HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Packet 2018_09_18 3pmSeptember 18, 2018City Council Agenda
At the September 11th City Council Meeting, the following
individuals received two or more nominations to be
interviewed for the At-Large Member seats:
- At-Large Member - District 1 Representative:
Becky Cortez, Quentin Redman, Phillip Rhamy, David Stucky,
and Bernardo Vasquez
- At-Large Member - District 2 Representative:
Pedro Anaya, Kevin O’Neill, Joseph Raso, and
Daniel Vaccaro
- At-Large Member - District 3 Representative:
Jennifer Becker, John McKay, and Heather Rubio
Applicants for the At-Large Member - District 4
Representative Seat to be interviewed:
- At-Large Member - District 4 Representative:
Edgar Armenta, Hunt Palmer Sr., and John Volland
The following applicants were nominated by the Nominating
Authorities as prescribed by Chula Vista Municipal Code
section 2.63.050 to be interviewed for the Designated
Member seats:
- Raymundo Alatorre, Growth Management Oversight
Commission
- Francisco Escobedo, Chula Vista Chamber of Commerce
- Gary Ficacci, Chula Vista Police Chief
- Manolo Guillen, Chula Vista Fire Chief
- Nicole Hobson, Association of Chula Vista Employees
- Gloria Juarez, Growth Management Oversight Commission
- David Martinez, Chula Vista Police Officers Association
- Darrell Roberts, Chula Vista International Association of
Fire Fighters
The activity is not a “Project” as defined under Section 15378 of the
California Environmental Quality Act State Guidelines; therefore,
pursuant to State Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) no environmental
review is required.
Environmental Notice:
Council conduct the interviews. Recommended Action:
Page 2 City of Chula Vista Printed on 9/13/2018
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 2
September 18, 2018City Council Agenda
ADJOURNMENT
to the Regular City Council Meeting on September 18, 2018, at 5:00 p.m., in the Council
Chambers.
Materials provided to the City Council related to any open-session item on this agenda are available for
public review at the City Clerk’s Office, located in City Hall at 276 Fourth Avenue, Building A, during
normal business hours.
In compliance with the
AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT
The City of Chula Vista requests individuals who require special accommodations to access, attend,
and/or participate in a City meeting, activity, or service, contact the City Clerk’s Office at (619)
691-5041(California Relay Service is available for the hearing impaired by dialing 711) at least
forty-eight hours in advance of the meeting.
Most Chula Vista City Council meetings, including public comments, are video recorded and aired live
on AT&T U-verse channel 99 (throughout the County), on Cox Cable channel 24 (only in Chula Vista),
and online at www.chulavistaca.gov. Recorded meetings are also aired on Wednesdays at 7 p.m. (both
channels) and are archived on the City's website.
Sign up at www.chulavistaca.gov to receive email notifications when City Council agendas are
published online.
Page 3 City of Chula Vista Printed on 9/13/2018
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 3
P a g e | 1
September 18, 2018 File ID: 18-0439
TITLE
INTERVIEWS TO FILL ALL 11 SEATS FOR INITIAL TERMS ON THE MEASURE A CITIZENS’ OVERSIGHT
COMMITTEE
Interviews of all nominees will be held Tuesday, September 18, and Thursday, September 20, 2018.
Appointments will be made at the conclusion of interviews at the September 20th meeting. No appointments
will be made on September 18th.
At the September 11th City Council Meeting, the following individuals received two or more nominations to
be interviewed for the At-Large Member seats:
- At-Large Member - District 1 Representative: Becky Cortez, Quentin Redman, Phillip Rhamy, David
Stucky, and Bernardo Vasquez
- At-Large Member - District 2 Representative: Pedro Anaya, Kevin O’Neill, Joseph Raso, and Daniel
Vaccaro
- At-Large Member - District 3 Representative: Jennifer Becker, John McKay, and Heather Rubio
Applicants for the At-Large Member- District 4 Representative Seat to be interviewed:
- At-Large Member - District 4 Representative: Edgar Armenta, Hunt Palmer Sr., and John Volland
The following applicants were nominated by the Nominating Authorities as prescribed by Chula Vista
Municipal Codesection 2.63.050 to be interviewed for the Designated Member seats:
- Raymundo Alatorre, Growth Management Oversight Commission
- Francisco Escobedo, Chula Vista Chamber of Commerce
- Gary Ficacci, Chula Vista Police Chief
- Manolo Guillen, Chula Vista Fire Chief
- Nicole Hobson, Association of Chula Vista Employees
- Gloria Juarez, Growth Management Oversight Commission
- David Martinez, Chula Vista Police Officers Association
- Darrell Roberts, Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Council conduct the interviews.
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 4
P a g e | 2
DISCUSSION
At the meeting of September 11, 2018, pursuant to Chula Vista Municipal Code section 2.63.060, the City
Council nominated individuals to be interviewed for certain At-Large seats on the Measure A Citizens’
Oversight Committee and set the date and time to interview these nominees as well as all nominees for the
At-Large-District 4 seat and all Designated Member applicants who were nominated by the designated
Nominating Authorities as prescribed by Chula Vista Municipal Code section 2.63.050.
Interviews of all nominees will be held Tuesday, September 18, and Thursday, September 20, 2018.
Appointments will be made at the conclusion of interviews at the September 20th meeting. No appointments
will be made on September 18th.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The Director of Development Services has reviewed the proposed activity for compliance with the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and has determined that the activity is not a “Project” as defined under
Section 15378 of the State CEQA Guidelines because it will not result in a physical change in the environment;
therefore, pursuant to Section 15060(c)(3) of the State CEQA Guidelines, the activity is not subject to CEQA.
Thus, no environmental review is required.
DECISION-MAKER CONFLICT
Staff has reviewed the decision contemplated by this action and has determined that it is not site-specific and
consequently, the 500-foot rule found in California Code of Regulations Title 2, section 18702.2(a)(11), is not
applicable to this decision for purposes of determining a disqualifying real property-related financial conflict
of interest under the Political Reform Act (Cal. Gov't Code § 87100, et seq.).
Staff is not independently aware, and has not been informed by any Councilmember, of any other fact that
may constitute a basis for a decision maker conflict of interest in this matter.
LINK TO STRATEGIC GOALS
The City’s Strategic Plan has five major goals: Operational Excellence, Economic Vitality, Healthy Community,
Strong and Secure Neighborhoods and a Connected Community. The boards and commissions program
supports the Connected Community goal. Members of the City’s boards and commissions play a vital role by
participating in the City’s processes and helping influence public policy with their diverse viewpoints.
CURRENT-YEAR FISCAL IMPACT
There is no impact on the general fund.
ONGOING FISCAL IMPACT
There is no ongoing fiscal impact.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Citizens’ Oversight Committee Application Packet
Staff Contact: Leah Larrarte
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 5
Citizens’ Oversight Committee
Applications
District 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 6
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 7
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 8
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 9
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 10
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 11
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 12
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 13
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 14
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 15
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 16
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 17
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 18
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 19
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 20
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 21
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 22
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 23
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 24
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 25
DAVID M. STUCKY
Chula Vista, CA 91914
(
SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS
Successful experience in all aspects of business operations and management including
Commercial and municipal real estate management
Project Management
Financial management and budget administration
Research and analysis
Strategic Planning
Community affairs
Proven leadership, analytical, problem solving and decision making skills.
Superior oral and written communication skills.
Extensive experience in team building and organizational development.
PROFESSIONAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS
City of San Diego, San Diego, CA 1996 – 2018
Management Analyst, 2008 - 2018
Responsible for administration of the City of San Diego contractor prequalification program
Identify and determine the qualifications of over 400 contractors to bid on capital improvement projects
Analyze financial statements, contracts and supporting documents
Liaise with other City departments and industry organizations
Conduct internal training and community/industry outreach efforts
Assist in the development and administration of Small Local Business Enterprise certification program
Coordinate Public Works Department implementation of online bidding
Acting Deputy Director, 2007
Responsible for directing and managing all aspects of the Facilities Division of the General Services Department
Oversee, through subordinates, management, maintenance, repair and minor construction in
approximately 1600 City-owned facilities
Oversee, through subordinates, hiring, training, supervision and discipline of over 120 employees in a
variety of building trades
Develop, implement and administer operating budgets of approximately $15 million
Develop, implement and administer capital improvement budgets of approximately $25 million
Coordinate Facilities Division participation in Witch Creek fire response and recovery efforts
Building Manager, 1996 - 2008
Manage a portfolio of downtown office buildings owned by the City of San Diego including the City
Administration Building, Development Services Center, Crabtree Building and the historic World Trade Center
Develop and implement an effective tenant retention program
Supervise building staff, including contract employees and in-house trades
Develop and administer operating and capital improvement budgets
Prepare bid specifications, coordinate the selection of service vendors and negotiate service contracts
Develop and implement long-range building rehabilitation and marketing plan
Coordinate leasing, renewals and tenant improvements
Special projects
Conduct condition assessment and feasibility analysis of Central Operations Yard relocation
Develop an interdepartmental program to implement energy efficiency projects in City-owned facilities
Create Facilities Division Rewards & Recognition programs
Manage implementation of City-wide access control protocol
Coordinate General Services Department participation in Cities’ Readiness Initiative
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 26
DAVID M. STUCKY
Page 2
Aegis Management Services, Bonita, CA 1994 - 1996
Real Estate Services Specialist
Provided professional advisory and consulting services to owners and managers of commercial real estate
Prepared marketing, leasing and business plans
Recommended market positioning strategy for existing properties
Implemented financial and operations reporting systems for newly acquired properties
Developed effective tenant relations and retention programs
Coordinated the solicitation of bids and selection of building service vendors
Represented commercial real estate interests before legislative and regulatory bodies and community
organizations
East County Management Company, El Cajon, CA 1993 - 1994
Development Manager
Managed a portfolio of 500,000 square feet of office, industrial and retail property
Developed and administered operating and capital improvement budgets
Prepared and presented periodic financial and operations reports
Implemented effective tenant and client relations procedures
Administered existing leases and coordinated renewals
Supervised building construction and tenant improvement projects
Managed maintenance and repair of facilities and grounds
Coordinated government and community affairs
Prepared and implemented marketing and business development plans
Shield Security, Inc., San Diego, CA 1990 - 1993
Director of Marketing
Led sales and marketing efforts for a regional, contract security provider
AMPCO Parking, Inc., Los Angeles, CA 1988 - 1990
Branch Manager
Responsible for marketing and operations for Southern California region
Prepared and submitted lease and management proposals
Negotiated management contracts and leases
Coordinated advertising, public relations and community affairs
Exercised management oversight of operations at 36 locations
Supervised hiring, training and discipline of 175 employees in multiple trades at all skill levels
Managed the purchase, installation and maintenance of automated access control equipment
Prepared market forecasts and operating and capital improvement budgets
Conducted site appraisal and analysis
Organized government and legislative affairs
Ace Parking Management, Inc., San Diego 1984 - 1988
Area Supervisor
Coordinated parking operations at Horton Plaza and downtown San Diego
Scheduled and supervised finishing construction
Hired, trained, scheduled and disciplined up to 70 employees
Developed and implemented accounting procedures and audit controls
Prepared and administered operating and capital budgets
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 27
DAVID M. STUCKY
Page 3
EDUCATION & LICENSES
Bachelor of Arts, Political Science
Occidental College
Los Angeles, CA
Juris Doctor
University of California, Hastings College of the Law
San Francisco, CA
Internship
National Labor Relations Board
San Francisco, CA
Certificate in Emergency Preparedness Management
Federal Emergency Management Administration
California Real Estate Sales License (currently inactive)
City of San Diego, Academy 2000
City of San Diego Leadership Development Program
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
SAN DIEGO BUILDING OWNERS & MANAGERS ASSOCIATION (1988 to 2018)
President, 1995
Chair, Government Affairs Committee, 1996-1997
Chair, Energy Task Force, 1994
Founder/Chair, Office Building of the Year Awards, 1988-1993
RPA Course Instructor, 1996-2004
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OWNERS & MANAGERS ASSOCIATION (1990 - 1996)
Treasurer, 1996
Member, Board of Directors, 1990-1996
Chair, Strategic Long Range Planning Task Force, 1995
BUILDING OWNERS & MANAGERS ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL (1988 to 2018)
Secretary/Treasurer, 2005-2009
Executive Committee, 2005-2011
Finance Committee, 2002-2009
Trustee, BOMA Foundation, 2005-2009
Chair, Industry Defense Fund Oversight Committee, 2003-2005
Chair, Awards Committee, 1999-2002
Vice Chair, Nominating Committee, 2004
Life Member, 2018
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 28
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 29
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 30
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 31
DISTRICT 1
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 32
Citizens’ Oversight Committee
Applications
District 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 33
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 34
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 35
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 36
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 37
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 38
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 39
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 40
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 41
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 42
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 43
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 44
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 45
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 46
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 47
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 48
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 49
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 50
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 51
DISTRICT 2
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 52
Citizens’ Oversight Committee
Applications
District 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 53
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 54
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 55
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 56
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 57
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 58
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 59
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 60
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 61
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 62
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 63
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 64
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 65
DISTRICT 3
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 66
Citizens’ Oversight Committee
Applications
District 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 67
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 68
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 69
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 70
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 71
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 72
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 73
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 74
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 75
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 76
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 77
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 78
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 79
DISTRICT 4
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 80
Citizens’ Oversight Committee
Applications
Designated Member
Nominations
Growth Management Oversight Commission – Raymundo Alatorre and Gloria Juarez
Chula Vista Chamber of Commerce – Francisco Escobedo
Chula Vista Police Chief – Gary Ficacci
Chula Vista Fire Chief – Manolo Guillen
Association of Chula Vista Employees – Nicole Hobson
Chula Vista Police Officers Association – David Martinez
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters – Darrell Roberts
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 81
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 82
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 83
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 84
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 85
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 86
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 87
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 88
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 89
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 90
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 91
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 92
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 93
Chamber of Commerce Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 94
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 95
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 96
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 97
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 98
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 99
Police Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 100
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 101
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 102
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 103
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 104
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 105
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 106
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 107
Fire Chief Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 108
Association of Chula Vista Employees Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 109
Association of Chula Vista Employees Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 110
Association of Chula Vista Employees Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 111
Association of Chula Vista Employees Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 112
Association of Chula Vista Employees Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 113
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 114
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 115
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 116
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 117
Growth Management Oversight Commission Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 118
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 119
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 120
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 121
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 122
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 123
Chula Vista Police Officers Association Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 124
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 125
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 126
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 127
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 128
Nomination of Designated Members of the
CITY OF Measure A Citizens' Oversight Committee ["COC") CHULA VISTA
The following information is submitted by the Nominating Authority to nominate one or more individuals to be
considered to serve as a Designated Member on the COC, in accordance with CVMC chapter 2.63.
Qualifications Applicable to All COC Memberst:
Must be qualified electors, (City residents who are qualified and registered to vote in the City).
Must NOT be a current City employee or current elected City official, unless otherwise specified below.
NOMINATING AUTHORITY:
Chula Vista Chamber of Commerce; norninee(s)
must be a mernber of the Chamber
XChula Vista International Association of Fire
Fighters (IAFF); nonunee(s) must be an active
member of this association; nominee Lag Y be a City
employee
Association of Chula Vista Employees (ACE);
nominee(s) must be an active member of this
association; nominee may be a City employee
Chula Vista Police Chief
Chula Vista Police Officers Association (POA);
nominee(s) must be an active member of this
association; nominee may be a City employee
0 Growth Management Oversight Commission;
nominee(s) must be from this commission
Chula Vista Fire Chief
DESIGNATED MEMBER NOMINEE(S):
Up to three nominees may be submitted. Please attach contact information for each Nominee. (See, CVMC Chapter
2.63 for additional information.)
CERTIFICATION
I certify under penalty of perjury that the above Nominees were selected in accordance with all applicable policies
and procedures of the No I represent, and that I am authorized to submit them for
consid /
Signature: Date 2a 1 a Phone Numberb
Printed Na e: .S EmaiLoiTb
Position with Nominating Authority:
After completing this form, please return to the City Clerk in person, by mail, or by email at cityclerk@chulavistaca.gov.
CVMC 2 63 050(B)
Nominee's First and Last Name Nominee's Email Address omi ee's Phone Number
2.
3.
CERTIFICATION
I certify under penalty of perjury that the above Nominees were selected in accordance with all applicable policies
and procedures of the No I represent, and that I am authorized to submit them for
consid /
Signature: Date 2a 1 a Phone Num
Printed Na e: .S
Position with Nominating Authority:
After completing this form, please return to the City Clerk in person, by mail, or by email at cityclerk@chulavistaca.gov.
CVMC 2 63 050(B)
Chula Vista International Association of Fire Fighters Nominee
2018-09-18 Agenda Packet Page 129