The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutReso 1984-11757 RESOLUTION NO. 11757 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA APPROVING THE PROPOSAL BY THE SAN DIEGO COUNTRY CLUB TO REDESIGNATE ABOUT 6.00 ACRES OF LAND, LOCATED ON THE NORTHERLY SIDE OF NAPLES STREET, WESTERLY OF CORTE MARIA AVENUE, FRa.! "PARKS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE" TO "MEDIUM RESIDENTIAL" ON THE GENERAL PlAN DIAGRAM The City Council of the City of Chula Vista does hereby resolve as follows: WHEREAS, the tion of six acres residential use, and San Diego Country Club proposes the alloca- of its 150-acre site to medium density WHEREAS, two of the involved six acres of land are within the City of Chula Vista, and WHEREAS, the remaining land is in the unincorporated area of the County and thus requires prezoning and subsequent annexa- tion, and WHEREAS, EIR-84-7 on this project has been reviewed and the information considered, and it has been prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act of 1970, as amended, and the California Administrative Code and the Environmental Review Policy of the City of Chula Vista, and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission at their meeting of August 22, 1984 recommended approval of said proposal. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Chula Vista does hereby approve the proposal by the San Diego Country Club to redesignate about 6.00 acres of land, located on the northerly side of Naples Street, westerly of Corte Maria Avenue, from "Parks and Public Open Space" to "Medium Residential" on the General Plan Diagram. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council does hereby certify that EIR-84-7 has been prepared in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act and the Environmental Proce- dures of the City of Chula Vista and the Council has considered the information in this document as they reached a decision on the project. Presented by Approved as to form by '!!:;7K:I:m~ector Planning of aÁÆ.G.2f~ Thomas J. Harron, City / v Attorney ADOPTED AND APPROVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, this 11th day of September -- 19 84 ,by the following vote, to_it: AYES: NAYES: ABSTAIN: ABSENT: Councilmen Scott, Moore, Cox, McCandliss Councilmen None Cou1cilmen Malcolm Councilmen None {l.c" e City of Chura Vista STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO ) s s. CITY OF CHULA VISTA ) I, JENNIE M. FULASZ, CMC, CITY CLERK of the City of Chula Vista, California, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the above and foregoing is a full, true and correct copy of RESOLUTION NO. 11757 ,and that the same has not been amended or repealed. DATED City Clerk ( sea) CC-660 i ::~:::~:?~/(7 ·:~:~~~:::?:\~á....<i!iU¡: ......,............... ....................... ...... ::. !!UT!t!/!!!H E!!hfí1ii:nJmw·~;~·;::::: :: ~..-.:....,..........r... .::::::: .::::::: .. . ...... ·..·....·~f'· ....... ¡¡ )IfY~{UÜ~:T iTU ::::: .. .:::::::::::2};::' ,,,,,,,·f.·f.;:::::::::::::::::: t::::::::::/iit¡¡ib'J<:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: . ~ :::::::::::::::::;::::::::::... '~( ..................... i'äj............................ ···..···..¡¡¡i1'··'¡¡·..·....··..··......·..··......····· ,.. ~ ......... ... ............... i!!!!!!!!!!!!.~¡~:~!~1m!!!!!!!!!!!m!!!!!! : !!¡¡¡¡~~~~F:!:Rß~~Þ,~t,gm!ll:~;?~~,~·. ..~ ~ mmm!!!¡¡!!!¡!!¡!¡¡¡mm¡¡~j~: ...........-...., ................ ·-11!;;;................................... ...... ... .... . ...........-.. - ~ wiiilli.·w·}jggm~t: ::::..:mm '~~,8!~~.·;~Pr~.ç~rr;/:r:::~g ~~mmm~~gm~:~m~mm~~ gmm~ggggg' :~~; v/.....................,................. . .......... ,. ··r'·G'·.,· . ,·:.r ...... -·..·PROPOSED· MED .............. ..... '" :;;::::.:~:::~:~:.,;;:::::::::::: ;þ::::...... ,.. -0 01" r....r..- r ~ if"" t.'::::: . ... :::::::::::::: ... .. .. . "'...,................ ·<....1 """'r r ·...F - r r, r '-' ...... ... . .............. ................ . ........................ . .... '" "".f" c·· Co r rr " rc....· "'DENSIIY Rr-Slp.l............... ................. ......................... .f71.... ......... Sou - . I.J. - ,'. ..."r ...... _ ....... I ,... ............... ::::::::::::::::: .:::::::::::::::::::::::.... ::::::: .~/::::::::: :.~ ~J"",. '/¡s . -,." .::::" '~::::::"""h_ 'n ...........~... _0 ::::::::::::::: -'~..n...... d~-"~" <...-. ..n_m··"'f,mn :¡iiiii¡mi~' =;;~;;~!~;i~~~¡;:~~~~~~~;;~:¡ii~;~:ij¡'¡¡¡¡,'¡:!~ ~ r~ I'·············,······,··~ . .......... -.....Thoro fare Com I ~...............................j...................., . . , ~~~ _~¡~í.. ~1_¡fl~~m;'!II,'¡,~!¡'I!I¡!,'¡I,!ifi!¡m¡!¡i,¡!;,III!I~ ¡ill! é I ~.~. ."~'^,."\ "\,,,'1~~_l!!///Æ~{fM~/!!/:.:;.·:·:~¡¡~·'.. .:::.~~wmmW7.' ..;:. .:.:;.:: ~"~~ .' ~¥~~~~1~!f· EXHIBIT A ' :.~~..._":.,'-7;::.~~.: GPA 84-1 Adjacent General Plan Designations . . 1000' 2000' . I ~:::-. " ~.ft~,-·_· ..;"i,",!...'"I~~'1.'-I ~;~;~~'~~~ J.. ..~~~. '\-."~...~. , " c..... c.....~ \. . .".; ~..' ~.\ ..... ~t..~, ~'.:.¿ '. ,..\ '.: ."..1 . _ ~_\ \'\ S~ ','-....;.~: ::~: Proposed amendment to the General Plan for apprax. 6 acres at Naples St. near Hilltop Dr. from "Parks a Public Open Space" to "Med. Donsity Residential" o I . ~ ",'. '~. . , ' .': .:.~ '-.: .~. -::..,".... \' ..'."-.....:.;..: '.~ ".,:: .:.', ...;...J.'. . '. t 1_= ..'.~-- ,:'::;: ~-~~.~:.::;. :1...".., . ..... ~ ~, :. = F.".. ~ '. ':. ::::;J ,.::.>. :;~J": "r::: .' . :~= ::..... .:. .... -~ '" . . .'. .. .~:¡¡; -=-" Ë~ J. ~ ..... ?~ ~ .:¡:;:~~r;.:~fq t:' . ":¡C =¡.' ~ l~'· ~" ";:i';;:"¿8~,,,' '::1- . .-..- - r::::':: w .. . " : : II i I I II ¡ L I~·.:r: I III II !. '~T.~:;'!\.. \ }-- 1:~...:i= - r ... ~ "'Ill'" "', t tor .:..:.o(....¡\, ~ , Þ Ë 3:=;:~..:~ .'. ;111"'III¡r ~ ..... ;'!.I,!!rfo-V::'~tJ·:, =-- L-¡":" I .. ~ .. : 1I1I ' ~ ~: :: .... ... . : : . If'-.J ¡lilT .J(~ COu~r~ _.e STREET ~~::'.~:~J I '-. t I I : .m' :~L:~:~...:: IjiJTI.: .;....:. " ~"" ~...;__.~~:- I' . ....::; ~j' .;.,. ~. .,.... ..'i¡. '., . - . {/ _ - R3G , ~~.. ~~L .... ..~\" . - .. .IIGIIEI DIt 'tf r-:"'--. __... :1;';: " I r: _ f:...ÞiC '. ~'!, .....,. Z~,__ \ L::::; -, ~---_.. ...~ ~.' ., .'-' I ~ Tf'¡~'''''''''''' R3G e ',-r.I·:, '1 ¡=...,--:, . - ~ ~~ .'1 ",... -.. !m';:--::" I ,1 c.... ,o, .. .1-'. , . . . ¡- . , - . \<!Il _ I' ' ,--, L:.J..... .. - r~-' . :.~...' ~.' ..r Ie=. ....~ ____00_'.'0 ·i t't'~L' Illi &-.~, ... 111·Lt,· ·l·· '." I L:I1 . ·-oo <. . . ,I., . l.l..LL.: I ...0 ""._\\:I'i10,"';;; - íLJ:- .-(~ "0... ·"oJ ¡In ,"iI'·tJI', '1'T I iT r:-1: J ~ i .". : I '_SF"""';"' 'L' _~;;¡,,.... (~;,~: .._- Y: I "I r'n) j [I il: L ST. SFD' , :_L f- (".~y ,..;. ,. ... .VISTA· '. - I _ . ~ -.... -_' ~ "'··~~~'-A,....· .~ -ET. . :':. .." <Ð~ ¡. 'J1t~'~~~'~;~~.f":;«':,·>t~.u:;~:,~~_'~.~~!.~.~_;,~":"(:':;;"'~';:;"::~;~~~"!I 0.. I~~L-" L5 R I - ·...¡,...I~· ..·,..."-P::....3.~··'·...'.·.: :--.......:.. .-'\... ,".. ~.' .~I'''"' ...... ..........,.. .... . ; . - .-- ,¡..·\...t;.~·;,;!'''~'''·'··\'-·l''.~··.''·~·'' '.. .-.,....>.........--:---...~......(::..'.,~.................. :..,. "_ i [ ~~ø'''c .~~;);lf!.;·l~.~~~~i~~~~l;~~~~~..~~.; ~ ~~~~~}~f~f~}~~·~·~:~g:.~~4:~~::~i~ :~:~~:...;\~ ~~i-~ . : . £ ~ .... i J 3'D ....\...:~... "d~ ~,.)..,¿".:-¡;:.....,.~.r::: ·t ··....0·. .........'!.............:..~..~.. ......:¡ .~'"...... .....é.:. of-:: TFD'h1 t ~ ~f~_'''''\l" or. j'f,._.~ .'"'.~........._t...r$_·90 "'0 ~-.'.." ,....,., ,.''1,'' ,...- ~I r--r-- H.....C -.' >~--- ~'" m ~ ::'~:f.,:";;:FJ!.i~£::.~::';:~$ti;.jI,··;{C... . ··;t~,·y~,·~;:·~:>;.;;;·:·{;,'·:::::.,~:·:';·7;:.S~:..,....V'"-- I _ I I ~ ~.... w .~...~..'J,ò"·.:ç"""'-.':-'.1~'-.-··"'·H'''''''' OUr:f Y":J:'.;'· ~~..~...'....~. :......... .:- '7''':> '.-:;';, . fl r;-_. . .. . _. .L. ~, "~HEAL~H:; ::f;:~:~f;~;.~?J.~r~~~;:~~~;~~~t~::~·~:~.;:}~~·~·;~:~,'.~:,~:~:.:~~~.:::i·~~~;F~~:.~..~~~:.~~~~:~~. .r~ Q .; ~~. Ï t-'-' r IT :t SERVo ~,,;....\-t\ ~,,:'··...·;·:i- '\'i' .". .......~<~::':::..~.':". SAN CIEGO COUNTRY CLUa ..:\.,.~...;-:........ r / r- .... .-.. R-1) . ~ II" - -:,g-"'- '"\"..~:.:..¡......;: '{.'O:.; -'-,' ··.:·:·(~:..---.·..1·_. "·oJ 10-' ....~_.......\...{.,"....t-..::~...::.;.:'::C ... ~ . - / "".,., FD - "~..~.{~;, \..,_":o....1'~~~~1h..~.;~......_... ..':"t'.. " ....~..._......._. ......~:.~. .....:,.::... .. E ~ .. ~. ..... .. · ~ t~\~~~tl\t\~K~rr1Q;~Ki:~~JJi~~~~ ..=' != i·', ::!: ~ L ~~...~~;i.:::::~~,.~.::.:,.:¿>~:2:;.:1..;¡..;~~:~.~~:~;·'.::'::::::~,;~.L-:;::'~:.: 1:1ë :'::" L. .' .... flETA' "-,~~."'" :~:,";f.:·'. ,,_.; .~..~..~ ~ ...:_-......~.../......_ ,~:·i.;·. r- --.. ....J '". "'10' '. t -~ . ........... ..........~..........-.....- r-'- 0 r - . -'; f, :;~~ :. ,,~~~,!·~:;:.~.::l:{PR·ÖPOSAL· . "':,;}?&J ~ r-~ ..:: :~/~ :.~. , f-, I -- -..... :l( ~~ ~'~~·.'.~;f.~A~E~ (6 a.t.r~~)~iI'··:·:> ;., ~ _:: %. :::.".:' .... 11 VI ^>,'\..":.,.-:_.,...~.";:"'<{ ,...., "..,;........:. --- '.:J~' t'C-T: .... u. '..1Wo '-~ ,...,"",-., ,,:...... ... '...., ... .0;. .' to.ot.:, _._ "_,,, ]. . _.....n~ "-.. /r- ~ I\(~ 1>&~..>;:·::::.:~;:;:::::~:::.;:·::~i~;~{::-:· ..;¡~; ç ~}·n,-:... t.:...... J! ," t~. \C ~ ··.··{I'"R- ~ "';.:'i;~':-<;.>.::,~:~""\:"~::"'''''.~:¡ ï' ; - v-....... ..._..~. _._ _._ .~. .--I"1......i:~·· ~-t ':- ;.."-::.7"':::....~... ......_;~:'.:..~':\' VACi.~T , .. _~~ ; ;;'!T::-:;:·'·-; : ;!. ..: Iri~~~»~- :..;.X; :~r:...., .~.,c,v'c.I...... t.~..j.'¡L'-F.:· ""\.I..-N:T~-":"" . : . . N~P~E~ . ,;. . ~. C VI~:' j : ----. ~ ,.. . . . . . .. : : ,.............. ...... - r- ¡:"¡:" ~ "! I;--r-... - T~I".~9.~ f--4 _ ~-~ t-::!= t::¡-¡-. -i: r:=:ìr ';"... .... -w --,-~. '1 ,I- b::i : t ---r:tL . ;: .:; -4.. 0'" ...i '-'= === :::::- .:-j- r- R: f---- J~ .......;..... : ~~;~tû~ ..--~ ::r:: =£ ]~ ~L. ~~:; ~~ - ·1 ! 1II::r.: ..£- ; ..... -.- ~ ~ .... .... r : I- f=l:.:. ¡....t: . . b" ~! '''LE .... ~. '-I-. .J.l.L I ~R:= -S:.:: I', : ~~~- ~ ':1 .t :t:~: .. "'1; ~'!.' . ::r:::1::::: H---- :;:.. ::.: l!.J ..::t ,=. ~ _ [ ., ~r ¡..:.:: I';::' .' t--- --"-- .... _-~ _.- fù . O.FORO '"-- -. I ----- ' a-,-,..... ~ ~ .'- -.----'- ~I . . . t- J :g ª , ~. . l t r , . ...: ~ '7'lrf-:- j t-=- . ~ I---:--...-i- _6 , ., . r' ~@) "·r··· '-'! _.~~-:-: :. . . . w' "0' I. ~ .~-- . o 400' 800' t I I .. .. HIUfOIl' ..' [~ " ... ---. : : ; ; f;·; : ~.;: :. ~ :{.Ut-)~ L L~ ~-: f":~j ~ q : : . , -- ;;;. ---":._.~-~:':' .... '.' EXHIBIT B .00 ~ f~ ..- ! i GPA 84-1 Adjacent' Zoning a Land Use .- ~ --1 I .co ~_ \\í51 Proposed amendment to the General Plan for ,_.. . m-- , , ___._-..1.. opprox. 6 ocres ot Noplas St. neor II . II from Parks e. Public Open Spoce "Med. Density Residential" H!lItop'Dr. to . , .1 ill": ~: f '---- . Exhibit C . @ August 17, 1984 í1.EC::ìVED JY... .....n.._..__....____.._·...·· City Planning Department P. O. Box 10ß7 Chu1a Vista, CA 92012 ~ 2""":· . .. ~; """ ,....þ Gentlemen: PL!\l\j;~¡¡,-!Cj D¿?P~~;T;:,iE;lT We wish to make the following and Rezoning of the Snn Diego comments in our opposition to t1i~Hþ.\·1nVbhf~hgg·\u:'Jnn!p,. Country Club project. Since the EIR is the main issue of this controversy, we will comment on that. When the bureaucratic jargon is stripped from the report these ;facts remain: The o.:!.r quality, traffic "conßestion, noise, loss of open space, loss of old trees, a:'.1d' aesthetics will he a negative factor in this project. ncalistically, ir:1pacts du¡·ing construction cannot be eliminated. "¡.litigation r-.Ieasures" are virtually all debatable. ".'\nalysis of Significance" cannot be a sweeping conclusion. To a large portion of residc;'1ts in this area, the significance will be great; to hQ!,1eowners of further distances, the significanco will be less or non-existant. We believe the Pl~nning Commission should weigh the ilYlportance to the City of valuable open space against the convenience of a 400 member club who wish to build a new clubhouse. This is the real issue. There is, of course, chal1ce for error in making a decision for either side. However, we believe that to err on the side of at least a status quo on the project is better than approving it and suffering irreversible damage to the open space area and the City of Cbu1a Vista. Thank you for your consideration. ""-"() . j ".f/', ;/ ·/...~T{Cl-rL.o- 0"/~t'~~f¿ 1'tJ!? -iJ. / 111 ,) Jl;;:J.í 1-- (ì ~ / .v< 30 /¡' _d~V" Zf' '-Jo',r '... .':' f:?, /1 ~/~.9J..<5t/ .If .,,,J.......(.).:..t.......- ./ _ ~. .(P-?1t'--.11l, (jcß1~j)- V' '~/v'''-- . .lJ ,/ / ''-? v-~ (. ) (;' ~-I ·{c--¿..fJ:-.' t/ a..-w.-e'-- t.IA...-'Í e. í i ..-,i· ~ .c ~-l 0" C(/ ¡~~'~..... I/A/Þ!r--.;...è-...Þ; 7"" /.l i I"~ ~L'Jl' - :_):WtAMJ ;11, L ;':1 '1-") i ,.., \'; ,~.. ?lr1 ' , i 1_/ - I ~_"~"""""_' ',;..1 I vð....l£..<..d- ,: , '1.¡"", C<L '1> II _,~._(..v---IÁ ~ :""¿,\<V', ._ ,,,-0 - (\lyJ rf~~ ~\-r(ì 0 ~ ~ S-\ '\ (¡JI1Üì \J\S"~ ,;,r '. \ v ·¥!.;....:o\\ Yours very truly, , /' /) ¡/- ,~;..... _j¿,,;,t ~ ~¿,'oc. - ';-Ô-;;J1,.,... L /I,-~--ç,--,"- ~ F ~~ ¿>I¿f-<_< c.~ (./~--x-?""_..vl£". )~ /' . ,,' //i .~~./ /T ".~-"S-::_Q_ C/......-tL<:--... /ù ,/ (:.J ,~". . .....- ....,..,....... i( or-).' _ .) (n"-""cC-<,-.( "'-11'( //(,_. L~'(/~")J:1.~"F / C'_ S- -:+- C c.' l-<- 7 c /"/1.. P. (1 (A AY::: j' "- i"" " . / / I-......r__.-:·~_.i-~,,~· 1_' j-<---i...-r~ "---('~---""'L'¿ / .I () S-:r~ ~·_~,~._Z.? JY? ~:_C___,1 (_<:_~.. \0("" ~ ~a(~' , (J¡O<j"1 ("Oi?1"e ¡'/IIA(l¡A \ ~,::JQ.j) ~o....wvo--- 0;.(.; \"","':.' I~~ (![Ï2í...... -- ....-€>~.~,,_\.;.. ··~(:'~£~I !..j(J ,''1 !L..I_.:¡'¡': ,:.... - \~ t l.JC'"- .'........ ~, ?-,-\\l.51 It l,;}" .~ -t;~ J.)~IIß ! () t / (! od fi,- ;;(;rNlrI ¡;?cH. dv¿4 U,,?-!/l,· (ýJ~'.?;o// -C-GU~~ -r Z- tF.yfL7iij¿ c:.6J:.-- 20/( c:Lk- J~I C/'-- '1 -/ì~r¿,ª. bwAJJJ ?p, .1f4J.l1v ) c¡:· CJ«. V;J:¡ M- c¡ 7-£'11 - CtI../UJ-I"."}V~L~. .~ /i;~1.. {3f. tA,..J' 0.. V: "I e.Jt- "I2MI -kà"._ ~ o~ \()~î: 0(~\1\ ~~\. (>'¡.." J "" \.J~::. \ " Q "'c. _ ",,\20\~ ~., - :1"nU--"'-- ~ 10 (/ ~:- :./')..,;.-1:: tv o.--¡ ( I./- Cp c) II ) 'A/~ - ß)-/'y,,~ . /{):56 .~Íî- Idój e/w.J~ ~'k ¡ 9,;1-tJ II ,/,", /" / ' .. -,:. .~>. . '.>- I/~~_ __é.,¿.rf" I:: " ~:.<./ /' CI - ~F ::(-r¿~ {//O~/ VIS/;¡- fI/!J I e¡( i.{/;¡ ViT4- ,C'~ a 7.?-ð1f -I) ~I/'--r~ ~c?- /0),.2 ¡//.š./~ V-/~ (! h?t ¿» ¿,/o +/9- ) C'P 0/ -?C7 /,/ -tfcJm ~~b lo,)g VIS r t4 t.J/1¡ ( tit.! fA 1./1 sr 11 7 a; s'.Jo ( ( -/~ / ß¢)4~ /Ô.27 r;sÎIl ÞYp/t-2 tJl¡ C !u.-J 0( o{; -ht- ( CC4 q 20 f ( -C~'fy:C(~ ¡(Q~ { 0 ''J.- 7 U -vd-Icc Cu ("If. () l ~Ll ~ L..-1/~ L ~ G q'"\ð1// -~3~ ~ (X-'/ V( ¿; 0 ~ t--.'..;,..~ 'yJ &-;;J c..v '9;< D / / - --¡lÙ~, ( g¿,I1~-0 / 0 ó 7 )/<--:<:-i;;:J U ~ t ZI c:; /-0 I / - çj;æ Ih~,/ 100 f /f/.¿.:vt< téfi9-fJ-- Ct '7" f ( ,- 0 Irv /;;./. I .....£,.~ / Iv/(,.U-ILér /7'ì Cï _0\r' '~ /' --" '- "1 {/ ~ / é o:i' :/ r rc (_~ ' " _.L'-:"-LL\. J~ Jl<-/_. /2...:--1/ . '~. ¿,. ~. <~ (~;~. . ,"" ~ '. //./ - ~O~\L-\ . D~Æ'~ IL,:j5 'J,'":;~ vÀ1,... 0-.\J. G\ ~La\,\ ?-,-\\l5'ì . , t". t}, .' ( ( . /Jhcvt1UU(..e...,{1.f!.~~-/ Çk ..-L~~ U c2 c5 //7 ó!-~~ / r9 ö t> COA. ïl? m F1 A I ;:f 4" Q~ ~ -;/fr'?/~¡,< ~7¿ . (j ;L. ~ -0f~ x£t. Œ- ¿/ /~h I!d/Ø',µ I'~ cØ:. ¿'7.d ~-k,@.U. J~~. /O~¿' ~ ~ A ~, 9- é'/ ¡J () Ç) 7lf· . ~b1 &..¢ ~ ~ . /uK.-f !J q'dß- L7A"J....... ~ G . , O?7- C?.o ~ rî Aç;¡A.) 0!....V /"f\ n'-JJJ . , , fk.djÇ) ~dJ2-L-, (lu~ ~ ( <it /..Iiit1AAJ0 ~2J\ /63 Z ,~--, ~ C ~ ~ .' {)~~~ . 11'~:(Y.fj.f, I17Y¡'-.U~/~JJ \f'lILQ.. V,tAO,- I '01;1' ~. ,6:E/!1/f1Z- -r Jð3£ /1tJ þL/I!1¡";() 1251.aj~ £. ~~ pJ'f roOk["£ HAlf/IT It/VI ~ ¿¡¡tÚ~ C!v (ðh()L~ V/.Ç.-I.:;) (If t'..J~ 71· 7Ú-a.oL .... /' . ¡oJfI ~':¡71ClA/-~é.Ý /?)~ ~#- l~c?J..O~~~~ Œ/~ ~, ~. 9~o// ~~p;.,~ ¿;j2.ðJ1 (Ü'J...~ ~vY'1(...l,~?1-vd111 c-- Ý . G6-) t~"" lIald tUldu/(¡,iu., ?ó1J1i1 IOJ 7 C01"t- 1YIú/!lå.. Chu.J!r.. '1)1$+&1, ~4. Q20 JI /)\. l+ oCtj ~ ¡ {) 1../)- CV""\. ¡; Ì\t¿¡A.ov(, (' " '11- C I í ?-_\\Î6'\ Planning Commission -13- August 22, 1984 ---- . -. ..- 3. CONSIDERATION OF FINAL EIR-84-7 - SAN DIEGO COUNTRY CLUB Commissioner Green cited a potential conf1 ictof interest and left the dais after appointing Commissioner Cannon as Chairman Pro Tern. Environmental Review Coordinator Reid stated that the public hearing was held on August 8, 1984, during which written comments were presented with the staff report and additional written and oral comments were received at the publ ic hearing. In addition, the Commission granted Richard D. Nielson's request to submit his written comm¡;nts to staff on August 9, 1984. All of the comments and testimony have been incorporated into the final EIR along with responses re9arding ·each of the comments. The finding of this final EIR is, that all potentially significant environmental impacts can be reduced to a level of insignificance, staff is recommending that the Commission certify that EIR-84-7 has been prepared in compliance with the requirements of CEQA and the environmental revi ew procedures of the City of Chula Vista and that the Commission will consider the information in that document as it reaches a decision on the project. Director Kremp1 reminded the Commission that the pub1 ic hearing on the EIR had been concluded at the August 8 meeting, but would need to be opened for items 4(a) and 4(1)), and suggested that action be taken on the EIR at this time. MSC (Guiles/Carson) - Green abstained - to certify that EIR-84-7 has been prepared in comp1 iance with the Ca1 ifornia Environmental Qual ity Act of 1970, the Environmental Review Procedures of the City of Chu1a Vista and that the Planning Commission will consider the information in that document as it reaches a decision on the project. 4. PUBLIC HEMING: (a) (b) GPA-84-1 - PROPOSAL BY THE SAN DIEGO COUNTRY CLUB TO REDESIGNATE ABOUT 6.00 ACRES OF LAND, LOCATED IN THE NORTHWESTERL Y QUADRANT OF NAPLES STREET AND HILL TOP DRIVE AND WESTERLY OF CORTE MARIA FROM "PARKS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE" TO "MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL}>" (4-12 DWELLING UNIIS PER GROSS ACRE) ON THE LAN DIAGRAM OF THE LAND USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN CONSIDERATION TO REZONE AND PREZONE 6.0 ACRES LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NAPLES STREET AND OPPOSITE 01 XON DRI VE FROM R-l AND S-9D (COUNTY) TO R-3-P-14 - SAN DIEGO COUNTRY CLUB .. 9- -\ \îSï .. Planning Commission -14- August 22, 1984 Principal Planner Pass stated that staff recommends approval of GPA-84-1 based on the following analysis: The site is in an area which is dominated by medium-density residential and open space land uses and such usage would be harmonious with the adjacent areas within Castle Park. The proposed amendment would better meet the current need for middle income housing in the South Bay and is prerequisite to the appl icant's proposal to develop a well-ordered residential annex to the San Diego Country Club. In answer to Commissioner Tugenberg's question, Principal Planner Pass said that the median income in this area is approximately S24,000.. Under HCD regulations, 50-80 percent of the median income is low, 80-100 percent is moderate, and over 120 percent is middle income. Principal Planner Lee, using overhead projects and slides, showed the location of the proposed site in re1 ation to the sing1 e-fami1y homes and the shopping center, the proposed proj!ct, and views from the project site. He pointèd out that the subject property is located at the southeasterly corner of the San Diego Country Club with 520 feet of frontage along Naples Street. The southerly 200 feet,_ or approximately 2 acres, of the property is located within the City of Chula Vista while the northerly 4 acres is located in the County. The applicant is requesting multiple-family zoning at a density of 14 units per net acre on the property to develop an 80-unit condominium project. The density of the project and the proposed zoning are in conformance with the proposed amendment to the General Plan. Principal Planner Lee continued that the proposed development and its relationship to the adjacent commercial area, the single-family area to the east, and its separation from the area to the south part by Naples Street, make the property more isolated and, therefore, it can be developed to a higher density with only a 1 imited impact on the adjacent uses. Principal Planner Lee noted that the staff is recommending the inclusion of development standards specifying no residential structure will exceed two stories in height and no structure is to be located within 50 feet from the R-1 zone which would exceed one story in height. The front yard setback along Naples Street shall be a minimum of 20 feet. Staff is also proposing a zoning wall and fence along the easterly property 1 ine which will be coordinated with the adjoining property owners. No further removal of existing trees shall be permitted wi thout eva1 uation by the City Landscape Architect and shall be rep1 aced with specimen-sized material. He concluded that staff is recommending approval of this request with these standards included. This being the time and the place as advertised, the public hearing was opened. Richard Nielsen, 1032 Corte Maria, neighboring property owner, expressed concern that the social and economic factors and their effect have not been discussed a1 though he had been reassured they would be. He stated that when the project was first presented to the Club members, it was categorized as "high-density, luxury condominiums" but when reviewed in the EIR it was described as "medium-density, medium-income." He pointed out that the EIR "-., 9-_\\1S1 '. Planning Commission -15- August 22, 1984 called for the setting aside of 1/2 acre for parkland, yet the mitigating factor indicated that a fee would be ¡)aid. Mr.' Nielsen concluded by reexpressing his concern that the Connnission had not received sufficient public testimony to reach a mature decision. Principal Planner Lee explained that there was no park located in the area, therefore the project would be assessed a fee based 'on the nulltler of units. This fee would be utilized to develop or maintain park1ands in other parts of the City. Tony Ambrose, HCH & Associates, 4877 Viewridge Avenue, S.D., representing the app1 icant, stated concurrence with the reconnnendations and conditions of approval presented by staff and declared the San Diego Country Club wishes to prepare this property for 80 high-quality medium-density condominiums. Others speaking in opposition to the project were: Mrs. Joseph Choate, 25 Moss Street; Bob Pritctíård, 1061 Corte Maria; Donald Thompson, 1052 Corte Maria; and Joseph Choate, 25 I'Dss Street. Their remarks included: The tall buildings would obscure the view; rental property would devalue property; only open space in the heart of Ch.ula Vista is the golf course which is now threatened; one infringement leads to another; view destroyed; traffic congestion at Naples and Moss; noise from the shopping center; why should the residents be subjected to a store in front and back of the property;on the west and north there is a problem with the air quality--the people in the south and east and the gol fers deserve air as clean as it is now; why is a decision about County property being made by Chu1a Vista; for 25 years taxes have been higher in this location - now the property will be devalued. In reply to a question, Charles Talbot, 1420 Mapl e Street, stated that the compost area had been maintained since 1921 and the cost of removing it was $7,000. Tat L. Wai, HCH and Associates, 4877 Viewridge Ave., S.D., indicated his availability to answer any questions re engineering. Louis Fernandez, 968 Corte Maria, stated there were a number of favorable things about the project including rejuvenation of the shopping area, that 80 more cars wou1 d not adversely affect traffic, all two-story dwell ings are below view level, and the·area will be a nicer place in which to live. Connnissioner Carson remarked that she was assuming that the Connnission had been addressed by at least three of the homeowners affected by the proposed project; and requested the petition be read so its contents be ascertained. At the request of the Chairman, the Clerk read a petition signed by 47 individuals, stating opposition to the project. No one else wishing to speak, the public hearing was closed. ~» ?-_\\1S'ì '. Planning Commission -16- August 22, 1984 MSC (Guiles/Carson) - Green abstained - to recommend that City Council approve the proposal to amend the p1 an diagram of the Land Use E1 ement of the Chu1 a Vista General Plan, GPA-84-1. MSC (Guiles/Carson) - Green abstained - that based on the findings contained in Section E of the staff report, to recommend that City Council enact an ordi nance to rezone and prezone approximately 6.0 acres located on the north si de of Nap1 es Street opposi te Dixon Drive from R-L and S-90 to R-J-P-14 subject to precise p1 an development standards "a" through "e" in the staff report. Commissioner Green returned to the dais and resumed the Chairmanship. . 9-.\\~'5Î ( , CITY OF CHULA VISTA ( DISCLOSURE STATEMENT APPLICANT'S STATEMENT OF DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN OWNERSHIP INTERESTS ON ALL APPLICATIONS WHICH WILL REQUIRE DISCRETIONARY ACTION ON THE PART OF THE CITY COUNCIL, PLANNING COMMISSION AND ALL OTHER OFFICIAL BODIES. The following information must be disclosed: 1. List the names of all persons having an interest in the application. SAN DIEGO COUNTRY CLUB 88 'L' STREET CHULA VISTA. CA 92011 List the names of all persons having any ownership interest in the prope:ty involved. . 2. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a corporation or partner- ship, list the names of all "individuals owning more than 101 of the shares in the corporation or owning any partnership interest in the partnership. 3. If any person identified pursuant to (1) above is a non-profit organization or a trust, list the names of any person serving as director of the non- profit organization or as trustee--or-benefi<:iary or trustor of the trust.* DR. WALTER HAASE DANIEL LARSEN LAWRENCE E. ANTINONE RONALD BURGESS ROBERT SWINGLE BILL NELSON 4. Have you had more than $250 worth of business transacted with any member of the Council within the past twelve months? Yes No x Person is defined as: "Any individual, firm, copartnership, joint venture, associ~tion, social club, fraternal organization, corporation, estate, trust, receiver, syndicate, this and any other county, city and county, city, municipality, district or other political subdivision, or any other group or combination acting as a unit." *CONTINUED FROM LINE #3. DR. WALTER SHAW KEN BAIRD AUGUSTINE SILVEYRA of ap icant/date OUNTRY CLUB name of applicant ~lf1 (NOTE: Attach additional pages ÇL_\\ÎS'\