HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026/05/19 Agenda I declare under penalty of perjury that I am employed
by the City of Chula Vista in the office of the City Clerk
and that I posted the document according to Brown Act
requirements. rr
fr
►� -k
Dated: .'(= sirneds •- •••..-
CITY OF
CHULA VISTA
MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OPPr-
John McCann, Mayor
Tiffany Allen,City Manager
Carolina Chavez,Councitmember- District 1
Marco A.Verdugo,City Attorney
Jose Preciado,Councitmember District 2
Kerry K. Bigelow,City Clerk
Michael Inzunza,Councilmember- District 3
Cesar T. Fernandez,Councilmember- District 4
Date: Tuesday, May 19, 2026, 5:00 p.m.
Location: Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL, SPECIAL HOUSING AUTHORITY, AND SPECIAL SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO
THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY MEETING
Notice is hereby given that the Mayor has called and will convene special meetings of the Housing Authority
and Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency meeting jointly with the City Council at the time and
location stated on this agenda.
Watch live in English and Spanish: chulavistaca.gov/councilmeetings or Cox Ch. 24 (English only).
Free Spanish interpretation is available on-site.
In-Person Public Comments: Submit a request to speak to City Clerk staff before the close of the public
comment period on an item or before the close of the general Public Comment period for non-agenda items.
Electronic Public Comments: At chulavistaca.gov/councilmeetings, locate the meeting and click the comment
bubble icon. Select the item and click "Leave Comment." You may also email cityclerk@chulavistaca.gov.
eComments, emails, and other written comments must be received by the day of the meeting at noon for a
regular meeting or three hours before the start time for a special meeting.
Watch Live or Recorded (English and Spanish): Visit chulavistaca.gov/councilmeetings. Click "ES" at the
bottom to switch to Spanish. Closed captioning is available in both languages.
Accessibility: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to
participate in this meeting, please contact the City Clerk's Office at cityclerk@chulavistaca.gov or (619) 691-
5041. Providing at least 48 hours' notice will help ensure that reasonable arrangements can be made.
Gov. Code § 84308 Regulations: To promote transparency and fairness in the governmental decision-making
process, there are rules to prevent public officials from being unfairly influenced by contributors to their
campaigns. The type of activity these laws were enacted to limit is often referred to as "pay-to-play," and is
governed in California by Government Code section 84308. Parties to any proceedings involving a “license,
permit, or other entitlement for use,” as that term is defined in the Political Reform Act, pending before the City
Council must disclose any campaign contribution over $500 (aggregated) within the preceding 12 months
made by the party, their agent, and those required to be aggregated with their contributions under Gov. Code
§ 82015.5. The disclosure must include the amount contributed and the name(s) of the contributor(s). "G.C. §
84308 Regulations Apply: Yes" on this agenda indicates that the item is subject to these regulations.
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Complete Agenda Packet: The agenda packet, including staff reports, draft resolutions and ordinances, and
other backup materials, is available at chulavistaca.gov/councilmeetings or the City Clerk's Office.
Time Allotted for Speaking (subject to change by the presiding officer)
- Consent Calendar (any or all items): 3 minutes
- Agenda Items (not on Consent): 3 minutes
- General Public Comment (not on agenda): 3 minutes
Individuals who use a translator will be allotted twice the time.
General Public Comments: Twenty-one (21) minutes are scheduled near the beginning of the meeting. The
first seven (7) speakers will be heard during the first Public Comment period. If additional speakers are
registered, they will be heard during the continued Public Comment period. If all registered speakers present
at the time address the City Council during the first Public Comment period, there will be no continued period.
Submitting Request to Speak: A request to speak must be submitted to the City Clerk before the close of the
public comment period on an item or before the close of the general Public Comments for non-agenda items.
GETTING TO KNOW YOUR AGENDA
AGENDA SECTIONS
Consent Calendar items are routine items that are not expected to prompt discussion. All items are
considered for approval at the same time with one vote. Before the vote, there is no separate discussion of
these items unless a member of the City Council or staff removes the item from the Consent Calendar.
Public Comment provides an opportunity to address the City Council on any matter not listed on the agenda
that is within the jurisdiction of the City Council. Under the Brown Act, the City Council cannot take action on
matters not listed on the agenda.
Public Hearings are held on matters specifically required by law.
Action Items are items expected to cause discussion and/or action by the City Council but do not legally
require a public hearing.
Closed Session may only be attended by members of the City Council, support staff, legal counsel, and others
specified on the agenda. Closed session may be held in very limited circumstances as authorized by law.
CITY COUNCIL ACTIONS
Resolutions are formal expressions of opinion or intention of the City Council and are usually effective
immediately.
Ordinances are laws adopted by the City Council. Ordinances usually amend, repeal, or supplement the
Municipal Code; provide zoning specifications; or appropriate money for specific purposes. Most ordinances
require two hearings and go into effect 30 days after the final approval.
Proclamations are issued by the City to honor significant achievements by community members, highlight an
event, promote awareness of community issues, and recognize City employees.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 2 of 12
1.CALL TO ORDER
2.ROLL CALL
3.PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG AND MOMENT OF SILENCE
4.SPECIAL ORDERS OF THE DAY
4.1 Presentation of a Proclamation Honoring EMS Week in the City of Chula Vista
4.2 Presentation of a Proclamation Proclaiming May 17 through May 23, 2026 as National Public
Works Week in the City of Chula Vista
4.3 Presentation of a Proclamation Recognizing Chula Vista Resident, Vien R. Zhivago, Upon
Retirement from the Drug Enforcement Association
5.CONSENT CALENDAR (Items 5.1 through 5.14)
Consent calendar items are considered together and acted upon by one motion. There is no separate
discussion of these items unless the Mayor or a City Councilmember removes the item from the
consent calendar. Items removed from the consent calendar will be heard as action items.
5.1 Approve Meeting Minutes
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Approve the minutes dated: April 21, and 28, 2026.
5.2 Waive Reading of Text of Resolutions and Ordinances
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Approve a motion to read only the title and waive the reading of the text of all resolutions and
ordinances at this meeting.
5.3 Consider Requests for Excused Absences
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Consider approving a request to excuse Deputy Mayor Fernandez from the April 28, 2026, City
Council meeting.
5.4 Comprehensive Code Update: Consideration of Amendments to the Chula Vista Municipal
Code
Report Number: 26-0075
Location: No specific geographic location
Department: Development Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: Yes
Environmental Notice: The proposed action qualifies for the “common sense” exemption
pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3).
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt an ordinance amending Chula Vista Municipal Code (“CVMC”) Title 1 (General
Provisions), Title 3 (Revenue and Finance), Title 5 (Business Licenses, Taxes, and
Regulations), Title 10 (Vehicles and Traffic), Title 12 (Streets and Sidewalks), Title 15
(Buildings and Construction), Title 17 (Environmental Quality), Title 18 (Subdivisions), Title 19
(Planning and Zoning), and Title 21 (Historic Preservation). (Second Reading and Adoption)
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 3 of 12
5.5 Community Facilities District Annexation: Initiate Annexation of Eastlake Self Storage Project
into CFD No. 97-2
Report Number: 26-0169
Location: Located generally adjacent to State Route (SR) 125, south of Eastlake Dr, and north
of Otay Lakes Rd, as shown more particularly on the annexation map
Department: Development Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity was adequately covered in previously adopted Mitigated
Negative Declaration (MND) IS16-0004, State Clearinghouse Number 2019099048, for the
Eastlake Self Storage Project.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt the following resolutions:
A. Setting forth the boundaries of the proposed Annexation No. 14 into CFD No. 97-2,
Improvement Area “C”;
B. Setting forth the boundaries of the proposed Annexation No. 1 into CFD No. 97-2,
Improvement Area “D”;
C. Declaring the intention of the City Council to authorize the proposed Annexation No. 14 into
Improvement Area “C” of CFD No. 97-2, levy a Special Tax, and set a time and place for the
public hearing; and
D. Declaring the intention of the City Council to authorize the proposed Annexation No. 1 into
Improvement Area “D” of CFD No. 97-2, levy a Special Tax, and set a time and place for the
public hearing.
5.6 Road Maintenance: Adopt a List of Projects for Fiscal Year 2026-27 Funded by Senate Bill 1,
the Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017
Report Number: 26-0156
Location: Citywide
Department: Engineering
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State
Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3), no environmental review is required.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution approving the proposed list of projects for fiscal year 2026-27 funded by the
Road Maintenance and Rehabilitation Account created by Senate Bill 1: The Road Repair and
Accountability Act of 2017.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 4 of 12
5.7 Investment Report: Receive the Investment Report for Quarter Ending March 31, 2026
Report Number: 26-0115
Location: No specific geographic location
Department: Finance
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act (“CEAQ”) State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State
Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) no environmental review is required.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Receive the investment report for the quarter ending on March 31, 2026.
5.8 Open Space Districts: Initiate Proceedings, Approve the Engineer’s Report, Declare the
Intention to Levy and Collect Assessments for the Open Space Districts for Fiscal Year 2026-
27, and Set a Public Hearing
Report Number: 26-0058
Location: The Open Space Districts are located throughout the City, for specific District
locations please see Attachment 3
Department: Finance
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a "Project" as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State
Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) no environmental review is required.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 5 of 12
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt the following resolutions:
A. Initiating proceedings for the levy and collection of assessments for Fiscal Year 2026-27 for
Open Space Districts 1 through 11, 14, 15, 17, 18, 20, 23, 24, 26, 31, 33, Eastlake
Maintenance District No 1, Town Centre Maintenance District, and Bay Boulevard Maintenance
District pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972;
B. Approving the Engineer’s Report, declaring the intention to levy and collect assessments;
and setting a public hearing for July 14, 2026, regarding the Fiscal Year 2026-27 assessments
for Open Space Districts 2 through 11, 14, 15, 17, 18, 20 (Zones 1 through 4, 6, 8, and 9), 23,
24, 26, 31, 33, Eastlake Maintenance District No 1, Town Centre Maintenance District, and Bay
Boulevard Maintenance District;
C. Approving the Engineer’s Report, declaring the intention to levy and collect assessments;
and setting a public hearing for July 14, 2026, regarding the fiscal year 2026-27 assessments
for Open Space District 1;
D. Approving the Engineer’s Report, declaring the intention to levy and collect assessments;
and setting a public hearing for July 14, 2026, regarding the fiscal year 2026-27 assessments
for Open Space District 20 Zone 5; and
E. Approving the Engineer’s Report, declaring the intention to levy and collect assessments;
and setting a public hearing for July 14, 2026, regarding the fiscal year 2026-27 assessments
for Open Space District 20 Zone 7.
5.9 Transfer Unclaimed Monies: Transfer Unclaimed Monies from the Deposits Fund to the
General Fund
Report Number: 26-0101
Location: No specific geographic location
Department: Finance
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State
Guidelines Section 15060(C)(3) no environmental review is required.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution transferring unclaimed monies in the amount of $18,583.24 from the
Deposits Fund to the General Fund.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 6 of 12
5.10 Transfer Unclaimed Monies: Transfer Unclaimed Monies from the Cash Bond Deposit Fund to
the General Fund
Report Number: 26-0150
Location: No specific geographic location
Department: Police
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State
Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) no environmental review is required.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution transferring unclaimed monies in the amount of $7,442.30 from the Cash
Bond Deposit Fund to the General Fund.
5.11 Waiver of Development Impact Fees: Approve a Waiver of Parkland Fees for a 96-Unit
Affordable Rental Housing Project within Otay Ranch Village 2
Report Number: 26-0166
Location: Lot MU-2 within Otay Ranch Village 2 at the Intersection of Santa Victoria Road and
Santa Diana Road/Birch Road
Department: Development Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: Yes
Environmental Notice: The proposed action is not a project under the California Environmental
Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b)(4), as it involves a
governmental funding mechanism and does not commit the City to a specific physical project.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution waiving parkland fees and obligations for a 96-unit affordable rental housing
project within Otay Ranch Village 2.
5.12 Vacation of Easement: Vacate Portion of Storm Drain Easement within Parcel 8 of Parcel Map
No. 19543
Report Number: 26-0161
Location: 1190 Broadway
Department: Development Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State Guidelines
Section 15060(c)(3) no environmental review is required. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the
activity qualifies for an Exemption pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the California
Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 7 of 12
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution approving the vacation of a portion of Storm Drain Easement within Parcel 8
of Parcel Map No. 19543, which Easement is being abandoned in a portion of its current
alignment and being relocated to another part of the property.
5.13 Housing Grant Funding: Approve the Fiscal Year 2026-27 U.S. Department of Housing and
Urban Development Annual Action Plan
Report Number: 26-0116
Location: Intersection of Naples and Granjas, 31 4 th Avenue, and all other projects are not site
specific
Department: Housing and Homeless Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: Yes
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State Guidelines
Section 15060(c)(3), no environmental review is required. Under the National Environmental
Policy Act, the activity is exempt pursuant to Title 24, Part 58.34(a)(2)(3) & (10) of the Code of
Federal Regulations.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt the following resolutions:
A. Approving the Fiscal Year 2026-27 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development annual spending plan for the Community Development Block Grant and
HOME Investment Partnerships Program within the 2026/27 Annual Action Plan,
authorizing the City Manager to execute subrecipient agreements, memorandum of
agreement(s), and all documents related to the grants; and
B. Approving the Fiscal Year 2026-27 annual spending plan for the Emergency
Solutions Grant within the 2026/27 Annual Action Plan, authorizing the City Manager to
execute subrecipient agreements and all documents related to the grant.
5.14 Property Management Agreement: Approve an Agreement with Ryan Companies US, Inc. to
Provide Property Management Services for the City-Owned Building Located at 1775 Millenia
Avenue
Report Number: 26-0122
Location: 1775 Millenia Avenue
Department: City Manager
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The Project qualifies for a Categorical Exemption pursuant to State
California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines Section 15301 (Existing Facilities).
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt a resolution approving an agreement between the City of Chula Vista (“City”) and Ryan
Companies US, Inc. to provide property management services for the Millenia Library Building
located at 1775 Millenia Avenue.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 8 of 12
6.PUBLIC COMMENTS
Twenty-one minutes are scheduled for the public to address the City Council for three minutes each on
any matter within the jurisdiction of the City Council that is not on the agenda. The remaining speakers,
if any, will be heard during the continued Public Comment period.
7.PUBLIC HEARINGS
7.1 TEFRA Hearing: Conduct Hearing to Approve the Issuance of Tax-Exempt Multifamily Housing
Revenue Bonds for the Otay Ranch II Affordable Housing Project
Report Number: 26-0090
Location: Northwest corner of State Route 125 and Rock Mountain Road
Department: Housing and Homeless Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The proposed Project is adequately covered in the previously certified
Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) for the Otay Ranch University Villages Sectional
Planning Area (“SPA”) Plan (FEIR 13-01; SCH #2013071077; and incorporated by reference in
City Council Resolution No. 2014-232 on December 2, 2014).
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Conduct the public hearing and adopt a resolution authorizing the issuance of tax-exempt
bonds in an amount not to exceed $80 million for the Otay Ranch II affordable housing project.
7.2 Annual Budget: Consideration of Adopting the Fiscal Year 2026-27 Operating and Capital
Improvement Budgets and Revised Fiscal Year 2026-27 Compensation Schedule
Report Number: 26-0067
Location: No specific geographic location
Department: Finance
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: No
Environmental Notice: The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines. Therefore, pursuant to State Guidelines
Section 15060(c)(3), no environmental review is required. Under the National Environmental
Policy Act, the activity is exempt pursuant to Title 24, Part 58.34(a)(2)(3) & (10) of the Code of
Federal Regulations.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 9 of 12
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Conduct the public hearing and adopt the following resolutions:
A. Adopting the operating and capital improvement budgets for the City of Chula Vista for fiscal
year 2026-27 and appropriating funds for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027, excluding Open
Space Districts: #01, #20 Zone 5, #20 Zone 7; Community Facilities Districts: 07-M, 97-1, 97-2,
99-2; and Capital Improvement Project PRK0349
B. Adopting the operating budget for Open Space District #01 for fiscal year 2026-27 and
appropriating funds for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027
C. Adopting the operating budget for Open Space District #20 Zone 5 for fiscal year 2026-27
and appropriating funds for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027
D. Adopting the operating budget for Open Space District #20 Zone 7, Community Facilities
District 07-M, and Capital Improvement Project PRK0349 for fiscal year 2026-27 and
appropriating funds for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027
E. Adopting the operating budget for Community Facilities Districts 97-1, 97-2 and 99-2 for
fiscal year 2026-27 and appropriating funds for the fiscal year Ending June 30, 2027
F. (Housing Authority) Adopting the operating budget for the Housing Authority for fiscal year
2026-27 and appropriating funds for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027
G. (Successor Agency) Adopting the operating budgets for the Successor Agency to the
Redevelopment Agency for fiscal year 2026-27 and appropriating funds for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 2027
H. Amending the Compensation Schedule and Classification Plan to reflect the addition of
various position titles and changes in salary as reflected in the fiscal year 2026-27 operating
budget
I. Approving the fiscal year 2026-27 Compensation Schedule effective July 10, 2026, as
required by California Code of Regulations, Title 2, Section 570.5
J. Approving the amended compensation summary for all Unrepresented employees and
elected officials, including authorization for the Mayor to execute any necessary contract
amendments to implement said amended compensation summary (4/5 Vote Required)
8.ACTION ITEMS
8.1 Consider Items Removed From the Consent Calendar, if Any
Consider items removed from the consent calendar by the Mayor or a City Councilmember, if
any. If no items were removed from the consent calendar, this item will be withdrawn.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 10 of 12
8.2 Housing Authority & City Housing Funding: Approve a Funding Commitment of up to
$4,000,000 for the Park Hill UMC Development
Report Number: 26-0167
Location: 545 East Naples Street
Department: Housing and Homeless Services
G.C. § 84308 Regulations Apply: Yes
Environmental Notice: The funding action has been determined to be exempt from the
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to State CEQA Guidelines Section
15061(b)(3). The Project itself meets all requirements set forth in California Government Code
Section 65913.16(c). No further review under CEQA is required.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Adopt the following resolutions:
A. Chula Vista Housing Authority resolution authorizing a commitment of up to $3,000,000 in
Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Fund funds for the construction of an affordable
housing development to be located at 545 East Naples Street (4/5 Vote Required); and
B. City Council resolution authorizing a commitment of up to $1,000,000, less $25,000 for City
staff administrative costs, in Local Housing Trust Fund funds for the construction of an
affordable housing development to be located at 545 East Naples Street. (4/5 Vote Required)
9.PUBLIC COMMENTS (CONTINUED)
There will be no continued Public Comment period if all speakers present at the first Public Comment
period are heard.
10.CITY MANAGER’S REPORTS
10.1 Request for Clarification of Special Events Referral from May 5 City Council Meeting
11.MAYOR’S REPORTS
12.COUNCILMEMBERS’ REPORTS
13.CITY CLERK'S REPORTS
14.CITY ATTORNEY'S REPORTS
15.CLOSED SESSION
Announcements of actions taken in closed session shall be made available by noon on the next
business day following the City Council meeting at the City Attorney's office in accordance with the
Ralph M. Brown Act (Government Code 54957.7)
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 11 of 12
15.1 Conference with Legal Counsel Regarding Existing Litigation Pursuant to Government Code
Section 54956.9(d)(1)
Name of case: A) City of Chula Vista v. Slade Fischer, et al., San Diego Superior Court, Case
No. 24CU006375C
Name of case: B) Eric Crockett v. City of Chula Vista, et al., San Diego Superior Court, Case
No. 37-2024-00012828-CU-OE-CTL
Name of case: C) Roxana Kennedy v. City of Chula Vista, et al., San Diego Superior Court,
Case No. 26CU026069C
16.ADJOURNMENT
to the regular City Council meeting on June 2, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers.
Materials provided to the City Council related to an open session item on this agenda are available for
public review, please contact the Office of the City Clerk at cityclerk@chulavistaca.gov
or (619) 691-5041.
We encourage community participation - sign up at www.chulavistaca.gov to receive email notifications
when City Council agendas are published online.
City of Chula Vista - City Council
May 19, 2026 City Council/Housing Authority/Successor Agency Agenda Page 12 of 12