Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Post Agenda Packet ; ; **POST-MEETING AGENDA** Date:Thursday, October 20, 2022 Time:6:00 p.m. Location:Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA Welcome to your Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force Meeting Public Comments: Public comments may be submitted to the Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force in the following ways: In-Person comments during the meeting. Join us for the Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force meeting at the time and location specified on this agenda to make your comments. Please visit www.chulavistaca.gov/boardmeetings for current mask requirements and other safety protocols. • Submit an eComment. Visit www.chulavistaca.gov/boardmeetings, locate this meeting, and click on the comment bubble icon. Click on the item you wish to comment on, and then click on "Leave Comment." The commenting period will close one hour before the meeting. All comments will be made available to the Commission and the public. • Mail or email comments. Submit comments via email to adhernandez@chulavistaca.gov or by mail to Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force, 276 Fourth Ave, Chula Vista, CA 91910. Please send comments early; written comments received within one hour of the meeting may not be distributed until the following day. • Accessibility: Individuals with disabilities are invited to request modifications or accommodations in order to access and/or participate in a Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force meeting by contacting the Office of the City Manager at adhernandez@chulavistaca.gov (California Relay Service is available for the hearing impaired by dialing 711) at least forty-eight hours in advance of the meeting. Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL Task Force Members: Conser, Denaro, Elliot, Enriquez, Hernandez, Kohse, Martinez-Montes, Maynard, Pinto, Sardina, Vice Chair Zamora, and Chair Medina 3.PUBLIC COMMENTS Persons may address the Task Force on any subject matter within their jurisdiction that is not listed as an item on the agenda. State law generally prohibits the Task Force from discussing or taking action on any issue not included on the agenda, but, if appropriate, the Task Force may schedule the topic for future discussion or refer the matter to staff. If you wish to speak on any item, please fill out a "Request to Speak" form and submit it to the Secretary prior to the meeting or submit an electronic comment per the instructions on page one of this agenda. 4.ACTION ITEMS The Item(s) listed in this section of the agenda will be considered individually by the Task Force and are expected to elicit discussion and deliberation. If you wish to speak on any item, please fill out a "Request to Speak" form and submit it to the Secretary prior to the meeting or submit an electronic comment per the instructions on page one of this agenda. 4.1.Approval of Meeting Minutes 4 Approval of Minutes from September 21, 2022 Recommended Action: Task Force approve minutes. 4.2.Consideration of Statements of Interest for Acquisition of the Columbus Statue Including Action to Determine Recommended Disposition 8 Task Force to consider one Statement of Interest submitted by Sons of Italy - Fratellanza Garibaldina, Lodge #1627 including responses to Task Force questions. Recommended Action: Task Force discuss and recommend disposition of Columbus Statue for City Council consideration. 4.3.Consideration of a Framework for Monument Installation or Removal and City Asset Naming or Renaming 26 Framework includes guidelines and procedures for the installation, removal and disposition of monuments as well as naming or renaming City assets. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 2 of 56 Recommended Action: Task Force discuss and take action, as appropriate, on proposed Framework. 4.4.Consideration and Possible Action Regarding Proposals for the Renaming of Discovery Park and Proposals for Marker Language 55 Task Force to consider proposals for the renaming of Discovery Park and marker language to place at the former site of the Columbus Statue. Recommended Action: Task Force discuss and take action as appropriate. 4.5.Authorizing the Chair to Work With Staff to Present Task Force Recommendations to City Council Chair Medina to work with staff to prepare final presentation including possible Memorandum to City Council with Task Force recommendations. Recommended Action: Task Force discuss and take action as appropriate. OTHER BUSINESS 5.STAFF COMMENTS 6.CHAIR'S COMMENTS 7.TASK FORCE MEMBER COMMENTS 8.ADJOURNMENT Materials provided to the Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force related to any open-session item on this agenda are available for public review by contacting ADHernandez@chulavistaca.gov. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 3 of 56 1 REGULAR MEETING OF THE CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS STATUE AND DISCOVERY PARK TASK FORCE Meeting Minutes September 21, 2022, 6:00 p.m. Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA Present: Member Conser, Member Elliott-Santos, Member Enriquez, Member Hernandez, Member Kean-Ayub, Member Kohse, Member Maynard, Member Denaro, Vice Chair Zamora, Chair Medina Absent: Member Pinto Also Present: Secretary Hernandez Others Present Marketing and Communications Manager Anne Steinberger _____________________________________________________________________ Member Kohse joined the meeting at 6:08 pm. Member Enriquez joined the meeting at 6:14 pm. Member Hernandez joined the meeting at 6:24 pm. Member Elliott-Santos joined the meeting at 6:40 pm. 1. CALL TO ORDER A special meeting of the Christopher Columbus Statue and Discovery Park Task Force of the City Council of the City of Chula Vista was ca lled to order at 6:03 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, located at 276 Fourth Ave Chula Vista, CA 91910. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 4 of 56 2 Chair Medina opened the meeting welcoming two new members to the Task Force, Salvatore Denaro and Nadia Kean-Ayub. Chair Medina requested a moment of silence in honor of Deputy City Attorney Simon Silva. 2. ROLL CALL Secretary Hernandez called the roll. 3. PUBLIC COMMENTS No public comment. 4. ACTION ITEMS 4.1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Moved by Member Conser Seconded by Member Maynard Task Force approve minutes. Yes (5): Member Conser, Member Kohse, Member Maynard, Member Denaro, and Chair Medina Abstain (2): Member Kean-Ayub, and Vice Chair Zamora Result: Defeated (5 to 0) Amendment: Moved by Member Kohse Seconded by Member Maynard Task Force approve minutes. Yes (9): Member Conser, Member Elliott-Santos, Member Enriquez, Member Hernandez, Member Kohse, Member Maynard, Member Denaro, Vice Chair Zamora, and Chair Medina Abstain (1): Member Kean-Ayub Result: Carried (9 to 0) 4.2 Consideration of Statements of Interests for Acquisition of the Columbus Statue Including Action to Determine Recommended Disposition Chair Medina introduced the item and discussion ensued. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 5 of 56 3 Consensus was reached to submit the following questions to the applicant, Sons and Daughters of Italy, regarding their application and allow for two weeks to respond: 1. Assurances regarding language for a plaque 2. What are the plans for the statue after the Italian American Club in Las Vegas or will it be on permanent loan there? 3. Define types of locations (private vs. public) 4. For what purpose does the applicant want the statue? 5. Why are Sons and Daughters of Italy interested in the statue? 6. Does the Italian American Club have interest in taking ownership? Robert Johnson submitted an e-comment opposed to the item. Vincent Ferrer submitted an email regarding McMillin's history with the Columbus Statue. 4.3 Discussion and Possible Action Regarding a Draft Proposal for a Framework for Naming Parks and/or Other City Facilities Chair Medina introduced the item and discussion ensued with feedback being given on a number of items on the draft document. The Framework Ad-Hoc Subcommittee will work to incorporate the feedback received and bring back a final draft for the Task Force's consideration at its October meeting. Robert Johnson submitted an e-comment opposed to this item. 4.4 Discussion of the Annual Report of Activities and Authorize the Chair to Work With Staff to Finalize and Submit Chair Medina and Staff Liaison Adrianna Hernandez introduced the item and discussion ensued. Moved by Member Enriquez Seconded by Member Kohse Authorize the Chair to work with Staff to finalize and submit report. Yes (10): Member Conser, Member Elliott-Santos, Member Enriquez, Member Hernandez, Member Kean-Ayub, Member Kohse, Member Maynard, Member Denaro, Vice Chair Zamora, and Chair Medina 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 6 of 56 4 Result: Carried (10 to 0) OTHER BUSINESS 5. STAFF COMMENTS No staff comments. 6. CHAIR'S COMMENTS Chair Medina thanked everyone for being at this meeting. Chair recognizes that the process is important and appreciates everyone's patience, time and energy. Chair Medina shared the City is planning an Indigenous Peoples Day celebration and hopes Task Force members can attend. 7. TASK FORCE MEMBER COMMENTS Member Kohse requested adding the re-naming of the park to the next meeting agenda and reminded the Task Force that there are still arts grant funds available, although diminishing, and encouraged those interested in placing a work of art at the park to apply. Vice Chair Zamora thanked Chair Medina for his leadership and expressed her willingness to assist with workload. Member Kean-Ayub shared an invitation for a retirement party for Mayor Mary Casillas Salas. Member Enriquez shared her appreciation for Deputy City Attorney Simon Silva and his work on behalf of the Task Force. 8. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 8:08 p.m. Minutes prepared by: Adrianna Hernandez, Secretary _________________________ Adrianna Hernandez, Commission Secretary 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 7 of 56 1 Adrianna Hernandez From:webmaster@chulavistaca.gov Sent:Saturday, August 13, 2022 11:32 AM To:Adrianna Hernandez Subject:Request for Statements of Interest Entry A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Request for Statements of Interest (RFI)- Columbus Statue Date & Time: 08/13/2022 11:31 AM Response #: 2 Submitter ID: 104054 IP address: 72.192.175.41 Time to complete: 59 min. , 19 sec. Survey Details Page 1 On May 25, 2021, the Chula Vista City Council considered and approved the permanent removal of the Christopher Columbus statue and at their September 28, 2021 Council meeting, appointed a Task Force to consider, among other things, recommending a disposition of the statue for City Council consideration. The Christopher Columbus and Discovery Park Task Force is seeking statements of interest to transfer ownership of a statue/outdoor bronze sculpture (“Statue”) created by Mario Zamora, a world-renowned artist, to an entity, upon terms deemed by the Task Force to be appropriate and advantageous. From June 15, 2022 through August 13, 2022 at 5 p.m., this offer is extended to any museum, historical society, educational organization, or other entities interested in acquiring statues for relocation and placement. The recipient would be responsible for any and all costs associated with relocating the Statue. Transfer recommendations are subject to City Council approval. The Task Force issues this Request for Statements of Interest (“RFI”) to determine whether, and how many, entities are or may be interested in discussing specific terms for acquisition of the Statue. See Resolution 2021-132. The Statue that is subject of this RFI is a bronze/sculpture of Christopher Columbus, currently being stored at a city facility. Information regarding the Christopher Columbus Statue can be found at: http://collections.si.edu/search/detail/edanmdm:siris_ari_321831. Warning: External Email 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 8 of 56 2 Note: this RFI is not a solicitation for procurement of goods and/or services; no contract for goods or services will be awarded as a result of this RFI. SECTION 2: MANDATORY RESPONSE FORM STATEMENT OF INTEREST SUBMITTED IN RESPONSE TO CITY RFI # 22-001 Provide the following information: 1. Entity Name Sons of Italy - Fratellanza Garibaldina, Lodge #1627 2. Office [Physical] Address , Escondido, CA 92026 3. Contact Name [Authorized Representative] Salvatore Denaro 4. Title Member of the Board - Immediate Past President 5. Telephone Number 6. Entity Website URL www.sonsofitalysd-1627.org 7. Email 8. Type of Entity [check at least one]: [×] Other (please specify) Cultural/Educational/Charitable/Fraternal Non-profit 9. Is the Entity an IRS 501(C)(3)? (○) Yes 10. Attach documentation verifying the type of entity, and your entity’s 501(c)(3) status [if applicable] STATE EXEMPTION FED ID.pdf 11. Please provide a brief description of your entity or organization 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 9 of 56 3 The Order of the Sons & Daughters of Italy (formerly Order of the Sons of Italy) was founded in 1905 by six Italian immigrants who came to the United States during the great Italian migration (1880-1923) One of the original founders, Giuseppe Carlino, was a sculptor. The order was founded on the principals of liberty, equality and fraternity. It originally focused on improving the life of the early Italian immigrants who were often oppressed and marginalized. The order did so by providing Italian-American immigrants articulate leadership, responsible representation in civic matters, and economic institutions to function for its members. The first lodge was established in California in 1922 and the Fratellanza Garibaldina Lodge #1627 i s celebrating its 90th anniversary in 2022. Today, the Order seeks to address itself to the changing needs of its members. Scholarship grants, funded college aid and assistance programs, leadership in promoting more equitable immigration laws, intense activity in civic and local governmental programs, promoting a more positive tone in public relations to offset the rising tide of anti-defamation are part of the Order’s working programs. We are dedicated to promoting our culture, traditions, language, ancestors' legacy, and contributions to the U.S. and the world. 12. Are you interested in acquiring the Statue for relocation and placement? (○) Yes 13. Please provide an explanation for your interest and if acquired, how the Statue will be displayed and for what purpose. Explanation may be up to five-pages in length including maps or placement diagrams. * (See Note 1) Note 1: In your explanation above, please also provide the following information:  Organization Mission Statement  Year Organization was established  Location where statue is intended to be displayed  Public access to statue, if any  Knowledge/Experience of Artists’ Moral Rights under the Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA) and the California Art Preservation Act (CAPA)  Ability to maintain the statue  Ability to fund relocation, maintain and repair the statue Note 2: Any transfer of ownership of the statue to an interested entity would require approval by majority vote of City Council and would be subject to negotiated terms and conditions. The Statue is to be provided in an “AS IS CONDITION.” The recipient of the Statue would have to comply with any and all legal requirements regarding the Artist’s rights under the Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA) and the California Art Preservation Act (CAPA). The recipient would be responsible for any and all costs associated with the acquisition and removal of the Statue from city property. The City may also require follow-up questions in-writing and/or in-person. See attachment detailing responses to each of the Note 1 requirements. Sons of Italy Statement of Interest re Columbus Statue.docx SECTION 3. INSTRUCTIONS Process  Submit application within (60) sixty days of issue date  City staff meeting to review completeness of application within approximately (15) days of filing 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 10 of 56 4  Potential Columbus and Discovery Park Task Force Presentation/Interview at date to be determined  Selection notices will be distributed Questions regarding this RFI? Contact: Adrianna Hernandez, Senior Management Analyst, Office of the City Manager Telephone: 619-691-5254 Email: Adhernandez@chulavistaca.gov **Responders should NOT submit questions or requests for information to any other City officials or employees. Thank you, City of Chula Vista This is an automated message generated by Granicus. Please do not reply directly to this email. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 11 of 56 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 12 of 56 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 13 of 56 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 14 of 56 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 15 of 56 Statement of Interest Submitted by Sons & Daughters of Italy, Fratellanza Garibaldina, Lodge #1627 (“Sons of Italy”) Organization Mission Statement We are a national organization of men and women who represent the estimated 17 million Americans of Italian heritage, dedicated to promoting our culture, our traditions, our language, the legacy of our ancestors, and our contributions to the U.S. and the world. We are sons and daughters, grandmothers and grandfathers. We are corporate executives and we are union members…young students and retirees…teachers and attorneys…doctors and firefighters…bakers and Wall Street brokers…and everything in between. We are philanthropists and we are model global citizens with purpose beyond ourselves. And we are proud and patriotic Americans of Italian heritage. We exemplify the very best of what it is to be Italian American. Year Established The Order of the Sons & Daughters of Italy in America (formerly the Order of the Sons of Italy in America) was established in 1905. Lodge #1627, Fratellanza Garibaldina, was established in 1932 in San Diego. Its missions include encouraging the study of Italian language and culture in American schools and universities; preserving Italian American traditions, culture, history and heritage; and promoting closer cultural relations between the United States and Italy. Location of Display Sons of Italy proposes it acquires Mario Zamora’s Columbus Statue (“Statue”) and place the statue in a venue where it can be protected, preserved, and honored as a work of art, while also being available for any member of the public to view. We propose a common arrangement in the art world, specifically placement of the statue on long-term loan in suitable locations. Sons of Italy proposes to initially place the Statue at the Italian American Club in Las Vegas (“IAC”). The IAC was established in 1960 and has a building it owns at 2333 E. Sahara Ave Las Vegas, NV 89104. As a non-profit social club, the IAC is a hub of the Italian-American community, not only within Las Vegas, but for those visiting from around the country. They host concerts, banquets, Bocce tournaments as well as grant scholarships and promote Italian-American culture and heritage. (See https://www.iacvegas.com/) Importantly, the IAC facility is used to host meetings of a number of different non-profit Italian-American organizations including Sons of Italy, Knights of Columbus and others. The facility has large protected rear patio area where the Statue would be placed. Should any member of the public request to see the Statue, they will be allowed to do so. The map view of the IAC can be seen on Google Maps reflecting the rear patio behind the main building. https://www.google.com/maps/@36.145532,-115.1160438,104m/data=!3m1!1e3 Photos of the IAC are included below. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 16 of 56 Public Access to Statue The proposed placement of the statue is on private commercial property. It will be available for any member of the public to view upon request during open hours. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 17 of 56 Knowledge/Experience of Artists Moral Rights under the VARA and CAPA One of the six founding members of the Sons of Italy in 1905 was an Italian-American sculptor, Giuseppe Carlino. The Sons of Italy appreciate there is a great public interest in preserving the integrity of cultural and artistic creations. The Italians as a people are not only known for their contributions to the art world, but have a deep history and cultural values related to the protection and conservation of art in all its forms. Italy is often used as a point of reference in the worldwide conservation community and Sons of Italy views the potential acquisition of the Statue as a great honor that comes with greater responsibility. Our organization appreciates the contributions of art and the need to preserve and protect the artists work and reputation. As such, if granted ownership of the statue, Sons of Italy would take every step possible to ensure this work of art and the reputation of Mario Zamora and his work is protected. The Smithsonian Institution has registered Zamora’s Columbus sculpture as significant to the Italian culture. (See https://collections.si.edu/search/detail/edanmdm:siris_ari_321831?q=%22Zamora%2C+Mario+1920- %22&record=2&hlterm=%26quot%3BZamora%2C%2BMario%2B1920-%26quot%3B) When the statue was commissioned for placement in the Rancho Del Rey community in Chula Vista, it was to honor the spirit of discovery, courage and exploration. This theme was a centerpiece of the community that was built on land that was part of the Spanish land grants. Ability to Maintain the Statue Sons of Italy is a well-established organization with over a century of history. Our organization has the ability to maintain the Statue as needed indefinitely. Ability to Fund Relocation, maintain and repair the statue. Sons of Italy has the ability to fund relocation of the Statue by professionals and will obtain proper insurance for transport. The maintenance and any necessary repair can and will be funded by Sons of Italy. Closing Thoughts The excerpt below is taken from the inaugural address by one of the six founders of the Sons of Italy, Dr. Vincenzo Sellaro on June 22, 1905. It reflects the spirit in which the organization was founded, and the realities of an oppressed people who left their land in order to survive and build a better life. It also reflects the spirit of courage, tenacity, self-improvement, and sense of community that embodied much of the Italian-American spirit. “Today we are gathered together for one main purpose, that I want to believe someday will become a very important part of American history. We are the newest of the immigrants to this great country, and because of the fierce and undeserved prejudice and discrimination that we have had to suffer for nearly two decades, we must begin to work together, for our common good. We must educate ourselves, and insist that our children receive the best and highest education possible. Only through this education will we understand the ways and beliefs of this marvelous adopted country of ours, and be treated as equal 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 18 of 56 and worthy American citizens. We left our native land for a new life, in order to survive. Our former country with its government demonstrated after so many years of trying, that it was simply not capable of providing for us the life we deserved—a decent life, a respectable life. The majority of us have come to these shores as the poorest of all Italians, and the least educated of most of Europe. But today I must also share with you that we are also the most courageous for having made the decision to come here, to have left behind our motherland and our families, in the hope, not to find a new life, but to earn a better one. Where only a few of us, before leaving Italy were fortunate enough to have received an education, many of you-us, have reached these shores as common laborers, tenant farmers, field workers and shepherds, gardeners, fishermen, but just as many as artisans, such as masons, carpenters, stonecutters, bakers, tailors and miners. Second to none has been our contribution of tradesmen, lawyers, teachers, accountants, entrepreneurs, pharmacists, and yes, doctors as wel….. Some say that history has dealt us a lousy hand, being that we are the last to come to America. After all, wasn’t it one of our own who discovered America? I say to them that the others, for the most part, came here with masters, came as slaves in many cases. We, on the other hand, have come of our own accord. We are a free people. It is because of this that today I have a dream, and hope that someday, even if it takes a hundred more years before we are fully accepted, our children and their children’s children, even if they carry a single drop of Italian blood will be able and proud to continue to carry on our traditions, our culture and our language. It is up to us, and what we do today!” 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 19 of 56 October 6, 2022 City of Chula Vista Columbus Statue Task Force 276 F St Chula Vista, CA Sent Via Email Re: Sons and Daughters of Italy Interest in Columbus Statue Dear Task Force Members: The following information is provided in response to your recent requests related to our organization’s interest in the Columbus Status as enumerated below. 1. Could Sons and Daughters of Italy make any assurances regarding language to be used for a plaque? At present, the Sons and Daughters of Italy does not have proposed language. The organization is open to the input of the Task Force in that regard. At a minimum, any plaque would credit the artist for his work. Language on any plaque could be negotiated with the initial suggestion that it be neutral and non-political. 2. What are the plans for the statue after Italian American Club in Las Vegas? Or, will it be on permanent loan there? There are no plans for future placement after the Italian American Club in Las Vegas at this time. The intention would be to have it on semi-permanent loan there with an agreement that if Sons and Daughters of Italy were to acquire a facility in Southern California it would return to the area. Alternatively, despite the long history of the Italian American Club in Las Vegas and its ownership of its building, if the property sold or the business closed, Sons and Daughters of Italy would take possession of the statue and place it at an alternative location. Lastly, in the event that an Italian-American heritage museum were to open in San 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 20 of 56 Diego, the statue would return to San Diego for placement there. There are currently proposals and fund-raising efforts for such a museum in San Diego. 3. Please define the types of locations the Sons and Daughters of Italy would pursue placement at? Specifically, please identify if they are public or private locations. Placement is anticipated at private locations that are open to the public, but not public spaces or property. For example, future locations sought would include museums, cultural centers, or an Italian-American organization’s location. 4. For what purpose, and why, do the Sons and Daughters of Italy want the statue? Context is important in answering this question. The short answer is history and culture. It is also important to note that the answer may vary if you were to ask individual members. The primary response, which we believe is nearly uniform, is the historical relevance of Columbus to the Italian-American immigration story in the late 1800s and continuing through the first several decades of the 20th century when millions of Italian Immigrants came to the United States. This was 400 years after Columbus arrived in America. The majority of Italian-Americans today are the descendants of immigrants who arrived here in the late 1800s through the early 1920s. Many experienced hostility, discrimination and even violence. Many fled poverty and sought opportunities, religious freedom and risked everything when they courageously left their homes and families to pursue a better life. It is also important to note that at that time, Italians identified with the region they were from rather than as a united people. While it is impossible to present a uniform statement as to what Columbus represents to individuals within our organization, there is the acknowledgment that Columbus was a unifying figure among the Italian-American community in the early 1900s. The idea that Italians as a whole should come together to support one another and promote education, success, and continuation of their collective culture was a cornerstone of the establishment of the Sons of Italy more than 100 years ago. Italians remained proud of their individual roots while realizing the strength of coming together. A general holiday (the precursor to formal “Columbus Day”), came on the heels of the infamous lynching of Italian-American men in New Orleans in 1891. When it was recognized as a national holiday in 1937, President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s proclamation described Columbus as a “brave navigator” whose voyage “was the culmination of years of bold speculation, careful preparation, and struggle against opponents who had belittled his great plan and thwarted its execution.” The description of Columbus was something many Italian- Americans could related to. Our organization promotes liberty and equality. There is no argument that much of the history of Columbus is inconsistent with the ideals of our organization. He was also brave 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 21 of 56 and bold, like many of the Italian immigrants. Both the good and the bad are part of the history which cannot be erased. 5. Does the Italian American Club in Las Vegas have interest in taking permanent ownership of the statue? No. Many members of the Italian American Club in Las Vegas are also Sons and Daughters of Italy members. The desire is to have a safe place where the statue can be preserved and protected and appreciated as a work of art. Should you have any additional questions, please don’t hesitate to ask. Our organization welcomes the opportunity to work with the City of Chula Vista and this task force. Sincerely, /s/ Sal Denaro Sal Denaro Immediate Past-President 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 22 of 56 1 Adrianna Hernandez From:Vincent G Ferrer Sent:Friday, August 12, 2022 1:08 PM To:Adrianna Hernandez Subject:RE: Friendly Reminder: Deadline Approaching for Columbus Statue RFI Attachments:Personal Recollections regarding Christopher Columbus Statue in Discovery Park.pdf Good afternoon Adrianna, As you know, the McMillin Family and The Corky McMillin Companies have deep roots in Chula Vista, as the homegrown developer and builder of many masterplanned communities within the City and surrounding areas, as well as many philanthropic efforts throughout the community. The Christopher Columbus statue was created for the new Discovery Park in McMillin’s Rancho Del Rey in the early 90’s, and we thought it important to share with the committee and City leaders the history of its commissioning through the personal recollections of Sandy Perlatti, our long-time executive marketing director. Because of our history with its creation, we’re very interested in its future. As an option, if the City through these current efforts is unable to find a suitable home, we’d like you to consider us to be the caretaker of the statue for safe keeping on private property, and subject to whatever conditional requirements the City would impose, including any messaging if it were on display. Please feel free to contact me for any additional questions or information. Respectfully, Vince Vincent G Ferrer EVP | mcmillin, LLC Warning: External Email 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 23 of 56 Personal Recollections regarding Christopher Columbus Statue in Discovery Park, Chula Vista, CA Scott, When I returned to McMillin in January, 1990 from my short hiatus working for Home Capital and the Baldwin Company, we were in the final stages of planning the Grand Opening of Rancho del Rey. Prior to my arrival, Rick Davidson had worked very hard and passionately on the theme for the master-planned community. The creative team wanted to tie Rancho del Rey (Ranch of the King) to the history of the land and to identify with classical Spain’s architecture. They also realized that the 500-yrar anniversary of Christopher Columbus ‘s discovery of America was coming up in 1992. At that time, I believe the creative team to include Gary Meads (Knoth & Meads Advertising Agency), Jim Frampton of Jim Frampton and Associates and Bob Young of Motivational Systems, Inc. I believe ONA was our master-planned landscape company. The sculpture by Mario Zamora was to be the centerpiece of Discovery Park which celebrated the 500-year milestone since Christopher Columbus discovered America. The dates of 1492-1992 were on the bronze plaque installed with the statue. We paid in excess of $100,000 for this lovely bronze statue and it breaks my heart that it has been vandalized and threatened for destruction. Mario Zamora came to our office during the process of creating the statue. He wanted to make sure we had the proper instructions for installing the statue. As I remember, he did not speak English and we had to have a translator. The decision was to show Columbus as an explorer, a discoverer of the new land and thus the name Discovery Park. The emphasis was to be on Christopher Columbus as an explorer and not the highly decorated hero he became once he returned to Spain following his conquest. At this point in time, I don’t believe there was any controversy regarding Christopher Columbus and his contribution to history. Mario Zamora created a small- scale version of the statue for us to approve prior to creating the large, permanent version. It was in Corky’s office for many years. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 24 of 56 Our Community Relations department visited the nearby schools and the students created the colorful tiles that were installed on a dedicated bench in the park. The students were asked to create the tiles with the discovery theme and many of them were depictions of the ships that came over with Christopher Columbus. We were always very proud of the marketing of Rancho del Rey and won awards for the park, the information center, the brochure, advertisements and public relations campaign. The Grand Opening involved guests picking up a mock passport and having it stamped at each of the current selling projects within Rancho del Rey and then turned into the Information Center for a drawing. The grand prize drawing was held for an actual “trip to Spain”. I think it would be nice to see if there is an institution that would like the statue that is affiliated with discovery and history that would not consider the statue to represent the negative aspects of the conquest that are at this point in time so controversial. Do you think the San Diego History Center would consider having it? Just a thought. Carolyn and Joe Shielly have stayed in touch with Rick Davidson if you would like to reach out to him for his personal memories of creating the theme, etc. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 25 of 56 Monument Installation and Naming/Renaming City Assets FRAMEWORK I.Background Statement A.To provide history, context, and rationale for proposed the framework II.Definitions A.To build a common understanding of terms used within the framework III.Tenets and Values A.To remind all stakeholders about the deep values and tenets that ideally root the City of Chula Vista IV.Guidelines A.General rules and instruction about naming City assets and monument installation V.Process and Procedures A.Steps for the application, review, and approval process 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 26 of 56 I.Background Statement On September 28, 2021, the Chula Vista City Council heard public comment from various community members and commissions in order to address the permanent disposition of the Christopher Columbus statue in Discovery Park and the renaming of Discovery Park. Council voted to establish a task force (Columbus Statue Removal Task Force) composed of the Human Relations Commission, Parks & Recreation Commission, Cultural Arts Commission, Kumeyaay community, and Sons and Daughters of Italy to address the following items:Disposition of Christopher Columbus statue; renaming of Discovery Park; identifying replacement artwork; and the development of a framework to guide the city with naming/renaming of City assets and installation of future monuments.The City of Chula Vista currently does not have a formal policy regarding the naming or renaming of City assets or monument installation. The City, through its departments, and advisory boards and commissions, has followed a number of processes/policies for naming or renaming its parks, libraries and other City assets, as well as monument installation. The Columbus Statue Removal Task Force utilized various steps in order to develop a framework that would provide the City with a clear protocol for future naming, renaming, and monument installation requests while ensuring transparency and allowing for public participation throughout the process. The task force researched similar efforts, discussions, and policies from surrounding cities, as well as other cities within California, and drew upon best practices from each. The task force developed and approved a framework with the purpose of establishing uniform guidelines for the naming and renaming of City assets, as well as to establish criteria and guidelines for the consideration and installation of monuments deemed by the City to be appropriate. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 27 of 56 II.Definitions1 City Assets Tangible or intangible items of value that are owned or created by the City, including but not limited to both City facilities. This definition does NOT include PUBLIC ARTWORK, City Facility (included in City Assets) Any part of real property or structure owned by the City or for which naming rights or monument installation are conferred by agreement, including, but not limited to parks, libraries, Recreational Facilities buildings, parking facilities, interior or ancillary features that are a part of, or within, a larger facility and other City facilities. Commission Commission as recognized by the City of Chula Vista City Council and/or City Charter; Commemoration Refers to specific events on the anniversaries of events designated of importance to the City, typically held annually and often in conjunctions with sites or markers or markers of memorialization. Department Director Appointed director of the department that oversees the City Asset eligible for naming, renaming, or monument installation. The director may assign this responsibility to other department staff within their delegation of authority. Donation or gift A monetary (cash) contribution, endowments, personal property, real property, financial securities, equipment, in-kind goods or services, or any other City Asset that the City has accepted and for which the donor has not received any goods or services in return. For purposes of this Council Policy, the terms 1 Definitions influenced by City of San Diego Council Policy 900-20, Naming of City Assets 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 28 of 56 “donation” and “gift” shall be synonymous. Donor A person or other legal entity that proposes or provides a donation to the City. Funding Financial or in-kind resources to provide funding that might result in naming or renaming. Funding Source The source of funding which can include individuals, nonprofit organizations, and for-profit entities. Marker Permanent writing on plaques, walls, stone carvings, pavers, bricks, electronic display, or interpretive signs that are temporary or permanent and are used to memorialize; also considered a monument Memorialization intentional attempt to give importance to particular people, sites, events, incidents in the historical record of the City through the placement of monuments, plaques, statues or other markers. Monument Markers, statues, and other similar permanent installations which are installed on City property with City permission. Monuments may be in various forms including statues, fountains, or gardens among other forms of monuments as determined by the city. Naming The selection and approval by the City for the initial naming of a City Asset other than streets within the public right of way. Non-Profit Organization A corporation or an association that conducts business for the benefit of the general public without shareholders and without a profit motive. Public Art In contrast to the presumed permanence of 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 29 of 56 monuments, this includes more temporary installations wherein aesthetic considerations take precedence over historic significance. Approval lies with the Cultural Arts commission Renaming The selection and approval by the City for a new name of an existing City Asset other than streets within the public right of way. Work of art While both public monuments and public art/installations can be commonly referred to as ‘works of art’, each carry an important distinction in historical versus aesthetic significance, as well as protocols for approval, as noted in the definitions in this document III.Guiding Principles/Tenets/Values ❖Process Matters as Much as Outcome:We aim to take time for quality, move at the speed of trust, and cultivate relationships beyond the life of a single monument and/or name. We strive for a powerful final result that is fueled by intentional and iterative processes. We balance urgency and timeliness with purposeful 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 30 of 56 reflection. We work collectively with Kumeyaay communities to review history. ❖Truth Telling and Accountability:We work towards acknowledging a comprehensive and robust history of our region. ❖Elimination of Prejudice and Discrimination : We acknowledge that the historical and contemporary practices of monument installation and the naming/renaming of public assets has created harm and continues to marginalize communities and community members. The installation of monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets must thoroughly vet efforts, donations, and proposals that inflame prejudice, bigotry, and discrimination. ❖Welcoming City:We believe that truly welcoming places have intentional, inclusive policies, practices, and norms that enable all (especially those marginalized) community members to live, thrive, and contribute fully. ❖Public Memory and Memorialization is POWER:Monuments, naming, and renaming can convey a powerful connection between Chula Vista and its history, and in some instances its future. It is therefore important that the placement of monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets be limited to circumstances of the highest community-wide importance, to maintain the significant difference between commemoration and memorialization.2 IV.Guidelines Our communities are dynamic as they continue to change in many ways. The ethnic and racial compositions of our communities are an integral part of this change, as we have witnessed shifting community demographics over time. The process of monument installation and the naming/renaming of city assets must engage the concept of permanence in an ever changing society. Therefore monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets should have a broad acceptance in a multicultural 2 City of San José, Council Policy 9-14, Monument Policy 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 31 of 56 society while also considering future generations. The City may name/rename City assets and/or install or accept City-approved monuments on City property as a form of “Government Speech” as City recognition of significant events or people or to provide information from the City on topics approved by the City, as set forth below: a.The contributions of individuals or groups who made a substantial impact upon the City of Chula Vista: b.The history of Chula Vista: c.Historical or cultural influences on Chula Vista; d.Native flora, fauna and wildlife of Chula Vista and the greater South County area; e.Local innovation or creativity that has contributed to Chula Vista’s growth and prosperity; or f.Other criteria selected by City Council and set forth in an amendment to this Policy. Order of Preference : Monument installation and the naming/renaming of city assets are pursuant to the following guidelines in order of preference: 1.Geographic Location.Whenever possible, all City assets will be considered for their geographic location. Creating names and monument installation based on the asset’s geographic location should be considered first. The geographic location may be based on the relationship of the asset to a specific place, neighborhood, major street, regional area of the City or the City’s name if the asset serves the entire community. 2.Other Considerations.Consideration of monuments and names may also include a prominent form of topography, prominent flora, and cultural or historical precedent. 3.Extraordinary Circumstances.Only under extraordinary circumstances and broad public support will the City consider monument installation and the naming/renaming after a person or group. Monument Installation or an asset may be named in memory, or honor of, an individual or group if it fulfills the criteria outlined in this policy: i.The person or organization made lasting and significant contributions to the protection of natural or cultural resources of the City of Chula Vista; or ii.The person or organization had a significant positive impact on the lives of Chula Vista’s residents; or 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 32 of 56 iii.The person or organization offered a lifetime of volunteerism and service to the community; iv.The naming of the person or organization does not result in the excessive commercialization of the City asset. V. Process and Procedures Monument Review Process ●The City Manager or designee shall provide the initial screening of monument proposals to determine if the proposed monument complies with the provisions of this framework (policy) including without limitation, to evaluate the suitability of the proposed monument site, if any. ●The City Manager (or designee) shall decide whether to forward the proposal for further review or to decline further City consideration of the proposed monument based upon considerations consistent with 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 33 of 56 this framework (Policy). ●If the City Manager’s decision is to conduct further review of the proposal, the City Manager or designee, shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s for consultation and the City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the proposed site and objectives of the Monument. If there is a doubt regarding the appropriate commission, the City Manager shall determine the appropriate commission for review of the proposal. ●The city manager or department shall prepare a report for consideration by the commission, and coordinate with all other departments and commissions that are relevant to the proposed monument. ●The commission/s shall review the proposed monument to make an advisory recommendation to the City Manager regarding the monument based upon the factors set forth in this framework (Policy) and the Review Criteria set forth below. Each monument applicant or donor shall be informed in writing of their right to appeal the City Manager’s decision in the monument donation/application materials prepared by the City. ●If a proponent for a proposed monument disagrees with the City Manager’s decision regarding a proposed monument, the proponent may submit a written appeal of the City Manager’s decision to the City Manager within 30 calendar days of the City Manager’s decision. ●The City Manager and the overseeing commission/s shall evaluate the merits of the appeal and determine whether to forward the appeal to City Council pursuant to the Council meeting rules. ●City Council shall make a final determination on the approval or denial of the Monument proposal by evaluating (i) the merits of the Monument proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy), (ii) City Manager’s reason for denial, (iii) the results of any staff review of the proposal, and (iv) the recommendations of the appropriate City Commission. Monument Review Criteria ●A proposed monument must conform to the approved Government Speech 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 34 of 56 topics and reflect the values and tenets listed within this framework (policy). The proposed monument is not objectionable to the persons or community including those that the monument is intended to honor. If through the public outreach process, the City Manager finds that a proposed Monument is a source of substantial dissension or discord within the City, the City Manager shall seek further direction from departments and commissions before making a final determination. ●A Monument must be made of durable materials, able to withstand the elements for a minimum of 50 years with minimum maintenance, shall be made of materials resistant to vandalism and graffiti as much as is reasonably possible, shall be of a scale, materials, color and style appropriate and consistent with aesthetics of the proposed location of the Monument and such other reasonable factors as City Manager determines. ●The Monument proposal has been through community outreach conducted by the group or person suggesting that the City install the Monument, and that the installation and maintenance of the Monument is within the priorities of the work plan of the responsible Department. ○Community Outreach shall be directed to specific interested groups, that can include: i.Public notification of proposed changes through media or a public meeting ii.Outreach to specific local organizations that may be considered stakeholders, i.e., South Bay Community Services, YMCA, Southwestern College, other Non-profit organizations located within the City, local school districts, etc. ●The City may decline to approve or to accept a monument for any lawful reason. ●Monument proposals shall be considered by the applicable (or closest applicable) City commission/s and department/s associated with the proposed location for the monument. That commission shall make a recommendation to the City Manager for approval or disapproval based on consistency with this framework (Policy) and as further described in the Review Process. The City Manager may accept or deny the recommendation 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 35 of 56 from the commission as further provided in the review process. ●The City shall only proceed with the design, fabrication, and installation of a monument after completion of the review process and the conclusion is to move forward. In reviewing a proposed monument, the relevant departments, the applicable City Commission and City Manager shall review the proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy). Monument Removal Process The City Manager or designee shall provide the initial screening of monument removal proposals to determine if the proposal complies with the provisions of this framework (policy) including without limitation, to evaluate the removal implications on the monument site, if any. The City Manager (or designee) shall decide whether to forward the proposal for further review or to decline further City consideration of the proposal based upon considerations consistent with this framework (Policy). If the City Manager’s decision is to conduct further review of the proposal, the City Manager or designee, shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s for consultation and the City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the site and objectives of the monument. If there is a doubt regarding the appropriate commission, the City Manager shall determine the appropriate commission for review of the proposal. The department shall prepare a report for consideration by the commission, and coordinate with all other departments and commissions that are relevant to the monument removal proposal. The commission/s shall review the proposal to make an advisory recommendation to the City Manager regarding the monument based upon the factors set forth in this framework (Policy). Each monument removal applicant shall be informed in writing of their right to appeal the City Manager’s decision, found on the monument removal proposal application provided by the City. If a proponent disagrees with the City Manager’s decision regarding monument removal, the proponent may submit a written appeal of the City Manager’s decision to the City Manager within 30 calendar days of the City Manager’s decision. The City Manager and the overseeing commission/s shall evaluate the merits of the appeal and determine whether to forward the appeal to City Council pursuant to the Council meeting rules. City Council shall make a final determination on the approval or denial of the proposal by evaluating (i) the merits of the proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy), (ii) City 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 36 of 56 Manager’s reason for denial, (iii) the results of any staff review of the proposal, and (iv) the recommendations of the appropriate City Commission. If a monument is approved to be removed, consideration should be given to placing a marker to chronicle the event, shared decision to do so, and its historic significance. Monument Disposition Process In the case that the City Council approves monument removal, the disposition process is as follows: 1.The City Manager shall refer the responsibility of monument disposition to the appropriate City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the monument site and objectives of the monument. a.At the discretion of the City Council, a special task force may be assembled consisting of the Human Relations commission, the Parks and Recreation Commission, the Cultural Arts Commission, and specific community members. 2.The City Manager shall prepare a report for review by the commission to provide contextual information (ie. monument location, history, removal process), as well as the directives of the framework (Policy) including values, tenets, and disposition process. 3.The City Manager (or designee) disseminates a Requests for Statements of Interest (RFI) for a period of sixty days. The RFI process includes a media press release conducted by the City staff, as well as promotional strategies to inform potential stakeholders. 4.After the closing of the RFI period, the City’s commission or specialized task force reviews all RFIs. The City’s commission or specialized task force may ask the RFI proposers for a follow-up presentation or for additional clarification on the RFI application. 5.The City’s commission or specialized task force shall deliberate on the RFI proposals utilizing the values and tenets listed within this framework (policy), community feedback, and advisement from City Council. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 37 of 56 6.When, and if, a RFI proposal attains unanimous approval, the City’s commission or specialized task force shall make an advisory recommendation to City Council 7.As per the framework, when a monument is removed, consideration may be given regarding the placing of a marker at the site. The City’s Commission or specialized task force may prepare a proposal for a future “marker” that chronicles the event, shared decision to do so, and its historic significance. The marker, fitting the definition of a monument, then follows the Monument Proposal and Review Process. 8.In the case that the City’s commission or specialized task force is unable to make an advisory recommendation to City Council regarding disposition, the monument will remain in City storage for three years. After three years, the City Manager initiates a new cycle of the monument disposition process. Naming/Renaming Nomination Process City departments, commissions, task forces, and community members shall submit their naming or renaming proposal to the Department Director depending on asset type. If applicant’s proposal follows the intent of this framework ( Policy), the Department Director shall make a proposal in writing for naming or renaming of a City Asset as follows: ●For library facilities, the Department Director will make the proposal to the Cultural Arts Commission. ●For parks and recreational facilities, the Department Director will make the proposal to the Park and Recreation Commission. ●For other City Assets, the Department Director will make the proposal to the City Manager, who shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s and/or City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the City asset and objectives of the asset. Written proposals must, at a minimum, include the following information: ●The proposed name; ●Reasons for the proposed name, including a discussion of the criteria identified in this policy; 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 38 of 56 ●Written documentation outlining community support for the proposed name; ●If proposing to rename a City Asset, justification for changing an established name. Naming and Renaming Review Process Upon receipt of a naming or renaming proposal for any City Asset, the Department Director reviewing the naming or renaming proposal shall consider the following items in the review, including but not limited to, the following: ●Submit the proposal to appropriate City historical staff to review the California Historic Resources Inventory Database (CHRID) to determine if the City Asset is a Designated Historical Resources with an assigned historic name; ●Ensure that supporting information has been authenticated; ●If the City Asset is a Designated Historical resource listed on the local, State or National Register of Historic Places, any on-site recognition shall comply with the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and shall be reviewed and approved by the City’s Historical Resources staff according to those standards; ●Ensure compliance with framework (Policiy) ●Consider the impact of the naming or renaming to the community; and ●Other City staff may review and provide input on the proposal for naming or renaming. ●Consider the cost of implementation and signage, and identify the funding to cover such costs. The Department Director will submit the proposal to the City Attorney’s Office for legal review of the following issues that include, but are not limited to: ○Ownership rights, by agreement or by law; and Adherence to City policies, as well as any local, state, or federal regulation. If a naming or renaming request is for a library or park, the designated City’s Commission shall hold a public hearing to consider the necessity or desirability of naming the park/facility, and the proposed name and any alternatives. The public hearing will be announced on the commission’s website for at least thirty (30) days in advance of the hearing. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 39 of 56 The designated City’s Commission shall prepare a recommendation for action by the City Council. The recommendation shall include no more than three (3) names for the asset that the Commission deemed most appropriate under this framework (policy) and the reason for the Commission’s selection. The City Council will review the staff report and the Commission’s recommendation and take action. The City Council’s selection is final. Non-selected names can be resubmitted for consideration in subsequent years. Name Change Once a name has been selected under this policy, it shall not be changed unless, after an investigation and public hearing, the name is found to be inappropriate because it does not fulfill the criteria laid out in this framework (policy). Review of a name selected under this framework (policy) shall occur only once a year, per the procedure outlined. A facility’s name, once upheld, shall not be reviewed again or changed for fifteen (15) years unless extraordinary circumstances merit, and approval is granted by the City Council. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 40 of 56 Monument Installation and Naming/Renaming City Assets FRAMEWORK I. Background Statement A. To provide history, context, and rationale for the proposed framework II. Definitions A. To build a common understanding of terms used within the framework III. Tenets and Values A. To remind all stakeholders about the deep values and tenets that root the City of Chula Vista IV. Guidelines A. General rules and instruction about naming City assets and monument installation V. Process and Procedures A. Steps for the application, review, and approval process 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 41 of 56 I. Background Statement On September 28, 2021, the Chula Vista City Council heard public comment from various community members and commissions in order to address the permanent disposition of the Christopher Columbus statue in Discovery Park and the renaming of Discovery Park. Council voted to establish a task force (Columbus Statue Removal Task Force) composed of the Human Relations Commission, Parks & Recreation Commission, Cultural Arts Commission, Kumeyaay community, and Sons and Daughters of Italy to address the following items: Disposition of Christopher Columbus statue; renaming of Discovery Park; identifying replacement artwork; and the development of a framework to guide the city with naming/renaming of City assets and installation of future monuments. The City of Chula Vista currently does not have a formal policy regarding the naming or renaming of City assets or monument installation. The City, through its departments, and advisory boards and commissions, has followed a number of processes/policies for naming or renaming its parks, libraries and other City assets, as well as monument installation. The Columbus Statue Removal Task Force utilized various steps in order to develop a framework that would provide the City with a clear protocol for future naming, renaming, and monument installation requests while ensuring transparency and allowing for public participation throughout the process. The task force researched similar efforts, discussions, and policies from surrounding cities, as well as other cities within California, and drew upon best practices from each. The task force developed and approved a framework with the purpose of establishing uniform guidelines for the naming and renaming of City assets, as well as to establish criteria and guidelines for the consideration and installation of monuments deemed by the City to be appropriate. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 42 of 56 II. Definitions1 City Assets Tangible or intangible items of value that are owned or created by the City, including but not limited to City facilities. This definition does NOT include PUBLIC ARTWORK. City Facility (included in City Assets) Any part of real property or structure owned by the City or for which naming rights or monument installation are conferred by agreement, including, but not limited to parks, libraries, Recreational Facilities buildings, parking facilities, interior or ancillary features that are a part of, or within, a larger facility and other City facilities. Commission Any commission as recognized by the City of Chula Vista City Council and/or City Charter; Commemoration Refers to events on the anniversaries of past events designated of importance to the City. They are typically held annually and often in conjunction with sites or markers of memorialization. Commemoration serves the purpose of continually reinscribing the importance of the original event in public memory. Department Director Appointed director of the department that oversees the City Asset eligible for naming, renaming, or monument installation. The director may assign this responsibility to other department staff within their delegation of authority. Donation or gift A monetary (cash) contribution, endowments, personal property, real property, financial securities, equipment, in- kind goods or services, or any other City Asset that the City has accepted and for which the donor has not received any goods or services in return. For purposes of this Council Policy, the terms “donation” and “gift” shall be synonymous. 1 Definitions influenced by City of San Diego Council Policy 900 -20, Naming of City Assets 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 43 of 56 Donor A person or other legal entity that proposes or provides a donation to the City. Funding Financial or in-kind resources to provide funding that might result in naming or renaming. Funding Source The source of funding which can include individuals, nonprofit organizations, and for-profit entities. Marker Permanent writing on plaques, walls, stone carvings, pavers, bricks, electronic display, or interpretive signs that are temporary or permanent and are used to memorialize; also considered part of a monument it is describing. Memorialization Intentional attempt to give importance to particular people, sites, events, and/or incidents in the historical record of the City through the placement of monuments, plaques, statues or other markers. Indicative of a City narration on the history of itself. Monument Markers, statues, and other similar installations, designed to be permanent, which are installed on City property with City permission. Monuments may be in various forms including statues, fountains, or gardens among other forms of monuments as determined by the City. Naming The selection and approval by the City for the initial naming of a City Asset other than streets within the public right of way. Non-Profit Organization A corporation or an association that conducts business for the benefit of the general public without shareholders and without a profit motive. Public Art In contrast to the presumed permanence of monuments, this includes more temporary installations wherein aesthetic considerations take precedence over historic significance. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 44 of 56 Approval lies with the Cultural Arts Commission. Renaming The selection and approval by the City of a new name for an existing City Asset other than streets within the public right of way. Work of art While both public monuments and public art/installations can be commonly referred to as ‘works of art’, each carry an important distinction in historical versus aesthetic significance, as well as protocols for approval, as noted in the definitions and guidelines within this document. III. Guiding Principles/Tenets/Values ❖ Process Matters as Much as Outcome: The City of Chula Vista aims to take time for quality, move at the speed of trust, and cultivate relationships beyond the life of a single monument and/or name. We strive for a powerful final result that is fueled by intentional and iterative processes. W e balance urgency and timeliness with purposeful reflection. We aim to work collectively with Kumeyaay communities when reviewing the region’s history. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 45 of 56 ❖ Truth Telling and Accountability: We work towards acknowledging a comprehensive and robust history of our region. ❖ Elimination of Prejudice and Discrimination: We acknowledge that the historical and contemporary practices of monument installation and the naming/renaming of public assets has created harm and continues to marginalize communities and community members. The installation of monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets must thoroughly vet efforts, donations, and proposals that may inflame prejudice, bigotry, and discrimination. ❖ Welcoming City: We believe that truly welcoming places have intentional, inclusive and equitable policies, practices, and norms that enable all (especially those marginalized) community members to live, thrive, and contribute fully. ❖ Public Memory and Memorialization is POWER: Monuments, naming, and renaming can convey a powerful connection between Chula Vista and its history, and in some instances its future. It is therefore important that the placement of monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets be limited to circumstances of the highest community-wide importance, to maintain the significant difference between commemoration and memorialization. 2 IV. Guidelines Our communities are dynamic, as they continue to change in many ways. The ethnic and racial compositions of our communities are an integral part of this change, as we have witnessed shifting community demographics over time. The process of monument installation and the naming/renaming of city assets must engage and strive for balance between the concept of permanence in an ever-changing society. Therefore, monuments and the naming/renaming of city assets should have a broad acceptance in a multicultural society while also considering future generations. The City names/renames City assets, installs or accepts City-approved monuments on City property as a form of “Government Speech”, as City recognition of significant events or people, 2 City of San José, Council Policy 9-14, Monument Policy Commented [1]: maybe: ...to be mindful of the relationship between commemoration and memorialization. Commented [2]: not sure of to keep the footnote, and if so, raises question of "the difference" its alluding to, as that is not clear in our current definitions. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 46 of 56 or to provide information from the City on topics approved by the City, as set forth below: a. The contributions of individuals or groups who made a substantial impact upon the City of Chula Vista: b. The history of Chula Vista: c. Historical or cultural influences on Chula Vista; d. Native flora, fauna and wildlife of Chula Vista and the greater South County area; e. Local innovation or creativity that has contributed to Chula Vista’s growth and prosperity; or f. Other criteria selected by City Council and set forth in an amendment to this Policy. Order of Preference: Monument installation and the naming/renaming of city assets are pursuant to the following guidelines in order of preference: 1. Geographic Location. Whenever possible, all City assets will be considered for their geographic location. Creating names and monument installation based on the asset’s geographic location should be considered first. The geographic location may be based on the relationship of the asset to a specific place, neighborhood, major street, regional area of the City or the City’s name if the asset serves the entire community. 2. Other Considerations. Consideration of monuments and names may also include a prominent form of topography, prominent flora, and cultural or historical precedent. 3. Extraordinary Circumstances. Only under extraordinary circumstances and with broad public support will the City consider monument installation and the naming/renaming after a person or group. Monument Installation or an asset may be named in memory, or honor of, an individual, group, or organization if it fulfills the criteria outlined in this policy: i. The person, group, or organization made lasting and significant contributions to the protection of natural or cultural resources of the City of Chula Vista; or ii. The person, group, or organization had a significant positive impact on the lives of Chula Vista’s residents; or iii. The person, group, or organization offered a lifetime of volunteerism and service to the community; iv. The naming of the person, group, or organization does not result in the excessive commercialization of the City asset. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 47 of 56 V. Process and Procedures Monument Review Process ● The City Manager or designee shall provide the initial screening of monument proposals to determine if the proposed monument complies with the provisions of this framework (policy) including without limitation, to evaluate the suitability of the proposed monument site, if any. ● The City Manager (or designee) shall decide whether to forward the proposal for further review or to decline further City consideration of the proposed monument based upon considerations consistent with this framework (policy). ● If the City Manager’s decision is to conduct further review of the proposal, the City Manager or designee, shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s for consultation and the City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the proposed site and objectives of the Monument. If there is a doubt regarding the appropriate commission, the City Manager shall determine the appropriate commission for review of the proposal. ● The City Manager or department shall prepare a report for consideration by the 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 48 of 56 commission, and coordinate with all other departments and commissions that are relevant to the proposed monument. ● The commission/s shall review the proposed monument to make an advisory recommendation to the City Manager regarding the monument based upon the factors set forth in this framework (Policy) and the Review Criteria set forth below. Each monument applicant or donor shall be informed in writing of their right to appeal the City Manager’s decision in the monument donation/application materials prepared by the City. ● If a proponent for a proposed monument disagrees with the City Manager’s decision regarding a proposed monument, the proponent may submit a written appeal of the City Manager’s decision to the City Manager within 30 calendar days of the City Manager’s decision. ● The City Manager and the overseeing commission/s shall evaluate the merits of the appeal and determine whether to forward the appeal to City Council pursuant to the Council meeting rules. ● City Council shall make a final determination on the approval or denial of the Monument proposal by evaluating (i) the merits of the Monument proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy), (ii) City Manager’s reason for denial, (iii) the results of any staff review of the proposal, and (iv) the recommendations of the appropriate City Commission. Monument Review Criteria ● A proposed monument must conform to the approved Government Speech topics and reflect the values and tenets listed within this framework (policy). The proposed monument is not objectionable to the persons or community including those that the monument is intended to honor. If through the public outreach process, the City Manager finds that a proposed Monument is a source of substantial dissension or discord within the City, the City Manager shall seek further direction from departments and commissions before making a final determination. ● A Monument must be made of durable materials, able to withstand the elements for a minimum of 50 years with minimum maintenance, shall be made of materials resistant to vandalism and graffiti as much as is reasonably possible, shall be of a scale, materials, color and style appropriate and consistent with aesthetics of the proposed location of the Monument and such other reasonable factors as the City Manager determines. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 49 of 56 ● The Monument proposal has been through community outreach conducted by the group or person suggesting that the City install the Monument, and the installation and maintenance of the Monument is within the priorities of the work plan of the responsible Department. ○ Community Outreach shall be directed to specific interested groups, that can include: i. Public notification of proposed changes through media or a public meeting ii. Outreach to specific local organizations that may be considered stakeholders, i.e., South Bay Community Services, YMCA, Southwestern College, other Non-profit organizations located within the City, local school districts, etc. ● The City may decline to approve or to accept a monument for any lawful reason. ● Monument proposals shall be considered by the applicable (or closest applicable) City commission/s and department/s associated with the proposed location for the monument. That commission shall make a recommendation to the City Manager for approval or disapproval based on consistency with this framework (Policy) and as further described in the Review Process. The City Manager may accept or deny the recommendation from the commission as further provided in the review process. ● The City shall only proceed with the design, fabrication, and installation of a monument after completion of the review process and if the conclusion is to move forward. In reviewing a proposed monument, the relevant departments, the applicable City Commission and City Manager shall review the proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy). Monument Removal Process The City Manager or designee shall provide the initial screening of monument removal proposals to determine if the proposal complies with the provisions of this framework (policy) including without limitation, to evaluate the removal implications on the monument site, if any. The City Manager (or designee) shall decide whether to forward the proposal for further review or to decline further City consideration of the proposal based upon considerations consistent with this framework (Policy). If the City Manager’s decision is to conduct further review of the proposal, the City Manager or designee, shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s for consultation and the City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the site and objectives of the monument. If there is a 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 50 of 56 doubt regarding the appropriate commission, the City Manager shall determine the appropriate commission for review of the proposal. The department shall prepare a report for consideration by the commission, and coordinate with all other departments and commissions that are relevant to the monument removal proposal. The commission/s shall review the proposal to make an advisory recommendation to the City Manager regarding the monument based upon the factors set forth in this framework (Policy). Each monument removal applicant shall be informed in writing of their right to appeal the City Manager’s decision, found on the monument removal proposal application provided by the City. If a proponent disagrees with the City Manager’s decision regarding monument removal, the proponent may submit a written appeal of the City Manager’s decision to the City Manager within 30 calendar days of the City Manager’s decision. The City Manager and the overseeing commission/s shall evaluate the merits of the appeal and determine whether to forward the appeal to City Council pursuant to the Council meeting rules. City Council shall make a final determination on the approval or denial of the proposal by evaluating (i) the merits of the proposal based upon the criteria set forth in this framework (Policy), (ii) City Manager’s reason for denial, (iii) the results of any staff review of the proposal, and (iv) the recommendations of the appropriate City Commission. If a monument is approved to be removed, consideration should be given to placing a marker to chronicle the event, including the reasons for the decision to do so, and its historic significance. Monument Disposition Process In the case that the City Council approves monument removal, the disposition process is as follows: 1. The City Manager shall refer the responsibility of monument disposition to the appropriate City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the monument site and objectives of the monument. a. At the discretion of the City Council, a special task force may be assembled consisting of the Human Relations Commission, the Parks and Recreation Commission, the Cultural Arts Commission, and specific community members/stakeholders. 2. The City Manager shall prepare a report for review by the commission to provide contextual information (ie. monument location, history, removal process), as well as the directives of the framework (Policy) including values, tenets, and disposition process. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 51 of 56 3. The City Manager (or designee) disseminates a Requests for Statements of Interest (RFI) for a period of sixty days. The RFI process includes a media press release conducted by the City staff, as well as promotional strategies to inform potential stakeholders. 4. After the closing of the RFI period, the City’s commission or specialized task force reviews all RFIs. The City’s commission or specialized task force may ask the RFI proposers for a follow-up presentation or for additional clarification on the RFI application. 5. The City’s commission or specialized task force shall deliberate on the RFI proposals utilizing the values and tenets listed within this framework (policy), community feedback, and advisement from City Council. 6. When, and if, a RFI proposal attains unanimous approval, the City’s commission or specialized task force shall make an advisory recommendation to City Council. 7. As per the framework, when a monument is removed, consideration may be given regarding the placing of a marker at the site. The City’s Commission or specialized task force may prepare a proposal for a future “marker” that chronicles the event, shares the decision to do so, and its historic significance. The marker, fitting the definition of a monument, then follows the Monument Proposal and Review Process. 8. In the case that the City’s commission or specialized task force is unable to make an advisory recommendation to City Council regarding disposition, the monument will remain in City storage for three years or as determined by the City Manager. After three years, the City Manager initiates a new cycle of the monument disposition process. Naming/Renaming Nomination Process City departments, commissions, task forces, or community members shall submit their naming or renaming proposal to the Department Director depending on asset type. If applicant’s proposal follows the intent of this framework ( Policy), the Department Director shall make a proposal in writing for naming or renaming of a City Asset as follows: ● For library facilities, the Department Director will make the proposal to the Cultural Arts Commission. ● For parks and recreational facilities, the Department Director will make the proposal to the Park and Recreation Commission. ● For other City Assets, the Department Director will make the proposal to the City Manager, who shall refer the proposal to the appropriate department/s and/or City’s commission/s (ie. Parks and Recreation, Cultural Arts, Human Relations) most closely associated with the City asset and objectives of the asset. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 52 of 56 Written proposals must, at a minimum, include the following information: ● The proposed name; ● Reasons for the proposed name, including a discussion of the criteria identified in this policy; ● Written documentation outlining community support for the proposed name; ● If proposing to rename a City Asset, justification for changing an established name. Naming and Renaming Review Process Upon receipt of a naming or renaming proposal for any City Asset, the Department Director reviewing the naming or renaming proposal shall consider the following items in the review, including but not limited to, the following: ● Submit the proposal to appropriate City historical staff to review the California Historic Resources Inventory Database (CHRID) to determine if the City Asset is a Designated Historical Resources with an assigned historic name; ● Ensure that supporting information has been authenticated; ● If the City Asset is a Designated Historical resource listed on the local, State or National Register of Historic Places, any on-site recognition shall comply with the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and shall be reviewed and approved by the City’s Historical Resources staff according to those standards; ● Ensure compliance with framework (Policy) ● Consider the impact of the naming or renaming to the community; and ● Other City staff may review and provide input on the proposal for naming or renaming. ● Consider the cost of implementation and signage, and identify the funding to cover such costs. The Department Director will submit the proposal to the City Attorney’s Office for legal review of the following issues that include, but are not limited to: ○ Ownership rights, by agreement or by law; and Adherence to City policies, as well as any local, state, or federal regulation. If a naming or renaming request is for a library or park, the designated City’s Commission shall hold a public hearing to consider the necessity or desirability of naming the park/facility, and the proposed name and any alternatives. The public hearing will be announced on the commission’s website for at least thirty (30) days in advance of the hearing. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 53 of 56 The designated City’s Commission shall prepare a recommendation for action by the City Council. The recommendation shall include no more than three (3) names for the asset that the Commission deemed most appropriate under this framework (policy) and the reason for the Commission’s selections. The City Council will review the staff report and the Commission’s recommendation and take action. The City Council’s selection is final. Non-selected names can be resubmitted for consideration in subsequent years. Name Change Once a name has been selected under this policy, it shall not be changed unless, after an investigation and public hearing, the name is found to be inappropriate because it does not fulfill the criteria laid out in this framework (policy). Review of a name selected under this framework (policy) shall occur only once a year, per the procedure outlined. A facility’s name, once upheld, shall not be reviewed again or changed for fifteen (15) years unless extraordinary circumstances merit, and approval is granted by the City Council. 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 54 of 56 Option 1: Marker language without new monument This park lies on the land of the Kumeyaay, the original caretakers of the territories extending from present-day Ensenada to Oceanside and from the Pacific Ocean to the Colorado River. [Park Name] honors the ______. [Elaborate on new name] On this site, previously named Discovery Park upon its founding in 1990 as part of the commemoration of the quincentennial of the so-called “discovery of the new land”—stood a statue of Christopher Columbus. After years of protests by local Kumeyaay, other Indigenous peoples, supporters, and city residents, in 2021 the Chula Vista City Council voted to remove the statue and rename the park. We offer this in the spirit of not “erasing history” but rather as a necessary and reciprocal healing of the harms and injustice of colonial erasure and the distortion of history. Option 2: Marker language with new monument: This park lies on the land of the Kumeyaay, the original caretakers of the territories extending from present-day Ensenada to Oceanside and from the Pacific Ocean to the Colorado River. [Park Name] honors the ______. The monument _____ points to ______. [Elaborate on the monument and new name] * * * * * On this site, previously named Discovery Park-- upon its founding in 1990, as part of the commemoration of the quincentennial of the so called “discovery of the new land”-- stood a statue of Christopher Columbus. After years of protests by local Kumeyaay, other indigenous peoples, supporters and city residents, in 2021 the Chula Vista City Council voted to remove the statue. We offer this in the spirit of not “erasing history” but rather as a necessary and reciprocal healing of the harms and injustice of colonial erasure and the distortion of history. Park Name Recommendations: In order of priority: 1. Name: Kuskilly/ Kuuskilsh Rationale: Definition: tears coming down the nose, tears of god. Eventually they hit the mouth or the “waterfront”. It’s a reference to thick lip or the “bay” itself. It is a Kumeyaay honoring of geographic locations and topography of the area. Nominated by: Mike Connolley 2. Name: Mat Tipaay “The Peoples Land” 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 55 of 56 Rationale: Honoring the original peoples and acknowledging their presence. Nominated by: Stan Rodriguez 3. Name: Kanap Uuyaw “Telling Knowledge” Rationale: Correcting falsehoods of the past. Nominated by: Martha Rodriguez 4. Name: Kumeyaay Park of Chula Vista Rationale: Original peoples or the first people. Nominated by: L. Maynard 2022-10-20 CCSDPTF Agenda Page 56 of 56