Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-09-18 BOE Agenda Packet Date:Wednesday, September 18, 2024 Time:5:15 p.m. Location:City Hall, Bldg. A, Executive Conference Room #103 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA Board of Ethics Regular Meeting Public Comments: Public comments may be submitted to the Board of Ethics in the following ways: In-person comments during the meeting. Join us for the Board of Ethics meeting at the time and location specified on this agenda to make your comments. • Submit an eComment. Visit www.chulavistaca.gov/boardmeetings, locate this meeting, and click the comment bubble icon. Click on the item you wish to comment on, then click "Leave Comment." • Email comments. Submit comments via email to BOE@chulavistaca.gov.• The commenting period will close at noon on the day of the meeting. All comments will be made available to the Board and the public. Accessibility: Individuals with disabilities are invited to request modifications or accommodations in order to access and/or participate in a Board of Ethics meeting by contacting the City Attorney's Office at BOE@chulavistaca.gov (California Relay Service is available for the hearing impaired by dialing 711) at least forty-eight hours in advance of the meeting. Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL Board Members Barragan, Colon-Torres, Gersten, Hurst, Salas, Torres, Velissaropoulos 3.PUBLIC COMMENTS 4 Persons may address the Board on any subject matter within the Board’s jurisdiction that is not listed as an item on the agenda. State law generally prohibits the Board from discussing or taking action on any issue not included on the agenda, but, if appropriate, the Board may schedule the topic for future discussion or refer the matter to staff. If you wish to comment, please submit comments electronically at: www.chulavistaca.gov/boardmeetings or submit an electronic comment per the instructions on page one of this agenda. 4.ACTION ITEMS The Item(s) listed in this section of the agenda will be considered individually by the Board and are expected to elicit discussion and deliberation. If you wish to comment on one of these items, you may do so at www.chulavistaca.gov/boardmeetings or submit an electronic comment per the instructions on page one of this agenda. 4.1 Approval of July 17, 2024 Meeting Minutes 39 Recommended Action: Review minutes and consider for approval. 4.2 Written Communications 42 Communication from Board Member Jose Torres requesting an excused absence from the June 12, 2024 Board of Ethics meeting. Recommended Action: Consider request for excused absence as appropriate. 4.3 Continued Discussion and Possible Action on Board of Ethics Work Plan for Fiscal Year 2024 - 2025 Update on ad hoc subcommittees work plan for the following projects: Group A: Lobbying Ordinance - Board Members Isidro Barragan, Leslie Hurst and Bobby Ray Salas Group B: Ex Parte Communications Policy - Board Members William Gersten, Jose Torres and Bobby Ray Salas Group C: Amendments to Code of Ethics - Board Members Alexia Velissaropoulos, Leslie Hurst and Robert Colon-Torres Recommended Action: Discuss ad hoc subcommittee work and/or goals and take related action as appropriate. City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 2 of 42 OTHER BUSINESS 5.STAFF COMMENTS 6.CHAIR'S COMMENTS 7.BOARD MEMBERS' COMMENTS 8.ADJOURNMENT to the regular meeting on October 16, 2024 at 5:15 p.m. Materials provided to the Board of Ethics related to any open-session item on this agenda are available for public review by contacting the City Attorney's Office at BOE@chulavistaca.gov. City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 3 of 42 1 Doris Cornejo From:Jett888 Jett888 Sent:Tuesday, July 23, 2024 8:16 AM To:Board of Ethics; CityAttorney; marco.verdugo@sdcda.org; Councilmember Jill Galvez; CityClerk; assemblymember.alvarez@assembly.ca.gov; CHULAVISTACA Support; Gilbert Contreras Subject:Re: Board of Ethics - Contact us WARNING - This email originated from outside the City of Chula Vista. Do not click any links and do not open attachments unless you can confirm the sender. PLEASE REPORT SUSPICIOUS EMAILS BY USING THE PHISH ALERT REPORT BUTTON or to reportphishing@chulavistaca.gov Why did my letter take so long to reach you? I sent it: 05/06/2024 10:29 AM It is now 7/22/2024. 72 days you take to do anything with my complaint and 77 days till you respond to me, in this email. I'm given "90 Days to complete the complaint" but really only have 13 days? July 22, 2024 To Whom It May Concern, I am writing in response to your recent communication regarding my initial complaint submitted on May 6, 2024, concerning the ethical conduct of Kevin Pointer and others involved in the approval and defense of the exclusive use contract between the City of Chula Vista and Sunnyside Saddle Club (SSC). Firstly, I must express my deep frustration and disappointment with the significant delay in your response. It has taken a staggering 77 days for a reply to reach me, which is unacceptable considering the urgency and seriousness of the issues raised. Your requirement for me to now complete a 30-page complaint form within 13 days of receipt is both unreasonable and disproportionate, particularly after enduring such an extensive delay on your end. I have already provided detailed accounts and documentation outlining the violations of Chula Vista Municipal Codes, the California State Constitution, and other relevant laws perpetrated by Page 4 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Kevin Pointer and his cohorts. These violations include but are not limited to the wrongful exclusion of the public from a publicly owned facility and the blatant disregard for established legal frameworks and ethical standards. Moreover, the contract signed on October 17, 2023, granting SSC exclusive, 24/7 access to a facility within Rohr Park, a public asset utilized by the community for decades, is a clear betrayal of public trust. This contract has not only deprived me and others of our constitutional rights to access public facilities but has also caused significant harm to my personal interests and the well- being of my horses. It is evident that the decision-makers involved, including Maria Kachadoorian, Megan McClurg (city atty) Mayor John McCann, Megan McClurg, and Deputy Mayor Preciado, City Councilmembers Gonzalez, Cardenas, Chavez, have failed in their duty to uphold the law and protect public resources. Their actions have led to the prolonged violation of the public's rights and the perpetuation of a public nuisance. Given the gravity of these violations and the extensive documentation already provided, I firmly believe that the onus is on you to take immediate corrective action. I refuse to allocate further time and resources to fill out a cumbersome complaint form (30 pages) when the essential facts and grievances have already been communicated repeatedly over the past months. Therefore, I urge the Ethics Committee to promptly investigate and address these issues, ensuring accountability and restitution for the community. It is imperative that the public park facility is restored to its intended use without further delay. I trust that you will handle this matter with the utmost seriousness and expediency it demands. Sincerely, Stacy Jett On Mon, Jul 22, 2024 at 3:11 PM Board of Ethics <BOE@chulavistaca.gov> wrote: Hello Ms. Jett, I am in receipt of your email. Your comment was attached to our July 17, 2024 agenda and provided to our Board of Ethics members during our meeting. If you wish to submit a complaint for review by the Board of Ethics, please complete the attached complaint form. The completed form should be delivered to the City Clerk’s office located at 276 Fourth Ave., Building A (inside the main City Hall lobby). Page 5 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 6 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 7 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 1 Doris Cornejo From:Robert Sent:Tuesday, July 23, 2024 6:29 PM To:CityClerk; CityAttorney; John McCann; Jose Preciado; Board of Ethics; HumanResources Subject:AUDIT 7.23.24 WARNING - This email originated from outside the City of Chula Vista. Do not click any links and do not open attachments unless you can confirm the sender. PLEASE REPORT SUSPICIOUS EMAILS BY USING THE PHISH ALERT REPORT BUTTON or to reportphishing@chulavistaca.gov Page 8 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Page 9 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 10 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Attn: Brian Albright Email: balbright@sdcounty.ca.gov Dear Supervisors. County Board of Supervisors, City councils and Parks and Recreation Department, Board of Ethics and to whom it concerns. San Diego County officials, /District 1/Chula Vista City officials, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the developments at Rohr Park, specifically concerning the locking of the public equestrian arena by the Sunnyside Saddle Club (SSC), which began as long ago as April 2023. (Title 2. Public Nuisances CA Civil Code 3490. No lapse of time can legalize a public nuisance, amounting to an actual obstruction of public rights.) As a resident of Bonita and a longtime user of this public facility, I believe it is imperative to remind San Diego County of its obligation to provide essential amenities, including public access to equestrian facilities, to the community. I have frequented and relied upon this arena for decades to manage my horses. The city officials of Chula Vista, also within District 1, approved a 5 year, 24/7 lockout of the public from accessing this public park facility. In addition to this, Judy Tieber, the president of the Sweetwater Valley Civic Association (located in Bonita, in San Diego County) publicly approved the 'exclusive use' contract between Sunnyside Saddle Club and Chula Vista at the October 17, 2023 City Council meeting. Civic centers are intended to uphold and support the public's ability to access their Public parks and facilities, not privatize them. This decision reflects a profound breach of public trust. The required notifications of this important community matter were not met, as even the local Bonita Valley Horsemen president and members were unaware of the meeting. However, Judy Tieber, the president of the Sweetwater Valley Civic Association, was coincidentally informed and publicly supported the 'exclusive use' contract between Sunnyside Saddle Club and Chula Vista on October 17, 2023 during a Chula Vista City Council. According to her LinkedIn page As of July 24, 2024, Tieber owns the Mt. Miguel Equestrian Stables, a boarding facility used by many Sunnyside Saddle Club members. This lack of transparency is concerning, especially considering the impact on our community. As a result, members of the community, including myself, are being unjustly kicked out of the entire park and the facility when attempting to utilize this vital asset as well as being harrassed and physically intimidated by the Sunnyside Saddle Club affiliates. My husband, today, was just served a restraining order by Richelle Farley, for "workplace violence" which wasn't approved but he still now needs to appear in court to defend himself. He has seen Richelle Farley one time when she approached us. Richelle had approached me and my horses in the round pen and began video taping me. My husband began video taping her. All interactions are documented . Richelle's "workplace" is listed as 4548 Sweetwater Road, Bonita CA, 91902, this is the Rohr Park location. Is Richelle employed by the City of Chula Vista? Labeling it as 'workplace violence,' seems like an extremely desperate attempt to keep a member from accessing public park facilities and practicing their Constitutionally protected rights. This is just one more addition to the harassment tactics we continue to face." How much longer will both San Diego County and the City of Chula Vista support this type of harassment and treatment of a member of the public? I am deeply concerned about the fairness of the legal process in light of recent events. My husband has been served with a temporary restraining order under the guise of 'workplace violence,' despite there being no substantiated evidence or prior incidents to support such a claim. This action appears to be a desperate attempt to prevent our access to public park facilities, further exacerbated by documented instances of harassment and intimidation by affiliates of the Sunnyside Saddle Club. Given the ongoing challenges with city officials regarding the application of laws and codes, I worry about the impartiality and fairness of the judgment process. It is crucial that the legal system upholds transparency and adheres to due process, ensuring that all individuals are treated fairly and their rights are fully protected Page 11 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 3 The actions taken by Sunnyside Saddle Clubs president, Richelle Farley, with apparent support from local officials, to deny public access through the implementation of locks on the arena gates, are alarming and in violation of California Resource Code Sections 5400-5409. These sections clearly stipulate that if public park facilities are repurposed or taken, comparable facilities must be provided to the same community in the same location. Locking a historically accessible facility and granting exclusive use to a private entity directly contradicts this mandate. Government Code section 25123 is relevant as the locking of the public equestrian arena at Rohr Park by Sunnyside Saddle Club contravenes the conditions under which the park was accepted for public use. In light of California Civil Code section 3334, which addresses the detriment caused by the wrongful occupation of real property, the ongoing restriction of public access to the equestrian facilities at Rohr Park by Sunnyside Saddle Club represents a clear violation of public trust and legal obligations. The public arena and surrounding facilities were historically utilized by the community, including backyard horse owners like myself, for recreational and equestrian activities. By granting exclusive use and allowing locks to be placed on these public facilities, Chula Vista and San Diego County is effectively depriving the public of their rightful use of public resources without proper legal justification. This not only disregards the intent of the original acceptance of the parkland but also undermines the principles of fairness and equitable access to public amenities as mandated by California law. The fiduciary duty of San Diego County extends beyond mere oversight; it encompasses the responsibility to safeguard public assets for the benefit of all residents, including backyard horse owners like myself. The decision by County Supervisor Nora Vargas to grant $25,000 of public funds to Sunnyside Saddle Club exclusively for their 'show seasons' represents a significant misuse of taxpayer money. This grant, intended for neighborhood reinvestment, was allocated without proper consideration for equitable community access or public benefit. By denying access to the equestrian facilities at Rohr Park and requiring membership for participation in their shows,as well as mandating restricted use, Sunnyside Saddle Club effectively excludes the broader public from enjoying these amenities, which were historically accessible to all. Furthermore, the promised improvements funded by this grant, such as new fencing and arena maintenance, have not materialized after nine months, demonstrating a lack of accountability in the use of public funds. This action undermines the principles of fairness and responsible stewardship of public resource s, highlighting the need for transparency and equitable distribution of county resources. District 1, which includes Bonita and Chula Vista, relies on shared amenities like the Rohr Park equestrian arena to foster community engagement and support recreational activities. As a resident and taxpayer, I urge the County to reconsider its position and take immediate steps to restore public access to the arena. Furthermore, I call upon Supervisor Nora Vargas and the Board of Supervisors to uphold their commitment to transparency and accountability in matters affecting public lands. There is an alarming trend in San Diego County where public equestrian facilities are being dilapidated, stolen, shut down, privatized, and taken over. San Diego County has allowed this troubling trend of handing over public facilities to private entities for private profit, alongside the closure of public arenas despite acknowledging a thriving horse community in areas like Bonita, Lakeside, Dehesa/Crest. This practice extends beyond the monopolization of the Rohr Park arena by Sunnyside Saddle Club. For example, some facilities charge exorbitant fees for public use, up to $125-$175 per hour, despite being developed through community contributions. This pattern not only restricts public access but also undermines the county's responsibility to manage public assets in the best interest of all residents. It raises serious concerns about equity and fairness in the allocation and use of public resources. Additionally, round pens, vital amenities for horse owners, have been removed from San Diego park lands without replacement by the county. The Page 12 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 4 shutting down or blocking public access to vital riding arenas is unacceptable. As such, I am exploring legal avenues to address these violations and seek appropriate remedies to uphold community rights and access to public amenities. This is what disease is made from—these unexpected shocks and injustices. The unwarranted actions taken against us, including the unjustified restraining order and the denial of our constitutional right to use a public park facility, have caused immense stress and disruption to our lives. It is disheartening to see public officials turning a blind eye to legal violations and allowing such harassment tactics to persist. The contract approval ignored legal standards and violated our community's trust. We are left questioning how such unfair treatment can continue unchecked. This must be addressed, not just for our sake but for the integrity of our community and the principles of justice that should guide our governance. In conclusion, I respectfully request a prompt review of the current situation at Rohr Park and urge the County to take proactive measures to ensure that public assets remain accessible to all residents. Please let this serve as a reminder of the County's obligation to represent the interests of the entire community and uphold the principles of fairness and inclusivity in land use and resource allocation. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and actions in support of preserving public access to essential equestrian facilities in District 1. Sincerely, Stacy Jett I've enclosed images which show or illustrate what I have mentioned. I have video documentation as well. Also troubling is the harassment when being in the Park by large tractors, or SSC affiliates actions. Page 13 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 14 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 15 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 16 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 17 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 18 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 19 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 20 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 21 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Firstly, I must express my deep frustration and disappointment with the significant delay in your response. It has taken a staggering 77 days for a reply to reach me, which is unacceptable considering the urgency and seriousness of the issues raised. Your requirement for me to now complete a 30-page complaint form within 13 days of receipt is both unreasonable and disproportionate, particularly after enduring such an extensive delay on your end. I have already provided detailed accounts and documentation outlining the violations of Chula Vista Municipal Codes, the California State Constitution, and other relevant laws perpetrated by Kevin Pointer and his cohorts. These violations include but are not limited to the wrongful exclusion of the public from a publicly owned facility and the blatant disregard for established legal frameworks and ethical standards. Moreover, the contract signed on October 17, 2023, granting SSC exclusive, 24/7 access to a facility within Rohr Park, a public asset utilized by the community for decades, is a clear betrayal of public trust. This contract has not only deprived me and others of our constitutional rights to access public facilities but has also caused significant harm to my personal interests and the well- being of my horses. It is evident that the decision-makers involved, including Maria Kachadoorian, Megan McClurg (city atty) Mayor John McCann, Megan McClurg, and Deputy Mayor Preciado, City Councilmembers Gonzalez, Cardenas, Chavez, have failed in their duty to uphold the law and protect public resources. Their actions have led to the prolonged violation of the public's rights and the perpetuation of a public nuisance. Given the gravity of these violations and the extensive documentation already provided, I firmly believe that the onus is on you to take immediate corrective action. I refuse to allocate further time and resources to fill out a cumbersome complaint form (30 pages) when the essential facts and grievances have already been communicated repeatedly over the past months. Therefore, I urge the Ethics Committee to promptly investigate and address these issues, ensuring accountability and restitution for the community. It is imperative that the public park facility is restored to its intended use without further delay. I trust that you will handle this matter with the utmost seriousness and expediency it demands. Sincerely, Stacy Jett Page 22 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 1 Doris Cornejo From:Kerry Bigelow on behalf of CityClerk Sent:Thursday, August 15, 2024 6:20 PM To:Robert Johnson; Board of Ethics; CityClerk Subject:RE: Board of Ethics - Regular Meeting Hello, Robert. We received your email. There was a typo in the Board of Ethics email address. The BOE email address is boe@chulavistaca.gov, which I’ve copied on this email. Thank you, Kerry Kerry Bigelow, MMC | City Clerk | City of Chula Vista, Ofϐice of the City Clerk 276 Fourth Avenue | Chula Vista, CA | 91910 | (619) 407-3590 | kbigelow@chulavistaca.gov Email correspondence with the City of Chula Vista, including attachments, may be subject to the California Public Records Act and, therefore, may be publicly disclosed unless otherwise exempt. From: Robert Johnson Sent: Thursday, August 15, 2024 6:11 PM To: boe@chulavistaca.org; CityClerk <CityClerk@chulavistaca.gov> Subject: Fwd: Board of Ethics - Regular Meeting WARNING - This email originated from outside the City of Chula Vista. Do not click any links and do not open attachments unless you can confirm the sender. PLEASE REPORT SUSPICIOUS EMAILS BY USING THE PHISH ALERT REPORT BUTTON or to reportphishing@chulavistaca.gov AUDIT OF EMAILS FOR MEETINGS> ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: City of Chula Vista <webmaster@chulavistaca.gov> Date: Thu, Aug 15, 2024 at 5:31 PM Subject: Board of Ethics - Regular Meeting To: Board of Ethics - Regular Meeting  Date: 08/21/2024 5:15 PM - 6:15 PM  Location: Chula Vista City Hall, Executive Conf. Room 103 276 Fourth Avenue, Bldg. A Chula Vista, California 91910 Page 23 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Click here to view all meeting agendas and notices or visit: https://www.chulavistaca.gov/departments/city- clerk/boards-commissions/boards-commissions-list/board-of-ethics Having trouble viewing this email? View on the website instead. Change your eNotification preference. Unsubscribe from all City of Chula Vista eNotifications . Page 24 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 1 Doris Cornejo From:Robert Sent:Monday, August 19, 2024 2:10 AM To:CityClerk; CityAttorney; John McCann; Jose Preciado; Board of Ethics; HumanResources; Charter Review Commission Subject:Fwd: Time Magazine CBS Case Study of Media Bias = Magazine Cover Change WARNING - This email originated from outside the City of Chula Vista. Do not click any links and do not open attachments unless you can confirm the sender. PLEASE REPORT SUSPICIOUS EMAILS BY USING THE PHISH ALERT REPORT BUTTON or to reportphishing@chulavistaca.gov ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: alan mil Date: Thu, Aug 15, 2024 at 9:50 AM Subject: Time Magazine CBS Case Study of Media Bias = Magazine Cover Change To: News ABC 10 San Diego <team10@kgtv.com>, News ABC 7 Los Angeles <pr@abc7.com>, News ABC 7 San Francisco <KGO-TV.Programming@abc.com>, News American Spectator <editor@spectator.org>, News American Thinker Editor <editor@americanthinker.com>, News American Thinker Editor Andrea Widburg <andrea@americanthinker.com>, News American Thinker Monica Showalter <mmshowalter@gmail.com>, News Ballotpedia Editor <editor@ballotpedia.org>, News Big League Politics <contact@bigleaguepolitics.com>, News CBS 8 KFMB San Diego Richard Allyn <rallyn@kfmb.com>, News CBS KBAK 29 Fox 58 Bakersfield Now Bakersfield <news@bakersfieldnow.com>, News CBS KCAL 9 Los Angeles <kcalnews@cbs.com>, News CBS KPIX 5 San Francisco <kpixnewsassign.editors@cbs.com>, News Cheyenne WY Tribune Eagle <news@wyomingnews.com>, News Chula Vista Live Data , News CNN <tips@cnn.com>, News Coast News Group <stories@coastnewsgroup.com>, News Coronado Eagle Journal <editor.eaglenews@gmail.com>, News Coronado Times <manager@coronadotimes.com>, News Crescent City Times-Standard <editor@times-standard.com>, News Daily Caller <sendtips@dailycaller.com>, News Daily Mail <newsUS@dailymail.com>, News Daily News Los Angeles <dnmetro@dailynews.com>, News Denver CO Post Editorial <openforum@denverpost.com>, News Encinitas Avocate <editor@encinitasadvocate.com>, News Epoch Times News Letter <newsletter@epochtimes.com>, News Epoch Times NTD Evening News <EVENINGNEWS@ntd.com>, News Epoch Times NTD Today News <NEWS.TODAY@ntd.com>, News Epoch Times TV <epochtv@epochtimes.com>, News Fox 11 Los Angeles <comments@foxnewsinsider.com>, News Fox 11 Los Angeles <fox11news@fox.com>, News Fox 2 KTVU Oakland <newstips@fox.com>, News Fox 5 69 San Diego <news@fox5sandiego.com>, News Fox 5 69 Sarah Alegre <SAlegre@fox5sandiego.com>, News Fox 5 San Diego Receptionist <kswb-receptionist@nexstar.tv>, News Fresno Bee <customerservice@fresnobee.com>, News Howard Jarvis <info@hjta.org>, News Idaho Statesman, Chadd Cripe, Editor <ccripe@idahostatesman.com>, News James O'Keefe <info@okeefemediagroup.com>, News James O'Keefe <james@okeefemediagroup.com>, News James Okeefe Media Group <support@okeefemediagroup.com>, News JBS <jbs@jbs.org>, News Judicial Watch <info@judicialwatch.org>, News KOGO Carl DeMaio (Chairman Reform California KOGO DeMaio Report) <carl@reformcalifornia.org>, News KOGO Carl DeMaio (Chairman Reform California KOGO DeMaio Report) <carl@carldemaio.com>, News KOGO Carl DeMaio (Chairman Reform California KOGO DeMaio Report) <carl@carldemaio.net>, News KOGO Carl DeMaio (Chairman Reform California KOGO DeMaio Report) <carl@carldemaio.org>, News KOGO Lou Penrose <Lou@loupenrose.com>, News KOGO Mike Slater <MichaelSlater@iheartmedia.com>, News KOGO Steve Geofferies (Mike Slater Manager) <SteveGeofferies@iheartmedia.com>, News KPBS San Diego <news@kpbs.org>, News Kron News 4 San Francisco <BreakingNews@kron4.com>, News KTLA 5 Los Angeles <ktla@ktla.com>, News KUSI 51 San Diego <NEWS@kusi.com>, Page 25 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 News KUSI Allie Wagner <awagner@kusi.com>, News KUSI Allison Edmonds <aedmonds@kusi.com>, News KUSI Brandon Stone <bstone@kusi.com>, News KUSI Dan Plante <dplante@kusi.com>, News KUSI Diane Tuazon <dtuazon@kusi.com>, News KUSI Ed Lenderman <elenderman@kusi.com>, News KUSI Jason Austell <jaustell@kusi.com>, News KUSI Kacey McKinnon <kmckinnon@kusi.com>, News KUSI Lauren Phinney <lphinney@kusi.com>, News KUSI Logan Byrnes <lbyrnes@kusi.com>, News KUSI Mark Mathis <mmathis@kusi.com>, News KUSI Paul Rudy <prudy@kusi.com>, News KUSI Teresa Sardina <tsardina@kusi.com>, News La Jolla Light <robert.vardon@lajollalight.com>, News La Prensa San Diego <news@laprensasd.com>, News LA Times Los Angeles <tips@latimes.com>, News Larry Elder <contactthelarryeldershow@gmail.com>, News Las Vegas Fox5 <desk@fox5vegas.com>, News Las Vegas KLAS Channel 8 <KLASweb@8newsnow.com>, News Libs of TikTok <libsoftiktok@substack.com>, News Libs of TikTok <newsletter@libsoftiktok.com>, News Marin Independent Journal Managing Editor <jswartz@marinij.com>, News Marina Times San Francisco <letters@marinatimes.com>, News Monterey Herald Managing Editor <dkellogg@montereyherald.com>, News NBC Telemundo CW KGET Bakersfield <17News@kget.com>, News New York Post <tips@nypost.com>, News New York Sun <tips@nysun.com>, News New York Times <tips@nytimes.com>, News OANN Addison Smith In Focus <InFocus@oann.com>, News OANN Chanel Rion Weekly Briefing <weeklybriefing@oann.com>, News OANN Dan Ball Real America <RealAmerica@oann.com>, News OANN Kara McKinney Tipping Point <TippingPoint@oann.com>, News OANN Pearson Sharp <pearson.sharp@oann.com>, News OANN Stephanie Myers <Stephanie.Myers@oann.com>, News Orange County Register Los Angeles <local@ocregister.com>, News Portland Oregonian Editorial <letters@oregonian.com>, News Project Veritas <veritastips@protonmail.com>, News Public Square <groups@publicsq.com>, News Ranch Santa Fe Review <editor@rsfreview.com>, News Sacramento Bee Sacramento <customerservice@sacbee.com>, News San Diego News Desk <news@sandiegonewsdesk.com>, News San Diego Reader <newsletters@sandiegoreader.com>, News San Jose Mercury Sarah Dussault <sdussault@bayareanewsgroup.com>, News Seattle Times Jim Brunner, politics <jbrunner@seattletimes.com>, News SF Chronical San Francisco <iteam@sfchronicle.com>, News Star News Chula Vista <info@thestarnews.com>, News The Blaze Cortney Weil Senior Editor <cweil@blazemedia.com>, News The Blaze Dave Urbanski Senior Editor <durbanski@blazemedia.com>, News The Federalist <info@thefederalist.com>, News The New American <editorial@thenewamerican.com>, News Times San Diego <news@timesofsandiego.com>, News Union Tribune San Diego <local@sduniontribune.com>, News Voice Of San Diego Lisa Halverstadt <lisa.halverstadt@voiceofsandiego.org>, News Voice Of San Diego Will Huntsberry <will.huntsberry@voiceofsandiego.org>, News Washington Examiner Liam Quinn Deputy Managing Editor <lquinn@washingtonexaminer.com>, News Washington Examiner Max Thornberry Breaking News Editor <mthornberry@washingtonexaminer.com>, News Washington Examiner W James Antle III Politics Editor <jantle@washingtonexaminer.com>, News Washington Post <letters@washpost.com>, News Washington Times Cathy Gainor Managing Editor <cgainor@washingtontimes.com>, News Washington Times Charles Hurt Opinion Editor <churt@washingtontimes.com>, C Senator R Missouri Josh Hawley <SenatorHawley@hawley.senate.gov>, CA Advisor D Newsom Ann Oleary <ann.oleary@gov.ca.gov>, CA DA D Rob Bonta <rob.bonta@doj.ca.gov>, CA DA Deputy D Matthew Struhar <matthew.struhar@doj.ca.gov>, CA Governor D Gavin Newsom <gavin.newsom@gov.ca.gov>, CA Rep (74) R Laurie Davis <assemblymember.davies@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (75) R Marie Waldron <assemblymember.waldron@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (76) D Brian Maienschein <assemblymember.maienschein@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (77) D Tasha Boerner-Horvath <assemblymember.boerner@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (78) D Christopher Ward <assemblymember.ward@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (79) D Akilah Weber <assemblymember.aweber@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (80) D David Alvarez <assemblymember.alvarez@assembly.ca.gov>, CA Rep (Fed 3rd) R Kevin Kiley California <kevin@electkevinkiley.com>, CA Rep (Fed 48th) R Darrell Issa <CA48DI.Outreach@mail.house.gov>, CA Senator (11) D Scott Weiner <senator.wiener@senate.ca.gov>, CA Senator (18) D Steve Padilla <Thomas.Lawton@sen.ca.gov>, CA Senator (18) D Steve Padilla <senator.padilla@senate.ca.gov>, CA Senator (32) R Kelly Seyarto <senator.seyarto@senate.ca.gov>, CA Senator (38) D Catherine Blakespear <senator.blakespear@senate.ca.gov>, CA Senator (39) D Toni Atkins <senator.atkins@senate.ca.gov>, CA Senator (40) R Brian Jones <senator.jones@senate.ca.gov>, Mayor Carlsbad Keith Blackburn <keith.blackburn@carlsbadca.gov>, Mayor Chula Vista John McCann <jmccann@chulavistaca.gov>, Mayor Coronado Richard Bailey <rbailey@coronado.ca.us>, Mayor Del Mar Tracy Martinez <tmartinez@delmar.ca.us>, Mayor El Cajon Bill Wells <Bwells@elcajon.gov>, Mayor El Cajon Bill Wells <bwells@cityofelcajon.us>, Mayor Encinitas Tony Kranz <tkranz@encinitasca.gov>, Mayor Escondido Dane White <dawhite@escondido.org>, Mayor Imperial Beach Page 26 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 3 Paloma Aguirre <paloma.aguirre@imperialbeachca.gov>, Mayor Lemon Grove Racquel Vasquez <rvasquez@lemongrove.ca.gov>, Mayor National City Ron Morrison <rmorrison@nationalcityca.gov>, Mayor Ocean Side Esther Sanchez <esanchez@oceansideca.org>, Mayor Poway Steve Vause <svaus@poway.org>, Mayor Rancho Pales Verdes John Cruikshank <john.cruikshank@rpvca.gov>, Mayor San Diego Todd Gloria <MayorToddGloria@sandiego.gov>, Mayor San Marcos Rebbeca Jones <rjones@san-marcos.net>, Mayor Santee John Minto <Jminto@cityofsanteeca.gov>, Mayor Solana Beach Lesa Heebner <lheebner@cosb.org>, Mayor Vista John Franklin <jfranklin@cityofvista.com>, SD County DA Summer Stephen District Attorney <SanDiegoDA@sdcda.org>, SD County Michael Vu <michael.vu@sdcounty.ca.gov>, SD County Supervisor Chair District 1 Nora Vargas <District1community@sdcounty.ca.gov>, SD County Supervisor District 2 Joel Anderson <joel.anderson@sdcounty.ca.gov>, SD County Supervisor District 3 Terra Lawson Remer <Terra.Lawson- Remer@sdcounty.ca.gov>, SD County Supervisor District 4 Monica Montgomery <Monica.MontgomerySteppe@sdcounty.ca.gov >, SD County Supervisor District 5 Jim Desmond <jim.desmond@sdcounty.ca.gov>, SD County Court Clerk Andrew Potter <Andrew.Potter@sdcounty.ca.gov>, <melanie.burkholder@carlsbadca.gov>, <carolyn.luna@carlsbadca.gov>, <priya.bhat-patel@carlsbadca.gov>, <teresa.acosta@carlsbadca.gov>, Chula Vista Council 1 Carolina Chavez <cchavez@chulavistaca.gov>, Chula Vista Council 2 Jose Preciado <jpreciado@chulavistaca.gov>, Chula Vista Council 3 Alonzo Gozalez <agonzalez@chulavistaca.gov>, Chula Vista Council 4 Rachel Morineau <district4@chulavistaca.gov>, <jekblad@coronado.ca.us>, <mdonovan@coronado.ca.us>, <cdowney@coronado.ca.us>, <ctanaka@coronado.ca.us>, Coronado <jduncan@coronado.ca.us>, Terry Gaasterland <tgaasterland@delmar.ca.us>, <dworden@delmar.ca.us>, <ddruker@delmar.ca.us>, Del Mar Council Dan Quirk <dquirk@delmar.ca.us>, <ablackwell@encinitasca.gov>, <khinze@encinitasca.gov>, <jlyndes@encinitasca.gov>, <behlers@encinitasca.gov>, <cmartinez@escondido.org>, <jgarcia@escondido.org>, <cgarcia@escondido.org>, <mmorasco@escondido.org>, Imperial Beach City Council Carol Seabury <carol.seabury@imperialbeachca.gov>, <jack.fisher@imperialbeachca.gov>, <mitch.mckay@imperialbeachca.gov>, <matthew.leyba-gonzalez@imperialbeachca.gov>, <amalone@lemongrove.ca.gov>, <ggastil@lemongrove.ca.gov>, <lianalebaron@gmail.com>, <jmendoza@lemongrove.ca.gov>, <asnow@lemongrove.ca.gov>, Luz Molina <LMolina@nationalcityca.gov>, <jrodriguez@nationalcityca.gov>, <DYamane@nationalcityca.gov>, <mbush@nationalcityca.gov>, <ejoyce@oceansideca.org>, <rwrobinson@oceansideca.org>, <rkeim@oceansideca.org>, <pweiss@oceansideca.org>, <cgallagher@poway.org>, <bpepin@poway.org>, <aedmondson@poway.org>, <pdehoff@poway.org>, <cfrank@poway.org>, <joelacava@sandiego.gov>, <jennifercampbell@sandiego.gov>, <stephenwhitburn@sandiego.gov>, <raulcampillo@sandiego.gov>, <marnivonwilpert@sandiego.gov>, <KentLee@sandiego.gov>, <VivianMoreno@sandiego.gov>, Vice Chair and SD Dist 9 <seanelorivera@sandiego.gov>, <pscollick@san-marcos.net>, <mnunez@san-marcos.net>, <msannella@san-marcos.net>, <sjenkins@san-marcos.net>, <EMusgrove@san-marcos.net>, <rmcnelis@cityofsanteeca.gov>, <ronnhall@cityofsanteeca.gov>, <lkoval@cityofsanteeca.gov>, <dtrotter@cityofsanteeca.gov>, <dzito@cosb.org>, <kbecker@cosb.org>, <jedson@cosb.org>, <jmacdonald@cosb.org>, <kvaldez@cityofvista.com>, <ccontreras@cityofvista.com>, <jgreen@cityofvista.com>, Katie Melendez <kmelendez@cityofvista.com>, <dodonnell@cityofvista.com>, SANDAG CEO Mario Orso <mario.orso@sandag.org> COPY TO NEWS MAYORS SANDAG STATE REPS CITY COUNCILS SD COUNTY SUPERVISORS BCC TO THE COMMUNITY Good Morning! Page 27 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 4 PLEASE SHARE THIS - CASE STUDY MEDIA BIAS NEWS MAGAZINES, NEWSPAPERS AND TV NEWS BELOW MY SIGNATURE AG THAT CAUSED CRIME CA NO TAX ON TIPS CBS NEWS TWO VERSIONS CBS ATTACKED DONALD TRUMP NO TAX ON TIPS https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-tips-taxes/ CBS PRAISED KAMALA HARRIS STOLE TRUMP PROPOSAL AS HERS https://www.cbsnews.com/news/kamala-harris-taxes-on-tips-trump-proposal/ HISTORY - VP HARRIS SIGNED BILL FOR IRS TO GO AFTER TAX TIPS MISLEADING TITLE FUNDED IRS AGENTS AS "INFLATION REDUCTION ACT" https://fairtax.org/articles/vp-kamala-harris-cast-tie-breaking-vote-to-let-irs-track-workers-tips-so-they-can- be-taxed CASE STUDY IN DEPTH - TIME MAGAZINE Links below to order famous history AP photo magazine cover many of the News attempting to hide. Leading News had called for not publishing the famous photo by Pulitzer AP Photo Journalist; THE PHOTOGRAPH A MOMENT IN HISTORY of attempted assassination of former president, many news organizations have complied by not publishing history AP Pulitzer Journalist photo! NY Post Exposed The News That Called Out To Censor History Photo https://nypost.com/2024/07/17/media/photo-editor-fears-bleeding-trump-pictures-will-be-used-as- propaganda/ NY POST Immediately Published History Photo SAME DAY NEWS https://nypost.com/cover/july-14-2024/ Page 28 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 5 WHICH NEWS CALLED OUT TO CENSOR PHOTO? NY TIMES? WASHINGTON POST? WHO? "Axios cited a photo editor and photographer "from a major news outlet" who suggested the media refrain from using the photo "despite how good it is" to avoid casting the former president in a positive light. "The amount that publications have been using Evan's photo is kind of free PR for Trump in a way, and it's dangerous for media organizations to keep sharing that photo despite how good it is," the editor told the outlet. The photo has been praised as both iconic and instantly historic, and it will be on the next print cover of Time magazine. Some observers have said it could change some people's perceptions forever of Trump, one of the most controversial, beloved and loathed political figures in American history. Vucci, a Pulitzer winner who has covered thousands of similar events for the AP since 2003, told Fox News Digital that he understood he was experiencing a historic moment in time as shots rang out in the direction of the former president." https://www.foxnews.com/media/editor-major-news-outlet-tells-media-bury-iconic-photo-trump-after- assassination-attempt-report Page 29 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 6 Republican presidential candidate former President Trump is surrounded by U.S. Secret Service agents at a campaign rally on Saturday, July 13, 2024 in Butler, Pennsylvania. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci) TIME MAGAZINE CHANGED THE AUG 5 2024 COVER SHIPPED TO ALL THE STORES! Prior To Publish of 08-5-2024 Issue I had contacted Time and tagged many news I posted on July 20 2024 "If @TIME financial smart as 2016 Can Easily Sell Out THIS COVER" @AP @CNN @nytimes @washingtonpost @nypost @ABC @CBSNews @MSNBC @NBCNews @FoxNews @OANN @gatewaypundit @AmericanThinker @FDRLST @realDailyWire @newsmax @EpochTimes @BreitbartNews @bigleaguepol @DailyCaller @theblaze "" Page 30 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 7 My order direct from A360 Magazine Warehouse of $9.99 free shipping of the ORIGINAL CANCELED TO STORES TRUMP COVER Aug 5 2024 Time Magazine came, this version of Time magazine NOT CIRCULATED to stores. Rare Time Magazine issue will be high price collectable years later, I'm keeping my copy of History Trump Assassination Attempt On Time Magazine Cover https://magazineshop.us/products/preorder-time-magazine-08-05-24-edition-attack-on-trump-former- president-survives-shooting-with-nation-on-edge Here is Time Web page with original cover that was canceled to ship out to stores. https://time.com/6998302/trump-rally-shooting-2/ COMPARE NEWS ARTICLES TWO MAGAZINES ABOVE AND BELOW PUBLICATION BIAS INSTEAD OF JUST REPORTING NEWS? Trump On JBS New American magazine, my copy also came in the mail. :) https://thenewamerican.com/product/tna4015/ Page 31 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 8 ALL TIME MAGAZINE COVERS BELOW HAVE THE SAME DATE AUGUST 5 2024! Time Magazine censors history photo GOP Trump proposed this alternate AUG 5 2024 cover: https://time.com/6999339/political-violence-america-unity/ TIME photo illustration; Evan Vucci—AP Time second alternate AUG 5 1024 cover switched to praise Democrat Harris cover: https://time.com/7001028/why-joe-biden-stepped-down/ Page 32 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 9 MEME BELOW INCLUDES WHOLE STORY ADDED CAPTURE OF TRUMP IN THE WAY: FROM ISSUE 07-2-2018 WHEN TIME MAGAZINE LIED IMMIGRANT BABY CRYING POLITIFACT "Immigrant girl on Time cover wasn't separated from mother." https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2018/jun/25/gateway-pundit/immigrant-girl-time-cover-wasnt- separated-mother/ Time censored Trump Cover AP Historical photo final neutral selection sent to stores: THE SAME DATE AUG 5 2024 - SAME ADS - SAME NEWS ARTICLES INSIDE Page 33 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 10 THE HISTORY COVER CHANGED TO TRAVEL OPINION SHIPPED TO STORES https://time.com/7000434/worlds-greatest-places-2024/ CASE STUDY MEDIA BIAS DEMOCRAT VS REPUBLICAN ONE A PRAISE ARTICLE OTHER AN ATTACK ARTICLE AUGUST 26 2024 Time Magazine VP Kamala Harris Refused Interview Gets Praise News Article TIME MAGAZINE CENSORED HISTORY TRUMP SHOOTING COVER CALLS HARRIS HER MOMENT https://time.com/7009317/reintroduction-of-kamala-harris/ Page 34 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 11 December 19 2016 Time Magazine Donald Trump Gives Interview Gets Attack Article TIME AWARDS PERSON YEAR - CALLS PRESIDENT TRUMP DIVIDED STATES AMERICA "Time Person Year better or worse has done the most to influence the events of the year" https://time.com/time-person-of-the-year-2016-donald-trump/ Page 35 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 12 -- Couple great links below my signature BOOKMARK AND SHARE Ballotpedia to research Facts every Candidate and Proposition :) Alan Curry https://ballotpedia.org/Elections M m m https://vote.gov/ M m m REPEAL PROP 47 AG KAMALA HARRIS BILL MISLEADING TITLE "SAFE NEIGHBORHOODS AND SCHOOLS ACT" CHANGED FELONY TO MISDEMEANOR NO JAIL $950 THEFT NO JAIL ENCOURAGE DRUG ABUSE CHARTS AND GRAPHS https://growsf.org/blog/prop-47/ PROP 36 NOVEMBER 2024 BALLOT REPEALS PARTS OF PROP 47 AND RESTORE LAW Page 36 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 13 https://ballotpedia.org/California Proposition 36, Drug and Theft Crime Penalties and Treatment- Mandated Felonies Initiative (2024) M m m Page 37 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 1 Doris Cornejo From:Robert Sent:Friday, August 23, 2024 4:01 PM To:CityClerk; CityAttorney; John McCann; Jose Preciado; HumanResources; Board of Ethics; Communications Subject:public opinion WARNING - This email originated from outside the City of Chula Vista. Do not click any links and do not open attachments unless you can confirm the sender. PLEASE REPORT SUSPICIOUS EMAILS BY USING THE PHISH ALERT REPORT BUTTON or to reportphishing@chulavistaca.gov RESIDENT its not just us who track your progress. Page 38 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 1 REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF ETHICS Meeting Minutes July 17, 2024, 5:15 p.m. City Hall, Bldg. A, Executive Conference Room #103 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA Present: Member Hurst, Member Colon-Torres, Member Salas, Member Torres and Chair Barragan Absent: Member Gersten, Member Velissaropoulos Also Present: Assistant City Attorney Megan McClurg and Secretary Doris Cornejo _____________________________________________________________________ 1. CALL TO ORDER A regular meeting of the Board of Ethics of the City of Chula Vista was called to order at 5:18 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL Secretary Cornejo called the roll. 3. PRESENTATION 3.1 Board of Ethics - Role, Duties, and Procedures Public Comment: Robert provided public comment. Board Members heard presentation. 4. PUBLIC COMMENTS Page 39 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 2 Public Comment: Robert provided public comment. 5. ACTION ITEMS 5.1 Approval of June 12, 2024 Meeting Minutes Minutes approved. 5.2 Written Communications Absence approved. 5.3 Selection of Chair and Vice Chair for Fiscal Year 2024 - 2025 Moved by Member Colon-Torres Seconded by Member Torres Motion to nominate Commissioner Isidro Barragan as Chair and Commissioner Leslie Hurst as Vice Chair for fiscal year 2024-2024. Result: Carried (5 to 0) 5.4 Consideration of and Possible Action on Proposed Annual Report for Fiscal Year 2023 - 2024 on Board of Ethics Activities Moved by Member Colon-Torres Seconded by Member Salas There was consensus of the Board to approve the proposed FY2023-24 Board of Ethics Annual Report and work with staff to send it to City Council. Result: Carried (5 to 0) 5.5 Continued Discussion and Possible Action on Board of Ethics Work Plan for Fiscal Year 2023 - 2024 Board Members of each ad hoc subcommittee updated the board on their findings and progress. Page 40 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda 3 OTHER BUSINESS 6. STAFF COMMENTS Secretary Cornejo provided the Board with City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics business cards and encouraged the Board to promote the openings in the Charter Review Commission. 7. CHAIR'S COMMENTS Chair Isidro thanked staff for being present in the meetings and efforts to make these meetings happen. 8. BOARD MEMBERS' COMMENTS Commissioner Colon-Torres thanked Secretary Cornejo for her help and hard work. 9. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 7:14 p.m. Minutes prepared by: Doris Cornejo, Secretary _________________________ Doris Cornejo, Secretary Page 41 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda Page 42 of 42 City of Chula Vista Board of Ethics September 18, 2024 Agenda