THE MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION AND THE MITIGATION MONITORING
PROGRAM FOR IS-91-15
WHEREAS, the property which is the subject matter of this resolution is identified and
described on Chula Vista Tract 91-02, and is commonly known as Bonita Hills Executive Estates
("Property"), located at the northern terminus of Moonview Drive, and being within the County
of San Diego (APN-592-030-58); and,
WHEREAS, a duly verified application for a Tentative Subdivision Map was filed with
the Planning Department of the City of Chula Vista by Michael Anthony Demich; and,
WHEREAS, said application requests the subdivision of 8.37 acres into twelve (12)
residential lots and two (2) open space lots; and,
WHEREAS, the development of the Property is the subject matter of a Prezone, PCZ-9l-
D, which is being heard concurrently with this application, an Initial Study, IS-9l-l5, and a
Coastal Sage Loss Permit, CS-95-03, which are being considered concurrently with this
application, and an annexation, ANX-94-0l, which will be heard at a later date; and,
WHEREAS, the Environmental Review Coordinator conducted an Initial Study, IS-9l-l5,
of potential environmental impacts associated with the implementation of the project and has
concluded that there would be no significant environmental impacts which could not be mitigated
to level less than significant, and recommends adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration
and Mitigation Monitoring Program issued for IS-9l-l5; and,
WHEREAS, on September 26,1994, the Resource Conservation Commission reviewed
the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-9l-l5 and the associated Coastal Sage Scrub Loss
Permit for CS-95-03; and
WHEREAS, a motion to approve IS-9l-l5 and CS-95-03 by the Resource Conservation
Commission failed with 3 votes in favor, two opposed, and two absent in that four affirmative
votes were necessary to approve said motion; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held an advertised public hearing on said project
on September 14, 1994, and voted 4 to 2 to 1 to recommend that the City Council approve the
Tentative Subdivision Map in accordance with the findings and conditions listed below, and
I'IP~ I
Resolution No
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.2
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission further recommends that the City Council
authorize the Director of Planning to issue a Final4(d) Loss Permit for the Project (CS-95-03);
and
WHEREAS, the City Clerk set the time and place for a hearing on said application and
notice of said hearing, together with its purpose, was given by its publication in a newspaper
of general circulation in the city and its mailing to property owners within 1,000 feet of the
exterior boundaries of the property at least ten days prior to the hearing; and
WHEREAS, the hearing was held at the time and place as advertised, namely 6:00 p.m.,
October 11, 1994, in the Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, before the City Council and
said hearing was thereafter closed.
NOW THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL fmds, determines and resolves as follows:
Section 1.
Adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring
Program
The City Council hereby finds that the Project will have no significant environmental
impacts and adopts the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring
Program for IS-91-15.
Section 2.
CEQA Findings.
The City Council hereby finds that the Project will have no new effects that were not
examined in the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15 as of the date of the
application for the initial study.
a. Adoption of Findings - After its independent review, the Council does
hereby approve, accept as its own, and incorporate as if set forth full
herein, and make each and every one of the CEQA Findings as found in
the Mitigated Negative Declaration for IS-91-15
b. Adoption of Mitigation Monitoring Program - As required by the Public
Resources Code Section 21081.6, City Council hereby adopts the
Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ("Program") incorporated
herein by reference as if set forth in full for Mitigated Negative
Declaration for IS-91-15 The City Council fmds that the Program is
designed to ensure that during the project implementation and operation,
the Applicant and other responsible parties implement the project
F,\HOME\PLANNINGlMARTIN\BONIT A \9102CC.RES
JlI]) ,).
Resolution No
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.3
components and comply with the feasible mitigation measures identified
in the Findings and in the Program.
Section 3.
Incorporation of All Feasible Mitigation Measures.
The City Council does hereby adopt and incorporate herein as conditions for all
approvals herein granted all mitigation measures which it has determined to be feasible
in the approval of the Tentative Subdivision Map. Further, the City Council does hereby
authorize the Director of Planning to issue a Fina14(d) Loss Permit for the Project (CS-
95-03)
Section 4.
Approval of the Coastal Sage Loss Permit Findings.
The City Council does hereby approve the Section 4(d) Coastal Sage Take Permit
Findings and authorizes the Director of Planning to issue a Final 4(d) Loss Permit for
the Project (CS-95-03)(Appendix E in the Mitigated Negative Declaration).
Section 5
General Plan Findings--Conformance to the General Plan.
Pursuant to Government Code Section 66473.5, in the Subdivision Map Act, the City
Council fmds that the Tentative Subdivision Map as conditioned herein for Bonita Hills
Executive Estates, Chula Vista Tract No. 91-02, is in conformance with all the various
elements of the City's General Plan, based on the following:
1. The site is physically suitable for residential development and the proposal
conforms to all standards established by the City for such projects.
2. The design of the subdivision will not affect the existing improvements -- streets,
sewers, etc. -- which have been designed to avoid any serious problems.
3 The project is in substantial conformance with the Chula Vista General Plan
Elements as follows:
a. Land Use - Based on the provisions of Section 4 1 of the Land Use
Element of the General Plan pertaining to Residential Low (0-3 du/ac),
this Tentative Subdivision Map is deemed to be consistent with the
General Plan.
b. Circulation - The project has limited access via Moonview Drive to
private streets. These streets meet minimum City requirements for such
streets. The project will not adversely effect the Circulation Element in
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102CC.RES
/1/]) ...J
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.4
that the adjoining street system was designed to handle the anticipated
flow of traffic resulting from this and other area projects.
c. Housing - The type of housing being proposed is large-lot, detached
single-family residential structures. This project meets the goals,
objectives and policies of the Housing Element in that Goals 1 and 4,
General Objectives 1, 3, 4 and 8, and Housing Policies 2, 6, 7 and 8 are
implemented by this project.
d. Conservation - The adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and
Mitigation Monitoring Program for IS-91-15 satisfies the goals and
policies of the Conservation Element of the General Plan in that mitigation
measures listed in the forgoing documents are applicable to this project.
e. Park and Recreation, Open Space - The project is approximately one-third
of a mile from Terra Nova Park, a neighborhood park as defined in
Section 4.3 of the Parks and Recreation Element, and therefore
implements this General Plan element.
f. Safety - The project meets the threshold standards of the Growth
Management Plan. The nearest Chula Vista fire station, Station #2, is
located at 80 East "J" Street. In addition, the Bonita-Sunnyside Fire
Protection District Station is located on Bonita Road near Acacia. Either
of these stations could respond in case of an emergency in Bonita Hills
Executive Estates.
Seismic Policy of the Safety Element - The study Soil and Geolol!ic
Reconnaissance for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, a study carried out by
GEOCON ,Inc., a geotechnical engineering firm, concluded that due to the
project's proximity to regional active faults, including the Elsinore Fault
and the San Jacinto Fault Zones, which lie approximately 41 and 62 miles
to the northeast, respectively, there does not appear to be a significant risk
of seismically induced liquefaction occurring on the property. Therefore,
the project implements or otherwise conforms to Policy Statement 5 of
Section 3.2, Seismic Policy, of the Safety Element, which states:
"5. No lands shall be subdivided, developed, or f1l1ed within the City
of Chula Vista in the absence of supportable, professional evidence
that the proposed subdivision, development, or land fill would be
geologically safe. "
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102CC ,RES
l'Ip'r
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.5
g.
Noise - Due to the location of the project, noise attenuation is not
required.
h.
Scenic Highway - The project is not located on any scenic highway
i.
Bicycle Routes - The project is not located on any bicycle route.
j.
Public Buildings - No public buildings are proposed on the site. The
project is required to pay RCT fees prior to the issuance of building
permits.
Section 6.
Subdivision Map Act Findings.
a. Balance of Housing Needs and Public Service Needs.
Pursuant to Section 66412.3 of the Subdivision Map Act, the Council
certifies that it has considered the effect of this approval on the housing
needs of the region and has balanced those needs against the public service
needs of the residents of the City and the available fiscal and
environmental resources.
b. Opportunities for Natural Heating and Cooling Incorporated.
The configuration, orientation and topography of the site partially allows
for the optimum siting of lots for passive or natural heating and cooling
opportunities as required by Government Code Section 66473 1
c. Finding re Suitability for Residential Development.
The site is physically suitable for residential development and the proposal
conforms to all standards established by the City for such projects.
Section 7
Conditional Approval of Tentative Subdivision Map.
The City Council does hereby approve, subject to the following conditions, the Tentative
Subdivision Map for Bonita Hills Executive Estates, Chula Vista Tract 91-02. Unless
otherwise specified, all Conditions and Code Requirements shall be fully completed to
the City's satisfaction prior to the approval of the First Final Map. Unless otherwise
specified, "dedicate" means grant the appropriate easement, rather than fee title. The
Developer shall:
F:IHOMEIPLANNING\MARTINIBONIT AI9I02CC.RES
Iff)- ,
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.6
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
1. Prior to approval of the Final Map, revise the Tentative Subdivision Map as follows:
A. On the slopes between Lots 1 to 4, the Map states a 2: 1 ratio in several locations,
however, the contours, as shown, are at a 3 1 or lesser ratio and shall therefore
be required to be labeled 3'1 or 4: 1, as appropriate.
B. On the street frontages of all lots, the Map indicates a "4: 1 variable slope." This
reference shall be changed to read "4 1 maximum slope" in all instances.
C. Delete reference on the map to the six foot high chain link fence separating Open
Space Lots "A" and "B" from adjoining residential parcel. The Map shall instead
indicate a decorative wall along the northern boundaries of Lots 1, 2 and 3 with
Open Space Lot "B," and at the top-of-slope on Lots 4 through 9, inclusive.
2. Submit a comprehensive wall/fencing program for review and approval by the Director
of Planning prior the approval of a grading plan and Final Map. Subject plan shall
address the decorative wall required pursuant to Condition 1 C. above.
3 If deemed necessary by the Director of Planning, submit proof that each project
component complies with the City's Growth Management Element and Program and
threshold standards prior to Final Map approval to the satisfaction of the Director of
Planning.
4. Submit for review and approval the landscape concept plan, including the entryway
treatment to the Director of Planning prior to approval of the Final Map. The plans shall
include provision for correction of anyon-site erosion problems.
5. Pay the amount of fees applicable to the project, including but not limited to'
A. The Transportation and Public Facilities Development Impact Fees (DIF) prior
to the issuance of any building permit.
B. Signal Participation Fees.
C. All applicable sewer fees, including but not limited to, sewer connection fees.
D Park Acquisition and Development (PAD) fees.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONIT A \9102CC .RES
If]) -(,
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No 7
The fees to be paid shall be those in effect at the time of collection. The applicant is
responsible for contacting the appropriate City department to ascertain the appropriate
time of payment and the amount.
6. At submittal for Final Map, me a copy of the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and
Restrictions (CC&R's) applicable to the subject property with the City of Chula Vista.
The CC&R's shall be recorded concurrently with the Final Map and shall include:
A. Provisions for the formation of a homeowner's association (HOA) which shall
assure maintenance of private facilities, including the private streets, common
areas, Open Space Lots "A" and "B," and drainage systems in perpetuity The
City of Chula Vista shall be named as party to said Declaration authorizing but
not requiring the City to enforce the terms and conditions of the Declaration in
the same manner as any owner within the subdivision as related to areas of public
concern such as, but not limited to, the maintenance of common areas and the
adherence to other ordinance regulations of the City.
B Prohibition of television antennas, garage conversions, parking outside of
designated areas.
C. Open Space Lots A & B shall be reserved as undisturbed open space, except for
construction and maintenance of required private drainage facilities in Lot B, as
approved by the City.
D A statement that the subdivision shall be accessed from Moonview Drive and that
Randy Lane will be used for emergency ingress and egress only.
E. Requirements that there shall be no deviation from the grading approved as part
of the Tentative Subdivision and Final Maps.
F. Requirements that Open Space Lots "A" and "B" shall remain undeveloped, and
that the homeowners will abide by the Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation,
Preservation and Monitoring Plan for Open Space Lots "A" and "B."
G. Prohibition of vertical sheer walls/retaining walls on any residential lot. In the
event a wall must be constructed on any residential lot, crib walls shall
constructed and maintained with landscaping, to the satisfaction of the Director
of Planning.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONlT A\9102CC.RES
/'1/)-7
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No 8
7 Dedicate Open Space Lots "A" and "B" as private open space easements. Said
dedication shall be recorded with the County Recorder and proof of said recording shall
be submitted to the Director of Planning prior to issuance of any grading permit.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW COORDINATOR
8. Submit proof that subject project is emolled in the Natural Community Conservation
Program (NCCP), to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning, prior to approval of a
Final 4(d) loss permit.
9 Comply with all mitigation measures required by IS-91-15, or any addendum thereto,
which are hereby incorporated herein and which shall be implemented in accordance with
the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act.
10. Comply with all requirements of the Coastal Sage Loss Permit required by CS-95-03, or
any addendum thereto, which are hereby incorporated herein and which shall be
implemented in accordance with the requirements of the State of California.
11 Submit a Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and Monitoring Plan for
APN 592-171-61 and that portion of APN 592-030-57 which will be disturbed as a result
of grading activities, to the Director of Planning for review and approval prior to Final
Map approval. The Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and Monitoring
Plan shall also be submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California
Department of Fish and Game for their consideration and approval. Said Comprehensive
Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and Monitoring Plan shall be implemented prior to
submittal of any application for grading or building permits and shall be maintained for
a five (5) year period or until such time as the re-vegetated plants are capable of
surviving without the assistance of an irrigation system, to the satisfaction of the Director
of Planning.
12. Submit a bond for the Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and Monitoring
Plan for APN 592-171-61 and that portion of APN 592-030-57 which will be disturbed
as a result of grading activities, in an amount equal to the cost and installation of the
plant material and irrigation piping and devices plus five years of maintenance, to the
satisfaction of the Director of Planning.
13. Submit a fencing program for APN 592-171-61 for review and approval by the Director
of Planning prior to Final Map approval.
14. Submit a Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and Monitoring Plan for
Open Space Lots "A" and "B" to the Director of Planning for review and approval prior
P,\HOME\PLANNINGlMARTIN\BONIT A \9102CC.RES
Jf./) ...~
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No.9
to Final Map approval. Said Comprehensive Habitat Reclamation, Preservation and
Monitoring Plan shall be implemented prior to submittal of any application for grading
permits and shall be maintained in perpetuity by the Homeowners Association.
SWEETWATER AUTHORITY
15 To the satisfaction of the Sweetwater Authority ("Authority"), execute or submit the
following:
A. A Hold Harmless Agreement for the fill that was placed on the proposed
subdivision.
B. A Release of Liability Agreement and written permission for vehicular and
pedestrian traffic through the Authority's easement, adjacent to the proposed
subdivision, shown as that portion of Street "A" between Moonview Drive and
the southeast edge of the subdivision, and that portion of Street "B" just east of
Street "C."
C. A Hold Harmless Agreement for the proposed security gate at the south end of
the Authority's easement.
D. An Agreement to Improve Water Facilities, to serve the proposed subdivision.
Said agreement shall be presented to the City Engineer that the subdivision will
be provided adequate water service and long term water storage facilities.
E. A letter to the Authority from the Chula Vista Fire Department stating fire flow
requirements.
F An agreement with the Authority allowing encroachment in the eight foot
easement for electrical and telemetry conduit, which was approved pursuant to
Resolution No 17219, if necessary.
16. Acquire an off-site private access easement from the Sweetwater Authority needed to
serve the subdivision or provide evidence that one exists.
17. Access the site from Moonview Drive only, except that Randy Lane may be used for
emergency access.
18. Install a crash gate east of Street "C" in a location satisfactory to the Sweetwater
Authority and the Chula Vista Fire Department, and remove the bar gate located on the
northern leg of the Sweetwater Authority access easement which connects to Randy Lane.
F,IHOMEIPLANNINGlMARTINIBONIT A \9102CC.RES
/'1P- ?
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No 10
PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT
19 Submit plans to and obtain approval of the Director of the Parks and Recreation
Department for the installation of approved landscaping and a permanent irrigation
system on Lot "A" of Chula Vista Tract 80-15 - Map No 10051, from the cul-de-sac
crib wall on Moonview Drive to the rear boundary of 411 Windrose Way The
landscaped area is to include all areas below existing brow channels. All utilities must
be situated upon City property and service only existing City property. Shared systems
are not permitted between Bonita Hills Executive Estates and the City. The City will
assume maintenance responsibilities upon the successful installation and completion of
the maintenance period.
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT. ENGINEERING DIVISION
Streets. Ril!hts-of-Wav and Imorovements
20 Design and construct full street improvements to meet City standards for private streets
for private streets A, B and C shown on the Tentative Subdivision Map within the
subdivision boundary or off-site, as required. Said improvements shall include, but not
be limited to: asphalt concrete pavement, base, concrete curb, gutter and sidewalk,
sewer, drainage facilities, street lights, signs and fIre hydrants. Detailed horizontal and
vertical alignment of the centerlines of said streets shall be reflected on improvement
plans and said plans submitted for approval of the City Engineer. No parking shall be
allowed on Streets "A" and "C" and parking will be allowed on only one side of Street
"B" as shown on the Tentative Subdivision Map.
21 Construct the entrance to the subdivision at Moonview Drive as an alley type entrance
per regional standard drawing G-1? with maximum curb radii of 10 feet or as approved
by the City Engineer Construct 5' wide sidewalk from subdivision boundary to existing
sidewalk on the westerly side of the entrance.
22. Construct or provide to the specifications or satisfaction of the City Engineer the
following features to the proposed controlled access entrance to the subdivision:
A. Gates located to provide suffIcient room to queue up without interrupting traffic
on public streets.
B. Turnarounds at the gates with 40 ft. minimum radius.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTIN\BONITA\9102CC.RES
JJ/p..-/P
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No. 11
C. Delineation of border between public street and private street by enhanced
pavement. No enhanced pavement shall be located within public right-of-way
D Emergency vehicle access.
23. Construct all sidewalks within the subdivision a minimum of 4 feet wide.
24 Include on the Final Map reciprocal private access easements over private streets, A, B,
and C to be granted to subsequent owners of Lots 1 through 12 pursuant to Section
18.20 150 of the Chula Vista Municipal Code.
25 Grant to the City on the Final Map a general access and utility easement over the private
streets within the subdivision to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
26. Acquire all off site rights-of-way necessary to construct a turnaround at the north end of
Moonview Drive from the Chula Vista Elementary School District and then grant same
to the City, to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
27. Acquire and grant to the City an off site general access and utility easement over Street
"A" within the Sweetwater Authority property needed to serve the subdivision or provide
evidence that one exists.
28. Obtain approval from the County and Sweetwater Authority to construct the off site
private street to serve the subdivision.
29 Notify the City at least 60 days prior to consideration of the Final Map by the City if off-
site right-of-way and easements cannot be obtained as required by the Conditions of
Approval (only off-site right-of-way or easements affected by Section 66462.5 of the
Subdivision Map Act are covered by this condition).
After said notification and prior to the approval of the Final Map:
A. Pay the full cost of acquiring off-site right-of-way or easements required by the
conditions of approval of the Tentative Subdivision Map
B. Deposit with the City the estimated cost of acquiring said right-of-way or
easements. The amount of the deposit is subject to the approval of the City
Engineer.
C. Prepare and submit all easement and/or right-of-way documents, plats and
appraisals necessary to commence condemnation proceedings.
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTlN\BONITA\9102CC.RES
I~.J) -1/
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No 12
If the developer so requests, the City may, but is not required to use its power of
eminent domain to acquire right-of-way, easements or licenses needed for off-site
improvements or work related to the Tentative Subdivision Map The developer shall
pay all costs, both direct and indirect incurred if said acquisition is requested.
The condition to construct the related off-site improvements which fall under the purview
of Section 66462.5 of the State Subdivision Map Act are waived in accordance with that
section of the Act, if the City does not acquire or commence proceedings for immediate
possession of the property within the 120-day time limitation specified in that section.
Sewers
30 Design the sanitary sewers to meet City standards or as determined by the City Engineer
Construct manholes a maximum distance of 400' apart and 15' deep.
31 Provide paved or otherwise improved access with a minimum width of 12 feet and a
maximum grade of 15 % designed to an H-20 wheel load, or other loading as determined
by the City Engineer, to all sanitary sewer manholes.
32. Grant to the City an easement centered over all 8-inch sanitary sewer lines within the
subject property and new off-site sewer facilities constructed to serve the subdivision.
The minimum width of said sewer easements shall be 15 feet.
33. Obtain written permission from the County of San Diego to connect the proposed 8-inch
sanitary sewer line to the existing sewer in Glen Abbey Blvd.
34 Pay the Spring Valley sewer connection fee.
Grading and Drainage
35. Submit and obtain approval by the City Engineer for grading plans prior to approval of
the Final Map. Grade slopes to a maximum horizontal to vertical ratio of 2.1.
36. Obtain notarized letters of permission for all off-site grading work prior to issuance of
a grading permit.
37 Comply with all provisions of the NPDES in effect prior to issuance of a grading plan.
An erosion and sedimentation control plan shall be required as part of said plans.
38. All on-site storm drain facilities shall be private. Extend the proposed storm drain
outlets within Lot "B" as necessary to the natural flowline of the local drainage basin to
F:IHOMEIPLANNINGlMARTINlBONIT A 19102CC.RES
l'fj) ~/~
Resolution No
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No. 13
which it is tributary. Limit flows to pre-development volumes and non-erosive velocities
and provide erosion control to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
Water
39. Present written notification to the City Engineer from Sweetwater Authority that the
subdivision will be provided adequate water service and long term water storage
facilities.
40. Upgrade and/or construct new water facilities as required by Sweetwater Authority and
the City Fire Department to provide adequate water service and fire flows.
Al!:reements
41 Hold the City harmless from any liability for erosion, siltation or increase flow of
drainage resulting from this project.
42. Defend, indemnify and hold harmless the City and its agents, officers and employees,
from any claim, action or proceeding against the City, or its agents, officers or
employees to attack, set aside, void or annul any approval by the City, including
approval by its Planning Commission, City Council or any approval by its agents,
officers, or employees with retard to this subdivision pursuant to Section 66499.37 of the
Map Act provided the City promptly notifies the subdivider of any claim, action or
proceeding and on the further condition that the City fully cooperates in the defense.
Ooen Soace
43 Request annexation into Open Space District No. 11 and deposit $3,000 with the City to
process the annexation.
44 Open Space Lots A and B within the subdivision shall be privately owned and maintained
by the homeowners of this development.
Miscellaneous
45. Vacate the easement for slope and drainage facilities within Lots 6 and 7
46 Annex the subdivision site and the two adjoining easterly parcels, totaling 14.23 acres,
from the County of San Diego to the City of Chula Vista prior to approval of the Final
Map.
F:\HOME\PLANNlNGlMARTINlBONlT A\9102CC,RES
)ljp , (]
Resolution No.
Bonita Hills Executive Estates - PCS-91-02
Page No. 14
47. Tie the boundary of the subdivision to the California System - Zone VI (1983).
48. Provide the City with the Final Map in a digital format such as (DXF) graphic file.
Submit this Computer Aided Design (CAD) copy of the Final Map in accordance with
the guidelines for Digital Submittal issued by the City Engineer.
Code Reauirements
49. Comply with all applicable sections of the Chula Vista Municipal Code. Preparation of
the Final Map and all plans shall be in accordance with the provisions of the Subdivision
Map Act and the City of Chula Vista Subdivision Ordinance and Subdivision Manual.
50 Underground all utilities within the subdivision in accordance with Municipal Code
requirements.
Failing any of which conditions, or failing the continued maintenance of same as the condition
may require, this conditional approval and any entitlement accruing hereunder, shall, following
a public hearing by the City Council at which the Applicant or his successor in interest is given
notice and the opportunity to appear and be heard with regard thereto, be terminated or modified
by the City Council.
Section 8.
Notice of Determination.
City Council directs the Environmental Review Coordinator to post a Notice of
Determination and file the same with the County Clerk.
That a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the owners of the property and the City
Council.
J)
Presented by
Robert A. Leiter
Director of Planning
Bruce M. Boogaard
City Attorney
F:\HOME\PLANNING\MARTlN\BONITA\9102CC.RES
PI.!) -1'1
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
MEETING DATE
ITEM
October 11. 1994
15/1
ITEM TITLE: Report on the Library Board of Trustees
Recommendation of South Chula vista Library as the
name of the new library being Constructed at 389
Orange Avenue
SUBMITTED BY: Library Director~
REVIEWED BY: City ManagerV~~~ (4/5ths Vote: Yes___No-X-)
~ (j ~- Council Referral #2095
The official name of the new library currently under construction
at 389 Orange Avenue has been the topic of discussion for a number
of years. Since the building's exterior signage needs to be
ordered within the next few weeks an official name should now be
chosen.
RECOMMENDATION: That Council accept the report and name the new
library at 389 Orange Avenue the South Chula vista Library.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their meeting of September 28,
1994 the Library Board of Trustees voted (3-1-1) to recommended
that the new Library at 389 orange Avenue be named the South Chula
vista Library. (ATTACHMENT A) Other relevant Boards and
Commissions recommendations are listed below.
DISCUSSION:
The naming of the Library at 389 Orange avenue has been actively
discussed since the fall of 1990. (ATTACHMENT B) At that time it
appeared that the site would accommodate both a library and a
dedicated park and/or community center. Therefore, a variety of
boards and commissions were polled as to their name preference.
The results were:
Library Board of Trustees: South Chula vista Library
(ATTACHMENT C)
Montgomery Planning Committee: orange Avenue Park and
Library (ATTACHMENT D)
Parks and Recreation commission: Montgomery Library/Park
Complex (ATTACHMENT E)
Following the death of the city's Principal Planner Dan Pass, in
late 1990, the Montgomery Planning commission voted to change their
name recommendation to the Daniel M. Pass Library and Memorial
Park. At the request of the Montgomery Planning Commission, both
the Library Board of Trustee's (ATTACHMENT F) and the Parks and
Recreation Commission (ATTACHMENT G) also agreed to this change.
I5A -'I
ITEM I..5A
MEETING DATE
, PAGE 2
10/11/94
On April 23, 1991 the City of Chula vista was awarded a $6.7
million California Library Construction and Renovation Bond Act
grant. When finalizing the grant contract, the California state
Library required the City to attach a name to the project. For
state Library reporting purposes only, the name South Chula vista
Library was chosen and has been used throughout the grant
implementation.
Although the new library will be in a park-like setting, the state
Library indicated that the library site could not be a dedicated
park, nor could it include a community center. Therefore, the
library name no longer was a Parks and Recreation commission issue.
In addition, the Montgomery Planning Committee was dissolved and
therefore, has not reviewed their previous recommendations.
On May 26, 1993 the Library Board of Trustee's revisited this issue
and voted to rescind their previous action and return to their
first recommendation, the South Chula vista Library. (ATTACHMENT
H)
As part of the FY 1993-94 budget process, Mr. Goss sent the Council
a Supplemental Budget Item on the name issue (ATTACHMENT I).
As part of the FY 1994-95 budget process, the Library Board of
Trustees voted on May 25, 1994 to reaffirm their previous
recommendation to name the new library the South Chula vista
Library (ATTACHMENT J). The name issue was highlighted in Mr.
Goss's formal budget transmittal to the city Council (ATTACHMENT
K) .
On June 21, 1994 the city Council conducted a public hearing on the
FY 1994-95 budget. At that hearing, a group of local citizens
raised a number of issues related to the new library. One
suggestion was to name the library after Cesar Chavez. This
suggestion was referred to the Library Board of Trustees.
(ATTACHMENT L)
The Library Board was unable to take action on this suggestion at
their meeting on June 22, 1994 because the issue was not on their
agenda. However, it was discussed at their July 27, 1994 meeting
when members of the citizens group presented a petition which
included the request that the name of the new library reflect the
Hispanic heritage of the area. (ATTACHMENT M) After some
discussion, the Library Board asked for additional public input on
this issue. (ATTACHMENT N)
Per the Board's request, Library staff quickly developed a simple
survey form (ATTACHMENT 0) and distributed 1,500 copies to branch
libraries in the city. The forms were available to library patrons
until September 15, 1994.
/.5/1, :L
ITEM /.5';9, PAGE 3
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
The results of this highly unscientific survey were reported to the
City Council on September 23, 1994 (ATTACHMENT Pl. Some 34.35%
(147) indicated a preference for Cesar Chavez and 33.18% (142)
expressed a preference for South Chula vista Library.
Additionally, 15.19% (65) checked otay Library, 11.68% (50) checked
Orange Avenue Library, 5.14% (22) checked Montgomery Library, and
0.47% (2) checked Daniel M. Pass Library. There were also over
forty other names suggested. This survey was conducted in an
informal manner and since it is not statistically valid the Board
was cautioned that it should only be used as anecdotal information.
On September 28, 1994 the Library Board once again reviewed the
history of the name, considered the informal survey, and heard
public testimony. During the discussion of the issue, three Board
members (Donovan, Alexander and Clover-Byrum) indicated their
preference for South Chula vista and one Board member (Viesca)
indicated his preference for Otay Library. The final motion was to
recommend the name be South Chula vista Library and this passed on
a vote of three to one with Trustee Williams absent.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. The contract for both the interior and
exterior signage has been awarded, however the letters for the
exterior must be ordered within the next few weeks in order to be
installed on schedule.
List of Attachments
I
?;J
S
~
A. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, September 28, 1994
B. city Council Information Memorandum, September 19, 1990
C. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, September 26, 1990
D. Montgomery Planning Committee Minutes, October 9, 1990
E. Parks and Recreation Commission Minutes, October 18., 1990
F. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, December 5, 1990
G. Parks and Recreation commission Minutes, November 15, 1990
H. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, May 26, 1993
I. Supplemental Budget Memo No. 16, June 8, 1993
J. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, May 25, 1994
K. City Manager's FY 1994-95 Budget Transmittal Letter
L. City Council Minutes, June 21, 1994
M. Community Petition
N. Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, July 27, 1994
O. Name suggestion Form
P. City Council Information Memorandum, September 22, 1994
I,M.;J
~~l\
~?
TEL:619
FAX:619
,;'
I ~ I ,.,
UUL:EP 29""" :2,
CI'-- "" , ._J
II [ . . ,~...:)
h Iii" C.~
-5 7
,":1
DR. JORGE A. MURGA
319 PEARLWOOD STREET
CHULA VISTA,CALIFORNIA
91911-4527
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
September 25 1994
pst;
10
cA~
olio-
"'"<
"'"C;S
a;t.
!I
~
:II
....
(')
....
<
....
o
City of Chula Vista Council Members
Chula Vista
California
:III
'"
(A
.....
Dear Council Members,
~
The San Diego Union Tribune published on Saturday,
1994 "C. Chavez favored as name for library: Chu1a
will have last word on new building's moniker".
September 24,
Vista council
I want to express our family support in favor of the Library Board
of Trustees motion for the name SOUTH CHULA VISTA LIBRARY and intend to
provide additional support for the above mentioned name.
In regards to the late C. Chavez and his farm-worker labor union merit and
activism I think it should be decided by historians~arid~n~t' by
the Chu1a Vista council.
I want to remind you that by coincidence Cesar Chavez name, rhymes
with the name of mexican boxing champion Julio Cesar Chavez. T~is
circumstance creates the possibility of several misconceptions
of " lapsus mentis" and/or "lapsus linguis", among the 147
supporters of the name Cesar Chavez for the new library.
Resp\ec~~li\:A^A ~_
Dr. J A. Mu; ;;"''f
21amk- t ~
Mrs. Sandra L. Murga '~
c.c. Library Director David Palmer
c.c. Library Board of Trustees
c.c. Mayor-elect Shirley Horton
-
.
/>/9 ~'I
-
II-e ff1 ) f) Q....,
INFORMATION MEMORANDUM
SUBJECT :
October 11, 1994
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
John Goss, City Manage~ ~
David J. Palmer, Library Director~V
Community Petition
DATE:
TO:
VIA:
FROM:
Item lS.A. on tonight's Council agenda is Report on the Library
Board of Trustees Recommendation of South Chula vista Library as
the Name of the New Library Being Constructed at 389 Orange Avenue)
The full text of the Community Petition (Attachment M) was
inadvertently left out of the Agenda Statement. The city Clerk has
a complete copy of the 24 page (double sided) petition for Council
Review.
/SA -s
eBest
American
PATRIOrTI
Cesa~Chavez I
.__ - __ . .. I
Cesar was born March 31,1927, on a small farm near Yuma, Arizona that his grandfather homesteaded ,
during the 1880's. At age 10, life began as a migrant farm worker when his father lost the land during the
Depression. These were bitterly poor years for Cesar, his parents and brothers and sisters.Together with I
thousands of other displaced families, the Chavez' migrated throughout the Southwest, laboring in fields I
and vineyards. Cesar left school after the eighth grade to help support his family.
---- ---" -- - - . - .--"
He joined the U.S. Navy in 1945, and served In the western Paciflc during the end of the World War II. In
1948, he married Helen Fabela, who he met working i1 the Delano vineyards. The Chavez family settled
in the East San Jose barrio of Sal SI Puedes (get wlf you can).
-----..-. --- ..__.-
In 1952, Cesar was laboring in apricot orchards outside San Jose when he met Fred Ross, an organizer.
for the Community Service Organization, a barrio-based self-help group among Mexican Americans. Within'
several months, Cesar was a full-time organizer with eso, coordinating voter registration drives, battling
racial and economic discrimination against Chicano residents and organizing new CSO chapters across I
California and Arizona. I,
Cesar served as CSO National Director in the late 1950's and early 1960's. However, in 1962, he resigned
from his paid CSO job, and moved his wife and eight small children to Delano, California where he
founded the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA).
In September of 1965, the NFWA with 1200 memberf8milles, joined an AFL-CIO sponsored union in a
strike against major Delano area table and wine grape growers. Cesar led this successful five year strike-
boycott which rallied millions of supporters to the tied Farm Workers. He forged a national support
coalition of unions, church groups, students minorities and consumers.
Cesar E. Chavez died on April, 1993. On August 8, 1994, the family of Cesar received In a ceremony
presided by President Clinton, a posthumously awaRled National Medal of Freedom Award. In naming
Cesar to receive the medal, Clinton cited him as 'one aI the most influential labor leaders of this century.
He championed the rights of Hispanic farm workelS lIvoughout his courageous and inspiring life...'.
Cesar E. Chavez, 1927- 1993 -.
'One of the heroic figures of our 1Ime', Senator Robert F Kennedy;
)5A -10
r
i
f
!
(
~'
"
"
,
~
<:
~
~
~
l t'
U'
!\'-
I
(
I
,
,
(
(
l
-;:!C>"IJ rn",., lUiiU
C': J5 -= S tc~ ~ e -
=~=rn ]J!fG j:!1J
!1!...8 C '-"e- lI)-5
Q,,,c .,.- ., .... "
Cl.bO-S= ~s~1J1J1J
<.5 -:i 0..1:- 0''::': e;
G.i - :; ~ := c:> ..... ..fIJ E c r ~
....c........"Qr--,-1J ==
l! 1:: l.o IJ Il""l en C fti =: 8 .. ~
CI.l ==.!:!,:......."ii ~ oW "" ~ ==
IJ.Qi: "OlJc <<>.....-
-Su nl.2.lJfti nllJl:'-s:!.!!!
IJ t: tlCl- Cl.f! ... 0 Vl.~
g:;:;;s;Jl h li.t..~
.l: t;llu..c::- =--...! e > c::~
>..i ... ~ ~.c - Co o:a I,)
IJQE.2o=IllO"-~"'..c
c. =.....c.-cl.l=_...
o..c_Q.1I1tJU)._bOO~IJ>"
E.. t go = ~= 1 DEl i..l:.c
=., ~Ul!! S ~'i:!Hl:ll
- .c.JI: ~.3 e.= g IJ 1.1 == ~
~~ tLSt"i ME-~ 1: ec.g
)C,I ~Q..c.! ca 8.i 10
~c; ~.! 1Ii.b WJ.5':" 0 >.. 0=.
_ &: ftI- c'" := ...c:...- ....::.. 'i t;--L. .1:: a:. c.. -a...... IJ I
., 15 IJ :a. ~ s= ~!! == -i ~..- ~ 0': C .... &.l 0 > g >..
::5 ~.s'i~ .~ 8 e t~~:!! d t ': :.n ~j;;c>.2 .....0
.. .... 8 ...."ct- ...... -.. Sl:l...a> !l80i:;'''
oi~.>iJ~M a~~a~ ~~~ ~~~ ~!R=g~8ccis;
......e .Cu.,.lllJ.... ..tI ... ::z::-- co5.J!c- N I)"
p- .!!I) .'t "1J.,gS"o&o >..-..5 a-"-,,- ...........go
!~I.i~~!&I~ii21..-: .!:l~.2~ ~~~t~.e:~ose:
c.>i->.:t: u.....~C5!.....- - .,s<..:iftloCG:s>.cf!!
l;'l! t:::!!,-'ll.!l Bj ..lifo ...s! e cl5ll .e t i,p..e l!fl:l..s~ S g~
M~=J =~.~~~~c:e-~ ~ t~o;~----~-~
':'..!!:E! IIJ:J:-a-.- "..i-.:9= ~.. III E als ",-32 ~ II e=:;.c
"6._c" U-....-I; ;;,..0: .e" IZl l:l.="=l!!SIl lC-
>8.'llJ:=;.!l'llj!-g~lsll~~ ~b~t~:Jl~~~l!o~~S
>... j Cf!-__II.! ClIOI!-=::~"- to. .c QC!
] 11 ~ ~ e:~H~ S.l5 "': e.d-e Sj =-l'E ; H~~'S .. Sit S'j;;,8
u E i j ~rl;ll b~'U.8 "s &J~ U.id5 U~~.:!~ ~ ~-i,i
p_.c:: >; I: 5.5
~i:-."" ,..c-~
.. :l8"= c.8:I::.. ~.... Jlit..it
.s~=gi~ 8so~i _~'5 -l!!'5~
..JC:U)>~ "liolSci5 G.o "E -
...]'2< ~'S ; Sl:S ~of! io &-- !5.l!! t:~
"it.~-" I:""''p,ol! ~.l;& .--'iil;; ..
olll1::j- ~ic.E~ F= =11"'11.1;
'''&g-~ 0 ._~... iJlS li.es: 1l
1l~...r...l!" li~""':':;;-ll ""'l!!N" ..
';)_0 _..a 8~"'II.c..-!1lO -= &1:.= 1l
iJjl.-g >~i~;.iJ~~ 'ISJj
.. 1l.- f....S::iu..Q,... u"'j
.11 &Jj . -e ~J.5 I! co ~ c::I ~ "f t ~ $" II
ftl!!tai.j-~Ju<~o!Oli~1l-Ej~..=.l;N
1Il _ .... S"'->,., 0 ...-..
.1I"Ji " t-- 8..'" j!....,... e:~"':;;;"
>;Jll~.l!!e~i~~-~Ilo~~ii~g~ei~id
.-..!_~ ';j..= .5S .e...!!"",
.- - =..c 1:.,
..
ell
ell
..
0;
"
..
II
~
II
II
-
CIo
II
III
~
..
'1:1
.
..
"
~
~
.-
>
ca
-
:I
..:
U
ItJ
= liP
l3'S
Q,ell
1tJ=
'EN
ell~
o ell
,.Q.=
e-O
e;
,.Q!
~O
~ '"
,.Q t>
~ g
'"
=ii
0'0
:;) a
:; ~
:;) =
O-l;:
S2.~
e; g-
inS
-:r
o 0
.. ~
~-
= 0
t"I._
cr. ~ ;::.
OOt:~
3 ~ < -
_ r:.:)
.. r'l ...
o 0 r'l ?:"
""3o~
;:. o~ =. =
tb =< :3 ~
::>lI>Q
= 0"-'
...____e!- ~_.
_. '
'''CleM>'>'' .,c N-l)lltlO 1)18')_
~ I:l.-=: = = ~- ~ :E ftl &i ~"c..c: = ?'.! ~ e:
ee~uftle'"">' ~!-~~~~ie -UP~
.~U ~I) _._C~~N~_ ~'"" A
;t C = ... S:J CS '~.a -e u C) ~ :: C ftl ~ ~
UC~~C)~C)> CU~~~ftC)w~ftl~ U
~_~ .- .'- ~~ ...... U-~
~~E~O-~ ~~~~SU-;.e ftl~
>to=' cuctiM u:;",~ ...~--=.~~;"5
"11,.g t'] tIC... rei C 0.8 ri ~ ~ C ... >...c :
_ '" ICI ftl 0 ..U A ... - = ftl "" ... tIO._
u~~e~A~ ~ C).~.~ftl=~~OftlCe
~ ~:J ~~~"O ~ S'~::> ~.s'C ~ :.~:g a!
I~ftlccu~'; ICI~O~~"'JCUs;to>ftlo
=';i ftl.c ., .c:._"Q 0::1:9; ...-..!!..-
<~'>-~-~c" u~.~~.c:U-~<Cu=ftl~
u ... I) ~ ~... 1)..._E.....c~~
~j~~j ii ~~~i!~]j~~J:~~ ~e.
<_ eo-~ ., =&C.......O C)~OC)
..J~-S -!.,!; .- ec!-c:a cOO t,) ~'i~6
~~igN >..!!" "'c;.sJ:JiJ;~I.lE Del>.
=~d5'=' ~.~'E~t:~ tJ~ c_".!!" lSO:: !ll,.6 i
UkC)3ftl-~...' ~~~.t,)C>. ON~~
~~~~~~S ~~ ~~l~~ "C~,_
~
J
-
.
lD
S
0'
ot:
!
.i
8
Ntn(U
~~E
ca "C ",.
.c ~ 'w
(.)1=
:e .~ ~
enfi!
(U .c:t
,... en._
~.--
CI
'"
c
it
>--l:
c~
~J
d:1_
CD ~ 1 '
C>
..
ll.
"
o
II
-
..
;;
..
;;
.z:
U
CO
II
(/)
, " I .. .
.~ .=..:: I
:u ..r-g Il
'..8.... ~
!:; :; -= CP
!t;Jlt::a-5
"--.- ..
:; 11....0 U I) ~
,> ......c::I
iC." >-.....:-
~=~EI.l-=
J II '-ol 11"'8 t.1
)>.ftl':::_..s::
...... ftl u'"
~ 5'" "';.5"'Cl
:l,.--"'C_ c:
.= C CJ ftl
~:E:~6~ct
:-~<--e.:: ~
; :: -' (.; -= 5
~C;:tne;-'
"0 JlS!' ,il" -
e..~='i '" ....:cnc.:: ~: I h-~~ >~g ~.! .5
itJi~~~I'~~~l~i~~~~J~~Jl~~l~~Ji~
li1~'Jt~JJ~;!~~~~!~!!;]~sil~~~~'~
eO..............l:G,)orf-'IIl!!c...e>-"1a _...~Q,~"U
:x: = - II'l ftl ... 0 eLl - cU -= is.c"c;; 8."cU.z: _ u._.z: Go) Cf'J Go) - O. Q. "'0 0 II
.,.i iJ'ii~&:Q =-.c S iro ~_..!!&&. 0'::- 01= g-5 ~.;; =-;; e:c"'O:S"ii
~~~~~~g~~~~i::~l~li~~~~~~~~E:jJ~
Go)_%eo~~:f~-E~-~~Cf'J~~..lO-~~.~s~~Go)=~
e"o>.R-c::C .cU's"Ef;cU::!ECfil=- eCLl0G,)lPt::.II'lCf'J~..c.!!.s
c>. ....:.:._.t:_;itCll .....c-CCLl o=' !:o>Ecc..Q o=s-~
. c.'"5.;c ~:: ....!a ~ 8.~=::l-'C: ftl~,-. g.Oc ~ ftl &.8 o~ cue! :'CLl Go)
E8~.~~~;~~~ftl5~..c:-CLle~oC~Cf'J~~C::~-~~~~
-UltlO~a:---!So"'ol~"'Cii5"'"'O ..:.cere I"': ::l':;>re"'c'CLl_
~~.9~~~~~~~Q. re~II'l~~;~~~c~~~~~~~S~~
..= rIJ.o ~ In C': ~ >. g: CLl re e ~.a.:o::3 . tl Q. rc -= 0 E ~ tc u::)::':..= - >..5
= -()s>()c ~tIG"'O-:::__._~ort""E...r.Ug~ ~v.C': :. -'~..."'O
~ E~~~~~~e)ct~~~5~~Z~S~~>~~.;-~~~~~~
.ll:
=
-
.
..
=
:0
u
Q
I.lKcU -.A:
.:II: I.l- ~ --u
._ _ _Q = CLl _
.::: .:.,u._ I ~=
"o",,,,,s,,c
=.E ".8101 0
.sstG,).,j-g-
G)-a;:et=fi
Ul c Ul,_--,:_ e
.scct;ts"ii..
G,)....,lIC...... if: c:
.c ~'.E BolU ~~
::~Cf'J.,.,&E-;;~.
Cl IoC l\.l CI) rc .- ~ .--=---
7CGJ;:E~;-"i I
~~-~~~~ ~ ~~:A 1.
GJ'-,.!!;! c::: E Q,)O .
-= g':'~Q,)O..c
.:::::E~(I';5U~
_ w .,....~ _ I" C!l
'E
o
:I:
-
III
.!S!
!!!
=
~~ )s;-
-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
,
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Address
-
Phone
-.
. __~..""!!I/6Jii
(~~O#lr
~Jl~
-~
-~
IS It - q
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vis".a
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
,
Oc::ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non.violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vis:a
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. . -i~. :~..' ..
.... . ..
~
-.-
.~ ."'\
. For these reasons and many more, we woUld like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
-
/5 A - LO
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4. 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of.the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new fibrary in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobmzation. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in Cafifornia or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. H"1S name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. . {!.: ..' ,
..'\ . J::
>
"
For these reasons and many more, we wo5iCi like tci"you to know our opinion that the
new library be caned Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
/5A- 1/
--
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula V1S'.a
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
,
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our c.'1i1dren as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {~.. ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we woGtd like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Neme
Address
Phone
I
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vis".a. CA 91910
,
Oc.ober 4. 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in California or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our chadren as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the futIJre of the United .States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. . {~.: ..... .'
.... . 'J: :-
::..:.. .~.,\
" For these reasons and many more, we would like tel you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
, Name
Address
Phone
.V 9/9)/
8)
;Jf~~
~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobnization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones:y and support of others, not only in California or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. H"1S name
evokes a symbol for us and our chndren as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. . {\. :_.. . ..
.1\. ~ ..-.- ::
.
For these reasons and many more, we wo~i~. like tcfYou to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely.
Name Address
JO<l'{)pe/in p Jv(tJ/Yr uto ......",
(11411.1 G P/Pfdy Pnlnro A;()
Phone
........
~
v\
oXn oJ 0 VOy
Jr~-~R~
fJ;n;a- (ltJ ~--tlJvAW-
~;LQot b;~~u~t-
.
ISA - 1/..(
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista. CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of-the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. . . f~.: ::... . ..
For these reasons and many more, we woijjd like tcfyou to know our opinion that the
new library be caned Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
h z
jJW'1t /)()A1CAef' :.... 0_ ~h3
~~~~~~
Lrfir1/() f!zuerwl'o _~
1511 -).5
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City CounCIl of Chuta VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
,
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of-the undersigned citizens of Chura
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in Califomia or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We beneve that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
wcrk and perserverance. '. {~: :./:"..' " .
,
:0..- .....
. For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
__'-'_~'--__~A______ __ _
t:~~
15" A
~
1(P
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purposa of this letter is to express the opinion of.the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new fibrary in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in Califomia or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We befieve that the fut1Jre of the United .States is based olthis example of hard
work and perserverance. . . ~:.: :,t-.... .'
,
-.-
~~ ......
.. For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to knew our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
,
15 A 1"1-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of.the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hone~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. H"1S name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
werk and perserverance. . {~. :k'.; . :
1\ . ....-
,
For these reasons and many more, we wo5id like td'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
, Name
-- -~-- - -
er7O- y ~re~
15A I g
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we woulcllike to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely .
Name
'3
~~\") ~'N\~vG\c\~
'I r U/
. . .
. -
,,~r,a~ 1J'J\,1~~-"""---' _
/5 A. - / 1
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chura Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
~'" bj~c /
. -
. -
--~ -.....~.~~~--
-
........-
...,.
---
_A \~"J.. ~\ Vl'lO
Jvt ?r~ Iv\c.rfi ne.:2
) rJl~AJA '2P.(2.:20sP!
.
t
z-v:: t=~~'"'~o
J.hp\ l0 lares .. ..
/5~ft oJ..O
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
~~\J~\
Address
A ,V 12rn(hl ~
Phone
~
-----------
);;MP'Z'7V (r _ ,
Luz- Mana 'Z.CQ
v -.
J()(::F~' C05~//f)
CtJil()> <</~{O ff/
--------'-
,
· __-...r._~-
~
.......
/5 - A-
0:<.... I
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
;::l
_.,~<<,;.w
'"I
/J 1(...(./(1.(../ /.Vi-a )-7/
r'l_ 7:;' .. It. () _
L/C/Ll/UI~<!Z'?I?(rdc_'Io II'{ .
lZit. t..l.~ 111/,(,:?' '.If''''-, Q! f
/J~ ff YrJ i.
r'ft,Lle:;46~. 0/:./1.1/1, t 4<':~ I I
JT7~~ #~~",
(/r~' f/;';a.~ Il
15A ---~
\ I / I
/
li,
I!
( \
__---f"
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. }:>.. .~ _
For these reasons and many more, we wo~ld like tcfyou to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
Name Address
LInn (/1/1 (]O!rlPAD ~
Elsbe:i-h t3!(2j-retZi _.-
KtUU6tf
Phone
.-1"'7
(/
-
, ___;;7
15A - 023
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
~7~
{/
-
15" A ~..2 1..(
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chura
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. "'. ~.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
.4nw~ P?d;/p
-
-
__.n._ __ _ ___ ill.
l,fJ - ..2.5
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chura Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us. honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United _Slates is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. {~" 't:".
For these reasons and many more, we wotiJd like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
-k
~
r-~5(O UftOA- 1/ 1/ )/ 1/
)fJ', IJ (a, V it
---r 0 Y
~
~~~
\ . '\D ~v\:\],((j ~v
~---~ --- ..------ ------
15r4
_ .;t (0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4. 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us' honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {~: .: .
For these reasons and many more, we would 6ke tcfyou to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~,
~
'eE(Cf CAu-J IRO JIe-
Address
-
Phone
"'-\-0 \"\\ ~ y:.o. II'^ ( y,,-
. I
'"
.
to CJe...-z:
I
AJ.'("\n.{\(l ~I"'\( hf'.-z..
rRe~ ~t:rrlCL
2pv.Ja ~
I 5A -:L 1-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {'.. ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we would like tei 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
r~:J -7
, .~~y.."
~'-r {J~Dr1Ja
-'l:::)CeX'(~ \J~ ~OI
ISH ~ .L~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserveranoe. f: J: .
For these reasons and many more, we would like td .you to know our opinion that the
new li,brary be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
U\.I cvei-e
---:r- ~ t',-J t\ 1---\ Po
i '(
II , ""
~/! i ~
'-/I1Sl:>ov'f.-2
-
---
)
-
. 4
s-
I5'Pr _
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ~. ~ .. .~ .
For these reasons and many more, we would 6ke to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
~L. L....hJA
f!:aJ
Q
H?'jl./...\ ){~<he::l-=
~l<~~
-
. ~
- -
t
-LJL'O ~~<40
/514
:)0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. ., .~.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name I_~. .
:J/lu-r-tC-L- (/e...6Yl ~
~
/514 - 3~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orr'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ~:: " ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we wo~ld like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name ~ress ... _-------------..
~l:OvMJMt /2()~l.- ~
1__
..
_ ~___.'."_'L __1"'__.,......___.___
&j2f/.e:.ct.- rAid-II d4..
fJ:.kwi 0 &/Y'})WlC
JOSe r-AorcQlcb
~~~''1-1./
/))~"~7/:1,.,N
/5~1 -ilL
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ~. '. ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Nam
-------....... -~---..-.......::.--.-
Cb
an:r~" =.
:L.' :/',( /fr; /l ~1/ fn .
\Kll5i-t- ~o _
J~~00-- fu.ev:n
.~ - -
..~ .
/51-1 - 33
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. .. ~.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Phone
Name
(lO:sE AI _ 6o/vl t:=, z...
Address
.....-
VIVI/'>.N'/'o<. 0wNZA/9.L
k \ Of\. (Lon bU><12 (l i A
A LLA; N'
'""L
HONlCA V t>.G -
L.u 0 'I v' 1'1--L..E.-
/5A - 3 Lf
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
,
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Nam.. ~--~
~;::~:;- .
.b,IN"<.(
r;;ii1ffJ:U;;:;;~ ~
(--5'U/vfr/Vltle OtitVN . . ......
RI/t7iV'S'O ~ VAW-W ~ ~
[JOEL mpJAt
/511- - 35
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
~IOt-lt::LLt l. G;t'IRCIA
AKfl-WE NftKftMi/r<A-
...........
--
-
r
01
MnN\a \JmrSOA _
::icJse A lafrr~ __-
~'{}JO~ ~~ ,., ,. ,-
f . ..'. , ,"6-
A/\ OU,O/lO/leg
~
~
:-~
w "".,.".
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in CMula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or ehula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. ~:'.. 'J:: .
For these reasons and many more, we would like tcfyou to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
f c(,)H V II Jk_(
0f.cgep.... \/A\lf::,~
('"
(:)
..>.\cue..
-_....--- -,,---_.-
..
-
, .....'-'\ IT""' V' V -,~ \O,l,t:>ft
-
------ -------- '
'- !J)
-/!stt- 3 1-
t, ". \(('0.. 7, a.1({(~~
~ 9~~Q~
f-J H,,\ A 1\ I:..V A;~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
J"R0f:' ENc.<sO
~ rV1l-~
_,. ,~--.-."~~~...a'
(\()
~uJPQ::OR.. ~. 7.~I?,rC:RA~
/5 'A
-
32
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
.
- - .... -..........-&.~ .
~{
/5A -39
~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
DA~lJ
Z
e-jllAtfwu ~~ _
Av~.el, Lu^-l~ {( If (fl II
ll\7_y\orcj\lQlCl~(() _
Ir
(I
/r
/(
1'1
/(
t(
))
II
J)
)J
))
/Y1f
-- Jj 0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
for us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society trr6u~h non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
i
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would li!<e to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name .a J ~
~~- ~
~-b.fdo f1- /JrldL
~
-
5
tOl (MW
7'rJ/rt4t-f till
n.o
vo..r(Jb,c<
qQU?
ual.
lA
/5ft- 'IJ
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chuta Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
~\ new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
~~inCereIY'
Name
Address
Phone
......
lIoBl..4-r.k 9-.,4I.:il"'..dG.~-'\
~J
Jv...... L'l1.~ ~ ,:,.
M.u
~~I\MlIk,^ ~...I"""w#At:l
~
-
~-
;J,
/51f-Lfcl..-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chura Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image e.f Cesar E. Chave~ signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. " . '.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
I'. b.
Name
a~fj,rra 0fi/alliCt _v.' __ .... -rr.'r _
(
.J:'Me.. l"\'<e-r . ~ r f_ Jl ,~
~ ======
. . _~'0 . . __. 9
1:}^ ~\\\\:i ~
fl/ laM +~ '. . (el
/5A- ~ '-13
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
Sincerely,
Name
phone
......
.........
.---
/5A
'-
'1'-/
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chura Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others. not only in Califomia or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. . ~ '-. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
(~J~wJ (l;
\'\0-0' \ S-t~ks
\\{)!O- we (\(U\6 t1, .....!!!!!!~k. \j\o"\U ~\~l:':,1r-Tf(' ''-'(J->-
f~)(.1( Cxu1- )./!
6ft "'/:5
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of ChulaVlsta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. > .~. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
.s (J --'~..,~ A:J
~
'..... ~
A
ti
~-eA,t 'fl2 "f\AGl"l ... N'l
MMt.\^- ~vVv)1.Jf-
ak1.L1Jf')IIl1~ ~\ j~----
""..J l\IJ,::!e;z..-
.
E~n'qcl~ 'p-r-II?
helM 6t-1~4
-
-
-
J5A
J../ b
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ~: ~ : .~..
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
lv\ or' c>. VI ('
I (t (I' {laID
Bol
~t[",
HOl2 (lb
=--
h'>l!L
LA,i.,;\Z4 D MtNDcZ,A-
L1:;JJ~
lltNEV tale 8N'IID
----- ----
..
11M
Cl--tJlo ~
~s ~'?s
1./1-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new fibrary in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States Is based orr his example of hard
work and perserverance. " .-. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
b
fl c:b'\~
~~~
Be1ZNCDl:;::\loC WA-'/N't: _
.~
~~ ltl.-- QrnU !tZ
15A 18
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others. not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ., .
For these reasons and many more, we would Dke to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
. -
-'
/5fJ - '19
,
-,
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States Is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. :' :. .
For these reasons and many more, we would &Ice to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
l::!J (A\ DIl\JD
~
---
C!.t1R.1 S
;:~. jl~ ~'
15ft ~ 50
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
-
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
_~ I :z
~~~:Z====-
)TEuE: UDtz~ _
()
~iAQ. _ fJJl~
f<ooeJr1txJ1t" Aw~
.
. ---
/51', - 5/
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for ali people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be calied Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~
fJs{'fL/.ftyJlo'LM){jYJ'r ~
ILJV
/5ff r 5.:L
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chura VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. .;
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
JU..,,,,'FER &t1J5ItNq
........
Phone
--
\J~c-e. ~
~BR'e/ ysdV 1'10
- ........
k-eJ Ie h
5kpho(j f\/l Ciu6kr .....,.....
.AAaf'ro /1. (},Iu ......
yC('~ ca;g-ft1AfJ01.....~ ^- --~
/511 - 53
=-
........
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others. not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.' -
For these reasons and many more, we :IIould like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Jc/tI,y L~F7
Address . Phone
_C~_
6e-r ",,'A r- wlC"0" NC(
'I .
--~ -
0(!'"rJC>, [ 0T1/C I,::;
-
o
Lc<'-'~_~"'~' ~)
J10w & 2%r .
1511 - 5tJ
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chura Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. .
For these reasons and many more, we would 6ke to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~' .::=::
1'/1 ~0J .. .
'/<thJJ =
~jJ;~ l/?r
{()~~'~fi ~
f&fl4J (Jot'W' ~
f
V~
15f) ~. 55
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new Bbrary in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orr his example of hard
work and perserverance. " ~.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
---~~ ~-
.cLM~ E
N~
,......
J::1()r1~Jn
---------
~,y/l'~ b'UM'
--~
/511-5(0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
t
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
<.-/
..~
-p-7=- ~...,..
....---
... - -----...-.~~
,.... - - .
.,
/511- 5"1--
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpcse of this letter is to express t'1e opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence. community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {'.. :t::"
-. ...
.~ ...
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name U Address Phone
~~~~.""~~.,,,~~ =
--
~
,:/f3? ~n
L);~
~ --
~_.- -------~-
4r4J _ --.. II
{~cfO ~
15ft. 58
Cesar E. Chavez, 1927-1993
'One of the heroic figures of our time', Senator Robert F. Kennedy
Cesar Estrada Chavez, President of the United Farm Workers of America, AFL-CIO, founded and led the
first successful farm worker's union in U.S. history.
Cesar was born March 31,1927, on a small farm near Yuma, Arizona that his grandfather homesteaded
during the 1880's. At age 10, life began as a migrant farm worker when his father lost the land during the
Depression. These were bitterly poor years for Cesar, his parents and brothers and sisters.Together with
thousands of other displaced families, the Chavez' migrated throughout the Southwest, laboring In fields
and vineyards. Cesar lell school after the eighth grade to help support his family.
He joined the U.S. Navy in 1945, and served in the western Pacific during the end of the World War II. In
1948, he married Helen Fabela, who he met working in the Delano vineyards. The Chavez family settled
in the East San Jose barrio of Sal Si Puedes (get out if you can).
In 1952, Cesar was laboring in apricot orchards outside San Jose when he met Fred Ross, an organizer
for the Community Service Organization, a barrio-based self-help group among Mexican Americans. Wrthin
several months, Cesar was a full-time organizer with CSO, coordinating voter registration drives, battling
racial and economic discrimination against Chicano residents and organizing new CSO chapters across
California and Arizona
Cesar served as CSO National Director in the late 1950's and early 1960's. However, in 1962, he resigned
from his paid CSO job, and moved his wife and eight small children to Delano, California where he
founded the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA).
In September of 1965, the NFWA with 1200 member famHies, joined an AFL-CIO sponsored union in a
strike against major Delano area table and wine grape growers. Cllsar led this successful five year strlke-
boycott which rallied millions of supporters to the United Farm Workers. He forged a national support
coalition of unions, church groups, students minorities and consumers.
From the beginning the UFW adhered to the principals of non-violence practiced by M.K Gandhi and Dr.
Martin Luther King, Jr. The 1965 strikers took a pledge of non-violence and Cesar conducted a 25 day
fast in 1968 to reaffirm the UFW's non-violent commitment The late Senator Robert Kennedy called Cesar
'one of the heroic figures of our time', and flew to Delano to be with him when he ended the fast.
Since 1975, the UFW won most of the union elections in which it participated. By the early 1980's tens
of thousands of farm laborers working under UFW contracts enjoyed higher pay, family health coverage,
pension benefits and other contract protections.
Wrth the recent California governors farm labor board activities have become more lax. in response to this,
Cesar called for another grape boycott in 1984.
In July and August of 1988, he conducted a 36 day 'Fast for Life' to protest the pesticide poisoning of
grape workers and their children.
Cesar lived with his family since 1970 at La Paz, Keene, California Uke other UFW offlcers and staff, he
received substance pay which didn't top 5,000 a year.
Cesar E. Chavez died on April, 1993. On August 8, 1994, the family c:I Cesar received in a ceremony
presided by President Clinton, a posthumously awarded National Medal c:I Freedom Award. In naming
Cesar to receive the medal, Clinton cited him as 'one of the most inlluentiallabor leaders of this century.
He championed the rights c:I Hispanic farm workers throughout his courageous and inspiring life.....
15A ~ 51
I~I
Sat!f!Pi~o
THE SAN~.IEGO UNlON1I'RlBpNE
\
. SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 1994
, ,
CIIULA VISTA - Ce..r Chive,
ed.... out South Chull Vi"1 by two
toles II the most popular name lor the
city's new rmasUrd-yellow branch IIbr.ry
In an informal sune, of library patrons.
aid library director DAvid Palmer.
Some 147 01 the 475 people respond'
Inl to . Iibnry questionnaire uld they
wanted lhe branch library named after
the Ia.e Cha.... who pined internation-
al recol11ition I!I an .dvoc.te of mllrant~
worker riJht. and II . r.rm.worker la-
bor union orpnizer.
South Ch.... VI.tlUbrary - the
Mme previously picked by the Librlry
IloardolT_... -w"chosen by 145
people, Pllmer said.
Less popular IUI.estions included
OIlY Ubrlr7, which WI' picked by 65
people, Ora.... A..... Library ..llh 50
YOtes .nd Montcomery Ubrary with 22
'fOles. The branch library it! in the Mont-
aomery Park section of the city .t the
. Interaectlon of Quint.rd Street and Or-
-se .nd Fourth lYenuel.
'. I l.InIan-T.-..lJONrINF.UION .. More esoteric sullestlonl Included
rnd Grtg Rollings ofCltula Vista hope to smooth th, way (or mOil,.,,'" Q$,,"II.~ry,.:, . t Precious Momntl Llbrary.nd Rainbow
, I i ~ '. ~1 ,\;~~:~~l":,;'.;;,;;,:'~ C 1.~~l;;l\\tt"'fiJ~'~,: ~ I,r{\ ;t~'::;:;=~~'=:':~::'~
~ak barriers t(j"other SIde ";:'hl'i::~"::;:b::~:ft:ih;;'~
seplf.lte occasions to name the branch .
South Chu" Vistl Library.
But Palmer ,SIIid the trustees took the
lnlornud sUl"Yey lrom mld.August to mld-
September aller several people lIIid the
name 01 the new library should reflect
the heritace 01 the INlny Latinos who lire
eJ:pected to' patronize it and who live
near it,
The name win ulUfMtel, be: decided
b7 the Cit, Council.
Mayor-e'ect Shirlf'Y lIorton ..id yes-
terdlY lhat.... wiH wait lor the trust...
to make a recommendation before mak-
lnt her pre.~ence lutowft.
-,
I
. t . .. ,"
.: Malting Passage Possible
PI. ' " .
.\ .
':'!'
uring
Otay
ather
c:mcer patient who dies in a Mexic:m
clinic, the drug runner who is killed on the
wronR side of the border - they're all
aflected by the same oo,tacle5.
U.S. funeral homes cnn'l take bodies
inlo or out of Mexico. That's Mexican law.
Only one penon - the driver - Com be
in the Cltf with II body when Roing throuah
the commerciltl crossing. That's a U.S.
re~trtction.
Funeral processions can't {ollow bodies
.er05!; the beuder. That's the law oIlogis-
tic!!. Mourners nlWlrWo throulh the non- "
commercilll eu.,loms Rate and bodies must
RO throuRh the commercial late - Ind
who knows when they'd get together
again? ,..,.
To .mooth death'. ~I~ IcrOD the
ween
os.",d
I else
1 red
Jasks
!rican
Soo Deeth on Pogo B.8
(5A
C. Chavez
favored
as name
for library
'.
Ch:ula Vista council
will have last ward on
new bu:ildi'l1!J'S moniJrer
.'y RAY HUARD
ShfIWrilft
~
00
;
i
I
,
!
(
,
,
(
,
f
i
"
(
~
<:
,
,
~
l t'
U
!e
\~- -j ~~~ I Ht
i!ca;; ,...
eli\~ ~
--~- ~.-L
~~....~~~
-
"i
...J~
II
~
~
I
...\
\
l
\
~
~
r-..
I,
. t
l
i
I:
I
r
l
~C>'G.l m...Cl\l lU'
.s us ~ !! ~.s ~ e .!!
_ C'C 5 a:l -g..!!;; ~ G.l
.. ... .. = ._ " - '" -S
8."'" ...- .. e ... . .. ..
: Q, bO'5 = ~!l ~ II II) G)
I < C .....S! ...c- o'_-~ i:
, '-..-..
tJ - -2 ..c :: Q .......'" e C f6
..... 0 ....."Or;-..- &1 :=
S t: t.. eLl ~ eft 0 iG = 8 .. e
'" ::,!!:! bO*~'iJ~..o.;I... ~:=
C,J _Q1:"'g"O C) = Go)........
:5 u ~'- fJ ;;; ~ Go) ~-s ,:!l.!
e G.l t: tlC- Cl.: ... 0 Cl').2a
-=,,=" 8.... OIl
f.SI! to o1!'fi.~ 0 G.l tlC~
- .::: "'Cl u U .. ?:>.: !:: >0.5
>.Cl\lt.l..._ -....- "Sj
..~?S ~.~1.~ ~~:;.~ ""'....
.ct::G.l0 =QOocG,)>-
.... tJ c.c t'=-] tJC::"c.J:l
1lC....>~I>C""'-cO-"CI
clUe Q,)ocu!l::=u....GJ
.... .c.x i~ e..c g C) CI) :: 'So
~r- t: G.l"'Cl .E-.x t: ECQ 0
)1,) iid:SJ!:! ~ 2..&1 ~
cun; >'1)...' 'c'o>.
:5 E lh5 c: f g'-:;'-:"- Ea..: 'i e;.::!: .~.:. 0" "'Cl...... CU' 6
= S ~.5:g. E e= ~ J f ~ ~ ~ ~ It :5! 2.1.5 .; Si~ 0 ;; g~
:s . ilia. "a82t= <:!!!-= g;go =.,.!!il~1G8..c""C
ctJ IIIU 8 .-ac,.., ccllll= _ C Eg.= "001:,8
j~~~l~: i~~~J ~~~ ~~~ i28,~i~~g~S:
.S 8 ... u l. 'E I,) lot 0 0 Ii 9::1 S as 1.0::", ........ s 0
~~bi~~~fo~~A-lo~~ ~~~ QQ~-~~~~~e~
-e!.08;:e=>:S.fgtiii~ :C=f .<-="~'iatftJje;.Cf
~U..:,:s!=.....ej~S'5.......e~... ijliJeJ~t"Ctt'!!' .5h:c:g51
__=~Q- .~- =E-~ -~ E~ f ~---~-~
,:!J!:i c: IIt5!-e-;i t:g-.i= Jl = -. E Q.;i 5';G E ~ 8=~-:=
;; hi'; !.!!'OJ!~~"5! =:i.s~ ~bh ~ :Jl.g~ ~2 c~~.9
c">'c-C: j c: -.!.si ocal!-=-e--!: o..c:: CIa"
~!i jil~~;jijj~j:jiiiiJ~]i!;j::i~
. c"J5~ it_..c'5 >-5 E eB
boo.__ -"CI' . _ =...
;.:~II= ~~~_= 111111 ~~II.
~~bei~ UE~.~ ;~= =~=~
:J C:CI) ~c:;-;i ~~J5d5 11.0 "0 -
e-cs< II""'" i E. > ~- II cu U ~
......:; ... C e "~.2" C B:;08--
5l.5~j' .;!l-E i 5:!" = II f 1; i
'=&il--i! 0 .2ls'.lS il..,S 8,e.9= ...
iJJ..."'.J!!" g.........:."':;... ii2..~ !il.
v; - g _..c:: &I t:. .. ~..c: ...- ~ tal" .c ~ == "CI
=~jifl ~~i~:]~li~iS~f II
iil~I&Jl~ ."E~j1i~j:>2:'"':8.1!~!l~-!
~2~!.~~Jo<~c.!!og.!!~-iJ=..I.lS..
.. -g!l!o1" eli->'" 0 ..3="
~~.s ll.l< t''$ h ~ fl-5Jl,:~'g t'il...~.i
=~lJ~J~I~.slo~~i~~iJ~Jc
..
o
o
~
0;
l>1
..
~
.Cl
II
~
-
Do
~
1Il
.::
.
~
.
..
"
e':
Fl. ~ w
en 13, S
.- Cl.1lS
> .,,=
,.,. 1: ~
.. IlS >
_ OIlS
::I e.~
..c f'"
..,:e!
~ ....:l'O
~ '"
.rJ ~
C n
l'Il en
en
=ti
0'0
::l a
: ~
::l ::l
~
S2.1l>
ArC-
.. 0
r;;~
5:r
~ ~
l'Il _
::l 0
,",,-
tr. ~ ;.:
0- 0 r;: ~
3 ~ rf 5
l'Il n ..:; ~
o 0 n r.
.... 3 0 .
::l
::. o,=::l -
- - ~
f1) .., ;.j,o
=>SQ
::l C--.
... - ___eo- -2.....
......"::'-
.c
l
-
.
III
E
o
./::
~
..
"
~
NtnQ)
~eaE
ea -= ",.
.c (U ..
Uti=
~.~~
enfl!
~ -=
#, tn._
~._-
Q
II:
C
~t
>''E
C..
~~
,,,,~,,,>.>.I ~c: N-~'"C..ClO ""111')-'
~"e~=;;~ ~~e~~c=~~ ~~~~
E ~ _~ e ... >- ........ -- 1e::2 ..os;: - u f!
~;! cuU ~ cu ''!::-iG..80"C ~~ fI) "'Cf... "'~
~ C '"' !3 ....J: '0 tlO.c U It) > flI c:g ..c: -
"C~"..II~"'> c',~"'C.c~cu~~~lt) u
~ ---.--..c:.c... ""'"c
0~O~Q=~ ~"'C~mou-;..c:~-~-
->.;;... ..c:, V_tO cn_"'O tIOflIC-S-
-1=\ j ~"'.. ~ e to e ~.8 ~ ci ~ ~ -g"C ~~ ~
- . C'II ftl.8 .u ..0 ~ - - C n:s '"" .... tlO._
~~~~1~~ ~~~~~~g~~~;~~
r- C'II..J C..c:__"'CI ~ ftI- IV f-'c 0 ...>'"0 C
I~~~cu~'~ ~~~~i~~~!~flInls
<:C>.!..c:';:"'C V) cu:.J-;;--fi= it: < C cu:;.."
u ......=u ~ ~--u..._~"'..c:~u
Eo- c CllI ... 0 rc .!! .... I: .. c:..8 _ oS II 0 bCJ& U IJ !2
5!3f"3CU=0CO ftI.!2CCE~ "'O~-- -'-is.
>~o~..8 e~ 1~ ~ It) Wl~J~~ 5.2> 8't.
<~ ...o-~ esc:_ _ocu~"'C II
..l,ll-:5 =-l!.'O :;; ~t!l"E:S ~.8~!l"'" !2'H;g
5 ;! -! ; g ~ >-:E.! ~ ~ i : ..!! S..~ = I: 6 i
U]Jl~~i8tt:~~:s!i~~~r~d~~
_~~U~~_ _~ "'C._~C'l:I "'C>.~
:61_
cP ~ \ ~
01
..
0..
c:
o
..
-
..
:;
..
:;
.c:
(.)
G>
G>
en
~i I J.i! '"
:u~t"i ..
· .. B .. .. S.
! Ii ~]-;:J!
~ t;_~ a.~
iti,!uuf
~~ ;...::; E
~c:8"eCl).!
). U u"O II
)~C'C~-B=
;- rc f! .. C"'C
......""C ......- C
:-= c- CJ rc
~:E:;g~Ui
:.~<~~ ?rl
~ :: -:::: '-l:: ~
~ c ~ r.Jj e>_
'!
CI
~
-
<II
..!!!
~
&l ~ dJ I
:.!:!15 f 1"B
b ,:,u._ I ;...::J
~8p...C:~e.Q
-.- c..8 ....9
.,SE&l&l";C.,
&l"CI;e t= &l
= = ~.= 1fj= e
.QCI;I&lI,lCtJl'II
I.l:;.ac _... ~ c
..c &l-t: 5! &l >."S
_ >.- -::J I'll ~
_ ., If) DeleO;; ~~-s
01< cu If) CI;I .--...,.-
~C)=:E~;-i
e;tlO~~~cl.l
~ .~t l'!f& ~ (0 (
:;::E::V'::v~
_ u "...~ _ ,,,, re
I.l 0 1.152. 1. J, -
g.--:S"i I.l':' ~~i:r:: c:. ~~~ :-~~ rh.e .5
~iJi~~~~-~~~1~~~~~~!i~Jl~~1~~l~~
1i1~,it~~J~;!i3~~!i~!;I~iiB~~~~~
= c e.s 'ti -= f ;; t.; ~.i C.c:E tJ.." cu.::: ...!L.c &l (t) tJ ~ 1$. 8:~" t:
...i. 0 I.l._-c:l >'..c _:>:> 0 -ez.. Co.c:CU'; ooX.s tlIO..c cu-:; -- CU'-"Q:Siil:
_iO.&.2rtJlIlI.1'II o~~-- 0 U :::I-c:cC'CJQ1......cc: ...
~. _ ..,.!..c l:o:S=;- !2 = - iI:;!ftj ~ ~=~'i) eo ::J eiii.cii: ct.l.. .. e'"
o~~ I)e..c c_ . G"J ~:"::.!!.5 0_ > -:s e._'"Cl..c:...Eo- .ct c;- lLI~e ~
11__ e'itteao ... -=...-ftl-:::r.ct.l_gO-o>.tI; _O'-IJ .....
t.:)o ,C-c= .1J~"'C=I.l"'Ca.g=- el.l(t)CI)IJt-ct.lIl)~.c_!!"e
c~~U~._~_~0~~..cI.lCIJ o~ ~eCC~-o=e-~
I'll Q.-a~ ~ t: ....~ 0 8.5c:l-C: ceCa;., o.Ot:) ii fa 8.g o.~ 1.1"" ~G.l U
eo r.f'::""'C ::See ~t..:lI.l""O .=u ...._~-.....I'e'...J.c
u~~_~--I'e'~~I'e'~..c1'e' eUo I~~-E'~-~- -
"i)U)tlCI~C")-,,,,",:.~o=o 1-_Ci5"'E._~Cftl 5l:cn5:::l .Z.:c..t:=
... -= 0 v..::: ""0 ...J t:..c )I( Co f':: It) &l'J f- ftl - e: c;; tlCl C .t;'. .0 -0 tr.l ... cu 0....: I'll
] ,,;:.g ~ -;; ~ ~ >- ~ ~ ~ E ~ .2.:0 fj ~ ~ Q,u _::..9 E &: I'e' W =' ~ ..:"i >..5
- r:: ~ ...::: .:= :; E ~ ~ oG c:; t:l.t;:: ~ g.!; = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l1).S!.2: t': 4). - ~ - t: 'E
a r..;=;::~,,::!,,::...-.,o\:t,.;>t::-:..~~...-i=."'::"I ......_~,........'!":'_e"\
.Ill:
=
-
.
ell
=
III
~
GI
Q
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. ~::.. ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we wo~ld like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Address
/5A -
~~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chuta Vista, CA 91910
I
Ocober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others. not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our c.'1ildren as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. . {'.. :~..
. .
:.~ '. -....
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to knew our opinion that the
new library be caned Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
6-,^^ ~AJ"i
(Q ,
Ad
1'/
/5A ~ ~ 3
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chufa Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. H"1S name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
"
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
9d
J () (-\ \f-J {l\ (/ eJ I{ '-9 u c1...
;:i'M(') <;;tt> s;",;-yP-" 3_' I";
CL-vi'Y'ie"rn(~Lb:J ~~d~ _I
I11Ar1/.A Gflrc/ ~ ,
1:fL~;G~~';'~
loA- - G'i
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chura Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'You to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name r
-UJrtv & ~ \) I ~j1h
,
90
15A ~ 05
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United States is basad orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {;: :~. '
:.~ '. .....
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
, Name
Address
Phone
S(JU rtl G
.:lSc; be" 1 Q) '::'bn' 0
-
, .
~ L~'\.l..\(>'"
.
:1-
~o.Y'\.~r'I\lrl\' ~7.
l5~ - 0 0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
Oc:ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chule
VISta about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization end mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United ,States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. }.;.. 't"
,
:.~ '. .....
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
N'O"~Q. ~
~ ;!-i:~ ~
~
.
N"'-~
-~
-~,
..
,
. ~ ~.
/5A - 0 t
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
I
Oc::ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express t'le opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society thoufOh non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vis:a
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our cl,i1dren as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {~.. t: .
:-~ .~ -....
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Casar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
~1:~~~N:='-
6, cYJ. ,~II II If })
/5A - 0 g
Ms. Shirley Horton. Mayer
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Oc:ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez: to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society thouGh non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. ,.,. ..
.1~' '~,,,. ;J:'" .
.;
For these reasons and many more, we wdGfd like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
,
15A -
(of:!
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Oc:ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote end support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person end image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones:y and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. ..,
.~~ ~'.j.' ~..
..;
For these reasons and many more, we woGld like to 'you to knew our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
N,ml" ~ ~'"".
t;CW.A...; , ,.., :. 1
i1 Qr-k -Avrtd;
to<~~~~
-~o'.'J eo. (ft.~ =
l-J(J.J..)r1/-..-~
_ ..,- .... It,.'+. - I
/5A - '-:;'-0
Ms. Shirley Horton. Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Harten:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the futt.:re of the United .States is based on'his example of hard
wcd< and perserverance. ,.~{'... :./:,.' .' .'
For these reasons and many more, we would like to"you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
.;
Sincerely,
.
~_.~~~~...-
)
~ '"
lPbreQ-S Gon~ -
/ SA - 1 (
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
J.-IC<d~
.
..........
15A -
::;~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Oc;ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. . {: ~l ~,.:. ..
". .....
....' -....
For these reasons and many more, we wo'old like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Casar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
p~-~
Phone
p
. l v.........
/5A
7-3
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Address
Phone
---
15A- i-'l.(
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chuta Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based orfhis example of hard
wor,.; and perserverance. .,. ..
),~. f.l ;;:~ -
..;
For tt.ese reasons and many more, we woUld like to 'you to knew our opinion that the
new library be caned Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
]) fa rt(L 1.0
f\
r
15A --1-5
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non.violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. f.. ./: .
For these reasons and many more, we wo~ld like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~ ~_,,11. ~
(
v.
~
-~----
~dJ,;..r",.LL -
/5P\ - i-fo
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
'-
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
6fl-Ul~ ~
.. = _ J(~' u :'(i1t
------.~.. - *'... --
1:12A--
\.t M~ GL- 'L.\ U 0
j)O~\M---5b 0aVQ~ _4 qdl~'l
l}.4V10Je-O (:,)vcue~_
a.j (2tM
,51\
:r::r-
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express t'1e opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or ehula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the fut\.:r\l of the United .States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. . > . ..
."$" )" "E"
.......
For these reasons and many more, we wo'uld like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name - ~d~re;i ~.
rYf1~~~ ~
S III V )JoR C. P u L i \) 0
____..___ ill.
-- .
In
LJ~Vh ~Sc(1YY1~~(l
(ifUv de lA Lvz n io. 7-
f.AlVu.~ l~
_ _ _' __...__,;,r,_s..l:..r'...iJ.....ii'O"::;;O____..~. -- - ., ,
.j
'-
/51\
'12
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Oc:ober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express t'1e opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance.~, ~ . .~.' .'
.~. .....t:" ~
For these reasons and many more, we wobld like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
-
ISf\- - lCf
p
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the neme of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chule Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leacers. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserveranca. ~:;: .~..
For these reasons and many more, we would like td 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
(6"n02f Cl~
" .--,.-=
u
v .-'--.
~~F;~r~~V'~~
~d-./#~Lff_
-
_~~jJf/'61_~,;#'/'-~'.'~,;h.:AI'''';.w.i~
f 5Pt- - ~ 0
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for'us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
6/L.1?E/{IO
(' Address Phone
rJ'L~~;Z ~
s
:t: -~ - ' .--
("' I 10 '
- ":~~ ;(aPr~
;5Pr - ~(
-
. "
__'.....a..:a.:.._..~___-=-_,.A'I,-...: .
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us. honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. f : .~..
For these reasons and many more, we woUld like td 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Phone
ttLlGl (\I\)
~~,,~"'C\ t>JO,n",,- \~ ).f \l _I
""'Mlle.! CO ~do
6
<.
05f?
J5Pt - q d--
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. {~; .~ .
.,. ...
For these reasons and many more, we would like td you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name ~ d
lu7 _ () ado
) :/iC.-F c,~ -A. ':::If\ LA
R, 6:')0 f2~/,I9S
Addre~
-
LI
~~....._...~.....~~
(2(:wL
N2ll
If>. Ii.
t1 t2 c:cJ
/5(1 ~ 23
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. f " ~ .
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,
Sincerely,
A',I:.'1/-fI.(/Z (!rw7
II (t,4 C!ft.i(';?
I E.:5U5, FI /)?/ .
r/
'I'
f/
t/
t/
.51wf}ou;1C ~
M r/lL- Vt- Y L.-- /' .
--
/511: - 8'1
Ms. Shirley Horton. Mayor
City Council of Chula VISta
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
J/
fJPMJ" ~WA/
~_~ .2f~~~H-n~.- ~J-. -- -.- ~
~~:../ 7f t;o/!-'2Pt/e'c... - ---..
L (/2. Goo"./.- )> 11./<"<. ----------- --
,
1<6 ~ (/ It. 0 (lu8j)'J }~) #7 ~
V' '
15ft ~ 85
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chura Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
"
For these reasons and many more, we would &ke to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
~ J.l~,.f'~t ..... ....JJL_
Gr;at! Vl. ~L /k ~ ' .
{:?/)f'1o.... () ~)n~}nv-y,-~'n('/n.V.
jo:~';d~~
1511 - g b
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
E
7
15ft - S 1
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~ -~ -.
'"
}},1~JA P.-<--,,,- ;/&(77
tA~~
/5A ~ $
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. ' -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
"-
Name
i A{:J~I(j
~ - ~ ..
_ . ____-_____ _ _______ l'
!J
8>
/51\ - &1
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to .you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~ . ~ ii.. hone
11:/ a/7M .A4 h),
J~d/~O~ _
::\.sW10161 ,1),;;ICftJdo -..-.... ~
<../
P/Z./C I<-ajsde./~ ___, ,I-'U
!:~~:~:==
1kf1f~~ =:
/6A - 10
)
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. "
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
(J(J./,n(//Cu _
~
~ C\;} o~n <;,
\/!\'J'-\') ~
/7)A- ql
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Oc:ober 4, 1994
~,
Deer Ms. Horten:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chu!a
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society thouGh non-violence, community organization end mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based on'his example of hard
work and perserverance. .' - .'
i ,:$;.,/ $"'~
'.. .....
.... .....
For these reasons and many more, we wo'old like to you to knew our opinion that the
new library be called Casar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
ias~
l..ef~S C9~tjC>
gffuJl>)4p'/?d _(/.'V.j~
~7/C 1ft K;:}/1)/>6'L
~(C(O ~();IU0
\v\', \ ""'"
~'
-~~~,'
~v1~.,
II
~ ""-->1 -........."t' '--t.\.....
Jr
~-
,
-~----'-~
,
'I t-Irr-'f:...r.'-l~
- -
.. -.."""'""'-' ~-",,~.--.
, C' \
Ov ..:::> "'---
~(:J~'~~~~
, SPt - q '2
r.. .-
. - -......-.-- ....__.~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
"
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
"
/Sa t(ll~
f 5'11- -&f 3
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
.'
"
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orrhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
-,
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
(5ft - Cf'-(
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
"-
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Phone
'" .... .
'/
~Z'~>~
#~A~ ~/
ctfJ-
15A-~q5
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their/education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would Ilke to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely, C611UlUi019 0 DE 07/1 y
.(.cSl1e Ch /Jt/ Ez-
Name
~~lAJ;r:: bON-UW~
Address Phone
-
15 It- ~ 9 &
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4. 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His l'1ame
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
["11\.0... Q~'IvC:lI\\~S
C0,~~ /3~~_
-'7-PL OL
15Ft ~ r 1-"
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
?; U 5.{ V1^- ]).t~ ~
~
/'1
'-"
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
" "
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance. " -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
-
i~:; ct"tr') 0s=
"\f\''''\t\ Q,S\'J>...f\j c..~l:".
/!51't ~ Q 1
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in Califomia or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based on"his example of hard
work and perserverance.
-.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
-"___"_I__~
/51t ~ 1& ()
Ms. Shirley Hortcn, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
Ocober 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: hones~ and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United _States is based on'his example of hard
wcrk and perserverance. ,Xi> ;,,:,.... .'
For these reasons and many more, we wciUI~i like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
,;
Sincerely,
Name
Address
Phone
.
-----
/5f+ - /0 I
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance. -
For these reasons and many more, we would like to 'you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name a--t
~? <.W\iA__
~
Phone
---
2-
/51f - 1t1~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to aevance in their eeucation and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaeers. We believe that the futt..:re of the United .States is based orthis example of hard
work and perserverance. .~::: :J:" .
For these reasons and many more, we wo~ld like to 'you to knew our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
""'
Sincerely,
;
( ( / / ,,- - -" .-
/\ fr r /"'-.
'<<\~
\
~,-'7
1M
- -
~I
I }, J,
/'11
(ll::l.~'J(~
/,
/5/1 - /03
~
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
~~~=--
/J1 Frf-Jv fCV. /J1I4l./!...~U~"?- _
-A1'~(((IJtk 1")"\I}ULI!i?(./ 1:.."2- II _" I, Ii ( (
~Tl JfOJ\A ON.l-
1511 - /& ~
\
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
/7}1~j/1 z: 6mc),J
'n~ V>lEf?r?
t.f/r-u. ~
-
-
1-
/511- - 105
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the future of the United .States is based orfhis example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
f>..,..;Ce:/4
Name1\ rJ Address Pho
-p.& VYl AN C~ '-.:) (!l\ vwPrt-epJ p. _ _ T
f\ .... Q. I" I
~ y...tJII\- II\-IY] Po. li-N4 " A'" ,r 1"'-'--"
v / I
(\ , .. I
\"\ (j '-M. ~ ~ ~ D. \- Ol ~ \ \ \ (' C'9 ItA rr ~ Q -
\ l/p Lr't(
C'l... JC--CJ...'(,\,......,V
15ft - /0 (c
Ms. Shirley Horton, Mayor
City Council of Chula Vista
F Street
Chula Vista, CA 91910
October 4, 1994
Dear Ms. Horton:
The purpose of this letter is to express the opinion of the undersigned citizens of Chula
Vista about the naming of the new library in Chula Vista. Our vote and support is for
Cesar E. Chavez to be the name of the new library on Orange Ave.
For us, the person and image of Cesar E. Chavez signifies the struggle for betterment
of society though non-violence, community organization and mobilization. Cesar E.
Chavez means for us: honesty and support of others, not only in California or Chula Vista
but for all people to advance in their education and understanding of others. His name
evokes a symbol for us and our children as a hero and model of our best community
leaders. We believe that the Mure of the United States is based on his example of hard
work and perserverance.
For these reasons and many more, we would like to you to know our opinion that the
new library be called Cesar E. Chavez.
Sincerely,
Name
,b. j. CA.N;
1(1:1~~~~~k
-
1/'11
~ f'
J-IAY,ilIJM YousIF
'~'INu(~((t-k- _
{f){-~_UA- ~~~
-
/~14 - Ie '1
,
Cesar E. Chavez, 1927-1993
"One of the heroic figures of our time', Senator Robert F. Kennedy
Cesar Estrada Chavez, President of the United Farm Workers of America, AFL-CIO, founded and led the
first successful farm worker's union in U.S. history.
Cesar was born March 31, 1927, on a small farm near Yuma, Arizona that his grandfather homesteaded
during the 1880's. At age 10, life began as a migrant farm worker when his father lost the land during the
Depression. These were bitterly poor years for Cesar, his parents and brothers and sisters.Together with
thousands of other displaced families, the Chavez' migrated throughout the Southwest, laboring In fields
and vineyards. Cesar left school after the eighth grade to help support his family.
He joined the U.S. Navy in 1945, and served in the western PaciIic during the end of the World War II. In
1948, he married Helen Fabela. who he met working in the Delano vineyards. The Chavez family settled
in the East San Jose barrio of Sal Si Puedes (get out If you can).
In 1952, Cesar was laboring in apricot orchards outside San Jose when he met Fred Ross, an organizer
for the Community Service Organization, a barrio-based self-help group among Mexican Americans. Within
several months, Cesar was a full-time organizer with CSO, coordinating voter registration drives, battling
racial and economic discrimination against Chicano residents and organizing new CSO chapters across
California and Arizona.
Cesar served as CSO National Director in the late 1950's and early 1960's. However, in 1962, he resigned
from his paid CSO job, and moved his wife and eight small children to Delano, California where he
founded the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA).
In September of 1965, the NFWA with 1200 member famlfles, joined an AFL-CIO sponsored union in a
strike against major Delano area table and wine grape growers. Cesar led this successful fIVe year strike-
boycott which rallied millions of supporters to the United Farm Workers. He forged a national support
coalition of unions, church groups, students minorities and consumers.
From the beginning the UFW adhered to the principals of non-violence practiced by M.K. Gandhi and Dr.
Martin Luther King, Jr. The 1965 strikers took a pledge of non-violence and Cesar conducted a 25 day
fast in 1968 to reaffirm the UFW's non-violent commitment. The late Senator Robert Kennedy called Cesar
'one of the heroic figures of our time', and flew to Delano to be with him when he ended the fast
Since 1975, the UFW won most of the union elections in which it participated. By the early 1980's tens
of thousands of farm laborers working under UFW contracts enjoyed higher pay, family health coverage,
pension benefits and other contract protections.
With the recent California governors farm labor board activities have become more lax. In response to this,
Cesar called for another grape boycott in 1984.
In July and August of 1988, he conducted a 36 day 'Fast for lie' to protest the pesticide poisoning of
grape workers and their children.
Cesar lived with his family since 1970 at La Paz, Keene, California. Ukeother UFW officers and staff, he
received substance pay which didn't top 5,000 a year.
Cesar E. Chavez died on April, 1993. On August 8, 1994, the family of Cesar received in a ceremony
presided by President Clinton, a posthumously awarded National Medal of Freedom Award. In naming
Cesar to receive the medal, Clinton cited him as 'one of the most influential labor leaders of this century.
He championed the rights of Hispanic farm workers throughout his courageous and inspiring life.....
/5/1 - /08
;I.l 'J' - ;-.",." -
~("):;.~;:;::=-
::r0 (':"'0-::::-
e..1i"3 ~ ~~.;:;
~3-'Q.:-':::-
=~5:r:ro~
nt .. .., lJIQ IJQ ::::I 11l
~ .~:r-n:>>
=_(1 _.:rM'-
bc,o";>> (,II ('1....0
~ -0 l>>~~ ~'<;:
_'<C'llllI~.~:r
=............. ..
tll'IoC'ltlQlcr'
a =;&.C'.;J:I r:
.. ::l~ :I ......~
-:SC,8C'1ttiQi
o;~r~ ~r;=
:!'< ~ --~... ::;'
_~ ::I ..=.._.
""" "" .....
T"- "I'D
a. ~ p ~ :- ~ ;; :.~.;; ;i ~:: ;; ~ ~ .:: 0':: ~;; ~ q ~ ~ :::r;:; ~ :=. = ~ Q CJ
"'1 .1;'- ~ c: :n '. 3 ~ C"':l:.R ""'I - ~ 0 Co _. -.....;... :n ::: ~ < - ('1 - =
:r'< _::-,.::;5, ('"";:IoI)Q 0'::- ~ ~?aN c:--.::: 3 --" '< C')~ tn i1l 0 r.o ::r
.--o(D"'1~O~~~:::~~~(D:IoINr.o~~ ~(D~~. :::-Ql~::ro
_~ _(':I. -orno.j--....=.::::-; _:lII"'O><::r=-C"""~::rtnO_.-
- (t '2. :;" ~ < 3: C 'lI; .., ~:::,;- 3 Q.'" S2 ~ a" 0::;- 0 ii":.... _ (It ~ OQ "" !!..
~~lllI~-~~~~tnn=?~(I~~::r>>gQl~lllI~::;-~~3~~a3
(I(D~3i(D-'o2~QI~Co~o~lllI=_Qn~:n~'''''''o~~~lllI
3~- -O~~~=3~2=oO(D=~::r"'lllI0~_"'='';- '<:s
01 ;;':r ~ t;i":. ...., (D (D r.o t't a Q.."" = c. en ; g,.tD ~ a.- (I' :r::: _ a '< ~ G')
~~C'I~ao~u'<~~o -~~==lllI-:=-~;'~~o3Z,(D
.. =- c:r UI !""!... ~ -; .. Q. 01 0 -. -< - 0 =" ii':r C'I . 0 0 :r (Ii 0 ... 0
~a~OI~~~~cao~~ai~~~~OI:S~_&~=~~.--~
E~~~;~~~o~~i~~o~~~~i~I~~i~~~~r~i~
~QCa'i ...~t'Datl:rii""-tI "~,;a" ^Ol't-..,O..I>>:!.-;:S:C
'~I~!~!I~I!lg!liI2!f~;f~iIJ'~I~[
~~[~f~~~l~~!;~~~~~~l~~~~~~~!i~~
55" ;.cfc-S< 'i"~.Lj. -:' ~g2::: ,(t i;....g
_ ~ . &. . Sl't Otl
is
ar
en
-
~
a.
c
is'
'=
=
en
.
-
=
::II:"
~ ~ U':l= ~;
::s -:") ..- - -
~;;- &.2:~-f
.fJ!; g i:3:~
l>>!') _=' =~
='_0_0....-_
;:~.;:~~
:r=~0I'<(
tt ,,"(1 n CIt (
c-m:l.gg.;
2' - =..... <~
(; ~n a~c
:""B ;:i':;' t1 ~
=-'" :;;" - :
.. - C>.l:! = ,
" . .. is...
ii &,~..~;
I 2'::r I "'1
,tI !'
en
..
..
o
=-
c
;;;
<
;;;
-
..
o
;:)
"
..
'"
".\) CD
-I~
~~~t ~~!.~ ~~ ~~~9&~;
;: ::;'...N ~.J<:::t tI! Q.g'0l:I. ~a..k' =._. tI an
= g .!!I..c:" a = ii": g . ~ i e:~ a.. g ti ~!;Po.:: c:=
'Cj"g:=>"-:esro-a.~...,"' 0 Nlil!!!.
=-<_.~ iCl Q ~:I e: (t Ci' -"2 S' ~OS:
~o=-<ltt~;;'-3~= ~~ --!::: t:n-
''01 ~~:I e.; let O'~: c;;-; a i gi"iSf~
m n;~ 0 rc :r "" g":I ...:; ;" 01 ~ "" · ! -i
n:r"".- an""~ ~ r'D:s ~<n>
Ca.Ct'D=>~_:r~~~~ ~~:r~~:r
,.." ii"_-a :rcrc 0 a..c;:::r en tt>> =.= I
o.<o~r'DO""~cno"". e.~ =.~
=Ca_o"'O'" III C'Il_IU:;i Q..-.::r__iiJ--.1
.. 0." ... -.-... <<-~..... .... ~ '.,....,
~_._~~n.oc,< ::r~~ ~::r..,~C;:~~
g=IUOtt .c;;'rsO(t t'D '<g-:=";:;J'" ~...
~-~i~~i~r~~rrg. .~il~t~
_;:'=1>>00: Q..""Ul OI..,n 'f" _5.'<..
=~_~~~_no~a~~ ~~a~o~~
~~\~ ~ ::r~ -..._-. -..,~=
n nAl. CIlIttDl:rQ..QII\~::S ..c:tt_.tltJ(liCl
_=-g:= I>> ..c:<'I n::r"'aq o~;;..,= ~
~n..,Q.. Ul~<'I~9~~-= ;"-- ntl=~
AI n_ a:.~a:=a~03~ ,<5f~tJa.;a
~~;< =~~~~ClIUe: (I'I'~==~(t~
_fA I ~ GQQ..CI_...' =l'A ,<,<",,~Q...
= in. n
Sf-tm
~ J!. Q)
=!~
D)ft):r'
3 Q.~
CD~JS
~~
".;!
=.,...c
~i!
:.
,.,
Cl
0'":10'"= ll"::l t'lc-.....-
"I>>"" i1a3! ::'-0=""='- - .',-.
~~ ~ ~ l fiil ~;.;i5-li; Ei~ gJ!f &'5: <
~~~=-~~=..._.. _~~..-_&=~r1i~
~~-=-~sr~~~~Q~o~>O~~ra~!~iil~
. "iil~- =--="_,,1', =---:1
i~ ~ ;; a..g ;.. = iil ;. t:; an ~ a. ;~ a" ~
~:r -~~a~~~-~'< !_.O~=
a. o..S" ~s-c~_:r~=~ "'~l::l.....
.. ;;;:~ = if a." 5.~ =-3"'':1 ta =-!r 2.!rill.
.. _M..... __." ....0 ....., ta"
... .. _ ;; '0 =- '0 '" = () ::1._ 0.0 ...
0~t'D g'fI.:I! .., 'Qt:r M ==:1'
g !... ;; ",,6'= rU.&'~, oor~r~S?
- ...g.-r o"'~:;.~ i c.I_:r. .:!
~ ~~1i.. _~~ _~:I= 2.;~a.;_
o - ~ O.Q ~~=(I -~i~=~
~ ;fji ~~~ l.:t~ i~E;~;
. moC'll -~=..9 ;::!::l.a!.=-~
5::I:I!r~ !r=-~. lfln! !C""!!' go _ _ -
!g.; ~ [i:"g!i: ~~ U.!=~:$ia.:j1i;~f~S r ~ ~ ~
~~~~-u:~~a... 8.....~or .;.~ ~~~ g <I-~
.aq :1"'0 .., ....=-=;:QII0 0-._-=:5:1" '<
S~~oilg~~5::I~:I-<~ ~;; ~a.~~~r2.~;;;:r2.!~
_n l:!:I..c.",."!!,,,".:r ;1..0 "-"a.-()ii'"===ill.
;aa:a~,i~~ fa ;.{- =-:1 a=ia5=~ 6'iru 52" E:= ~~l>>
~i~~'~ :I;~~~iS~~ ~~aR~o;~iS~~-~~:I~
l ~ ~ ~~ l-;~~i:~. ~!r[ ~!; 1 gf~~~ if~!rg. ~il ~ ~
'or:;a3O'."C\oC(Ii"'~~ I!!-jitl __o~ oa_g._""t_(lia-E._t'ld
08.....j.. ":r"'S"= ..-'< ~=n.ji"S"n~;a.~. O.~5-
.. (I N ;... - ~.. fa e.~ !
~~~p ;g!]~f f~a ~~; {;~~! R~i~~!!
a.:J.OSCc.o gi-i =-0 e_ :1="'= <g O. _.l\JiI
~n~~.~=a(li = 0&= ~~> ~~a8~ -~_~ ~I>>-
~g=~;:-=!'5'~'8S: at;::r dl~E' ;<t!i'=o -e:=; stc.o
. . (I...... Q.. OQ 0 ,;:;:' ;::~ ~ :"50 ~ g''''t --= tilai Ei-!. ~:;.
. . = I I.. O\oC ~tI
o
g
J
c
..
Q.
Ot:'"'
~-
QlO'
110 iil
6~
="0'
=0
~ 110
Na
=QI
1lO'l:I
~.~
QI
n
=--
r:
-
DJ
<
-.
(I)
At
:::'
~O
3
m
.
-
...c.....;;;.--...
._ ..Q C
t:i<UCC
"'_ i: 1::0 q)
--......c
- C E -
SjO ""-
Vl u 0 0
... u CIJ
E :J - '"
;.. '" :::
$!:~Oc
;:: ~ ~ ;J')
-'V
o C
- q)
~ g
..c.9
3.23
.Blq
C:=O
"
::r-o
C C
q) <U
l! <II
c.5
!!-=
..
'" q)
~ :=
<U C"
'" ~
---,...
101
It !il ~ liilrS1~ '"
.2 == rtlll:"o-iM Q.(I li -!a
~ = .. .. a =-:1 0'""" ... =- _
"-"=";"0..00".
~_C=_",,=(lcn..c:....)C
O"~COO: a.c~'= C tI_e
.....~o..= ..'&::1=-0
-'=(l=fA::r..c :=
;'2 m -c*OQ ~O~ a'a ~tI
t'D :: 0 ~ _ r::r (I - .., t'D a'''<
r-:I < a;'< _ g.(')Q.5' =r
/IICJl:I:ll"l:l_I>>:r"I>>:!=-rrioO
'e'tAOt'D- ~~..=-a
~ g srq ;~ ~ l!. i. ~ g:r
-cS'll CIItttt c..:-:ctt
fA S'--~*OQ(I"'CII
(;l"aM~Ou:l-tl...-g
c tI_~~-..,o..
~ ~= = Cft._~::.:g-E.-!',
., :,C'00 _:ro ~- :r> i
tI(I(I=O~ lS-OQ'g I
t4 sn ~ a (I _.;- c:T'2 I
;. II: _ c ~. = 8'" bl
(I; =;ra s=.c=a-
- :; ~ O'~ !!. :a ~ 5"
~tt ClI""CII C'I'<=~
-t
Di
'"
..
.
Ao
.
:.c
al
..
'<:I
-
..
S
0'"
..
..
10
!O
..
""
""
..
, .
-~j
:Ii
,;i
.)\
.~ 1
}
.,
.i
)
.i
)
l
.1
J
l
J
1
:;
;f
\
)
) .
"
,
\...J
\
\
~
,
.\
\
\
\-t
I,
...
f
a
_=...... ~,r"..
~.....
:--"--8 -i-:;r ~
.A I; \iJ U
.1 ~ ~ Oli~ ~
:H I ~~.h f__4
}
,
)
I
,
,
I
1;
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chuli:l Vlsti:l Public Libri:lry l.md the City of Chuli:l Visti:l for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighb,'jrhood To insure that the new'
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista PubllC Llbrary and the City of Chula Vista
1) The name of the new' librarv should honor the latino heritage.
.
2) Tho:; new librarv' should orovide bil1nqual and blCultural
serVlces. collections i:lnd events.
31 The new library should hlre bilmgual and blCultural personnel.
.
for kev administratlve oositlOns
.
Name Signature Address Phone
'.
1~:N' P{,~,dd ~du6'~'l~ /~/.-
~. L \.>~~~;""-IL L..,- l It
3
'5
- .
-~- .
4 c
c..\ U~1 +( li-a ()
5 OS/2..Jc..l"-
6 &t11 .
l,
,
7
-,..
~\._~ )III r...
o
(J c.,C C1 r
L./~/YjP~7 ~,' v
~---- ~~;I
8
<>
I
9 ..-"'
J 8#JZ
10.
-\J\ ]() v1
.
L I; ,,':'" (~I/ 111+;3 na ' \ _ ",,'~ v ;,w=-, -.
(flr(oS, ~2~,..jrJt7- _/
15ft - / It'
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
\.
~. ,I
v
)c0~ ?
-
16
17
Ii tn-
e, $hJZh S-li
~~ f L}'
20.__AA '~J~'----1) /l ~
III 0t.Jz..lA. _ _' JlA. q ~c<.M_dQ
I - -
21
fffi~/-f.-w tj'~ I.f~
22 /7", , /0. rr- r-- #'
. '/ ~ 1..t'<-<-"-'~ ~ ( .1+1_~I .:;
-
18
19
23 CJ; 1ft
24
.. .
, ~
_---....-~~ --~ -~... .
_ fY) ~
/5f1- -/11
y\
,
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library., in our neighborhood. To insure that the ne'w
llbrary serves the needs of our commumty, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new library should honor the latino heritage
2) Thf new librarv should providf bil1ngual and bicultural
ser\lJces. collections. <lnd events
3) The neV'i library should hire bilmaual and bicultural personnel,
for kev administrative posltlOns.
.
Name
Sianature
,A,ddress
Phone
1.
(2..Au{.. p,e^ 'ZIl
2. "" ~ '\' -\- '" t.\..
j
~
,
-----
-
'-~l ~.
_ L;,
~
~'-' 6, D
4
to, -'.
tlo'
~ -~....._-=~ ~
5
6
-1-
e.~
w-c.u' 6 u.
o
\.' 'lA
f'VI/\~'::C', ~;-e/-
g...-r /J _
J(/;JAI' /ftr/c;cJt _3
10 / Ii) ~
a~ W-~'~~5i/=~
\. l 1...
(
7
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Ntlme
Si antlture
Address
Phone
...,.~IJ. /
\"' l.t/..j '?:"'){~l;'\
12. \
Cct"-)Id C;,\2Hn(dO~
1~ '\
,)~ - :)1;7. ( I ;
''I; It U-Y1'.~ J n ~ / Y7
'-- I'
14 . / Y',y/ . '
, ,Y VA..{'.;.:;-~''';;~
G :,-, t{lUY,-,' 7.\
.,
( I
I)
~Z'
//
/' r'
1/
- - ~ ~
-~~...~"""""j""'-"
24
'1l:"
.:....J
15A - /13
\)
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are resido:;nts of S.outh Chula Vlsta. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creatmg a
magnificent no:;"N library', in our neighborhood. To insure that the new /)
library serve::; the needs of our community, we solicit the following 7
from the Chula Vlsta Public Library and the City of Chula VistEI:
1) The name of the nev., library should honor the latino heritage.
2) The nev., llbrar\/ should pro\/lde bilmgual and bicultural
services. collectIOns. and events.
3) The neV.l librar"," should rllre bllinaual and bicultural personnel.
.
for kev admmistratwe positlOns
.
Name
Signature
.A.ddress
Phone
'.
e,,-,A h ~QIEJ cQ~\.&~l.\~I,~~
2. /) " ( .
k' I
y' c 1-<. .
... 'I 7 !
, /' /
-;! , e~ 'i..-?..f6-. a ' .~
4/11r\lS~<~ ;/!-~ _.
5'--'\~ ~
0; 1/ \ C" I /
/':{;~~d4JJ<-- "l\., ,)...",,~
6 r/);4~ A
~W'~~r~o
./772 L<--",,- fr1/.x-v _:3
i / ~
/./f7~;; ft-~~ ____
9
,.rLn ,;;Z;J ':zA'.0~,>, If/ _-I '
10 ~ l.h:t"'k~~- il 1 ~
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
C:' t
,~lgna ,ure
Address
Phone
11
15 f\,. i' ;,. c->.c.
1611 ....::-\ \
( \, \ 0-'
. . ~}I/ )\111 L
17 @/nLiAJDo
18 ~,~v Klc-
1 9 'Iv! AO I cO,OJ, ('11 "r'1 ?:Nr=: z
20 Mo^L\..~< y~ nAU........ ~.~ 0 &~Y'
"
21 CD ~
\ ~\ I:\. < .,1",,-1' leU'" t b
'--":>
-
. '1
L<;i "r1...lCL..n
(~ .
.'>l~,.' 7,~ \
12.
<:.... u ~
"::')lLl},tJ
(~'7 L'
13
IJ /'"
j.~_ '-:/ ~f,~_
.1 (rr---
14
~~l,_ (\ \.V \ Lv L\.,-\\ t\.....-
~
' .
'.
\... . V
~
,~
..-a- ,"
_' .. r-'7;
,'" " ..
. '.
~rkJ"~~
23 ) _ i
IYir.yrlJ", ',:" .,),;J1)'. i?1'0>-'~1
?4 J j, 14'~'
- ., .' I/) , i
I , 'II ' I ~
, I',}. 0( f'I ',I ,./:'/2 ,./:; ..' M<.l8..' .
I f
1
22.
;-7;-I.")r'
\
')1::'
,,-__J ~
/ / I
-!.-/ I rJ) 1(i
. Jr..;;.-.
-7
~~"
~. - /', '~~
15ft-115
1\
, )
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Llbrary and the City of Chula Vista for creatmg a
magnificent new library, in our neighbortlood To insure that the new /)
librat'y serves the needs of our community, we SOliClt the following /'
from the Chula \/1sta Public Library and the Clty of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the new library should honor the latino heritaae.
2) The new l1brarv should Pt'ov'ide bllingual and bicultural
serVlces collectlOns. and events.
:,:1 The nev,! library should hlre bllmQual and blcultural personnel,
for kev admimstrative posltions
Name
Sianature
,A,ddress
Phone
,
3
~
d I ;>~ 1//
10',1-,1,,_/1 _
~. lblT<u'ld_ 15A~>;lb .. ~
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
N~me
Si9nature
Address
Phone
20
~~~<Lc }d~Al-? _
12. ~r, (~l~~ /~~ Gl~ _
13 'n; ~uX,-" (j(tr-wJ~ ~~~.1.?
14
11
15
~(
16
Q
'1 ~~-
f?~
'--~
~
17
q(~
-
t I
0? f9--J.-<-rL '
21
~x.41r~.
22. , ri . _
l-Yt.~.;t~~- ~
::?7?~~ P- ~
Rh_~.~
t1J)r<>-~ H~ _
-
,
25
15ft -/Ii-
\..t.
,
Petition (oncerninq the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Lib~ry and the City of Chula Vlsta for creating a
magnificent neV1 lib~ry, in our neighborrlood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our communit')', we SOliClt the following
fl'om the Chula Vlsta Public Library and the Clty of Chula Vlsta:
I) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritage.
.
2) The nelAl l1brarv should providi? bil1ngual and blcultural
services. collectlons and events
3) The neV.i l1brarv should hire bilingual and blcultural personnel.
.
for kev administrative positions
.
Name
Signature
Address
Phone
~
~J:.e ut(-" ~L~U/J ,,' ) ,-
/
vI, FS
~c~a(JP\~n~J(b~-- _
7
8 r;. R ~ A)
.~1-U . 'v~,~._
~~ Ci~'}~
10 }) ~ 1)
'-- ~ /~
- -
/5/t -
-
.~
-
/ /8'
Petition Concernina the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Sianature
.A.ddress
Phone
/
q.
, / ---- / .,1
~~(lj " /u(ro/li,zrc<2/
...
11
13
I
. 7
14
.........
15
17
'.
~
,
~~~X
200 . . Cjl we!
~ ,C
21 /
Ac//&~' E '/9'/r/9~O
.
"S': &/
24
. rut{
~QSC:Z- 6JlLAZ-__
,-
vI
,y(
'7
23
?<:;
~~~
---
15~ - //9
1\
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are resIdents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neIghborhood To insure that the neVi
library' serves the needs of our community, we sol1cit the following
from the Chula Vista Public Librar\1 :md the.Cltv of Chula Vista
, ,
I) The nam<,: of trle ne'N librar"/ srl(,uld honor the latino heritaoe.
.
2) The nev.,.. librar\! should pr'(Jvide bil1ngual and bicultural
serVlces. collections. ::lnd events
3) The new llbrarv should hire bllmoual and bicultural personnel.
.
for Ve\l administratIve positIons
.
l'lame
Signature
6 /7-
71~(hc~!J(7~"'h~
/ ~ .
7 v'
:J:9t" LF~2
{ . .'
~~'\\J~Q C US teQ
9 cf;J /{ (!Al-;;f
10~,,(\cQS CO'l~cj)
15A - I ~
3
,ku
/T '
5 1//1
~V11
4
\
~('7'-?'A'//?V?; <1)
. .-
J [ "
Address
Phone
-
-
,
-
~
{t
o
c/
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
Name Signature Address Phone
I'!>wA~b fll"Ss<"; -f'4afR.~ ~
1;;("(J("e.../r.. !!alMa II10 Y7(iL. ~.euL /t~"//c.ltlaa/lc'
12.
18
q < ~. S'
~
20
21 ~.
A.:._____.....__~_ =~....0liii:I....""_~~..~__"__"
15A - 1;;.../
,;
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula VIsta. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista PublIc Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the ne\'l
lIbrary serves the needs of our commumty, we solIcit the followmg
from the Chula Vista Publ1c LIbrary and the City of Chula VIsta:
1) The name of the new librar'~l should honor trle latino heritaae.
2:1 Tho? new' librar-\," should provide bilingual and bicultural
serVlces, collections, and events.
3) The nell.' librarv stiould hire bilmaual and bicultural personnel.
for kev admimstratlve positions
,
Name
Si<;lnature
.A.ddress
Phone
~J,1'1: ~
~ff tV.: Z
,
lz
4/?}IJR.//J EST/fb€ ,(/lNGld/ 7?a.~ .f~ _y
v
5 0~~' ~e:4 --.L~'~: ~i_--";;"'; ____Ii ~
6
c _. J-."
vj-, I, rt ~~ . r-tJX
7,
~ 4. y; 't .L~ 4 61c.;;
8 ,". /,
t...-t'Y? . / /. j; -T-
"t IF..... e,..,,;-;!:., vI..- t:-- /1...!.- ~ .;. ~..,..,__
/
V
"~~.....~---~
. ~ - , ...
, j
~
9
YJl~
-
-~..
1" i
U. I, ,^ I
~~l' VJ,,~ -
- ., l/ .. -
/) t
II ,;1/ ~ y.,.., )l/~
rt. :.i .".
_~/"7'P"_"
/5,4 - J~.:2
-,- " . 1
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Sianature
Address
Phone
11
1 2. , \ \ '. 0--\
\ O\~~~ ,_b.~\ULtt.,w
1 3 c:;? ,/ _ # ~ c:z::; ,. .0 <
lY> ~~'~~
)v& 0 ~
15 _ I
<..
_5
- -- ~ ----- ..---- ~
'~~:~V~-7r ~C::/'T /71:::r;cr-
(u/qJ
----......
s
/
16
--- -----
-:" I Y"''''' v'."
17.
1~ ,
1 Q ! ~,! .-
:f/yf/7'x ~/./.;A'j ~ .~./~
20 ~" ,/ )
Amt( 0 m~. "
21/ ~ ~ ~
dctc..~' f:(:fl/_"cl. ---;-4' ~.. " 1/ _
.22. I (,' .
(V '. -
23 Jl tfr;J.JA~~
"4 i ~ -
.:. , MLt~ C~/k;>_c1 15
2- t
':>
1511 - IOL3
Petition Concernina the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Llbrar'/ and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent ne'N library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we SOl1Clt the following
from the Chula Vista Publil:; Llbrary and the City of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the new library should honor the latina heritage
2) The ne\N librarv should provide bilingual and blcultural
servIces. collections and events.
~
3) The neVi librarv should hlre bllmgual and bicultural personnel.
,
for kev admmistrative posltlOns
.
Name
Slgnature
Address
Phone
1---6 C'
J ,)C'- oLI.s.Or I u '--')~
2. ^1..-8~?N bJ~;,;D~
3 :-'
~LL4
4 M(J, (.t/w f+v fig
5 l O\J(c"~:r Cask JJClinOJ
-
~
I . _ .... ....... ....
6
J. e:...:. -. ......e.. cP. Go \,~ '\. 'e. <__GS
7 rf2o&~y!o 0.LS J rl ~ 'tc.J
8 [~( I} I- 1--<A (/J-'J 1"I!i '1 c j
9 f... i ~
10 ~6. ~~
;/ 15 A - I d.- t.;
l<. l L L <. L l L/
-~
/ / )
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Sianature
Address
Phone
/1/
'1'\ ' //):_
,It ,~
1.g! i()! 1 ~_,
/,~7?(l J.L. ilL '-
10C;;// "
- H9~k ~~ l~li(}
20
-
" .. - ".- ,.' . '- . .
.
21
22.
23
24
25
1511-/~
\\
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. V.,Ie are very grateful to the
(hula Vista Public Llbrary and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community', we solicit the following
from the Chula Vlsta Publ1c Library and the City of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritage.
,
2) The neVi librar\/ should pr'ovide bil1naual and bicultural
services collections. and events.
3) The new library should hire bil1nyual and bicultural personnel.
.
for key administratlve position::;
.
Name
Sign1lture
,A,ddress
Phone
~l~~\ ~Q~ ~
2. / .
"7 ---/,1,_
fu/"..~l~~ ,...' '
~ I ~
~ '~C>C;o.\\I(\' ~I<"::' ;;/1_
4
10
A
5
6
CJ / t''1U ,'lJ'lp//1! /1' /l
7
8 ~:" ::~
-Lr
9,
15A - I~h
....'
I -7
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
-f);.
_ iO
. . .
17
V'
'q,Q
20
21
22,
23
24
\
25.
/5A: ~ /~::;-
..~;,. ~~ /
-', f
~ .L-
,,/ i
( . !
~.}
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creatmg 1:l
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we SOliClt the following
from the Chula Vlsta Public Library and the Clty of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new library should honor the latino heritage.
2) The new library should proyide bilinaual and bicultural
services. collections. l:lnd events.
3) The new library should hire bilingul:ll and bicultural personnel.
for key administrative positlOns.
,
Name
SignClture
Address
Phone
3.
2.
4...- _
1VCL"'L".)CCl \.J\ll(",'\;VIi~ '__...,
5 OJ1Ao-r S67cs
6
..- ~ ......-,
re(3..'I(:..1. "". t:8U.l ':.
.-
7
n
c::--
8
9
~"!f,
'Jil.':JMJA- 5wE:Tf _
/SA - );;L.g
Petitlon Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Sianature
Address
Phone
11 :' ';;70,'(
I
~
~.
12.
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22.
23
24
25
j,5H - /.,;2. 9
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritage.
.
2) The new librarv should provide bilingual and blcultural
services. collections. and events
3) The new library should hire bilingual and bicultural personnel.
for kev administrative Dositions.
.
Name
Signature
Address
Phone
'-
~ .
5
.,;.oj,___ , 0-
f
4
- .'
~......~.......~... -. ""- ,.
['0
oct
7f],d:t~ ~~d,,-, I
~ 8,-[1 1/1~.
Cr.;;t'LJ",- (~j, '-." . .' . " ....... , ".
9 e.. . ~ - _, ':/
f!1), df' ;f J?tL k-u.L/
v~,
10
~(j
15A - t30
Petition Concernina the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Sianature
Address
Phone
11 ~Y'--< '\.
/I
1 ?::t1{lIJ ;'!j!~_
,.)
(vc~L77
13
"-;7
14 j;OI.H Q~~
15
,-
16
17
1,s
19
20
21
22.
23
24
?C)
~-
15 A - )3/
\
., \
.,
J
Petition (oncerninq the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula \lista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creatmg a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
llbrary serves the needs of our community. we solicit the followmg
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the Clty of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the ne''''' librarv should honor the latino heritage.
,
2:1 Tho:- new' librar\- should provide bilingual and bicultural
ser\llces, collections and events
3) The ne.,.-! l1brarv she.uld hIre bilinaual and bicultural personnel.
,
for ke\/ administratl\/e pOSItions
Name
Sianature
Address
Phone
I / /r 1/
1/
//
/
Uf..t.<-
7
.
4v~ ~
8 rf;B~Lfj ~.-
9 I r
C/2-~ 7/L-
~I ~
151r -/.3~
,
, "
!j
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the neV'i
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the followmg
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new library should honor the latino heritaae.
.
2) The new librarv should provide bilmgual and blcultural
services. collections. i:'lnd events.
3) The ne'vv library should hire bilingual and bicultural personnel,
for kev administrative positions.
.
f\lame
Si gnature
Address
Phone
,
10
/5A -/33
"
\ ~ \
Petition Concerning the New library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chuli:l Vista Public Libri:lry and the City of Chula Vista for crei:lting i:l
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure thi:lt the new
libri:lry serves the needs of our community, we SOllcit the following
from the Chuli:l Visti:l Public Library i:lnd the Citv of Chuli:l Visti:l:
. ,
1) The ni:lme of the new libri:lrv should honor the latino heritaqe
.
2) The ne\'l librarv should provide bilinqual and bicultural
services. collections. i:lnd events.
3) The new librarv should hire bilingual i:lnd bicultural personnel ,
.
for kev administrative positions.
.
Ni:lme
Signature
Address
Phone
2.
~...~,~.'''s.~.___'--__~~ '
'"
-
5 Ghrl~TDp)-e.j- ~,,^j ~
6 . .
~~ Th,,-th',rofh '- _1---' ~
7 cb~ C;/ct/~ _ .......
8
c.. ~. (\\ oofC.
9 ,;
y/ C","c?cY\
tOl.--. '
II ! <). :1
_..... * -~ .
-'
I SA )31
Petition (oncerninq the New Library in South (hula Vista
Name
Sianature
,A.ddress (
Phone
lv
?5C
-
11
12.
fro,"'c.''Jtc A-~v."e..
13
14
15
16
,
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
'"'Ie::
.....J
15ft. ~65
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula VistCl Public Llbrary and the City of Chula Vista for creatmg a
maqnificent new library, in our neighborhood To insure that the new
- '
llbrary serves the needs of our communi tv , we SOl1Clt the following
. .'
from the Chula Vista PubllC Library and the City of Chula \/1sta:
I) The name of the nev./library should honor the latino heritage.
:::::1 The neVi llbrarv should provide bilm]ual and blcultural
serVlces. collections. C1nd events.
3) The new librarv' should hlre bilmgual and bicultural personnel.
for kev admmistratwe positions
.
Name
Sianature
,A.ddress
Phone
,
1 ,~.::?/~,-~
mllJeYlIQ]::, [/;rr,ScC<.. ~
"
L.
(
3
, .
, . , _ . ~ ~. ~.....~ A'~ _ , " "~
~ . ........,. ~ . -^ -~ . ""
t:;"
-' /.c:--
4.Jt:'V /;/....6)
~-
6
g-r-
_L eLl)to.
10
of l} M n-- ;4 1,(/ (.,~ e~.
7
8
/51+ -/30
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
f\Jame
.A.ddress
Phone
11
...,... sc:.-
-
12. /7 J
[,"'1'/0
'~'_~......_~.?...~_",:~,~ ~,c... 4 ~ .<:
7Jl<
"
16 F r ( I
-- (. \.;;( \...) I i'L I fJ2_ ()
17 ,~d(; c: ? _ ~
15 .' L ~ l; r ~. );,( I~ t-{ ~ L
19
20
21
2')
.....
23
24
25
/511 -/3+
Petition Concernina the New library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the nev'llibrarv should honor the latino heritage.
,
2:1 The ne\'l librarv should provide bilingual and bicultural
ser\fJces collections and events.
3) The new' libran/ should hire bilingual and bicultural personnel.
,
for kev administrative positions.
.
Name
Signature
Address
Phone
;tww IbdeiAJ
I:'
..J
FRAIVK ~t=:V1 t.-t...f)
6 :tC~ ~~E.l ~~RA
7 /7) _ _' ;J . .
C ~. L e.-u~;}tfuJ-.Jpv
I
+-:. ;......~
8
9 (
15A
I
\ ~'.
\-
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. Y.fe are very grat.eful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit. the following
from t.he Chula Vista Public Library and t.he Cit.y of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritage.
.
2) The neV'l librarv should provide bilmgual and bicult.ural
services collections elnd events
3) The new librarv should hire bilingual and bicultural oersonne1.
.
for kev administrat.lve Dositions.
.
Name
Si9nature
Address
Phone
1 {~ (1Jbfa,
2. . , .
,/.. .
~<<l.(, -/Yi
,
,
/' .-
,-;,
l,<
..~
_ ~-/' ,,-I. '--:;- , ."7
3
,
.1-
I y'
"", ~I I ,; /4'... _--~c
_A.- _ L. .. \... _ --- '-... _ (
I' -'
1:/ _';. ~ ~J_~
'] . .. .... I
-)~~
~ _..~"' __ - _ {,__~-;:::''' I /.'\ L,L
. - - - ,- -, - -..' ."" '..f /-:; II
4 r-:l ''....f'-
C'll" /1- ,....,,-, r,_~
~'.
'j"
-, ,....
I -,-..' y'- ,.,/"'\' I( \(
___ i ~':: _ ,-,' ~
5 I
..-/" , / ,-..
6
7
8
9
10
I;':~~"I
.... .w;;.
v
I~
l l
I~A
. '--
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborrlood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
t) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritaae.
.
2) The new librarv should provide bilingual and blcultural
services. collections. and events.
3) The new librarv should hire bilinaual and bicultural personnel.
.
for kev administrative positions.
.
Name-
Signature.
~ ,
I
Address
Phone
'.105 t:: 5/lfl/d e'l 1ft
1,...., \ c
~ co~
~ ":k'f1 '1l( C '-<..I! ~iL
It. LfjL~~ .%~tw
..r J.er.l CAct?Z:t -.) /1f
/0;~--Z~ '.
~l__
.
.' ---
7
l
. ..
- - -- --- -. ---
'!II
s.
~Clrrno-nf1A
)CillCL
/514 -If ()
Petition Concerninq the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Signature
Address
Phone
11
12.,.
(ed/a 7;/'.r,....~ .
13
y::- .
14
d~;J//~ 4~t7
15 /
16
~ -
'"" ,,:1-
17 ~tJr'
18
e..~
Pl{\/N
19
20.
21
~
:=J~~ \1~~_
23 - I
24
"1
-.'"4
25
16A,- I'll
\ ,
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Signature
,A,ddress
Phone
l#f1V ;k~~1lI1Ji-7 ;k1 h'7.....r- -. . J . '8
12'-1" )'tk"'~
/~~4 C ~"Le:=I' , "
13
? 0
1 4 ~-\a~b:: ~~No<;
lS-----'\'\,lU\.V-c, (~8'->l.I"t,,-~Y-, _::, ~
16
.. -- --... - --- - ~----;~~~~ -
,
\' ~\..J \'0\ 0... +==to\~-ES.
\ s. I /)
f l?~cE:'/1 tf,;,J 'j; f....
\ C\. ';-' L "
(,_~ ~A?<<'~ J/ I OJ-/! t~,-~
1,0.
~.. -
- ~---- - -~ ~ ~~~--------
-
15fr- /-rJ..-
\
"
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chuli:l Visti:l Public Libri:lry i:lnd the City of Chuli:l Visti:l for crei:lting i:l
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we solicit the following
from the Chula Vista PubllC Library and the City of Chula Vista:,
I) The name of the new library shoukJ honor the latino heritage.
2) The ne'N llbrarv should provide bilingual and blcultural
services. collections ~nd events.
3) The new lib~ary should hir'e bilinaual and bicultural personnel.
for kev administrative positions
.
Name
Signature
Address
Phone
,
JtDR.6..J.)r.) . a
'T" ~11>--.
~~
4
5
7
8
9
.j ~.IZL::/r- /t! U#',d.L~J)u--re...
!5Pr.-/L/3
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
Name
Signature
,A,ddress
Phone
l4..'Ui-U-I_LjL.x~ _
, ;t
13 Q,-~ "J)~,\ ~.t I..JI~J
14 \ . -
-) fdJ. J....
, "'-"Z..-U,
:: 'l'~,L'r,fh:5 ~
~a_
,.
\
19
/T)0ilt/;.v
!J
20
21
22.
.. --------
23
/
.
~I.
)
24
25
~\t,c..,-- ~,d,,- ~
2 (,. {k,.AUtL l:;> V @afJ!J-
(5rt- ~ /1 ~
\
,
Petition (oncerninq the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista. We are very grateful to the
Chula Vlsta Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we SOl1Clt the following
from the Chula Vlsta Public Librar(tmd the Clty of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the new' librarv should honor the latino heritaae.
.
1
2) The new librar\/ should provlde bihnqual and bicultural
serVlces. collections and events
3) The new l1brarv should hire bilmaual and bicultural personnel.
.
for kev administrative P')Sltlons
.
Name
Si9m:lture
Address
Phone
2.
~ '-/
)
4
5
~d.e.vd-
~~
....,/7''>_
,_.
10
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
Name
Si9nature
Address
Phone
15 /.0/
0~e>c<
16 ~ /J )\
. ~1(~~/AJtrP
~ 6' .L~'-~
~'1f - - ,..- ~'lo.
13
14
- -... -. ...-
1
17
~i~~J
18
.
OJ ot1,,~)
19
..
/ Sf!< -I~ &;
'\
\
Petition Concerning the New library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vlsta Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent new library, in our neighborhood. To insure that the new
llbrary serves the needs of our commUn1t'~l, we SOl1Clt the followmg
from the Chula Vista Public Librarv and the Cltv of Chula Vlsta:
.' ,
I) The name of the neV'i librar' should honor t e latino herita e.
2) The new librarv should pt'ovide bilinaual and bicultural
services. collectlOns. and events.
31 The new' librarv should hire bihngual and bicultural oer'sonne1.
.
for kev administratJve positions
.
Name
Sianature
.A.ddress
Phone
~lAW cL:tuu ~
(
"
Uij/(
_II
3
4
__ __ :6:
~
7 ~Cl\j) n.:;.hc.o <> l= Cl!un",J .n......d1':!5
8 \l\lr.i+E.J I <<:... (,..I-l-ME::2~~C'~ _
":>~ \C> P I '-
9. Jf;d ~1n-aA@
10 I
. q ,<<
(l'Jdf/(;V N/c()/~<; &-MUfiJ,~ 15A -IZ-f-r.
~
)
Petition Concerning the New library in South Chula Vista
We are residents of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vlsta Public Librar'/ and the Citv of Chula Vista for creatinq a
.,' .
magnificent nevv library. in our neighborhood To insure that the nev,/
library' serves the needs of our community. we solicit the following
from the Chula VIsta Public Library and the CIty of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new librarv should honor the latino heritaae
.
2:1 The new librarv should orovide bilingual and blcultural
services. collections. and events.
3) The neV.i llbrarv should hire bilingual and bicultural oersonnel.
.
for kev administratwe oositions
.
Name
Sianature
,A.ddress
Phone
fhd;f Pec~fl
2 ' - \~
E "t\<\' C\ \,<?_ b,a"-"""-Q-.\EC-
3
( I'
(9.0/1 utlQ~
5
f ({
6 '~, e -h,c. r 0 Aqvl((f:.
'-.)
7
(
,/
'8
/// "
6JC"
11 ;j I V1J (.-/71-
~ .'
(p,j~ L r
15A - 1'18
I
-_.~
Petition (oncerninq the New Library in South (hula Vista
Name
c; \ GILt r:::>r
11 -
O\ftu,v~ LC
12. (OOY1~" pP,rm v'effS ~L:i .J/'vfY?,U.. ~:17 (j"
13 Cij/l//7taNubfiu' Cd/lluO- kobf.fl...f -
1 4 G:2#CEJ:c! (VI Y :
'J() '/ .t=,C;-' , -' ,C.-L~ & .,d '7
15 r r /" '
, . 1,- (/" :!(jU j"J
16 II
JI\Vl(L
0' /..,! I
17
Lt) 2...- Soft)
18 o1?Z(J/-l .m/8F1'CJ
19 J D '2- So'Tt.-.,
20 A
1tr1.r Ai'[ 0
A
I'
2
24
15ft --/1 ~
Petition Concerning the New Library in South Chula Vista
No:lme
Signature
Address
Phone
11
12. .'.' ~ ~
~~0.-~~~ ~ ~J~
, .
13
,I;~__~b'_'_' (J'Ai"~") A- ~.-1~,- ~
14
15'--70 _
~f7dYUA/'--.J ~/~ . .
16 c.~~vs~e.. \.t,.n.::,\D~r-e.~ _ Ja..
17
o(l.o E. C AiJS:' i S.
--- - . --------
18 .e
1911v!~A/VIfl,;~ _
20 ~ cL.. ACH-~
. ~~~
22. ~ Q",,-,- O--~
23 .J r1-~ r/ oc-J
24
21
719,
/1
__ a:J .
, --
/
25
t(
15ft - IS~
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are resld-:nts of South Chula Vista We are very grateful to the
Chula Vistij Public Library and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
m1:lgnificent new library, in our neighborhood To insure that the new
library serves the needs of our community, we sollclt the following
from the Chula Vista Public Library and the City of Chula Vista:
1) The name of the new library' should honor the latino heritaae
2) The new' library should provide bilmgual and bicultural
5erVlce5. collections. and event5.
3) The new l1brarv should hire bllingual and bicultural personnel
.
for key admmi5trative p05itlons
.
Name
Signature
.A.ddre5s
Phone
"
3
rid
'<< -
I
- ....~.-;;:............~"..,~...~I":.
e).V,
2.
-, -- - . --' , --
4J~
~
5
f'\ '5 u e. I ..}Y' '1 e-{ ~OfJ ',,-)
6 ~JLJ~
7 7J-L-~~--"~C~ /' _
8 /' /J
, . L--'
;::::: -d~//I .4 ",j /V-;:-'
l
,
---~-
9 /
10
~
1511 -
/5tJ
Petition ConcerninQ the New Library in South Chula VistlJ
Name
Signature
11
.
J A f-U/v-€..!{/
12.11'r/ R _
'7:; Jd-n . fJ SS&t1/J.u;!/
.I' " ~ /
13 "\
YI/Dnv?<f 'RD,rSen7>A_/'.p _
14 . /
15
T f"f:i1,J) l.UAh/'/-'S
-
16
17 CU\Lle.'('n'1C>cf~,~) J_
]8~"lV\G"J..'(ft- Kcl-mo.s ~
19 / .. - 'J .s ~/
C1'--UI,~ .k.. l<;nJ110 I~
20 J:} / C
ex n ~, J ~ 1~(1/ /7'~~
21 ~~.:/~<->"" //'.0br.- .~. 7'/4//
22. .( . .~ ,
/J1fr>>)A"~-/f2cl& _
23 /.' / / ) . . /? _ _.- - r
L;tI[~/':r..(i ~:.kj ((il kr-r i .
24 :/ ,/ U ;1
,--/,~~ Ra-n!~
25 ~ _ i/
C . / tJ.
15A ~ I ~l.,
i
/ '
/ :,-
i l
Petition (oncernina the New Library in South (hula Vista
We are residents of South Chula VIsta We are very grateful to the
Chula Vista Public LIbrary and the City of Chula Vista for creating a
magnificent nev.! library, in our n~ghborhood To insure that the ne'.'!
library,' serves the needs of our community, we solicIt the followmg
from the Chula Vista Publ1c LIbrary and the City of Chula Vista:
I) The name of the new librarv should honor trle latino heritage.
.
2) The nev.! librarv should provide bilingual and bicultural
ser'v'lCes. collections. and events.
3) The fie,,! librar\l should hir'e bilingual and bicultural personnel.
.
for kev administrative posltions
.
Name
Signature
.A.ddress
Phone
3
L
~
-~
r~
-
2.
4.
,
)
-
5)\\\ I r \"..." \\.:) f ') ;'\',1;,., :--::l..--,-
6 Te.-yp~o. Z &. """n ""''''1
7 C~ ,s A ('YVIc::J c/=:Jrf .
~ rL /YIol1) '"Y\ a Arre /1 a-no /
a JI -
- S'r, i,' G R Q..,. ~ "' 1) <> b d
10') ._
~~ iv~r&d~./~-i
1614 - I ~~.
COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT
ITEM /..5'g
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
ITEM TITLE: Report on Library Board of Trustees' recommendation
to name the Young Adult Room at the new library for
Arturo Barrios
SUBMITTED BY: Library Director~
REVIEWED BY: City Manager1G),., r (4/5ths Vote: Yes_No-1L)
'if Council Referral # 2863
At the city council meeting of March 1, 1994 the council referred
to the Library Board of Trustees the suggestion that a room or wing
of the library at 389 orange Avenue be named after Olympian Arturo
Barrios. (ATTACHMENT A) At the Library Board of Trustees meeting
of April 27, 1994, the Board discussed the suggestion, indicated
their support, but deferred action until naming guidelines could be
formally developed. Towards that end, the Board requested that
staff research how other libraries handled naming rooms and bring
forward a proposed set of guidelines. (ATTACHMENT B)
At the city Council meeting of May 24, 1994 the council voted to
name the Young Adult collection, the Arturo Barrios Collection,
with the understanding that the Library Board of Trustees'
recommendation regarding the official name of the room would come
later. (ATTACHMENT C) This agenda statement transmits that
recommendation.
RECOMMENDATION: That Council accept the report and name the Young
Adult room after Arturo Barrios.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At the Library Board of Trustees
meeting of September 28, 1994 the Trustees reviewed this criteria
and voted (3-1-1) to adopt points 1 and 2 of the proposed criteria
for naming wings or rooms at the Chula vista Public Library. The
Trustees then voted (4-0-1) to recommend that the Young Adult Room
in the new library be named after Arturo Barrios. (ATTACHMENT D)
DISCUSSION
Library staff research found that few libraries had or were willing
to share an official policy regarding names. However, it is clear
that larger libraries, both public and academic now use name
recognition as one of their primary fund raising tools. For
example, USC reports that at least 50% of a building must be funded
by a donor before their name appears on a building. The San
Francisco Public Library has produced an entire naming prospectus
for their new Central Library which lists various opportunities
ranging from $25,000 to $500,000 donations. San Diego Public
Library also has a name recognition program beginning at the
$10,000 donation level.
In light of the limited information, Library staff recommended the
following proposed criteria for Library Board consideration at
their September 28, 1994 meeting.
/58 - /
!
s
2:;
ITEM 1~J1, PAGE 2
MEETING DATE 10/11/94
policv Proposed to the Librarv Board bv Staff for Namino Winos or
Rooms at the Chula vista Public Librarv
The Library Board of Trustees will recommend to the City
council for its approval that a wing or room at a Chula vista
Public Library facility be named after an individual based on
the fOllowing criteria:
1. A monetary gift to the Chula vista Public Library of at
least $20,000
2.
significant contribution to the
enhancement of the Chula vista Public
City of Chula vista.
development and
Library and/or the
3. significant contribution to the recognition,
representation, or advancement of social issues related
to peoples or communities of Chula vista.
During their September 28, 1994 discussion, the Trustees indicated
their support for Criteria No. 1. A number of Board members
questioned the vagueness of the word "significant" under Criteria
No.2. During discussion, no Board members supported criteria No.
3. A motion to adopt criteria No.1 and No.2 was approved on a
vote of three to one (Donovan, viesca, Clover-Byram voting for,
Alexander voting against and Williams absent. Mr. Alexander
indicated he did not support criteria No.2.)
Based on the accepted criteria, the Trustees then voted 4-0,
Williams absent, to recommend that the Young Adult Room at the new
library be named in honor of Arturo Barrios.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Approximately $500 will be needed to purchase and install an
appropriate plaque. These funds will come from the South Chula
vista ClP LB125 project.
List of Attachments
A.
B.
C.
D.
City Council Minutes, March 1, 1994.
Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, April 27, 1994.
City Council Minutes, May 24, 1994.
Library Board of Trustees' Minutes, September 28, 1994.
/ fa.. ...2-
Cj'~
ATTACHMENT A
Minutes
March J, 1994
Page 11
Vicki Soderquist, Deputy City Clerk, stated if it was includod in a general discussion it would be beldod so that it
would stand out. The minutes would reflect that action was tak~n by common consensus rather than a vote.
Mayor Nader statod it sbouJd state it was amended hy unanimous ronsent.
Council member Horton:
16b. Councilmember Horton stated Arturo Barios had sponsarod a major JOk race in Cbula Vista over the last
several y~rs and the proceeds were invested in the community with most of the funds providing books for children.
She recommended the Library Board and staff consider naming a rOOm or a wing of the library after Mr Barios
as he intended to make o.ula Vista the home of his annual race.
M:SUC (Horton/Nader) to refer the issue of naming a wing or room of the library after Arturo Banos to the
Library Board for CilINderation, to be brought back with their report in the next several weeks.
Councilmemher Rindone:
/16c. Councilmember Rindone stated he wanted to make a referral to staff regarding the four parking spaces in
front of Silvererest Senior Center on Third Avenue. There was a concern that the same vehicles were parking there
all day' long and they were not metered.
'/~6d. Councilmember Rindone statod there was some concern by one of the school districts regarding the need
for resources or haVing to close programs in place for child care services for infants and young children. He
wanted a referral to the Child Care Commission to have them look at interfacing agencies or projects to ensure that
any Current facilities that Were open Were not lost and what funds were available.
../16e. Councilrnember Rindone stated there was concern expressod on the exterior of the new library on 4th and
Orange, i.e. no windows on the corner and what landscaping would be put in. He requestod a one page update on
the item. He felt memos to Council on those three issues would be sufficient unless staff needod Council direction.
~MSUC (Rindone/Nader) to refer !be issue of the parking in front of Silvercrest Senior CentH and the
concerns regarding the library to staf'/'; and refer the concerns by the school district regarding child care to
the Child Care Commission.
vMayor Nader felt it would be open to the Child Care Commission to make a recommendation to be placed on the
agenda if they felt that was appropriate.
16f Councilmember Rindone stated he was concerned with the listings of items for closed session. Many times
the items were not discussed and he requested that the City Attorney indicate, prior to c1osod sessioo, whether there
were any items that did nol oeed to be discussed and have them removod from the agenda. He felt the listing l~
to inappropriate assumptions.
Mayor Nader stated that sometimes the Councilor City Manager wantod to bring an item forward. He suggestod
that the minutes r~nect which items were discussed. That way theTt~ would be a public record available to the media
and public that would clarify the poinr Councilmember Rindone was making and still preserve the ability of
individual Councilmemben to discuss the items that Wer~ on the agenda.
Councilmember RiDdone stated he had no problem .if the City Manager statod an item was not going to be discussed
and a Councilmember indicatod that they wanted to discuss the item. He was concernod that there was not a good
system as to what was being publishod and what was being discussod. I f Council was not going 10 discuss a
particular case it needed to be removod before Council adjournod inlo closod session.
City Attorney Boogaard statod he endorsed and supported identifying the items ah-;ad of time: He could indicate
the ooes that he intended to discuss. The problem ,/SOm::jof the .tems were In a dy:.anuc state of flux. The
ATTACHMENT B
LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
APRIL 27, 1994
vice Chair Donovan suggested that if the plan to
name the young adult room after Arturo Barrios, an
athletic theme for the artwork would be
appropriate.
3. Furniture and Equipment
Director Palmer reported that furniture bids for
the South Chula vista Library have come in under
budget. Principal Librarian, Deborah Barrow
reported that the Purchasing Department received 16
bids, none of which were from Chula Vista vendors.
The bids were divided into seven sections, some
vendors bid complete sections, while others bid
only portions. Library staff has had to carefully
analyzed the bids with the Purchasing Department to
determine the best price. Bids appear to be 12%
under budget.
Staff expects to present bids to the City Council
by mid May. Vendors will have five months to
deliver the furnishings, which coincides with
completion of construction. A few of the bidders
are offering significant discounts depending on if
they get the entire bid or just a portion.
Trustee Williams asked for an updated chart listing
the furnishings bids after staff analysis.
Director Palmer reported that a copy will be sent
to the Trustees as soon as it is available. Mr.
Palmer also asked the Trustees to attend the
Council meeting to support the Library's selection
when this item is presented.
ACTION
B. Names - Arturo Barrios
Director Palmer asked the Trustees to revisit this issue
so that their position could be forwarded to the City
Council.
Because of his contribution to the community, Trustees
considered it appropriate to name the Young Adult Room in
the new library after Arturo Barrios, but were reluctant
to do so until a set of guidelines or criteria was in
place for naming future rooms. It was the consensus that
to name the room without an established criteria in place
would open the Trustees to a barrage of petitioners and
Va,,'!
LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
APRIL 27, 1994
future criticism. Further, to act hastily on this issue
did not seem appropriate considering the extreme care
being taken to select an artist for artwork in the South
Chula vista Library.
MSC (Clover-Byram/Alexander) given current Library Board
sentiment, the Trustees propose that the Young Adults
Room of the new South Chula Vista Library be named the
Arturo Barrios Room at such time that criteria and rules
are in place to guide naming other areas of the new
library. To that end, the Trustees have requested
professional library staff to create proposed guidelines
based on CLA or other libraries. (4-0-1 with Chair Viesca
absent)
Staff is expected to respond to this request by the July
meeting. Trustees asked Director Palmer to report their
action to the City Manager.
ACTION
C. Coffee Cart at civic Center Library
Trustees discussed the concept of having a coffee cart at
the civic Center Library. Other libraries currently
provide this profitable service. The Friends of the
Library are uncertain as to whether they would like to
take on the operation of the coffee cart as it would
require them to file corporate taxes on revenues.
MSC (Clover-Byram/Alexander) that the Library Director
conceptually explore securing a vendor to provide a
coffee cart at the civic Center Library with proceeds
returning to the Library. Trustees further requested
Director Palmer to report the results of his
investigation at a later meeting. (4-0-1 with Chair
Viesca absent).
The Director indicated that he would now explore the
feasibility with city officials.
D. Library Budget
Director Palmer reported that the city Manager has
requested several scenarios for open hours at the civic
Center and South Chula Vista Library for his budget
report to Council. A copy will be forwarded to the
Trustees as soon as it becomes available.
4
/52J-5
ATTACHMENT C
Minutc::s
May 24, 1994
Page 3
Mr. Boogaard stated the agreement allowed the builua to commence construction, but did defer the payment for
sixty days. If the payment was not maue in sixty uays, the City could stop processing any further final maps or
entitlements under the agreement. It did give the builuer the right to pull the building pennits within that sixty day
period.
ORDINANCE 2592 PLACED ON SECOl'.TI READING BY COUNCILME!\IBER FOX, reading of the text
was waived, passed and approved unanimously.
MSUC (Nader/Fox) the implementation of Council's previous direction was drafted to late to be placed on
the agenda and as a matter of urgency, per the City Attorney's recommendation, would be added to the
agenda.
MSUC (FoxlRindone) to approve the agreement with Baldwin Company and authorizing the Mayor to execute
the same.
7 RESOLUTION 17492 APPROPRIATl?'o.G FUNDS FOR LITIGATION EXPENDITURES _
Historically, the City has not budgeted for outside legal professional services in the normal annual budget cycle.
Instead, the City appropriates funds as the need arises on a case by case basis. Previously appropriated funds will
shortly be exhausted and additional appropriation is needed for four cases in order to be able to continue to
effectively represent the City's interest. Staff recommends approval of the resolution. (Assistant City Attorney
Fritch) 4/5th's vote required.
8. RESOLUTION 17493 APPROVL'-G THE TEMPORARY CLOSL'RE OF THIRD AVE!'.'1JE TO
VEHICULAR TRAFFIC BETWEEN "E" STREET Arm DAVIDSON AVENUE ON THURSDAYS
BETWEEN 2:00 P.M. AND 8:00 P.M. FOR A FARMERS' MARKET SPECIAL EVENT, WAIVING
BUSINESS LICENSE FEE FOR THE DOW'\TOWN BUSL"<ESS ASSOCIATION AND VEl'.TIORS
PARTICIPATING IN THE SPECIAL EVE:>-;T, WAIVING L"lITIAL STUDY DEPOSIT (FEE) FOR LONG-
TERM FORMAL STREET CLOSURE - The Downtown Business Association (DBA) proposes to establish a
weekly certified Farmers' Market in the Town Centre I Project area as a special event and requests the closure of
a portion of Third Avenue between "E" Street and Daviuson Avenue on Thursdays between 2:00 p.m. and 8:00
p.m. for a 60-day period commencing on 6/2/94 to accommodate the Market. In addition, the DBA requests that
the City waive business license f~s for the vendors participating in the Market. Staff recommends approval of the
resolution. (Director of Community Development)
9 RESOLUTION 17494 PROCLAIML"iG THE YOUNG ADULT MATERIALS COLLECTION AT
THE SOUTH CHULA VISTA LIBRARY THE "ARTURO BARRIOS COLLECTION" - Council has asked
tbe library to consider naming a wing or room of the new south library after Arturo Barrios. The Library Board
of Trustees has discussed the proposal at two meetings and has deferred action, asking that library staff develop
potential criteria to be:: used when naming a room or wing of a library building. At present, library staff proposes
that the young adult collection at the new library be named in honor of Mr Barrios and that an appropriate plaque
be installed in that an~a. It would not pr~luu~ naming a room or wing aft~r Mr Barrios once criteria has been
developed and approved. Staff r~ommc::nds appro\ al of the n:solulion. (Library Director)
10. RESOLUTION 17495 ACCEPfIl'.G BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACTS FOR THE
PURCHASE OF LIBRARY FURNITURE INCLUDING SHEL VL'iG, CUSTOM CASEWORK, SHELFT ASK
LIGHTING, OFFICE FURNISHINGS, MISCELLANEOUS ACCESSORIES AND INTERIOR SIGNAGE
FOR THE SOUTH CHULA VISTA LIBRARY - Bids t()f furniture and shelving fur the new South Chula Vista
Library were advertised and rdased on 3/2/94 Sixtc::.cn hi us wc::r~ r~i,.':c::iv~u anu opened on 4/5/94 The bids came
in at $176,59779, or approximately 12.8%. unuer biu for a total of $1.200.272.21 The California Library
Construction and Renovation Bond Act provides for reimbursement of 65 % of the related costs. Staff recommends
approval of the resolution. (lnt~rim Finance Directur and Library Dircdor)
/5/1 -?
ATTACHMENT D
DRAFT MINUTES
LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
September 28, 1994
II. CONTINUED MATTERS
ACTION
2.
Report on naming Library Rooms and Wings
During the last Trustee's
Trustees were presented with
criteria to be used in naming
and other items in library.
1. A monetary gift to the Chula vista Public
Library of at least $20,000
2. Significant contribution to the
development and enhancement of the Chula
Vista Public Library and/or the City of
Chula vista.
3. Significant contribution to the
recognition, representation, or
advancement of social issues related to
peoples or communities of Chula Vista.
meeting, the
the following
wings, rooms,
Director Palmer
direction as to
proceed.
asked the Trustees for
how the Library should
vice Chair Clover-Byram supported criteria #1,
stating that the definition of the word
"significant" would be very subjective.
Trustee Alexander also
criteria #2 and #3.
criteria #1 be expanded
than wings and rooms,
etc.
was concerned with
He suggested that
to include items other
e.g. chairs, tables,
Trustee Viesca suggested naming a rooms after
past Library Director, Rosemary Lane, and
Arturo Barrios.
vice Chair Clover-Byram supported criteria #1
and finding a way to deal with other names as
they corne up.
Trustee Alexander supported using criteria #1
for naming wings and rooms and the other
criteria for naming other items.
1>11'7
10/;1/1994 10:03
6195335466
H.R. FRAUENFELDER
PAGE 01
81~05~94 WED \0:41
. ." ~
.
~\1
:, ,1'i fli~
. "......1 .
.
. f: )IF!L~:ER l'nSEP..Ol-/il
Fax'
f -S/11
...
l03D CO.NGItESS
2D S'is...~O~
H.R.~f7b
1/_.... -.,/....... J. ,-Irl",
s..1I."~ AIIHW{ 1-/./,.,
IN TIIE H01.;SE OF REPRESE:s''IATI\''ES
:lr1r. FIJ.~I;~ (for bim~r and }.1.~, SCI1L"'}l;) introd"~M the foao\\.:.ntr bill:
"hicll1lras rei'erred w tht Comnlittee on
-
A BILL
To an\p.ncl the Federal Water pollution Control Act rtllatUig
to San DiG go oceall discharge and \,aste ,_ater reclamation.
1 Be it enacted 'Oy the Senate (l.Yld House of Reprl!$l'llt(l0
2 tiv€$ oft1w United lSta.tes oJ America in ConQft$s Q.!sembled.
3 SEC-TIOS 1. SHORT nTLE.
4 This _~et mav bl! cit.ed ~ the ';Oce~ PollutioTl Re-
o
5 dnctio-Il .Act" .
6 SEC. z. SA..'" nlEGO OCEA" 1>ISCFARGE A..."D W~sn WATER
7 RECLA-~TIOS.
-8 Section S01 (.;) 01: the Federal Water Polhltion Control
9 .Act (33 U.S.C. 1311(j)) is am~uded-
)1 +-1
~,. 1ll!l4IA:UA""..)
~ 10/11/1994 10:03 6
" 19.5335466
~i-G5-g4 WED 18:41
F,' ~1' FIL~Er< ,~'ll "F.R,019
~
1
2
.
"
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2~
Oc.l:tN 5, 19910 (1'44 un,)
H. R. FRALBFELDEP
? L.C.
2
(1) in 'P&r~'aph (1)(A) by iDSel'tIDg b~f()re the
sp.n",iC!olon at the end the following: Ht and ~~cept as
\
pro~ided in pa.l'a:;rapb. (5)"i l.lud
(2) bJ~ e.dcliDg lilt. tbe end the foUomng new
pa.t~ph:
"(5) E:aE~S10:S 0:10' .1PPUCA'1'10:S PEADLI~"E.-
"(A) N G'F.~'r;RAL.-.ln the 180-day period
beginnini OIl !.he date of the enactment oi this
para!l:raph, \.he city of San Diego, California,
ma~. app1.v for ~ xuQdificll.tion pursuant to sub-
se<:tion (h) or tho. raquirenlent$ of subsli!<:timl
(b)(l)(B) mth re$!'ect t.o biological o~-gp.n de-
nlalll\ and t.otal suspended solids in the effluent
c'Uschar~d Into marine water<>.
:'(D) .-\P:r'UCATIO~.-An applicl1tion under
this paragraph sho.ll ~<:lude 1\ ClonunitJr.~nt by
the applicant w i:nplelnent a \'rlIStt.\ '\T1ITP.l' ree.
lamatioXl program that, at a 7"inimum, ",ill-
Uti) achit,'e a s>"Sum ca.padty of
45,000,000. :allons of reclaimed ,~a.ste
\\"ateT' per da~'~' Je.nulU'Y 1, 2010;
"(ii) result in a reduatiou in the quan.
t.ity of suspended solids discharged by the
appliCa.Ilt iXlto the marine en,"iromnent dur-
in!! the period of the nlodification,
11,~
PAGE 02
t,
.
10/11/1994 10:03
- #-- . . .,
... .-
6195335466
.-
H. R. FRAUENFELDER
OCi-CS-34 ~ED 10:42
F: ,;\1 l'lLSIi:\l. .Flt!'ER.019
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
!'l.Le.
.:
.:
3
"(0) .Ar>Dl'rl0~.\L O(")~-ol'l'10,,s.-The Ad-
n~nistl'a.tOr nlll~' nnt grallt a modifi{'a,tim;l pur-
suant to an applh:ation submitted under this
par~..graph unless the AdmWililra.tor deter.nine$
that such modification "ill result in rCll'l,I)'\'lU /',If
not less than 68 percent of the bioloiical o:cy-
gen demand (on an RJmual 9:9'erair:) and not
less thAn 80 pel'c..nt of total suspended solids
(on a montbl~' ayerll$;e) in the wl:lebarge to
-.rbich tht: cLlJplication a.1Jplies.
"(D) PREJ.,t:'II~.AJlY PECliOIO~ P:sAD.
LI~.-The .~drninistrator Ilball aDllO'\l,.T;ee a
pr&li.minlu~T deaision on all application submit.
t,<,d under this paraifa.ph not later thl\n 1 )'ear
after the date thtll1Wlica.tion is l;~bmitttd.".
. )7;3
r~~ ~ t...tt.4&~.ft\.l
PAGE 03
~'. G4.'r:~