Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutcc min 1986/01/21 MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA Tuesday, January 21, 1986 Council Chamber 7:00 p.m. Public Services Building ROLL CALL MEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor Cox; Councilmembers McCandliss, Scott, Moore, Malcolm MEMBERS ABSENT: None STAFF PRESENT: City Manager Goss, City Attorney Harron, Assistant City Manager Asmus PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG, SILENT PRAYER The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. was led by Mayor Cox, followed by a moment of silent prayer. 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES for the meeting of January 14, 1986. MSUC (Moore/McCandliss) to approve the minutes. 2. SPECIAL ORDERS OF THE DAY a. STATE OF THE CITY ADDRESS ~ Mayor Cox The State of the City Address was delivered by Mayor Gregory R. Cox. 3. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS a. REQUEST FOR RESOLUTION SUPPORTING HR 864 AND SB 1446 AND SUPPORTING LEGISLATION TO ESTABLISH A P.O.W. COMMISSION IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA American Ex-Prisoners of War, Department of California, State Department of Public Relations, Dixie Lee Lessman, 2553 Coronation Drive, Union City, CA 94587 Mrs. Lessman requested the Council adopt a resolution in support of HR864 and SB1446 establishing a P.O.W. Commission in California. MSUC (McCandliss/Scott) to refer this to the Legislative Committee. MINUTES 2 - January 21, 1986 b. CLAIMS AGAINST THE CITY: 1. Abel Flores, 3955 Marcwade Drive, San Diego 92154 2. Randy & Cynthia Majewski, 1380 Mesa Grande Place, Chula Vista 92010 3. Peter John Cooper, 5757 College Ave., San Diego 92120 4. Evergreen Helicopters Inc., 3850 Three Mile Lane, McMinnville, Oregon 97128 5. Gilbert Chris Beahan, 327 Quail Place, Chula Vista 92011 Claims were filed against the City for the following: a pedestrian accident at Palomar Street near Second Avenue resulting in a wrongful death; injuries suffered in a car accident at the intersection of Valley Road and Via San Miguel Road; an alleged vehicular accident in National City; a vehicle collision with a Life Flight helicopter display; and an auto accident between Third and Fourth Avenues on Orange Avenue. MSUC (Moore/McCandliss) reject the claims. c. PROPOSAL FOR BOWLING CENTER ON PROPERTY ADJOINING CITY GOLF COURSE - Harold S. Elkan, President, Sports Arenas, Inc., 5230 Carrol Canyon Road, Ste. 310, San Diego 92121 Mr. Elkan requested the Council consider a proposal regarding the relocation of the existing Cabrillo Lanes to the property adjoining the Chula Vista Municipal Golf Course. The City Council deferred action on this and any proposals for this property until after a lease was executed with American Golf regarding the operation of the restaurant. Therefore, it was recommended this letter be acknowledged and received. Councilman Malcolm remarked this use would be a good addition to the community because it is family-oriented. Therefore, he stated he was not in favor of staff's recommendation and suggested a more careful review of the proposal be done. City Manager Goss reported staff is reviewing the parking situation in this area. MSUC (McCandliss/Malcolm) to acknowledge receipt of this letter and explain (to Sports Arenas, Inc.) what is going on. d. CONCERNS REGARDING RV'S PARKED ON PRIVATE PROPERTY - Mary I. Helvie, 301 Nocturne Court, Chula Vista 92011 Ms. Helvie expressed concern that RVS are included in the same category as "junk" vehicles parked on private property. When the Montgomery Planning Committee study on this subject is provided to Council for action, she suggested the community's input also be considered. MINUTES 3 January 21, 1986 The City Manager recommended this letter be acknowledged and that Ms. Helvie be notified when the Community Appearance Ordinance comes before the Montgomery Planning Committee, the Planning Commission, and the City Council. MSUC (Malcolm/Scott) accept the staff recommendation. e. REQUEST FOR MEMBERSHIP IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA WATER COMMITTEE, INC. Susan Golding, Supervisor, 3rd District, County of San Diego, 1600 Pacific Hyw. San Diego 92101 The Southern California Water Committee, Inc. (SCWC) was created to educate the public concerning existing water supplies. Supervisor Golding requested the City Council consider a resolution approving membership in SCWC. MSUC (Malcolm/Scott) to refer this to staff for report. PUBLIC HEARINGS AND RELATED RESOLUTIONS & ORDINANCES 4. PUBLIC HEARING EASTLAKE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 RESOLUTION 12335 ORDERING IMPROVEMENTS, FORMING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT AND CONFIRMING DIAGRAM AND ASSESSMENT (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) This being the time and place as advertised, Mayor Cox declared the public hearing open. In his written report, Director of Public Works/City Engineer Lippitt explained that on December 17, 1985, Council initiated the proceedings to establish a Maintenance District under the provisions of the "LandsCaping and Lighting Act Of 1972" of the State's Streets and Highways Code. The establishment of a maintenance district under the "1972 Act" will allow the annual consideration by Council of the assessment of costs for maintaining landscaped medians, streets and supplemental lighting to benefitting property owners. In answer to Councilman Moore's question, Director Lippitt stated all improvements to the median islands for decorative paving will be paid for by the developer. There being no public testimony, either for or against, the public hearing was closed. Director Lippitt, in response to Councilman Malcolm's concern, stated the only assessment districts proposed are for this item and the district providing water and sewer improvements. MINUTES - 4 - January 21, 1986 RESOLUTION OFFERED BY COUNCILMAN SCOTT, the reading of the text was waived by unanimous consent, passed and approved unanimously. 5. PUBLIC HEARING BAY HOSPITAL PROPOSAL TO LEASE AND SELL FACILITY (Community Development Director) Councilman Scott noted since his employer, Merrill-Lynch, is involved in this item, he would refrain from discussions due to a possible conflict of interest. Councilman Malcolm stated he has a relative who is employed by the hospital, and he will abstain from this item as well. Councilmen Scott and Malcolm left the dais at this time. This being the time and place, Mayor Cox declared the public hearing open. On January 14, 1986, the City Council was apprised of the proposal by Bay Hospital to restructure its indebtedness and transfer operation from a non-profit to a for-profit entity with the City involvement due to its position as sponsor of the outstanding bonds. City Manager Goss explained on behalf of the City, consultants have been contacted and documents have been forwarded to staff by the hospital for review. While the issue is time-sensitive and it is requested by Bay Medical Center that resolution of the issues be determined by the end of this month, he recommended that, to deal with the number of complicated issues raised by the 'proposal, this matter be placed on the Council Conference agenda scheduled for Thursday, January 23, at 4 p.m. The City Manager noted additional information was provided immediately before this evening's meeting which includes the project description of improvements to the hospital if the lease is completed, news article refuting operation costs of non-profit vs. for-profit hospitals, and reactions to the following six conditions of approval: (a) The defeasance should unequivocably assure the City that there are no outstanding debts against the hospital that could relate to City sponsorship. (b) The City should be indemnified from any actions relating to the proposal of Bay Hospital and/or of National Medical Enterprises (NME). MINUTES - 5 - January 21, 1986 c The City should not be liable, in any manner, for its legal ownership of the facility and its lease back to the Owning Board and sublease to NME. d The City's reversionary interest should be returned to the community through an indigent care program. The management of the indigent care program, while under the sponsorship of the Owning Board, should have community input and, therefore, it is proposed that the City appoint at least one member of a five-person overseeing board for indigent care. e The City should be reimbursed for out-of-pocket expenses and for lost property taxes during the period of time the hospital was off the tax rolls. The amount plus interest is calculated at $237,828. (f That, in concept, free information services be provided from the Health Information Center portion of the non-profit corporation to the City for such activities as support for senior programs, employee education, etc. Councilwoman McCandliss asked that a representative of the hospital as well as bond counsel be present on Thursday afternoon. Mr. Mickey Rabuka, President, Paradise Valley Hospital, suggested this issue be evaluated by an unbiased, independent expert before the Council takes action to defease the bonds. There being no further public testimony, either for or against, the public hearing was declared closed. MS (Cox/McCandliss) to continue the public hearing to the Council Conference on Thursday, January 23, 1986 at 4:00 p.m. Councilwoman McCandliss questioned the tax-exempt status of the bonds in the event the hospital is sub-leased to NME. In response, Community Development Director Desrochers clarified the defeasance process as the method in which present bonds can be paid along the schedule stated in the perspectus. Mr. Robert Larsen, representing Bay Medical Center, explained if anyone other than the City defeases the bonds, they become taxable. Bond purchasers obtained bonds with the understanding that they were tax-exempt and if the bonds were paid off, a 4% penalty of the capital amount would be required. If the bonds were paid in full, then the title immediately passes to the City. The question still remains as to who would run the hospital. If nothing is done, the bonds would be called in Year 2010. MINUTES 6 January 21, 1986 In answer to Councilwoman McCandliss' question, City Attorney Harron clarified the lease purely addresses the 35-year term, and the sale of the hospital would supersede the lease. The motion to continue this item passed by the following vote: AYES: Cox, McCandliss, Moore NOES: None ABSTENTIONS: Scott, Malcolm Councilmen Scott and Malcolm returned to the dais. 6. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS None. CONSENT CALENDAR (7 - 15) (Items 9a, b, c, 12, 13, and 14 pulled.) MSUC (Cox/Malcolm) to approve the Consent Calendar. 7. RESOLUTION 12336 APPROVING THE REFUND OF BICYCLE FACILITY (TRANSPORTATION DEVELOPMENT ACT) FUND BALANCES (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) In the past, the City obtained Transportation Development Act (TDA) funds from SANDAG to build bicycle facilities in the City. Two projects have recently been completed at a cost savings and balances should be refunded to SANDAG so that the monies can be allocated to other projects in the Region. The refund of bicycle facilities (TDA) fund balances are as follows: a. Claim 108 Account No. 602-6020-LT02 $9,062.32 b. Claim 139 Account No. 602-6020-LTF05 250.77 TOTAL $9,313.09 Councilman Malcolm questioned why the money had to be returned instead of being used for the Bayfront. In response, Director Lippitt stated if the funds are not expended, they must be returned to SANDAG. He noted $5,000 is currently in the signing program for the Bayfront which will come out of these funds. MINUTES 7 January 21, 1986 8. RESOLUTION 12337 APPROVING AND GRANTING EASEMENT TO PACIFIC BELL IN LOT 200 OF BONITA LONG CANYON ESTATES, UNIT 1, CV TRACT NO. 81-4 AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE SAID GRANT OF EASEMENT (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) On April 16, 1985, the City Council approved the Final Subdivision Map of Bonita Long Canyon Estates, Unit 1 by Resolution 11993. A proposed grant of easement to Pacific Bell for underground telephone purposes is now before the City Council for approval. 9a. RESOLUTION CERTIFYING THE TELEGRAPH CANYON CREEK IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 15221 OF THE STATE CEQA GUIDELINES (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) b. RESOLUTION APPROVING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA AND THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO FOR REAL PROPERTY ACQUISITION SERVICES AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE SAID AGREEMENT (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) c. RESOLUTION ACCEPTING 16 DRAINAGE EASEMENTS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF TELEGRAPH CANYON CREEK FLOOD CONTROL CHANNEL (Pulled from Consent Calendar.) 10. RESOLUTION 12339 APPROVING HOUSING COOPERATION AGREEMENT WITH FINANCIAL SCENE, INC. FOR AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING UNITS (Community Development Director) On January 8, 1985, the City Council established in Resolution No. 11895, as a condition of approval of the Beacon Cove residential project on East "H" Street in the Terra Nova Subdivision, a requirement that an agreement be entered into between the City and Financial Scene, Inc., the owner/developer, providing for the delivery and maintenance of 20% of the dwelling units of the project for occupancy by low income households for ten years. The delivery and maintenance of those units is intended to partly satisfy the affordable housing obligation of the entire Terra Nova Subdivision. MINUTES - 8 - January 21, 1986 11. RESOLUTION 12338 APPROVING THE STREET NAMES FOR THE BAYFRONT'S MAJOR STREETS (Community Development Director) The Redevelopment Agency requested new street names be considered for the Bayfront Redevelopment Project Area reflecting the changes in land use and character proposed under current plans. On September 19, 1985, the Redevelopment Agency approved the proposed street names for the Bayfront Area with the exception that "F" Street was proposed to be named Lagoon Drive. Funds for this program (~115,000) are to be encumbered in the 1986-87 City budget. 12. REPORT COMPARISON OF RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR LAUDERBACH COMMUNITY CENTER AND CITY RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING CITY RECREATION FACILITIES (Director of Parks & Recreation) RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION #11309 REGARDING THE RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING USE PERMITS FOR THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PARKS AND RECREATION FACILITIES TO INCLUDE THE LAUDERBACH COMMUNITY CENTER ( Director of Parks & Recreation) (Pulled from Consent Calendar.) 13. REPORT REGARDING GUIDELINES TO DEFINE AND REGULATE REMODELS VERSUS NEW CONSTRUCTION (Director Of Planning) (Pulled from Consent Calendar.) 14. REPORT "GUEST HOUSE" REGULATION OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE PCA-86-3 (Director of Planning) (Pulled from Consent Calendar.) 15. REPORT REGARDING RAILROAD CROSSING AT "E" STREET/I-5 AND "L" STREET/I-5 (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) On October 24, 1984, the City Council directed staff to investigate the possible upgrading of the railroad crossings at "E" and "L" Streets; specifically, the removal of the wooden planks and "the installation of concrete or some other material." END OF CONSENT CALENDAR MINUTES - 9 - January 21, 1986 At this time, Mayor Cox introduced and welcomed Mr. George Scott to the Council meeting. 9a. RESOLUTION 12340 CERTIFYING THE TELEGRAPH CANYON CREEK IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 15221 OF THE STATE CEQA GUIDELINES (Director of Public Works/City Engineer) b. RESOLUTION 12341 APPROVING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA AND THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO FOR REAL PROPERTY ACQUISITION SERVICES AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE SAID AGREEMENT (Director Of Public Works/City Engineer) c. RESOLUTION 12342 ACCEPTING 16 DRAINAGE EASEMENTS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF TELEGRAPH CANYON CREEK FLOOD CONTROL CHANNEL On January 1, 1986, the Montgomery area annexation officially became effective and the City of Chula Vista assumed the entire responsibility for the construction of the Telegraph Canyon Creek Flood Control Project. Prior to the annexation, the County of San Diego was the lead agency for this project and was responsible for the right-of-way acquisition proceedings. The County of San Diego has been requested to continue acquiring 39 rights-of-way on the City's behalf. acquisition cost is estimated to be about $676,200. Funds have been budgeted ($2,313,400) which can be used to cover the entire right-of-way acquisition cost. The City needs to fund another $2,386,600 to cover the entire estimated Chula Vista share of the project cost. In answer to Councilman Moore's question, Director Lippitt explained until approval is received from the Corps of Engineering, the project is uncertain. City Attorney Harron elaborated that if the City does not receive the dedication, public hearings would have to be advertised and perhaps, even commitment to eminent domain made. Discussion followed concerning the law requiring full appraisal value offered to property owners in projects such as these and formation of an assessment district for such improvements to property. MINUTES 10 - January 21, 1986 Director Lippitt stated the project could be delayed three years if assessment district formation procedures were begun. He noted right-of-way and utility relocation costs (approximately ~750,000) are reimbursed by the Department of Water Resources. RESOLUTION OFFERED BY COUNCILWOMAN MCCANDLISS, the reading of the text' was waived by unanimous consent, passed and approved unanimously. 12. REPORT COMPARISON OF RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR LAUDERBACH COMMUNITY CENTER AND CITY RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING CITY RECREATION FACILITIES (Director of Parks & Recreation) RESOLUTION 12343 AMENDING RESOLUTION #11309 REGARDING THE RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING USE PERMITS FOR THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PARKS AND RECREATION FACILITIES TO INCLUDE THE LAUDERBACH COMMUNITY CENTER ( Director of Parks & Recreation) Director of Parks & Recreation Mollinedo reported that on December 31, 1985, the City assumed the responsibility of administering and operating the Lauderbach Community Center. Since their existing Rules and Regulations are in conflict with the City's policy, an amendment to the City's Rules and Regulations governing the Use Permits for Parks and Recreation facilities is necessary to include the Lauderbach Community Center. Councilwoman McCandliss commented that income tax services are provided by volunteers through the Lauderbach Community Center. A determination for the City to charge for such services should be contingent upon the existing fees charged, if any. RESOLUTION OFFERED BY COUNCILWOMAN McCANDLISS, the reading of the text was waived by unanimous consent, passed and approved unanimously. Mayor Cox noted a conflict of interest with Item 10 (Housing Cooperation Agreement with Financial Scene, Inc.) because he is a stockholder with Great American Savings (parent company of Financial Scene). Therefore, he requested reconsideration of this item. MSUC (Cox/Malcolm) Council reconsider action taken on Item 10. (Mayor Cox left the dais at this time.) MINUTES - 11 - January 21, 1986 10. RESOLUTION 12339 APPROVING HOUSING COOPERATION AGREEMENT WITH FINANCIAL SCENE, INC. FOR AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING UNITS (Community Development Director) RESOLUTION OFFERED BY COUNCILWOMAN MCCANDLISS, the reading of the text was waived by unanimous consent, passed and approved (Mayor Cox abstained). (Mayor Cox returned to the dais.) 13. REPORT REGARDING GUIDELINES TO DEFINE AND REGULATE REMODELS VERSUS NEW CONSTRUCTION (Director of Planning) In response to a Planning staff report regarding the remodeling of a single-family residence on Country Club Drive, the City Council in May of 1985 requested that the Planning Department: 1. Review existing City ordinances regarding remodel standards and return with a report and recommendations for possible revisions to the Municipal Code including a clarification as to when remodeling becomes new construction. 2. Review other changes regarding lot coverage, setbacks, and height limitations. The recommendation was that Council direct the Planning Department to proceed with draft ordinances for Planning Commission consideration. In response to Councilman Moore's question, Director of Planning Krempl explained any building addition which would increase the property by 15% or greater would be subject to all current City guidelines. MSUC (Moore/Scott) to accept staff recommendation. 14. REPORT "GUEST HOUSE" REGULATION OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE PCA-86-3 (Director of Planning) On April 11, 1985, the City Council requested that staff look into the City's "Guest House" regulations with a view toward strengthening the standards if necessary. It was recommended Council direct staff to prepare an amendment to the Guest House provisions of the Municipal Code with a referral to the Planning Commission and the Montgomery Planning Committee. Specifically, the amendment would be to delete from the R-1 and R-2 zones the opportunity to construct a guest house unless the MINUTES - 12 - January 21, 1986 lot size exceeds 10,000 sq. ft. and retain in the A and R-E zones. Also the occupancy restriction would be strengthened from the present "occasional use" limit to one that would restrict occupancy for any one guest to no more than 60 days per year. In response to Councilman Scott's question, Director Krempl indicated requiring a Conditional Use Permit for a "Guest House' could be viewed as a viable option. MSUC (Scott/Moore) to refer this to the Planning Commission (and the Montgomery Planning Committee)--the possibility of a Conditional Use Permit also to be reviewed at the same time as an amendment to the rules and regulations. OTHER RESOLUTIONS AND RELATED MATTERS 16. RESOLUTION 12344 APPROPRIATING FUNDS FOR THE WATER FEATURE AT THE WEST END OF THE LIBRARY (Director of Planning) On January 14, 1986, the City Council approved Proposal "B" for a cascading water feature at the Library. It is necessary to appropriate ~56,340 for its construction. Funds for the construction cost are available in the following funds: Library Construction ~9,142, Special Capital Outlay - ~23,000, Revenue Sharing Contingency - ~14,000, California Library Service - $10,198. RESOLUTION OFFERED BY COUNCILMAN SCOTT, the reading of the text was waived by unanimous consent, passed and approved (Councilwoman McCandliss opposed). MSUC (Scott/McCandliss) to designate the Library Water Feature as the official 10-year Library anniversary project and the City's official 75th anniversary project. 17. REPORT OF THE CITY MANAGER a. REPORT ON CITY'S UNDERGROUND UTILITY ALLOCATION City Manager Goss reported that annually, SDG&E advises the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) of the underground allocation per its franchise agreement with the City. The letter recommending to the CPUC that the City of Chula Vista's allocation for 1986 be ~662,748 is in error. MINUTES - 13 - January 21, 1986 He requested authorization to send a letter to the California Public Utilities Commission and SDG&E advising them of the error made in calculating the City's underground utility allocation, and that the City, through its Council Committee, continue to discuss with SDG&E a possible waiver of the City's franchise as it pertains to the formula for determining funds for undergrounding utilities. City Manager Goss referred to an informational item pertaining to this calculated City underground utility allocation. He noted that the calculation also did not reflect the reduction to the City's total allocation due to the recent Montgomery annexation. MSUC (McCandliss/Scott) accept the staff recommendation on 17a and appendix "b" (recalculation of allocation due to newly annexed area). b. City Manager Goss requested Council input regarding the order of the agenda for the Council Conference this Thursday since the Bay Hospital item has been added. It was the Council consensus to docket Bay Hospital as the last item on the agenda. 18. MAYOR'S REPORT - None. 19. COUNCIL COMMENTS a. All Councilmembers complimented the Mayor on his State of the City message. b. Councilman Scott suggested the SDG&E plant located on Bay Boulevard be painted bright red, blue and yellow giving it a "high-tech statement." MSUC (Scott/Cox) to ask the City's sub-committee to bring this up with SDG&E. c. Councilwoman McCandliss questioned the status of the non-complying home on Oleander (owned by Mr. Wheeler). MSUC (Malcolm/McCandliss) to obtain a staff report. d. Councilman Malcolm discussed the financial comeback of Rohr Industries noting the increase in their stocks. e. Councilman Malcolm mentioned Congressman Bates' latest move to legalize drugs. f. Councilman Malcolm discussed Senate Bill 1254 (unfair labor relations) which is before the Senate Appropriations Committee. MSUC (Scott/Moore) to oppose SB1254. MINUTES - 14 - January 21, 1986 g. Councilman Moore reported on the 75th Anniversary commemorative medallion. In order to get the best price, the Committee will order 500 medallions and have recommended the City purchase an additional 500 as well. The total cost will be $7,125. MS (Moore/Scott) for the Council to purchase 500 medallions in conjunction with the 75th Diamond Anniversary for ~7,125 which includes four different packaged medallions (tax and shipping included) to be utilized as the official City gift. Councilman Scott stated he would rather support a resolution to be brought back for this item. SUBSTITUTE MOTION MSUC (Moore/Scott) for staff to bring back a resolution for the purchase (of medallions). h. Councilman Moore noted that 2,000 paperback and 250 hard-cover Heritage books have been ordered in conjunction with the City's 75th Anniversary which should arrive prior to March 2, 1986 (premier celebration). i. MSUC (Cox/Scott) for a Closed Sesson (at the end of the business meeting) for pending litigation (Sierra Club vs. Coastal Commission) and discussions on the Section 404 Permit. The Council recessed to Closed Session at 9:52 p.m. ADJOURNMENT AT 9:40 p.m. to the Council Conference on Thursday, January 23, 1986 at 4 p.m. and to the Council Tour of the City scheduled for Saturday, January 25, 1986 at 2:00 p.m. (joint meeting and tour of the City with Planning Commission and Design Review Committee) Adele A. Deputy City Clerk 0724C/ak