HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-05-09 Privacy Task Force Meeting SummaryTechnology and Privacy Advisory Task Force
Meeting Summary
May 9, 2022
Task Force members present: City staff and consultants present:
Mae Case
Candice Custodio-Tan
Lucia Napolez
Pedro Rios
Sophia Rodriguez, Chair
Patricia Ruiz
Charles Walker
Maria Whitehorse
Dominic LiMandri
Dennis Gakunga
Simon Silva
Adrianna Hernandez
Jim Madaffer
Jeremy Ogul
Task Force members absent
Carlos De La Toba
Rafal Jankowski, Co-Chair
Art Pacheco
The meeting was called to order at 6:05 p.m.
Public Comment – Items Not On The Agenda
Three speakers provided public comment: Nick Paúl, Nancy Relaford, Margaret Baker. One individual
provided e-comment: Seth Hall.
Presentation on Existing State and Federal Law
Simon Silva, Deputy City Attorney for the City of Chula Vista, provided a detailed presentation on the
state and federal laws that control privacy. Task force members engaged in questions and discussion
regarding the presentation.
Two speakers provided public comments: Margaret Baker, Norell Martinez.
Potential continuation of agenda items
Jeremy Ogul informed the task force that they had the option to delay one of the remaining agenda items
to a future meeting.
Member LiMandri moved to delay Item 4.2, the presentation on privacy in other California cities, to a
future meeting. The motion was seconded by Member Napolez. The motion failed with the following
votes:
YES (2): LiMandri, Napolez
NO (7): Custodio-Tan, Whitehorse, Rodriguez, Case, Rios, Ruiz, Walker
Presentation on privacy in other California cities
Jeremy Ogul presented an overview of 10 examples of how other cities have approached privacy
technology and oversight with advisory bodies.
Tasked force members engaged in questions and discussion of the presentation.
One individual provided e-comment: Seth Hall.
Discussion of public outreach plan
Jeremy Ogul asked the task force for feedback and ideas on the format. Task force members engaged in
discussion and provided ideas and general direction to Madaffer Enterprises.
Public Comment: Items on the Agenda
Two speakers provided public comments: Margaret Baker, Nancy Relaford.
Staff Comments
Jeremy Ogul spoke regarding the formation of future agendas.
Task Force Member Comments
Member Custodio-Tan moved to invite the Ad Hoc STOP Chula Vista Surveillance Group to give a 30-
minute presentation (including 10 minutes of questions and answers by task force members) at a future
task force meeting. The motion was seconded by Member Rios. The motion passed unanimously.
The meeting adjourned at 9:30 p.m.
- Meeting summary prepared by Jeremy Ogul