The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2019-05-08 Packet CHUTAVISTA PlanninLy Commission REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2019 Council Chambers 6:00 p.m. Public Services Bldg 276 Fourth Avenue CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL: Commissioners Burroughs, De La Rosa, Milburn, Nava,Torres,Zaker, and Chair Gutierrez MOTIONS TO EXCUSE: PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND MOMENT OF SILENCE OPENING STATEMENT: 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: February 13, 2019 March 13, 2019 PUBLIC COMMENTS: An opportunity far members of the public to speak to the Planning Commission on any subject matter within the Commission's jurisdiction, but not an item on today's agenda. Each speaker's presentation may not exceed three minutes. CONSENT ITEMS: The Chair may entertain requests by staff to continue an agenda item. The Chair may also entertain a recommendation by a Commissioner to approve certain non-controversial agenda items as Consent items. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an agenda item listed as a Public Hearing may not be acted upon by the Commission as a Consent Item. Public Hearing items shall be heard by the Commission as a Public Hearing. - 1 - I Planning Commission Agenda Page -2- May 8, 2019 PUBLIC HEARINGS The following item(s) have been advertised as public hearing(s) as required by law. If you wish to speak on any item, please fill out a "Request to Speak"form (available in the lobby) and submit it to the City Clerk prior to the meeting. 2. PUBLIC HEARING: CUP16-0030; Consideration of a Conditional Use Permit to establish and operate a temporary Recreational Vehicle and Boat Storage Facility at 1228 Eastlake Parkway Resolution of the City of Chula Vista Planning Commission approving Conditional Use Permit CUP16-0030 for a temporary Recreational Vehicle and Boat Storage Facility located on a 6.5-acre site at 1228 Eastlake Parkway within the Eastlake R Sectional Planning Area (OS3 Zone). Applicant: Frank Orhmund Project Manager: Oscar Romero,Assistant Planner Staff Recommendation: Conduct the Public Hearing and adopt the attached Planning Commission Resolution, PCC-16-0030, approving Conditional Use Permit CUP16-0030, based on the findings and subject to the conditions contained in the attached Planning Commission Resolution. OTHER BUSINESS 3. Appointment of a second Planning Commissioner to the Bayfront Cultural and Design Committee due to the resignation of Yolanda Calvo 4. DIRECTOR'S REPORT: 5. COMMISSION COMMENTS: ADJOURNMENT to the next Regular Planning Commission Meeting on May 22,2019 at 6:00 p.m., in the Council Chambers. Materials provided to the Planning Commission related to any open-session item on this agenda are available for public review at the City Housing Office;located in City Hall at 276 Fourth Avenue,Building 300,during normal business hours. In compliance with the AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT The City of Chula Vista requests individuals who require special accommodations to access, attend, and/or participate in a City meeting, activity, or service, contact Patricia Salvacion at (619) 476-5391 (California Relay Service is available for the hearing impaired by dialing 711)at least forty-eight hours in advance of the meeting. —2 — ITEM 1 APPROVAL OF MINUTES - 3 - THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK -4 - CHUTAI ISTA f f i l l � f 1f 11 1 Planning Commission DRAFT MINUTES MEETING OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING COMMISSION I February 13, 2019 Council Chambers 6:00 p.m. "" Public Services Bldg A til, I, d'Ilyl 276 Fourth Avenue CALL TO ORDER 4�i 1i111l'�L` 'I1Iilr ROLL CALL: Commissioners Burroughs, De La Rosa,!!!Milburn, Nava, Zaker,�alln'd,, Chair Gutierrez �,IIIII�I'ill!�I'�III!„ tl�l�li�) I! IgI,I�giaq It�'ll''L,, lidl'u MOTIONS TO EXCUSE: None "II'tl I!I'T ! III I'� ll 1,+. I I II� , '1111 �,�IIIIII„I PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND MOM ENTILENCE 41;lchll!;I IT111 I'i F"fll Chair Gutierrez acknowledged Commissioner Calv`6 her ressgnat1, n from the Planning Commission and thanked her for her years of service'I"'l7!''I!� ill!II;I 'I „ d " ��"YI'I'�iI!IIII'I'ilill� Iu IL u ,lu'I'pl!IIIIIVf'',r !I'I I OPENING STATEMENT.; Planning Commission Minutes Page -2- February 13, 2019 2. PUBLIC HEARING: DR18-0018; Design Review consideration for a Self-Storage Facility in the Escaya Business Park within the Village 3 Master Planned Community. Applicant: HomeFed Village III Master, LLC. Resolution of the City of Chula Vista Planning Commission Approving Design Review Permit DR18-0018 for a 127,000 square-foot Self-Storage Facility on Lot 817 (3.1- Acres) in the Escaya Business Park within the Otay Ranch Village 3 Master Planned Community. HL '`Till: 7 III4'I Project Manager: Janice Kluth, Sr. Project Coo rd inatolr�i,�;l'I'i°If, ,, 11 II�I�Io �Hiy, 'I.41ulI;II Staff Recommendation: That the Planning Commission adopt-Resolutions DR18-0018, ,r"jlj�l Ilp UIIVIhh, approving the Escaya Self Storage Project,based on the findings and subject to the conditions'Icontained therein, �i I,',Il�t I 'UMI Ili�i'ilII�llill�I;,II i� hll d& Project Ill Project Manager, Janice Kluth gave a slide present ation;of the,upfoiect that included the design plans, a site plan, and parking. The, Escaya Self-Storagll'ek"Project is located in the Escaya Business Park and includes 125,805 square feet of self sto age space, 27 RV storage parking Vlnll, �IIP�I spaces and a 1,192 square foot office for leasing and management ' QUESTIONS TO STAFF: - Il it I -I I,II ll,qh, III I� �G'll- IIIQI I�iii j�I11�,�11 • Will the landscapmgllalo�ng Heritage Road`include trees" rills. • What are the elevations of tje building and the line of sight? aril,;,,,,, I�" II'lII'�III"� �I�Ii� 'i'Ill SII Ii�IIII�q`��a i�'II�III� f 1�III SII •,II, OPENED PUBLIC HEARING �,I„ �';h'Lwyy N;illli!i"l III�I Ij � i� r , UII'�ili ll III fl'I iil'll r��Ill IIgjl'i js�1'll.l'll Ste„ve,levingso of Hornle liFled, representing the developer and applicant, thanked staff for°"their presentationof tfi°II��ILe�iiproject and mentioned that there are additional projects I''1 1 rIN�I��IV I,,",i llthait are currently under const, ion in Escaya including a city park. II, I�I Ili i Mr. Levingson answe_red some of the questions asked by the commissioners and explained!"that the slope is an average of 23 feet from Heritage Road, the slope is landscapediiwith plants and will include layers of trees, the decorative fence is wrought iron to enhance the look of the building. Ijl!il" CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING COMMISSIONER DELIBERATIONS Questions to staff and applicant included: • Will there be lighting at the top of the building? • Has the storage facility always been part of the master plan? • What is the parking standard for the facility? — 6— Planning Commission Minutes Page -.3 February 13, 2019 • Will the landfill be visible from the storage facility? ® What is the circulation of the parking? MSC: Motion by Burroughs to approve Second by Milburn Vote: 6-0-0-0 Commissioner Zaker and Gutierrez thanked the applicant for bringing employment opportunities to the community. Ila, • OTHER BUSINESSy'll- Qyqjl II'I!' RI'I �IIIII'I t�I 'Nrt�'ll'I��I III I 3. DIRECTOR'S REPORT: None I�rhlll! `Ill a 4. COMMISSION COMMENTS: IIIII' ;I,I,1 iu fil �l l II' y11� I r xrl!;II!Iijlh ,,I Ip 1!!1�. Ii'II a,ll ILII u p�l!III III (� jlll t'n��',i The commissioners thanked Commission CalII8llvo.111ilfor her service to the Planning Commission. NH b' 1!Ihll�;, Iti '(��',u 1, „IIIb• '�1'l III II'I p'll hY (I IIII,II aIJl I O III,i`�II IllllN'i-'Illll�n. ADJOURNMENT at 6:40 p.m.to the nelxt Retgular Pllanning Commission Meeting on February 27, 2019, at 6:00 p m'�II�Iint�e Council Chambers. �lll pNill�f �IIII'I'pI�V4' nN ' IIhII I'I h NII III .lila 1 �1 II•l 111 qm i+`II:''i-,IIj III��,�W ll, IIII,jl1. '111 lillil li h,� lllll l`- III 111 11ijli III ., Ijll�.. III II ii14' i I I Ii In IIIIIIIIIn111I,�Ili�!n VIJIh`SI i II II IIIF II'S`II �IIIII VIIIIIIpIiI�IIII IIIIf,II II I- III'' - NII�IIIIhIIfH� '""iI!III'hI(II1��+51I I �,II��.'liii''I'I'I:�I,'�h I�Vlli�l'Ip`11 IIIII��I'1�111i1 II.�N!IIIiIIIiVIh�GIII!�,!' IIII III„`I �i III;'IiIII�i N 71. �III!Iipl l If II I �y , I ! III IIII, IIIA 1111 liI hl,ly ry 11 I I!ul Illi l till r I j p l ukl i; 1 lig IIIjlltili I �_i ,IIII VIII�. mill I. 1 �ill,lil, 'III II'I! IhN411'h IIII. I,I I! II ,,NVI�9i;ilr.. ,;Illy i I I I — 7 — THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK _ 8_ CHURVISTA Jil- Planning Commission DRAFT MINUTES MEETING OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING COMMISSION March 13, 2019 111"'1 Council Chambers 6:00 p.m. Public Services Bldg A 276 Fourth Avenue CALL TO ORDER IIIII,II�;I,I ,�;jlltl6l�� il!III I II'II''�!�I ROLL CALL: Commissioners Burroughs, De La Rosa, MilbIIur; Zaker, an,IIc�';, II! , ln IIIA, Chair Gutierrez yl h1,0 ABSENT: Commissioner Nava p,ltllll''� Itii�Ii 11 IIIIi''I! "'Ii�I'ItIV, I{I, OPENING STATEMENT: !�IIIIIIIaI IgII II(;u The City Attorney asked the commissionersto disclose any Ex PIIIIiIja!'!:,rterCcmmunication that they may have had regrading items on thea ends �rll I'° 'I!"'I!f,, g 9III �p!IIIQ! III l I!I I 'IIIII„ it illlii,l III ,I�,IIIdIII'I'-� Chair Gutierrez menglptioned11that he spoke With Dan Holm=over the phone regarding Item #1. Jp II�� II:,G aP� Mr. Hom urged support of theroject ; l llll�'I'ulll!IIIIj''li l is I)�'III�II!�Ilhli, �IiI Ijij I 'I+Ili li ,II Commissioner Zaker ali§"b.sp1'ilwith Dan Holrr,";;',over the phone regarding Item #1 - I!,I}I4Sil �I!II�,IIIII I III�IIIIIIIIII,lilll t _il14 Mr.Hom urged support obit 'e'p oject'..dIl;Cor�missioner Zaker also mentioned that as a dllllihv"'I!;'p19 11i1iI,IlI�I,iNI,. II,,!�G��III, '�IIIhI1i)I,I��I,Id, memlber of the Goy�ernmentiCommittee of the Pacific Southwest Association of Realtors, 4l1 lti he.attended a meeting with thg'developer who made a presentation of his project to the d„11�f, I!'� ,,II'II committee requesting support. f!I„Ir Till I;II II (I!II,I �;il,i h,rl I;r l!Ij II I 'ul Commissioner De La RosRTJ entioned that hespoke with Frank Orhmund who shared ,III IIS III�q 611�'I! details of his4project an,d'urged support (Item #2). Commissioner De La Rosa also spoke with Dan Holm'riegardm'g Item#1-who urged support for his project. Commissioner De La Rosa also spoke with`Norma Casarez regarding a different question on an agenda item. PUBLIC COMMENTS: An opportunity for members of the public to speak to the Planning Commission on any subject matter within the Commission's jurisdiction, but not an item on today's agenda. Each speaker's presentation may not exceed three minutes. There were none. — 9 — Planning Commission Minutes Page -2- March 13,2019 PUBLIC HEARINGS The following item(s) have been advertised as public hearing(s) as required by law. If you wish to speak on any item, please fill out a "Request to Speak"form (available in the lobby) and submit it to the Board Secretary prior to the meeting. 1. PUBLIC HEARING: CUP16-0030; Consideration of a Conditional Use Permit to establish and operate a temporary Recreational Vehicle and Boat Storage Facility at 1228 Eastlake Parkway du Resolution of the City of Chula Vista Planning Commission approving Conditional Use Permit CUP 16-0030 for a temporary Recreational Vehicle and=Boat Storage Facility located on a 6.5-acre site at 1228 Eastlake Parkway within theEastlake II Sectional Planning Area (OS3 Zone). Applicant: FrankOrhmand Project Manager: Oscar, mero, Assistant Planner r Staff Recommendation: Conduct the Public Hearingandadopt the attached Planning Commission Resolution, PCC-16-0030, approving C nditional Use Permit CUP16-0030, based on the findings and subject�to the conditions�c retained in the attached Planning ��Commission Resolution. Assistant Planner Romero gave a Ode prese taon that included a site plan, views from the west,views-from the north, viewsfrom t : h, views from east to west. Olivia Staford,of Focus Corn, Inc., represe ting the applicant, gave a slide presentation which included the project history, prole,-" improvements, site enhancements, and operations. COMMISSIONE'N goollill R f.UESTIONS TO STAFF: Questions hncluded the fol.owing: tim - . What is the e line of the temporary status? • What is the zor}ing of the parcel? • What are the co; ditions of the CUP? Concerns wer`e_�a. dressed by Frank Orhmund, Oscar Romero, Kelly Broughton, and Steve Power. PUBLIC HEARING OPENED- limited to 5 minutes The following speakers spoke in favor'of the project: -Michelle Alvarez John Carroll — 10 — i Planning Commission Minutes - 3 - March 13, 2019 -Kenny Doll -Raquel Fernandez -Ray Gobeil -Jeffrey Stewart -Jeff Stuart The following speakers spoke in opposition of the project: -Carmen Berumen -Giselle Murray -Carolyn Anderson -Sandra Conrady Frank Orhmund, applicant, expressed that hewouldl ke to buildaoject that would serve the community and mentioned that heshas received severalr,.equests, including the management company from Antigua, asking if residents can pardon his°property. Mr. Orhmund asked for support of his project V PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED *H COMMISSIONER DELIBERTATIONS 4 ., Questions included the followi ® What the is zoning for the parcel? A:t alronz ` • Security/sec'AsurJ yplan • Use and wneed m the community 3 • Light►ng . • LandscapingftenangLL ffi • Noise = F • Ho'urs"ofoperation� i� (I i • Petition received Can a CUP be„revoked as there beenV!a titraffic study? 'al • What kind of landscaping can be expected? Ilya • Are there anyather potential uses for the site? • In regards to current RV parks, what is the land use? • What ar']01he surrounding land uses of current RV parks? Burroughs: Cannot support the project as presented Zaker: Will not be able to support the project as presented De La Rosa: Will not support the project as presented _ 11 _ Planning Commission Minutes -4 - March 13,2019 MSC: A motion was made by Commissioner Zaker and seconded by Commissioner Burroughs - Recommended that the item be continued to a date uncertain to allow the applicant and the community to continue discussions. The applicant accepted to have a continuance to work on the process. Vote Yes: 5—Burroughs, De La Rosa, Milburn,Zaker, and Gutierrez,,!lI,. No: 0 Abstain: 0 ry 11' Absent: 1- Nava i illi I,ililLl' I,VIII lu't�llu I� gNll.ill�h'�Illlglh. ' i i�u 2. PUBLIC HEARING: DR17-0040 considerationof a 170-unit apart - int complex with ,,'11111 I'I IIIIIII'ilill�, an affordable housing component, andFl1recreation areas including a �I�mining pool, IVp II,IIIIV clubhouse, and dog run_on approximately 5 3 acre ,p;lYvest of 1-805' and south of eye IWC i l II 1,11 � Bonita Road. Resolution of the City of Chula Vista Planning 1'1I, ommission adopting Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation,I;i,�Vhorutormg and Re Illrtng Program IS-18-0001, llllllil.L• and approving a Design Review Permit'Dg117 0040 to con§; ct one four-story building and six three-story buildings totaling i 149,5341 ware-fectil lconsisting of 170 apartment 31116 �0 " ��''''(ii`III'�Plli'IU�� units including nine-affordable units Wll th,associated; Ming, recreational facilities and open space on I roxima ely 5.3 acres 1,located south of Bonita Road, between Bonita 1 Glen Drive and I'805. ��IIII "III I;,:�IIII, Applicant Silvergate Development, LLC P�i�oject Wo:-i Donn, Senior Planner St ff Recommendation: he Planning Commission adopt Resolution IS-18- "0001gDR17-0040 a o ting F (IS-18-0001) and approving the Project, based on the findigs and subject to ' e conditions contained therein. PUBLIC HEARINGbOPENED - li�f�ited to 5 minutes The following speakers spoke in support of the project: -Shannon Baer -Jennifer Bustamante -Lisa Cohen -Melissa Deen -Carol Crossman -Neil Hadley -Doug Kerner -Krysthal Moneda — 12 — Planning Commission Minutes - 5 - March 13, 2019 Joseph Raso -Jim Reynolds -John Sheehan -Kelly White -Nicholas Wilson The following speakers spoke in opposition of the project: -David Butler -Suellen Butler -Ron Caton -Norma Cazares -Laura DouglasMqq 't -Kay Duge -Lisa EppertAP � s -Joanne Fischer -Brad Franklin -Theresa Franklin { -Cate Gilman -Blanca Leos Guzman 12M -Abraham Hanond § a -David Hanond -Roberta Harrison � �� ` Y -Doug Hicks -David Hanono -Tara Hoffman -` -Ethel Layne -Hal Lem _ � �� -John Lyon. �� :�.� _2 -Chrisp,glPMalone -KevnyM1., ne -Dan Mc .a an -Negar M1rgo7,�,, -Laurie Murphy ' -Scott Olsen fl- -Judith Pidgeon *4 -Gloria Ramsey3 -Mark Ramsey John Salts -Gary Smith -Claire Wachowiak -Dan Wachowiak -Sean Wachowiak PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED - 13 - I Planning Commission Minutes - 6 - I March 13, 2019 The applicant's traffic engineer provided data that was collected by various agencies including SANDAG and CALTRANS for information regarding trip distribution and generation and safety data. The applicant mentioned that an additional benefit to the community would be paying $5.1 million dollars in impact fees. COMMISSIONER DELIBERATIONS Questions including the following: • Were there comments back from the State Traffic Engineer? __ • Are there affordable units in the project? __A • What is being done about the fees being charged for parkm-gyin the apartment complex across the street? ff • Will there be improvements made to Bonita Road? 4� Road?, � 2 • What will be the construction timeline? ", _ � Chair Gutierrez made a motion to approve the project. The motion failed dueto lack of a second. �U� �` h Chair Gutierrez asked for a motion to oppose the project Nomotion was made. +VIII III , Chair Gutierrez asked for a motion to support the project under4 rtain circumstances. No motion was made. IIII IIII VIII Chair Gutierrez made ;a,;l+motiI�on to approve the project.l The motion was seconded by Commissioner Milburn'!1IThe motion failed with'the following vote: 7'I'I�'I 1111111 ,IIA Jill- u,IliIII�Iw Yes: 1 - Gutierrez lI(I'I' li �ill:I,, SII �I411fI1Ii)�I I +II ,, I No:3 - Burroughs,Milburn, Zdker ��III�`I 'illll" � li„I IIIIIii+I 61 + ISI„, VIII u'�� Abstain 11:, De La Rosa, II,�I Absenrt ;1 NavaVIJ 6 i; OTHER BUSINESS ,' U'�II�11 I it 3. Appointment of a second Planning Commissioner to the Bayfront Cultural and Design Committee due;to Ithb resignation of Yolanda Calvo. This item wasr'roved to the next meeting due to the absence of two commissioners, 4. DIRECTOR'S REPORT: Kelly Broughton mentioned that there is a vacant seat on the Planning Commission, applications are still being accepted. — 14 — Planning Commission Minutes - 7 - March 13, 2019 S. COMMISSION COMMENTS: The commissioners expressed their appreciation for the public participation. ADJOURNMENT at 10:56 p.m.to the next Regular Planning Commission Meeting on March 27, 2019, at 6:00 p.m., in the Council Chambers. At gW`` I . WN, IN _ASO AN Nt � ;} .. 4A I a k — 15 — PHIS PAGE LEFT BLANK _ 16 _ CH U L .A VISTA t,k , PLANNING COM MISSION "E - � �yyy �� - AGENDA STATEMENT n - Item: 2 Meeting Date: 05/08/19 ITEM TITLE: PUBLIC HEARING: CUP16-0030; Consideration of a Conditional Use Permit to establish and operate a temporary Recreational Vehicle and Boat storage facility at 1228 Eastlake Parkway: Applicant-Frank Orhmund Resolution of the City of Chula Vista Planning Commission approving Conditional Use Permit CUP16-0030 for a temporary Recreational Vehicle and Boat Storage Facility located on a 6.5-acre site at 1228 Eastlake Parkway within the Eastlake II Sectional Planning Area(OS3 Zone) SUBMITTED BY: Oscar Romero, Assistant Planner REVIEWED BY: Kelly Broughton, Director of Development Services INTRODUCTION On July 28, 2016, the Applicant, Frank Orhmund, submitted a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) application for approval to operate a Recreational Vehicle (RV) and Boat Storage facility at 1228 Eastlake Parkway within the Eastlake II Sectional Planning Area (SPA) (OS-3 Zone) (see Attachment 1-Locator Map). The CUP would be for a five year period. BACKGROUND Under the provisions of the Unclassified Use Provisions outlined in 19.58.400 Recreational Vehicle Storage Yards, the Applicant is applying for approval of a 5-year CUP to allow the construction and operation of a proposed RV and Boat Storage facility on the subject site. The granting of the CUP will allow the Applicant to conduct the necessary site improvements in order to construct and commence operation of the facility. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW The Development Services Director reviewed the project for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and has determined that the project qualifies for a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 (New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures) of the State CEQA Guidelines because the project consists of the installation of minor improvements for outdoor storage. Therefore, no further environmental review is required. - 17 - Planning Commission May 8, 2019 PCC-16-0030 Page No. 2 RECOMMENDATION Conduct the Public Hearing and adopt the attached Planning Commission Resolution, PCC-16- 0030, approving Conditional Use Permit CUP16-0030, based on the findings and subject to the conditions contained in the attached Planning Commission Resolution(see Attachment 2). DISCUSSION Project Site Characteristics: The 6.5-acre project site is located along Eastlake Parkway between SR-125 and Eastlake Parkway, north of Trinidad Cove and south of Clubhouse Drive within the Eastlake II SPA in the OS-3 Zone. The project site is located off Eastlake Parkway and has a frontage width of 220-feet with an existing 65-foot San Diego County Water Authority easement and San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) easement of 120-feet spanning from the east to west side of the property. The two easements stretch from the north side of the parcel to the toe of slope on the southern end adjacent to the residences. The proposed project will use part of the easement for ingress and egress as well as for emergency vehicle turn around. The RV Storage will be located on the southern SDG&E easement where it will be graded with permeable concrete for stored vehicles and a more durable concrete for emergency vehicle access. The site is surrounded-by a combination of parcels; to the north is a high school (PC40S4 zoning), to the south is a residential complex(PC4RM25), and to the west SR-125 and east is an existing church(PC4PQ) as further described in the following table: Land Use District Existing Land Use General Plan Designation g Site Medium-High Planned Community 4— Residential (OS-3) Vacant North PQ-Park-Quasi Planned Community—(OS- Eastlake High School Public 4) South FC—Freeway RM25—Medium Commercial Residential 25 Antigua Condominiums EastRL M—Low-Medium PQ-Public Quasi Parkway Hills Church of the Nazarene Residential West . PC-Special Planning N/A SR-125 Area I I J — 18 — Planning Commission May 8, 2019 PCC-16-0030 Page No. 3 Project Description: The site will provide outdoor storage for 80-100 recreational vehicles and operate seven days a week from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. The property will not accommodate any permanent structures but will include light poles with surveillance cameras to assist in monitoring the site. The proposal will also include a 40-foot landscape enhancement fronting on Eastlake Parkway from the interior edge of the curb to the entrance. ANALYSIS: Findings for granting of a Conditional Use Permit The required findings for the granting of a Conditional Use Permit are described in Chapter 19.14 of the Chula Vista Municipal Code ("Municipal Code" or "CVMC"). One such finding is that the Project would provide a needed service to the surrounding community. The proposed storage facility would be desirable at this location as it would provide a needed service for residents of the surrounding Eastlake community. The existing Covenants Conditions and Restrictions (CC&R's) governing the residential areas of Eastlake prohibit both the parking and storage of RV's and boats along the streets or within private driveways. The Project would allow for the storage of RV's and boats for residents of Eastlake and the Chula Vista neighborhoods that currently have to use storage elsewhere. The second finding made must prove the project proposal will not be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property or improvements in the vicinity. The proposed storage facility is topographically lower than both parcels to the north and south of the site and will be screened by existing landscaping and a 6 foot high fence. Although the storage facility will not be completely screened, its visibility from the adjacent properties will be minimal. In addition, the site will include lighting (which will be shielded from adjacent properties), a locked gate and security cameras and other improvements described herein. As such, the project will not be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property or improvements in the vicinity. The third finding must confirm that the proposed use complies with the regulations and conditions specified in the code for such use. The storage facility has been reviewed and conditioned to reflect the provisions in Section 19.58.400 of the CVMC. Finally, the fmding must be made that-the project will not adversely affect the General Plan of the City. The proposed project is a temporary use allowed for a maximum period of 5-years (with possible time extensions). The Conditional Use Permit is in compliance with the General Plan and CVMC Section 19.54.020 listing recreational vehicle storage yards as an Unclassified Use and subject to the granting of a CUP by the Planning Commission. Compliance with Development Regulations: The project site is zoned OS-3 (Open Space) and has a General Plan Medium-High Residential land use designation. In recommending approval of the requested CUP to the Planning Commission, staff relies on the following sections of the CVMC: _ 19 _ Planning Commission May 8, 2019 PCC-16-0030 Page No. 4 CVMC Section 19.54.020 (Q) Chapter 19.54 describes Unclassified Uses that may be permitted in any zone subject to review of the use in terms of compatibility at the proposed location and subject to the approval of a CUP. Specifically, Section 19.54.020(Q) lists recreational vehicle storage facilities as part of the list of unclassified uses that could be considered with the approval of a CUP, subject to review of specific compatibility issues outlined in CVMC Section 19.58.400. CVMC Section 19.58.400 Section 19.58.400 requires that an application to establish a recreational vehicle storage yard shall address the following issues: (1) height limit for stored items, (2) screening (landscaping and fencing), (3) surfacing, (4) access to the site, (5) office facilities, (6) customer parking, (7) lighting, (8) hours of operation, (9) security, (10) signing, and (11) surrounding land uses and structures. Said items are discussed in more detail below. Section 19.58.400 also indicates that approval of an RV storage facility that is considered by the Planning Commission to represent an interim use of land based upon zoning or development patterns, shall be subject to a review and report filed each year with the Zoning Administrator. These reports would indicate the current status of development within the immediate area, including any proposal for the adjacent parcels. Permits for an interim RV storage yard shall be granted for a maximum period of five years with extensions subject to rehearing before the Planning Commission. Height/Screening and Landscaping A six foot high chain link fence with a privacy lath will be provided along Eastlake Parkway and a chain link fence around the perimeter of the site. Along the property frontage facing Eastlake Parkway will be a 40-foot landscape strip from the edge of the interior of the curb to the entrance. The proposed landscaping would be an aesthetic improvement to the site and would provide some additional screening beyond what would be provided by the six foot high perimeter fence. The items stored will be motorhomes,boats and travel trailers with a range in height of 8-13 feet. As a result,the upper portion of some of the,vehicles may not be completely screened from view from the street or the adjacent property to the south. The existing site is topographically 15-feet below grade of the site directly south of the proposed project. The Applicant will allow the existing landscaping along_the.southern property line to grow .to a height of 6-feet within.the proposed site to screen the first floor of the residences as viewed from their private open space. Minimal visibility of items stored at this facility could occur within this line of sight. Otherwise, there are no visual impacts to the surrounding area. Two conditions of approval will address concerns related to screening: First, a building height of thirteen and a Half feet would be established for RV's as conditioned by SDG&E; Second, storage would be limited to motorhomes, trailers, boats on trailers and operable vehicles, These conditions would minimize potential visual impacts from the facility to occur. - 20 - Planning Commission May 8, 2019 PCC-16-0030 Page No. 5 Surfacing, Access and Site Improvements The area will be utilized for the proposed RV storage facility. The site, including driveways and storage areas, would be paved with permeable asphalt surfacing. No office facility will be provided on-site. In addition, a twenty-six foot wide fire drive aisle will be provided through the center of the project and would contain additional surfacing required to accommodate emergency vehicles. Access to the storage facility will be through one controlled automatic gate. The gate would be activated by an electronic keypad for recognition. Parking and Circulation There are 11 separate parking spaces provided within the storage facility. Customers will pull up to boats and other trailers, hitch up, and drive away. In the case of motorhomes, customers can park their car in the storage space as they leave with their coach. In addition, if other temporary parking is required, due to the thirty to forty foot length of the storage spaces, there may also be additional room within said space for the parking of cars. Lighting and Security The site will contain a number of security lights. The light poles will be fifteen feet high in order to provide sufficient lighting for security purposes. A photometric study was prepared to show that no light spillage would occur beyond the property lines. Hours of a enation Hours of operation of the storage facility would be daily from 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. There will be no on-site attendant. However, surveillance cameras will be located on-site for security surveillance. As described above, the entry gate would be activated by an electronic keypad for recognition. The gate will be programmed for activation only during these hours of operation. Land Use Compatibility The proposed project is located on a parcel with a utility corridor. The site is located in the eastern portion of the City. There are existing uses adjacent to the parcel, a residential parcel is located to the south,a high.school is located north of the site, SR-125 is west and a church is on the east side across Eastlake Parkway. Because the requested CUP would only be granted for a period of five years, any development of these parcels would be taken into consideration for any future requests by the applicant to extend the operation of the storage facility beyond a five-year period of time. The project produces very little traffic with no significant noise impacts. PUBLIC INPUT During the project review process, City staff received 6 comment letters from concerned residents who own property south of the proposed project site (please see copy of Letters included in this packet as Attachment 3). The letters express concerns related to land use, transients, noise, property values, aesthetics and hours of operation. In response, the Applicant attempted to contact residents via social media in an attempt to meet and discuss issues. Staff has reviewed the project based on the standards contained in CVMC Section 19.58.400 requiring that an application to establish a recreational vehicle storage yard shall address the following issues: (1). height limit for stored items, (2) screei _ 2 1'_ dscaping and fencing), (3) surfacing, (4) Planning Commission May 8, 2019 PCC-16-0030 Page No. 6 access to the site, (5) office facilities, (6) customer parking, (7) lighting, (8) hours of operation, (9) security, (10) signing, and (11) surrounding land uses and structures. Staff reviewed the proposed project and found that the proposed use meets the requirements of the CVMC. CONCLUSION Staff finds that the proposed use meets the requirements of the CVMC and that allowing the storage facility to operate for five years would be an appropriate interim use of the site. As discussed in this staff report, the use will have no significant impacts on the existing surrounding land uses. DECISION-MAKER CONFLICTS Staff has reviewed the property holdings of the Planning Commission members and has found no property holdings within 1,000 feet of the boundaries of the property which is the subject of this action. Consequently, this item does not present a disqualifying real property-related financial conflict of interest under California Code of Regulations Title 2, section 18702.2(a)(7) or (8), for purposes of the Political Reform Act (Cal. Gov't Code §87100, et seq.). Staff is not independently aware, and has not been informed by any Planning Commission member, of any other fact that may constitute a basis for a decision-maker conflict of interest in this matter." FISCAL IMPACT There are no fiscal impacts from the preparation of this report and the processing of the CUP. All costs are covered by the Applicant's deposit account. ATTACHMENTS 1 Planning Commission Memo 2 Locator Map 3 Planning Commission Resolution 4 Correspondence 5 Ownership Disclosure Form 6 Eastlake III Community Association CC&R's 7 Project Plans (via flash drive) Prepared by: Oscar Romero,Assistant Planner,Development Services Department — 22 — i Attachment 1 i ULA V ciAV TYOF CHISTA Develo p ment Services Department PLANNING DIVISION MEMORANDUM Date: May 8, 2019 To: Chula Vista Planning Commission From: Oscar Romero, Assistant Planner Project Name: Titan Storage Permit#: CUP16-0030 Project#: BB-2438 Subject: Conditional Use Permit— Planning Commission Continuance On March 13, 2019, the Planning Commission voted to continue CUP16-0030. The applicant is now presenting an updated proposal that attempts to address concerns raised by the PC on March 13, 2019. The Applicant has made changes to the proposed project, in order to address concerns raised at the March 13,-2019 PC hearing. First, the hours of operation were initially between the hours of 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., and are now proposed from 7:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. The hours have been modified to avoid any overlap with early morning school traffic during drop-off (school start time is 7:15 a.m. during weekdays). Second, the Applicant has modified the site's lighting plan to have only four to five lights on throughout the night to illuminate the entrance, middle and rear of the -project site. Previously, the entire site was to be illuminated throughout the night. Finally, residents and Commission members found the project to have potential safety concerns, and as such, the applicant has submitted a letter from a security expert that supports the site Security Plan. Planning Commissioners also wanted staff to clarify the Open Space designation of the site. Open Space is a Special Purpose District within the Eastlake II Sectional Planning Area (SPA) document intended for general agriculture, open space, public and quasi-public uses. For all open space districts in the Eastlake II .SPA, there is no lot size limitation and it is the intent that these districts may be applied to a portion of a lot provided that the remainder of the loft meets the requirements for which it is zoned. Page 1 of 3 H:\DSD\Boards&Commissions\Planning Commission\2019 Meetings\05.08.2019\Item 1 -Attachment 1 -PC Comment M — 2 3 - The Open Space District is included in the Planned Community District Regulations to achieve the following purposes: 1. To preserve open space for the conservation of natural resources; 2. Maintain the natural character of the land; 3. Provide for public/quasi-public and recreational uses; 4. Conserve areas of historic and community significance for the enjoyment of future generations; 6. Provide for private use of land under limited development; and 6. Promote public health and safety. The Open Space Zone in the Eastlake II SPA plan is a term with seven categories consisting of various uses and intensities overlapping and some distinct to the open space zone, but all allow for some form of development. For example, uses that are allowed within some open space zones include conference facilities, country clubs, health club/spa(s), hotel/motel/lodging facilities and public and quasi-public uses such as educational institutions. Specifically, the site location is zoned OS-III. OS III allows the following types of land uses listed in the table below. It is important to note that the OS-III designation does not permit any type of permanent structure, whereas other OS zones in Eastlake II do allow permanent structures. Land Use P _ - A— N — Not C — Conditional Permitted Administrative Permitted Use Permit Review y •€. ,- .tea Agriculture- � p �� .• X �� , �- all Arboreta X (Horticulture Garden Commercial X Equestrian Facilities Field Crops X Golf X 276 FnllrEh Avenue Bldg R,hula Vista, CA 9191Q (61_Q)h91-.91(11 I www r1m,alliatara ornr Page 2 of 3 H:\DSD\Boards&Commissions\Planning Commission\2019 Meetings\05.08.2019\Item 1 -Attachment 1 -PC Comment N -24 - course/Country Club Hotel/Motel/Lodgmg �� '� �` v -.-_...., .�'SS;M1 zz uEL�...:v� Incidental X concessions public uses fflT Tree Farming X F�;§-r Within the Eastlake Community there are several Open Space zones with existing developments. The OS-IV zone is developed with educational institutions, such as Eastlake High School directly north of the project site and Olympic View Elementary directly east across Eastlake Parkway. The existing Eastlake Country Club has been developed under the zoning designation of OS-VI. These examples serve to show the Open Space zones as areas facilitating compatible land uses and not strictly as preserve or green space. Staff has reviewed the project for consistency with the Eastlake II SPA, and the Chula Vista Municipal Code development standards and found the proposal to be consistent with the intent of the OS-III zone. 276Fn�th A L-nupRlrla R C'hiila Vic}a CA gigin I ( (1�9Q1 1 u n..�}��aviclaragnu Page 3 of 3 H:\DSD\Boards&Commissions\Planning Commission\?nl A Maalings\05.08.2019\Item 1 -Attachment 1 -PC Comment M - 25 - PHIS PAGE LEFT BLANK - 26 - Attachment 2 V_J_ i EASTLAKE - HIGH SCHOOL CLUBHOUSE DR L7olullonou L7 3 p POlE T E3 Cl C3c fn 4 p � p G7 CATIONo � f= m C3 z CM3 � t7�©a4Qo w .po 14, OLYMPIC VIEW ? ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Lo N r' PARKWAY HILLS w CHURCH OF THE . NAZARENE LOCATOR NORTH C16-0 - 27 - THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK - 28 - Attachment 3 RESOLUTION NO. PCC-16-0030 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT CUP16-0030 FOR A TEMPORARY RECREATIONAL VEHICLE AND BOAT STORAGE FACILITY LOCATED ON A 6.5-ACRE SITE AT 1228 EASTLAKE PARKWAY WITHIN THE EASTLAKE II SECTIONAL PLANNING AREA (OS3 ZONE) WHEREAS, on July 28, 2018, a duly verified application for a Conditional Use Permit ("CUP" or "Conditional Use Permit") was filed with the City of Chula Vista Development Services Department by Frank Orhmund(Applicant); and WHEREAS, the application requests approval of a Conditional Use Permit to allow the use of a Recreational Vehicle (RV) and Boat Storage facility(Project); and WHEREAS, the area of land, which is the subject of this Resolution, is an existing 6.5- acre site at 1228 Eastlake Parkway(Project Site) owned by UTR, LLC (Property Owner); and WHEREAS, the Development Services Director reviewed the Project for compliance with the California. Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and has determined that the Project qualifies for a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 (New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures) of the State CEQA Guidelines because the Project consists of the installation of minor improvements for outdoor storage. Therefore, no further environmental review is required; and WHEREAS, the Director of Development Services set the time and place for a hearing on the Conditional Use Permit application, and notice of the hearing, together with its purpose, was given by its publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the �ity, and its mailing to property owners and residents within 500 feet of the exterior boundaries of the property at least 10 days prior to the hearing; and WHEREAS, the hearing was held at the time and place as advertised in the Council Chambers, 276 Fourth Avenue, before the Planning Commission, and the hearing was thereafter closed; and WHEREAS, after considering all reports, evidence and testimony presented at the public hearing with respect to the Project,the Planning Commission took action on the Project. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the Planning Commission of the City of Chula Vista hereby finds that, in the exercise of its independent judgment, as set forth in the record of this proceeding, it has reviewed the proposed project for compliance with CEQA and finds that the Project qualifies for a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 (New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures) of the State CEQA Guidelines because the —29 _ Page 2 May 8, 2019 Project consists of the installation of minor improvements for outdoor storage and that no further environmental review is required. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Chula Vista that it hereby snakes the following findings:. That the proposed use at.this location is necessary or desirable to provide a service'or facility which will. 'contribute'to the general well being of the neighborhood or the community. Approval of the Project will allow the Applicant to provide a storage facility for RVs and boats used by residents within the surrounding neighborhoods. According to the Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions (CC&Rs) of the Eastlake Planned Community, neither RVs, nor boats can be parked along the street or within the driveway of the residences. The proposed storage facility will serve a demand for residents of the Eastlake and surrounding communities who need a location to store their RVs and boats. That such use will not, under the circumstances of the particular case, be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property or improvements in the vicinity. The project site is located off Eastlake Parkway and has a frontage width of 220-feet with an existing 65-foot San Diego County Water Authority easement and San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) easement of 120-feet spanning from the east to west side of the property. The two - easements stretch from the north side of the parcel to the toe of slope on the southern end adjacent to the residences. The proposed project will use part of the easement for ingress and egress as well as for emergency vehicle turn around. The RV Storage will be located on the southern SDG&E easement where it will be graded with permeable concrete for stored vehicles and a more durable concrete for emergency vehicle access. The storage facility will be completely enclosed and screened from public view by fencing and landscaping. The high school on the north side will not be visually impacted due to an uphill slope, and the residential side on the south will be screened by existing landscaping and a 6 foot high fence. Although the storage facility will not be completely screened, its visibility from the adjacent properties will be minimal, In addition., the site will include lighting (which will be shielded from adjacent properties) and security cameras and other improvements described herein. Further, this is considered an interim use until such time as a more economically viable and appropriate use can be developed on the site. As such, the Project will not be detrimental.to the health, safety or general welfare_of persons residing-or working in the vicinity or injurious to property or improvements in the vicinity. That the proposed use.will.comply.with the regulations and conditions specified in the e . code for such use. The proposed storage facility has.been reviewed and conditioned in light of the provisions contained in Section 19.58.400 of the CVMC. The Project will be approved for an initial period of five years, and annual review reports must be provided to the Zoning — 30 — Page 3 May 8, 2019 Administrator. Said reports will describe the current status of the area, including that of the immediately adjacent parcels to the north and south. I That the granting of the Conditional Use Permit will not adversely affect the General Pian of the City, or the adopted plan of any government agency. This Conditional Use Permit is in compliance with the General Plan and CVMC. Section 19.54.020 lists recreational vehicle storage yards as an Unclassified Use and subject to the granting of a CUP by the Planning Commission. Section 19.58.400 further defines factors that must be considered in determining the appropriateness of the use at the proposed location and describes the timeperiod for the granting of said permit. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission, based on the findings above, hereby approves the Conditional Use Permit, CUP16-0030, subject to the following conditions: I. The following shall be accomplished to the satisfaction of the Development Services Director, or designee, prior to issuance of a Building Permit, unless otherwise specified: Planning Division 1. Storage shall be limited to the following: motorhomes, trailers, boats on trailers and operable vehicles. 2. A height limit shall be limited to 13.5-feet and shall apply to all items stored on the premises as conditioned by SDG&E. 3. All project lighting shall be shielded and oriented so as not to cause glare to adjoining properties or the public right-of-way. Prior to Site Plan approval, a Final Lighting Plan shall be submitted for review and approval. The Lighting Plan shall indicate that no off-site spill of lighting from the site occurs. 4. This Conditional Use Permit shall expire five years from the date of final approval after any appeal period has expired. Any requests for a time extension shall be subject to review by the Planning Commission. 5. Approval of this Conditional Use Permit shall not waive compliance with any Sections of Title 19 (Zoning) of the Municipal Code nor any other applicable City ordinances in effect at the time of Building Permit issuance. .6. This Conditional Use.Permit authorizes only the use specified in the application for CUP16-0030. Any new use, modification or expansion of the use, or activities not authorized under this permit, shall be subject to the review and approval of the Zoning Administrator or Planning Commission in accordance with applicable Sections of the CVMC. - 31 - Page 4 May 8, 2019 7. This Conditional Use Permit shall become void if not used or extended within three years of the effective date thereof in accordance with Section 19.14.260 of the CVMC. Failure to comply with any conditions of approval shall cause this permit to be reviewed by the Planning Commission for additional conditions or revocation. 8. The Applicant shall and does hereby agree to indemnify, protect, defend and hold harmless City, its City Council members, Planning Commission members, officers, employees and representatives, from and against any and all liabilities, losses, damages, demands, claims and costs, including court costs and attorney's fees (collectively, "liabilities") incurred by the City arising, directly or indirectly, from (a) City's approval and issuance of this Conditional Use Permit (including all environmental review) and (b) City's approval or issuance of any other permit or action, whether discretionary or non-discretionary, in connection with the use contemplated herein. The Applicant shall acknowledge their agreement to this provision by executing a copy of this Conditional Use Permit where indicated below. The Applicant's compliance with this provision is an express condition of this Conditional Use Permit and shall be binding on any and all of Applicant's successors and assigns. 9. Any violations of the terms and conditions of this permit may result in the imposition of civil or criminal penalties and/or the revocation or modification of this Conditional Use Permit. _ 10.If any of the foregoing conditions fail to occur, or if they are, by their terms, to be implemented and maintained over time, if any of such conditions fail to be so implemented and maintained according to their terms, the City shall have the right to revoke or modify all approvals herein granted, deny, or further condition issuance of - all future building permits, deny, revoke, or further condition all certificates of occupancy issued under the authority of approvals herein granted, institute and prosecute litigation to compel their compliance with said conditions or seek damages from their violation. Applicant or successor in interest gains no vested rights by the City's approval of this Conditional Use Permit. 11.Applicant shall -develop and maintain the Project Site in accordance with the approved Site Plan on file in the Planning Division, the conditions contained herein, and Title 19. 12.Applicant shall pay all applicable fees, including any unpaid balances of permit processing. 13. Prior to placement of any signage on site, the Applicant shall be required to obtain required approval.by the City. 14. The Applicant shall submit a Security Plan for review and approval by the Police Department. - 32 - Page 5 May 8, 2019 Building Division 15. Prior to occupancy the Applicant shall apply for a Building Permit showing that the site will be improved as shown on plans approved under CUP 16-0030. 16. The Applicant shall provide a note on the cover sheet of Building Plans indicating that this Project will comply with 2016 California Building Code, 2016 California Energy Code, 2016 California Fire Code, 2016 California Electrical Code, 2016 California Plumbing Code, 2016 California Mechanical Code, and 2016 California Green Standards Code as adopted and amended by the State of California and the City of Chula Vista. Fire Prevention Division 17. The Applicant shall apply for a Grading Permit with the City of Chula Vista Land Development Section to permit the road and associated site improvements. 18. The Applicant shall apply for a Fire Permit to permit the design and installation of the underground fire service wet utility(private hydrant lateral). Landscape Architecture Division 19. All comments and corrections for Landscape Plans shall be completed prior to any Building Permit issuance. Land Development Division 20. All comments and -corrections for the Storm Water Quality Management Plan (SWQMP) shall be revised and completed prior to and Building Permit issuance. 21. The Applicant shall pay the corresponding Engineering Fees in accordance to the City's Master Fee Schedule, 22. The Applicant shall acknowledge that all on-site utilities shall be private. 23. All driveways shall conform to the City of Chula Vista's sight distance requirements. Furthermore, landscaping, street furniture and/or signs shall not obstruct the visibility of drivers at the driveways. 24. Prior to beginning any earthwork activities at the site and before issuance of Building Permits,Applicant shall obtain a Land Development Permit (Grading Permit). 25. The Project shall comply with the City of Chula Vista Storm Water Ordinance (Chula Vista Municipal Code CVMC Chapter 14.20 Storm Water Management and Discharge Control) and follow the recommendations of the City of Chula Vista Best Management Practice (BMP)Design Manual and the corresponding Appendices. - 33 - Page 6 May 8, 2019 26. Prior to the approval of the Grading Plans, the Applicant shall execute a Storm Water Facilities Maintenance Agreement with Grant of Access and Covenants with the City for the proposed BMPs for the site. 27. The Applicant shall obtain a Construction Permit to perform any work within the city's right-of-way. 28. The Applicant is responsible for the replacement of any broken or damaged curb, gutter, and sidewalk, and noncompliant driveways along the frontage of the Project Site. Required improvements shall be constructed following the requirements of the Chula Vista Design and Construction Standard Drawings, all to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. II. The following on-going conditions shall apply to the Project Site as long as it relies on this approval: 29. The facility will operate seven days a week from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. 30. The Applicant shall submit, on an annual basis, a review report to the Zoning Administrator outlining the current status of the interim use in light of existing and proposed surrounding development. 31. The conditions of approval for the Conditional Use Permit shall be applied to the subject property until such time approval is modified or revoked, and the existence of the approval with conditions shall be recorded with the title of the property. Prior to the issuance of the Building Permits for the proposed project, the Applicant/property owner shall provide the Planning Division with a recorded copy of said document. III. EXECUTION AND RECORDATION OF RESOLUTION OF APPROVAL The property owner and the Applicant shall execute this document by signing the lines provided below, said execution indicating that the property owner and Applicant have each read, understood, and agreed to the conditions contained herein. Upon execution, -this document shall be recorded with the County Clerk of the County of San Diego, at the sole expenseofthe property owner and/or Applicant, and a signed, stamped copy of this recorded document shall be filed with the City Clerk within ten days of recordation. Failure to record and/or file shall indicate the property owner's/Applicant's desire that the Project, and the corresponding application for building permits and/or a business license, be held in abeyance without approval. Signature of Property Owner Date Signature of Representative Date — 34— Page 7 May 8, 2019 IV. GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 66020(d)(1),NOTICE Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d)(1), NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the 90 day period to protest the imposition of any impact fee, dedication, reservation, or other exaction described in this resolution begins on the effective date of this resolution and any such protest must be in a manner that complies with Government Code Section 66020(a) and failure to follow timely this procedure will bar any subsequent legal action to attack, review, set aside, void or annul imposition. The right to protest the fees, dedications, reservations, or other exactions does not apply to planning, zoning, grading, or other similar application processing fees or service fees in connection with this Project; and it does not apply to any fees, dedication, reservations, or other exactions which have been given notice similar to this, nor does it revive challenges to any fees for which the statute of limitations has previously expired. V. CONSEQUENCE OF FAILURE OF CONDITIONS If any of the foregoing conditions fail to occur, or if they are, by their terms, to be implemented and maintained over time, if any of such conditions fail to be so implemented and maintained according to their terms, the City shall have the right to revoke or modify all approvals herein granted, deny, or further condition issuance of all future building permits, deny, revoke, or further condition all certificates of occupancy issued under the authority of approvals herein granted, institute and prosecute litigation to compel their compliance with said conditions or seek damages for their violation. The Applicant shall be notified ten (10) days in advance prior to any of the above actions being taken by the City and shall be given the opportunity to remedy any deficiencies identified by the City within a reasonable and diligent time frame. VI. INVALIDITY; AUTOMATIC REVOCATION It is the intention of the Planning Commission that its adoption of this Resolution is dependent upon the enforceability of each and every term, provision and condition herein stated; and that in the event that any one or more terms, provision, dr conditions are determined by a Court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, this resolution shall be deemed to be automatically revoked and of no further force and effect ab initio. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission hereby adopts this resolution approving Conditional Use Permit, CUP 16-0030, in accordance with the findings and subject to the conditions contained herein. — 35 — Page 8 May 8, 2019 PASSED AND APPROVED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA, CALIFORNIA, this day of , 2019, by the following vote, to-wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: Gabe Gutierrez, Chair ATTEST: Patricia Salvacion, Secretary Presented by: Approved as to form by: Kelly Broughton Glen R. Googins Development Services Director City Attorney - 36 - Attachment 4 Oscar Romero From: Carmen Berumen <cberumenl.@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday, November 25, 2018 14;10 PM To: Oscar Romero Subject. CUP16-0030, Unwanted recreational storage yard next to our homes Mr. Romero I am writing to express my strong opposition to the application by Titan Storage for a recreational vehicle storage yard, case number CUP16-0030, I have left two messages this past week on your voicemail. About 2 years ago we received an initial notice with vague information and listing an address 1228 Eastlake Parkway, this address is on city land used by the Chula Vista water department. Now the latest notice received November 19, 2017 points to a different location. The project description with a map Indicates that this storage yard is going to be located on the SDG&E easement between our homes and Eastlake High School. This is unacceptable. i I have talked to several of my neighbors and I have yet to find one person who wants this storage yard next to us.This unsightly area will be a magnet for thieves, the homeless and drug use since this will be next to Eastlake High school and across the street from a middle school.This storage yard will provide a perfect cover for illicit activities,The noise level and fumes from these recreational vehicles is also of concern. Our safety,privacy and property values will be greatly affected by this Storage yard. This eyesore does not belong next to homes and schools and is more suited for areas like 9 the industrial areas of Otay Mesa or along Main St. in Chula Vista. i The timing of the last notice listing specific location and notifying us that the city Planning Division will make a decision on a l Tuesday November 27,2018'is highly suspect given that this last notice contains time and date and was received on r Thanksgiving week giving us only 3 days notice.This storage yard is unacceptable and the timing of this last notice feels like an ambush. Jur HOA manager and Board of directors are meeting this Wednesday Nov.28,2018 and this Storage yard is a highly anticipated topic. A I and many of my neighbors are strongly opposed to this project and request that the applicants petition to operate this Storage yard on the site described on case number CUP18-0030 be denied. j j Carmen Berumen Resident and MoMeoWner in Antigua at Eastlake _ 37 _ Oscar Romero From: Raquel Herrera <tulip78rh@gmail,com> Sent: Monday, November 26,201812:17 AM To: Oscar Romero Subject; CU P16-0030 Fallow Up Flag: Fallow up Flag Status: Flagged Hello Mr. Romero, Conditional Use Permit Titan Storage, 1228 Eastlake Parkway I received a Notice of Application for the above address which is next to Antigua @ Eastlake Condominiums, the letters have limited information about the project and based on the information provided I have the following concerns; Hours of operation,d am-10 pm 7 days a week,located directly next to people's backyards,this will affect quality of life due to noise, customers hanging out and proximity„A visit to the prof cot site should be a must ; when considering this type of business next to a residential complex. I am asking for the hours of operation to be amended, closing should not be past 7 pm and weekend hours of operation should be more reasonable. Also will the city have any security and fencing requirements? Don't see many of these next to apartments,so I might be short on the list of problems that can come our way.I hope your consideration tabes into account what is best for the neighborhood and those closest to the project, Sincerely, { Raquel Cintron 1217 Aruba Cave#1 3 Chula Vista, CA 91915 5 73 J 1 - 38 - Oscar Romero From Giselle Murray <Igvalco@gmall.com> Sent: Monday,January 07,203.9 5:34 AM To: Oscar Romero; Mary Salas; Steve C. Padilla Cc: Patrick Murray Subject: Opposing RV Titan Storage Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Wiirnm i. Jib 19'k- Ili* outside f C' W 6 th- Mob 1.,46 ih g Hello Nft, Oscar Romero, First off,my husband and I are residents of Antigua at Eastlake and strongly oppose the proposal CUP 16-0030 for the RV storage yard,Titan Storage,that the City has received applications for.We were informed by concerned neighbors that unless we wrote to you, we WaWd not receive notification of hearings at council or even final word on a decision of whether this would go through or not, So,we would like to be on this distribution list and kept up to date on when meetings will occur at council and when we can voice our concerns, These concerns are many. For starters,crime.With the last tax increase/proposition passing claiming it would go to police and fire only to go to the general fund and be appropriated elsewhere,how can we trust our neighborhoods will be safe,Leaving it up to those who are applying for this permit to provide their own(and probably only to cover their property)? It is not news that there has been a steady increase in crime hi the Eastlake community with no more police being assigned to our side of the city. Criminals know our patrols are few and have taken full advantage by breaking into our homes,vehicles, stealing packages from our front doors, etc.No satellite station is slated to-be built out here,yet the population continues to increase due to city measures and developments that are allowed to pass building out every last stretch of land.When will our City leaders, Council and "Public servants"realize the irreparable damage they are doing to the safety of our community,residents, children,and property values? Financial gain-should not take precedence over the well-being of our neighborhoods.The children that attend Olympic View Elementary and students of Eastlake High will be affected by this approval. We would hope that along with the crimes listed above,violent crimes do not become.much more prevalent affecting our young children and teens. Property values will most likely also decrease for us at Antigua with floodlights being on all night,but I'm sure the City has not considered this or at least shows no regard for it. Traffic-more of it.With the comings and goings of those who will be parking their large RVs out here,our already busy city streets will continue to be further impacted. Fm sure following all this,more proposals will be pushed for for further tax increases to remedy all of the aforementioned issues, 1 - 39 - This type of land usage is more appropriate for an area zoned commercial and NOT mixed into residential, Perhaps the City could suggest to those applying for this permit somewhQre off of Main Street, because Eastlake is not fit for this type of usage and it is completely unfair to residents and our children. The neighbors at Antigua have been rallying against this anal I am certain you will be heating from more of us. .Again,we expect to be informed of decisions and City Council dates. Thank you, Giselle and Patrick Murray 1 v�o, ail,com vatrickJ.mqrrayl(@,gmaiI.com 619-495-4821 F t t}i i k h i ' 7 _ 2 — 40 — ii Oscar Romero From: Patricia Salvacion on behalf of Department Administration Sent: Tuesday,January 08,2019 9:33 AM To: Oscar Romero Cc: Stan Bonn Subject: FW:City of Chula Vista: Development Services Contact Us-Web Notification Follow Up Flag: f=ollow up Flag Status: Flagged Oscar, Please see email below regarding CUP16-0030-Titan Storage,2218 Eastlake Parkway- From.,Webmaster Sent:Monday,January 07, 2019 8:42 PM l To: Department Administration<dsd chulavistaca, ov> y Subject:City of Chula Vista: Development Services Contact Us-Web Notification i A.new erntry to a form/survey has been submitted, Form!Name: Development Services P � Date&Time: 01/07/2019 8:41 PM Response#: 1562 ` Submitter ID: 56462 IP address: 172.24.96.7.10 Time to complete: 44 min., 15 sec. i s F Surrey Details i ................................................................. a t Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questiorts by filling out the farm.below. First Name Carletta Last Name Coleman Email Address rnoonbb3@gmail.com Phone number,if you (619)322-0057 prefer.(optional) Comments Good Evening, lI aim writing today about Titan Storage.The company Is planning on opening a Recreational Storage Yard next to Antigua Eastlake which is the townhouse community I live in.First of all my question is why would SOG&C allow a company to store motor homes under powerlines?There Is something already occupying the property,Poweriines! The company can go anywhere else to store motor homes like an industrial park in Chula Vista, 1 - 41 - This type of business does not belong in our neighborhood,This is a residential neighborhood, Why would someone pay$400K+for a home and to look at an eyesore and have flood lights shine in their windows 24/7? This type of storage yard will Invite criminal activity Into our neighborhood and affect the safety of our kids who play here and attend Olympic View Elementary and Eastlake High School, Our property value Is going to drop dramatically[I am totally against this, City Is Chula Vista,why would you allow this?I ma extremely disappointed and will fight this move Into my neighborhoodI Carletta Coleman Thank you, City of Chula Vista This is an autornated message generated by the Vision Content Management SystemTM.please do not reply directiy to this email. 2 _ 42 _ Oscar Romero j From; Steve Power Sent: Monday, February 04,201911:50 AM To. Oscar Romero Subject: FW:Antigua resident's unanimous opposition to Titan Storage application, case number CUP16-0030 Attachments: seller disclosure,msg; 1st notice,msg;2nd notice.pcif; 3rd notice.pdf Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Please make sure that all of these people get notices. Thanks From:notm anti ua ahoo,corn<notmvantiauayahoo,com> Sent: Monday,February 4,201911:44 AM To:Steve Power<SPower2chulav1staca.gov> Subject:Fw:Antigua resident's unanimous opposition to Titan Storage application,case number CUP16-0030 PC Warning:TI7"s.:;email.o i"in #e fro autside`the Ci cif CFiula.Vist. l.17 n '1i lit 1, t!3...a.. .rr! ty #a , o c ck oil links sr"o"en attachments ,u les :..1'; .r.'i••,. .. P•_I:IFC,: e:s+ Q.1r".; ::=_,•.a}.,,:. _ re GC1• .� ::,: ;•:; .._ h. n' c'and'or '�e��'ec - �;.1,. :�, _ - 1! .g� d tin th��mes'sa"�e.' i. :,�:=: ;:�,:.:., I hope this is the correct email and this message reaches you. j Thank you. -----Forwarded Message----- From: notmyantigua(&yahoo.com<notmyantiqua@yahoo.com> z To:kbroughton(&,chulavistaca.cov<kbrounhton a0chulavistaca.cov};s wars chulavistaca, ov ,wowersAchulavistaca,gov>;tcruzAchulavistaca.gov<tcruz chulav'ataca. ova;spadillaQchulavistaca.gov <spadlllaOchulavistaca,g Cc: Beatriz Moreno<bettv,rnore102PYahoo,com>; Nicole Henley<nicole oIIvia1Qyahoo.com>;Chris &Carolyn Anderson<chris.Carolyn.andersonCcbgmall.com>;Sue Hekman<suehekman@gmall.com>;Armando and Sarah Orozco <rroutearound(cDgmail,com>; Raquel Herrera<1ullp78rhQgmail.com>; Stephanie <ste hanieelsa00 ahoo.com>; Rebecca Colangelo�colangelorebecca(7a.grnail.corn>; Christopher Guerrerl <christa her uerreri mall.com>;Rebecca Parco<rebeccaparco@,yahoo,com>; Oil Lisama<oliyerlisama79@gmail.corn>;Carlette L.. Leonard-Coleman <cartetta,l.leonard-eolemanC7a lmco.com>;Sandy Conrady<issybee 6(.hotmall.com>;fgvaleo(7a prnaiLcom <Igvalco0,gmail:com>; Laura Alvarado<alvarado.carrilloa ay hoo.com?; Blanca Leos<blancadeleos@hotmaiLcom> Sent: Monday, February 4,2019, 11:13:02 AM PST Subject: Antigua resident's unanimous opposition to Titan Storage application, case number CUP16.0030 Mr, Broughton I and my neighbors talked to you at last month's City meeting regarding our opposition to Titan Storage's application to operate 6am-10pm seven days a week next to our homes and schools. I sent an email with my neighbor's emails copied onto the body of the email which I fear did not reach you,this time I will cc all my neighbors so that they also have access to this information. When we talked,you requested we send you copies of what we have regarding our opposition and concerns to the operation of a storage yard next to our homes and Antigua homeowner's emails so that your office can send out a timely notification to let us know when Titan storage application will be on your bi-monthly department meeting agenda. please 1 — 43 — find attached copies of the 3 notifications we have received from your office along with Western Pacific Housing(home builder) seller's disclosure. Thank you for your time Carmen Berumen Antigua resident 619-4055041 I J 7 li !i n i� it 'I !I .i 7 J 7jI 1 1 2 — 44 — �,�; •Seller s DnscltssureStatement. t� t a�. ML requirements, to railnim m sound transfer into neighboring Residential Jjnits, and to Provide 3 fire lirotmtion Measures.,These-common walls-and+eomrnon£lacus are not"sound proo#TM and sonic sound transfer could be exPerieneed and should be expwta It is therefore important that Buyers do not penxdwo,the common wall and common floors as this will affect the f 'construction m l easum intended to meet code requirments. Addifia rally, there ars fm Protection measures in the ceilings which should also not be penetrated without consulting a liwe used bwlding conttactor. Each Buyer is responsible for satisfying himself or herself as to the acoustics and noise attenuation between Residential Units in the Community. 62.NOME cad MCMC IS► uFS: This Subdivision nay be impacted by noise from SR.125 oaf+, EastfAe Boulevard, Eastlake High, Sctwl, and other 40biing land u , Additionally,Antigua is located in close proximity to an above ground water tank owned and, operated by the Quay Water District and residents may be iVWted, from noise (such as deliveries and daily opexations) associated with operation of this facility. The Qtay Water District is planning to install a Pump stations south of the Antigua Communtity that has the Potential is result in noise audible from your residence. Noise impact mitigation measures ! for the Residences have been based upon and implemented in accordance with the City of ! � Chula Vista building standaW& . r SR 123 is currently being planned by the City of Chula, 'Vista and. associated agendes to i extenei from the 905 firay#o the Poway . (Buyers are advised to contact the City of Chula Vas"Engineering D`PaMnent for details concerning SR-125 such as &4.). �C-aven'tbt$R-125 will:e -`red Awmt,to and i�nmWiately west th Antigua community,anise from SR-125 will be auch-ble throughout the Antigua community: lie order to meet City of Chula Vista exterior noise standards,balcony noise barrim will be required for a number of Plan 1 balconies located along the future State Route 125 corridor. Units requiring baleony barriers on the Plan 1 baby include units 128, 1.29, 136, 137, 144, 145, � 152, 153, 160 161,1-68,'169, and 176. These balconies, to be a will 4Pe Plexi-glass or plate glass, ar � � l of stucco and nrst:vcted throughout �y different than the wood balconies tl will be co ughout the community. - Buyer acknowledges that there may be noise assoeiat"d with the use and Ooymeaot of the POOL spa,clubhouse and recreational areas by Antigua residents and their guests during hours of operation whicli include mooing and night times. Additionally, there may bac noise associated with the pool and spa equipment. Purahasm of units.next to or neat the Ixwlhc rea►tion area ad mwle dge this noise Potargal. �3. SAN 1LDIEI�CA C i ' VA A�3'Y' [!l '1'Y'lEo A►iLI€Il l :; Waw Braes owneed arid maintained by the San Diego County Water Authority are located to the north of the Antigua community along the northern property lane, There are cmUm ly two aqueducts within the Sae Diego County water Authority easement consistuig of a 69 inch lice and a 72 inch line. Please be aware that the San Diego C,taurnty Water Authority can utt`lize this easment to install more water lines and/or replace or upsize the existing lines, As -with any t acture,the San Diego County Water Authority docs pearform routine main#=ance and therfom will utilize the easment for vachile access as needed to reach their faoilties 4MMt page 17 of 33 -45 - ! Sellees Disclosure Statement to the project and as well as facilities located beyond the community boundaries, For more, infbr,mation•regandiug these fwilities,•pleasc contwt•the San Diego County Water Authority. .. 64:SA�li' DIEM,GAS-AND ;ELEP-THIO (SEWS,& RGM. >�W��1 5 'The project is located adjacent to overhead electricity �1�'AtCIII,� 3 �1.IIrTDRR��.t,C1UNi� .. �,�. p power Imes owned and maintained by San Diego (iris ,& Bleettic Company (SDG&E). Currently, the SDG&E facilities located to the wrth of the project site consist of the following:, 69kv tirra mission lines, 230kv transmission lines, a 4" high pressure gas distribution line, and a 30"high pressure gas distribution line. Each of these facilities ate located withirdn the SDC7&E easement situated to the north of the .Antigua Community. SDG&E has the right to add to,change,or modify the existing facilities at any time. Thc power lines emit invisible fox= known as sleatroniagdnetiu fields (EhWa). EY1+a surround anyNog that caa ducts electricity, such as telwasions,microwave evens undi stereo e gwpment. Ell+E+s bave attracted attdmtiozn because some resem+ch studies have suggested there may be a link betwom EWs,and certain,types of ca met 00M rein has indicated i no connection at all. At this dime,we do not know for sure whether or not EWs pose any serious health risks. Research is ongoing, but it could take years for scicnee to provide defhnifive answers. SDG&E is allowed to bring machinery and people onto the property v covered by the easement to construct and lay now power lines, gas lines,pipes and overhead- Y struchm, as well as to repair, replace and remove odsting lines, pipes and overhead structures. The power lines may be above1pund or undietgmutnd. SW&E also has the right to go on the property coved by the casement to repair, replace, remove and maintain abovogtouad and undmpoundl lines,piles and other sttnotuM. The pomitted activities may include placing poles or dither structwe on the property for holding power lines and digging j halos andlor trenches on the lropettY. Met Mkes no express or implied warrmty or on to residents or owners with respect to the present o7 future v is a of any ! actual or potential health rislm associated with EMYs. Buyer acknowledges that Seller has no control aver SDG&E power lines on their promt or future lode 60% You hereby teleww Seller and any of Sellers Affiliated entities,agents or employees from any an all claims for damages,and/or.expmM, Wjury or death resulting from exposure to said power lines and from any loss of reWe value due to future changes in information or pubfit'opinion on EWs. If you have any questions or condemns rprding EWS, you should contact the SDG&ls EMF Center at(800) 336-SDGE, You should also contact the California Public Utilities Commission, the government agency which regulates California electric utilities at (4i5)703.1282.This subdivision may be impacted by noise from tho powerlines. t 65.sUBMETERIN G: The conirnunitY will have amain public water meta which measures ,tinter usage for all residences. Each residence has been pre-plumbed with a private water "submeterine'device(ala electronic device that measures the volume of water usage for each individual residence). This We of device will be iustalled in your garage, and will allow a company employed by the Association'to use ag electronic device to re84 each s6ineter. Each home, '_ will be responsible for v ainta g,repaIdng and the$ulna r, Page 18 of 33 — 46 — MEW OUSTA CH : DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Development Planning Division T-n November 01 , 2016 NOTICE OF APPLICATION As a property owner, tenant, or person who has requested notice, you should know that an application has been filed with the City of Chula Vista for a CONDITIONAL USE- PERMIT to Titan Storage, 1228 Eastlake Pw., proposal For outdoor storage of 90-100 recreational vehicles (boats & cars) and containers. The project site is located at 1228 EASTLAKE PW. PROJECT NUMBER: CUP16-0030 PROJECT NAME: Titan Storage PROJECT MANAGER? Harold Phelps CONTACT PHONE NUMBER: 619-409-5872 The decision to approve-or deny this application will be made atafuture date. You will receive another notice informing you of an administrative consideration date, time, and location of a public hearing, In addition, the project may. 10--e scheduled for a Community Meeting in the area in which it is located. If you have any questions regarding this application after reviewing this information, you may call the City of Chula Vista Project Manager listed above. This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request. - 47 - i MY OF � CHLAA VISTA I DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT Development Planning Division Pr October 26, 201 ' ,! NOTICE OF APPLICATION Asa property owner, tenant, or person who has requested notice,you should know that an application has been tiled with the City of Chula Vista for a Conditional Use Permit to Titan Storage, 1228 Eastlake Parkway for a proposal for outdoor storage of 90-100 recreational vehicles (boats & cars) and containers. The project site is located at 1228 EAS►TLAKE PARKWAY. { a PROJECT NUMBR: CUP16-0030 { i PROJECT NAME; TITAN Storage i PROJECT MANAGER; Oscar Romero { CONTACT PHONE#: 619,691.5098 I f i k The decision to approve or deny this application will be made at a future date. You will receive another notice informing you of an administrative consideration date, or the date, time, and location of a public hearing. In addition, the project may be scheduled for a Community Meeting in the area in which it Is located. If you have any.questions regarding this application after reviewing this information, you may call the City of Chula Vista Project Manager listed above. This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request. ` - 48 - NOTICE OF CONSiaE'RAT-ION OF-AN. ADMINISTRATIVE CONDITIONAL.WPIE- MIT By THe. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR. ;Y ,�:T. OF THE CITY OF CHIULA VISTA;CALIF6111hIIA NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT THE ZONING ADMI�NI6TRAT-Okof-the City:'of.�huja Vista, CSI tnrili consideran administrative Conditional Use Ferr�it(CU�,) . plj tio0'for. 0.TPJe'Q's'rhl� rized 0.�folio s. CONSIDERATION DATE: November 27, 2018- CASE- 01f3 CASE-NUMBER: OUP16.003{l � v, �: ;�'��. . #„ APPLICANT: Frank Orhmund, Titan Storage SITE ADDRESS: 1228 Eastlake Parkway, Chula Vista, CA 91915 PI'OJECT DESCRIPTION: Proposal to approve a Conditional Use Parmit to allow a ROD,eatioraal Vehicle Storage Yard on a vacant lot within the SDG&E right of way In the Eastlake 11 SPA. The applicant is proposing to operate a storage yard for 80-100 vehicles Monday thru Sunday from 6 a.m,to 10 p.m. The site is located between the SR-125 and Eastlake Parkway on the north side of Trinidad Cove and South of Clubhouse Drive. The site is within the Open Space District and has a General i Plan designation of Residential Medium-High (RMH). ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The Development Services Director has reviewed the proposed project for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act and has determined that the project qualifies for a Class 4, Section 15304 (Minor Alterations to Land) of the State CEQA guidelines. Thus, no further environmental review Is required. i Any written comments or petitions to be submitted to the Zoning Administrator must be received by the ! Development Services Department no later than 12:00 noon on Monday, November 26, 241 B. Please direct any questions or comments to Project Planner Oscar Romero In the Planning Division, Public Services Building B, Chula Vista Civic Center, 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA 91910, or call at (619)691-5098. Please include the case number noted above in all correspondence. The'permit shall be considered without a public hearing unless a hearing is requested by the applicant or other affected party by the comment deadline, C' If you wish to challenge the City's action on this application in court, you may be limited to raising only J those Issues you or someone else raises in response to this notice prior to the Zoning Administrator's consideration,of the application. A copy of the application and accompanying documentation and/or plans are on file and available for inspection and review at the City Planning Division of the Development i Services Department. Within teen business days after the decision is rendered,the applicant or other interested person may appeal the Zoning Administrator's decision to the City Council by submitting an appeal form and the required fee to the Planning Division. Please notify the Project Planner in writing if you wish to receive a copy of the Zoning Administrator's decision. ' -49 - Oscar Romero From: Steve Power Sent: Wednesday, February 13,201910:29 AM To: Oscar Romero Cc: Kelly Broughton Subject: FW:Storage yard application CUP16-0030 next to Antigua homes in Eastlake Oscar. Please clarify for her ASAP. PC on March 13th From:Carmen Berumen<cber9men1@yahoo,com> Sent:Wednesday,February 13,201910:27 AM To:Kelly Broughton<kbroughton cel chulavistaca.eov> Cc:issvbee 60hotmail,com;Igvalco@gmail.com;Tony Cruz<tcruz@chulavistaca.,gov>;Steve C. Padilla <spadi.11a@chulayistaca.gov ;chris.carolvn.anderson gmaii,com;Steve Power<SPower@.chulavistaca.gov>;Oscar Romero<oromero@chulayistace.gop Subject: RE: Storage yard application CUP16-0030 next to Antigua homes in Eastlake Warning;This email.,Qriginated:fr©rri ou#side..the:City of.ChuId-VIstg:•;D:6iiot;Elickjc� l links oro 'eii attacl�ixtet ts'`iinle5s tiu recti raze the' en nd re;ex ect'n`'the ess - :•E y ;�. . ,,.f.. p_ i,g. tli. .age.: : Hi Thanks for your quick reply.Just to make sure we understand:the Titan storage yard application will not be decided by the Planning department but it will be discussed in a public meeting and voted on by the city council le Mayor and ' I councilmen,in their weekly meeting and the application is on the city council meeting agenda for Tuesday March 12th 2019? ! I Thank you Carmen City oh Chula Vista website: The City Council meets regularly on the first four Tuesdays of the month at 5:00 p.m„in the Council Chambers,located at 276 Fourth Avenue in Chula Vista," Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android On Tue, Feb 12, 2019 at 7:39 PM, Kelly Broughton <kbroughtonCQohuiavistaca,cov>wrote: Sorry Carmen. I was mistaken on the days that I told you. I apologize for the bad information. Kelly Broughton,Director Development Services City of Chula Vista -----original Message---- From:Carmen Berumen [cberumenl@yahoo,com] i — 50 — Received:Tuesday, 12 Feb 2019,6:03PM To:Kelly Broughton [kbroughton@chulavistaca.gov] CC:Steve Power[SPower@chuiavistaca.govj;Oscar Romero [oromero@chulavlstaca.gov];Sandy Conrady [issybee_6@hotmail.com];Chris&Carolyn Anderson [Chris.carolyn.anderson@gmail.com];Iayalco@gmall,com [Igvalco@gmail.com];Steve C.Padilla [spadilla@chulavistaca.gov];Tony Crux[tcruz@chulavistaca,gov] Subject:Storage yard application CUP16-0030 next to Antigua homes in Eastlake 111tarning;'Fh s.entail,origiriate from;tsutside the;City.of C hula.Vista:f>~o not click on,.liriks.,or:open�ittachme�ts dniess you recdnize. a sender:Ad;ate:expectirig the`message. Mr.Broughton Last TuesdayPeb.6th my neighbor Sandy Conrady talked to Oscar Romero Inquiring about when the public decision for the Recreation Storage Yard Case number CUP16-0030 was scheduled. She was told by Oscar Romero that it was scheduled for next month Tuesday Larch 12th 2019. But we are very confused because when when I and my neighbors spoke to you at last month's city council meeting you informed us that the Planning department's public meetings occur the 1st and 3rd Wednesday of every month at bpm. Sandy Conrady called back and left Oscar Romero a message about the conflicting information and we have yet to get a response. Is the Recreational Storage Yard application being decided by the Mayor and councilmen or the Planning Department? Thank you Carmen Berumen 619-405-5041 I 3 i — 51 — Oscar Romero From: Jonathan Massie <jmassie@massieberman.com> Sent: Wednesday,April 24,2019 1:11 PM To: Oscar Romero Cc: Hugo Munoz Subject: FW: Conditional Use Permit/CUP 16-0030 Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Warnuig: External Good afternoon Mr. Romero: Email . Please accept the following email on behalf of Antigua at Eastlake Homeowners Association ("Association") concerning the conditional use permit(CUP 16-0030) proposed by Frank Orhmund. Please be advised that the Association takes no position on this application. Further, no one, including but not limited to Mr. Orhmund, may speak on behalf of the Board of Directors of the Association nor represent the Association's position in this regard. Again,the Association is not now nor has it in the past taken a position on the application of Mr.Orhmund and no one is authorized to make statements on behalf of the Association. Please call with any questions. Jonathan D. Massie, Esq. MASSIE BERMAN 35884 TH Avenue, Suite 200 San Diego, CA 92103 Tel: 619-260-9010 Fax:619-260-9016 "IMPORTANT INFORMATION-This e-mail, including any attachments, may be protected by the attorney-client privilege,work-product doctrine and may be restricted from disclosure by law. If you received this e-mail in error, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and permanently delete all copies of this e-mail and any attached documentation. _ 52 _ Patricia Salvacion From: david sikute <davidsikute@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2019 6:48 PM To: Oscar Romero Subject: CUP16-0030 RV Storage Facility Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Warning: External Email Dear Oscar, Date:Thu, 25 Apr 2019 Subject: CUP16-0030 RV Storage Facility Would you buy a home situated next to an RV storage area? Neither would any of the Antigua home owners---but we have already bought here. Who would think that some day we would be right next to an RV storage facility. When we sell,we will have no trouble finding a buyer---all we have to do is lower the price to a fraction of its current value. Why should a Storage Facility be allowed to reduce the value of our homes We wouldn't be allowed to reduce the value of their business. Eastlake High School is adjacent to the proposed storage area and Olympic Elementary School is across the street. If they are allowed to use this area for RV storage---it will benefit the homeless. Why live on the street,when they can break into an RV and have everything they want. One can only imagine the crime that this facility will bring to the neighborhood. David R. Sikute 2074 Barbados Cove#1 Chula Vista, Ca. 91915 —53 — S t r March 13,2019 To the City of Chula Vista Planning Commission/City Council/Planning Department: When doing a simple Google search for, "Why do zoning regulations exist?"the answer is evident and applies to cases exactly like Titan Storage. "To achieve this purpose,zoning laws regulate the impacts of land use that may not be in the best interests of the people, generally including such things as:Protecting the value and enjoyment of properties by separating incompatible land uses and minimizing their potentially negative impacts upon each other." Titan Storage not only would take away from our property values, which we are desperately.. trying to protect, and enjoyment of our homes and neighborhoods,but is also in complete violation and LEGALLY incompatible for where they plan on locating,the hours they plan on operating, and the noise and light nuisance they will be creating for residents in bedrooms that will be directly facing bright floodlights. Not only are financial interests clearly at play,but information regarding this project has not been shared in an open and clear fashion from the very beginning of this proposal. This is why we,the residents of Antigua, started a petition directed at our Council members which has about 300 signatures from concerned citizens not only within the gates of Antigua,but surrounding neighborhoods as well. This is a community-wide concern.Weare urging City Council,the Planning Commission, and the City of Chula Vista's Planning Department to consider all the negative ramifications Titan Storage will have on our local safety, dangerous traffic impacts on elementary and high school students,property values, and the overall community environment. When searching on the City of Chula Vista's eZoning for the address provided, 1228 Eastlake Parkway,the parcel is designated and zoned Residential(NOT Commercial).It is within the Eastlake H Planned Community, zoned PC40S3. CUP 16-0030"Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard"on a vacant lot within the SDG&E right of way in the Eastlake 11 SPA. Project description:The site is within the Open Space District and has a General Plan designation of Residential Medium-High(RMM. The notices residents received stated, "The permit shall be considered without a public hearing unless a hearing is requested by the applicant or other affected party by the comment deadline." This is false. This matter must be up for public hearing because as stated in regulations only the matters described below are eligible to be authorized without a public hearing. Since Titan Storage does in fact involve the construction of"other substantial improvements to the property in question" a public hearing needs to be held. - 54 - if a final_decision rs not made today,not only are we legally entitled to subsequent public hearings,we deserve and demand them. 19.14.030 Zoning Administrator—Actions authorized without public hearing. The Zoning Administrator is authorized to consider and to approve,disapprove or modify applications on the following subjects,and/or issue the following required permits wrthoutsettmgtetmetter for a public hearing: A.Conditional Use Permit.The Zoning Administrator shall be empowered to issue conditional use permits,as defined herein,in the following circumstances: .. Where the use to be permitted does not nvolve the construction of a new building or:othersubstant►al strQ gl improvements on the property�ri question; Further inconsistencies and direct zoning violations by Titan Storage are outlined below. -e- 01Y 1 �€�� h€cuf; e � � SECTION 11.RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS In addition to the objectives outlined in Section 1.0(Purpose and Scope),the Residential Districts are included in the 11.0 Purpose Planned Community District Regulations to achieve the following purposes: • — To reserve appropriately located areas for family living at a broad range of dwelling unit densities consistent with the General Plan and with sound standards of public health,safety and welfare; • — To ensure adequate light,air,p rivacy and open space for each dwelling; • — o mmim[ze traffiic congestion and avordrthe overCoadmg of publicsennces and utilities by preventing construction of buildings of excessive bulk or number in relation to the land area around them; • Toprotect resrdenttat properties from nose,iliummation,unsig6tUness odorssmolceandTo�Iier object�onabie�nfCuerices and, • — To facilitate the provision of utility services and other public facilities commensurate with anticipated population, dwelling unit densities and service requirements. _- e ar € edeaiet €��ii V.2 Permitted and Conditional Uses.Quasi-Public Facilities(PQ), The following uses shall be permitted uses where the symbol"P"appears and shall be permitted uses subject to a Conditional Use Permit where the symbol"C"appears. Uses where the symbol"A"appears shall be subject to an - 55 - Administrative Review.Uses where the symbol"N"appears are not permitted.Uses where the symbol"a"appears are only permitted as an accessory use to a basic permitted use. Land Use PQAgriculture-Interim AArboreta(horticultural garden)P Christmas tree sales A Church/Religious Institution P Church related schools C Club, lodge,fraternal organization A Community Facility P Crops,Field N Fruit and vegetable stands C Grading and Infrastructure improvements P incidental Concessions A Parks and Recreation Facilities P Public and Quasi-public uses P Temporary tract signs and offices A Utilities(public and private)P Senior Care and recreation P Day Care Facilities a.Rec'reation,In profit,such as ball feldsl l? 1. Subject to the requirements outlined in Section 19.48.040(B)(6)(d)CVMC. UF_11cern me occpafronsa11oeQ.Ztaes "io� 11>Ecle axa�erhallUee�o _-" - -x� p VI.1 Home Occupations A. Home occupations may be permitted only when in compliance with the conditions listed herein.A permit must be issued by the Director of Planning prior to operation of such use.The fee shall be in accordance with the Master Fee Schedule. There shall be no stock in trade or exterior storage of materials in the conduct of a home occupation. A home occupation shall be conducted entirely within a dwelling;!fin an attached or a detached garage,it shall not impede the use of said garage for vehicle storage. Electrical or mechanical equipment which creates visible or audible interference in radio or television receivers or causes fluctuations in lint voltage outside the dwelling unit,shall be prohibited. Only the residents of the dwelling unit may be engaged in the home occupation.There shall be no sale of goods on the premises. The establishment and conduct of a home occupation shall not change the principal character or use of the dwelling unit involved. 7.There shall be no signs other than those permitted bythis ordinance. 8.The required residential off-street parking A home occupation shall not create vehicular or pedestrian traffic in excess of that which is normal for the land use district in which it is located. _ 9 Na�eh�cles tCOr oilers(including p[ck�ap-€cks grid vans)or con�rs miction o_r_o��er equipr�ien�;exceptti�has normally mcieental•to resident�a}use,shall fie:kept on the.sites V12 Recreational Courts Construction of recreation courts includingnecessary fencing and fighting, —gib` �"Z' ry g maybepermittedsubIfect�o �drrnnistrative rev�ewrand a�n�frig that adjacent proper�ies�,v�Il dot be unduly afFec�ed: Recreation courts shall meet the following minimum standards: 1. A maximum 20-foot high fence(measured from the finished grade of the court)shall be allowed. Fences shall include a screening material which screens the court activity from off-site view and which improves the appearance of the fence. 2. Setbacks for the court shall be:Side yard:10 feet Rear yard: 10 feet 3. Maximum of eight(8)lights permitted,height not to exceed 22 feet.All lights and light fixtures shall be certified by a qualified lighting engineer to: 1. Be designed,constructed, mounted and maintained such that,the light source is cut off when viewed from any point five(5)feet above the ground measured at the lot line. 2. Be designed, constructed, mounted and maintained such that the maximum illumination intensity measured at the wall of any residential building on abutting property shall not exceed 2 foot candle above ambient levels. - 56 - 3. Be used between 7.00 a m and 10:00 p.hi. 4. The surface area of any recreational court shall be designed,painted,colored and/or textured to reduce the reflection from any light incident thereon. S. Landscaping shall be installed as required between the fence and the property line. Other considerations/concerns we are bringing forward include: 1. The need for updated speed/traffic surveys along Eastlake Parkway. These are legal requirements as well.Elementary school students walk along this road every morning and afternoon get to and from school and teens and their parents also use this as the main access to Eastlake High School. It is already a heavily trafficked two-lane road that simply cannot handle the comings and goings of large RVs. 2. Crime. It is not news that there has been a steady in in crime in the Eastlake community with no more police being assigned to our side of the city. Criminals know our patrols are few and have taken full advantage by breaking into our horses, vehicles, stealing packages from our front doors, etc. No satellite station is slated to be built out in the Eastern side of the City,yet the population continues to increase due to City measures and developments that are allowed to pass building out every last stretch of land.An RV site such as the one proposed would be a perfect breeding ground for illicit activities, a perfect hideout for potential child predators right next to our schools, and would attract even more homeless that are already located right up Eastlake Parkway by Walmart.We wouldhope that along v nth the aforementioned crimes,Trtolent crises do not become much more prevalent affecting our young children and teens who attend Olympic View Elementary and Eastlake High School. The bottom line is legal requirements/zoning regulations must be followed by all applicants and financial gain should NOT tale precedence over the well-being of our community. Signed, Giselle Murray, a concerned resident And the neighbors of Antigua at Eastlake - 57 - I i i I Oscar Romero From: Baffico,Chris <CBaffico@semprautilities.com> Sent: Tuesday, March 12,2019 5:06 PM To: Oscar Romero Cc: frank@otayrealestate.com Subject: 1228 Eastlake Parkway,APN (643-380-06-00) -Case.-CUP16-0030 To whom it may concern, I wanted to take this opportunity to comment on the proposed RV&Storage facility at 1228 Eastlake Parkway. I'm a homeowner at Eastlake of Antigua and to be honest, I hadn't heard about the project until a few months ago. Although I had many concerns in the beginning, I realize now that I may have had a knee jerk reaction. In. participating in an open forum(Nextdoor app)it allowed me to see both points of view on.the matter. I took the opportunity to meet with Frank Ohrmuud,the project developer, and found that he was very professional, transparent, and willing to hear all of my concerns and answer all of my questions.It wasn't until I found myself needing storage,that I found that the majority of storage facilities were at full capacity and had waiting lists.As I understand,this project has been in the works for at least a couple of years, and the time to discuss mitigation of concerns was certainly welcomed at that time. It is my belief that Frank would have been more than happy to include within his proposal actions to resolve in a neighborly way any concerns brought forth. I believe that this project will satisfy a need for storage in the area and it is my hope that the business will be open to any concerns that may arise as a result of a storage facility next to Eastlake of Antigua. Respectfully, Chris Baffico 619-917-7873 Get Outlook for iOS - 58 - 1 March 11, 2019 Oscar Romero,Pro ect Manager Development Services Department Public Services Building = 276 Fourth.Avenue Chula `v=ista, C_& 91915 Re: Case Number CUP16-0030 Site Address:1228 Eastlake Paelway -- A P i�T ( -380-06-00) _ Dear i_Vir. Romero, Thank you for allowing us to submit our concerns. -My husband and I are Resident's of Antigua Eastla :-e and we are STRONGLY opposed to a Recreational Storage FacMty,being located next to Antigua and the schools. For buying a home,Antigua wasfis a nice affordable area and quieter than a lot of the areas we previously looked at. All of our purpose f©r choosing Antigua, as the place to buy a home,-wC go down the drain if a Recreational Storage Facility is allowed neat door ley husband and I worked and saved too long for our dream home and investment to be squashed by someone else's financial benefice It is a known fact that real estate prices will drop if this is allowed.We sure would not have even looked to buy-a home here if we drove by and saw a Storage Facility next door. Who wants to live right next to a Recreational Facility that will enhance traffic noise,vehicle pollution, and an unpleasant haven that would affect people living here,in the surrounding area and the schools.I have a background in Public Health as well as working with schools and youth programs and this definitely would put our children at higher tisk for easy exposure to: Illicit drug use and selling,illicit.activities,predators,for selling and buying alcohol,came,increased traffic,increase accidents that include students and other pedestrians. I am asking that you put yourself and loved ones in our shoes. Can you honestly say that it would not affect yore? Sincerely, Carol u and Chris Anderson 1205 Cabezas Cove .`8 - 59 - Re: Case number: CUP16-0030 Site Address: 1228 Eastlake Parkway, APN (643-380-06-00) Planning Commission of the City of Chula Vista, CA 276 Fourth Ave, Chula Vista, CA 91910 We are contacting you today regarding the proposed project for an RV storage facility on the property between Antigua Eastlake Townhouses and Eastlake High School. 1. We strongly object to the development of this RV storage facility in this location. My husband and I are residents in the Antigua Eastlake Townhouse community. We understand that the area we live in is comprised of residential and commercial structures. But placing a RV storage facility in an easement next to a residence and school is concerning. Our concerns are: 1. Drop in our property value. 2. Intrusion of privacy for our community, especially for Antigua residents tha(face the proposed RV site area. 3. Not an ideal location for a storage yard. 4. Cramming a facility in an area with powerlines, gas and water lines. 5. Safety hazard for children and adults. This area has heavy foot traffic especially morning, during the day,school hours and the evening. 6. It is an high traffic area for vehicles exceeding the speed limit in this particular location. 7. The Chula Vista Police Dept. set up regular speed traps in front of the entrance to our community and write many tickets for the speeders in this particular area where the proposed site will be. 8. No stop sign, or traffic light,lights on sidewalk or street/sign indicating there is a business in the easement. 9. Future traffic accidents. 10. is crime a possibility? 11. An eyesore. This is a good neighborhood. 1 understand the owner wants to make money, but at who's expense? The only one who will benefit is the property owners, not the residents in the area or children in neighboring schools. Thank you. Eddy and Carletfa Coleman 1206 Aruba Cove Unit 2, Chula Vista, CA 91915 - 60 - This email is to let you know my opposition to the construction of the Recreational Yard Storage, next to my community:Antigua at Eastlake. This neighborhood already has to deal with all the traiiic of the schools around it, especially the high school. But either than that it's a peaceful and quiet neighborhood. Building a storage yard next to it will attract more tragic, noise and vandalism all day long. Therefore, as a home owner I completely disagree with the project of the Recreational Storage Yard by my neighborhood. Thank You. Blanca Leos, 2039 Azure Cove Unit B, Chula Vista CA 91919. — 61 — To whom it may concern, I am writing this letter to express my objection toward the Titan R.V. Storage facility that has been oppressed upon us and is expected to be built right next to our home. I also would like to express some frustration,anger, helplessness, and fear that I feel this has brought upon my family and I as well.First let me explain my frustration, I am frustrated because when we bought our first home here we were not only buying a home but we were investing in our future.We were not only purchasing a home but a lifestyle, an experience. It was not just the home it was the neighborhood,the schools,the shopping centers, the well-manicured landscape, the distance away from the industrial area, and the potential for growth that compliments its residents. This is what that we were investing in when we bought our home,we never agreed to this disruption and the negative consequences that will result if it is allowed to be built next to us. I am angry. I am angry because our expectations were so high when we purchased our first home.We were excited and anxious to start our new life here in Eastlake.This is where we were going to raise our kids,we thought, as we were handed the keys to our very first home. We thought we had bit the lotto with the affordability in a neighborhood such as this. You see,I joined the Navy to live the American Dream,to own a home, and raise a family in a decent neighborhood because I was raised by parents who were not homeowners and I wasn't raised in an area as nice as this. I lived in New York City and I understand firsthand how much an area can influence your upbringing. This is the neighborhood I choose AS IT IS and many other servicemen who have done the same. I feel helpless,I feel helpless because these expectations I feel are being taken right out from underneath me and I feel powerless to do anything about it. This is not what I had volunteered in the service of my country for. I joined to protect the constitution and democracy for the citizens of this great nation.Now I am one of those citizens asking that democracy work for me. I feel fear, I feel fear because I am afraid of the negative consequences that this facility will bring. I fear that it will blemish our neighborhood,that it will bring down our property value, and that it will bring an unwanted presence to our beautiful community and our children_ Lastly I would like to leave you with this,imagine that this was being done to you in your neighborhood right next door to you,how would you feel? Thank you for the opportunity to express my concerns I hope this has made an impact for my family and the families of my community as well. Regards, The Guerreri Family 1205 Cabezas Cove 7 — 62 — a ' . Re: case number CUP16-0030 application for Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard To whom it may concern: I have been a resident home owner at Antigua for almost 20 years and I am strongly opposed to building the proposed storage facility based on concerns for safety, noise, traffic, and loss in property values. Our community population is relatively quiet and it is a pretty ideal living area but we already get a lot of noise echo from within and from around our community. Trucks coming and going to and from the storage facility will cause a major disruption for our hardworking family oriented community.This will be even worse during the construction process and traffic will bottle neck and be hazardous in the Eastlake school zone both during and after construction. A storage facility would also bring a transient population coming and going with vans and trucks which adds a dangerous element to Eastlake high school students and the many pedestrians in our community. I would ask that anyone viho wants a storage facility in their backyard to raise their hand. No takers? Of course no one would request a storage facility.be built`literally' in their backyard. This will drastically impact our property values. I bought a home in a beautiful neighborhood that you are proposing to make an industrial style setting. It's very upsetting. Thank you for your time and attention. Anna MacDonald 1165 Latigo Cove Chula Vista. CA 91915 — 63 — 1 To whom it may concern Our little four-lane Eastlake Parkway hosts both a Wal-Mart Super store and shopping center and a large high school.There are already certain times of day and certain times of year where It`s difficult to enter or leave our housing complex.Adding a storage center and drawing additional tragic really isn't what this area needs. The developers might also consider the number of parents who will inevitably use their storage facility as school drop-off/pick-up space as they use our street entrance on Tripani Cove. I'm especially wary of having a public space with easily accessible storage options right next to both Eastlake High School and Olympic View Elementary School. I feel like that's a safety concern that's worth considering. Nathaniel MacDonald 1165 Latigo Cove Chula Vista, CA 91915 — 64 — Resident Written Opposition b - _ From: Nicole Henley(nicole oliviai @yahoo.com) 3 --^ To: notmyantigua@yahoo.com Bate: Monday. March 11,2019,3:51 PM PDT Hello Everyonel Sorry I gilt not be able to attend the meeting on Wednesday but I v+rill provide a written statement Below To whom it may concern I am a resident who lives directly behind in what%would be the possible storage yard With this being said, I am completely opposed to this being built.Not only wrill it be an eye sore, but also jvill depreciate the value of our homes,brim unwanted visitors/chime into our backyard,bring a disturbance of noise and light,and give us absolutely no privacy.We bought this home Mth the excitmeni of nobody living behind us,and nv v with this possible storage yard m family disappointed and uer y 1y is very behind us would even be an roptia Peas rake into consideration ofaces in the chula Eho�v this storage age or this to bya dlwn�ii affect so t�ariy families lot and deny the application. , Respectfully- Nicole espectfullyNicole H_/Eduardo 1_.. Antigua Resident Son:from .`ahooMil onandroid i i — 65 — Re: case number CUP 16-0030 application for Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard To who, it may concern: I have been a resident home owner at Antigua for almost 20 years and I am strongly opposed to building the proposed storage facility based on concerns for safety, noise, traffic, and loss in property values. Our community population is relatively quiet and it is a pretty ideal living area but we already get a lot of noise echo from within and from around our community. Trucks coming and going to and from the storage facility will cause a major disruption for our hardworking family oriented community.This will be even luvorse during the'construction process and traffic will bottl-- neck and be hazardous in the Eastlake school zone both during and after construction. A storage facility would also bring a transient population coming and going-with vans and trucks which adds a dangerous element to Eastlake high school students and the many pedestrians in our community. I would ask that anyone who wants a storage facility in their backyard to raise their hand. No tapers?0f course no one would request a storage facilitry be built`literally; in their back yard. This will drastically impact our property values. I bough_a home in a beautiful neighborhood.that you are proposing to make an industrial style setting. It's very upsetting. Thank you for your time and attention. Anna MacDonald 1165 Latigo Cove Chula Vista.CA 0101.5 �r W. " -- - 66 — Written Opposition From: Blanca Guzman(blencadelem@h&Lmait..com) To: notmyantigua@yahoo.com Date: Monday, March 11,2019,7.55 AM PDT This email is to let you know my opposition to the construction of the Recreational Yard Storage,next to my community: Antigua at Eastlake.This neighborhood already has to deal %Mth all the traffic of the schools around it,specially the high school. But either than that at a peaceful and quiet neighborhood. Building a storage yard next to it will attract more tra-T noise and vandalism all day long-Therefore as a home owner I completely disagree with the project of the Recreational I'c Storage Yard by my neighborhood. Thank You. Blanca Leos. 2039 Azure Cove Unit 8, Chula Vista C.A91915. Sent from my I[Phone fir- 5 ;TU -67 - Subjecc Case number CUP 16-003 3 ;.: Leoxna, -Coleman, Caiiettaa 1<c rleiia.l.leonard cCtem u�t�lm... 1:"8 PI 1{�hoFaIs ago} to oror,1ero@chuia`0s; oc.go ,Eddy Coleman.,rfoi)n£b3�'Qglna�i.Cor Y—11 aee v;'-'-�w3=-ata at ,«_ad:;mgssag> i=as`r==91 Cakb3':{'st li46i- -� a-.,: ad t=„s- e;��`a. _ Good Afternoon Mr. Romero, --_` Re:Case number:CUP IC-0030 ;--P Site Address:1998 Eastlake Parkway,APP 0-380-00-001 Planning Commission of the City of Chula Vista,CA . 76 Fourth Ave,Chula Vista, CA 91910 g We are contacting you today regarding the proposed project for an RV storage€acilry on the property be ineen Antigua Eastlake Townhouses and Eastlake High School. ' We strongly object to the development of this RV storage fadlity in this location- My husband and l are residei-1ts hi the Antigua Eastlake Townhouse community. We --_ understand that the area we live in is comprised of residential and commercial structures- But placing a RV storage€acility in an easement next to a residenca and school is concerning. - Our concerns are: =- 1.Drop in our property value. _- 2. Intrusion of, privacy for our community,especially for Antigua residents that face the proposed RV site area. 3.Not an ideal location for a storage yard_ 4.Cramming a facility in an area with powerlines,gas and water Ilres. ------- 5.Safety hazard for children and adults.This area has heavy foot traffic especially morning,during the day,school hours and the evening. 6. It is an high traffic area lbr vehicles exceeding the speed limit in this particular location. 7.The Chula Vista Polite Dept_set up regular speed traps in front of the entrance to our community and write many tickets for the speeders in this particular area where the proposed site will be. 8. No stop sign,or traffic light, lights on sidewalk or street/sign indicating there is a business in the easement. 9. Future traffic accider ts. 10. Is crime a possibil!W. 11. An eyesore. — 68 — se numbe-r. UP16-0030 12-9'3 Ea��uf`-�OKe fark-WaY.,APN6A 3-363M Planning Co-,nmf:sSIO.-,of the Cily Of Chula Vista,Cj& -h Av% 27-6'Fourf hula VICA �qq 10 sta A VV,8,s-re contacVptoday reW.ding te p-,,o j-sed pr- _q YOL. 0 t�'3 Prc)P-':'�LY Ant-agua. Easalake Q TI Vve S tron-cily d-`ebPM efllt-of this RV storage MY hus- 4 and I arero ids Eastlake T understand ihat the, area wet�,fe is con-,,�, -Sad of res� 8trIL-1-Otmes-B-,4 pla-cing a RV-storage:;-jbcqIi;t,-v an �Chccd is r-�-erninq. DrOP� r,& 011- 2 Im Of Ntaq IIxIs7 PT y fbr,="c"-mm-I-n-RY,,e-S-PO-cialffy Tur Ar PM-POSed RV site ama, 3- -a n- We a!10 0 at-b r,f-6 r z s tOrf ag e Ya r d, aa mm, ing a fzatty in an area M-m po"-V, ha�- d for d'Oldren and a&tlfts T is area has tie, -9t dII-*19 the dam- �- - hmi tn 't 1&:aq MUh VAC amaf or vc-hic—le-o1 M-e-ding the mph 7 -All-- pOEM D_Sr Ip re ap un and wale-manick Proposed she v MR be Y, etslort; espeeder its No ztqp s� trant c V--g�,T buOine---z 44 theca. - the c re tra-r-ft 9- Futu accident5, 1 D 0, Is cr jnf-m a POSSIbIlIv? A..q-ey a good ne€-ibOthOI3d-, I Under-tendthe,o�"x er 2US, wh�s ex pense'i T M- -()afy On a WI10 mm hone rL is pro, men in SGhG-_, md nelo, bo Tf mnk yotf. Eddy and Ca- letta Colama-r,, 1206 AFUba Cove Unft 2,Chub CA 91915 -69 - From: Ciselle Murray Re; CUP16-0030 Fran Orhmund, Tien Storage meq' IL ii ism — 70 - `cfcren 13,2019 ,t Planning Depart--Mt: �T t7 1.S�hi�'yn 4T3 S'"i 3�bxs.:' 7-Sim i...o i 1.C+�vlfl l City�v4p '1V . L S.o the Gty O C-hdR ---- b When doing a simple Google search for, '`Why do zoning regulations exist?"the answer is evident and applies to cases exactly like Titan Storage. "To achieve this purpose,zoning laws regulate the impacts of land use that may not be in the best interests of the people,generally including such things as:Protecting the value.and enjoyment of properties by separating incompatible land uses and minim Ez n their potentially negative impacts upon each other." Titan Storage not only-would take away from our property values,-which we are desperately trying to protect,and enjoyment of our homes and neighborhoods,but is also in complete violation and LEG�LkLLy incompatible for where they plan on locating,the hours they plan on operating,and the noise and light nuisance they-rill be creating for residents in bedrooms that will be directly facing bright floodlights. Not only are financial interests clearly at play,but information regardingpthispproject has not been shared in an open and clear fashion from.the very beginIl g of �Proposal. This is why we,the residents of Antigua, started a petition directed at our Council members which has about 300 signatures from concerned citizens not only wifffiin the gates of Antigua,but surrounding neighborhoods as well.We are urging City Council,the Planning Commission, and the City of Chula Vista's Planning Department to consider allthe negative ramifications Titan Storage will have on our local safety, dangerous traffic impacts on elementary and high.school students,property values,and the overall community environment. When searching on the City of Chula Vista's eZoning for the address provided, 1228 Eastlake A ,aA,-ti OT Commercial).It is-within the Park-ray,the parcel is des;gnated and zoneu Res=��_�{N Eastlake 11 Planned Community,zoned PC40S3. CUP 16-0030"Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard"on a vacant lot within the SDG&E right of way in the Eastlake II SPA deslgp_at�on of� eiip�ace l � das a €ionhh Project descrfp wt The feral flan notices resident received stated,"The permit shall be considered without a public hearing unless a hearing is requested by the applicant or other af-Bected party by the comment deadline.'- This eadline. -This is false. This matter must be up for public hearing because as stated in regulations only the matters described below are eligible to be authorized without a public hearing. Since Titan Storage does in fact involve the construction of"other substantial improvements to the property in question" a public hearing needs to be held. - 71 - 39.14.030 ZoringAdministrator-Actions authorized without public bearing. The Zoning Administrator is authorized to consider and to approve,,disapprove_orlmodifapplications onthe + following subjects,and/or issue the f ollowing required permits sstt�ng t,r ir�a�rer.ror a pubs ROW; A=Conditional Use Permit.The Zoning Adminisrator shall be empowered to issue conditional use permits,as defined herein,in the following circumstances: v(here the useto'hd peri irtnc3 dins nab involve he`cons':' tr_10 o a sev buil art Tl}cT stiE�s h�rai strurturaj 1p�oveans ort the FraP? Y to questii ii _. Furffier inconsistencies and direct zoning violations by Titan Storage are outlined below. ecic�irtelouc€ € aseF ems S ECT ION il.RES1DIENTIAL DISTRICTS In addition to the objectives outlined in Section 1.0(Purpose and Scope),the Residential Districts are included in the 1I'.0 Purpose Planned Community District Regulations to achieve the following purposes: - To reserve appropriately located areas for family living at a broad range of dwelling unit densities consistent with the General Plan and with sound standards of public health,safety and welfare; - To ei�v�re adequat¢lt�rr,asr,�riv�ty and open space for each dwAil,ng, and utilities by preventing construction of buildings or excessive bulk or number in relation to the land area around there; t� s _ To aratetit resiciei c pra{ rgesrri elorse �ilurr�tEan anszgislrrts,cedar..{sink{ and �hes aectionabla�rtfluenees and, -J To facititatethe provision of utility services and other public facilities commensurate with anticipated population,dwelling unit densities and service requirements. V.2 Permitted and Conditional uses.,Quasi-Public Facilities(PQ),The following uses shall be permitted uses where the symbol"P"appears and shall be permitted uses subject to a Conditional Use Permit where the symbol"C"appears.Uses where the symbol"A"appears shall be subject to an Administrative Review.Uses where the symbol"N"appears are not permitted.Uses where the symbol"a"appears are only permitted as an accessory use to a basic permitted use. - 72 - Land use PQ Agriculture-Interim A Arboreta(horticultural garden)P Christmas tree sales A Church/Religious institution P Church related schools C Club,lodge,f sternal organization A Community Facility P Crops,Field N Fruit and vegetable stands C Grading and Infrastructure Improvements iprovements P incidental Concessions A Partes and Recreation Facilities P Public and Quasi-public uses P Temporary tract signs and offices A utilities(public and privates P Senior Care and recreation P Day Care Facilities a Recre� ion,no profit,such as ball f alds .P Subject to the requirements outlined in Section 19.48.040(E)(5)(d)CVMC n€ ercimeecu afIaed €Rs fa�esl`ice4rlrlehaIept tt1.1 Home occupations A. Home occupations may be permitted only when in compliance with the conditions listed herein.A permit must be issued bythe Director of Planning prior to operation of such use.The fee shall be in accordance with the Master Fee Schedule. There shall be no stock in trade or exterior storage of materials in the conduct of a home occupation. I A home occupation shall be conduced entirely within a dwelling;if in an at=tached or a detached garage,it shaft not impede the use of said garage for vehicle storage. Electrical or mechanical equipment which creates visible or audible interference in radio or television receivers or causes fluctuations in lint voltage outside the dwelling unit,shall be prohibited. Only the residents of the dwelling unit may be engaged in the home occupation.There shall be no sale of goods on the premises. The establishment and conduct of a home occupation shall not change the principal character or use of the dwelling unit involved. 7.There shall be no signs other than those permitted by this ordinance. S.The required residential off-street parking A home occupation shall not create vehicular or pedestrian traffic in excess of that which is normal for the land use district in which It is located 9a veh�efes ortr �►yrsrnlud�ng pick u trucker and vans cifstructibrr carstt��r efpmentxelit€E€sa tt.a'�y_ClLidcrtt��;ttt f S!'��'1•s.��.-�se,.sha�be k�At or the;site' .~ .-' - V1.2 Reereaflo al costs Construction of recreation courts,including necessary fencing and lighting,ma}r bep2rrrrtied srTeo fnin3stratve revieyv anal a frndrrfg hatd� cent:p,epnraasx}tnoE be unduly affectec- Recreation courts shall meet the following minimum standards: 1. A maximum 20-foot high fence(measured from the finished grade of the court)shall be allowed.Fences shall include a screening material which screensthe court activity from elf-site view and which improves the appearance of the fence. 2. Setbacks for the court shall be:Side yard:10 feet Rear yard:10 feet 3. Maximum of eight(8)lights permitted, height not to exceed 22 feet.All lights and light fixtures shall be certified by a qualified lighting engineer to: 1. Be designed,constructed,mounted and maintained such that,the light source is cut off when viewed from any point five(5)feet above the ground measured at the lot fine. 2. Be designed,constructed,mounted and maintained such that the maximum illumination intensity measured at the wall of any residential building on abutting property shall not exceed 2 foot candle above ambient levels.. - _ ci€tn � adrltfrQfa € € Q 3. Be used between 7:GGa.ri:and 10>OO'.rn.. - 73 - 4. The surface area of any recreational court shall be designed,painted,colored and/or textured to reduce the reflection from any light incident thereon. 5. Landscaping shall be installed as required between the fence and the property fine. C�aer considerations we are bringing forward include: L . The need for updated speed/traffic surveys along Eastlake Parkway. These are legal requirements as well.Elementary school students walk along this road every nsorning and afternoon to get to and from school and teens and their parents also use this as`the main access to Eastlake I-ligh School. It is already a heavily trafficked two-lane road that simply cannot handle the comings and goings of large RVs. 2. Crime.It is not news that there has been a steady increase in crime in the Eastlake community with no more police being assigned to our side of the city. Criminals know our patrols are few and:have taken full advantage by breaking into our homes,vehicles, stealing packages from our front doors,etc. No satellite star on is slated to be built out in the Eastern side of the City,yet the population. continues to increase due to Cit,measures and developments that are allowed to pass building out every last stretch of land.An RV site such as the one proposed would be a perfect breeding ground for illicit activities, a perfect hideout for potential child predators right neat to o E,schools, and would attract even more homeless that are already located right up Eastlake Parkway by WalmmrL We would hope that along wdt'n the aforementioned crimes,violent crimes do not become much more prevalent affecting our young children and teens who attend Olympic View Elementary and Eastlake ugh School. The bot-tom line is legal requirements/zoning regu bans must be followed by all applicants and uncial gain should NOT take precedence over the well-being of ourcommunity. - 74 - Fr m: Sandie Conrady Re: CUP16-0030 Fran Orh Hund, Titan Storage �a 0 - 75 - Re: CU 16-0030, Titan Storage application Good evening members of the Planning Commission my name ii Sandra Conrady and I am a homeowner in the Antigua at Eastlake neighborhood. I would like to bring to your attention the number of Recreational Vehicle Storage Yards already operating in the Eastlake area. In my research I found that there are 12 recreational vehicle storage yards in commercial areas within a 10 mile radius of the Antigua neighborhood and none of these are-next to residential homes or schools. Therefore, I cannot comprehend that a recreational storage yard is be ing considered next to homes or schools and I am certain that r y neighbors who signed the petition have similar feelings. I submitted a copy of the petition wita my neighbor's signatures. then I bought my home 18 years ago, I would never have thought that there would be a possibility of look`ng at a recreational vehicle storage yard out of my front door and ivindows or high powered flood lights beaming thru nay Indoors from Gam to 1 apm, seven days a week. I would also never have imagined that I would.be here.standing in front of you, defending what I was planning as my retirement home, against what I see as someone else's uncial gain.. Thank you for listening to my concerns. - 76 - C;ER Re ipienta Stephen Padilla„ohn mrr-nn, !Mary Salas L etter: Greetings, Asa homeowner,! care about my communitf�and so do r iy neighluors. We are opposing the proposed storage yard between our commun4 and Eastlake High School being proposed by Titan Storage. Please see our concerns and consider our petition.We will be attending the nem formal city council meeting to voice our opposition. _ 77 _ Signatures Sarah Orozco Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 .. .. .... . .. Silvia Olivarria San Diego,CA : 2019-01-10 Samuel Offivarria Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Armando Orozco Chula Visa,CA 2019-01-10 Gise le Murray Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ..... .......... .......... . . ... . .. ... .. .... . . .. ..... .. . .... . ............. ........ .... Patrick Murray Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ................ .... Stephanie Romero = Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-14 Carolyn Anderson Chula Vista, CA 2419-01-14 Yonathan Solornon Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 Carletta Coleman Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 . . . . . .... ... ... . . .. Leah Hurtado Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-lo ........:. ..... ..... .. Yoana Perez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 ......... .. I......... _.......... Karen Moreno San Diego, CA : 2019-01-10 Israel Avalos Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jackie Alien Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ..... ... ........ .... Ted Owens Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-1 o ..... . . .... .. .. ....... . .......................... .. .. .. . . ..... .. ... Sharon Arnora Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Carmen Berurnen Chula Vista, CA 2019-41-10 Desiree Huynh Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Kristen Dobberteen Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 - 78 - N mea Location Sarah ieller-McC lemei�t C hula Vista, CA 2019-01-1 D Kelayna Schissler Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Zaida Alicea Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Eddy Coleman Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jennifer Hall Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 __......... ...._.. ... .. ............ _..... .... .. ... Yolanda Street Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 _. .................................... .. .... ...__....... . ._.. . ... . Maria McDuff Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ..... .. . .... . .......... . _..... . .. _ ... . . ... .. Maria Gonzalez Bonita, CA ' 2019-01-10 Marianne Bernaldo Chula Vista, CA : 2019-01-10 ..._...._..._.......... .... ........... ...... Favioia sancheZ Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Pavel Morales Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jessica Rivera Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jennifer Behr Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Ed Mcguire Chula vista, CA 2019-01-10 Nastassia Burke Los Angeles, CA 2019-01-10 Melba Gogue Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 Bizualem T adesse Dallas,TX 2019-01-10 _................. ...... ................ ....... .. ........ .. _-....._........ .................... .......................... . . ...... . __.. ... . Michael Mardn Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Dianne Olayvar Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Nichelle Carreon Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Ana Alvarado Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Arianna Gonzalez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 - 79 - ami Re Lct� ...Oa Kristine Armstrong = Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 . . ..... . .. . .. . .. ... ... .. .. Jessica Hernandez . ... Chula Vista, CA . . .. ......2019-01-10 . . . ...... .... . Debora Hayes Chu laVista, CA 2019-01-10 . . . .. ......... . ....... Angie nava Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Erinj .. .... ... .... ...... . .... ... ... .. . ac son Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10-Mi - ....... . . Cris Baco . . . . . . . San Diego, CA 2019-01-10 ....... ........ .. ................. re ecca thomase san di�go, CA 2019-01-10 ......... .. ..... ... .. Paula Za-valza : r ............. ... . . .. ..... _.. . . Thula Vista, CA : 2019-01-10 .............. ..... . . Ke cy Campbell Riverside, CA 2019-01-10 oerni Porilla Van Nuys, CA 2019-01-10 . ....... .. . . . . .... . am o.rl ett Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 .......................... ... . Marlene Ysi Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ...................... .............. .... Luis Lopez P Chula Vista CA 2019-01-10 Krystal Serrano ...`...... . .. . . � � Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 .._.... .......... . ... .... .... . ..................................... ... ...... . Sylvia Rosenberg Calgary, Canada 2019-01-10 . .. .... .. ..... Michelle Vicente Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 .......... .. Laura Lefebvre ... .. . Hacienda Heights, CA 2019-01-10 ...............I.........I...... .. ....._. . Steven Fenger : Chulalista, CA 2019-01-10 Chula' r wade cynthia La o,la, CA 2019-01-10 .. .. .............. .. . .... . ... ... . ...... .............. ............. Fola►ni Hickman Murrieta,CA 2019-01-10 Rebecca Colangelo Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 . . . ....... ....... ..... . .. ....... ... Dona Giron Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 - 80 - Yair Gersten Van buys; CA 2019-01-10 Silvia Masieri Chula Vista,CA 2019-0.1-10 Maria C:allico Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 Debra Wheeler Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Sonia Estrada Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Chelsey Moore San Diego, CA 2019-01-10 Michelle David Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Shanna bight Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 Miriam Palavicini Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 ............... _. _... . . .._.. ... ... .._...._ ....... .. . .. . Maria Turner Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 __. ....................... _ .. ..... . . . . Bertha Munoz Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 - . ............... . . .. . ._................ ....._.........................:........ .. Mar k--Valladolid Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Lee Daugherty Chula Vista,CA ` 2019-01-10 Onder Sengur Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 _ ........................... ... ............... ....... ... . ........ . . . _ ... . ..... . Sonja Glass Chula Vista, CA 201 9-01-10 Wade Page San Diego, CA 2014-01-10 Julie Hill Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 ..................._..... ................................... . .. ............. ............ .............._.... ......._........_.._.._-.. .. .... . . ......-. ...._..... .. ... Aletha Loftfield Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Maya Bloch Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jonathan David Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-10 Susan Shean-zeballos riverside, CA 2019-01-10 Francisco Medrano Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 -81 - a Robert Mitchell Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-10 Jim MILLIMAN Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 . ... ..... . . . ....... Ricardo Aguirre-gamboa Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Christopher Guerred East Lake, Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 ............ Clarissa Sasa San Diego, CA 2019-01-11 Steven Elliott : San Diego, CA 2019-01-11 ... ....... .. . . ............ . . . Clete Strausbaugh : Chula Vista, CA : 2019-01-11 Oliver Lisama Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 ....... ... Pedro Machuca Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-1 i Ericka Martinez : Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 labee Gomez Chula Vista, CA : 2019-01-11 .................................... . nhi nguy e?n Chula Vista, CA ; 2019-01-11 .............. . . .. ...- .. ....... .-_.. ... ....... � 2019-01- ......._. ............................. .. . .. Candace Thrower ower Chula Vista, CA - 11 Joe Garcia Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 .......-.... .... .... ........_... . Lavern Zisko Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 . .. ...... .. ........... .. . ...... Ignacio Aguilar Van Nuys,CA 2019-01-11 Alfonso Alvarado Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Gerry Bushnell Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Cindell Smigmator Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Miguel Esparza Chula Vista, CA : 2019-01-11 Miguel Pirnentel Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 . .. ... .. .... . .. .... . Nicole Henley Chula vista, CA 2019-01-11 - 82 - ame 4 ui� Daniela Ovalle Berkeley, US 2019-0;-11 Laura Alvarado 1101 Latigo Cove unit 5, CA 2019-01-11 Cruz Alvar ado Chula Vista, CA : 2019-01-11 Trudy Bohm Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Steve Lindgren La Habra, CA _ 2019-01-11 ..... . . _ ..._... ..... Leann Armando Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 David Moreno Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Christian Ortiz Chula Vista,CA ` 2019-01-11 _. _ .. .. Felipe mercado Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 ........ ... . _... . .._. .. .. _........... ._. .. ... ._..._........... . .. ._.......... . Steven Smigmator Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Veronica Marquez Chula vista,VA 2019-01-11 _... .... . .............. . ..._......_...._................... .. ................ ... ... ............................................................................-. .._._...... ..... John Zee Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 .......... ... ...... .. ... . . ...... ...._.. . . _ ...............__....... - ...., ........._. Traci Walker Chula vista, CA 2019-01-11 Eduardo Lizarr aga Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Marienn Alvarado Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Claudia Medina = Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 .... ............. ........._. .. ... ...... ........_ ...... .... _... .... ........ ............._. Amy Childers Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 _......... ................ ... .............. ... ... .............. .... .......................... ..._....__ _..... . . _.................. ..... ... ..... ... Antonio Albano Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 _. .. . ..... ..... .. ...._..... Sue Hekman Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Leonel Gutierrez San Diego, CA 2019-01-11 _... _. ....-...... .. . . .................. ............. . ...... ......... ...... . . ._ Amy Mss! Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Andrew Pantoja San Diego, CA 2019-01-11 - 83- Name � Lo��t��n )Gate Jimmy Hayes Chula Vista, CA . 2019-01-11 - Cristina Portillo Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Any Aguilar Los Angeles, CA 2019-01-11 Rosio Escobar Chula Vista,CA 201 1.9-07-11 Barbara Ibarra Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 ... .. ........................... ..... ...... Veronica Espinoza Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 ...... ... Veronica Castaneda = Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 ias a McCalicher Chula Vista,CA ` 2019-41-11 . .. ... ............. ... ............................................ ......... . . .......... Joanne Stewart Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 ............................... . . . .. .................. .......... . . Justin Sorensen Yorktown, US 2019-01-11 ... ..:. ......... ..... ...... ...... ......... Cosette Ramirez chola vista, CA 2019-01-11 ........... .............. ..... Sandra Kam : Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 ........... .... ..... . Lourdrs Lopez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-71 ......... . ........ . . . atia Callahan Chula vista, CA 2019-01-11 ......... ............... . Daniel Perez Tijuana, Medco 2019-0--11 . .. ..... .. Suraya Nunez Chula Vista, Cts 2019-01-11 ..................... Julio Aispuro LongBeach, US 2019-01-11 ........ .... .................................................. . .................................... ......... ......................... Stephanie Beltran Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 = .............. ...... ......................... Sap 'Y = columbia, US 2019-07-11 .. .... . . . .. . Bray en Penn Wallingford, US 2019-01-11 .............. ...... ...... .... ........... . .... . Sunny D Atlanta, US 2019-01-11 . .......... .. .. .. ... .. . ........ ...... James Dubin Rockford US 2019-01-11 - 84 - LO Patricia Moriarty La Jolla, CA 2019-01-11 Andrew Almond Huntsville, US 2019-01-11 Tristen Cain Denham Springs, US 2019-01-11 Christine MacLeod Malden, MA 2019-01-11 Sam Krneyer Southfield, US 2019-01-11 Karen Wren Norman, US 2019-01-11 _._............. _. ........... . ..-....... ......... .. .. Margaret Witte = Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Anakin Shirley Orlando, US 2019-01-11 _.. . .._ _.. ..............-........ .._......._.......... . . ..._. Emma Adjasu Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-11 Victor Cortes Chula Vista, CA ' 2019-01-11 Lilia Maciejewski Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-11 Teresa Bristow Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-12 . ......................................... . ..... ........................... ..... ....-. Jose estenoz San Diego, US 2019-01-12 Jose Martinez Houlder, US 2019-01-12 __......_... - ......... ....... .............. .. ... ._. _...... ... ........ .......... ..._.... .. Erick Lopez Phoenix az, US 2019-01-12 _..._..._ . ... ...... ... . ......... ................ ... .. . . . .. _. . ......... ... .......... . ...... .. ... ..... . . .. . Krayshawn Norman Wichita, US 2019-01-12 Dillon Pirtle West Frankfort, US 2019-01-12 _........ ...... .. ... ... ... ..... __ ..... ..._. ..... ................._. .. ... .................. . ................ _ ... Citiali Torres Riverside, US = 2019-01-12 Sherine Mir Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 _ . .. _ . _. .. ..... ...... ... . . . ... .. ... . ......_...... .. _ ....:....... . . .._... Radhakrishna Kamath Roseville, US 2019-01-12 _ . ............... Alex Martinez San Jose,US 2019-01-12 Anthony Davis White Plains, US 2019-01-12 - 85 - Jonny Polarek San Diego, US 2019-01-12 Zach Zinner Monroe, US 2019-01-12 Robe—it Stevens Yakima, US 2019-01-12 John Paul Tamez Whittier, US 2019-01-12 ... .. .. . . . .. . . ... ... ......................_......................:. ....... ..-.. .... . ............ .. Nicole Marrujo Chula Vista, CA ` 2019-01-12 ......................-... .......... ... Birdy Michael Yulee, US 2019-01-12 _....... .......... _._..: .................._.... . ._......._. Zach Laliberte Exeter, US 2019-01-12 .. ..._.......... .._ .. Utkarsh Nath Fremont, US 2019-01-12 .......... . .. ..............._.._....._.........._.._._.._._.._......__...... .................... ................_ Paola Pena Arleta, US 2019-01-12 ......... . . ... ..... ......................................_.............................................. ..... ...... .. ...... Undie Brown Tempe, US = 2019-01-12 ..... . .... . ............... ........ ................ ... ... . .... Ashley Scheib Prince Frederick, US 2019-01-12 ................................................................................................................ Mariapaz Aquino Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 .----........................ ............._......... . Christina Martinez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 . . ......... .......................... . .... .................... ... ........ ..... . ... . .. Evelyn Rodriguez San diego, US 2019-01-12 ........................ ...... ...._...... .......-------------- .. . Gerald Chiles Chula Vista, CA = 2019-01-12 _. .... . ....... ................... Edsson Vargas : Houston, US 2019-01-12 ................................................. ......_........._... Caleb Husted The Colony, US 2019-01-12 ............ . .................._...................................._....:...................... Joseph Adcock Wylie, US 2019-01-12 ............... ...... ............. ....................:.. ..................... .... ...... .. ZacSchrader Burlington, US 2019-01-12 Carrie Barnes Fpo,AF 2019-01-12 ........_..................... ............................._...... Aaron Williamson Wayland, US 2019-01-12 . ........... .. .. .. Laura Cerveny Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 - 86 - Date Judd VIheeler Van Nuys, CA 2019-01-12 Katelynn Lettrnann Toledo, US 2019-01-12 Thaniai Shirley Hacienda Heights, CA 201.9-01-12 Suzanne Lajoie Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-12 P1lakaveli Jones El Paso, US 2079-01-72 ... ........ . .. . . . .._.. ............. ... _. .. ......- ...... . . . ... .. ........._.. ...... _ ._ .. Tyrek Browning Spartanburg, US 2019-01-12 Read English US 2019-07-12 .... ...... ... ..... ..... _. .......... ............ ..........-._............ ... .........._ ............. . ..... Logan Reiss Stafford Springs, US 2019-01-12 . ........... ........ ......._.. . -_.._.._............. ........... ................................ .. - .. .. ....._.. ...__................... ._....._............. . Jason Chi Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 .......... .....-.. ............._ ........ ....... . . ...... Destiny Summers Placentia, US -019-01-12 Adajisha Nesbitt Duncan, US 2019-01-12 _. .... .... . .. ............ _ _ .. ...................................... ... ..-......._ ... ..... ................ ...-. ............................ - ._.. ._.. .. ....... ... Colby Friedmann = Council Bluffs,US 2019-01-12 Sandra Conrady Chula Vista, CA = 2019-01-12 Amanda Gonzales Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-12 . . ............... ....................... ...... ........._.. .......-.. ....--......................... . . .. . .._...................._................................. ................ ........_. .-......... .... Ry l-n D-arker C. 'Vis-a f A �i�o nv a e..a a ate+...: L i t u i a 7€iJ l.�1 Lf'L Alexi Rabay San Diego, CA 2019-01-12 Bryan Chavez Los Angeles, US 2019-01-12 _ .. _ ...-. .... .......... .................. .. ..............._.- ............ ............-....... ... . ............ ..... . Angie Valencia Los Angeles, US 2019-01-12 _.. .............. .. .. ............ ... . .............. ... ... .... . .... ..... ... . .... .. ... ..._....... _- ..... .. . Bresley Wood Flint, US 2019-01-12 Anna MacDonald Chula Nista, CA 2019-01-12 _...... .. . . . .. _......... ............-...._......._................-...._.. - .... Destiny Stewart Plano, US 2019-01-12 sandra white Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 -87 - .:. . ... late . .......:... Josefina Chavez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 Lauren Chi Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 - Samantha 011 ,rarria Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 imora sims ` Union, US 2019-01-13 ayreAlzubaidee Brentwood, US 2019-01-13 . .. ... Tricia Smith : Rochester,SVA 2019-01-13 ...... . ............. .......... ... .... .............. . Lucas Perez = Wriument, US 2019-01-13 ......................... ... .. ._ ......... ... Rj Holliman Spartanburg, US 2019-01-13 . .............I........ .... . . . ...... ......... . ................ .. Alexis Duran San Bruno, CA 2019-01-13 Kimmie Nguyen : Grand Prairie, US 2019-01-13 ................................. ............._. _ Lorena Castillo : US 2019-01-13 .................................... ie Oflis Port Townsend, Us 2019-01-13 Manuel Esquivias : Los Angeles,, US 2019-01-13 . . ....................... .... . EricSchwartz Bronx, US 2019.01-13 .......... ..... ......... . Linda Young Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 ... .. .............. ... ... . .. .............. Mason Divita Littleton, US 2019-01-13... _... . . ................... .... ... ....... ... . .. ............. ........ Alicia Avilez ............... ...... .. .. . . Rowland Heights, US 2019-01-13 ............. ............................... . .. ............... jeremiah eionzales Howell, US 2019-01-13 ............. .. ..... . ........ .. ........... . grace gebbia New York, US : 2019-01-13 . . ........................... ...... ............... ... .. _ Anthony Thick : Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 ................ michelle Fuentes chula vista, CA 2019-01-13 ..... . .. ........... . . Abby Heart New York City, US 2019-01-13 - 88 - ieresa y'liliarns Houston,i} 2019-01-13 Tyrone Parker Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 Brittany Vi ray Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-13 jahir Ugarte Bronx, US 2019-01-13 Corey Pope Van Nuys,CA 2019-01-13 Kallie Harmon Hamilton,US 2019-01-14 Antonia Lopez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 _ ............. ..... . ............... ...... ......_. . ...... . Cathlee Conrady Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 ............ . ...... .. ............ ..... . ............_.. ..........._.... _-...__.................. . ....... .. .... .... joanie Pia Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 ..-....... -.............. ... .... ......_ . ... ... . _.....__._..-.. ... Manuel Pia Los Angeles, CA : 2019-01-14 grace Stanley Farmington, US 2019-01-14 ............................................ .................................... .... . . ..... ....... ......................... ......................... .... .. .._........ .._ _ ... Robert Ortiz San Francisco, US 2019-0 1-14 . .... ......... .. .......... ._.. . -....-... .-...-......_.. . ........ ..... ..... .......... ........ -......._... _..........- _ . .-..... Ana Simon Los Angeles, CA ` 2019-01-14 Andrew Gosselin Massachusetts, US 2019-01-14 _......._.... ...... ................................. ........ . victor mainwall Reseda, US 2019-01-14 Suresh Raman San Diego, CA 2019-01-14 .... .... .........I.......... .-... _ Nelda DuSay Petal, US 2019-01-14 Rafael Guerrero Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-14 Donovan Leonard Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-15 jeffrey Bennett Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-15 Ed Kanaya Scott Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-15 Elsa C Castaneda-K Chula vista ca, OR 2019-01-16 - 89 - aleYLOM roe Daze MICUEL LOPEZ Chula Vista, CA = 2019-01-16 Mariana Miller Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-16 ..... ..... . Antonia Flores Oklahoma City, OK 2019-01-16 . ...... . . . .... Talina Santos Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-16 .......... ................ . .. . ...._...,. . . . ............ .. ..... ... . .. Emillano Garcia : Palmdale, US 2019-01-16 ................... . Stephanie Balli : San Diego, CA 2019-01-16 Elia Jimenez Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-17 ....... ..........................__ ........ ........._.. _. . ..... ..... .. ..... Rebecca Manti = Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-17 ........................ .................... ....................... David Starr San Diego, CA 2019-01-17 ........................................._.. .. . Jonathan Boyne = Honolulu, US 2019-01-18 .... .... ............... ... . . . ..... ..... Isabella Conrady Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-19 ................... . . .. .........._...................................... .................................:................................... Renee Collier Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-19 __................ ...........:........................I......__..... _..... Vanessa Brinkman Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-19 Jaime Collier Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-19 Jeff Tabilln Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-19 Kayla Mains Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-19 - ...................... . .... . .. . .. Kamryn Dobbins San Diego, CA ' 2019-01-19 .. .................................................I.................. ..... Yolanda Esquer Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-20 ................... .. .......... ......... ...._... .................. ......... ... . ...... ... ...... S Rauch : IMPERIAL BEACH, CA 2019-01-20 ............. Anne Racquel Bacani Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-20 ....._........... ...................._....... .. ................ ._...... ..._....... Raghav Raj Bangalore,India 2019-01-20 .. .. ...... ....... .... ...... . .. Susan collier Chula Vista,CA - 2019-01-20 - 90 - N ire ti.on Melissa Minshew Binita, CA 2019-01-21 Esther Maciel Houston, US 2019-01-21 Eddie Minshew Gula Vista, CA 2019-01-22 Anitra Morgan Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-22 . Patricia Barajas Torres Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-22 Shannon Galama San Diego,CA : 2019-01-23 Jody Dalin Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-24 ... ................_... .__ .. .__..........._ ..._. .. ............. ................ ......._.............. .............._...................... ........ _ ... ... . . ...._.. Stephanie Reyes Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-24 _ ... . .. .......... ..._.._.........._.... .............:.. ..........._..... .. ........ ...................._...................-._..--.................... ............ ... .. .... .. .. ... Linda Bravo Chula Vista, CA 2019-01-25 Sylvia Bravo Chula Vista, CA ` 2019-07-25 Charmaine Gray Chula Vista,CA 2019-01-31 Sebastian Vazquez Sar! Carlos, CA 2019-02-01 ...............__...... _........_....................... .........--.... ......... - .. _........._...._....._..........._........... June Labrutto Philadelphia,US 2019-02-01 Karla Sanchez San Diego, CA 2019-02-09 ... . ........................................ .................... ...... ............. ...... ............. . Dennis ;fay Ci uIa N.4--...a, CA ......... ....... .......... ....... . Robert Ayers La Mesa, CA 2019-02-14 _...._... ..._. _..... .... ................. .......... .............. . ..................... ... ................ ... ..... Benjamen Thompson Gowrie, US 2019-02-14 Bobbie Keeling = NationaI City,CA 2019-02-15 . ............. .......... ... .... ... ... .......... ._. .. .... ... ... _ _. .......... ... ...._. .. ...... ......... ....... Carlyn Tripp = Chula Vista, CA : 2019-02-15 Kimberly Wade Malverne, US 2019-02-20 _... . .. .. .... . ..... ...._ _.._ ....... ............. ........_.. .._......._ ... . ............... .._. ........... .........__. . .. Richelle Moen Minneapolis,US 2019-02-20 Dallas Curling Norman, US : 2019-02-21 - 91 - Name L t .. --.L ©ate martha Arnare San Ramon, US 2019-03-06 Raj Jain Danville, US 2019-03-06 .... ............. .. .... . ..... ... Darla Saverstrom Chula Vista, US 2019-03-08 Amanda Conrady San Diego, CA ' 2019-03-08 - 92 - Fror n.. Carmen Be-rumen Re: CUP16-0030 Fran ®rhmund, Titan Storage t.tR �7Ta •may - 93 - RE: CUP16-0030 application from Frank Orhmund Good evening my name is Carmen Berumen and an Antigua homeowner.I am here to voice my opposition to the application submitted by Titan Storage to operate a Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard next to our neighborhood. I am dismayed that the applicant would show such disregard to home owners a nd school children by operating a Recreational Vehicle Storage Yard from Gam to 10pm 7 days a week next to homes and schools on a busy street and negatively affect homeowner's quality of life and home values. I and many of my neighbors living on the side that overlooks the easement paid a premium for our homes.According to Western Pacific Housing seller's disclosure the San Diego County Water Authority and SDG&E have the right of wayto this easement between Antigua and Eastlake High school. Nowhere does it say"oh and by the way this easement can be used for commercial use".If such a statement existed 1 would never had invested hard earned money to buy my home.Since receiving the first vague notice in 2016 I looked for information regarding Titan Storage and found nothing. I searched the address listed on the notice and it points to a different location than the one disclosed in the third notice received the week of Thanksgiving 2018. This storage yard,if approved,will drive our home values down from which we and especially new home owners will likely never recover.Some proponents or should I say`interested parties"behind this venture,claim that this will have negligible effects to our neighborhood and will only improve the land under the high voltage power lines.This claim is in sharp contrast to the information I received from Mr. Alexi Rabay a Bonita real estate agent, whom I consulted to weigh my options and my fears were confirmed that this Recreational Vehicle Storage yard will drive home prices down and will negatively affect the prestige of our neighborhood. We live in a residential area not an industrialized commercial zone.The only places I am aware of that uses land under high power voltage towers are in heavily industrialized and commercial areas in Clairmont,Kearny Mesa, North Park and where there is no more land to develop. A neighbor started a petition and as of today we have over 300 signatures and growing every day. I have talked with many of my neighbors and we are unanimous in our opposition to this Recreational Vehicle Storage yard. Thank you for listening to my concerns. — 94 — I ask you:would you allow this to happen next to your property?Please we ask that you not to approve Titan Storage's application,this will cause.negative damage to our neighborhood and quality of life frorn Which vie will linen never recover. i - 95 - Feb 20, 2019 Re: Storage facility adjacent to Antigua complex To whom this may concern. My name is Alexi Rabay, broker with San Diego Real Estate Properties and my opinion about having an RV and open storage facility next to the Antigua living complex would have several negative effects. Typically these-types of storage facilities are located in industrial or commercial parks and by h aving one of these facilities next to a residential complex, it poses non desirability to purchase properties there, in turn,that will make it more difficult to sell a unit there. Besides the real estate factors that will impact this complex,there exists other potential issues, such as higher noise levels, higher pollution levels of gasoline,oil and possible waste created by RV owners, etc. In my opinion,such type of facility would be best in a industrial or commercial zone or area. With respect, Alm R bay Alexi Rabay y Broker Rar--tior S; 619-250-4531 R. idetl Real Elate - - Real Estate Broker Via- BRF L 1 4 b _ Ca DRE Lic 02075321 _ � — 4r. . y ea , suite 310 �= � - LJ 10119i 9450- 5 3 v tv#IS'`4nDte eall 7: e--Prop:f£i.�a Corn – 96 – # �-g_ �n q A_t o E o, '%,,r�cam, wvEsv and - --__--- ---- Sale, Deposit scam and Joint Escr W :v Instructions Antigua SE-yLj-Tz-jERIS-DlkQYCLOSUPt.]�P STATEMENT , Tract -26 . We are pleased you have purchased a new residence in Antigua and will be living in one-of the-newest-and most prestigious communities in. the San. Diego Area. Please-take your time in reading this Disclosure Statement("Statement"� because it is intended to help you gain-valuable knowledge and information about the Al'3t gu co?n?"3]11'lty /�s you 3_`eZd thrr�z,ah_ t��S Statement 1�1ease bean ir, MMA 2' 7'1']1"{ 4 TA�'lY `J ,T •• ""�'a av�sysr keep tea, aze:aa� �L.7tLi signature acknowledges your receipt and acceptance of the information contained witbin. This Statement contains information which the Seller(Western Pacific Housing- Antigua., LLC) herein after referred to as "WPH" or Seller, is providing in connection with sales at Antigua. Seiler may elect at any time to change or discontinue use, in whole-or in part, of this Statement as more information may become available at a later date. The Antigua project is. located adjacent to the Master Planned community of EastLake Greens in the City of Chula Nista, County of San. Diego (hereinafter referred to .as "Subdivision, 'Tt6ed' or "ColxtMI-I iitY"). To H'S actlial knowledge, the following information contained herein is accurate as of the date of this Statement. Antigua is currently planned for a total of 252 residential units. - .additional units may be constructed (beyond the current 252 total) in offier areas. -97 - , = ` Seller's Disclosure Statement -= requirements, to minimi a sound transfer into neighboring Residential Units, and to provide, v»n fire protection measures. These-common walls-and common floors are not"sound experienced and should be proof'and same sound transfer could be P expected. it is therefore important { -ffiat Buyers do not penetrate.the common wall and common floors as this will affectthe construction measures intended to meet code requirements. Additionally, there are fire protection measures in the ceilings which.should also not be penetrated without consulting a liscensed building contractor Each Buyer is responsible for satisfying himself or herself as to the acoustics and noise attenuation between Residential Units in the Community. 62•NOISE and TKAhC MUES: This Subdivision maybe impacted by noise from SR-125 freeway, Eastlake Boulevard, Eastlake Sigh School, and other adjoining land uses. Additionally,Antigua is located in close proximity to an above ground water tank owned and opened by the Otay Water District and residents may be impacted from noise (such as deliveries and daily operations) associated with operation of this facility. The Otay Water District is planning to,install a pump station south of the Antigua Community that has the potential to result in noise audible from your Residence. Noise impact mitigation measures for the Residences have been based upon and implemented in accordance with the City of Chula Vista building standards. SR-125 is currently being planned by the City of Chula Vista and associated agencies to extend from the 405 freeway to the Poway area, (Buyers are advised to contact the City of Chula Vista Engineering Department for details concerning SR-125 such as ) �� that SR I25 wr7.l be �s31"cati"n' -�. etc. . even. constructed adjacent to and immediately west of the Antigua _ community,noise from SR-125 will be audible tbroughout the Antigua community. In order to meet City of Chula Vista exterior noise standards, balcony noise barriers will be required. - for a number of Plan 1 balconies located along the future State Route 125 corridor, Units requiring balcony barriers on the Plan 1 balcony include units 128, 129, 136, 137, 144, 145, 152, 153, i60, 161, 165, 169, and 176. These balconies, to be-constructed of stucco and plexi-glass or plate glass,will appeal.'aesthetically different than the wood balconies that win be constructed throughout the commuiiV. Buyer acknowledges that there maybe noise associated with the use and enjoyment of the POOL spa,clubhouse and recreational areas by Antigua residents and their guests during hours of operation which include morning and night times. Additionally, there may be noise associated with the pool and spa equipment. Purchasers of units_next to or near the Pool/recreation area acknowledge this noise potential, 63. SAM DIEGO COLINTYWATER AUTROPIr AC XIUS. Nater lines owned and maintained by the San.Diego County Nater Authority are located to the north of the Antigua community along the northern property line. 'mere are currently two aqueducts within the San Diego County Water Authority easement consisting of a 69 inch line and a 72 inch line. Please be aware that the San Diego County Water .Authority can utilize this easement to install more water lines and/or replace or upsize the existing lines. As _with an infrastructure,the San Diego County Water Authority does perform routine maintenance and therfore will utilize the easment for ve-chile adeess as needed to reach their facilties adjacent Page 17 of 33 -98- 3 Seller's Lisclosure Statement _- to the project and as we!! as facs'Sties located bey-and the community boundaries, For more information-regarding these facilities,please contact-the San Diego County Water Aut oiiEy. - 6,A_S SAI DIEGOO G-A-,q_ V Els k-7JL C (SEYW . ENER � '_� 8AIN D UNDERGROUND FACHMIES: The project is located adjacent to overhead electricity power lines owned and maintained by San Diego Gas & Electric Company (SDG&E). Currently, the SDG&E faciliti6s located to the north of the project site consist of the following:- 69kv tranmission lines, 230kv transmission lines, a 4" high pressure gas 'ice s a� tion 'lin rias T t_ distribution line, and rt iii uigii�;� g� fa3.1"��tiiu.vsa�.�. � �z tivhe.S are . located withirim the SDG&E easement situated to the north of the Awtigua, Gommtini, SDG&E has the right to add to,change,or modify the existing facilities at any time. The pourer line. emit invisi=ble forces known as electromagnetic fields (EMFs). EMFs nuomd anything that conducts electn ty, such as televisions,microwave ovens and stereo su equipment. Elm's have attracted attention because some research studies have suggested there may be a link between FAUS and certain typess of cancer. Other research has indicated no connection at all.. At this time,we do not know for sure whether or not V&Fs pose my serious health riffs. Rese=h is ongoing, but it could takke years for science to provide definitive answers. SDG&E is allowed to bring machinery and people onto the property covered by the easement to construct and lay new power lines,gas lines,pipes and overhead suuchm, as well as to repair, replace and remove existing liness, pipes and overhead structures. The power lines may be aboveground or mdeirgrovnd. SDG&E also has the right to go on the property covered by the easement to repair, replace, remove and maintain aboveground and underground lines,pipes and other structures. The permitted activities may include placing poles or other structure on the property for holding power lines and digging holes and/or #reaches on the property. Seller makes no express or implied warranty or representation to residents or owners with respect to the present or fature existence of any ace±iial or rr�^ten health.risks associated.with ENTs. Buyer aclmowledges that Seiler has no control over SDG&E power lines and their present or future location. You hereby release Seller and any of Sellers Affiliated entities, agents or employees from any an all claims for damages, and/or expenses, injury or death resulting from exposure to said power lines and from any loss of resale value due to future changes in information or public"opinion on ENTs. If you have any questions or concerns regarding EMFs, you should contact the SDG&E EMF Center at (800) 336-SDGE. You should also contact the California Public Utilities Commission,the government agency which regulates California electric utilities at (415)303-1252.This subdivision maybe impacted by noise from the powerlines. 6-5.SUBMETERING: The community will have a main public water meter which measures water usage for all residences. Each residence has been pre-plumbed with a private water "submetering'device(an electronic device that measures the volume of water usage for each individual.residence).This type of device will be installed in your garage, and will allow a company employed by the association to use an electronic device to read each submeter. rte, Each homeowner will be responsible for maintaining,repairing and replacing the submeter. I I Page 18 of 33 -99 - Re: CUP16-0030 application to Rec3reational Vehicle 5tog age Yard From: Christopher Garen, Antigua Resid.ent PI-Z CI Gn Vvl : - 4 . - 100- i I To whom it may concern, I an, writfing Li letter to express my objection. toward the Titan R.V. Storage facility that has been oppressed upon us and is expected to be built right next to our home.I also would like to express some frustration,anger,helplessness,.and fear that I feel this has brought upon my family and I as well.First let me explain my fizstrat on,I am frus�trated becar--ise when.we bought our first home here we were not only buy.-fi-x g a home but we-were investing in oarr future. we were not only purchasing a home but a Lifestyle,an experience.It was not just the home it was the neighborhood,the schools,the shopping centers,the well-manicured landscape,the distance away Rom the i du4_al are.-,and the po=emstial for growth that compliments its residents. This is ghat that we were investing in when we baught our home,we never agreed to the d1�--- p3 i on and the negative consequences that v,-M result if it Is allowed to be built next to us.i ate.angry.I am angry because our expectations were so high when we purchased our first home.We-were excited and anxious to start our new life here in Eastlake.This is where we were going to raise our kids,we thought, as we were handed the l--eys to our very first home. We thought vve had hit the lotto-wi��the affordability in a neighborhood such as this.You see,I joined the Navy to live the American Bream,to own a home,and raise a family in a decent neighborhood because I was raised by parents who were not homey vners and i wasn't raised in an area as nice as this. I lived in New York City and I understand firsthand have much an area can influence your uplaring<nng. This is the neighborhood I choose AS IT IS and n2any other servicemen who have done the same. I feel helpless,I feel helpless because these expel-tions?feel are bei.= g taken right out mom undemeedi.me and I feel powerless to do anything about it. This is not what I had volunteered in the senvice of ray county for.I joined to Prot-t the consti-taw oa and democracy for the citizens of this great nation.Now I am one of those citizens asking that democracy work for me.i feel fear,I feel fear because I am afraid of the negative consequences that this facility will bring.I fear that it will blemish our neig iborhood,that.it-v-,-ill bring down olu property and noir:-. hili, Lastly I would like to leave you with this,image that this was being done to you in your neighborhood ri_--ht next door to you,how would you_feel?'Pham,you for the opportunity to ex-press my convems I hope this has made an hmpact for my family and the fa it°es of ny community as well. Regards, The Guerreri Family 1205 Cabezas Cove 7 - 101 - Oscar Romero From: timf@phnaz.com Sent: Wednesday, March 13,2019 3:05 PM To: Oscar Romero Cc: frank@otayrealestate.wa-webapps.iad3a; com@phnaz.com Subject: CUP 16-0030 To whom it may concern, Parkway Hills Church does not oppose the above mentioned proposed project. We do not find that it would adversely impact this area. We do support this. Sincerely, Tim Fillmore Parkway Hills Church 1227 Eastlake Parkway Chula Vista, CA 91915 619-656-3697 — 102 — Attachment 5 •.,. ul n '. i ` t... t • ..:: '..� ,. .. ;:fit '., .. :. .... • .... ..:-. rt 'i'.• Vol mot kR4 G' Cou' •':1'tt.1�� t - 3 tis•. iso-.=•. t �. n _ - a�ia��i�'� - ciksc��ff�� _ anin :Com'tn'is�cn.arotliera : `: g - � 1��gskativ�.•i�:bi7j�.af,tlti��7Gi�y„�lstat�hat�t'+p�disclosur� '° .. anyam' ai n cyan ::s:ti. :t• :::��.:,k' :� .� i� t_isul��i� !� ��xh.�';�ie �• �'• ,, �. MR: g`�o i�1' ia�' ''�� •t:•. 4.•” Y QRS E^ es Q 'V it p rso s a - . . _ ,Ma�, test•'i� the'• �rgmect•: :'�• �:: `:dip ti�a ;: rii eFi 6t'c tr ;.::.:5? TOW '3 `<'. P act 40•g �li�tkt+�9 � Iicaewf ca trae#a ;r Q. , n.. r,5ula antra t�<CCi. f i.:.su - 3• .�:: .:{.. ..,t..i' ibIwo ex°r-s�:::`; •.k s? i.0 .tet_ ":tomiP '.•moi''` jt _ _ aJ' S.. - Y _ " { �N o''.t• iia .r S�`. .• 'v C i Y �C i .a •ice �t - •i a iiyyyy ,7. Sr�G ntifi•id - f1 SeCtl#n 't• � - j s a• x ►�t 'I. P. �alb:.":• ::;�' 'txr wxi .tri::th bus#nes� �tpo ` ey.s! „ ;F.�,'.•'. . vs?Nor { , ••t - OWNS; t - - '•L it .i • ,.•..'>3 is •: is „_ � . a Ya :•r> .rL:r• _ r Y j .. Why 'i t - jtoo* Y -" -..'31•.:x: p_ .i .. 1� �il '' iii' T zia i i1. .vim 'hove a.. n +a it tfr�•'�:ni'�.'�j: �'ri�t.. #�f yyy Wit.. r.trrAk :!' :;fr: y, Jr....� Au ;::•. •':.:i•::.;..y_� _ i, :'`::Y.�q:••' :•,.4'O rs :i'1• is U.-irl� �k ''� .. , :r ir't�f the n oop grit pir ai�i�atf ri gr t re.:J _i t 'tru f' e' iu .o t :..• " j i.\'.. - - •tSxNe^ SAN - 4 � _'i-`• two= j; } te. :Wiz:�_=^e. 1.::� _ i - i:3:• WAR C •L t 1 v. .`�`Y�- "�i.Biu��•in. :�� ,a �� tri':I ��`,+��• tr , .h � ,. �s .ki >�a! : •.ase h�. re t' �� •a'ti 'as�'tkte �Ott:t:•is:• e e. �Y. y-.. WA •r •i ♦t t .d - - t'•4 a .0 t - h t 0 - N - - ti^:•r •:'Y y `.` _ 1-t) °; `.;1y ,. _ �a#i- .�'± [•.,. -� .�b<a.e:.t: Oat-, _/ t�:f•o#'p1i+��t�O �:d.> i "':'iit it+c .F. k:i.0 a±4nth�an+off"�+rtal*"'.b tkie it3r of ila'ltistaYas:it lat i ��rf X G!'a=•��e�:t��=a' '�� •_,,. .. i iii I•:`�:"�.�:��.: `•6nthi? •��'�s•-.:'.=%-�.,. .,•No•: 5 , e All T Vii:•:: - i 3: r - - - - •:R ! ra VON. _ .t.,. is z-,<}zi.:,rsfi;+�•) t, •;ti p . f:•:esx bk6s�.� ��ii:�. ,_,L - .'I•:: i:.:Vit.:...'• .i.:;'• , 4d9 � � #=sru:rth Jtr:ert. e' Attachment 4 X., ;S:' . '' '' :I` •,T,•• .;:r,. •. •. : ; ;: �p w., :.:,...: .!.::. Y .''i,...all,„ice .t'`'..;.:,' .}'t 1. s '? - 'r ' ..?� ..� 'i. :CS:' :+azr ' :,,. i �,.. i::e.,..1 :: ' i .>> a :.}.. ;, :... ; . . ;.;;' %: . .. ..: ,. ::: .: . . ... ”'°?i.a'r:tslrf :.: i 1sion`' ' i` :v : ' :".,— ; eia: .frt n P'1r .� 'i t7 — _ a`.i 1: :r: - :s ''• :.; i :: r + a� -,. T.,,, ,,1� „:. r . ':!%,.°' �■ .;`R,'.rii: ... :^•. •r f,.',i- _ Huey.` ��x{, ....• ..,. ai. r'-' 'r .�F,_ 'S,. ., Z. 1`. <' :'. ? .: :j ;'Y sire1. r 't. :.- 14 's; �.r�:t i.::;, .. . .lf.:, . ;'. ,'.. d "). •'I"' - _ ;.tt :•p 5. y,•. ,��J ):L £.` ' J*... 5'_31 15 5- a: tt i::i 1 4 d,. ii. i - ' •- � g {. ,� ,� bn.:a..;. .;;: : rwis as; iater�itlti'th e�sntrat r, ti'' :licatl�tn'nn.ati` a: ai • ,.x. AFS . ini? , jtt; vnirit u&'h�o��%�t re than 5.2 tt v+rit61i ,&. a 10 pie' '•,:: ;_ -, .. the t 'a::;; riJ.-I... ''.cu r Z.' r e.t mem' ".11 n :, 1M fit f oC° u :.i" :f:,:40,.:,. y h ta•1�iCa d nttl° Yes- ;s: -1 6ft ::r., `3', airs;; :' - - ;t i i!'. Fy' - :•' '[:i'. ':'y.:.J' <':: i il. '14'; _ :,' ,: U. Ype rl7ifiei�in,t. ` ,,. ,,: k,4.F' �swe,' rotii rwis sib}: iated.v►�it#�t s1.7' ': ::, ,. :<;: :..-�p�tti ti in,pr�vi:de i'rriore than$410 car an its .e. utvele 3, ' (� tx� �y / y .?ci _alp } I.t; nrfficfai, ,:gf the [ x':IfI IRu� �1. 11I t G.�a, ..,1�` i,/ r.{L'1h' 7.i EicWd } G .e :t' y':' �rrr:-. Y. . ri t{ t' YFiP1 :d;i r.$drW,brnefit an#.. . :.:. ''<reci i nil$r6h4e-Qr, i'i nfli t6 ,r! a o ,a itiip vai a rnorxe t #ire I: . al ` ::..: . .:_...... :,:: t', ., . —= •6.•. a ,: i�;f.,I^;., ';:s;: :,lax •�' !rF7•i -..1.! _ _ _ _ j1 ::of --.:'s 1. it xS 1:1'.: r nq:s'.. f i t _ f iai --. s::t' ,. .t. a t'� is - a wt1. a u t e ...� � � 1 err�`JI'r � - .Y- rt •.? d. ^i`' R ..}:' 7" t: j: .YT�'i t• !+ :'.L'': ::,.C' i4 w :.. '7�' V `ZCJ_: - :p- 4,. - J.. ,A d i; �' fi s :I -'3•._ :. i II „I.., - _ _ S'F i - - - i l: 4.•4:: - - ,sial,.,,,,• _ :'i. LL'g; =i l '. aUl. :...t' ,:t.;I :`i'. t'�4 ., ♦ S• f ~:,a. }Y' n' ersa`. .`� , rr' i, t . W,-- +� i�ov� °.or oth . >.,.: _:.}.. z. ; .:. .. rare ... ii atl''rr `#e-.;1* • `..' _a w:� i sotirie.,Otind6me eif .5 r Arno. ta''ars:60001,!..?�f'.f 'c ,` ' ..-:�,: :'y:< ;. i e ityt�f` ::. tris ;i_rk thew` _ :., �,L ;,, :r, h o. 3- �. ;+t Z. : . _ :r j`' 1'�: - th ;f, r _ :,•::mac-. Via.n.' 'IS_• - .:'it'r •I - „r!l '}1::,:.' ,..J k_...•� S :3 �* ":":: +1: .•:j j _ ..:'��i'!i:�a, ,.'L.N.• Ty i.,G.' ...ln.n �i �i'' W icit'c. _ h .fi"i .enr#�t�'`e;rh�3' f�.4f h i:•itL'• ��rid - �:��t:, �..:..:� �`i° :I': - -._?12�:r ! 1: E, r>!•f .!'Q „+ d.•' -ay-' z ?v- 3 }.,' y: /y j 25` y. ra. t- :, i:F..- _ ____ _ _ ,.Six t•' - - _ - - - 't -Yv..l. Y'. L:::•. 1q:. '.Jr :}-_ 1 itk•: .�' (i' :: :r . —may. _ _ - - - ''.'J .. __ _ tt11 , Y:' rY. t'l- 1 F' gip:: 3 a „ _ - i>tj - 'C i �•7'.••T:: ,... ., - z'.;{ F' - :'�. ^..;z:. ;t"' ...' Ld,. �:. ,:[,` 1 - - 1 is _:u' '" — - r: i v .is+:i :t. I'r:: S' - _:.):: Y., '!4•' alis^i`i%i::;'. :.�A..:i :-a.. i?',i 3` h'' — :}. t:t. 1. 1. •:a,_. __n„ _ -`26�' .R /.• 1. { _• ,. tri.^,' -,.1' _ s'4�. ;: r. ;Y. - .t',1. :.: _ F t': :'3si' fi:- _ 3 - ter.' - - r.ru. i? :`., f '4j'' C ,i :.l"' a.f, . t :3,, :,} 1 q. ' 8:-.' s i c, .< :.fi: ;;a'. !r. ��':}} _- d. - n :A4 ;.� : } �) - : Sri.1"..d I .i!. _ '.' - } :='3Princ�r#�rpe,riarti%*zVsof �+ntraar�A�yiicarrt r� :' :f :}� i}, .. ` _+:• . , -: t , 5..:'.y.I.::' , :, air-:' 2 1 - ::: :S .s. ..,j f• .,f..} r.I - ..1. ✓'.:• 'Y :Y :e .. :f a•t: - f i /, ?'::''. :-Y•:� .I rJ a �+' $rM } i` f. '' art r#h oittt►lent . iat o 'W." t°t ' :,:: at i tp;:': I. tya1i,'! o0i • :.,—'.O ti*;' ru t� weljier;s ndfidteo' r* oth"ir` iun ;ct rr uiaici `i`ii,.:";_' '::` U,',.. )i Y is ik`' i7-, !tit23i u6d ; �. - s::.;:.,, *a : t`Ji t. Bn t W. i :grey o rer ! 11 R at'�c-Mb)n0ticu1° irr'' as a krr�kt•"I: '';: .. �:. ., �'. '' . , M1•k•i: '1 -�li0 q# a 3i ltr 0.'zZ #":.n irrN tai' `x'141' of<'.+ ti!rrierri i nre orr } � . ., : ' .. ..: X ciur herr a irig tt1el�.s r� i t 7"1;_k:: ;: ' _ lbaa`t•. i m`: i t i�c0vyim tt#e.,0fth4.c_ ' ';'arid: em .or 3ffm L. ,�'.' - . .= :;{ __. k .� ti+ , - Y- pig :�.M.. . °.F.: �': 'Itis.:ki t : : , t :" : . ' fi ' ''Y``ted _ ' •�i. die `o eft a '::�tcatiort'tir' onto is suirriittd diu i�.. �1.. x:11..,t; ,• jY. ,.. ::.IH p!. . P ►. Et, t':L. j a . . ,.t. ity - .. s.t k< t�#'u Oki. lr "q,"#.W' ttrr to eonsid ration 'y ie islatrve: " i . J... i,' . .,:35.,:.:. ....,. s; 1.1. �.;a. _, ;t ,,•. ': :.:r:< .:: ' , J.• •r'TVll F7r '`'�v•1!'�Fl7fs.�w u1M..': . x7b F 't(rt'f►Ave.rtu � h�iia'�J>it' ` i :t + . {b'1 '}: 1:1:•S;1i�i, • — 104— . • . .. ,.J '. . Attachment 6 FASTLAKE111 Community Association Dear Resident: RE: Commercial Vehicles As a member of the Eastlake III Community Association,we appreciate you working hard to keep the community an attractive and enjoyable place to live. We are writing to ask for your assistance with an item that recently came to our attention. It has been noted that you are parking a commercial vehicle on the streets of the Eastlake III Community Association. Please take note of CC&R's Section 10.6 below: 10.6 Vehicles. No trailer, camper, boat, recreational vehicle, commercial vehicle or similar equipment shall hereafter be permitted to remain upon the Covered Property, unless placed or maintained within an enclosed garage, nor permitted to be parked other than temporarily for purposes of loading, unloading or cleaning, on any street, whether public or private, alley, or Community Common Area or Project Common Area within the Covered Property. Temporary parking shall mean (a) parking for less than twenty-four (24) hours for vehicles belonging to guests or Owners, (b)parking delivery trucks, service vehicles and other.commercial vehicles being used in the furnishing of services to the Community Association or the Owners and (c)parking of vehicles belonging to or being used by Owners for loading and unloading purposes. The Community Board may adopt guidelines defining what vehicles constitute recreational vehicles and commercial vehicles,what constitutes temporary parking and rules for regulation of the admission and parking of vehicles within the Covered Property or any public or private streets within the Covered Property, including the assessment of charges to Owners who violate or whose invitees violate such rules. No automobile, recreational vehicle or equipment, commercial vehicle or any other motorized vehicle may be dismantled, rebuilt, repaired, serviced or repainted on the Covered Property unless performed within a completely enclosed garage or other structure located in a Residence which completely screens the sight and sound of such activity from streets, Community Common Area and neighboring Residences. Any charges so assessed shall be an Enforcement Assessment. Any fence or screen required under this Section shall comply with any standards promulgated by the Community Board or Architectural Committee as to size, color,or other criteria for permitted fences or screens. Golf carts and similar vehicles shall be operated within the Covered Property only pursuant to the Community Association Rules. The foregoing restriction shall not be deemed to prevent temporary parking for washing and polishing and those activities normally incident to washing and polishing of vehicles. Additionally,the EastLake III Community Association Community Handbook Parking Guidelines states: — 105— A. Parking Guidelines (Please refer to the CC&Rs,Article 10, Section 10.6) 1. The applicable Public Agency shall be allowed to impose and enforce all provisions of the applicable California Vehicle Code sections or local ordinances on any private streets contained within the Properties. 2.Prohibited vehicles as defined per the CC&Rs,Article 10, Section 10.6, are not allowed in any driveway or other exposed areas, or any street (public or private), except for the purposes of loading, unloading,making deliveries, or emergency repairs. a. Commercial Vehicles are vehicles, other than standard passenger vehicles or pickup trucks with a manufacturer's rating or payload capacity of one ton or less that are used in a trade or business or are of a type that is typically used in a trade or business. Notwithstanding the foregoing, pickup trucks or vans that have been modified for use in a trade or business(e.g.,by the addition of ladder racks, extensive advertising or signage, equipment racks, large storage compartments or other equipment) are Commercial Vehicles for the purposes of these rules. Public safety vehicles (i.e. police, border patrol, fire marshal, etc.) are permissible. 3. Vehicles owned, operated or within the control of an Owner, or of a resident of such Owner's Lot and Condominium,must be parked in the garage to the extent of the maximum designed capacity of such garage or parking space. 4.Driveways may not be used for parking purposes if the Owner's garage is not utilized to the maximum designed capacity for the parking of authorized vehicles, or if to do so obstructs free traffic flow, constitutes a nuisance, violates the Community Handbook, or otherwise creates a safety hazard. If you feel you have received this notice in error,please contact EastLake III Community Guidelines Administrator,David Alva at (619) 421-1268 or dalvanwaltersmanagement.com. Thank-you for your immediate attention to this matter. Your community spirit is greatly appreciated by your neighbors. Sincerely EastLake III Board of Directors — 106 —