Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 8 - Written Communications - Baker1 March 22, 2021 VIA EMAIL Maria V. Kachadoorian Chula Vista City Manager City of Chula Vista 276 4th Avenue Chula Vista, CA 91910 Glen Googins Chula Vista City Attorney City of Chula Vista 276 4th Avenue Chula Vista, CA 91910 Re: Chula Vista Police Department’s Automated License Plate Reader Program; California Public Records Act Request Dear Ms. Kachadoorian and Mr. Googins, We write regarding the attached records, which indicate that the Chula Vista Police Department (“CVPD”) has shared automated license plate reader (“ALPR”) data with federal immigration enforcement agencies such as U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”),1 U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”), and ICE Homeland Security Investigations (“HSI”). CBP is the largest law enforcement agency in the United States, with over 60,000 officers. The U.S. Border Patrol is a subcomponent of CBP. Throughout this letter, all references to CBP include the Border Patrol. One of the attached documents is an “Agency Data Sharing Report” dated November 17, 2020, which indicates that CVPD has shared detection data with the “San Diego Sector Border Patrol [CA]. We demand that you immediately stop any relationship with these or other agencies that provide any such agencies with access to driver location information. This letter: summarizes public records indicating that the Chula Vista Police Department has shared information about the locations of local drivers with federal agencies, including CBP, ICE, and HSI; describes the threat that the unrestricted use of ALPR technology poses to the privacy and safety of all community members; explains that California state law prohibits the sharing of ALPR data with out-of-state and federal entities; and reveals the contradiction to Chula Vista’s stated commitment to protect civil liberties. The letter concludes by urging the City of Chula Vista to immediately stop any ALPR data sharing with federal immigration enforcement agencies, to terminate the contract with Vigilant Solutions, LLC, altogether, to adopt surveillance technology usage and privacy policies to ensure compliance with state laws and protection of explicit privacy and civil liberties, and to establish an independent community-led Privacy Advisory Board to oversee acquisition and use of surveillance technology. 1 CBP is the largest law enforcement agency in the United States, with over 60,000 officers. The U.S. Border Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 2 I. Records Indicate that the Chula Vista Police Department Has Shared ALPR Data with Federal Agencies, Including CBP, ICE and HSI. Public records indicate that Chula Vista Police Department has shared ALPR data with federal agencies. For example, in the attached LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report dated November 17, 2020, CBP, ICE, and the HSI Bulk Cash Smuggling Center are listed as sharing partners with the ability to search the local ALPR data (including scans of license plates and the time and location of the scanned plate). The data sharing report lists the Chula Vista Police Department as a partner that appears to have allowed CBP, ICE, HSI and other federal agencies to search the information collected about driver locations. Such sensitive information could help federal agencies like CBP, ICE, and HSI to target, locate, and deport immigrant community members as they drive to work, run errands, or take their kids to school. If the Chula Vista Police Department is permitting federal agencies to search this information, it is violating our community members’ privacy and civil rights and placing our most vulnerable neighbors at serious risk. II. ALPR Surveillance of Chula Vista Residents’ Locations Raises Serious Civil Liberties and Civil Rights Concerns. No jurisdiction should acquire or deploy license plate readers, given the technology’s invasiveness and the breadth of revealing information such readers can collect about individuals. ALPR systems collect and store location information about drivers whose cars pass through ALPR cameras’ fields of view, which, after being matched to dates, times, and locations, can be built into a database that reveals sensitive information about where individuals work, live, associate, and travel.2 Further, ALPR systems are easily misused to harm communities of color and especially immigrants within those communities—a phenomenon that has been documented for over twenty years.3 As with other surveillance technologies, police deploy license plate readers disproportionately in poor areas, regardless of crime rates.4 2 See, e.g., You Are Being Tracked: How License Plate Readers Are Being Used to Record Americans’ Movements, AM. CIV. LIBERTIES UNION, July 2013, https://www.aclu.org/other/you-are-being-tracked-how-license-plate-readers-are-being- used-record-americans-movements; Automatic License Plate Readers, ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUND., https://www.eff.org/sls/tech/automated-license-plate-readers (last visited Feb. 10, 2021). 3 See, e.g., Angel Diaz & Rachel Levinson-Waldman, Automatic License Plate Readers: Legal Status and Policy Recommendations for Law Enforcement Use, BRENNAN CTR. FOR JUST., Sept. 10, 2020, https://www.brennancenter.org/our- work/research-reports/automatic-license-plate-readers-legal-status-and-policy-recommendations; Christine Hauser, Aurora Police Chief Apologizes After Officers Handcuff Children on the Ground, N.Y. TIMES, Aug. 5, 2020, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/05/us/aurora-police-black-family.html (ALPR falsely flagged a Black family’s SUV as stolen, leading to a stop during which entire family, including four children, was forced to lie on the ground during the stop); Vasudha Talla, Records Reveal ICE Agents Run Thousands of License Plate Queries a Month in Massive Location Database, ACLU OF NORTHERN CAL., June 5, 2019, https://www.aclunc.org/blog/records-reveal-ice-agents-run-thousands- license-plate-queries-month-massive-location-database; Matt Cagle, San Francisco – Paying the Price for Surveillance Without Safeguards, ACLU OF NORTHERN CAL., May 22, 2014, https://www.aclunc.org/blog/san-francisco-paying-price- surveillance-without-safeguards; Adam Goldman and Matt Apuzzo, With Cameras, Informants, NYPD Eyed Mosques, ASSOCIATED PRESS, Feb. 23, 2012, https://www.ap.org/ap-in-the-news/2012/with-cameras-informants-nypd-eyed- mosques; Michael Powell, Sari Horwitz & Toni Locy, Lt. Stowe’s Sudden Fall From Grace, WASH. POST, Nov. 30, 1997, Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 3 These abuses are magnified for border residents, who are exposed to local, state, and federal law enforcement officials throughout their communities. The mere act of crossing the border by car—a necessary, regular journey for many binational families and workers—subjects travelers to intrusive surveillance.5 For several years now, federal agencies like CBP, ICE,6 and HSI7 have accessed license plate information held by law enforcement agencies and/or by commercial vendors such as Vigilant Solutions, LLC (“Vigilant”).8 Vigilant’s database includes data collected by its public sector and private customers and contractors operating the company’s license plate readers.9 Federal agencies https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1997/11/30/lt-stowes-sudden-fall-from-grace/a6ac37f2-57d2- 47fb-b6da-0f8f6a45dde8/. 4 BARTON GELLMAN & SAM ADLER-BELL, THE CENTURY FOUND., THE DISPARATE IMPACT OF SURVEILLANCE 2 (Dec. 2017), https://production-tcf.imgix.net/app/uploads/2017/12/03151009/the-disparate-impact- of-surveillance.pdf; see also, e.g., Kaveh Waddell, How License-Plate Readers Have Helped Police and Lenders Target the Poor, THE ATLANTIC, Apr. 22, 2016 https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/04/how-license-plate-readers-have- helped-police-and-lenders-target-the-poor/479436/ (summarizing data indicating that Oakland Police Department deployed ALPRs “disproportionately often in low-income areas and in neighborhoods with high concentrations of African-American and Latino residents”). 5 DEP’T OF HOMELAND SEC., PRIVACY IMPACT ASSESSMENT FOR THE CBP LICENSE PLATE READER TECHNOLOGY, DHS/ICE/PIA-049(A) (July 6, 2020), https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/privacy- pia-cbp049a-cbplprtechnology-july2020.pdf. 6 Russell Brandom, Exclusive: ICE Is About to Start Tracking License Plates Across the US, THE VERGE, Jan. 26, 2018, https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/26/16932350/ice-immigration-customs-license-plate-recognition- contract-vigilant-solutions. 7 Suhauna Hussain & Johana Bhuiyan, Police in Pasadena, Long Beach Pledged Not to Send License Plate Data to ICE. They Shared it Anyway, L.A. TIMES, Dec. 21, 2020, https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2020-12- 21/pasadena-long-beach-police-ice-automated-license-plate-reader-data ("The department began sharing license plate information with HSI four months ago to help “restrict the flow of funding that supports criminal enterprises,” according to Special Services Lt. Bill Grisafe. Grisafe said in an email last week the department stopped sharing license plate information with HSI once it realized the division was affiliated with ICE."). 8 See, e.g., Tanvi Misra, Who’s Tracking Your License Plate, BLOOMBERG CITYLAB, Dec. 6, 2018, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-06/why-privacy-advocates-fear-license-plate-readers (“EFF also found that, on average, each agency was directly sharing [ALPR data] with 160 other jurisdictions . . . . These could be police departments . . . or Customs and Border Protection (CBP) . . . .”); Andrew Keatts, SDPD Shares Its License Plata Database with Border Patrol – and Hundreds of Other Agencies, VOICE OF SAN DIEGO, Apr. 26, 2018, https://www.voiceofsandiego.org/topics/public-safety/sdpd-shares-its-license-plate-database-with-border-patrol-and- hundreds-of-other-agencies/. For more background on Vigilant, see, for example, Conor Friedersdorf, An Unprecedented Threat to Privacy, THE ATLANTIC, Jan. 27, 2016, https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/01/vigilant-solutions- surveillance/427047/. 9 Diaz & Levinson-Waldman, supra note 3, at 3; Aaron Holmes, Customs and Border Protection Paid to Access a Private Company’s Network of Cameras that Spans the US, BUSINESS INSIDER, Sept. 10, 2020, https://www.businessinsider.com/cbp-vigilant-learn-camera-network-tracking-2020-9; Joseph Cox, CBP Bought “Unlimited” Use of a Nationwide Tracking Database, VICE, Sept. 10, 2020, https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/pky47y/cbp-surveillance-license-plate-reader-vigilant. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 4 like CBP, ICE, and HSI can thus access nationwide databases of license plates and associated location records to target people going about their daily lives in our community.10 Such surveillance is a matter of grave concern. Sharing ALPR data with CBP, for example, is worrisome given CBP’s well-documented history of civil and human rights abuses, which have gone largely unchecked.11 These concerns have taken on a new urgency because of CBP’s recent involvement in the monitoring, surveilling, and suppression of First Amendment-protected protest activity following the murder of George Floyd.12 CBP’s expanded domestic law enforcement activities are alarming—doubly so given confirmed reports that CBP has been unable to protect highly-sensitive location tracking data from malicious cyberattacks and other data breaches.13 Any sharing of ALPR data by the Chula Vista Police Department with a federal agency that asserts such broad authority with dubious constitutional justification is deeply troubling. Sharing of ALPR data with ICE, as another example, violates the privacy and civil rights of immigrants and their families, and places them at serious risk. Records obtained by the ACLU of Northern California (“ACLU”) from a Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”) request reveal that, as of March 2018, Vigilant provided 9,200 ICE personnel with accounts to use their database. Some 10 See DEP’T OF HOMELAND SEC., supra note 5. The ACLU found multiple articles reporting on primary sources referencing CBP’s access to commercial ALPR databases since at least 2015, but this 2020 PIA says “[t]he 2017 PIA only discussed LPR reads obtained from equipment owned and operated by CBP; at the time, CBP did not access commercially available license plate images and vehicle locations.” See Cox, supra note 9 (releasing documents proving CBP’s involvement with Vigilant since 2015). One possible explanation for this discrepancy, which CBP does not appear to have addressed, is that CBP has relied on information sharing with local law enforcement agencies to receive ALPR data while avoiding federal privacy law disclosure requirements. 11 See, e.g., Josiah Heyman, Jeremy Slack & Daniel E. Martínez, Why Border Patrol Agents and CBP Officers Should Not Serve as Asylum Officers, CTR. FOR MIGRATION STUD., June 21, 2019, https://cmsny.org/publications/heyman-slack- martinez-062119/; John Washington, “Kick Ass, Ask Questions Later”: A Border Patrol Whistleblower Speaks Out About Culture of Abuse Against Migrants, THE INTERCEPT, Sept. 20, 2018, https://theintercept.com/2018/09/20/border-patrol- agent-immigrant-abuse/; GUILLERMO CANTOR & WALTER EWING, AM. IMMIGRATION COUNCIL, STILL NO ACTION TAKEN: COMPLAINTS AGAINST BORDER PATROL AGENTS CONTINUE TO GO UNANSWERED (Aug. 2017), http://bit.ly/Council_StillNoActionTaken (examining records of alleged misconduct by Border Patrol employees); Garrett M. Graff, The Green Monster: How the Border Patrol Became America’s Most Out-of-Control Law Enforcement Agency, POLITICO (Nov./Dec. 2014), https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/10/border-patrol-the-green-monster- 112220. 12 See, e.g., Josh Gerstein, Feds Assemble ‘Operation Diligent Valor’ Force to Battle Portland Unrest, POLITICO (July 22, 2020, 9:37 AM ET), https://www.politico.com/news/2020/07/22/federal-government-assembles-force-portland- unrest-377785 (describing DHS Rapid Deployment Force in Portland as “Operation Diligent Valor”); Caitlin Oprysko, Trump Announces Plan to Send Federal Law Enforcement to Chicago, Albuquerque, POLITICO (July 22, 2020, 6:28 PM ET), https://www.politico.com/news/2020/07/22/trump-law-enforcement-chicago-albuquerque-378692 (describing deployments to additional U.S. cities under rubric of “Operation Legend”); Gregory Pratt & Jeremy Gorner, Trump Expected to Send New Federal Force to Chicago This Week to Battle Violence, but Plan’s Full Scope Is a Question Mark, CHICAGO TRIBUNE, July 20, 2020, https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/criminal-justice/ct-chicago-police-dhs-deployment- 20200720-dftu5ychwbcxtg4ltarh5qnwma-story.html; Sergio Olmos, et al., Federal Officers Deployed in Portland Didn’t Have Proper Training, D.H.S. Memo Said, N.Y. TIMES, July 21, 2020, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/18/us/portland- protests.html; Ken Klippenstein, The Border Patrol Was Responsible for an Arrest in Portland, THE NATION, July 17, 2020, https://www.thenation.com/article/society/border-patrol-portland-arrest/; Tanvi Misra, Immigration Agencies to Assist Law Enforcement Amid Unrest, ROLL CALL, June 1, 2020, https://www.rollcall.com/2020/06/01/immigration-agencies-to- assist-law-enforcement-amid-unrest/. 13 Zack Whittaker, CBP Says Traveler Photos and License Plate Images Stolen in Data Breach, TECH CRUNCH, June 10, 2019, https://techcrunch.com/2019/06/10/cbp-data-breach/. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 5 of these officers were members of the ICE division that engages in civil immigration enforcement. Through this arrangement, ICE can tap into Vigilant’s nationwide database of license plates and associated location records to target immigrants and other members of our community.14 Even more troubling is the disclosure of an ICE officer’s email requests to a La Habra detective, asking the detective to run license plates through the Vigilant database since the La Habra detective possessed access to data that the ICE officer did not. The La Habra detective pasted the results of his queries into documents and emailed them to the ICE officer. These emails show that, regardless of a local law enforcement agency’s decision to share or not share driver information with ICE, informal sharing of this information can and does occur. In addition, the California State Auditor’s 2019 report on ALPR usage by California law enforcement agencies found that the audited agencies “have not made informed ALPR image-sharing decisions” and “have conducted little to no auditing and monitoring [of license plate searches] and thus have no assurance that misuse has not occurred.”15 The Auditor’s report concludes that “it is likely that many of the survey respondents have the same problems we identified at the four agencies we visited.” While CVPD was not one of the four audited agencies, it is listed as a survey respondent; and CVPD’s documented failure to notice that it was sharing ALPR information with ICE for three years bears out that concern.16 Ultimately, whether obtained through formal permission, informal sharing, system misuse, or lack of knowledge and oversight, ALPR information helps ICE target, locate, and deport immigrant community members. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), which is an investigative arm of ICE, has conducted worksite raids in San Diego County.17 As documented in a report by the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC), HSI agents employed violent tactics, including pointing their firearms at workers in the presence of children.18 In a series of incidents documented in this same report, HSI agents apprehended a father, who worked at the Korean market under investigation, as he was transporting his child to school. The child was left stranded as the father was taken away.19 14 DEP’T OF HOMELAND SEC., Privacy Impact Assessment, Acquisition and Use of License Plate Reader (LPR) Data from a Commercial Service, DHS/ICE/PIA-039(a) (Dec. 27, 2017), https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/privacy-pia-ice-lpr-january2018.pdf. 15 AUDITOR OF THE STATE OF CAL., AUTOMATED LICENSE PLATE READERS: TO BETTER PROTECT INDIVIDUALS’ PRIVACY, LAW ENFORCEMENT MUST INCREASE ITS SAFEGUARDS FOR THE DATA IT COLLECTS(Feb. 2020), https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2019-118.pdf. 16 Gustavo Solis, Chula Vista Police Chief Says She Didn’t Know Department Shared Data With Feds, VOICE OF SAN DIEGO, Jan. 20, 2021, https://www.voiceofsandiego.org/topics/government/chula-vista-police-chief-says-she-didnt- know-department-shared-data-with-feds/ ("Chula Vista Police Chief Roxana Kennedy did not know that her own department shared license plate reader data with federal immigration officials for the last three years. Apparently, when the police department entered into an agreement with Vigilant Solutions to use its database back in December 2017, someone simply clicked a ‘share all’ button. The police chief said she just recently learned that Immigration and Customs Enforcement or Customs and Border Protection were part of the more than 800 law enforcement agencies that were given access to Chula Vista’s data."). 17 U.S. IMMIGRATION & CUSTOMS ENF’T, ICE Homeland Security Investigations Execute Federal Search Warrant During Worksite Enforcement Operation at Local Market: 26 Unauthorized Workers Arrested on Immigration Administrative Charges, ICE NEWSROOM, Nov. 19, 2020), https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/ice-homeland-security-investigations-execute- federal-search-warrant-during-worksite. 18 See AM. FRIENDS SERV. COMM., COUNTERING ICE’S ABUSIVE PRACTICES WITH COMMUNITY RESILIENCY: TESTIMONIES FROM SAN DIEGO 14 (Dec. 10, 2020), https://www.afsc.org/document/report-countering-ice-abusive- practices-community-resiliency. 19 See id. at 14-15. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 6 The Chula Vista Police Department should not share sensitive information about community members with a federal agency that comports itself with such disregard for human safety. It is important to note that some California law enforcement agencies have inadvertently shared ALPR data with HSI, not realizing that HSI is affiliated with ICE.20 According to a list of agencies with whom CVPD was sharing ALPR detection data through Vigilant as of February 3, 2021, one HSI unit (HSI Bulk Cash Smuggling Center) continued to receive access after ICE and CBP were removed following community outcry in December 2020.21 III. Sharing of ALPR Data with Federal Agencies Violates State Law. Sharing ALPR data with federal agencies violates state law. First, sharing residents’ data with federal agencies—such as CBP, ICE, or HSI—violates the California Civil Code, as amended by Senate Bill No. 34 (“S.B. 34”). Under the statute, “[a] public agency shall not sell, share, or transfer ALPR information, except to another public agency, and only as otherwise permitted by law.” Civ. Code § 1798.90.55(b). A “public agency” is defined as “the state, any city, county, or city and county, or any agency or political subdivision of the state.” See Civ. Code § 1798.90.5(f) (emphasis added). The Civil Code, therefore, prohibits an agency from sharing or transferring ALPR information with or to federal agencies, which are not California state or local agencies.22 Additionally, the California Values Act (“S.B. 54”) prohibits the sharing of personal information with agencies “for immigration enforcement purposes.”23 Cal. Govt. Code §§ 7282, 7282.5, 7284.6(a)(1)(D). Automated license plate reader data constitutes “personal information” within the meaning of S.B. 54 and the California Information Practices Act. See Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.3. In addition to violating the plain language of the California Values Act, sharing ALPR data with federal immigration enforcement agencies like CBP, ICE, and HSI undermines the values guiding state law, as set out in the legislative findings and declarations which accompany S.B. 54: “The Legislature finds and declares the following: 20 Suhauna Hussain & Johana Bhuiyan, Police in Pasadena, Long Beach Pledged Not to Send License Plate Data to ICE. They Shared it Anyway, L.A. TIMES, Dec. 21, 2020, https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2020-12- 21/pasadena-long-beach-police-ice-automated-license-plate-reader-data. ("The department began sharing license plate information with HSI four months ago to help ‘restrict the flow of funding that supports criminal enterprises,’ according to Special Services Lt. Bill Grisafe. Grisafe said.. . . the department stopped sharing license plate information with HSI once it realized the division was affiliated with ICE."). 21 PDF file received from City of Chula Vista, 2-3-21 Chula Vista Police Department_Data_Sharing_Report.pdf 22 S.B. 34 in no way limits the public’s right of access to ALPR data pursuant to the California Public Records Act (Government Code §§ 6250, et. seq.) and Article I § 3(b) of the California Constitution. The California Supreme Court has held that ALPR records are not categorically subject to withholding from the public under Section 2654(f)’s exemption for investigatory records. Records may only be withheld pursuant to another section’s “catchall” provision, and only after a case-by-case balancing process. Am. Civil Liberties Union Found. of S. California v. Superior Court, 3 Cal. 5th 1032, 1042–43 (Cal. 2017). 23 S.B. 54, 2017-18 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Cal. 2017), codified at Cal. Gov’t Code §§ 7282 et seq. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 7 (a) Immigrants are valuable and essential members of the California community. Almost one in three Californians is foreign born and one in two children in California has at least one immigrant parent. (b) A relationship of trust between California’s immigrant community and state and local agencies is central to the public safety of the people of California. (c) This trust is threatened when state and local agencies are entangled with federal immigration enforcement, with the result that immigrant community members fear approaching police when they are victims of, and witnesses to, crimes, seeking basic health services, or attending school, to the detriment of public safety and the well-being of all Californians. (d) Entangling state and local agencies with federal immigration enforcement programs diverts already limited resources and blurs the lines of accountability between local, state, and federal governments. (e) State and local participation in federal immigration enforcement programs also raises constitutional concerns, including the prospect that California residents could be detained in violation of the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution, targeted on the basis of race or ethnicity in violation of the Equal Protection Clause, or denied access to education based on immigration status…. (f) This chapter seeks to ensure effective policing, to protect the safety, well-being, and constitutional rights of the people of California, and to direct the state’s limited resources to matters of greatest concern to state and local governments. (g) It is the intent of the Legislature that this chapter shall not be construed as providing, expanding, or ratifying any legal authority for any state or local law enforcement agency to participate in immigration enforcement.” Cal. Govt. Code §§ 7284.2. IV. Sharing of ALPR Data Contradicts Chula Vista’s Commitments to Protect All Residents. Lack of Transparency and Accountability Reveal Need for Increased Protections and Independent Oversight. Early in 2017, community members, concerned about the cruelty wrought by the federal government’s immigration enforcement actions, asked the Chula Vista City Council (“City Council”) to declare Chula Vista a sanctuary city that would not cooperate with federal immigration agencies.24 A few months later, after hearing public comments and considering recommendations by City staff, the City Council voted unanimously to adopt a seven-point resolution25 that laid out a comprehensive approach to welcome and protect all members of the community, regardless of immigration status, and to reject cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Over the next three years, the City of Chula Vista adopted a series of measures, including joining the Welcoming America network, establishing a Human Relations Commission,26 and supporting local, state, and 24 Clerk of the City of Chula Vista, Meeting Minutes, Chula Vista City Council (Jan. 10, 2017), https://chulavista.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx. 25 Clerk of the City of Chula Vista, Meeting Minutes, Chula Vista City Council(Apr. 25, 2017), https://drive.google.com/file/d/1llbl39J9kJwzHMVoOPDunFUOJvFOgD9f/view?usp=sharing (adopting city council resolution No. 2017-063). 26 City of Chula Vista, Human Relations Commission, https://www.chulavistaca.gov/departments/city- clerk/boards-commissions/boards-commissions-list/human-relations-commission. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 8 federal legislation to protect immigrant communities.27 Most notable was the process that led Chula Vista to become the first certified “Welcoming City” in California.28 Also in 2017, Chula Vista Police Chief Kennedy issued a statement to clarify that the focus of the CVPD: “The spotlight on the proposed changes in the National immigration policy has caused anxiety and uneasiness in many undocumented individuals fearing arrest and deportation from our community. I want to take the opportunity to put your minds at ease and state that all members of our community matter, regardless of immigration status. The Chula Vista Police Department’s focus is on public safety, not immigration.”29 During this same time period - in direct contradiction to the City’s public measures to protect and reassure all residents - the CVPD quietly requested a quote (dated October 26, 2017) for new ALPR equipment and data sharing technology and a contract with Vigilant Solutions, LLC, was signed by the City on December 28, 2017. This purchase and new relationship with Vigilant allowed the City of Chula Vista to routinely capture and share the exact whereabouts of local residents, visitors, employees, etc., with over 800 private and public agencies across the country, including federal immigration agencies. The City’s data-sharing contract with Vigilant was not revealed until almost three years later, in an article published in the San Diego Union Tribune in December, 2020.30 The Mayor and City Council were reported to have been unaware of the arrangement, and the Police Chief later admitted that she had not known its details.31 Community members responded with an immediate outcry, demanding answers and a halt to Chula Vista’s ALPR program. The City announced at the end of the next Council meeting that they had stopped sharing ALPR data with two, but not all, federal immigration agencies, and the Mayor promised a comprehensive report in early January 2021. Meanwhile Chula Vista’s ALPR program has continued - sharing ALPR data with hundreds of agencies across the nation. The ad hoc community group which formed at that time has continued to call for transparency and accountability from the City of Chula Vista. We submitted an CPRA request for relevant information in December 2020; this was quickly followed by a letter signed by over 40 organizations and individuals, requesting that the City provide for broad public review and community engagement, including a series of community listening sessions to expand opportunities for community participation in the decision-making process about this critical issue. Community 27 See generally Chronology of Contradictory Policies and Practices in the City of Chula Vista, available at https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y4FNt78KXcLAUg8czmFg8spMjkWQtDgvvhMLhxI9i_0/edit?usp=sharing (chronicling City of Chula Vista protections and welcoming policies). 28 Chula Vista Named First ‘Welcoming City’ for Immigrants in California, KPBS, Dec. 3, 2019, https://www.kpbs.org/news/2019/dec/03/chula-vista-named-first-welcoming-city-immigrants-/. 29 City of Chula Vista, Welcoming City, https://www.chulavistaca.gov/departments/city-manager/welcoming (last visited Mar. 12, 2021). 30 Gustavo Solis, Chula Vista Gives Immigration Officials, Others Access to License Plate Reader Data: Data Includes Location, Date and Time of Every Vehicle Photographed, SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIBUNE, Dec. 6, 2020, https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/communities/south-county/chula-vista/story/2020-12-06/chula-vista-gives- immigration-officials-others-access-to-license-plate-reader-data. 31 Gustavo Solis, Chula Vista Police Chief Says She Didn’t Know Department Shared Data With Feds, VOICE OF SAN DIEGO, Jan. 20, 2021, https://www.voiceofsandiego.org/topics/government/chula-vista-police-chief-says-she-didnt- know-department-shared-data-with-feds/. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 9 members have expressed concerns in numerous eComments and emails to City leaders regarding the ALPR program. As of the writing of this letter, however, the City has not meaningfully addressed our requests and concerns, and we still do not know when or how the comprehensive ALPR report promised for January 2021 will be released. For the individuals and organizations who have signed onto this letter, the City of Chula Vista no longer feels safe or “Welcoming.” The purchase and deployment of ALPR surveillance technology and data-sharing, without informed oversight or community input, have undermined trust in the City’s commitments to safety and equal protection for all. Sensitive location information of vulnerable community members has been shared directly with federal agencies including CBP, ICE, and HSI. There appear to be no protections or procedures in place to prevent Chula Vista’s license plate data from being shared informally (as occurred in La Habra), or otherwise made available to federal agencies. Sharing Chula Vista’s ALPR surveillance data allows federal immigration enforcement agencies to target individuals based on immigration status and to perform other illegal dragnet investigations, tearing apart the families and the fabric of the community, as well as destroying trust in city government and in the promise of the civil liberties protections for all members of the Chula Vista community. The failure of the City to monitor its ALPR program demonstrates the urgent need to enact strong protections and independent oversight of the City’s surveillance programs. V. Chula Vista Police Department Should Terminate Its Use of Invasive Surveillance Technology and Establish Policies and a Privacy Advisory Board. The use of ALPR technology creates well-documented risks to civil liberties and civil rights.32 While the Chula Vista Police Department may take steps to remove certain federal agencies from the list of those with access to driver location information, the risk of informal sharing with these agencies remains. Thus, the best way to ensure that Chula Vista residents are safe from unnecessary intrusion into their personal lives is to reject the use of ALPR technology altogether. A growing number of California cities have ended or declined contracts with Vigilant because of the risks that widespread sharing of ALPR data poses to their residents.33 We urge the City of Chula Vista and the Chula Vista Police Department to do the same. 32 See, e.g., Ángel Díaz & Rachel Levinson-Waldman, Automatic License Plate Readers: Legal Status and Policy Recommendations for Law Enforcement Use, BRENNAN CTR. FOR JUST., Sept. 10, 2020, https://www.brennancenter.org/our- work/research-reports/automatic-license-plate-readers-legal-status-and-policy-recommendations; Dave Maass, ICE Accesses a Massive Amount of License Plate Data. Will California Take Action?, ELECTRONIC FRONTIER F., Jan. 29, 2018, https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/01/ice-accesses-massive-amount-license-plate-data-will-california-take-action; ELEC. FRONTIER FOUND., supra note 2; AM. CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION, Automatic License Plate Readers, https://www.aclu.org/issues/privacy-technology/location-tracking/automatic-license-plate-readers (last visited Mar. 12, 2021); AM. CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION, supra note 2. 33 See, e.g., Libby Leyden, State Audits License Plate Readers: City May Postpone Discussion of Use in Half Moon Bay, HALF MOON BAY REVIEW, July 10, 2019, https://www.hmbreview.com/news/state-audits-license-plate- readers/article_a75ef500-a348-11e9-ae13-fb224b7a6644.html (Half Moon Bay); Marco Rodriguez, ‘If they don’t want it, I won’t force it’: Delano Police Chief Said He Plans to Advise City Council Against License Plate Reading Technology, KERN SOL NEWS, July 1, 2019, https://southkernsol.org/2019/07/01/if-they-dont-want-it-i-wont-force-it-delano-police-chief-said-he- plans-to-advise-city-council-against-license-plate-reading-technology/ (City of Delano); City Council Drops Vigilant Solutions Contract Over Risk To Immigrant Community, SFGate, June 26, 2019, https://www.sfgate.com/news/bayarea/article/City-Council-Drops-Vigilant-Solutions-Contract-14054732.php (City of Richmond); Meeting Minutes, Special Meeting of the Culver City Council, Culver City Housing Authority Board, and Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 10 Further, we urge City of Chula Vista officials to adopt a process that requires transparency, oversight, and meaningful community engagement on the deployment of any surveillance technologies. The ACLU has published a model ordinance that cities can adapt for their local needs.34 This ordinance would require agencies to seek public approval of surveillance technologies in advance of their deployment. The ordinance would further require agencies seeking to acquire surveillance technologies to explain publicly the purpose of the acquisitions, the policies that will govern the technologies’ use, the costs of the technologies, the technologies’ risks to communities’ privacy and civil rights, and the availability of alternatives to the proposed technologies. Armed with this information, the Chula Vista community can better assess whether to sanction the acquisition and use of such technologies—helping secure much-needed trust between the community and its local government. Within the usage and privacy ordinance, the City should adopt a policy that empowers community members with the knowledge and technical details necessary to decide what surveillance technologies, if any, should be deployed in the City. This policy should adopt explicit privacy and civil liberties protections, including protections to prevent residents’ data from being used for the purpose of enforcing federal immigration law. In addition, we urge the City of Chula Vista to establish an independent community-led Privacy Advisory Board to oversee acquisition and use of surveillance technology. The Board would include community members, transparency advocates, technology experts, and lawyers. The Board would conduct annual reviews of reports and impact analyses of any existing surveillance technology and set up criteria for analysis of any future surveillance technologies. *** In conclusion, we demand that the City of Chula Vista and the Chula Vista Police Department immediately stop any and all ALPR data-sharing relationships and practices that may provide CBP, ICE or HSI with access to driver location information, whether through formal permission, informal sharing, system misuse, or lack of knowledge and oversight. We also urge the City to do the following: ● Terminate the contract with Vigilant Solutions, LLC, and use of license plate reader surveillance technology altogether. ● Pass a usage and privacy ordinance governing Chula Vista’s use of surveillance technology that is compliant with S.B. 34 and S.B. 54. ● Establish an independent community-led Privacy Advisory Board to oversee acquisition and use of surveillance technology. Successor Agency to the Culver City Redevelopment Agency Board (Mar. 13, 2018), https://culver- city.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=M&ID=596334&GUID=0D716B8A-439C-4B1E-A14C-54C706DB3AF7 (Culver City); Russell Brandom, ICE Contract Sparks License Plate Reader Backlash from Cities, THE VERGE, Feb. 7, 2018, https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/7/16988058/ice-license-plate-reader-backlash-alameda-deportation-aclu (City of Alameda); Haley Pedersen, Communities Across the Country Reject Automated License Plate Readers, ELEC. FRONTIER FOUND., Aug. 21, 2019, https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/08/communities-across-country-reject-automated-license-plate- readers. 34 ACLU OF N. CAL., SURVEILLANCE TOOLKIT: MODEL LEGISLATION FOR A SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY & COMMUNITY SAFETY ORDINANCE (2020), https://bit.ly/3bCPUle. Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 11 We also request the following records, pursuant to the California Public Records Act (Government Code §§ 6250, et. seq.) and Article I § 3(b) of the California Constitution: ● Records confirming that the Chula Vista Police Department has stopped any direct sharing of ALPR data with federal immigration enforcement agencies, including CBP, ICE, and HSI. ● Records of any communications between the Chula Vista Police Department and federal immigration enforcement agencies, including CBP, ICE, and HSI, relating to license plate reader data, Vigilant Solutions, Perceptics, and/or the LEARN database. Thank you for your attention. We look forward to your prompt action and response. Sincerely, COMMUNITY MEMBERS: Adriana Jasso, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 8 Alicia Riley, PhD, MA, MPH, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Allison Estrada, MD, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 3 (Padilla) Angelica Ruiz, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 4 (Cardenas) Barb Huntington, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 1 (McCann) Becki Wallies, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 3 Becky Thimm, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 1 (McCann) Beryl Flom, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 1 Birdie Gutierrez, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Brenda Aguirre, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Candace Young-Schult, Concerned Resident of City of Carlsbad Carolyn Theiss-Aird, Social Justice Chair, Pilgrim United Church of Christ, Carlsbad Caryn Hoffman, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 1 (McCann) Connie Mack, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Darryl Tell, Concerned Resident of Carlsbad David Harris, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 4 Denise Harder, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Dinora Reyna-Gutierrez, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 3 (Padilla) Emily Green, Concerned Resident of La Mesa Ismahan Abdullahi, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 9 Jacob Babauta, Concerned Resident of Bonita, County Supervisor District 1 (Vargas) Jerilyn Nolfi Brown, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Jose Lopez, Concerned Resident of Imperial Beach Kate Bishop, Vice President, Chula Vista Elementary Board of Education Kathy Cappos Hardy, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Kathy Tell, Concerned Resident of Carlsbad Kelly Gates, Associate Professor UC San Diego, Communication Larry Stowell, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 2 Lilly Irani, Associate Professor UC San Diego, Communication Lois Keplin, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 4 (Cardenas) Luz Maria Lopez, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 1 (McCann) Lynn DeHahn, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 12 Margaret A. Baker, DrPH, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Marely Ramirez, Concerned Resident of Coronado Maria E. Mora, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Mejgan Afshan, Concerned Resident of La Mesa Monica Santos, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Nancy Hazelton, Concerned Resident of San Diego Nancy Relaford, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 3 Nandita Kar, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 5 Nick Paul, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 3 (Padilla) Norell Martínez, PhD, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Patricia Huffman, 91-Year Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Pedro Rios, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 4 (Cardenas) Ricardo Medina, Ph.D., Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 2 (Galvez) Roberto Alcantar, Vice President of Southwestern Community College District Ronel Desauguste, Concerned Resident of south San Diego Ruth Kaplan, Concerned Resident of San Diego District 1 Tania Calvillo, Concerned Resident of Chula Vista District 3 (Padilla) Terry Zack, Concerned Resident of City of Coronado Tina Givens, Tech Workers Coalition-SD Vivian Marlene Dunbar, Concerned Resident of San Ysidro Wilda Vallon, Concerned Resident of south San Diego ORGANIZATIONS: Advancing Students Forward Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego and Imperial Counties Border Angels Borderlands for Equity Change Begins With ME (Indivisible) Employee Rights Center (ERC) Espacio Migrante Indivisible San Diego Persist MAS PACE (Muslim American Society-Public Affairs and Civic Engagement) National Day Laborer Organizing Network (NDLON) Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans (PANA) Pillars of the Community Rise Up San Diego San Diego Border Dreamers San Diego Immigrant Rights Consortium Secure Justice South Bay People Power Showing Up for Racial Justice – San Diego (SURJ-SD) Tech Workers Coalition-SD The San Diego LGBT Community Center TRUST SD (Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology San Diego) Coalition Together We Will San Diego UURISE - Unitarian Universalist Refugee and Immigrant Services and Education Item 8 - Written Communications Baker 13 US-Mexico Border program, American Friends Service Committee encl. CC: Mary Casillas Salas, Mayor of Chula Vista Chula Vista City Council Roxana Kennedy, Chula Vista Police Chief Assemblymember Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher State Senator Ben Hueso Congressman Juan Vargas City Clerk, City of Chula Vista Item 8 - Written Communications Baker Agency Data Sharing Report Detections Shared The Chula Vista Police Department Agency is Sharing its Detection data with the following Agencies: 100th Judicial District Attorney Traffic Enforcement 10th Judicial District Drug Task Force 17th Judicial Circuit Drug Task Force 21st Drug Task Force 24th Judicial District Drug Task Force 32nd Judicial District Attorney Office AATA Abbeville Police Department ACJIC (api)Acworth Police Department Adams County Sheriffs Office (MS)Addison Police Department (TX) Adel Police Department Adrian Police Department Alachua County Sheriff Alameda County Narcotics Task Force Alameda Police Department Alamo Heights TX PD Alamosa County Sheriffs Department Alapaha Police Department Alcohol And Tobacco Tax And Trade Bureau ALEA Allen Police Department Allendale County Sheriffs Office Alma Police Department Alpharetta Police Department (GA) Amberley Police Department (OH)American Canyon Police Department Anaheim Police Department Antioch Police Department CA Aragon Police Department Arapahoe County Sheriff Office Arcade Police Department Arcadia Police Department Ardsley Police Department Arizona Department of Public Safety Arlington Police Department (TX)Arnold Police Department Atascosa County Constables ATF National Account Athens-Clarke Police Department Atlantic City International Airport (NJ) Auburn Police Department CA Auburn Police Department Austin Police Department Austin Regional Intelligence Center (TX) Avondale Estates Police Department Azusa Police Department (CA) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 1 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Baker County Sheriff Bakersfield Police Department Baldwin County Sheriffs Office Ball Ground Police Department Banks County Sheriffs Office Bartlett Police Department Bartow County Sheriffs Office Bartow Police Department Batesville PD Bay Area Rapid Transit Police (CA) Beachwood Police Beacon Police Department Beaumont Police Department Beaumont Police Department (TX) Bell Gardens Police Department Bell Police Department Belleville Police Department (NJ)Belvedere Police Department Ben Hill County Sheriffs Office Bensalem Township Police Department Bergen County Prosecutors Office (NJ)Bernardsville Police Department Bessemer Police Department Beverly Hills Police Department Bexar County Constables (Demo)Bexar County Sheriffs Office (TX) Biloxi Police Department (MS)Binghamton Police Department Birmingham Police Department Blairsville Police Department Bloomingdale Police Department Blue Mound Police Department Blue Ridge Police Department Blythe Police Department Boca Raton Police Department Bolivar Police Department Boone County Sheriff Office Boonville Police Department Bossier City PD Bossier Sheriffs Office Bowdon Police Department Branson Police Department Brazoria County Constables Office Brea Police Department Brentwood Police Department Brentwood Police Department CA Bridge City Police Department Bristol Township Police Department Bronxville Police Department Brookhaven Police Department Brooks County Sheriffs Office Broome County Sheriffs Office Buena Park Police Department Buffalo Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 2 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Bulloch County Sheriffs Office Bulverde Police Department Burbank Police Department (CA)Burleson Police Department Burlington Police NC Burnet County TX Law Enforcement Burr Ridge Police Department Butler Police Department Byron Police Department CA DOJ - Bureau of Firearms (CA) CA Parole Apprehension Team (CA)Calcasieu Parish Sheriffs Office Caldwell Police Department (NJ)Calhoun County Sheriffs Office California Franchise Tax Board (CA)California Highway Patrol (CA) Calumet City Police Department Camden County Ga Sheriffs Office Camden County Police Department Camden County Sheriffs Office Camilla Police Department Canton Township Police Department Cape Coral Police Department Cape Girardeau Police Department Carlsbad Police Department Carroll County Sheriffs Office Carrollton Police Department Carrollton Police Department TX Carson City Sheriffs Dept Cartersville Police Department Carthage Police Department Casa Grande Police Department Castle Hills Police Department Castle Rock Police Department Cathedral City Police Department Cayuga Heights Police Department CBP - NTC Cecil County Sheriffs Office Cedar Hill PD Cedar Rapids Police Department Cedartown Police Department Center Point Department of Public Safety (AL) Centerville Police Department Chambersburg Police Department Chandler Police Department Chatham County Sheriffs Office Chattahoochee Hills Police Cherokee County Sheriffs Office Chicago HIDTA (IL)Chicago Police Department Chino Police Department Christian County Sheriff MO Cicero Police Department (IL)Cincinnati Police Department (OH) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 3 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Citrus Heights Police Department City of Burleson Municipal Court City of Garrett Police Department City of Kirby City of Vidor City of White Police Department Clackamas County Sheriffs Office Claremont Police Department (CA) Clarkstown Police Department (NY)Clayton County Police Department Clayton County Sheriffs Office Clayton Police Department (MO) Clayton Police Department CA Cleburne Police Department Climax Police Department Clovis Police Department Cobb County Police Department Cochran Police Department Cockrell Hill Police Department Cohutta Police Department College Park Police Department College Station Police Department Collier County Sheriffs Office Collins Police Department Colorado State Patrol (CO)Colquitt Police Department Comer Police Department Commerce City Police Department Concord Police Department (CA)Conecuh Sheriffs Department Conroe Police Department Contra Costa County Sheriffs Conyers Police Department Cook County States Attorney (IL) Coppell Police Department Coral Gables Police Department Coral Springs Police Department Corona Police Department Coronado Police Department (CA)Costa Mesa Police Department County of San Mateo Sheriffs Office Covington Police Department Coweta County Sheriffs Office (CSU)Coweta County Sheriffs Office Crowley Police Department CSU Fullerton Police Department Cuba Police Department MO Cumming Police Department Cypress Police Department Dallas City Marshal (TX) Dallas Police Department Dallas Police Department (Ga) Danville Police Department CA Daphne Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 4 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Darien Police Department Darien Police Department IL Decatur Police Department Deer Park Police Department DeKalb County Police Department Delaware County Sheriffs Office (OH) Delta Regional Auto Theft Team (CA)Demorest Police Department Denton County Sheriff Office Denton Police Department Department of Labor OIG (DOL OIG)Department of Transportation - Phoenix (AZ) Department of Veterans Affairs Police Des Peres Police Department DeSoto Police Department TX DFW Airport DHS - HSI (Houston)DHS - HSI (Newark NJ) DHS - HSI - New Orleans Dickinson Police Department Dillard Police Department Dilley Police Department District 21 Drug Task Force Doerun Police Department Donalsonville Police Department Dooly County Sheriffs Office Doraville Police Department Dothan Police Department Douglas County Sheriff (CO)Douglas County Sheriffs Office Douglasville Police Department Downers Grove Police Department Downey Police Department Drug Enforcement Agency (NATL) Drug Task Force 17th Judicial District (TN)Dryden Police Department Dublin Police Department (OH)Dublin Police Department CA Dublin Police Department Duluth Police Department Dunwoody Police Department Dutchess County Sheriff East Chicago Police Department East Dublin Police Department Echols County Sheriffs Office Edinburg Police Department Edwardsville Police Department9i El Cajon Police Department (CA) El Dorado County Sheriff El Paso Police Department El Segundo Police Department (CA)Elgin Police Department Elk Grove Police Department Elk Grove Village Police Department (IL) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 5 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Elmhurst Police Department Emanuel County Sheriffs Office Emeryville Police Department Enfield Police Department (CT) Escondido Police Department Evergreen Park Police Department (IL) Fairfield Police Department CA Fairfield Police Department CT Fannin County Sheriffs Office Farmers Branch Police Department Fayette CO TX SO Fayette County Sheriffs Office Fayetteville Police Department FBI - Chicago Federal Bureau of Investigation Federal Way Police Department Fitzgerald Police Department Flemington Police Department Flint Police Department Foley Police Department Folsom Police Department Fontana Police Department Forsyth County Sheriffs Office Fort Bend CO TX Narcotics Task Force Fort Bend County Sheriffs Office Fort Lauderdale Police Department Fort Worth Police Department Fountain Valley Police Department Franklin County Sheriff Franklin County Sheriffs Office Freeway Safety Network - EAST BAY Fresno County Sheriffs Office (CA) Frisco Police Department Fullerton Police Department Fullerton Police Department - DEMO Fulton County Police Department Gainesville Police Department Gallatin Police Department (TN) Galt Police Department Galveston Auto Theft Task Force Garden Grove Police Department Gardena Police Department Gaston Police Department Geary County Sheriff Georgia Tech Police Department Giddings Police Department GJPD Glen Ellyn Police Department (IL) Glendale Police Department AZ Glendora Police Department Glenn County Sheriffs Office (CA)Golden Beach Police Department Goodyear Police Department (AZ)Grand Prairie Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 6 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Grants Pass Department of Public Safety Grantville Police Department Greece NY Police Department Greenburgh Police Department Greene County sheriffs Office Greenville Police Department (TX) Gresham Police Department Griffith Police Department (IN) Grosse Ile Police Grosse Pointe Park Public Safety Groton Police Department Grundy County States Attorney Office Guadalupe County Constables Guadalupe County Sheriffs Office Gulf Shores Police Department Gulfport Police Department Gwinnett County Police Department (GA)Habersham County Sheriffs Office Hagan Police Department Hamilton County Sheriff (IN) Hammond Police Department Hampton County Sheriffs Office Hapeville Police Department Hardin County Sheriffs Office Harlem Police Department Harris County District Attorneys Office (TX) Harris County Sheriffs Office Hawthorne Police Department Hayward Police Department Heflin Police Department (AL) Hemet Police Department (CA)Henderson Police Department Hendersonville Police Department Hermosa Beach Police Department Hickory Hills Police Department HIDTA - Central Valley California Highland Park Dept of Public Safety (TX)Highland Police Department Hill Country Village Police Department Hillsboro Police Department Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office Hinesville Police Department Hinsdale Police Department Hiram Police Department Hogansville Police Department Holly Springs Police Department Hollywood Park Police Department Hollywood Police Department (Fl) Homerville Police Department Homestead Police Department (PA) Homewood Police Department Honolulu Police Department Hoover Police Department Hopkinsville Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 7 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Houston Police Department (TX)HSI Bulk Cash Smuggling Center HTU Iberia Parish Sheriffs Department Iberville Parish LA SO ICE Illinois State Police BATTLE Task Force (IL)Illinois State Police Task Force Imperial County Regional ALPR Program Indian Creek Village Indiana Intelligence Fusion Center (IN)Indiana State Police Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department (IN)Indianapolis Police Department Irondequoit Police Department Irvine Police Department (CA) Irving Police Department (TX)Irwinton Police Department Ithaca Police Department Jackson County Sheriffs Office Jacksonville Police Department GA Jasper County Sheriff MO Jasper County Sheriffs Office MS JCSO Special Ops JCSO-MACC Jefferson City Police Department Jefferson CO TX SO Jefferson County Sheriffs Office Jim Wells County Sheriffs Office Johns Creek Police Department Johnson County Sheriffs Office Joint Regional Intelligence Center (CA) Jones County Sheriffs Department Jonesboro Police Department Joplin Police Department Junction City Police Department Kane County Sheriffs Office Kansas City Police Department (KS) Kansas City Police Department (MO)Kennedale City Marshals Office Kennesaw Police Department Killeen Texas Police Department Kings Point Police Department Kingston Police Department Kirkwood Police Department Kyle Police Department L.A. County Sheriffs Dept La Habra Police Department La Mesa Police Department La Palma Police Department LA Port Police La Verne Police Department Lafayette Police Department (CA)Lafayette Police Department (LA) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 8 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Laguna Beach Police Department Lake City Police Department Lake County Sheriffs Office (IL)Lake Mills Police Department (WI) Lake Ozark Police Department Lake St Louis Police Department Lakeland Police Department Lakeway Police Department Lamar County Sheriffs Department Lancaster County Sheriffs Office Lanier County Sheriffs Office Lansing Police Department (IL) Las Vegas Metro Police Department Lee County Alabama Sheriffs Office Lee County Sheriffs Office Lee County Sheriffs Office (GA) Lees Summit Police Department Leesburg Police Department Leslie Police Department Lewisville Police Department Lexington County Health Services Liberty County Sheriffs Office Liberty County Sheriffs Office (TX)Lincoln County Sheriff MO Lincoln Police Department (CA)Lincolnton Police Department Lithonia Police Department Livermore Police Department Livingston County Sheriffs Office (MI)Locust Grove Police Department Lodi Police Department Logan County Sheriffs Office (KS) Loganville Police Department Lombard Police Department Long Beach Police Department Long County Sheriffs Office Los Alamitos Police Department Los Angeles CLEAR (CA) Los Angeles County Sheriff Los Angeles World Airport Police (LAX) Lovejoy Police Dept Loves Park Police Department Lowndes County Sheriffs Office Lufkin Police Department Lumberton Police Department Lumpkin Police Department Macomb Auto Theft Squad Madera Police Department Madison County Sheriffs Office (MS)Mahanoy Township Police Department Malvern Police Department Manchester Police Department Manhattan Beach Police Department Manheim Township Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 9 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Mansfield Police Department (TX)Manteca Police Department (CA) Maple Grove PD Maplewood Police Department Maricopa County Attorney (MCAO)Maricopa County District Attorneys Office (AZ) Maricopa Police Department Marietta Police Department Marin County Sheriffs Office Marion Police Department Marshallville Police Department MARTA Police Department Martinez Police Department CA Martinsville Police Department Martinsville Police Department (IN)Maryland State Police- BATTF Maryville Public Safety McDonough Police Department McDuffie County Sheriffs Office McEwen Police Department McIntosh County Sheriffs Office McKinney Police Department McRae-Helena Police Department Medford Police Department Meigs Police Department Merced Police Department CA Meridian Police Department Meriwether County Sheriffs Office Mesa Police Department Mesquite Police Department Mesquite Police Department (NV)Metro Police Department (TX) Metter Police Department Metter Police Department (DEMO) Miami Beach Police Department Miami Dade Police Department Miami Dade Police Dept (Data)Miami Police Department Midland Police Department (TX)Midlothian Police Department Midwest City Police Department Mill Valley Police Department CA Millburn Police Department Millen Police Department Miller County Sheriffs Office Milton Police Department Missouri City Police Department Missouri Police Chiefs Association Modesto Police Department (CA)Monroe County Sheriff NY Monroe County Sheriffs Office Monroe Police Department Monrovia Police Department (CA)Montebello Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 10 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Monterey Park Police Department Montezuma Police Department Montgomery County EMA (OH)Montgomery Police Department Morton Police Department Moultrie Police Department Mounds View Police Department Mount Vernon Police Department Mundelein Police Department (IL)Munster Police Department Murray County Sheriffs Office Murrieta Police Department Muscogee County Marshals Office Nacogdoches County Sheriffs Office (TX) Nacogdoches Police Department Naperville Police Department Nassau County Sheriffs Department (FL)Nelson Police Department Network 3 Illinois Nevada Police Department New Bern Police Department New Brighton Public Safety New Canaan Police Department New Castle County Police Department New Castle Police Department New Lenox Police Department (IL) New York State DCJS New York State Office of the Attorney General New York State Police Newark Police Department (NJ) Newark Police Department DE Newport Beach Police Department Newton County Prosecutors Office (IN)Newton County Sheriffs Office Niagara County Sheriff (NY)Niagara Falls Police Department Nicholls Police Department NJ State Police RTCC Norman Park Police Department North West HIDTA (WA) Northbrook Police Department (IL)Northeast Florida Fusion Center Northern California Regional Intelligence Center (CA)Northfield Township Police Department (MI) Northumberland County Sheriffs Office Norwalk Police Department Novato Police Department Nutley Police Department NY-MTA Police NYC Department of Investigation NYPD Real Time Crime Center Oak Brook Police Department (IL) Oakley Police Department Oceanside Police Department (CA) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 11 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Office of Inspector General - DC Ogden Police Department Oglethorpe Police Department (GA)Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation Oliver Police Department Omega Police Department Ontario County Sheriffs Office Ontario Police Department Opelika Police Department Orange County District Attorney (CA) Orange County Sheriff Orange County Sheriff (TX) Orange County Sheriffs Department Orange Police Department Orange Police Department (CT)Orange Police Department TX Orinda Police Department Oro Valley Police Department Osage Beach Police Department Ossining Police Department Oswego County Sheriffs Office Ouachita Parish Sheriffs Office (LA) Overland Police Department Oxnard Police Department Palm Beach County Sheriffs Palm Springs Police Department (CA) Palos Verdes Estates Police Department Paradise Valley Police Department Paramus Police Department Parke County Sheriffs Office Pasadena Police Department (CA)Pasadena Police Department (TX) Pascagoula Police Department Peachtree City Police Dept Pearl Police Department Pearl River County Sherrifs Office Pearland Police Department Pearson Police Department Pelham Police Department (GA)Pembroke Police Department Pendergrass Police Department Pensacola Police Department Perry Police Department Perryville Police Department Petaluma Police Department (CA)Phoenix Police Department Pike County Sheriffs Office Pima County Sheriff Pine Lake Police Department Pine Mountain Police Department Pitt County Sheriffs Office Pittsburg Police Department CA Placentia Police Department Plains Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 12 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Plano Police Department Pleasant Hill Police Department Pleasanton Police Department Polk County Sheriff Polk County Sheriffs (NDI2LEARN)Pomona Police Department Pooler Police Department Poplar Bluff Police Department Port Arthur Police Department Port of Long Beach Powder Springs Police Department Prince Georges County Police Prosper Police Department Putnam County Sheriff Queens County District Attorneys Office (NY)Ramsey County Sheriffs Rancho Viejo Police Department (TX)Rankin County Sheriffs Office Ray City Police Department Red Bluff Police Department Red Oak Marshals Office Redlands Police Department (CA) Redondo Beach Police Department Redwood City PD Reeve County Sherriffs Office Register Police Department Reidsville Police Department Reno Police Department Rhode Island State Police Richardson Police Department Richland Police Department Richmond County Sheriffs Office Richmond Police Department Ridgeland Police Department Rincon Police Department Ringgold Police Department Riverdale Police Department Riverside County District Attorneys Office (CA) Riverside County Sheriffs Department (CA)Riverside Police Department Riverside Police Department (MO)Rockdale County Sheriff Rockford Police Department Rocklin Police Department (CA) Rockville Centre Police Department Rockwall County Sheriffs Rohnert Park Police Department CA Rolla Police Department Roseville Police Department (CA)Roswell Police Department Round Rock Police Department (TX)Rowlett Police Department (TX) Sacramento County District Attorneys Office (CA)Sacramento County Sheriffs Office Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 13 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Sacramento Police Department Sacramento Probations Department Saint Louis County Police Department (MO)Salamanca Police Department Salem Police Department Oregon San Bernardino County District Attorneys Office (CA) San Bernardino County Sheriffs San Bernardino Police Department San Bruno Police Department San Diego County District Attorney (CA) San Diego County Sheriff San Diego Police Department San Diego Regional Auto Theft Task Force San Diego Sector Border Patrol (CA) San Joaquin County District Attorney (CA)San Joaquin County Sheriffs Department (CA) San Juan Police Department (TX)San Luis Obispo Sheriffs Office San Mateo County Vehicle Theft Task Force San Mateo Police Department (CA) San Pablo Police Department CA San Rafael Police Department San Ramon Police Department Santa Ana Police Department Santa Barbara County District Attorneys Office (CA)Santa Clara County District Attorneys Office (CA) Santa Clara Police Department Santa Fe Police Department (NM) Saraland Police Department Saugerties Police Department Sausalito Police Department Schaumburg Police Department Schererville Police Department Scottsdale Police Department Screven County Sheriffs Office Seal Beach Police Department Senoia Police Department Shawnee County Sheriffs Office Signal Hill Police Department Sikeston Police Department Simi Valley Police Department Skokie Police Department Smith County Sheriff Office Social Circle Police Department Solano County Sheriffs Office (CA)Somers Point Police Department Somerset County Prosecutors Office Soperton Police Department SOSINK South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SC) South Chicago Heights Police Department (IL)South Gate Police Department (CA) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 14 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report South Pasadena Police Department Southeast Michigan Intelligence Center (MI) Southwest Major Case Unit (IL)Sparks Police Department Sparks Police Department (GA)Speedway Police Department Springfield IL Police Department Springfield MO Police Department Springfield Police Department St Charles Police Department St Joseph Police Department St Louis Fusion Center St Tammany Parish Sheriffs Office (LA)St. Charles County Police Department St. Louis County Police Stanislaus County Auto Theft Task Force Stanislaus County Sheriffs Department Statesboro Police Department Stockton Police Department Stone Mountain Police Department Stratford Police Department Suffolk County NY Police Department Sugar Creek Police Department Sulphur Police Department Sumter County Sheriffs Office Sunny Isles Beach Police Department SUNY New Paltz Taliaferro County Sheriffs Office Talladega Police Department Tallapoosa Police Department Tarrant County District Attorney (TX)Tattnall County Sheriffs Office Tempe Police Department Temple Police Department Tennessee HLS District 7 Tennille Police Department Texas City Police Department Texas Department of Public Safety (TX) Thomas County Sheriffs Office Thomaston Police Department Thomasville Police Department Throckmorton County Sheriffs Office Tiburon Police Department CA Tift County Sheriff Office Tifton Police Department Tigard Police Department Toccoa Police Department Tompkins County Sheriff Torrance Police Department Town of Bay Harbor Islands Tracy Police Department CA Travis County SO Treutlen County Sheriffs Office Troup County Sheriffs Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 15 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Trumansburg Police Department Trumbull Police Department Trussville Police Department Tuckahoe Police Department Tucson Police Department (AZ)Tulare Police Department Tunnel Hill Police Department Tuscaloosa County Sheriffs Department Tustin Police Department Tybee Island Police Dept Tyler City Marshal Tyrone Police Department UC Irvine Police Department Ulster County Sheriffs Office Union City Police Department (CA)Union City Police Department Union County Sheriffs Office United States Forest Service CA United States Forest Service Utah United States Marshals Service University of Delaware University of Georgia Police Department University of Michigan-Flint Police University Park Police Department Upland Police Department (CA)Upson County Sheriffs Office US Attorney Southern District of NY US Postal Inspection Service VA Hospital Palo Alto Vancouver Police Department Varnell Police Department Ventura County Sheriff Department Ventura Police Department (CA)Vernon Police Department Vestavia Hills Police Department (AL)Vienna Police Department Villa Park Police Department Villa Rica Police Department Von Ormy City Marshals Office Wadsworth Police Department (OH) Walnut Creek Police Department Walton County Sheriffs Office Warm Springs Police Department Warner Robins Police Department Warren County Sheriffs Office (GA)Warrenton Police Department Warwick Police Department Washoe County Sheriffs Office Watauga Police Department (TX)Waterfront Commission of NY Harbor Waxahachie City Marshals Webster Grove Police Dept Webster Police Department Wenatchee Police Department Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 16 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Wentzville Police Department West Baton Rouge West Caldwell Police Department (NJ)West Covina Police Department West Point Police Department (GA)West Sacramento Police Department Westminster Police Department Westover Hills Police Department Westport Police Department Wethersfield Police Department Whigham Police Department White Bear Lake Police Department White County Sheriffs Office Whitehall Police Department (OH) Whitehouse Police Department Whitesburg Police Department Whitfield County Sheriffs Office Whittier Police Department Willacoochee Police Department Willard Police Department Williamson County Sheriffs Office Wilmette Police Department Windcrest Police Department Winder Police Department Winnebago County Sheriff (Machesney Park Division) Wise County Sheriffs Office (TX) Woodland Police Department Woodstock Police Department Woodway Police Department Wrens Police Department (GA) Wrightsville Police Department WRP-LPR Wylie Police Department (TX)Yakima Police Department Yates County Sheriffs Office Yellowstone National Park Yolo County Sheriffs Department Zebulon Police Department Detections Received The Chula Vista Police Department Agency is receiving Detection data from the following Agencies: Agency City State Union City Police Department (CA)Union City CA Dooly County Sheriffs Office Pinehurst GA JCSO-MACC Birmingham AL Foley Police Department Foley AL Brentwood Police Department CA Brentwood CA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 17 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report La Habra Police Department La Habra CA Midwest City Police Department Midwest City OK Schererville Police Department Schererville IN San Rafael Police Department san rafael CA Kingston Police Department Kingston GA Lincoln County Sheriff MO Troy MO Stockton Police Department Stockton CA Saraland Police Department Saraland AL Upland Police Department (CA)Upland CA Somerset County Prosecutors Office Somerville NJ Stratford Police Department Stratford CT Oceanside Police Department (CA)Oceanside CA Dimmit County Sheriffs Office (TX)Carrizo Springs TX San Mateo County Vehicle Theft Task Force San Mateo CA Belvedere Police Department Belvedere CA Hayward Police Department Hayward CA Bell Gardens Police Department Bell Gardens CA Brea Police Department Brea CA Whitesburg Police Department Whitesburg GA Hermosa Beach Police Department Hermosa Beach CA Clovis Police Department Clovis CA Elmhurst Police Department Elmhurst IL Woodland Police Department Woodland CA Marin County Sheriffs Office San Rafael CA Port Arthur Police Department Port Arthur TX West Baton Rouge Port Allen LA Lamar County Sheriffs Department Purvis MS Nevada Police Department Nevada MO Cicero Police Department (IL)Cicero IL Tracy Police Department CA Tracy CA Irvine Police Department (CA)Irvine CA Bulloch County Sheriffs Office Statesboro GA St Joseph Police Department St. Joseph MO McEwen Police Department McEwen TN Iberia Parish Sheriffs Department New Iberia LA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 18 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Killeen Texas Police Department Killeen TX San Pablo Police Department CA San Pablo CA Dublin Police Department CA Dublin CA Red Bluff Police Department Red Bluff CA Saratoga Springs Police Department (NY) Saratoga Springs NY Cedartown Police Department Cedartown GA Ouachita Parish Sheriffs Office (LA)Monroe LA Tulare Police Department Tulare CA McDonough Police Department McDonough GA Placentia Police Department Placentia CA Huntsville Police Department (AL)Huntsville AL Chambers County Sheriffs Office (AL)Lanett AL Vestavia Hills Police Department (AL)Vestavia Hills AL Otay Ranch Town Center Mall N/A N/A Delta Regional Auto Theft Team (CA)Stockton CA Lee County Sheriffs Office Ft. Myers FL West Covina Police Department West Covina CA Guadalupe County Sheriffs Office Seguin TX Grand Prairie Police Department GP TX Arizona Department of Public Safety Phoenix AZ Prosper Police Department Prosper TX Bensalem Township Police Department Bensalem PA Redlands Police Department (CA)Redlands CA Forsyth County Sheriffs Office Cumming GA Trumbull Police Department Trumbull CT Troup County Sheriffs LaGrange GA Riverside County Sheriffs Department (CA) Riverside CA San Joaquin County Sheriffs Department (CA) French Camp CA Jones County Sheriffs Department Laurel MS DeKalb County Police Department Tucker GA Logan County Sheriffs Office (KS)Oakley KS San Luis Obispo Sheriffs Office San Luis Obispo CA Antioch Police Department CA Antioch CA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 19 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Arnold Police Department Arnold MO Carthage Police Department Carthage MO Mahanoy Township Police Department Mahanoy City PA Burnet County TX Law Enforcement Marble Falls TX Overland Police Department Overland MO Rohnert Park Police Department CA Rohnert Park CA 100th Judicial District Attorney Traffic Enforcement Wellington TX Denton County Sheriff Office Denton TX CBP - NTC Washington DC Maricopa Police Department Maricopa AZ Union County Sheriffs Office Blairsville GA Trussville Police Department Trussville AL Los Angeles World Airport Police (LAX)Los Angeles CA Niagara County Sheriff (NY)Lockport NY Villa Rica Police Department Villa Rica GA Newark Police Department DE Newark DE Cape Girardeau Police Department Cape Girardeau MO Newton County Sheriffs Office Covington GA Allendale County Sheriffs Office Fairfax SC Salem Police Department Oregon Salem OR Thomas County Sheriffs Office Thomasville GA Somers Point Police Department Somers Point NJ Kirkwood Police Department Kirkwood MO Department of Transportation - Phoenix (AZ) Phoenix AZ Pima County Sheriff Tucson AZ Acworth Police Department Acworth GA Wise County Sheriffs Office (TX)Decatur TX Folsom Police Department Folsom CA Alpharetta Police Department (GA)Alpharetta GA Brevard County Sheriffs Office Titusville FL El Segundo Police Department (CA)El Segundo CA Christian County Sheriff MO Ozark MO NJ State Police RTCC Newark NJ Groton Police Department Groton NY Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 20 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Lincoln Police Department (CA)Lincoln CA Canton Township Police Department Canton MI Sugar Creek Police Department Independence MO California Highway Patrol (CA)West Sacramento CA Richland Police Department Richland MS Colton Police Department Colton CA CSU Fullerton Police Department Fullerton CA Phoenix Police Department Phoenix AZ Alameda Police Department Alameda CA Westminster Police Department Westminster CA Pigeon Forge Police Department (TN)Pigeon Forge TN Sahuarita Police Department (AZ)Sahuarita AZ San Diego Regional Auto Theft Task Force San Diego CA Webster Grove Police Dept Webster Groves MO Sausalito Police Department Sausalito CA Highland Police Department Highland IN Novato Police Department Novato CA Poplar Bluff Police Department Poplar Bluff MO Nacogdoches County Sheriffs Office (TX) Nacogdoches TX Vancouver Police Department Vancouver WA 24th Judicial District Drug Task Force Camden TN HIDTA - Central Valley California Sacramento CA Harris County Sheriffs Office Humble TX Warwick Police Department Warwick GA New York State Police Albany NY Monterey Park Police Department Monterey Park CA Annapolis Police Department (MD)Annapolis MD McDuffie County Sheriffs Office Thomson GA Riverside County District Attorneys Office (CA) Riverside CA Enfield Police Department (CT)Enfield CT Macomb Auto Theft Squad Mt. Clemens MI Manteca Police Department (CA)Manteca CA Long Beach Police Department Long Beach CA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 21 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Gallatin Police Department (TN)Gallatin TN Sacramento County Sheriffs Office Sacramento CA San Bernardino Police Department San Bernardino CA Marietta Police Department Marietta GA Westover Hills Police Department Fort Worth TX Scott County Sheriffs Office (IA)Davenport IA Lake City Police Department Lake City GA Lewisville Police Department Lewisville TX ATF National Account Washington DC Warner Robins Police Department Warner Robins GA Greece NY Police Department Greece NY Missouri City Police Department Missouri City TX Orange County Sheriffs Department Aliso Viejo CA Petaluma Police Department (CA)Petaluma CA Garden Grove Police Department Garden Grove CA Brentwood Police Department Brentwood MO Bartlett Police Department Bartlett TN Dickinson Police Department Dickinson TX South Pasadena Police Department South Pasadena CA Toccoa Police Department Toccoa GA Winder Police Department Winder GA Perryville Police Department Perryville MO Tucson Police Department (AZ)Tucson AZ Lanier County Sheriffs Office Lakeland GA Clackamas County Sheriffs Office Clackamas OR Clayton Police Department (MO)Clayton MO Evergreen Park Police Department (IL)Evergreen Park IL Nutley Police Department Nutley NJ Prescott Police Department (AZ)Prescott AZ Southwest Major Case Unit (IL)Hickory Hills IL Bartow County Sheriffs Office Cartersville GA Roseville Police Department (CA)Roseville CA Dutchess County Sheriff Poughkeepsie NY Yuma County Sheriffs Office (AZ)Yuma AZ Natick Police Department (MA)Natick MA Drug Enforcement Agency (NATL)Washington DC Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 22 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Pinal County Sheriffs Office (AZ)Florence AZ Montgomery Police Department Montgomery AL Pasadena Police Department (CA)Pasadena CA Corona Police Department Corona CA Calcasieu Parish Sheriffs Office Lake Charles LA Rockville Centre Police Department Rockville Center NY Doraville Police Department Doraville GA Illinois Statewide Auto Theft Task Force (IL) Thornton IL Tigard Police Department Tigard OR Sulphur Police Department Sulphur LA Martinsville Police Department (IN)Martinsville IN Hagan Police Department Claxton GA Tustin Police Department Tustin CA Geary County Sheriff Junction City KS Manheim Township Police Department Lancaster PA Orange Police Department Orange CA Laguna Beach Police Department Laguna Beach CA United States Marshals Service 1938 Saturn St.CA Torrance Police Department Torrance CA Cayuga Heights Police Department Ithaca NY Reno Police Department reno NV Conyers Police Department Conyers GA Carrollton Police Department Carrollton GA Los Angeles CLEAR (CA)Los Angeles CA ICE Washington DC Coronado Police Department (CA)Coronado CA Douglas County Sheriffs Office Douglasville GA Conroe Police Department Conroe TX Johns Creek Police Department Johns Creek GA Temple Police Department Temple GA Hidalgo County Sheriff (TX)Edinburg TX Merced Police Department CA Merced CA San Diego County Sheriff San Diego CA Signal Hill Police Department Signal Hill CA Bay Area Rapid Transit Police (CA)Oakland CA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 23 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Camden County Ga Sheriffs Office Woodbine GA Searcy Police Department (AR)Searcy AR Taliaferro County Sheriffs Office Crawford GA Woodway Police Department Woodway TX Palm Beach County Sheriffs West Palm Beach FL Dryden Police Department Dryden NY Hemet Police Department (CA)Hemet CA Citrus Heights Police Department Citrus Heights CA Millburn Police Department Millburn NJ Livermore Police Department livermore CA SOSINK Cincinnati OH Fate Department of Public Safety (TX)Fate TX Tiburon Police Department CA Tiburon CA Rockdale County Sheriff Conyers GA Henderson Police Department Henderson NV Cedar Hill PD Cedar Hill TX St Tammany Parish Sheriffs Office (LA)Convington LA Seal Beach Police Department Seal Beach CA Hoover Police Department Hoover AL Meridian Police Department Meridian MS Arcade Police Department Jefferson GA Riverside Police Department Riverside CA Redondo Beach Police Department Redondo Beach CA Douglasville Police Department Douglasville GA Westport Police Department Westport CT Athens-Clarke Police Department Athens GA Ithaca Police Department Ithaca NY Sparks Police Department Sparks NV San Diego County District Attorney (CA)San Diego CA Treutlen County Sheriffs Office Soperton GA Cuba Police Department MO Cuba MO Medford Police Department Medford OR Pembroke Police Department Pembroke GA Lancaster County Sheriffs Office Lincoln NE Shawnee County Sheriffs Office Topeka KS St Charles Police Department St. Charles MO Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 24 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report GJPD Grand Junction CO Oxnard Police Department Oxnard CA York County Sheriffs Department (NE)York NE Hopkinsville Police Department Hopkinsville KY Rowlett Police Department (TX)Rowlett TX Glendora Police Department Glendora CA Norman Park Police Department Norman Park GA Thomasville Police Department Thomasville GA Pomona Police Department Pomona CA Downey Police Department Downey CA El Dorado County Sheriff Placerville CA Martinez Police Department CA Martinez CA Crowley Police Department Crowley TX El Paso Police Department El Paso TX Tyrone Police Department Tyrone GA Cedar Rapids Police Department Cedar Rapids IA Northeast Florida Fusion Center Tallahassee FL Alameda County Narcotics Task Force Oakland CA Branson Police Department Branson MO Cleburne Police Department Cleburne TX Gillespie County Sheriffs Office (TX)Fredericksburg TX Coral Springs Police Department Coral Springs FL Buffalo Police Department Buffalo NY St. Charles County Police Department OFallon MO La Palma Police Department La Palma CA Bell Police Department Bell CA Doerun Police Department Doerun GA Lombard Police Department Lombard IL Hapeville Police Department Hapeville GA Ontario County Sheriffs Office Canandaigua NY Federal Way Police Department Federal Way WA Beachwood Police Beachwood OH Pleasant Hill Police Department Pleasant Hill CA Lake Mills Police Department (WI)Lake Mills WI Burr Ridge Police Department Burr Ridge IL Tompkins County Sheriff Ithaca NY Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 25 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Roswell Police Department Roswell GA Junction City Police Department Junction City KS San Bruno Police Department San Bruno CA Oro Valley Police Department Oro Valley AZ Cherokee County Sheriffs Office Canton GA DeSoto Police Department TX DeSoto TX Long Beach Township Police Department (NJ) Brant Beach NJ Hiram Police Department Hiram GA Palos Verdes Estates Police Department Palos Verdes Estates CA Grundy County States Attorney Office Morris IL Fontana Police Department Fontana CA Bakersfield Police Department Bakersfield CA DEMO Gloucester County Prosecutors Office (NJ) Woodbury NJ Pooler Police Department Pooler GA Lowndes County Sheriffs Office Valdosta GA Anaheim Police Department Anaheim CA Deer Park Police Department Deer Park TX Goodyear Police Department (AZ)Goodyear AZ Paradise Valley Police Department Paradise Valley AZ Hammond Police Department Hammond IN East Chicago Police Department East Chicago IN Habersham County Sheriffs Office Clarkesville GA Rolla Police Department Rolla MO La Mesa Police Department La Mesa CA San Diego Sector Border Patrol (CA)Chula Vista CA Iberville Parish LA SO Maringouin LA Yolo County Sheriffs Department Woodland CA Newport Beach Police Department Newport Beach CA Lansing Police Department (IL)Lansing IL Edinburg Police Department Edinburg TX Fayette CO TX SO La Grange TX Wylie Police Department (TX)Wylie TX Monroe County Sheriffs Office (AL)Monroeville AL Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 26 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Senoia Police Department Senoia GA Glendale Police Department AZ Glendale AZ University Park Police Department University Park TX Boonville Police Department Boonville MO Kennesaw Police Department Kennesaw GA Byron Police Department Byron GA West Sacramento Police Department West Sacramento CA Lumber City Police Department (GA)Lumber City GA University of CA San Francisco Police Department (CA) San Francisco CA Loganville Police Department Loganville GA Putnam County Sheriff Carmel NY Duluth Police Department Duluth GA Springfield MO Police Department Springfield MO Huntsville Police Department Huntsville TX Whittier Police Department Whittier CA Windcrest Police Department Windcrest TX Ventura County District Attorneys Office (CA) Ventura CA Stone Mountain Police Department Stone Mountain GA Hamilton County Sheriff (IN)Noblesville IN Lake County Sheriffs Office (IL)Waukegan IL Lees Summit Police Department Lees Summit MO Lafayette Police Department (LA)Lafayette LA Network 3 Illinois Homewood IL Midlothian Police Department Midlothian TX Hinsdale Police Department Hinsdale IL Tuscaloosa Police Department (AL)Tuscaloosa AL Wentzville Police Department Wentzville MO Woodstock Police Department Woodstock GA ALEA Montgomery AL Mesa Police Department Mesa AZ Modesto Police Department (CA)Modesto CA South Lake Tahoe Police Department (CA) South Lake Tahoe CA 17th Judicial Circuit Drug Task Force Demopolis AL Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 27 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Mansfield Police Department (TX)Mansfield TX Aragon Police Department Aragon GA San Bernardino County Sheriffs San Bernardino CA Lee County Alabama Sheriffs Office Opelika AL CA DOJ - Bureau of Firearms (CA)Sacramento CA Nacogdoches Police Department Nacogdoches TX Greenburgh Police Department White Plains NY Tuckahoe Police Department Tuckahoe NY Aurora Police Department (IL)Aurora IL Griffith Police Department (IN)Griffith IN La Verne Police Department La Verne CA Ball Ground Police Department Ball Ground GA Montebello Police Department Montebello CA US Postal Inspection Service Washington DC Smith County Sheriff Office Tyler TX Rocky Mount Police Department (NC)Rocky Mount NC American Canyon Police Department American Canyon CA Cobb County Police Department Marietta GA Newark Police Department (NJ)Newark NJ West Caldwell Police Department (NJ)West Caldwell NJ Frisco Police Department Frisco TX Naperville Police Department Naperville IL Murrieta Police Department Murrieta CA Elk Grove Police Department Elk Grove CA Ogden Police Department Spencerport NY District 21 Drug Task Force Norman OK Banks County Sheriffs Office Homer GA Giddings Police Department Giddings TX Homewood Police Department Homewood AL Pearland Police Department Pearland TX Redding Police Department (CA)Redding CA Washoe County Sheriffs Office Reno NV Grosse Pointe Park Public Safety Grosse Pointe Park MI Holly Springs Police Department Holly Springs GA Marysville Police Department (CA)Marysville CA Georgia Tech Police Department Atlanta GA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 28 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Douglas County Sheriff (CO)Castle Rock CO 32nd Judicial District Attorney Office Sweetwater TX South Gate Police Department (CA)South Gate CA Austin Police Department Austin TX Galt Police Department Galt CA Imperial County Regional ALPR Program El Centro CA Del Rio Police Department (TX)Del Rio TX San Ramon Police Department San Ramon CA Hendersonville Police Department Hendersonville TN Bossier City PD Bossier City LA South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SC) Columbia SC College Station Police Department College Station TX Chambersburg Police Department Chambersburg PA Fullerton Police Department Fullerton CA Fresno County Sheriffs Office (CA)Fresno CA Solano County Sheriffs Office (CA)Fairfield CA Delaware County Sheriffs Office (OH)Delaware OH Liberty County Sheriffs Office (TX)Liberty TX Chino Police Department Chino CA Fairfield Police Department CT Fairfield CT Burleson Police Department Burleson TX Downers Grove Police Department Downers Grove IL Palm Springs Police Department (CA)Palm Springs CA Arcadia Police Department Arcadia CA Port Hueneme Police Department (CA)Port Hueneme CA San Mateo Police Department (CA)San Mateo CA Fairfield Police Department CA Fairfield CA Pasadena Police Department (TX)Pasadena TX Farmers Branch Police Department Farmers Branch TX Bessemer Police Department Bessemer AL Homestead Police Department (PA)Bradfordwoods PA Orange County Sheriff (TX)Orange TX Menifee Police Department (CA)Menifee CA Lumberton Police Department Lumberton TX Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 29 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Grantville Police Department Grantville GA Carroll County Sheriffs Office Carrollton GA Fort Bend County Sheriffs Office Richmond TX Douglas County Sheriff (NV)Minden NV Powder Springs Police Department Powder Springs GA Commerce City Police Department Commerce City CO Oak Brook Police Department (IL)Oak Brook IL Fayetteville Police Department Fayetteville GA Binghamton Police Department Binghamton NY Escondido Police Department ESCONDIDO CA Vernon Police Department Vernon CA Tybee Island Police Dept Tybee Island GA Gwinnett County Police Department (GA) Lawrenceville GA Dallas Police Department Dallas TX Walnut Creek Police Department Walnut Creek CA Chatham County Sheriffs Office Savannah GA Avondale Estates Police Department Avondale Estates GA Orange Police Department (CT)Orange CT Meriwether County Sheriffs Office Greenville GA Joplin Police Department Joplin MO New York State Office of the Attorney General New York NY Gardena Police Department Gardena CA Wethersfield Police Department Wethersfield CT Fort Worth Police Department Fort Worth TX Hillsboro Police Department Hillsboro OR Camden County Police Department Camden NJ Carson County Sheriffs Office (TX)Panhandle TX Beaumont Police Department Beaumont CA Villa Park Police Department Villa Park IL Pittsburg Police Department CA Pittsburg CA Jefferson City Police Department Jefferson City MO Rapides Parish Sheriffs Office (LA)Alexandria LA Carrollton Police Department TX Carrollton TX United States Forest Service CA Willows CA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 30 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Tennessee HLS District 7 Clarksville TN Tift County Sheriff Office Tifton GA Bronxville Police Department Bronxville NY Haskell County Sheriffs Department (KS) Sublette KS Gresham Police Department Gresham OR Greenville Police Department (TX)Greenville TX Travis County SO Austin TX Livingston County Sheriffs Office (MI)Howell MI Rockford Police Department Rockford IL Calumet City Police Department Calumet City IL Grayson County Sheriffs Office (TX)Sherman TX Morton Police Department Morton MS Orange County District Attorney (CA)Santa Ana CA Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation London OH Alachua County Sheriff Gainesville FL Burbank Police Department (CA)Burbank CA Cathedral City Police Department Cathedral City CA Niagara Falls Police Department Niagara Falls NY Jefferson County Sheriffs Office Birmingham AL Rhode Island State Police North Scituate RI Fayette County Sheriffs Office Fayetteville GA Orinda Police Department Orinda CA Elk Grove Village Police Department (IL) Elk Grove Village IL Irondequoit Police Department Rochester NY Cartersville Police Department Cartersville GA Fort Lauderdale Police Department Fort Lauderdale FL Oakley Police Department Oakley CA Gulfport Police Department Gulfport MS Freeway Safety Network - EAST BAY Pittsburg CA Tallapoosa Police Department Tallapoosa GA Guadalupe County Constables Schertz TX Wayne County Airport Police (MI)Detroit MI Cape Coral Police Department Cape Coral FL Milton Police Department Alpharetta GA Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 31 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Salamanca Police Department Salamanca NY Jefferson CO TX SO Beaumont TX Cook County States Attorney (IL)Chicago IL Rankin County Sheriffs Office Brandon MS Simi Valley Police Department Simi Valley CA Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office Tampa FL Abilene Police Department (TX)Abilene TX Ossining Police Department Ossining NY Contra Costa County Sheriffs Martinez CA Trumansburg Police Department Trumansburg NY Indiana Intelligence Fusion Center (IN)Indianapolis IN Williamson County Sheriffs Office Georgetown TX Hickory Hills Police Department Hickory Hills IL Redwood City PD Redwood City CA CA Parole Apprehension Team (CA)Sacramento CA Carlsbad Police Department Carlsbad CA El Cajon Police Department (CA)El Cajon CA Jasper County Sheriffs Office MS Bay Springs MS Kinney County Sheriffs Office (TX)Bracketville TX Val Verde County Sheriffs Office (TX)Del Rio TX Boca Raton Police Department Boca Raton FL Brookhaven Police Department Brookhaven GA Whitfield County Sheriffs Office Dalton GA Caldwell Police Department (NJ)Caldwell NJ Richardson Police Department Richardson TX UC Irvine Police Department Irvine CA Alma Police Department Alma GA Des Peres Police Department Des Peres MO San Diego Harbor Police Department (CA) San Diego CA Tyler City Marshal Tyler TX Lodi Police Department Lodi CA Reeve County Sherriffs Office Pecos TX Santa Rosa County Sheriff (FL)Milton FL LA Port Police San Pedro CA Loves Park Police Department Loves Park IL Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 32 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report City of White Police Department White GA Baldwin County Sheriffs Office Fairhope AL Highland Park Dept of Public Safety (TX) Highland TX Allen Police Department Allen TX Donalsonville Police Department Donalsonville GA Ulster County Sheriffs Office Kingston NY Chenango County Sheriffs Office (NY)Norwich NY Munster Police Department Munster IN HSI Bulk Cash Smuggling Center Williston VT Costa Mesa Police Department Costa Mesa CA Putnam County Sheriffs Office Palatka FL Carson City Sheriffs Dept Carson City NV Yates County Sheriffs Office Penn Yan NY Clayton County Police Department Jonesboro GA Stanislaus County Sheriffs Department Modesto CA Madera Police Department Madera CA Flemington Police Department Flemington NJ Bossier Sheriffs Office Bentin LA Heflin Police Department (AL)Heflin AL Schaumburg Police Department Schaumburg IL Dunwoody Police Department Dunwoody GA Boone County Sheriff Office Lebanon IN Auburn Police Department CA Auburn CA Brazoria County Constables Office Pearland TX Rockwall County Sheriffs Rockwall TX Grants Pass Department of Public Safety Grants Pass OR Mesquite Police Department Mesquite TX Cypress Police Department Cypress CA Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department (IN) Indianapolis IN Pleasanton Police Department Pleasanton CA Thomaston Police Department Thomaston GA Rancho Viejo Police Department (TX)Rancho Viejo TX Winnebago County Sheriff (Machesney Park Division) Rockford IL Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 33 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Jim Wells County Sheriffs Office Alice TX Sacramento Police Department Sacramento CA Midland Police Department (TX)Midland TX Lexington County Health Services West Columbia SC Parke County Sheriffs Office Rockville IN Beverly Hills Police Department Beverly Hills CA Redmond Police Department (OR)Redmond OR County of San Mateo Sheriffs Office Redwood City CA Chandler Police Department Chandler AZ Sikeston Police Department Sikeston MO Stanislaus County Auto Theft Task Force Modesto CA Hot List Sharing The Chula Vista Police Department Agency is sharing Hot List records with the following Agencies: Agency:Hot List(s): Coronado Police Department (CA)LEARN_Chula Vista Police Department Oceanside Police Department (CA)LEARN_Chula Vista Police Department San Diego Police Department LEARN_Chula Vista Police Department Hot List Received The Chula Vista Police Department Agency is receiving Shared Hot List records from the following Agencies: Agency:Hot List(s): California Franchise Tax Board (CA)LEARN_California Franchise Tax Board (CA) Carlsbad Police Department LEARN_Carlsbad Police Department Clovis Police Department LEARN_Clovis Police Department CSU Fullerton Police Department LEARN_CSU Fullerton Police Department Forsyth County Sheriffs Office LEARN_Forsyth County Sheriffs Office Grants Pass Department of Public Safety LEARN_Grants Pass Department of Public Safety Hidalgo County Sheriff (TX)LEARN_Hidalgo County Sheriff (TX) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 34 of 35 Agency Data Sharing Report Huntsville Police Department (AL)LEARN_Huntsville Police Department (AL) Irvine Police Department (CA)IPD Regional Hotlist Lake County Sheriffs Office (IL)LEARN_Lake County Sheriffs Department Lumber City Police Department (GA)LEARN_Lumber City Police Department (GA) Murrieta Police Department LEARN_Murrieta Police Department Norwalk Police Department LEARN_Norwalk Police Department Oxnard Police Department LEARN_Oxnard Police Department Pasadena Police Department (TX)LEARN_Pasadena Police Department (TX) Red Bluff Police Department LEARN_Red Bluff Police Department Redwood City PD LEARN_Redwood City PD Riverside County Sheriffs Department (CA)LEARN_Riverside County Sheriff Riverside Police Department Persons Sacramento County District Attorneys Office (CA) LEARN_Sacramento County DA Office Sacramento Police Department LEARN_Sacramento Police Department San Joaquin County Sheriffs Department (CA) LEARN_San Joaquin County Sheriffs Department (CA) San Pablo Police Department CA LEARN_San Pablo Police Department CA Vestavia Hills Police Department (AL)LEARN_Vestavia Hills Police Department (AL) Washoe County Sheriffs Office LEARN_Washoe County Sheriffs Office Yolo County Sheriffs Department LEARN_Yolo County Sheriffs Department Yuma County Sheriffs Office (AZ)LEARN_Yuma County Sheriffs Office (AZ) Date Created: 11-17-20 LEARN Agency Data Sharing Report Page 35 of 35