The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2017-05-03 BOE Special PacketNotice is hereby given that the Board of Ethics of the City of Chula Vista has called and will convene a Special Meeting of the Board of Ethics on Wednesday, May 3, 2017, at 5:30 p.m. in Executive Conference Room C-103, located at 276 Fourth Avenue, Building A, Chula Vista,. California, to consider the item(s) on this agenda. SPECIAL MEETING OF THE BOARD OF ETHICS OF THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA May 3, 2017 Executive Conference C-103, Building A 5:30 p.m. 276 Fourth Avenue Chula Vista CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL: Commissioners: Esquer Guerrero ; Jemison, Vice Chair ; Kish ; Livingston ; Robles ; and Voorhees CITY STAFF: Silva PUBLIC COMMENTS Persons speaking during Public Comments may address the Board/Commission on any subject matter within the Board/Commission's jurisdiction that is not listed as an item on the agenda. State law generally prohibits the Board/Commission from discussing or taking action on any issue not included on the agenda, but, if appropriate, the Board/Commission may schedule the topic for future discussion or refer the matter to staff. Comments are limited to three minutes. ACTION ITEMS The Item(s) listed in this section of the agenda will be considered individually by the Board/Commission and are expected to elicit discussion and deliberation. If you wish to speak on any item, please fill out a "Request to Speak" form and submit it to the Secretary prior to the meeting. Comments are limited to five minutes. 1. Discussion and action regarding Prima Facie Review, within the meaning of and as required by Chula Vista Municipal Code section 2.28.110, of BOE complaint 2017-04-A 2. Discussion and action regarding amendments involving Development Service Department Director and Assistant Director and Technical Experts to proposed Lobbying Registration Ordinance (Chula Vista Municipal Code Chapter 2.55) previously approved by the Board of Ethics and update on status of Lobbying Ordinance OTHER BUSINESS 1. STAFF COMMENTS 2. CHAIR'S COMMENTS 3. COMMISSIONERS'/BOARD MEMBERS' COMMENTS ADJOURNMENT to the regular meeting of the Board of Ethics on May 17, 2017, at 5:15 pm in the Council Conference Room C-101, Building A at 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, California. Materials provided to the Board of Ethics related to any open -session item on this agenda are available for public review in the Office of the City Attorney at 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, Building A, Chula Vista during normal business hours. In compliance with the AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT The City of Chula Vista requests individuals who require special accommodations to access, attend, and/or participate in a City meeting, activity, or service, contact the Human Resources Department at (619) 691-5041 (California Relay Service is available for the hearing impaired by dialing 711) at least forty-eight hours in advance of the meeting. I declare under penalty of perjury that I am employed by the City of Chula Vista in the Office of the City Attorney and that I posted this document on the bulletin board at the City Hall according to Brown Act requirements. Dated;` V L— 4�1Signedl=–`_ Page 2 (Board of Ethics Special Meeting May 3, 2017 fJ 04/19/2017 7:07 AM (qq Ar CHULA Y! WY CLERK A 8s 33, BOARD OF 'I' .SCS COMPLAINT .FoRI\4- AND INSTRUCTIONS VIOLATIONS OF SPECIFIED PROHIBITIONS (CVMC 2.01.030(C)) 7/16 80E Complaint Foran and Instructions-Ravisod 01 • t i • ii. i i Pi © 04/19/2017 7:07 AM fi TABLE' OF CONTENTS BOE COMPLAINT FORK i1I3dS�CT PACE f hattodttctign.., . :.........................3 . Sectiola l[Coinplaiiiaiitlr►forxttatiota]....................;.......................•...A Section 2 (Respondent infoi,motion]...................................................� Section 3 [Specified hrohibltions].....................................................6 Section 4 [PCscription of l<%] ............. ........7 Section 5[Witnes=j............................. 8 Section 6[Ductimentation]........................................:............:.......9 Section 7 [Related Complaints] ...................................... ................10 Section 8 [Additional Information]., .................................. 10 Section 9[Vcrileation]...............................................................11 Instructions................................................ l2 Request for Confidentiality l<orrrt............................................. , Attachments: Chula 'Vista Municipal Code sections 2.01 and 2.28 Page 2 of 15 7/16 809 Complaint form and Instructlons,Rovtsed P2 (D 04/19/2017 7;07 AM a g iNTRQllTJC'1'XON The Board of Ethics only has the authority to hear complaints regarding violations of the Specified Prohibitions sot forth in Chula Vista Municipal Code ("CVMC") section 2.0I.030(C) by Couneilmembers (including Mayor), the City Attorney, Board or Commission nten)bers, or (ally Depar4nreot Directors, Please review CVMC see( ion 2.01.030(C) to ensure that your aIlegat!oil (s) involves file Specified Prohibitiog%. Copies ofCVMC Chapters 2.01 and 2,28 are included with this Complaint �Orm packet, The board of Ethics does not haveJu lsdiction to hear complaints about other issues or individuals, but the Board of Ethics may refer such eourplaints to othor enforcement agencies. !n the complaint process, the Complaining party ("Complainnnt") bears the burden of proving that the Specified Prohibitions were violated. The Board of8thics acts as the hearing body for complaints involvi» g violafloris of the Specified Prohibitions, The Board of Ethics must be impartial Iii its actions. Tire complaint process begins with apr•imafacie review oftile Complaint. Aprhiiafacicreview involves an examination ofthe information contained fu this Complaint Form to determine if the complaint was timely tiled (a complaint must be filed within 90 days of the violation), involves a City Officiat (as described In CVNIC 2,01), aud'wltethor tlrp complaint conluins a spedifio and fitll set of facts whlch show that a Specif'fo Prohlbition has been violated, Therefore, it is ituporlont that you provide as much tactual and doWled information as possible, particularly in the narrative section of this complaint form (Suction 4), and completely describe the acts that forin the basis for the alleged vioJatloos of the Specified Prohibitions. As tJte Complainant, your Jiamo is not colrridetitial and would be pltblicly avtiilablo, If you believe your fume should be confidential, you may make a re'q etit (by completing; a request for conCden(inlity Tarin) to tite Hoard of Rdiios fen limited confl6titiality, if your request is granted, your name would be kept confidential for a litli ted Period, but may be disclosed during the probable cause stage of the pm coedings, Wyour request is not granted, you will have the option to citlier pursue Ore conlplabit with your nama not being; confidential or you may withdraw your ceurplaint, •PieM complete a separate complahrt form for caeh City Official you believe violated the Specified Prohibitions set fort()itr CVMC 2.01,030(0), lfyou have any questions, you gray consult with an attorney. You may also contact Clic City Attorney's Office if Y00 have questlorts about the form at (619) 691 5037, but they c!o uoi provide ndv,Ice as to the substance o.f a complaint, The Board of Bthics must be areutral and cannot assist ally party in tiro contplahit process. TJnuik you for taking lime to submit your complaint, Page 9 of 15 7/1.6 BOE Complaint Form and Instructions-tievlsed P3 (J 04/14/2017 7:07 AM yD4 t. COAIPI,AYNTANT(T'l�,'XLSONWXIOlSCOMPf,AINXN(Y)INf(OTZMA'tION . Por each person that is filing this complaint (henceforlh called the Complainarri(s)) please provide this .following rNuxred irarmation: REQUIRED INFORMATION � COMPLAINANT �u NAME Jeffrey Howerton ADDRESS CONTACT PHONE NUMBER .��._ .. EMAI - ... The name of the Cotrrplainant(s) is not eot)rideniial. If you want to keel) Yom- name confidential for a limited period of time, you may make request for confidentiality. 'I'o do so, cacti person complaining must complete a request :for con#identiality fort)), which Is included with this complaint packago. . REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIALITY (Check appropriate box) 0 Yes If there are irxore thata one Complainant, please provide tho above information for cath addiiional' persoii on an additional sheet of paper. 0 Check if additional pages are attached, j Page 4 of Is 7/16130E Complaint Form.and Instructions -Revised P4 G 04/19/2017 7:07 AM D 5 2. RESPONDRi NT WEIRSON YOU Alts COM PT,AINXNO A13010'r) SNVORLWA', ION Cor each Person you are complaitlhig about (hencoforth called a Respondent) plcaso provide tiro following required information: RESPONDENT I Person yoti are complaining about Is: FULL NAME; . '�t'45'��. rig.• -.a -. THE ABOVE PERSON IS (CHECK ONE); 0 Tk[ MAYOR 0 COUNCILMEMBER 0 CITY ATTORNEY 0 BOARD OR COMMISSION MEMBER NAME BOARD OR COMMISSION : CITY DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR NAME CITY DEPARTMENT; Police' 1•f the Respowlent is not listed above, plaasacontact (lie City Attorney's C7ffko a((619) 691,5037. 1'110 Board of Ethics is unable to hear complaints regarding individuals not listed above, but may be able to provide a rererrAt to another agency. If there is more than one Respondent please provide the above informatio,a for each additional Respond'eut on an additional sheet of 1l aper. n Check if additional pages attachod. Captain Lon Turner Lieutenant Miriam Byron 1,1utenant Don Redmond Page 5 of 15 7/16 DOC Complaint f=orm and InstructionS•Revised P5 0 04/l,9/2017 7.07 AM x 3, SPE CINED PROHIBITIONS , The following checklist is a summary of the Specified Prohibitions found in CVMC 2,01,030(0). please review the actual ianguago of tho Specified Prohibitions to otisar0 that your allogations involver it violation of the Specified Prohibitions, You will be required, in Section 4, to provfdo a frill detailed description of the alleged conduct showing a violation of the Specified Prohibitions, ifhe Board,ofWIlles only oonsiders violations of the Speeificd Prohibitions, Any other allot ation(s) will not be considered and the complaint will be dismissed. Icor each person you are complaining about,, 1)leas0 cOniplOte.tile below sentence and olieck 1116 applicable Gos(es) fildicatittg t'lio•SpOcificd Prohibition believed tci hiive' boost violated. 04/0412017 Lon Turner, Miriam Byron, don Redrnont On _ .r. [Insert date or dates of violation] _(Respondent) who is .,WI�inant (City title of Respondent who violated the following Spcgii'led Prohibitions] violated {lie below clieckcd box(es); CJ 1, The City official accepted gifts, favors, or promises of futuro bdtieCts, lvhloll might compromise or tend to impair independence ofjudgment or action. Gifts do not include campaign contributions authorized by the political Reform Act, 0 2, The City oftlolal used ihoirofficial 11110 or position for personal gain. Versrnral gain includes, but is not limited to situations, wherein a City Officlal solicits items Of value In consideration of their oiticial'title or position, 1. Tia City Official divulged confidential information far personal gain ar for the gain of associates in a manner contrasty to the public interest or in violation of flay law. C 4. 'rhe City pfficiai used or permitted the use of City resources for unapproved non -city activities, except when iivailable to the general public, provided for by administrative regulations or policies, or approved by City Council, 0 S. The City Offichil 11nproperly appeared on behalf of the private interests of third parties before [lie Council or any board, conanission or proceeding of the city, O - 6. The Rx -City Oftieial (trot including a former mayor or counclintcinber) within 12•111oilihs of leaving office linproperiy appeared, as a compensated representative, before City Council, tomtuission, board, city administrativo office or agency or officer or employee thercgf for 1110 purpose of influencing any action or pu�aeeWing involving 1110 Issuance, amendment, awarding, or revocation of a permit, license, grant, or contract for the sale of pu ollase of goods or properly, fl 7. The former member of the City Council, Including ilie;vfayor within 12 months of leaving office improperly appeared as a compensated representative before the Council, or any cornrtris3ion, board, or city staff in connection with any case or o(hor matte, wilt) which 110/5116 porsonally participatod while an official er employee of the City. Cl S. 41110 City Official endorsed or rccortuncuded for compensation any commercial product or service in the name of the City or in tite employea's official capacity within the City tyithoul prior.approva i by it City. Caw1cI1 policy, 0 9. The City official violated Government Code section 87100 related to f nanciai interosts and govenunental decisions made by them, fit 10, Tho City ofricisd coerced lltoir subordinates or any other City employee to participate In an election oampaigu, contribute to a candidntu or political commilt o, engage Id any oilier politico activity relating to a paaticular party, candidate, or issuo, or to refrain from engage in any lawfal political activity, rl 11, 'fire City official displayed campaign materials in any city owned vehicle tinder their cosh -al and operated by that City official. 11., `fho City Officlai aided and abWod another City Official to violate the SimiGc prohibitions set forth in tic Code of 81hics. U 13, '1110 City Official negotiated for employment with any person, firm, or organizatlon at the same time that aforementioned person, firm, or organization hada mailer trending before City Council, I3oa d or Commiss€art, or City department and upon which the City Official must act or make a recommendation, Page 6 of 15 7/16 DOE Complains form and Instructions -Revised C) 6 P6 4 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 07 4, DWRIP 110 OF FACTS Provide a speolric and fuli dmoriptiorl of'thc facts constituting 1110 alleged violation oftho Specitied Prohibitions set forth in UMC2,01,030(c). You rn11st inulutla the dafe(s) ofthc incideni(s), describe ilio Respondent's position in the City, and have a #'i ll and specific description of what occurred (lint Violated the Spccifiod Prohibitions set forttl in CVMC 2,01,030(C). Avoid making unsupported 0011elusions Or sper;trlatioll; The Board of I tlties'ouly holds jurisdi.ctio�i'ovec allcgstii�n. in'volvirig ilio Specified Prohibitions set forth in MC2.01-030(C), You play attach additiunnl sheLts as sccessa�y. Made PRA request after nonresponse regarding complaint to the Chula Vista PD. Received documents from Tamisha Woods that included Police Report 16097291. Upon follow up regarding missing into, received ema€ls and statement that due to 'Investigative process' records could npt be disclosed regarding complaint 17-13008-and;to••contacPBon-Redmond-�lvfttwas-in•charge-of-it: rrih"mails•-l-received; Lf -'--- Redmond had-been--in-eefaet-ivlth-PAST-sever-d-months-prierto having-made-my-setnplalnt,---- After questioning-"odrnond-via-or4aii4w-stated-he.•had-pe-knowledge-of-whai-1 was-referring'lo-aad-.asked If I could forward-it-ota.-T,bls-compelled-misgivings- the I sues.Lwas cam ining-abo,utis_mQlad-inmissiagL- information fromithe department's coordination with the Manhattan DA. After sending several officers to my my home wheie..tbeymado threars.,lhlt,tdina mem-%s.#,gm the M�nliataap p_A. ThQre were no re, Qrrds. The issues at hand which' compelled that, stem from I believe efforts from the reporting parties violating my privacy arid aliempting to eWhoi� commerc€ I_a opportunities. For exam feta feature film related to the anti nuclear movement from the 70s and 80s, There was no lnvestigation or consideration o any ev dence." They have 1io records oTt�iis, a rhe same t Ing an experence 'fu tlier repnman frdm [h`e arfnien-f" So when I discovered Lt Redmond had been working on something, where the parties at POST I never corresponds wi c oarly-iia o mvestlg`yaie w 1�o was e approlirla e c n ac at�VPD-Phis s�ve1'trrort7l�s prior to my complafnt�So when he responded he had no Idea what !was talking about, I stated it put the othlcacy of the investigation in doubt and was waiting to hear back from POST and would forward that. In a letter dated the following day, Lon Turner sent me a letter that Miriam Byron was in fact conducting an investigation and all parties were eKottewafed.+urther-mare *yi:ny+RA--to-post; f ey-re-sponded-immediately-after-statfng-they had no records. I am alleging that Lt Redmond shared the emails and evidence I provided to him and decided to divulge that €nformatieiHo-close-out-my-sese I laelleve-that IN y stem fr-0m-lacf�e# lrategrity-af iheinvestigaiion itself and the everts --prior to -than f am alieg€1�g-that..upon being:lnforraed.,thurrlo�.andiirlaraz -__.� Byron assisted him in deciding to close out my Investigation, Of which it only relates fb the events in June of 2016 ignoring my underlying.-cancerril>e.eventspriorwas al5Qit�farmatiort�elated tS�tber coordination with the Manhattan DA where there are I believe ethical issues etc. Please use my email for all communication, It fs the best means to contact me. 1.1 If more spaco is needed, please clleck tilk box land attach additional sheets as ncccssary page 7of15 7/16 ROE Complaint Form and Instructlons-Ruvlsad 1VA 0 04/19/2017 7:07 AM S. WTt'NI�SS;GS Provide the. following inf'ornnation about witnesses that can provid4 facts that support the alleged violations of thu Specified 1'Coltibitinns: WITNESS 111 NAME:: VaIna Wilson . ADDRESS: i CONTACT PHONE NUMBER: ^ E-MAIL, t Provido the witness' statemen(: none. please see attached emalls Provide the foIIowl ng inform atloh About Witnesses that cat providd facts thatsu1)port the apeged violations of the Specified Ptohlbillms: i WITNESS V NAME: Kardn LoAto ADDRESS; CONTACTl'llONf E-MAIL _. --•,__...,..._._.� -- Page 8 of 15 7/16 WE Complaint form and Instructlons-Revised t O 04/19/2017 7:07 AM Provide elle wltnoW stat6menth, none, lease see attached emails If mote space is needed tbi witness statements' or add itional w*ltfw4 sbs, pli:a-se check this box and altach additionat sheets as necessary 6, bocUMNTAA ION g 'List and attach copies of any doemnents in yom, possession that support the alleged violations of the 81iee1fled Prohibitions. In addition, in below whother there aro other records, not in your possession, that you believe would assist the Board of Ethics ut rovicwing the complaint. Documents Attached DoeutnentNaule �� ^ Description ofA11e,ation Support E�Il�fr�in POST to Lt Rodmond Don Redmond had prior involvement Ers�il f_ rom Lt Redmond to meDon Redmond stating he had no prior involvemen PRA from Tamisha Woods Don Redmond in charge o lnyestigting. _ CVPD SWno no records of me or events with NYC DA Other recol'da not aftached neetllilant NnIne ^IDesoriptioll efAilC atioll Sit Ott µ " Response from Lon Turner Caie' closed Immediately a erit emai]s to on '--- -- ___ _� -------- -- with no re erenLe aim. Instead alleglh`g mlrtM- - -- was conducting 111VOWi"�a-ti . RCt 1fi0 7� 29 ~ Write up of event eords frfro, m PERT No evidence investiqation was conducted 0 If 1110xe spam, is needed, plgpo olloo ( this box and attach additional sheets as nuossary Page 9 of 1.5 7/16 WE Complaint roan and Instructions -Revised Al a9 P9 0 04/1912017 7:07 AM 7. Xll±; M. FED a)'v P1,AI1Y')E S Have you or someono you know mado or filed the scone or similar complaint in a court or with another agency? Yes t:1 No EI if yes, identify the.couti �r agei>cy and attacit �.cctpy pf Wiry gonlpl<sini olid rospnttse, Briefly clescriba the complai»t and response below: t bin t hi' E� nC Nanio Dosedbe complaint & response__ _ CA State Auditor ,-,kms made. ggggrdno POST stating no records after receivintg teen from City of Vista. Ind iCatin� d _-.] Chula Vista PD made. Same Internal complaint mechanism F, _ _Just Pokeiitlal hacked email from Don Redmond.just m G If more spac:c is needed, please check this box and attach additional sheets as necessary 8. A.Dp J joNALlNFORML AWON Provide any additloaal i0ormati6n that you beliovo may assist this Hoard of .Ethics in evaluating this eptrtplaittt, As stated I have filed another complaint with the Chula Vista PD, However, there is no confidence internal Investigative process. I also filed with the FTC, I was informed via third parties that I have an NSA Investigation. This among other things. I believe there may be potential the email I received from U Redmond t valla; t reiieve-thls sit atlatrrelates-again to the#€ and ex�loita#ion of eet ereiai rojecis - One is a film related to the anti nuclear movement from the 70's and 80's, Former peers -from institutions such as Brow"r-individuals frem4e-NYG,area•-have-beedmE3 Involved: -I have4esolved-oonflrrnation-tr-trn-- a10 ,letion, ,de. some but very-Ifttle.-Far-exAopie, Rufris l lankey of f`tewseaa� alleging-in•an emai# his satteague Jeff Brodsky has in depth knowledge of my situation. I never heard back. They are based in Los Angeles, The point is I believe this instanse�caes provide fuffher•itasight into that, As-statedrit is meted In furtiaetissit�g-in#ortrtation after their coordination with the manhattan DA. The contents from POST Involve other government officials. For example,4iaRr4a4.Sath Jaslcso"ho..is- state -se terx y gt ndmothet:.wham4a -involvecWn-lheLanti-nuclear activities works with. i have rQpefved no response from POST and again after requesting records, they stated they have none. Unfortunately, i believe the ethics Issue may stem beyond the city of chula vista as well and entail coordination with other agencies at the: local, state (Including those beyond CA) and federal level. Either way, this evidence 1 do -belie prauides_aul�lence thaLali i►, to SPG Ptitail,.a mishandling of rny�Qncorras�lt�uesfiga Meaning the original complaint I made must be considered as it reflects a at this point years long trend, Cl If more space is needed, please check this box and attach addltiottal sheets as ncccm8ry Page 10 of 15 7/16 004 Complaint Form and instructions -Revised P10 :r O 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 9. 3Lr,,R;Ii+.CCATX0N S doolire under penalty of perjury, under the Laws of tlic State of Calilarnia, that tho above statemonts and in.tormaHon are true and correct: 04119/2017 Chula Vista, CA By; Sigu; Jeffrey Howerton _ (Typed or printed •name) - �� Si taturri� Irthoro is nuore-than oxtc Oompfainalrt, each ono must coanpleto the above voriftteation on a soporate sheet of pat}er. 0 Cluck of there are additional pages with complainant verifications. Witness 3 Chula Vista Cita Clerk's office Tamisha Woods Witness 4 City Attorney Michael Shir'ey ON . 0mamm Page 11 of 15 7/16 DOE Complaint form and Instructions -Revised a 11 P1l 0 01/19/2017 7:07 AM t2 BOE COIi PLAINTTOS211'.l INS` RUCI'lon The following are instructions to help YOU complete the I30I3 complaint form. If you require assistance you should seek the advice of all attorney, If you have questions regarding the complaint form you may contact the City Attoniey's Office at (619) 691-5037, but they do not advise as to thesubstance bf a complaint. `ectiaii X' CCoiiiplaiinarit)(nfbi matfonl: In tlii's secilon, the person (You) or persons (You and o(hers) who are complaining, also called Complainant(s), identify themselves and provldc the below listed contact information. 1, Provida complete name. 2, Provide complete address. 'Ibis address will be, used to send correspondence. 3. Please provide a phone number where you may be contacted. 4. Provide an email address. If there isnot enough room on ilia form or there are additional complainants, you may use additional sheets of paper and provlde the requested identifying information. Iii this section, the complainant can also request to have their nacre kept con#idential. The request fOr confidentiality is -for a limited period of time, usually up to the probable cause hearing (at which time there identify may become known). To request confidentiality, a separate farm must be completed and must meet the requirements or CVkW section 2.28.O90(C). Sc1. ctlon 2 fltesnoiulent informatiogj: In this ,section, ,Yost tiro asked to identify the person or pe�'sor�is'.you are complaitrang about, also called the Respondent, and their City position. The requlred information includes: 1. Completo name 01171cial City Title 3, Identify if the 1;espond�nt is the City of Chula Vista .Mayor, a Councilmember, the City Attomoy; a Board or Cdrilttrissioii Member, or a City of Chula Vista Depai-inrent Director. The Respondent crust either be the Mayor, a City Councilmember, the City Attorney, a City board or oomniisslon, me mbcr, or a City Department Director, referred to as "City Ofkicials" in the Code ofEthios. 'Che Board of Ealics docs not hear'complainls regarding other individuals. City dcparuncnts inohido: Development Services L)cptu,tiircrri, f3cononric Development Depar'tnieni, Finance Department, Dire Department, Hutiran Resources Department, information and Technologies Department., Library, Department, t'olico Dopartment, Public Works Department, and lteematiom Department. Page 12 of 15 7/16 DOE Complaint Form and lnstructions-Revtsed P12 © 04/19/2017 7:07 AM qn�013 3' If there is not enough room on the form, you may use additional sheets of paper and provide the reque:stcd identifying information. Section 3int. pe(lRied Prohibitions]; Ill this section, for each Respondetlt,1wert their name in the blank for "[Name]" and W30it their City title in the, blantc .fat• "[City Title]" and then check dw-Specit°1ed Pro'hibitiori(s) that you believe was violated, T1ne checklist of'the thilic en specified prohibitions is a sunullary. You should review the actual language for each Speolfied Prohibition found in Chula Vista Municipal Code section 2.01,030(C), a copy of which is hlclllded in tiffs GUIr2pJaitlt, package, Please complete the above steps for each City Official you are complaining about. You may use additional sheets of paper if needed; Please note that the Board of'Ethics can only consider complaints regarding the Specified Prohibitions found in Municipal Code section 2.01.030(0), but cannot consider complaints about the Guiding Principles found in Municipal Code section 2,01.030(A) and (B). Section 4 jDescription of Filets]: in this section, please describe, fOr each Respondent, the facts that show a violation of the Specified Prohibitions, Legal -typo langltago is not required. Instead, write it like a story un chronological order, You must include the specific date the violation occurred and describe in detail what f'nets show a violation of the Specified Prohibitions. ';_'he spccifio date the violations occurred is important because the complaint nlust be filed within ,90 days of the violation. Also, avoid malting unsupported conalusloas or engaging in speculation. This section is very important because the Board of Ethics uses the facts in this seotion to determine if a pr Najhc.1e showing has been, made and to continue BOB consideratlon of the complaint. You may attach additional sheets if you need more space, ecHolr 5 jittresses ; In this section, provide the following information for each witness that supports your complaint: 1. Full name 2, Complete; Address 3, Phone where they may be contacted 4. A -mall where they Inky contacted Icor each witness, have thein write a statement detailing what facts they would provide that shows a violation of the Spoo f~zed Prohibitions. If that cannot bo done in ti.me, a sunvolary of what they woutd say is acocpt�ible. Also, the witness Dust be sonmeone you spoke with a.nd know what they will say. A wiftims is not someone who you think will say something in support of'your complaint, Please complete the above steps fot each witness. Please note that as the case progresses, the witnesses may be called to testify before the Bop -at a hearing on the merits of the complaint, Page 1.3 of 1S 7/16130E Compialnt norm and Instructions -Revised P13 EJ 04/19/2017 7;07 AM - •—MIJI.M. Section G Mocuxnentatiottl; III this section, provide copies any documents that support your allegation of a violation of the Specifted Prohlb! Iion. You may also provide web links to the documents if they ai•e oto the internet. Also, If you aro specifically aware of documents that exist, but aro not in your possession, please explain what tho documents are, what information they will contain, and where they are located, Section? Il2elat4ci Coin�ilaints ; In chis section, provide copies cif coi�tpla,inis that gq the same or" sitiiilar as lite ciurent complaint or related to the current complaint that you have.filed with another ugcney or couij. Other agencies may inelude District Attorney's Office (DA), Attorney General's Office (AG), or Fair Political Practides Commission (1!PPC), if you have received a response ftoin that other agency, please include that as well. !_action 8 fAdditiottal Inforinationl; if there is atay Vorination that you have not yet provided in this.complaint form, but believe such h1formntion is relevant and would assist the Board of Ethics in determining if there is a violation of the Specified Pro1bibition3, please provide that information is this section, if you are not sure, it is better to provide too much information than not enough, and you may provide such in Coronation in this section, Seetloii 9 {'Verification(; Chula Vista Municipal -Code section 2,28,090 requires that the complaint be signed and filed under penalty of perjury, Each pei;son that is making the ooniplaint must sign the complaint under penalty of perjury. Page 14 of 15 7/16 BOE Complaint Form and Instructlom-Revised D 14 P14 04/19/2417 7:07 AM RBQ J13ST FOR CONI:IUENTIAI.HY ,FORM A persolr filing a compinmt that a Specified Prohibition has bean vlolatod may Pilo a request to koep their name and Other identifying hiformallan (together called "identifying Iaiformation") confidential pursuant to CVMC section 2,28,090(0), '1110 complainant filing [lie request bears the burden of showing good "llso that their Identifying Information should bo kept confidential. •A separrto request must be submitted by each complainant requesting to keep their Identifying Inforiiiation confidential. The conftdentiolity is l(mited, and their namo.tnay 4 released at the probable cruse stage of the pr000cdings. If the request is deliied, tlhe ooinptainant must either )vithdraw their complaint or proceed tivith their name being public -ally available. 1, (Name], hereby request that my Identil�,ing Information bo kept confidential, pursuant to C:VMC Section 2,2$.090(0), and that good cause exists to do so beo<ar1se [011001( one that applies]: 11 The existence of an employer/employee or supervisor/subordinato relationship between respondent and winplairiant or the existence of such n relationship bolsveon complainant's spouse or immediate relatives) and respondent or respondent's spouse or immediate relative; ❑ Facts that show that complainant would be shunned, ostracized, or rebuked by an organization or group to which they oolong if their nama ware to bo made public:; 0 Syidenpe of prior acts ofrotallation or harm by respondent against complainant or any other person; ❑The ox#stence oftriminal convictions for crimes of violence by or tho existence of any restraining orders against respondmit; or 0 00ier Describe (in detail) in the-foliowing section belowwhy your Identlf ing Information shuld be kept rontidential. Cnnciusiatal� n:' speculative s#atenhents of J1a1�n or r:ctaiiation are: insuflieient to establish good cause. I declare under the rcnafty of perjury the following: 0 If snore space is needed, please check this box and attach additional shoots as necessary Signature: Date: Page 15 of 15 7/15 90F Complalat Form and Instructions-Rovised D 15 P15 0 0411.912017 7:07 ANl III Mill, 11111 711WO16 GIVer 20100OR OF ETHICS Chapter 2.01 CODE OF ETHICS Sections: 2.01,010 Establishment of the code, of ethfcs, 2.01.020 Application of the code of ethics. 2.01.030 Code of•athlbs. 2,01.040 Severability.. 2,01.010 Establishment of the code of ethics. Public office Is a public trust and City officials shall exercise their public duties in a manner that preserves that trust. The public's trust can best be preserved if City officials adhere to a high standard of ethics that transcends the standards prescribed by law. Nigh ethical standards require that all City officials understand and avoid unethical behavior, Unethical behavior can develop In a variety of situations, but It occurs when the public Interest Is not the sole and paramount Interest In all actions conducted by all City officials, The purpose of this chapter Is to encourage the highest standards of behavior by City officials, Increase public confidence In City officials, to identify and take appropriate action with respect to unethical behavior, and to assist City officials with decision- making in areas of ethical concern, Accordingly, the code of ethics Is hereby established. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2,01.020 Application of the code of ethics, The code of ethics shall apply only to City officials. "City officials" shall mean members of the Chula Vista City Council, including the Mayor, the City Manager, the City Attorney, the City Clerk, board members and comitmissloners, Assistant City Managers, City department heads, as will as ex -City officials•who were subject to this chapter, The Board of Ethics shall investigate vlolations of the code of ethics as set forth In Chapter 2.28 CVMC. (Ord, 3204 § 1, 2013), 2,01.030 Code of ethics. The code of ethics Is divided into two areas: guiding principles, as set forth in subsections (A) and (B) of this section, and specific prohibitions, as sot forth in subsection (C) of this section. The guOng principles are Intended to provide a set of principles from which City officials can draw upon to assist them In conducting the public's -business. As such, 'Ihe guldincd principles are directory in nature and not subject to tiro complaint procedures sot forth in CVMC 2.2$.090 through22, 8,150, The specific prohibitions are actions that City officials shall not engage in, and, as such, are subject to the complaint procedures set forth in CVMC 2,28.090 through 2,28.1 &Q, A. Guiding Principles, The public judges its government by the way City officials conduct themselves in the posts to which they are elected or appointed. All City officials should conduct themselves In a manner that Wit tend to preserve public confidence in, and respect for, the government they represent. The purpose of these guiding principles is to encourage the highest standards of behavior by Cityofflclals, transcending the standards required by law; Increase public confidence In the City officials that serve the public; and assist City officials with decision-making in areas of ethical concern. City officials, In the performance of their duties, should strive to adhere to the following guiding principles: d16 h16vlluu.rnn,lneulJlDhl,v.....n,IrAIll NJwkfgb.toll It, C,..—A. 111-11" n4 P16 09/19/2017 7:07 AM1111 11111OP 711 8120 1 8 chaplet 2.01 cOUE� OF E71i1es 1. City officials are agents of public purpose and hold office for the benefit of the public. As such, City officials have a duty to act in the best Interests of the public. City officials must strive to protect the public's resources through diligent and Judicious management. 2. City officials should not engage In, permit, or condone fraud, but should be proactive to Identify fraud and seek to correct the causes that lead to the fraud, Fraud In public service includes, but is not limited to, making false or misleading representations about a material fact or engaging In deceitful conduct. 3, City pfflclals should not engage In, permit, or condone.waste, but should be proactive to Ida ntify waste and seek to correct the causes that lead to the wasta. Waste In public service involves the extravagant, careless, or needless expenditure of City funds, or the consumption of City property, that results from deficient practices, systems, controls, or decisions. 4. City officials should not engage in, permit, or condone abuse, but should be proactive to IWntlfy abuse and seek to correct the causes that lead to the abuse. Abuse involves the Improper use of City resources, Including abuse of position, authority, or resources such as tolls, vehicles, or other City property. 6. City officials must be loyal to the public they serve and should put the public's interests above their personal interests, 6, City officials must protect and enhance the Image and reputation of the City, 7. City officials must treat all citizens condorting business with the City with due courtesy, efficiency, and Impartiality, and no one citizen shall receive special advantage, 8. City officials must always be mindful of the public trust and confidence in the exercise of their assigned duties and shall refuse to condone breaches of public trust or Improper attempts to influence the decision-making process. 9. City officials must always be mindful of conflict of interest law,, and abide by them. 10. City officials must be wAQre of all their financial Interests, thereby ensuring that such financial interests do not Influence their conduct or actions, 11. City officials should avoid an appearance of a conflict of interest when possible. Recusal or abstention is appropriate when a good falth determination has been made by the City official that such action is required. Fbwever, elected officials subject to this chapter are reminded that they are elected to conduct the public's business and should not abstain or recuse themselves without cause, 12. City officials are expected to abide by all local, stale, and federal laws. 13. The City values the ability of the boards and commissions to provide honest, forthright, learned, and independent advice to the City, thereby fostering greater public input into the conduct of City government. Accordingly, while City officials may attend City board and commission meeting, City officials should be mindful that their actions, whether intentional or not, may unduly Impair or Influence the boards' and commissions' ability to provide honest, forthright, learned, and independent advice to the City and, therefore, Clty officials should avoid such actions. 017 (D 04/14/2017 7;07 AM 711fl12r)1$ ChWer2,01 CODE of ETHICS B. Additional Guiding Principles for Board of Ethics Members, In addition to the guiding principles set forth in subsection (A) of this section, Board of Ethics members should adhere to the foiloWng: 1, A Board of 5lhics member that is a candidate for elected office should not engage in political or campaign activity that Is inconsistent with the Independence, Integrity, ar Impartiality of the Board of Ethics, Including, but not limited to, commenting on complaints that have been before or may appear before the Board of Ethics or endorsing another candidate for any elected office using their title as current or former Board of Ethics member. A reference by a Board of Ethics member, in their own campaign materials, that they are or have been a me6iber of the Board of Ohios alone does not violate this guiding prfhclpia. 2. A Board of Ethics member should conduct their outside activities so as to minimize the risk of conflicts With their duties as a Board of Ethics member. 3, A Board of Ethics member should perform their duties Impartially. To accomplish the aforementioned ghiding principle, a Board of Ethics member should refrain from participating In a matter before the Board of Ethics when they have a personal interest In the matter or, outside of a Hoard of Ethics meeting, have advocated, supported, or taken a position on that matter, • C. Specific Prohlbitiohs, it 1s prohibited and shat1 be deemed unethical for a City official to engage In one or more of the following actions: • 1, Aecepi gifts, favors, or promises of future benefits, which might compromise or tend to Impeir Independence of judgment or action. 2. Use their official title or position for personal gain, Personal gain includes, but Is not limited to, situations wherein a City official solicits or accepts items of value In consideration of their official title or position, This section does not include obtaining benefits that are otherwise authorized by law. 3, Divulge confidential information for personal gain or for the gain of associates In a manner contrary to the public Interest or In violation of any law, 4, Else or permit the use of City resources including but not limited to funds, seals or logos, City time, personnel, supplies, equipment, identification cards/badges or facilities for unapproved non -City activities, except when available to the general public-, provided for by administrative regulations or policies, or approved by City Council. 5. For current City officials, appear on behalf of the private interests of third parties before the Council or any board, commission or proceeding of tha City; nor shall members of boards, commissions, and other advisory boards appear before their ovm bodies or before the Council on behalf of the private interests of third parties on matters related to the areas of service of their bodies, except for limited exceptions, as provided for in Fair Political Practices Commission Regulaflons, Including Section 18702.4, 6. No ex -City official (riot including former elected City officials) for a peribd,of one year after leaving office or empfoymant shall, for compensation, act as an agent or attorney for, or otherwise represent, any other person by making oral or written communication before any City administrative offloe or agency or officer or employee thereof, if the appearance of 418 P18 O 04/19/2017 7:07 AM Wr MOW Chafter2.01CODE dFETHICS communication is made for the purpose of influencing any action or proceeding l6volving tho issuance, amendment, awarding, or revocation of a permit, license, grant, or contract for the sale or purchase of goods or properly. 7, No former member of the City Council, including the Mayor, shall be eligible to appear as a compensated representative at any time before the Council, or any commission, board, or City staff in connection with any case or other matter with whlch iiefshe personally parilelpated,whilo an official or employee of the City for 12 months following the date of separation from elected or appointed office, except by permission of the City Council finding on four�-fifths, Vote.that- special Identified. and orticulatod,circumstanCos exist, cast at a regular public meeting taken after the Involved member of the City Council has left office, Such special identified and articulated circumstances Include, but are not limited to, determinations that it is In the best Interest of the City to permit such representation, that the former Councilmernber, including the Mayor, Is uniquely qualified to appear on the matter, or It Is Impractical to require another representative to appear on the matter, 8. Endorse or recommend for compensation any commercial product or service In the name of the City or In the employee's official capacity within the City without prior approval by a City Council policy, 9. Violate Government Code Section 87100 related to financial interests and governmental decisions made by them. If a complaint is filed with the Board of Ethics alleging a violation of this subsection, the Board of Ethics recognizes that the 1~air Political Practices Commission ('FPPC") is the primary enforcement authority of the Political Reform Act and that their decisions should be given great weight. As such, If a complaint is filed concurrently, then the Board of Ethics may defer action on such allegation, as set forth in this chapter. If a complaint is not filed conourrently, the board of Ethics may submit a complaint to the FPPC and defer action until such complaint is addressed by the FPPC, A ruling on the merits by the FPPC maybe accepted as a finding of tho Board. 10, No City official shall coerce any of their subordinates or any other City employee to participate in an election campaign, contribute to a candidate or political committee, engage in any outer political activity relating to a particular party, candidata, or Issue, or to refrain from engaging In any lawful political activity, A general statement encouraging another person to vote does not violate this prohibitlon, 11. No City official shall display campaign materials in any City -owned vehicle under their control and operated by that City official, Campaign materials include, but are not limited to, ' bumper stickers, sighs, or other similar items, '12. No City official shall aid and abet another City official to violate the specific prohlblilons enumerated In this subsection, nor shall they aid and abet any person to engage in conduct that would constitute a violation of the specific prohibitions enumerated in this subsection on their behalf, 13, No City official'shall negotiate for employment with any person, firm, or organization at the same time that aforementioned person, firm, or organization has a matter pending before City Council, board or commission, or a City department and upon which the City official must act or make a recommendation, (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013), D19 IdlnlAwAurrrkw�f IktS�vi �m 7rarrtMdn�na�att,It' NJtir�,omkli J. WYM A )M w-J+nnt "I I ' P19 O 04/19/2417 7:07 AM WiMo16 Charter 2,01 C41lH of ETHICS 2.01.040 5avera;blilty, If any provision of this chapter, or the application of any such proylslon to any person or circumstance, shall be held invalid, the remainder of (his chapter to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of those provislons to persons or circumstances other than those as to Mich it is held Invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of Oils chapter are severable, (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013), Mobile Version D 20 ttklhJlW�.ycodohuW(st�nu,ccxttiC/UciwlnVltlnlA!!( hidAU+cls ill( MAnVIaI�t19M ►dmJfro ni W9 P20 p 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 7/1812016 Char 2,28 BOARD OF EV RCS' - Chapter 2,28 130ARD OF nTHICS* sections, 2,28,010 Establishment of the Board of Ethics. 2.28,020 purpose. 2.28,030 Bunctlon and duties of the Board of Ethics, 2,28,040 Powers of the Board of Ethics, 2.28.050 Membership. 2.28.060 Meetings and staffing. 2,28.070 Order of business, 2,28,080 Advisory opinions, 2.28.085 Board referral for investigation. 2.28.090 Complaints-- Form, referral to other enforcement agency and requests for confidentiality, 2,28,100 Complaint procedures — Receipt of complaint. 2,28.110 Complaint prooedtires —prima facie review. 2.28.120 Complaint procedures -» Probable cause hearing. 2,28.130 Complaint procedures — Hearing on the merits. 2,28,140 Complaint procedures —Decision after hearing an the merits. 2.28.150 Conflicts. 2.28,160 Disclosure of Board records, 2.28,170 Severability. ' Prior legislation: Prior code % 1.48 --1,61; Ords. 1040, 2297, 2463, 2629, 2630 and 2778. For provisions of Charlpr law concerning appointive boards and commissions, see Cfty Charter §§ 600 606, Code roviser`s note: Section 4 of Ordinance 3264 provides: "Violations of Chapter 22;.28 that occurred prior to the effective date of this Ordnanco, shall bo subject to the prov{slons• of Chapter 2.28 and/or Board of Ethics policies or procedures in effect before the effective date of this Ordinance." 2,28'.010 BStablNhment of the Board of Ethics, The Board of Ethics is hereby created, The provisions of Article VI of the Chula Vista City Charter, Chapters 2 01 and 2.,2-6 CVMC, and this chapter shall govern the Board of Ethics. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013), 2,28.620 Purpose. It Is the purpose of the Board of Ethics to advise and make recommendations to the City Council of the City of Chula Vista on all matters relating to potential unethical conduct and to make such necessary and appropriate recommendations to the City Council for the implementation of the code of ethlos, as set forth In Chapter 2.41 CVMC, and amendments thereto, which may become necessary from time to time. The Board or Ethics will serve as a hearing body for violations of the code of ethics, as sat forth In Chapter 2,D1 CVMC, and shall render Impartial and objective opinions and ensure that those covered by the code of ethics are appropriately Informed. D21 P21 09/19/2017 7;07 AM 022 71180 16 Chapter 228 BOARD OF ETHICS' Members of the Board of Ethics should be aware that they are in a unique position of trust given their role under this chapter and as such must strive to avoid any appearance of blas or partiality. Accordingly, they should be aware that their conduct and actions will be scrutinized by the public at all times, but particularly during the election cycle, (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013), 2.28.030 Function and duties of the l9oard of Ethics, It shall be the function of the Board of Ethics to implement the code of ethics as set -forth in this chapter. The duties of the Board of Ethics shall be; A. To receive or initlate complaints of vioiatlphs of the code of ethics, B, To hear and investigate complaints and transmit the findings and recommendations to the City Council. C. To render advisory opinions or interpretations with respect to the application of the code of ethics and this chapter, either on request or on its own initiative. D. To propose revislons of this chapter or other City policies to assure Its continuing pertinence and effectiveness. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2,28.040 Powers of the Board of Ethics, tri order to carry out its duties, the Board of Ethics is authorized to receive complaints, conduct Investigations upon complaints or information received, make referrals to other governmental agencies regarding unethical conduct, hold hearings, svmar witnesses, yonder advisory opinions and adopt rufos of procedure for the conduct of its business. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2.29.050 Membership. , A, The Board of Ethics shall be composed'of seVen members, to be appointed in accordance with Article VI of the City Charter, Chapter 2 2� CVMCr and this chapter, Irregularitlos in the Interview process set forth in CVMC 2,2 . (b) may be brought to the attention of the City Council, B. No person shall be appointed as a memb.er of the Board of Ethics, or shall be entitled to retain their membership, if he or she, Within the past 10 years prior to the date of appointment,_ has been convicted of any felony or a crime involving moral turpitude, has been found to have committed a criminal violation of the Fair political Practices Act, or has a conflict of Interest as defined in this chapter, C. A "conflict of interest" for purposes of this section shall mean the following; 1. The applicant or any of applidant's relatives is or has bean an employee of or sought employment from any City official subject to this chapter; 2. The applicant or any of applicant's relatives is or has been supervised in an employment setting by any City offtoiai subject to this chapter; 3. The applicant has served in any capacity (including staff member, advisor, or volunteer) involving the election, selection, or appointment of any City, official subject to this chapter to any public office (elected or appointed); 4. The applicant has served In any capacity (including staff member, advisor, or volunteer) opposing tho election, selection, or appointmerft of any City official subject to this chapter to P22 o 04/19017 7:07 AM 7Ha'2016 ChrgW 2.28 BOARD OF F:;rHIGS' any public office (elected or appointed); or 5, The applicant is related to any City official subject to this chapter, D. This section Is not retroactive: (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013), 2,28.060 Meetings and staffinn. The Board of Ethics WIJ hold meetings as set forth in CVMC 26 00(A)(2), The City Attorney or his or her appointed representative shall act as secretary to the board. The secretary shall cause notice of the meetings of the board to be kept and distributed, The secretary shall-alao give appropriate and required Wtten notice of all meetings to all members'and parsons having business before the board, (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013), 2,28.070 Order of business, A. The following shall be the order of business for all meetings; 1. Roll call of members, 2, Reading of minutes of previous meeting. 3. Amendment or approval of minutes of previous meeting, 4. Consideration of matters continued from previous meeting, 5. Consideration of new complaints, or requests, 6. Consideration of proposed or ewsting stats legislation In the field of ethics and amendments to the code of ethics of the City of Chula Vista, 7. Other business, 8, Oral communication, The aforementioned order of business may be modified by an affirmative vote of the Board of Ethics, B, Items of business shall be placed on the agenda as set forth in CVMC 2,25 2 0(A), (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013), 2,28,080 Advisory opinions. When a City official has doubt as to the applicability of a provision of this chapter to a particular situation, he or she may make a written inquiry to the Board of Ethics for an advisory opinion, The purpose of the advisory opinion is to assist the City official in the task of judging themselves, so as to enable them to properly carry out their rospOil sibillties as trustees in the public interest, and to conform their conduct to the coda of ethics, The City official shall have the opportunity to present their Interpretation of the facts at Issue and of the applicable provisions of this chapter before such advisory opinion is rendered, The Board of Ethics may also, on its own,initlative, Issue advisory opinions regarding the interpretation or Implementation of any provision of this chapter. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2,28,085*13oard referral for investigation. A, If an individual BOE mernber personally observes a violation of the code of ethics, he or she 023 M,JJ_JA...... w J,...P.,IwLI...........InA 066,J.AAU„lj%t_„1.tA_, .1 P23 G 04(19(2017 7:07 AM 711wai6 Chapter 2.28 HOARD OF ETHICS' may Inform the BOE, and request that the matter be referred to a panel attorney ("Panel Attorney') that is serving as the enforcement authority under Chapter 2�G2 CVMG for investigation, 13, If a panel to serve as the enforcement authority has not been established, the Board of Ethics shall establish, In a manner similar to the process used to create the panel for the enforcement authority, a panel of attorneys to serve pursuant to this section, C. The Board of Ethics may refer the matter to a Panel Attorney if the BOE member presenting the request makes a prima facle shoving as set forth in CVMC 2,28.1.10. This provision may not be used In the place of or to circumvent the other provisions in this chapter -for the submission of compWrlts. Once a BOE mamber 'submits a request under this section and the molter is submitted to a Panel Attorney, they shall recuse themselves from voting on the complaint. 0. The BOE referral shall go to a Panel Attorney for Investigation and determinatlon If probable cause exists on the complaint, The Panel Attorney may dismiss the complaint If he determines that probable cause does not exist or If he concludes he cannot prove flint probable cause exists, if he dismisses the case for lack of probable cause, lie shall inform the Board of Ethics and provide a basis for the dismissal, if the panel attorney determines that probable cause exists, he shall present his case as set forth In CVMC 2 2 .120 for determination by the Board of Ethics if probable cause exists, if the Board of Ethics determines that probable cause exists, another Panel Attorney will continue the investigation for submission to the BOE for a full hearing. Panel Attorneys assigned under this subsection Wil be assigned in the same manner they are assigned to investigate complaints for violations of Chapter 2.52 CVMC. The Panel Attorney shall present the matter for full hearing as sat'forth In CVMC 2,ZL1_30. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013), 2,28,090 Complaints — Form, referral to other enforcement agency and requests for confidentiality. A, All complaints regarding violations of -this chapter shall be In writing, identify a person subject to the code of ethics, contain a full allegation of facts that would constitute a violation of the specific prohibitions enumerated in this chapter, and be sworn under penalty of perjury. All alleged violations must be submitted within 90 days of occurrence or when it should have been discovered with the exercise of reasonable diligence, Justification for any delay In filing complaints is the responsibility of the complainant. t~or complaints concerning unethical patterns of behavior, such complaints must be recelved by the Hoard of Ethics within 90 days of the most recent event comprising the pattern of behavior complained of, or within 90 days of Wien the last event should have been discovered with the exerclse of reasonable diligence. The Board of Ethics will, in its discretion, limit the pattern of behavior to those events the Board of Ethics feels are proximately related in time to be a part of the same pattiern of behavior, B. The Board may refer tha,matter to a local, state, or federal enforcement agency that may have JurhSdictlon over the mattor at any st�go of the procoedings and may hold In abeyance Hoard actlon pending results of the referral. The Board of Ethics may, but is not required to, resume Board action on the matter if It has been provided notice of Inaction by the agency to whom the complaint was referred, the expiration ofany applicable statute of iimitaIlona, or inaction for more than one year by the agency to whom the complaint was referred, focal, state and federal enforcement agencies include, but are not limited to, the United States Attorney's Office, the California Attorney General's Office, the San Diego County district Attorney's Office, the San Diego County Grand Jury, and the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC). If the Board learns of misconduct during any stage of the proceedings, but the misconduct is not within the specific 024 W11A..nnn... "It ht.,.,v„It' AhlS., 4,NAim..asr...,.nIt, ,»e..Ir...,..nn�r,w..,,un.v, ! P24 W- 0 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 0 25 711ty a Chapler 228 BOARD OF ETHICS' prohibitions set forth in this chapter, the Board of Ethics may mako a referral to the appropriate local, state, or federal enforcement agency that may have jurisdiction over the alleged misconduct. C. The name of the complainant shall be disclosed unless the complainant has requested that their name be kept confidential and there is good cause to withhold such name, Requests for confidentiality shall be addressed as follows: 1, To request that their name be kept confidential, the complainant must provide, with their complaint, a detailed factual statement, sworn under penalty of perjury, that they v4uld suffer harm or retaliation if their name were to be disclosed, Facts that may be considered to deterimine if'doad cauao exists may include, but are not limited to a, The e)48tence of an employer/employee or supervisor/subordinate relationship betwmen respondent and complainant or the existonce of such a rolatlonshlp between complainant's spouse or immediate relativo(s) and respondent or respondent's spouse or Immodlate relative; b. Pacts that show that complainant would be shunned, ostracized, or rebuked by any organlzatlon or group to which they belong If their name were to be made public; c. Evidence of prior acts of retaliation or harm by respondent against complainant or any other person; d, The existence of criminal convictions for crimes of violence by or the existence of any restraining orders against respondent, Concluslonary or speculative statements of harm or retaliation are Insufficient to establish good cause. 2. Upon a request for confidentiality, the Ghalr and two Board members, chosen by the Chair on a rotating basis, shall form an ad hoc subcommittee within two business days of being Informed by the City Attorney's Office of a request for confidentiality and, after consideration of the request, determine If good cause exists to withhold disclosure of the name, The Chair shall Inform the complainant of its decision within five business days, I If tho decislon Is to deny the request for confidentiality, complainant shall have five business days to withdraw their complaint, If complainant requests that the complaint be Wthdram, the entire complaint shall be returned to complainant and their complaint shall riot be disclosed, The complaint and complainant's name shall be not disclosed during this evaluation process, 4. Upon a finding of good cause by the ad hoc subcommittee formed under this section, the name of [fie complainant shall be kept confidential unless and until a finding of probable cause is made, The complaint shall also be redacted accordingly. (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013), 2.28.160 Complaint procedures — Recelpt of complaint, A. The following procedures will be followed upon receipt of a complalnt: 1, The complaint will be assigned a case number. 2. The complainant ("complainant") will be sent a letter that provides notice that the complaint Itqu:IAMvvxa>Pnuf�Ilsl�rm,rm�GA/t;Fuf�Vsl�urintui,ua! n�rra,aAvr.rvn7s�t WII)ox rrin P25 0 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 026 711N2010 Chalef Z26 HOARD OF ETHICS" was received, the date of the next hearing In which the complaint will be addressed, and Mich generally explains the procedures that will be followed, 3. The subject of the complaint (hereinafter "respondent") will be sent a letter that provides notice that a Complaint has been received naming them as the subject, the date of the next hearing In Witch the complaint will be addressed, and which generally explains the procedures that will be followed. The respondent will also be sent a copy of the complaint with the letter. The complaint may be redacted as provided for in CVMC 2.,2i,090(C) (related to confidentiality requests). 4. The Chair of the Board of Ethics shall be notifiod that a complaint has been received. Notwithstanding any other time frames, the Chair may set a special meeting on the complaint. 5. A preliminary review (hereinafter "prima facie revlev/') of the complaint Wit be set within 30 days of receipt of the complaint. If the complaint Is received Wthin 90 days of a municipal election In which a City official is a candidate, the prima facie review of the complaint will be set within. 15 days of the receipt of the complaint. The Chair and members shall be sent copies of the complaint for their reviewprlor to the hearing. The Chair and members receiving copies of the complaint shall not discuss the complaint nor disclose the complaint to any person outside of the hearing. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2.28.110 Complaint procedures — Prima facie rev -low. The Board of Ethics will conduct a prima facie review ('prima facie •review') of the complaint. The purpose of prima facie review is to determine if the complainant has made a prima facie showing that the complaint complies with the requirements in CVMC 2.26,090(A) (Complaints — Form, referral to other enforcement agency, and request for confidentiality), thereby establishing jurisdiction A prima facie review may result in the following; A. N6 Prima Facie showing Made — Dismissal. After completing the prima facie review, the Board may dismiss the complaint for any of the following reasons; 1. The complaint Is not in writing or is not made under penalty of perjury; 2, The respondent is not a City official within the meaning of this chapter; 3. The complaint does not contain a full allegation of facts that would constitute a violation of the specific prohibitions enumerated In this chapter; 4. The complaint restates other complaints containing essentially similar or Identical allegations that have already been disposed of, and the evidence presented doss not warrant reopening of the previous case; 5. The allegations contained In the complaint are already under investigation by the Board of Ethics; 6. The complaint consists of speculation, opinion, frivolous contentions, or absurd accusations; or .7. The Board of Ethics determines other good cause requires dismissal, If tite dismissal Is for this reason, the good cause must be set forth In the minutes of the preliminary review. hltn:lhut�v,codeouhftslann.crn�lraX:tulnvls�s+totic.�uaa�ra�;�M/rw�r+�ra):�rooul,r,�.i�t7 as ,;,.n I P26 p 04/19/2017 7:07 AM • Y10016 Chsrlar2.26 BOARD of ETHICS' If the complaint is dismissed, the Board shall Issue a fetter to the complainant and respondent as soon as possible, indicating the reason for the dismissal of the complaint. Such letter Is not a conclusive finding and Is not Intended to be evidence In any enforcement action initiated by another agency, B. Prima Facie Shovving Made -- Further Action, if the Board determines that a prima facie showing has been made, then the Hoard shall determine the appropriate course of action, including the following; 1, the Board may request additional information from complainant or the respondent. The Board shall endeavor to complete thls action within 46 days from the prima facie finding, if the Information is not received within the 46 days, such fact shall be reported to the Board, After this stage is complete, the matter should be set for a probable cause hearing within 30 days. 2, The Board may preate an ad hoc subcommittee comprised of one to three board members to conduct further Investigation. The ad hoc subcommittee shall endeavor to complete its Investigation within 90 days of the prima facie finding. if the invest1dation is not completed within the 90 days, such fact shall be reported to the Board. After this stage is complete the matter should be set for a probable cause hearing wfthln 30 days, 3. The Board may hire an individual from a list of prequalified Investigators to conduct an Investigation. This provision Is subject to available funding. The investigator shall endeavor to complete the investigation within 90 days of the prima facie finding. If the Investigation is not completed within the 90 days, such fact shall be reported to the Board. After this stage is complete the matter should be set for a probable cause hearing within 30 days. The Board of Ethics shall establish a written policy for the selection of preggallfied Investigators. In determining qualifications, the Hoard of Ethics shall consider, but is. not limited to, the following; a,, Professional licensing; b, EVerience In conducting investigations; c. Area'or areas of expertise required -for the Investigation; d. Available support staff; e. Reasonable costs; f. The existence of conflicts of interest; g. Proven ability to time(y complete: tasks. 4. The Board may set the matter for a probable cause hearing. The Board shall endeavor to set the probable cause hearing within 45 days of the prima facie finding, (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013}, 2.26.120 Complaint procedures -- Probable cause hearing. The purpose of the probable cause hearing Is to determine if thero are facts and circumstances, of a'reasonably trustworthy nature, sufficient to jus(ify a person of reasonable caution or prudence in the belief that a violation of the specific prohibitions has occurred ("probable cause"). To find D 27 hHnli+U.+txlnty+tlil,hixt,rxanJ�N�tuOAM-14110kdnAsIn1VINOsA40an92Ai+"400A 7++n + P27 CD 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 7102016 Chvdor 228 BOARD Or GTIMS, probable cause, there must be an affirmative vote -of the majority of the entire voting membership. The following procedures shall be followed in the conduct of a probable causo hearing: A. Both parties shall be provided notice that the probable Cause hearing has been set. B, The complainant and rospondent shall be informed that they may lodge with the Board 10 days before the hearing addl(lonal evidence and a statement on their behalf for the Board's consideration. If such evidence is not provided to the Board within the time frame indicated, the Board may, but is not required to, exclude such evidence. As soon after receipt of such evidence by the Board, the Board should endeavor to provide the opposing party a copy thereof, C, At the hearing, the Board shall review, but Is not limited to, the following; the complaint, Including any supporting documents, that was filed; Information acquired during any Board - ordered Investigation or request for information; and any other documents or evidence provided to the Board before the probable cause hearing. D. The Board, In its discretion, may permit additional documents or evidence to be admitted Into the probablo'cause hearing, Tha Board, In Its discretion, may also permit witnesses to testify. Witnesses may be subject to cross-examination, as permitted by the Board, E. Both parties may comment on the Issue of probable cause, as permitted by the Brown Act. 1~, If the Hoard determines that probable cause does not exist, the Board shall dismiss the complaint. 0. If the Board determines that probable cause exists, the Board should set a hearing on the merits within 46 days thereafter, (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013}, 2.28.130 Complaint procedures —.Hearing on the merits. If probable cause Is determined to exist by the Board, then the Board shall conduct a hearing on the merits ("hearing on the merits') as set forth herein: A, Prior to the hearing on the merits, the Board may request additional Information as set forth In CVMG 2,28A 0(B). The Board should set a date by which a request for additional information should be completed. B. Both parties shall be provided notice of the hearing on the merits. The Board may provide copies of materials upon which the complaint is based to either party. C. In the discretion of the Board, complainant may present an opening and closing statement, present additional evidence and witnesses, Including rebuttal evidence and witnesses, and cross- examine Wtnesses, D. Iq the discretion of the Board, the respondent may present an opening and closing statement, present additional evidence and witnesses, including rebuttal evidence and witnesses, and cross- examine witnesses, F. The Board may admit, but is not limited to, evidence provided at the hearing on the merits, Information provided with the complaint, information provided pursuant to CVMC 2,28J 10(B), or subsection (A) of this section, Information provided at the probable cause hearing, and any other ovidence it determines should be considered. D 28 I,Itn'itawNrv4nitichtnnrnhYfAfRtNdn\figlaNJlXhilplhclaft�ffFu4a\/�i�(1��q}ilr4y��n Win i P28 0 04/19/2017 7;07 AM 711 M016 Chnrter 2.28 SOARD OF HTHiOS' F. The hearing on the merits is not a formal judicial proceeding, but the Board will exercise control over the hearing to ensure that it is conducted in an orderly and expeditious manner. While the technical rules of evidence are not applicable and hearsay Is admissible, evidence that Is admitted should bear indicia of reliability. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013), 2.28.144 Complaint procedures w Decision after hearing orti the merits. The Board shall document its decision in a written statement of decision, A vote of five board members is required to make a finding of misconduct,. Each finding of misconduct must be supported by a preponderance of the evidence. The statement of decision should be prepared expeditiously and shaltpe setved.upon.both partles Yfa certified mail With a certificate of mailing: . A, Misconduct pound -- Declaratlon of Misconduct. If the Board makes a finding of misconduct, the statement of decision shall contain, and be labeled as such•, a declaration of misconduct. The declaration of misconduct shall detall the misconduct that has bedn found to be true and the supporting evidence, The declaretion of misconduct shall be a final decision on the merits and shall not be changed by the City Council, The declaration of misconduct may contain a recommendation of sanctions against the City official found to have engaged in misconduct, including, but not limited to, the following; a reprimand, censure, or removal from office. The declaration of misconduct may also recommend remedial actions to prevent misconduct In the future. Government Code Sections M of seq. (Firefighter Procedural Bill of Rights Act) and 3300 et seq, (public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights Act) provide appeal rights for the Police and Fire Chief, The Police and Fire Chief shall be provided the'appeal rights required under the aforementioned Government Code sections and City Council shall act as the body hearing any such appeal. B. No Misconduct pound -- Declaration of No Misconduct, If the Board makes a finding of no misconduct, the statement of decision shall contain, and be labeled as such, a declaration of no misconduct. The declaration of no misconduct sholl detail the basis for its finding. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2.28.150 Conflicts, City officials subject to the specific prohibitions set forth in this chapter should not participate In or influence the complaint process as set forth in CVMC.2,28,090 to 2 2, 8.140 in their official capacitles, To this end, when a complaint involves a Board of Ethics member, a, Counclimember (including the Mayor) or the City Attorney, the following procedures shall be followed; A. If a complaint Involves a Board of Ethics member, then the named Board of Ethics member shall recuse himself or herself. B., If a complaint involves a CoundIrnember, Including the Mayor, then the named C ouncilmembcr snail recuse himself or herself. C, If the complaint involves the City Attorney, the Clty Attorney and'his or her office shall recuse themselves. Outside counsel shall be appointed by the Board of Ethics to advise the Board of Ethics regarding a complaint alleging misconduot by the City Attorney, The Board of Ethics may establish procedures for the sdiection of such counsel, (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2.28.160 Disclosure of Board records, hUDI�w+JdcodoquWishl»n.rcxr�CNGtxdnU<StNNI!( Ix�nVistntl9lr:h,Jet/�dars7?AIitndtoM D 29 AMr, P29 (D 04/19/2017 7:07 AM 1718/2016 0114pler,2,2060ARb OF ETHICS' The purpose of this section Is to advance the public's Interest under the Public Records Act to access information concerning the conduct of the Board In a manner that will not compromise the Board's ability to conduct effective and confidential investlgatlons Into alleged violations of the City of Chula Vista's code of ethics, The Board and its staff shall not make public comments regarding a pending matter until the Board has made a final decision on the merits or until [j1e matter is otherwise closed, The complaint may be released to the public, The -complaint may be redacted consistent with CVMC 2 28.0 -Q (regarding requests for confidentiality). The Board may release its records unless they fail within, but not limited to, the categories that follow; A, Preliminary or draft memoranda, documents, or records not kept 1n the or' djnary co:lrse of . business, B. Personnel, medical, or other simliar files, the disclosure of which would constitute an unwarranted Invasion of personal privacy. C, Documents or records protected under any law (state or federal) related to privilege., D. Records exempt from disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Government Code Section 6M et seq,), P. Documents or records More the public Interest against disclosure outweighs the public interest served by disclosure, Such documents ntay include, but are not limited to, the following: 1. The narhes of Juvenile witnesses; or 2. Personal or othenuise private information related or unrelated to the Investigation if the disclosure would constitute an unwarranted Invasion of privacy; or 3. The Identity of a confidential source; or 4. Information, which, if disclosed, would create a credible risk of endangering any individual; or 5, information, which, if disclosed, would endanger the successful completion of an Investigation More tite prospect of enforcement proceedings Is concrete and definite. (Ord. 3264 § 1, 2013). 2.28,170 Severabllity. If any provision of this chapter, or the appilcatlon of any such provision to any .person or circumstance, shall be held Invalid, the remainder of this chapter to the extent it can bo given effect, or the application of those provisions to persons or circumstances other than those as to Mich It Is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of this chapter are sevorable, (Ord, 3264 § 1, 2013). Mobile Verslon ttllp:lM�vvc�xlepuhlrshrrxa,com'G/JC Iw1a4lsta/11111Ct1ulaVisla02/CfvlaVic[o022n.r�rnlfk1,.28 anon 0 30 P30 P31 Michael Shire From: Jeffrey Howerto Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 201611:26 PM: . TO., Br'ookover Subject: Re: City of Chula'Vista Poi ice Contace Us Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hi Barbic, I was recently 51-50'd by officer Arce and PERT Officer Dicaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying. I would like to request my records. Do you have those or is there a different process? Thanks for letting Ric know. teff 4n Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey IiOwertOn wrote: Hi Barbie, I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is strange ' don't you think? And unfortunately, I am not getting what I feel an appropriate response. Could you pleaso.provide me. with the contact information of someone at your department who could be more helpful? Perhaps, do you have Lon Turner's email? I would like to reach out to him. If this not in fact through your police department. Perhaps, as in other instances, they are in fact at your police department but the records obtained elsewhere 0.e the fbi, the california threat assessment system, etc etc etc). I make no distinction, but in terms of records etc probably should. Thank you again for your help. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 PM, Barbie Brookover <$Brookovernchulavistaud.ofg> wrote; Hello Mr. Howerton, A thorough search of Chula Vista Police Department records was conducted per your PRA request, As stated (n an earlier email, the Police Department has -no records responsive to your request, and has no record of contact with you. 93 wbi; Yc,6roo�ei Police Support services Manager P32 Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619)_ 691-6128, Fax: (619) 586-5745 bbrookoyer c. hulavistapd,org www chulayistand.org From'. Jeffrey Howertbn EMni{t Sent: Monday, August 24, 20. 5' 1:34 AM' To.,*Balrookaver co. u:'City of,Chula Vista Police Contact: Us = Web Notification' Mr: Nowertan Barb.i;c,. ' If you cannot find answers. Then I am really compelled to file apolice report, or speak with someone who can help me find some alternatives. I all, involved in a eely sick s I activating others cameras andithati0n,,Aere there cophones on their cell egreen severe and egious privacy violations in my home (o example, phones aid computers) and have broadcast this to a wide audience. Going out of their way to humiliate and degrade me to peers but also professionally ar Behaviors where something like this sedngmedindividuals t question nder false pretenses s involves members from the Hollywood no above them. And I got the sense some of the people in on the backstory. eld when asked One of the members gave a card, but unfortunately not I to me, even eel like this has beezaznore than ample tihen asked. it Was txze t° get some sort of r it then lost. I was promised a follow up. And I f information on the matter and do so. There was one xrlsnondente indat icating soe white louse, it is me individuals speaking with the erative, that I find information on this matter. I was also forwarded p the DA's Office. If it is possible, could you please af�� rd this to someone someone from your office rememberscOr is this has the capaity to ybe check in with other offices. To see what tho issue is, y something you -could call up other offices to get tconfirmation on, It is either a major misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on my par Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, Jeff oil Mon, Aug 24, 201.5 at 11:05 -AM, Jeffrey H°Werton wrote: Iii Barbie, 2. P33 Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with theNew. York DA's office. Itis important that I exhaust all avenues as in the event I need to press charges, then the false and misleading d great h, have been Unfortunately, the situation I am involved in involves eactivitiesi Shortly after, th ys hoowedlup�belx ve hey were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering UP their contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me. Best; Jeff on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 7;50 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBroakover cr chulavistat�d,ox;> wrote; Hello Mr. Howerton, era rch of le This email is in response to the bhat i ChulRecords a Vista police Departm ntlhas nottedt records responsive to your below req�uest records, it has been determined for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as logs of Information that Is accessed via partner organizations." The Department has no record of contact with you, and has no record of your personal Information, please contact me if you have any questions. P34 police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista police Department Phone: 618 691-5128, Fax: (6191565.5745 bbrookoyer0chulavistapd,org www,chulavista ad,or Prom: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August: 16, 2015 9:31 PM To: Community_Reiations Subject: city of Chula Vista police Contact Us - Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name; Police Department Date & Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM tiesgonSe M 345 Submitter 113: 4033 iP address: Time to complete: 22 min• 55 sec. survey details 0 P35 Page 1 1. Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton Fmall Address Comments Email r Postal Address Postai Cita Postal state -prow zip Code4%W. • Country: United States of America Home Phone Work Phone Drivers License: .. DO This is a request under the Public Records Act and California Surishine'amendment. Earlier in the year, officers, showed up to my house regarding adv blls ed that officers to ft were sent, ollow as inUP co a niumber nation of with Iibelieve both the NYPo, and District Attorney's Office of Manhattan. uals Including elected officials and law enforcement located In Santa i3arbara, and Los Angeles. The follow up was nonexistent. 1) i am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as rehensive. So I am ation fags of information that is accessed via partner organizations, example, apartiof the su v eillance I am being subject tokhas been facnformilitatedd and not limited to what was explicitly stated, For through the electronics of others in my household. Or if there are people in your department assigned to an investigation elsewhere.., for example, under the California Threat assessment system or the fbi where this information Is essentially housed and accessed somewhere else. I am also seeking all correspondence with officials from Newyork where this was originally coordinated. ied on ve means. Also, for further specificity. The nature this I am a, has entaild that those Involved have art of. Iamb be specific because I aminot familiar�with your So I am also seeking information on other Investigationsp interface. For example, m o not have et to engage na phone. But ey have relied surveillance acn others electronics (computers, cell phones) and activating cameras and p This information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when In reality 1 am the target. I am requesting a waiver of all processing fees. My safety, Civil liberties and ability to advance in life have been assaulted and P36 creating stress. The follow up then rendered necessary, and creates undue financial burden. Furthermore,4his information is informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. regarding Meighmany commercialI Interests but the interest activities indirectly related and I believe what has motivated some of this is Y cOmetcla essentially roped in. Either way, the public in The california Public Records Act requires a response within ten whebusiness days.ight if act ss to the records I am requesting will take longer, please contact nfeWith informaC o If you deny any or all of this request, please cite each specific exemption you feel Justifles the refusal to release the informatidn and notify'me of the appeal procedures available to me under the law. #a Thank you for considering my request. sincerely, Jeffrey Howerton Thank you, City of Chula Vista ement System. Please do not reply directly to.this email. This is an auTomated message generated by the Vision Content Manag 6 P3 Michael Shire From: Barbie Brookover <BBrookover@chulavistapd,or9> Thursday, July 07, 2016 7:55 AM Sent: Jeffrey Howerton To: Rt_: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr, Howerton 2nd Subject: response Mello Mr. Howerton, P .fel 18, 2016, A copy of the requested report can da . throe h Friday, a,04 M to 5:00 PMe The cost of the after, is $100. Please be during regular business hours, Monday g prepared to show valid identification, Please contact me with any questions. Ba,�^riu�uv BYaakove� Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department �1t5 Phone: (699) 691-5126, l=ax: (619) 585 57 bbrooko er chuiavista dor www chulayista ,ar From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailto Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 201611:26 PM Iro. Barbie Brookover olice Contact Us -Web Notification _ Mr. Howerton 2nd response Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista P , Hi Barbie, I was recently 51-50-d by officer icer Arco and PERT officer Dieaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying. s. Do you have those or is there a different process? I would like to request my record Thanks for letting me know. Jeff wrote: on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey Howerton Hi Barbie, I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is lease provide z� e think? ith he conunfortunately, act inf rrl ayxorl of getting getting what I feel an appropriate response. Could you l . p you have Lon Turner's email? I would someone at your department who could be more helpful? Perhaps; do like to reach out to him. If this not in. fact, tluough yom' police department, Perhaps, as in other instances, they fact at your police department but the records obtained elsewhere ecoids etcbprobably shouldthreat i, the cal are in fa Y assessment system, eta etc eta). I make no distinction, but xta terms o Thank you again for your help. P38 Best, Jeff , Barbie Brookover On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 BM<BBro�okover �chulayista�d.or> wrote; Hello Mr, Howerton, . As stated n an A thorough search oli Chula Vista Department has Department records responsive a to your request,s Was conducted r nd ha n rrecp d of contact wiith you. earlier email, the Police D p Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone; (619)691-5128, Fax: (6181585-5745_ bbrookover@chulavistaad.or' wwwAulavista d.or From; ,Jeffrey Howerton (mallto Sent: Monday, August 24, 201511:34 TO: Barbie,.,Brr�orokol - � Community --Relations 5ub3 R of C Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton Barbie, ne If you cannot find answers. Then I am really coxupelled tore s �pao police report, there la ve been �k with eo�;e wdo can help me find son7.e alte.j atives. I and involved �n a really egregious pr.�ivacy violations in my 1101110 (for example,, a�xdienee.ing tG0 n out of theirlway to hun iliatelandCell Ph and computers) and have broadcast this to a w degrade me to peers but also professionally as tinned involves viduals to quest on under falsee patenses1 snot above Behaviors where something like this _sending them. And X got the sense some of the people in on the backstory. asked One of the iuenibers gave a card, but unfortunately not to mhas been more than ample ti 110 to get so�e, even when askit was id-diold �e sort of r it then lost. T was promised a follow up. And I feel like this P39 that I find ouse, It is do so. There was one man pictured at the whitelme ndividual sspea ng witia h information on the matter and correspondence indicating sbe check iarformation on this matter. I was also forwarded forward a from yowl office i emetnbers. Or is this ce, if it is possible, could You please forward this to someone who has the capacity to may s the DAs offs misunderstanding or this in with other offices. To see what the issue is. lVlayorifirniat on on. It is either a major something you could call up other offices to g et indicative of greater cause for concern on my part. Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, Jeff wrote: Au 24, 2015 at 11:05 A -Ml Jefftey Howerton On Mon, g . Hi Barbie, art of Several members identifying themselves as apyourpolice force came to my home. S ome wexe carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office. beast all avenues as in the event 1 need to press charges, then the false and misleading It is important that 1 ex . in involves -mull organizations. And great lengths have been Unfortunately, the situation I am involvedup their activities. Shortly after., they showed up I believe they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me. P40 Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie BTOOkOvOr <BBro� er cbulavistapd,oig> wrote: Mello Mr. Howerton, 16, er a rch of vailable This email is in response to the below Public RV sta Police Departmentihas notted trecords rtesponsive to your below request records, It has been determined that the Chula as for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared d of databases, tab with youwellld has �no record afityour personal is accessed via partner organizations. The Department has n information, Please contact me if you have any questions. Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619)6 91.5128, Rax: (619)585-6745 bbrookaver@chulavistapd.o r www chulavlsta IFrorn: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August 16, 201.5 9:31 PM Ta: Community -Relations Subecit: City of Chula Vista police Contact us ~Web Notification P41 A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted.. Form Name: Date &'time: Response #: Submitter ID: iP address: Time to complete survey Details Page 1 : Police Department 08/16/2015 9.30 PM 345 4033 22 min. , 55 sec. _ Z. Please feet free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton Email Address comments Email Postal Addres Postal City. Postal State-pro4w zip cod Country: United States of America Home Phoneoow Work Phone:o Drivers Licens DOB This is a request under the Public Records Act and california Sunshine amendment. elieve Earlier in the year, officers, showed up to my house regarding �dvised t e officers to HIM up'withoi a number ofiindividuals both the NYPD, and District Attorney's Office of Manhattan. S P42 including elected officials and law enforcement located In Santa Barbara, and i.os Angeles, the follow up was nonexistent. well as 1) I am seeking access to my persona la information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, apart of the surveillance I am being subject to, has been facilitated to s of information that is accessed ala partner organizattiions. This should be comprehensive. So I am seeking all eInformation g and not limited to what was explicitly stated. For examp , through the electronics of others in my house old. OrThreat if there arement system or the fbi wec here this information Is�ple In your department assigned to an is essentially elsewhered for example, under the Californiaan' housed and accessed somewhere else. i am also seeking all correspondence with officials from New York where this was originally coordinated. a t of, I. am being specific because I am not familiar with your Also, for further specificity. The nature of this situation, has entaild that those involved have relied on creative means,eSo am also seeking Information on other investigations I am p nd interface, For example, I do not have a phone. But they have relied on others electronics (computers, cell phones) activating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity, sentlaii exploiting the system, when In This information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are es Y reality I am the target. ave been requesting a waiver of all processing fees. My safety, civcreates l Ilbt rstundue fines and ancial Informative Furthermore, advance in lifelthis Information s cam q creating stress. The follow up then rendered necessary, an r informative and will Contribute greatly to public understanding. i�beli eve what has motivated some of this Is regarding my commercial interests but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest. Records Act requires a response within ten business days, if expect access to. the records I am requesting will The California Pubtic . take longe►; please contact me with information about why and when 1 might exp if you deny any or all of this request, please cite each specific exemption you feel justifies the refusat to release the appeal procedures available to me under the law. information and notify me of the Thank you for considering my request. Sincerely, Jeffrey Howerton Thank you,``r`"'�' City of Chula Vista P% message generated by the Vision Content Management System"". Please do not reply directly to this email. This is an automated P4 Michael Shire Frain: Jeffrey Howerton Thursday, July 07, 207.6 :A�l M Sent: Barbie Brookover To. Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact' Us - Web No - Mr. Howerton 2n Subject: response lease explain the delay? When l spoke witb officer Arce lie stated it Tbank you for letting m,e know. Can g there. Jeff . would be -ready immediately after my stay On Thu 7ul 7, 2016 at 7:54 AM, Barbie Brookover <RBro� okoyE c Gl�ulavista �d.or > wrote: Heiio Mr. Howerton, A copy of the requested report can be picked up at the Chula Vista Police Department, on or after, Monday, duly'18, 20% PM - during regular b usiness hours, Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. The cast of the report is $i .00. Please e prepared to show valid identification. Please contact me with any questions. police Support Services Manager Cho Vista Police Department phone: (699) 899.5928. Fax: (619)565-5745 bbrookove ac —hu lavISta d.or www Chulavlstapd.or Prom: Jeffrey Howerton I~maiita�6 PM Sent:: Wednesday, Juiy 06, 2016-11:26 Brookover subject: Re, City of Chula Vista ponce Contact tis -Web Natificatlon - Mr. Howerton 2nd response T(): Barble P44 14i Barbie, I was recently 51-501d by officer Arcs and pERT O£fi.cer Dicaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying. o request my records. Do you have those or is there a different process? I would lake t �l • Thanks for letting me ki"Ow• Jeff wrote: On Mon, Aug 24, ,2015 Ol5 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey Ilowerton 4001100—ow Iii Barbie, • 6u a air3. But this is strange don't you think`t And unfortunately, I am not ormationof I understood the first time: Thar Y o C. Gould you please provide me withe Lon Turnex'sf email? l would getting what I feel an appropriate resp helpful?s do ou have our of Perhaps, depar tment. perhaps, as in other instances, they someone at your department who o btough y p perhd � y e the fbi, the California threat like to reach out to him. If this no are in fact at your police departmentke butthed st ncttiorecords n, but n terns of records etc probably should. assessment system, etc etc etc). X snake Thank you again for your help. Best, Jeff ,�R,or,leovexncliulayista d.0%> wrote: On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 pM, Barbie Brookover <La-• Netto Mr. Howertan, P45 A request. As an A thorough search of Chula Vista police Department records was c oua requ strand has no record of cotactdwith you. earlier email, the Police Department has no records responsive o y polka Support Services Manager - Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (6191691-5128, Fax: (61�. 91655-5745 bbrookoverJ @chulavista d.or www,chulavista d.or From: Jeffrey HOW erto Sent: Monday, August 24, 1511:34 AM To- Barbie 13raol eve .. 1111kcOmm"I)ILY—Relations Cc: Notification - Mr. Subject: Re. t of Chula ista police Contact Us - Web Mowerton Barbie, If you cannot find answers. Then I am realty compelled to file a police report, or speak with someone who can activating others cameras and microphones on their cell el me find some alternatives. I am involved in a 1e��1 asick situation, where, there have been severe and d help egregious privacyviolations in iny.home (for exon p , es members from the blollywoad community - phones humiliate and hones and computers) and have broadcast the to a well, it audience, Going out of their way not above p uestion under false pretenses is degrade me to peers but also professionally a Behaviors where something � , this - sending arm o f the people in ed on the backindividuals tn Y to q them. And I got the sense s MOM than ample time to get some sort of bers ave a card, but unfortunately not tome, eventwhen asked. It was withheld when askedfor pile o£ the mem g it then lost. I was promised a follow ul�• And X feel like this has e some individuals speaking with the ttcr and do so. There Was one Tuan pictured at the White house. Itis imperative that I find information on the ixia ]ease forward this to someone who has the mbemCOr is maybe check infoixn:ation on this matter. I was also forwarded correspondence �n ica g the DA's office. If it is possible, could you p our office i this UP other offices to get a confinn.ation oil. It is either a major misunderstanding or this in with other offices. Ta11 see what the issue is. Maybe someone om y something you could c P indicative of greater cause for concern on my part Thank you for Your time and consideration. P46 Best, Jeff on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 11:05 AM, Jeffiey Howerton""PIWFWPiR—wrote: Hi Barbie, Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force carne to nay home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office. It is important that I exhaust all avenues as in the event I need to press charges, then the false and misleading Unfortunately, the situation I am involved in involves multiple organizations. And great leiigths have been taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up their activities. Shortly after, they showed up I believe they were contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookover(cDclaulavistaUd,ox wrote: 0 P47 Hello Mr. Howerton. 15, er a thorough rch Of lable This email is in response to the below Public a Vista poct llee Department uest has noed t elcords rtesponsive to yourbelregiu`est records, it has been determined that the Chula Vist for "Any flies, correspondencia e, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as logs of information that s accessed partner organizations;' The Department has no record of contact with you, and has no record of your personal information. a 'qpw n Please contact me if you have any questions. Bcwba-a,,6r°rnA0ver Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista police Department Phone' (61�9) 691-5128, Fax: (aaa) 585-5745 bbroakoyer@chulavistapd,org www.chul,avistapd.org From: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August; 16, 2015 9.31 PM `ro; Community_Retations sufoijecte City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us Web Notification Anew entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department pate & Time: 08/7.6/2015 9:80 PM Response #€: 345 P48 submitter ID: 4033... Ip address: Time to complete: 22 min. , 55 sec. survey Qetalls page 1 Please feel free to contact us with anY comments or questions lay filling out the faYm below. First Name Jeffrey Last !Name Ho Email Address Comments Email: Postal Address. postal City postai state-prov: Zip Code: Country: united States of America Home Phoned Work phone Drivers ticense�l' DOB: This is a request under the public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. ation th I r in the year, officers, showed up to my house regarding emails that o e Cel �� hfoliipW was with mher of�individuals Carlie Y both the NYPD, and pistrict Attorney's Office of Manhattan. I advise parbara, and toe Angeles. The follow up was nonexistent. including elected officials and law enforcement located In Santa 1)1 am seeking access to my personal Information. Any flies, correspondence, meetings, requests, shred databases; as well as atiOn logs of information that is accessed via partnerorganizations. gxampleo apart This ss the ld bvelil e c mpr I am being Soubject to, has been faI am seeking all cilitated and not limited to what was explicitly stated. F nve through the electronics of others in my household. Threat if there are people inyour department assigned toassessment system or the fbi where this Information Isan iessen tally n elsewhere... for example, under the California Thr o seeking all correspondence with officials from New York where this was housed and accessed somewhere else, l am als P49 originally coordinated. ed on Also, for further specificity. The natureoathis tion, has m apart of. I aim being specific because 1 d that those involved have remlinot familiar iwith your ve Means. 5o I am also seeking information on other 'investigations I Interface. For example, I do not have a phone. But they have relied on others electronics (computers, el) phones) an activating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity. This information 1 suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when In reality,I am the target. . ng y to e in life ve been I am rng stress, a waiver of all hen essing fees. My safety, civil rendered necessary, nd creates liberties financial ial burd n, Furchemaore th s Information Is creating stress, The follow up then rend informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. I believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commercial interests but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped In. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest, The California public Records Act requires a response within ten business days. If access to the records I am requesting will take longer, please contact me with information about why and when I might expect copies. ption you feel justifies the refusal to release the if you deny any or.ali of this request, please cite each specific exem information and notify me of the appeal procedures available to me under the law. Thank you for considering my request. sincerely, Jeffrey Howerton Thank you, City of Chula Vista rated by the Vision Content Management system"", please do not reply directly to this email. This is an automated message gene I P 0 Michael Shire From: Barbie Brookover <8Broakover@chulavlstapd.org> Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2016 3:55 PM To: Jeffrey Howerton Subject:RF; City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hello Mr, Howerton, CA Govt. Code 6253(6) allows public agencies up to 10 days after receipt of a request for records to determine if records shall be released and to provide the records or an explanation for a delay in records production. Barba-,-a-�ror�vet� Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619) 691-5128, Fax; (619) 585-57.45 bbrookover ch lavista d.or - ' www chulayistapd.org From: Jeffrey Howerton CmaiitoA Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2016 3:4"PSOMMI. To: Barbie Brookover Subject: fie: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Thank you for letting nae know. Can you please explain the delay? When I spoke with officer Arco he stated it would be ready immediately after my stay there. Jeff On Thu, Jul 7, 2016 at.7:54 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookOvcrOdl3 tavistaUd—'Org> Wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, A copy of the requested report can be picked up at the Chula Vista Police Department, on or after, Monday, July 18, 2016, Friday, 8:00 AM to 5;00 PM. The cost of the report is $1.00. Please be during regular business hours, Monday through prepared to showvalid identification. please contact me with any questions. police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department P51 Phone: (699,_) 69��6�28� PeX- (619) 5a5"5745 bbroo chulavistapd.or� wW chulavlsta pd.or r,romz Jefrey Howerton (mailt Sent. Wednesday, July 06, 2016 11:26 P. To: Barbie Brookover Subjects Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us -Web NotitTcation' Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hi Barbie, I was recently 51-50'd by officer Arce and PERT Officer Dicaprio with Officer Rhodes accompanying. I would like to request my records. Do you Dave those or is there a different process? Thanks for letting me know. Jeff on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote. Iii Barbie, straligo don't you think? And unfortunately, I am I understood the first time. Thank you againC Could llioss f ease provide, me with the contact inforn ation o not getting what I feel an appropriate response. y p someone at your department who could be more helpful?oPerhaps, dttn�nf have on s in other instances, esu, they like to reach out to him. If this not in fact tluougl� y p llifornift are in fact at your police department but he records obtained elsewhere (i.c, hedistinc ion, but n terms of records etc probably should are assessment system, etc etc etc). I make no Thank you again for your help. 2 P52 Best, Jeff d�> wrote: 4n Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 PM, Barbie Brookover <BLroa� koverC�chulavistaa Hello Mr. Howerton, RA uest. As stated an e thorough search of Chula art VistaPolice nDepartment rds responsive to your request,rand has no record of contact ilt you. earlier email, the Police Department h Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (6191_ 91____.6128, Pax: (6191s85457�5 bbrookoyer@chulayistapd.or�- www.chulavistal)d.org From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailt sent: Monday, August 24, 20.5 4 A TO, Barbie grookove Cc, Commdnity_Reiatipns Sub3 - u a Vis a.Police Contact, Us - Web Notlficatlon - Mr. HnWerton Barbie, with if you cannot find answers. Tien I am really compelea d to iclk situation, le a police rwhere there lspeak ve been severe and can help me find some alternatives. I am involved in a x y microphones on their egregious privacy violations in xny home (for example, activating diene.tGoing out of tl ethers canieras dr way o humiliate and Cell Phones and computers) and have broadcast this to a wide a degrade me to peers but also professionally as vsrell, It involves members from'the Hollywood community. P53 Behaviors where something like this - sending armed individuals to question under false pretenses is not above them. And I got the sense some of the people in on the backstory. ld when One of the members gave a card, fiat unfortunatelyfeel like this has been more than ample nixie ioege some so r it then lost. I was promised a follow up. And I information. on the matter and do so. There was one rman pictured radical t the ngrsome indiv duals spete house. it is aking with the information on this matter. X was also forwarded Correspondence the DA's office. If it is possible, could you please fobre orrdn hi t o so your office xer nwho bas lembexs�0 is this check meone in with other offices. To see what the issue is. May something you could call up other offices to get a confirniation on. It is either a major misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on my pa Thank you for your tinic and consideration, Best, Jeff wrote: On Man, Aug 24, 2015 at 11:45 AM, Jeffrey Howerton� Hi Barbie, Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York IAA's office. Itis important that I exhaust all avenues as in the event I need to press charges, then the false and misleading involved in Unfortunately, the situation I ani iltheir activities. Shortly after, they itheyholengths I believe they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this Were deleted? P54 Thank You for following up with me. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 2�, 2015 at 7:50 AM, Barbio Br0o ovOr �BBrookoyerC�c iavistapd.or > wrote: Hello Mr, Howerton, rch of This small is In response to the below Public Records Act i`c� �q�p��e�ti��d $4lreoords reer a thorough sponsive ve to yourbelowrequest vailable records, it has been determined that the Chula Vista for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, fd tat�y9 information accessed is via he Department has no record of databases and has no record of your personal partner organizations." T information, Please contact me it you have any questions. Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619) 28� Pax. MOO 686- 46 hbrookover chulavlsfiapd,or� www, vjgVd org 5 P55 From: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August 16, 2015 9.31 PM To: CommunityRelations Subject; City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department Date & Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response #: 345 submitter ID: 4033 IP address: 178.152.20.8.142 Time to complete: 22 Min,, 55 sec. Survey Details Page 1 1. Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton (Email Address comments Finail: Postal Address, Postal City: Postal State-prov zip Code. Country: United states -of America Home Phone: Work Phone: 606 Drivers License-4MIIP 6 P5 DOB.. 01/28/1986 This is a request under the public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. . d the officers to follow up with a number of individuals Earlier in the year, officers, showed up to my house regardinlga malls that were sent, This was in coordination with { believe both the NypD, and District Attorneys office of was nonexistent. including effected officials and law enforcement located in Santa Barbara, and Los Angeles. The follow up red databases, as 1 1 am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, c r eThis should be, meets hens veu Sot I amaseeking ail infarmatilas on logs of information that is accessed via partner organizationshas been and not limited to what was explicitly stated. For'exam thereart of the are people in yolance I am being subject ur department assigned town Investigatioin ted through the electronics of others in my household. Or lly elsewhere.., for example, under the California s hreat s all ossmr respse ondence with officals from nt system or the fbl where i'New York where thiswas housed and accessed somewhere else. I am al originally coordinated. Also, for further specificity. The nature of this situations, has af. Iaam being specific because f amrelied creative entltd that those Involved have not familiar with your so I am also seeking information ori other investigations I am p interface. For example, l do not have a phone. But they have relied on others electronics (computers, cell phones} an activating cameras and microphones etc to engage In surveiliance activity. This information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when in reality 1 am the target. e In life have been assaulted I am requesting a waiver of all processing fees. My safetypcdivcir�l�tesies and undue financial ial burdeny to • Furthermore, this information s creating stress. The follow up then rendered necessary, a informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. t believe what has motivated same of this is regarding my commercial Interests but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest. ccess to The public Records Act requires a response within ten busin'srn a ysif pect copies take longer, please contact me records I am requesting will with information about why a nd w el 1f you deny en art Y or all of this request, please cite each specific exemptione law.stifies the refusal to release the information and patlfy me of the appeal procedures available tome under th Thank you for considering my request.' v., Sincerely, Jeffrey Llowerton Thank you, city of Chula Vista,' P57 This is an automated message generated by the Vision Content Management System""• please do not reply directly to this email. P58 Michael From: sept: T4: Subject: Jeffrey Howerton 'Thursday, July 07, 2016 3;58 PM Barbie Brookover, Re., City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us -Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response s not ex. lained to me at the time. As state This wa 1?d, I was imme nformed I could request them immediately after' Thank you for letting me know. Thu, 'Jul 7 2416 at 3:55 PM, Barbie Brookover.eookover(�cliulavistaUd.or>�?wrote: . On Th , > Heilo Mr. Howerton, Code 625 qc) allows public agencies up to 10 daysrafter r CA Govt, delay in records producest for tion. to determine if records on shall be released and'to provide the records or an explanat o police Support Services Manager Chula Vista police Department phone: 18191„T E2Ing 8 pax: 699 585-87'45 bbtookover —Ch ulavlsta d.or www.chulavistaRIor prom: Jeffrey Howerton [Mailt 3 - sent: Thursday, July 07, M To: 33arbio Brookover 'ectt Ro; City of Chula Vista Police Coxatact�7s Web Notifi uboation - Mr. ZI0We1to'l 2ii response J ettin e know. Can you please explain the delay? When I spoke with officer Arche stated it o Thank you for l � m would be ready ininiediately after illy stay thele. Jeff P59 On Thu, Sul 7, 201.6 at. 7:54 AM, Barbie Brookover<BBrookoyer(c�chulavistaud.or>;> wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, o.,r,, " :a k§ on or after, d copy of the requested report can be Mondaypthroudup gi Frt the iday, 8,00 AM to 5:00 PMula Vista police , The cost of the report is $Monday, 00, t Please be 2016, during regular business hour , prepared to show valid identification. Please contact me with any questions. police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police pepartment Phone: ,(699) 6,91-512-8, Fax: f619i 585-5745 bbroo ,ov rA chulavista d.or www,ciiulavista d.or From; .Jeffrey Howerton [mailk Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 20151126 PM To: Barbie grookover Subject: Re: City of Chula vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hi Barbie, Y was recently 51�-50-d by Ofrtcer Arco and P w.f Officer DicapTio with Offzcer Rhodes accompanying. I would like, to request my records. Do you have diose or is there a different process? Thanks for letting 'no know, '.1 Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey Howerton - °wrote; Hi Barbie, T understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is strange don't you think? And unfortunately, I am not getting what J feel an appropriate response. Could you please provide me with the contact information of someone at your department who could be more helpful? Perhaps, do you have Lon Turner's email? X would like to reach out to him. If this not in fact througli your police department. Perhaps, as in other instances, they are in fact at your police department but the records obtained elsewhere (i.e the fbi, the califomia threat assessment system, etc etc etc). X make no distinction, but in terms of records etc probably should. Thank you again for your help. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 Pligr:Barbie Broak� Yqt�,<B)3rookoyergollutavi t -a d.o� wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, A thorough search of Chula Vista Police Department records was conducted per your FRA request. As stated 'in an earlier email, the Police Department has no records responsive to your request, and has no record of contact with'you. Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: 619 691-5128, Pax: (6'19) 6�__-85-5745 3 P81 bbrooko� chulavistapd.ar9 ._mw chuiavistapd,or From; Jeffrey Howerton [mailt sent: Monday, August 24, 2015 11-34 AM To. 0arble Cc: • Communitoelatlons Sub ecY: e: City o.' ula Vista Nice contact us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton Barbie, file a police, report, or If you cannot find answers. Then I air really c°rma el li tsick situation, where there have been severe andeak with sonicono help can help me find soma alternatives. I am involved y egregious privacy violations in my home. (for ex amp activating iene.tGoing out o£theix way to humiliate and hers cameras and microphones on their Cell phones and computers) and have broadcast this to degrade me to peers but also professionally as armed individuals to question undewell. it involves members from the Hfals pretenses is ollywood not above Behaviors where something like this -•sen g them. And I got the sense, some of the people in on the backstory. One of the members gave a card, but unfortunately not to me, even whethtked. it han t n ehheld when asked get some sort o£ i it then lost. I was promised a follow up. And I feel like this has been an ai ploinfom-iation on the inatter and do so, There was one nindicating at white somhouse. e individuals speaking with that h the infolmation on this inattei. I was also forwatded the DA's office. If it is possible, could you please forward ° ore fr someone ur office asremembers.the apaOr is this Check ill with other offices, To see what the issue is. May . something you could call up other offices to get a confirmation oil. It is either a major misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on my part, Thank you for your time and consideration., Best, Jeff wrote. On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 11:05 AM, Jeffrey Howerton . Hi Barbie, P62 Several members identifying themselves as apart of Your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the Now'York AA's office. .. Z le� It is impo leant that X exhati�st�all avenues as in the event l need to press charges, then the false and misleading Unfy, ortunatel the situation I ani involved in: involves multiple organizations. And rgreat lengths v believe been were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up their activities. Shortly after, they contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with xne. Best, Jeff On'Nlon, Aug 2.4, 2015 at 7:50 ANI, Barbie Brookover <BBroolcover@chulavistaud.or > wrote: Hello Mr. Hawerton, er a rch This email is in response to the below Public Records (sta Poliae Dues epartment submitted not records responsive to yourbelow arequeste Words, it has bean determined that the Chula your personal for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, a uwand i�as no of Qty n that is accessc via partner organizations. The Department has no record of contact with y Information, `? Please contact me if you have any questions. P63 Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (6619) 651 5128, Pax: (619) 585-5746 bbrookoyer9chulavistapd.or9 www chuiavistapd,or� From: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August 1.6, 2015 9:31 PM To: Community Relations Subject: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department Date 8o Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response it: 345 Submitter ID: 4033 IP address: Time to complete: 22 ruin. , 55 sec. Survey Details Page 1 6 ZEN 1. please feel free to Contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton Email Address' Comments Email Postai Address: Postal city Postal state-prov: 00. Zip Code: Country: united states of America Nome Phone Work Phon imp Drivers License DOB This Is'a request under the Public Records Act and California sunshine amendment. his was Earlier in the year, officers, showed up to my house regarding �ied the officers tosent. fol ow up a niumber of individuals elieve both the, NYPD, and District Attorney's Office of Manhattandv l including elected officials and law enforcement located In Santa Barbara, and Los Angeles, The follow up was nonexistent. 1)1 am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as should b logs of information that is accessed via partner organizations. This e comprehensive. So I am seeking all information eillance I am being subject to, has been facilitated and not limited to what was, explicitly stated. For example, apart of the sury though the electronics of others in my household. or If there are people in your department assigned to an investigation lly elsewhere... for example, under e the Californiam alsohseeking all arr sponde ce witreat assessmetit'FYstem or the hoffic officials froI where m New York where thiss information is was housed and accessed somewhere originally coordinated. ied on ve Also, for further specificity. The nature of this situation, has f investigations i am apart of. l am beld ing specific because ! mt those involved have inot familiariwEth your So I am also seeking information on other inv t g have veiled on others electronics (computers, cell phones) and interface. For example, I do not have a phone. But they artivating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity. purposes. And again they are essentially expiolting the system, when In This information I suspect being used for commercial reality I am the target. ty to advance In life have been am requesting a waiver of all hen processing necessary, ssarytand creates ersies and undue finainciall burden. Furthermore, tills Information s creating stress. The follow up then Informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding, P65 I believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commercial interests but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest. The California Public Records ew th Information about why and when lss days. If access to might expect cop she records 1 am requesting will take longer, please contact if you deny any or all of this request, please cite each specific ble to mo under the lawel ustifles the refusal to release the information and notify me of the appeal procedures avafia Thank you for considering my request. sincerely, , ' Jeffrey Howerton Thank you, City of Chula Vista g#;. ed message generated by the Vision Content management 5ystem�'", please do not reply dlrectiyto this email This is an aut�m�at. P66 Michael Shire From* Wilson, Vatna@PQST <Valna.W1lson@p0st.ca.90v> Sent: Thursday, July 14,2016 11:42 AM To: Don Redmond Cc: Lozito, Karen@POST Subject: Email contents from a Jeffrey Howerton From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailt S ent:ThursdaY, June 30, 2016 To: Lightbourne, Wiil@DSS <W111 Lightbourne@OSS.ca.gov>, I<ent, Jennifer (EXEGDIR)@OHCS <Jennifer Kent dhcs.ca�oy>; Scofleld, Stephanie@POST <Stepbanle Scofield@post.ca.gov> Cc: senator iackson@senate.ca.ao_v_; assernb[yMember.williams@assembly.ca.gov subject: Systemic Abuse Hi Jennifer, . Hi Will, I am forwarding a copy of a letter I am sending. If the state has knowledge of these activities. Then I believe the instance which I was subjected to, and the damages incurred in the extended time, period of which I have been subjected to this, not only for myself but the opportunity cost and corrosion and theft of commercial projects that much more pronounced. Furthermore, I need to know what I call do to defend myself from these assaults. When you are dealing with systemic abuse and corruption - deflecting towards things, is a means and mechanism of shutting any other investigation. When the police officers showed, the officer Victoria Dicaprio of Chula Vista's PERT. There was not any discussion nor any investigation of any of the events that transpired. Instead, I was patted down and sat down. Furthermore, within the less than 20 minute time period in which they showed. She already had access to my information. It seemed asuhher call tivolved i� the mo tterspro at hadrnd,naknow there handling ofed. Because I have this ht into calling the police on some of the individuals matter highly unorthodox, While at the hospital, she indicated she had access to Rd party information but would not yield her source. She stated, that what I am stating'makes no seznse' and'this is a problem that will not get better unless I get help'. I actually agree, the major difference is, my raental and emotional faculties are quite atune and instead again, I am concerned not only about the egregious assault on nay personhood, but also the flagrant exploitation of the commercial projects at hand. Well actually, not clear if everything (Le, sculpture parks etc) commercial but much of this rooted in using a means for an end. P-7 When people have an economic interest as well. It makes their behavior insurmountably more vile, but g You their, ei justice motives ave much easier to discern. When y ae�� oralioTllathsra problem. e those I tweed to knoed, are w. Where was an and instead seeking to do what they can to h penalize. incidence one year prior, where several officeu�showed ie�e one vof thindividuals involved reporting asat my door in coordination from both he, Manhattan DA/NYPD and Chula crista PDe. They had no arrested. however, upon requesting information e two officers -with C£frcer I�icaprioon this event months prior to this � Cffcer Arco and Officer records or anything else related to me. There w k. I Rhodes of the Chula Vista PD. The'latter, was one of'the officers who showed the first time where they had no records, They also indicated to me, if correspondence to these individuals. eir The correspondence I am sending now, they lravence becauought , se they cannot dmitthe� cannot they are my eintfac spyingrOnhmy only options are fabricating and duplicating evrd emails. What I am being subjected to, while unusual, is not �ouSorecedence. In fact,l double ch ecked, lith some of the nates with one ere are numerous GRscs On the record. At the hospital, the doctor gave me an oddfeeling. of the nurses after and there were statements such hiss ae problem in the event any other soeve there are microchips in my uwith . Either this was fabricated, or a severe misunderstanding. But p this information or seeks to use to corroborate some sort'of narrative to retroactively justify their behavior or funnel it into something new. As stated, the protocol Of those involved IS to lie. In household ° de ri al of acfor example t actiere this is prolific. The vities- my Father (who events that transpired fueled by provocations, and the frankly cannot stand and this nothing new but the only exploitation or anynt tdents have in the knowldge. No cost entailed mmunication ation wt himyhis individual) then proceeded to deny the flagrant grandmother (vvlao at one point worked with H1re �'ioua things at hand, Jackson), or his Again�despit thise these individuals elieve there is 'srgnifzcank activity exploiting me and feel empowered to lie, and also empowered to involvettauthorities. zed s too m�� .rs or mechanism to defend oneself lieve they are a threat to me, but gazn in seeking to shut down the validity of anything I assert, idating Itis not clear how they seek to selectively invalidate, id many other instances MO and me alone slwherle le information has selectively electively allows them to exploit. I have had messages delbile disappeared. I believe they nray have had sonic iiw the Santant 1 Barbarth the, a PD ote x somle sort o£ cobi�+m-Unity type contact was communicated to me at the time) r le could ever be something. It is not clear how conceivably sonIctlring so bizarre and extreme with so many peo p constructed. The note I ain sending is below. however, I believe some of the parties may already have access. I have communicated directly to Das Williams and to Hannah Beth Jackson. If the state has knowledge of these low activities... ect valid, for ey-OmPle, then X believe what X am being subjected to is a form of torture. convey the source Of those p ojects there is knowledge of commercial projects and them amidst this g mentallyunstable. I believe their actions tlyat mucks moxe severe, lain st rt ggo not care Theynazi are na when as each subsequent chapter ensures my life that. roach more corroded protecting me, The only doubts is how widespread this seems to be. 19 the A aitz nothing I am stating is without precedence and 7 do have to being able Correspondence use tlzisatherews notthing you g existence. This cannot be denied. But if you are shut own prior Can do. ow what m options are for gaining knowledge into what is a fact t s X believe t Abe involved takens being 1 need to kzz Y Again, below is the copy of 'the letter X am. sending to groups to keep that front me. ,Ag these things aro transpiring, and 1 am continued to be subjected to hardshipsand persecution or left vulnerable, e to groups who have no insight. This is a major problem, into this situation you may have and what my options are in pursuing Please let me, know what insights on where lily rights are not being unfairly assaulted or at risk to parties knowledge surrounding what is going abusing their power. Jeff (if the resultant -jill tile i an) rcacbing out tea sec II' deur k)VU i t��th There ha�clhc �, a numheuliliarlnlost�atahly (01, at lViVacyteast the ea�i aill i,t t4texl�l+n+) ant Im surroundint; m�' catnt)acrcial iv'ntects iaculg i �;randntotltor'<(her nantc is Juyoe ilouerton) im°ot�'erocnt in the anti-+luclrannnvanrent in the late 7t):, early i�t)s. Jerry Brc)it'n. Linda 12onstedt.'Th� Ea"Ies. ete. There arc actuallyi belie C 1\\,o lecture fhcrc ��'et'c u nurnbar of concert"* With rCcoSnizabIC natnes Ivor eaample,lackson i3rowne, Bonnie Itaitt. Ot1rs involved during this tun4 os quite tarled ti•om 13ruae Springstccu..lane 1 and } filmy and a clnc. In terms er the Nat" ontPo Viler PI utt ht tertns�of tnunta sie tthere ix Luis tJoc lhv�namn C,iolclhet� entitlev ivo ivukes which 1'aoiculat'ly at:tnd around Diabl 1 of which dutch hrouctey than that mid in t aot most held at iahaliht�n eonsi ler ah Ic some insi4titt into the �9lJSki cancet'ts on the; east colet held at A9adiscrn SquarcC;cat•cten, 1:3eyon<I the artisr, fn+m this period, the lilm will include ntnre cuntcmporary arti�ts to fulfil{ those to ,titc;5 do knight into the utile. St) it also o11'I'cr. unique clpportutltties mors akin to the muxic indu�trv. t.)I'whtch there tinancitlltillltlini'est+llentlhcnaturc t)I'1t11iC11I'ClitahtSUnelNJr. ins ,rogressed lv�t'ards dikes thing~ like E rand jury uialsatun llv(1`lany have to gusts nab' lhis ati tut ('<lrtnn,acl}'- a number of indiV Ual ha, ,I neo sou3ht to develop lhL aforalike oiled pr+�jccts. ! think it ell p people roil) Ibrtner peers. what began las untiutt;turc d �t I unpreccdentctl gccetis and uurtrol over my life While at the sanle time essentially taking advantace of this al)pt • lililary ii.e Air fr+)rce. \aryl and a host of others tltat6 in the t11crICt5�llaual lava iliiarc meat eonneeliatls tea the rnterlaiument and livanccii, Insb ids. lluwel•er. as this Situation huff pyogresscd it's gime on to include various goverutncn orlts Irt,nl the 1'i3i. I)C::�1'�>;a>l(' tt� tiG t�Sr\, n)o�t c,uullries You opGt;ttc iu. I•oc ca ample, in the l lig the NSA Isms to Ilartncr.hip with UC t{Q. To groups t t is 1 i1 1.111 d;\'1?l) ► nr other gr+utp• such as the t"onsuttler I;inanciul Protection t3w•cau ae those. involved lure nlanillulatcd informatirn they ( I .W l\ cx) vuim rallilities in order to maintain et,ntroi. 1 get 1110 xerrse there art.,u a nmber ofeompanic; in byvc obtained and are exploil"V t'cree, everything else. uch, telccnnt, entertainment inj ecntingl) ' Gvt ry. ti t0otin , and s11cu1 in the middle c»n later cants rad, and micrvpluittey. Liv S ld oP t}ters as \veli and I cant "W"ihttte the acti\itics to any one Lroup m ptrticutar; but ii vsytnl,tntm are Ilagrantly obvious, l hey blue �iolatctl n1y prtvat y m a = hcha� iars..�ntl it's actually quite a hit mtve extt n�i\ e. but there ars a mu u nutttber of \tars. l'or ESa111p1t 1'enintEl)''aett\'titin cell phone an It's created a lot of discord. and ) think unnecetisar'y conllict. ;Madk . 1'rackinh anti nxmitI Hill pt:rh;tp� directed at them =�� 1 am relatively incapacitated froth mclhility. erufussr,n not only For nx>. but others �+5 \yell: it is unclerm{nin� \what could he ntheru•ise a grcnt prc,ieet and food int•0shneut, it's qutt0 cc,rrntiivc nn a pertionAl ic\el is well, kler in about. Nhcre c s0ntially content i create foulAd those to W, r It can 110 construed as'atlter stuff i. base d; t other itctivitics and work i.cns ck,in but again, ~imply ha cont n }acre rs odtcr Mull but t 1 describe. II' you aro titrate nFthe srtuntion. yott tvifl kno\\ \vitas t am to l4 k 1 \vn• doing manifi stingy in other \\ays (i•c f�l`tlrivaov{zte without ht><n au tit itt;l>ti\cl ti,rtt cludin s nntsic l,ut u,ecther and cast nthled in \ordifferent tett)'. liar iti Iilht oPah4ve t i.e the st'lkitlg} I tealizet t tatart t , m f 1•e8oh out to irleiude<1 individual, and later (Ile t ��} reigning i �nt,rance or .>) in some catie, I've gotten c 11,ty at Uaitlinb in, generally yields cithvr 1 } nu rweg.0n�e b 6 treys ctc),1fn\\.cVer, (i,r me personally it has entailed incredih{y invasive tiolatians of n1) p me prr�nrlally. Any alt r l cestse and de i�ha or 'c�pre�sians oi' concern•for me mental hrttlth'. sivar. \ialation:,.ltarassinr t tential titnclraisinst Sources (otlicial4y or nary or ed suject . poi; thiti sound familiar to pan'! Sorry ii't11i• is nut of the les (o shnplyseek'"o At this ,uint 1 hu\e bran mostly i,alated iron (; ntact. All the \L'hile those involved smugl ;! t Winne wit + i to p' I hrhavinr� arnd de\ clopment of the aforcmcnt p ;nary elaril icatinn anti telt like y„u Indy have.ome insight based nn,+hq Clue InF't,►vet u1 p • \•< nd lh0 1rrjects descrihctl. Stere Wray also he infrastrucurrtd projects anti anistic in:-�tallatitrns as well rn• the buv,incs� related a; he• r 1 (I(veloptnenl of ~tart ups, rhere could he live events. of le ret iatL any insight you rnap' have. `thank you fc,r consideratiott Of' M) and ec<,nlmet'ee oppt,rtunitics. ��`hilc l earl ontirnl the �,alidity of \chat l am experiettcin . fn terms era i Tlterc are enuilterah}e rctarl atkin = ulatity and \vauld a} i speOrIcs. like l aid. t (I ell knots'. Simply b lUe`tisaca . l�atna (Valj Y. Wilson Senior Law Fr for'cenrerrt Consrrltmtt Il, Regtorr X (co urtties of imperial, Orange ane! San Diego), and State of Callfornia Contlltlsslorr oil POST Ti'iGa! Police Lraisart 7'rairtlitg Delivery & Compliance Bureau Califs•+tla IDeparinteut of Jtrstlee C0111MiSStot, on POST 860 Stillwater Road, Suite 100 West Sacrarttenlo, CA 95605-1630 916.227.957270 Ice P70 iMichael Shire Jeffrey Howerton— Saturday, July 1.6, 201.6 • : 9 VI From: sent: Fredrick Rowbotham To: Fwd: Establishing the Profit Motive of Local Police t=ortes Subject: --- Forwarded message --- P----- Froth: JeffreyHawerto A w - I Date: Sat; Jul 16, 2016 at 2:54 PM Sect: Establishing the Profit Motive of Local Police Forces Subject: To: mstewart@-020 0-1-9 Hi Mike, enforcement I do believe they are involved in• facilitating this t sending regarding various privacy violations andrre��oant commercial projects that are being developed. Unfortunately, Below is a nota I is g public safety or lav beyond any logistical or onscreen issues involving p situation, policingmodel but also encompassed the most significant swatlis of my life. t to d tel es on means and mechanisms to It involves members of the community who have entrusted themselves in some odd community eTh 'more community various law enforcement agencies. This has en p have consumed, it continues to devastate I ty and really explo tgthat morcitesslyf what they have 13 take advantage of any sort of vu •eve there is a profit trtotivo, but I also know therebaly oda I cefforts n coo firomethe ettisten a of the below vents oto Dove r rather Unfortunately, I do T belt our department. It was incredt y us situation. In fact recently I was 51-5O' in y degree of tvr'ttten confirmation. Even legitimate iorerely.es�o bit tnVolved. oint enough to confer follow up. Even within my household where the individuals have directly lied to me. X have overhear Humero conversations between them and also have received someA showing UP at my home about emails.•'fltey w several re is records of thedinateventsion tin your epartmeh the Manhattan nt and not able to obtain them anytvhere. much unjustly so,There is no excuse or justificattiion• ind in this • 'n is truly a societal evil T don't believe T will ever obtain closure. But it Is a profound, derail►ng force of which las s in 1 believe what is transpiring aspects o£ individuals life and very squandered what are the most precious asp with various others who are by all accounts citizens and there motives entirely about profit and the extent of the involvement of the local pate force hero. As stated, there is a different definition of What that mean circumstance. Like I said, T tend to equate t gain in some way, whether it is monetary or for more power and ego. ' well. There may have been fundraising efforts, investment with. retirement funds etc that maybe even the But I think worth asking beta as officers are not aware of. Thank you for letting me know• Jeff ,rivacy ctoiauutts l atn extier'sencing orally ul' ihermytiT�tandmtoth4r'xt(her nun eS I out rc;lclting nut to See, if yolk aro ftntiliar tvilh the angoinb I to the late 70: each' �(1 bein•c d� �rl(tltad. t"beet have been a numl)el' n laitm that le +st lift easiest to c�pl;tin) a tilm surroundinb b ' is .iatcc Ilowerttltt) ins+,heutcnl in the �tnh ttu nJa 1�nnstaJt.'Cltc C:.agi.s. etc. "there are actaallyi bel` f C'alili,trtr� t'he're o a e nun lhcr of concert~ a ith re cobnixahie Warnes for 11 ample Sackson 111,owne. [3ojlnie Raitt. (•Ode`s r volved durhtg this time e{uii( �artcti from 13rurc St>rinl teen, .Ione Fonda . )crry l3rntan. power i'lant. hl lellnfi of1Tlu`iiC. thele 1S doef3k nn dtl+exUutilslstfrnlnC-111tthis p rto(1- rhe triol l\ will limn antl a dnc. ht terutti ol'thc fcalut'ey, it is mashy gat in the Santa 13arhara, tiara Luis Uliy D,hisp+� and t..os f nb� 13ote1. ll harticlil',n'ly ut and around t)i01?ln (Inyt7n .oma meizht into the 1,1t J5Ci cllncet'ts on the cast coast held at h4tulisrn ~goon Hart cat. •,�•. cutlicmpt>r�tt'y arlitih to fulfill those rolcx of ��hich Much broader than that Mid in fact most held at the I•lally�t�aot inclutk: iw , P71 itItc%all lll"ighl flan the IIbtC. Sa a also OI'fer� unique a►1pOnunui(:s more akin to the music industry. Of V0111611 there inat heell conslderahte. lin;racing and ulresunent the ttatuN.. of wbich remains unclCat' a tti) think n originate 'roll' c t group stalking pragrea cci towarcls Other thins�a(i ku}t t�c of this jury `ol}portanity, mam' have to gain !eau this a, u'fort}utoto►�•, a nutn{tcr (�; in(lividi a1s have since sattglnt to d velop the o;arcm e gr d Prof tr , vemmcnt Ibrutcr Pet1�• 1Vhat hcgall ati ensu u�tu ttime ul+ I ecedeulcd access end cu'uol aver' illy fife While e the sante r. 6s his sit all o tr hast of oillel, both in the GSA and meal 1a\tn norm 'lent t ne entet•taimncnt ;til(1 finanec indusn•i4s. lra�s \serf a' this sit1tion ha,, progressed it's Bane t4,c,tthetlRS 1 telude �nriou. �o cannectious to 1 TO utero )s h (ir},% Erni' the 1rC31. r71;:f1's til�[C' to the NSA, rbc military i. r I inw,t cuunu•ir;5 you opct arc i'. r'or cxanlpte. in the lib. the \5A has a pt+miler hcontrill, s gent the. acme there are a number oi'cumpanies iu , • olhr:r groups sorb as the ("on,ut}leC hinancial PratCettan k3w'cau as thane• int•oltc:(1 h(tvC nlanipulate(i infvrnlauan they f ie LAIT, N\'pl7) o b haVC ObtabICti and ore ex}llailulg pet cc1.Cd �'ulneraClil ies slit elyd4)' to nt tL'C►1. telcG�l'. t;ltt41$ailltnent all(I SeClnntglV e�'�1'Vth 10 Cl:�c• 1 ,utcr (;m'eras. and mierujilloneti, %,., Iluo(in Cherandi 5 tvcmoll ^litanttnidclle Violat i can't auribut� tile acti4'ilies u) any one grt�ul' in particular, f uttile eYI )pians are flagrantly Obvious. 1'bey hat) e rrOCd lily privacy to a nunther of tt i> , hvr e�annpte remote y activating veli phan� at 1 nra )a(irated ii'om mobility, [t's created a tat of d Yatton► and gt od invtsttllink tent�lt It's (atacks. Trar king an(I nlonitoriug heha` iOm. And it's actually quit t hit It,,s c a to a lot but Ihetle are a mu tltu( perhaps dircctcd at tiler' as l otn relate Y i (:(ntlirSian not Otdy lin• Inc htlr uther5 os well: it is undermining what coo{d be othr:rtrise. a r e:enro�it c cu, a pCrsuual let cl as tteli. fat' nn,ly harden to ti tubal f am talking about, NVI}ere esselniail}' can`alir..ed thatc l ct mpellecl hone to content.1'herc is `r,iher aloft' but �t but can be consu u(d ai'olbn stuff is hased kill olher activities and walaI C cluing but ed 1 dc•scribc, f f puu are atrare of tUc situation. fou will inciudinu music put together' and assembled in a tlitTcrcnt tvay. But in light of l oche till d erre nalipUiivar y etc ta•ithout anything positive far i (lirieh};+Is and later the teork I tvasdoingmarvL tiulationshOt fust (l•C tihn and'yetcsyo},' a�r't»tu� ��; flti� tit Sf It reach Out la included t} ads del. I latvct•er. for ale pel;wriol{y it has el in(redtbly illi art rue }cru)nall), Any attempts at ga. " insight mrt e)lel t lihealth'.►ds thcr 1 } filo i'es►n,ltse 2)1'Cittnntg ignorunr e al ; l to . (til I crease an(I do iettis+r'Cy,reeston• eat'concern for , ontinue with the prrvac_v violation:(. ha as5htg illg t Of th lrt.nne nti()nc�1 prajQcts. Doe.►his rotund f'amilia,�d and r>�uittiat funcUa sung suureesi(olliciall oly r non) or �t thi5 pc,utt C have been lne)Stly isolated rroln COolaCt. Alt tine while those invOlvr(► timugly llvinat'iels� and devctupinc}1} of jit4 ale tiame clariticatiOrt and frit like you may bave sainC insight hared an in rrn Oise invor 1 business relnled ac hcv(lnd A1C pr(1jtCt, eSe.Scrihrtl, there may alae be in frasu•trctw`al prancers and artistic installation, as feel) or Cee devee)pulr It Of S}at•I Opti, 14'hile I can eaili•1rol tile voli(lily cif \that i am experiencing. in tel`ms of tohe SI of tilt5 mos > e I ,aid. i (100't know". Simlily seeking clarity and tvotdd oppreciate ally in, Wit you play haw(. 'Thank you fm Canside}nitta Jeff P72 michaei Shire from: Webmaster aWebmaster@ci.chula-vista,ca.us> Sent: Monday, January 16, 2017 6:37 PM To: Professional Standards Subject: City of Chula Vista: Service Complaint A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted, Form Name:. Service Complaint Form Date & Time: 01/16/201.7 6.37 PM Response #: 46 Submitter ID: 21824 1P address: Time to complete: 2 min„ 42 sec. Survey Details Page 1 escribe the incident that fed to this complaint, telling what happened from INSTRtJCTIUNs: Please complete this form and de what aspects) of the incident was improper beginning to end. Be as clear and specific as you can be. Describ(i.e. your specific complaint), and how it could be resolved to your satisfaction. You will be contacted for additional Information. If you need to file a crime report please contact the Chula Vista Police Department Dispatch Center (619) 691-5151- 1. Type of complaint: [x] Conduct [x] False Arrest [x] Poor Investigation [x] other 2. your Contact Information Name City Zip Code Home Phone cellPhone Email Address 3, Incident Information Location of Incident Date of incident 'rime of incident home Various mid day 1 Home Address State Apartment/Space Not answered Work Phone . b Birthdateim -,r'. P73 Case/Citation Number Not answered 4, Employees Involved 1) Employee Badge Not answered 1) Name of Employee Victoria Di Caprio Number Officer Casey Rose 2) Employee Badge Not answered 2) Name of Employee Number 3) Employee Badge Not answered 3) Name of Employee officer: Arce Number • 4) Employee Badge Not answered 4) Name of Employees Not answered Number g, please list anyone who wltnessed the incident:phone Number Name Witness #J. Mark Marvin Jordan Bach Not answered Witness #2 Witness #3 Julia Jacobson Not answered Not answered Not answered Witness #4 G, incident Details Please describe the incident that led at as this eft) ofithetincident was imp aper (i, telling what happened �e�yourspeetf c compla nt), and how it could specific . as you can be. Describe wh p be resolved to your satisfaction. . ent where Ongoing surveillance/harassment/h physical inetance its from polis l believeforces.This t ogr May of 2016. Where several officers from there was any presence but first p y NY DA. This was regarding emails. The larger the Chula Vista police department as well as officers from the sm Maaranhattan, includes severe violations of personal privacy situation is as such, thatthose involved engaged in'stalkirig, and theft and exploitation of comms. ercial projects. officers andronta invest gators scam to my housetion, have reported me to . Asking several questions and investigation to any t ho claim stating not civil contact those involved being assaulted andhey red thetotwo names) or ef arts at exploitatioin would be consequences. In a situation where my al projects have continued and time is civil rights, civil liberties are being a Whatever the unbiased take on that.situation essence. of the now I Upon follow epi ctimizinI rt allows those vequesgtederecordability tfrom the Chula Vista DPD. s I don to make threats, Shockingly they had none. Now I find this incredibly aven ans irod 1 find this all thetion more shocking, given thatat sient notone,they not have if they have no records of the events that P had been ating two, but SEVERAL officers to my door step. dFur ula Vista. To have no rmore, they had individuals of his t s i n an of itself pro blematic. All themore for sometime and flew out to San Diego an so, when it further derails anything else at hand. I should go onto state 1 have requested information from the Manhattan and Brooklyn DA's, and there has been no response. to elf nd not The behaviors have continued. I once did a test email with the Perbut i think soname in . However, theect is�gtuattonshasa cntinued g after several officers showed down the street, t don't know if related There was an instance in my household regarding situation broad and unforturiat ly much of the abuse who resides in the same and harassment have o Investigation of the events. Aichael v4owerton s stated, tto been subjected to, stems from there. 11) fact, ith the e v there may police be evi a nociations in the county,;.�he funding of some o these projects that have been coordinated Those involved have sought ,tubjugate me and abuse, varity o levels witne hin Che can to keep' coins Ys rained, ilisolI ed hile he andvidual has used tools and access given to engage in stalking those his family seek to take advantage of,the opportunities at hand. When confrontedie only physical ed i dense was in faction me, tion of which the police were called but chen waived'off. They showed up anyway -on showing to where it was clear I was nicked, Instead two officers'showed as well as a member from PERT. immediately up R my doorstep, without any investigation of the situation. P74 stance prior -made absolutely no on The officer submitting to the psych ward, �eusta�►dknthme and had actually seemingly had this decision iseem ng yi pre made. The the events. showed up with pre existing Information regardingto themselves Or others then it has to Instance compance - if a person is a threat elling this, meaning whatever the tunatelyt this is disputed In not Investigating the the matter, I was unfairly e dealt with first to deal with anything else. Unfortunately, ed to a bizarre humiliating experience and further Injustice. I can refer to other instances, where I have had to ca the subject police a this individual with far more evidence of a problem, and nothing has ever been handled in this capacity. d party information. t was After questioning the officer it was finally police departments nts are engaged in surveillance acme that they had access to titivitties upon the basis lof mentalfbealth what I already know, that the local polic p and that Some of this is being informed individuals regarding thIs Involved individuae alidityoof those behaviors. oinstead of ainyth njg that would confirmation that 1 have received from I am warrant, follow up being Instead relegated16 t oakl g fodnegating eg etgargding con 'tents that - entails tof an email victimized he basls of a m e t i health confirmation, two officers recently shows p. in Germ The check upl below Is attached . i kept a proxy email that I used for watching shows on nehave to explalntfllxhowathey c uad dedu y location aiwitho t confronting below. Unfortunately, there are two issues here. They civil rights that they are involved in surveithisclt ie. s ra e t conut more 'i m front that directly, YOU are being monortantly, it is encroaching on bizarre itored lin the shadows, g liberties. In a situation such as , this of which the validity ignored and instead has entailed The contents of the email are below. Again, i have confirmation of ask questions withot any repercussions for me. But even if the contents b0 them, without abelievable, is any fear of reprisal oht r being g systematically constrainled.Thlst have the right to believe those things, even act nem, is the tip of the Iceberg. I am asking that the injustices being Again, hese microItted ommrevenme be ts are indicative f heilarger situation. The may have already presented themselves in some capacity. Ag ollow up recently. There have now been two occasions where email contents which gives indication into wtappromptedEjs 311 the more disturbing. Mark Marvin from PERT Indicated to me they have showed. I recently followed up w h there are no records of PERT's involvement. ' 1 believe those involved are abusing variou's aspects of the system to facilitate their exploitation. Manipulating what they can ng In to maintain as long as possible. For example, while they do what they they can uld rationalize cons a n that for insuorance purposes hatte itheir ongoing behavior that could not be mor s corrosiv`eNaI I tho accessto information, I can't follow up. surveillance and guardianship.necessary Furthermore, the allegations I haus made, Ars not without validity. m der � with theStatedy It would appear that ern�lls are situation and Shedding insight into otheored and responses fabricated. But 1 have received some Indicating government organizations that are involved. Wwen ht apple and gl snit suppression, anything through the cracks that confirms what i already know, here Is differentg and itimize e and the When those involved in power, instead ignore and ealth. it subjects mlegate as 'e to further f I have a ri justice, When gmy efforts s to procure clarity situation as if it's existence Is indicative of mental h civil liberties and has a chilling effect. Each f these things, causes are met with unwelcome reprisal, it is an assault on my stress and hardship in an already situation rife with lt, aye when ot 6e msystematically ntained, it makes addressing the situation' harder...in which they can take advantage further. When records but further evidence of the behaviors I am being subjected to. i to ematls is not ch Below is the copy of an email I have sent since, of their sometimes les. it 1s not clear l owl they ar ssubstantlating themselves and associated unless backing a bit more. I am aware again my efforts are met With reprisal or shutdown or non response. Of the i am reaching out to see if your organdizzatei`o I d There have been a number, the ongoing rmost notably dor at least acy violations I arn ltheieasiest to explain) a resultant commercial projects being p is.{oyce "owe involvement in the anti-nuclear movement in the late s film surrounding my grandmother's (her name early Bos. P75 ackson , Borinle Raitt, others involved ing There were a number of concerts with recognizable names -far example wn, Linda {const dt,The Eagles, etc -There are actualyrI this time quite varied from Bruce Springsteen, Jane Fonda , Jerryta believe two feature•films and a doe. in teram aodthrund Diablo Cany oit is n Power planty set in the aht terms of mus c, there is a doc by Danny Angeles regions of California, Particularlyhe east at Goldberg entitled No Nukes which giver{ d the sight into ill include more contemporary artists totfulfidfl SE concerts On t thoseroles of which Garden, beyond the artists from the p he rs much broader than that and in fact most held is Industry. of hi h gowl, But there has bleen considelrable financing and Investmt into the tim the unique opportunities more akin to the nature of which remains unclear.- have ht to develop the I say this as unfortunately, a number of individuals unstructured groupgstalk ng progressed towards otherthings likelthink grand jury originates from former peers. What began trials, it's allowed people to gain unp have connections to he edented access and ntertainment I over my and finance Industries, es, However, asithIs tro situation advantage of this opportunity. Many the military (Le Air has progressed It's gone on to include Various USA and abroad incl uding most couom the ntries You operate htn�For �e example, in the UK the Navy) and a host of others bath In the such as the NSA has a partnership with GCHQ. To gro pose Involved theIRS,loca havellawmanipulated Inforenforcement mation onbtheyhave obtained andsare explo'I In Consumer Financial Protection Bureau as h perceived vulnerabilities in order to maintain control. I get the sense there are a number of companies in tech, telecom, entertainment and seemingly everything else. particular, bthe I cant attribute the activities to any one group in cel{ cell phone obvious,tOms are flagrantly and computer cameras, and microphones, DNS my privacy in a number of ways. For example remotely activating nd it,s actually quite a bit more extensive, but spoofing and man in the middle attacks. Tracking as dieted at hem astoring �l amAefatively incapacitated from mobility les. created there are a multitude of others as well and p p a tot of discord, and l think unnecessary conflict, it'snfuite corrosive on pe for mebut level as well. It is undermining whi could be otherwise a•great project and good Investment.q There is'other stuff butwhatcan be construed as'othe ostufoubased w `°hat i am talking about. Where essentiallyer activities and work I was doing but contentI simply harder to describe. if you are aware of the situation, y assembled In a dferent way. But in created from found content, Including mu to sicpeach out to incl ded individuals and later he work I wias doing manifesting In stalking) I realized that it compelled those r other ways (E.e film and television, art, music, videogames, ti adsQsitive for me personailytc). However, for me eAny altteimpts at gaining insight y Invasive violations of my personal privacy etc without anything p expressions of generally yields either 1) no response 7) feigning ignorance or 3) in some cases I've gotten cease and desists ar' concern for my menta{ health'. ly nue with the privacy At this point I have been mostly lsoladweloot of the d frm contact. All lreme tioned projects Doe se while those involved g is sound familiar to you? Sorry if this violations, harassing behaviors and pmenased on who is out of the blue, simply seeking some clarification business and related a beyond the prt like you may have ojects s descrtbed there may also be ved an potential fundraising sources (officially or hot) as well or the development of start ups. There could be five events infrastructural projects and artistic installations ke I said, I While i can confirm the validity of what I ou ma ehave! Thank you for considerationng, in teri-ris of the specifics iof n y message. know? Simply seeking clarity and would appreciate any insight y y Jeff Thank you, city of Chula Vista This Is an automated message generated by the Vision content Management System""� please do not reply directly to this email. P76 P77 Subject: Re: Re: From: Jeffrey Howerton < To: "Althausen, Dave@POb� ve; ausen@post,ca.gov> Time: Wednesday, April 12, 2017 9:4:5:24 PM GMT -07:00 Hi Dave, Thank you for .responding lout I don't thh& you're conducting the search in an appropriate manner. I recounted correspondence in which I received kom'Valna Wilson to the Chula v1sta PD via another PRA, It would entail there was other correspondence as well. I can also cite that which I have sent on my own. Did you include correspondence or just the identifying hifo removed of emails call logs etc? Can you let me know, and please re conduct your search. Jeff On Wed, -Apr 12, 2017 at 1.2:12 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST :a.cfoy> wrote: Mr. Howerton: Based on the identifying information that you have provided, POST does not have any record of you in Its database. This communication completes POST's response regarding your request. ' Thank you, Dave From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailto' _y - Sent: Wednesday, April 12, 201 To: Althausen, [lave@POST <Dave AlthausenPpost.ca.gov> Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Checking in on my pra. Can you please update nye on the status, Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 5:16 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: I've never had any formal association with post. My firstcontact was in 2016. Matters may P78 predate that though. On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:49 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave AlthausenPngp Lca, wrote: Thank you Mr. Howerton. Can you advise if you completed any POST courses in 2015/2016 or earlier? From- Jeffrey H'owerton F Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 4:25 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Here you go. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4;0� .PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave Althausen(o�post,ca.aov< mailto:Dave AlthausenCE1p _PM, Althausen, wrote: Mr, Howerton- i .. Thank you for your reply, In order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur full name or social security nuanber. Regards, Dave From- Jeffrey Howerton � 111tL11L com>] Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:49 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST . P79 Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state, I received a seperate public records request with. Valna Wilson of Post sending a message Don Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD.. I havenevercorresponded with either, so interesteclstd know what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. ,teff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave Althausen(a7post.ca.croy<mailto:Dave AlthauseuCapost.ca.goy> <mailto:Dave Althausen(@Post.ca.g <mailto:Dave Althausen(@i3ost.ca,ctov»> wrote: Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. Thank you, Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Commission on POST From: com> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11.:29 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST W Subject: Hi Dave, •'E Hi Dave, I am snaking a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with: 1.) Myself (Jeffrey Howerton) I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible, Please let me know if you need any other information, Thank You, Jeff [Xl<https:/Is(inde.rsILragment/info/uwv VaoDIn9Sna8cl iOYYxrshKkTlOVd3R47Mkv3iE=> [X] [X] <httas--, twitter com/CAaovexaanezzt>- [X] [X] [X]<https://sonde rs/fracnnent/footer/uwv Va0Dlu9Sna8. cl iOYYxrshKkTT OVd3 R47 Mky3 i E => [X]<httns //sends rs/fractn-ient/info/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl i4YYxrsliiClcTlOVd3R47M1 r3iE�> E [X] [X] t> [X] [X] [X]<h-tttsende.s/fracr��ent ooter uwv..VaoA1.u9Sna8cl iOYYxrsM,, ,: f.WR47Mkr3iE=> [X]<litt-os•//sends rs fraanieznt/info/V- MFHn3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG18 0mYM•8zAd3R47Mkv3iE => [X] [X] <httis•//twitter coin/CAgovernrnent> [X] P81 [X] [X] <httus://sende.rs/fraument/footer/vcVcrFHn3zw5 Sna8cl iOYYG180mYM8zAd3R47Mky3jE==> [X]<https://sende.rs/framnentlinfo/vcVgFH133zw5Sna8c1 _ iOYYGl8 OmYM8ZAcl3R47Mky3i E=> [X] [X]<httns://twitter.com/CAgovernmen > [XI [X] [X]<https://sende rs/fraginent/f`ooter/vcVgFHp3zw5Sna8el iOYYGl80inYM8zAd3R47Mkv3iE => P82 Subject: RE: Re: From: "Althausen, Dave@POST" <Dave. t ausen c post.ca.gov> To: Jeffrey Howerton Time: Wednesday, Apri- 12, 2017 12:12:02 PM GMT 07:00 Mr. Howerton: Based on the identifying information that you have provided, POST does not have any record of you in Its database. This communication completes POST's response regarding your request. Thank you, Dave M, From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailt Seat; Wednesday, April 12, 2017 5:42 AM To; Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov> Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Checking'in' on my prh, Can you please update me on the status. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 5:16 PM, Jeffrey Howerto wrote.- I've rote:I've never had any formal association with post. My firstcontact was in 2016. Matters may predate that though. - On Thu, Mar 30, 201.7 at 4:49 PM, Althausen, Dave a POST <Dave A1t;hausenPpost,ca,Crov> Wrote: Thank you Mr. Howerton. Can you advise if you completed any POST courses in 2015/2016 or earlier? From: Jeffrey Howerton P83 Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 4:25 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Re: Ili Dave, Here you go. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:09 PM, Althausen., Dave@POST <Dave.Althausen(most. ov.<v,<iiiailto;Ddve.Althauseii@]2ost.ca,gov» wrote: Mr. Howerton- Thank you for your reply. In order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur :full name or social security number. Regards, Dave From: Jeffrey Howerton mailt ] Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1.:49 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state, I received a seperate publiq records request with Valna Wilson of Post sending a passage Don Redmond o�the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorresponded with either, so interested know what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. P84 Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 20f7 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave AlthausenCa�post,ca.aov<ivailto:Dave Althausen(a)post.ca.g <mailto:Dave AlthausenP-post.ca.gov<mailto:Dave AlthausenCa7post.ca.crov»> ,wrote: Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA. analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, Please send that to me as it will assist with our research. Thank you. Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Commissioh on POST Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:29 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all information (Documents, photos, email.s, tests, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with; 1) Myself (Jeffrey Howerton) P85 I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me Imow if you need any other information. Thank You, Jeff [X]<htt s: senders fra znent info uwv VaoDI 9Sna8cl_iOYYxrshKk OVd3R47Mkv3•E—> [X] [X] <httns //twitter com/CAgovernment> [X] [X] [X]<httos //sende rs/fragment/footer/awv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshKkTLVd3R47Mkv3iE> [X]<htWs //sende rs/fragment info/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshKkTTOVd3R47Mkv3iE=> [X] [X] <https //twitter com/CAaovernment> [X] [X] [X]<httns //sende a.s/fragment/footer/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshnTTOVd3R47Mkv3iE=> [X] <httns //sende rs/fragment!info/vcVgFHp3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG180mYM8zAd3R47Mkv3iE > [X] [X] <,littps //twitter coin/CAgovernment> [X] [X] [XI rs/fracrnacnt/footer/vcV�{FI7p3zw5Sna8c9. i0YYG180mYM8zAd3R�k7Ml�.vBE=> [X] <htt s: senders fra znent info vcV P'H 3zw5Sna8cl i0YYG180n�.YM8zAd3R47M1�r3'E=> [X] [X] <https•//twitter coria/CMovernment> [X] [x] txa <https l/sendo rs/frac'ment/footer/VpVgFHU3zw5Sna8c1 joYYGZ8OmYM8zAQR47Mkv3iE-> Jeffrey is using Senders: caller Ip for email. Sry It for free. ME Subject: Re: Re: OW From: Jeffrey Howerton "Althausen, Dave PO ' <Dave.Althausen@ ost.ca.gov> To; Al @ p Time: Wednesday, April 12, 2017 5:41:41 AM GMT -07:00 Hi Dave, . Checking in on any pra. Can you please update me on the status. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at.5:16 PM, Jeffrey Howerton . wrote: I I've never had any formal association with post. My s contactwas in 2016. -Matters may I predate that though. On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:49 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST<Dave.Althausen(c)1)ost.ca.croy> wrote: Thank you Mr. Howerton. Can you advise if you completed any POST courses in 2015/2016 or earlier? From: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Thursday, March 30, 0171 -- To: 4:To: Althausen, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Here you go. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:09 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave.Althausen(@post.ca.crov<mailto:Dave,Althausen(a-oost.ca.g >> wrote: Mr. Howerton- Thank you for your reply. In. order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur full name or social security number. . Regards, Dave From.: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Thursday, March 31,1. To: Althausen, Dare@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state,,I received a seperate public records request with Vahna Wilson of Post sending a message Don. Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorresponded with either, so interested to know what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave AlthausenCa�t�ost.ca.ggv<inailto:Dave Althausen@i3ost.ca. ov> <inailto:Dave AlthaLtsen@post.ca.gov<mailto:Dave Althausen(a-post.ca,cf >>> wrote: Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA. analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. .Thank you. Dave .Althausen Public Information Officer Commission on POST To: Althausen, Dare ct POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all information. (Documents, photos, enaails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with: 1) Myself (refwerton) I would like this information in digital format delivered to xray email please if possible. Please let me know if you need any other information. Thank You, Jeff .,. [X1<htt ps: se,nde,rs fra nl6 t in.fo tlwv Va.o 1 u9Si. [XI [XI overnment> [XI [X1 [X]<https I/sends rs/fragment/footer/uwv VaoDlu9Siia8cl iOYYx rshKkTTOVd3 R47Mkv3i E = > [XI<htt s //sends is&agment/info/uwv VaoD1u9Sna8c1 i0YYxrshKkTTOVd3R47M1v3iE=> [XI [XI overnm-ent> [XI P89 [X] [Xi<�iittT)s•//sende rs/fragment/footerLu-M VaODlu95na8cl iOYYx rshiCjjOVd3R47Mkv3iE=> [X]<https://sende,rs/-agment/iiifo/vcVcLFHp3zw5Sna8cl iOYYGl8 OmYM 8 zAd 3847 Mkv39 E _> [X] [X] <https 1/twitter com/CActovemment> [Xi [X] [X]<littI)s.Hsende rs/fragment/footer/vcVc(FHi)3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG l80mYM8zAd3R47Mkv3jE=>' [X]<htt)s•//sende rs/fracrment/info/vcVaFHp3zw5Sna8cl i0YYG18 OmYM8zAd3R47Mkv3i E=> [X] [Xi <Lttps.Lt—witter c—oxn/CActoyernxnent> [X] [X] [X]<https://sende rs/Liacrinent/footer/VgVgFH-o3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG 180mYM8zAd3R47Mkv37E-=> .m Subject: Re: Re: , r Froze: Jeffrey Howerton To: "Althausen, Dave@PO < ave.Althauseza@post.ca.gov> Time: Thursday, March 30, 201.7 5:16:12 PM GMT' 07:00 I've never had any formal association with post. My firstcontact was in 2016. Matters may predate that though. On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:49 PM, Al.tlaausen, Dave a POST <Dave Altha isen a post.ca.crQ-V> wrote.- Thank rote:Thank you Mr, Howerton. Can you advise if you conapleted'any POST courses in 2015(2016 or earlier? From: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Thursday, March 3 17 4:25 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST. Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Here you go. Jeff . On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:09 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave Althausen@post.ca.troy< mailto:Dave Althausen nost.ca.crov>> wrote: Mr: Howerton- Thank you for your reply. in order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur full n.aipe or social security number. Regards, Dave From: Jeffrey Howerton mail to. r Sent: Thursday, March 30, 0 1: - - To: Althausen, Dave@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Hi David, T do not have a past id, I can state, I received a seperate public records request with Valna Wilson of Post sending a message Don Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorresponded with either, so interested to know what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30; 2017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST ;a.aoy< mailto:Dave Althausen(c-post.ca.gov><mailto:Dave Althausen c: post,ca,aov<naailto:Dave. P91 AllthausenC7a post.ca.goy»> wrote: Good morning Mr. Howert6W-'W'� I will :Forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. Thank you.' Dave Althausen Public Information. Officer Commission on POST From; j eff _9werton To: Althausen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am maldng a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with; elf I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me Imow if you need any other information.. Thank You, Jet [X]<httpsl/sends rs/frac�znent/info/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshUkJTOVd3R47M1rv3jE=> [X] [X] <https://twitter.com CAaovernment> [Xj [X] [XI <Ilttps sends rs/fracrment/footer&w-v VaoDlu9Sna8c1 iOYY rsl.�KkTTOVd3R47Mliv3iE�> [X]<https•//sends rs/fragnient/info/uwv VaoD1u9Sna8c1 1OYYxr8hK1d1OVd3R47M1w3jE=> [X] [X] <hU s://twitter.coz �CAggvernincnt> [X] [X] [X]<httUs,,//sends rs/fragment/footer/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshKkTTOVd3R47M1w3jE=> [X]<httos•//sends rs/fragment/info/vcVgPHp3zw5Sna8e1 iOYYG180mYM8zAd3R47M1v3iE => [X] [X] <httus;//twitter•comCAaovernznent> [X] [X] 2h [Xl<https://sends rs/fracrment/footer/vdVcgFHp3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG 18 0 mYM 8 zAd 3 R47 Mky 3 i E - > [Xl<https://sends rs/fracrment/info/vcVaFHo3zw5Sna8c1 iOYYGi80wYM8zAd3R.47Mkv3jE=> [X] [X] <https,//twitter com/CAgoveriiinent> [XI [XI [X]<littps:Hseiide rs/fracrn-lent/footer/vcVctFH133%wSSlia8cl iOYYGl80mYM8zAd3R47Mkv3jE=> P93 Subject: RE: Re; From, "Althausen, Dave@POST" <Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov> To: Jeffrey HowertonNO Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 4:49:24 GMT -01:00 Thank you Mr. Howerton. Can you advise if you completed any POST courses in 2015/2016 or earlier? From. Jeffrey Howerton Sent; Thursday, March 30, 2017 ;25 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Re: Hi Dave, Here you go. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:09 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave.Altliausen@post.ca.gov<mailto:Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov>> wrote: Mr. -Howerton- Thank you for your reply. In order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur falx name or social security number. Regards, Dave From.: Jeffrey Howertor Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1 To: Althausen, Dave@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject; Re: Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state, I received a seperate public records request with Valna Wilson of Post sending a message Doii Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorrespbn.ded with either, so interested to Imow what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. Jeff On Thu., Mar 30, 2017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave.Althausen@post. ca.gov<mailto:Dave.Althausen@post,ca.gov> <mailto:Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov<mailto:Dave.Altliausen@post.ca.gov>>> wrote: Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. P94 Thank you. Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Commission on POST To: Alth6usen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject; IIi Dave, Hi Dave, I am maldng a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with: iMyself (Jeffrey,I;owertan) I would like this information iii digital format delivered to any email please .if possible. Please let me know if you need any oder information. Thank You, Jeff [X]<haps://sende.rs/fragmentlinfoluwv VaoDlu9Sna8c1 iOYYxrshKkJJOVd3R47MItv3jE=-;> , [X] [X] <https://twitter.com/CAgovernment> [X] [X] [X]<https://sende.rs/fragment/footer/uwv VaoD1u9Sna8c1 iOYYxrshKkJJOVd3R.47Mkv3jE�> [Xl<https://sende.rs/fraganeait/info/uwv. VaoDiu9Sna8cl. 1OYYxrshKkJJOVd3R47Mkv3jE=> [X] [X]<https://twitter.coiii/CAgovernmeiit> [X] . [X] [X] <bttps://sende.rs/fragment/fodtex/uwvVaoD 1u9 Sna8c1_iOYYxrshl<kJJOVd3R47Mkv3j E=> [X•]<https://seii.de.i,s/fr. agi-nexit/info/veVgFHp3zw5 Sna8cl._iOYYGI80mYM8zAd3R47Mlw3jE=> [X] [X] <htips://twitter.coin/CAgoverniiient> [X] [X] [X]<https://sende.rs/fragment/footer/vcVgFHp3zw5Sna8cl iOYYG180mYM8zAd3R47Mkv3jE=> [X]<httl)s://seiide.rs/fragment/info/vcVgFHp3zw5Sna8c1 i6YYGI8'OinYM8zAd3R.47Mkv3jE=> [X] [X]<https://twitter.com/CAgovernineiit> [X] [X•] P95 [X]<https;//sende.rs/fragmeiit/f`ooter/vGVqFHp37-w5Sna8cl-iOYYGl80mYM82Ad3R47Mkv3jE=> i effrcsy Is using sonde rs: cal ler 10 for eme 11, -rr.I It for fro W -� [a". 441 W -� [a". Subject: Re: Re: - From: Jeffrey Howertoo To: "Althausen, Dave@POST" <Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov> Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 4:25:17 PM GMT -07-.00 Hi Dave, Here you go. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 4:09 PM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave Althausen(@Post.ca.cioy> wrote: I Mr. Howertonw Thank you for your reply. In order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur full name or social security number, Regards, Dave From: Jeffrey Howerto Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:49 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Re: Hi. David, I do not have a post id,- I can state, I received a seperate public records request with Valna wilson of Post sending a message Don Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorr esponded with either, so interested to know what other forms of communication there were and to what extent at your org. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2,017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave Althausen(cg ost.ca.aov< mailto:Dave.Althausen ost.ca. oar» wrote' Good morning Mr. HoWerton- I will forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist withh our research. Thank you. Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Commission on POST From: Jeffrey Howerton fjeffrevhowerton@amail.coxn<nx.ailto:ieffreyhowerton@amail.com>] P97 Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:29 PM To: Althausen; Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all informatio' (DIcuments, Photos, emails, tents, videos, data and other records 11�cludiYig other requests) associated with: elf (Teffre.v Howerton) I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me know if you need any other information, Thank You, Jeff [X]<https://sends rs/frarnnent/info/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8c1 iOXYxrshKkTTOVd3R47Mkv3iE=> [X] CX] <https ffiwitter.conVCAgovernment> [X] [X] [X]<https //sends rs/fragment/footer/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshMOVd3R47Mkv3iE—.> [X]<https•//sends rs/fragment/info/uwv VaoD1u9Sna8c1 iOYYxrshKkITOVd3R47Mkv3iE-.5 [X] [X] <httbs•//twitter.com CAaovernment> [X] [X] , [X]<https•//sends rs/fragzlieint/footer/uvti v VaoDlu9Sna8c1. iOYY)shKkTTOVd3R47Mkv3iE�.> Dear Coordinator: Please furnish me with copies of all records about me indexed to my name. If you have any questions please reach out to me via Fi. Please expedite processing and waive any fees, am without resources, under duress, and was informed of government investigations. To help identify Information about me in your record systems, I am providing the following required information: Full Name of Requester: Jeffrey Howerton Citizenship Status -SA Phone: rrently accessible only for identification purposes) Social Security Number' Current Address: Date of Birth: SNIWPlace of Birth CA USA I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct, and that i am the person named above, and I understand that any falsification of this statement is punishable under the provisions of IS U.S.C, Section 1001 by a fine of not more than $10,000 or by imprisonment of not more than five years or both, and that requesting or obtaining any record(S) underfaise pretenses Is punishable under the provisions of 5 U.S.C, 552a(i)(3) by a fine of not more than $5,000, Signature Date 03/3012017 } l( •< tom: dtS Subject: RL: Re: From: "Althausen, Dave@POST" <Dave.Althausen@post.ca.gov> To: Jeffrey Howerton Time., Thursday, March 30, 2017 4:09:45 PM GMT -G7-00 Mr. Howerton Thank you for your reply. In order to accommodate your request, please provide you ur full name or social security number, Regards, Dave From., Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Thursday, March A 2017 1:49 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST Cc: Cornejo, Dave a POST. Subject: Re: Yµ Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state, I received a seperate public records request with Valna Wilson of Post sending a message Don Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I havenevercorresponded with either, so interested to know what other forms of communication. there were and to what extent at your org. . Jeff on Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST <Dave.Althausen@post,ca.gov<mailto:Dave,Althausen@post.ca.gov» wrote: Good -morning Mr. Howerton I will forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. Thank you. Dave Althausen Public'Information Officer Commission on POST Prom; Jeffrey Howerto zuailto1 Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 1.1.:29 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all information. (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data P101 and other records including other requests) associated with: 1) Myself (Jeffrey Ho erton) I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. please let me lmow if you need any other mfonnation. Thank You, Jeff [Xj<https://sende.rs/fragment/info/tiwv VaoDIOSna$ci._iOYYxrshKkJJO'V•d3R47Mkv3jE=> [X] [X]<https://twitter%*com/CAgoverniYtent> [Xj, [XI [X]<https://sende.rs/fragment/footer/uw VaoDlu9Sna8cl—iOYYxrshKl�JJOV'd3R47M1 v3jE=> [Xj<llttps://sende.rs/fiagmentlinfo/uwv�_VaoDlu9Sna8cl iOYYxrshl<l4JOVd3R47MItv3jE=> [X] [X] <https://twitter..com/CAgovemment> [X] [X] [X]<https://sende.rs/fragment/footer/uwv VaoDlu9Sna8c1 iOYYxrshKkJJOVd3R4.7Mkv3jE=> •}; Jeffrey is using Senders- caller iDfor email. Trvitfor free, 0 P102 Subject: Re: From: Jeffrey HowertonT To: "Althausen, Dave@.POST" <Dave.Altha"aSepost.ca.gov> Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1.:49:44 PM GMT -07:00 Hi David, I do not have a post id. I can state, I received a seperate public records request with VaIna Wilson of Post sending a message Don Redmond of the Chula VlstaPD. I haven.evercorresponded with either, so Interested to know what other forms of communication there were axid to what extent at your org. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017. at 7:57 AM, Althausen, Dave@POST Dave AlthausenCc post.ca.aoy�> wrote: ! Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA. analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #k, please send that to me as it will assist with our research. Thank you. . Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Commission on POST From: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Wednesday, March 2"T, -2R -29 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST, Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated. with: 1) Myself (Jeffrey Howerton) I would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me know if you need any other information.. Thank You, Jeff P103 Subject: RE: From: "Althausen, Dave@POST" EDave.Althause @pos .ca.gov> To: Jeffrey Howerton ,"ornejo, Dave@POST" <Dave.Cornejo@post.ca.gov> Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 7:57:04 AM GMT -07: 00 Good morning Mr. Howerton- I will forward your request to our PRA analyst for a response to your inquiry. If you have a POST ID #, please send that to me as it will, assist with our research. Thank you. Dave Althausen Public Information Officer Coriumission on POST From: Jeffrey Howerto Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:29 PM To: Althausen, Dave@POST; Cornejo, Dave@POST Subject: Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am making a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails, texts, videos, data and other records including other requests) associated with: 1) Myself (Jeffrey Howerto3n) I would like this inform.ation.in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me know if you need any other information. Thank You, ,Teff . �� Jeffrey Is using senders. caller ID for email. Tty it for free, l� . P104 Subject: From: Jeffrey Howerton To: dave.althausen@post,ca,gov,davecor'nejo@post,ca.gov Time: Wednesday, MarcN29, 2017 11:29:16 PM GNU -07:00 Hi Dave, Hi Dave, I am malting a records request for all information (Documents, photos, emails', texts, videos, data and other records uiciuduig other requests) associated with: 1) M self (Jeffrey Hower ton" ) A X would like this information in digital format delivered to my email please if possible. Please let me know if you need any other information. Tli ank you, Jeff g, P105 ff PDQ 3 P106 Subject: Re: Re: From: Jeffrey Howerton To: Itunier@chulavistapd.org,mbyron@cl-iulavistapd.org Time- Thursday, April 13, 201.7 1.:27:57 AM GMT -07-00 I said, I would follow up after when I received a response from post. I did today. They stated they could find no records. This of course contradicts what I received from the City of Chula Vista. I have asked them to conduct their search'again however, I do not want to delay further. Unfortunately, I believe this reflects ongoing discrepancies, injustices and ethical.issues. I can't ascertain from your department or elsewhere but I do intend to file a complaint again while exploring other o.ptions. The below attachment is what I received from the city of ChiYla Vista. In order to forward to Lt Redmond, the individual would have needed to consult to find this out. I intend to make my complaint before the evening�as I believe this investigation was not properly conducted and reflects as an affirmation of more serious issues related to the commercial projects I have described. The attachment is for your own records.I have asked Tamisha to provide me as a pdf the emails in their original format (i.e producing the original message id) from the emails from. Post and then that concludes my current request. Jeff On Wed, Apr 12, 2017 at 5:23 AM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Dear Captain Turner, and Lt Byron, Re Case: 17-0008 The information in your letter contradicts what I have received already via a records request referencing Lt Don Redmond, My complaint is not regarding the instances on Jun 27th, 2016 but predates that as well. More problematic however, is via' another pra, I received indication that Don Redmond had been working on something well. before I made illy complaint. It was clear, that in order to submit information to him they had to inquire to find out. When I broached that topic, Don Redmond had no idea about what I was referring to. Unfortunately, again prior to -this, apart of the issue is missing records yet dealing with the consequences. Meanwhile because they are attached to commercial opportunities, others being enabled to exploit. I have been waiting to hear back, before checking into POST. However, I do believe this represents severe ethical issues OR indicative of something else. I am still awaiting to. hear back from Dost but was. -planning to forward all the communications I receive that are relevant. Unfortunately, given what I am dealing my concern was corroboration and damage control. your response came ori April 4th. I world appreciate your tape before moving forward with any other complaint. Now that the investigative process is over I am making a request for these records as well. I do appreciate your help resolving this matters, Jeff ---- Forwarded message ---------- From- ---- From: Jeffrey Howelftox Date: Mon, Apr 3, 2017 at 3:05 AM Subject: Re: Re: To: Don Redmond <DRedmond(achulavistapd.oEg> P107 Dear Lt Redmond, This is not reassuring as apart of my complaint is missing or falsified information, whole events even, allowing parties involved here to continue in the exploitation of various commercial projects. Evidence being ignored, and i4istead I leave continuued to suffer negative repercussions. For ex4niple, reliance on the mental health system. I will send you these documents, as soon as I hear back. But unfortunately, it casts a veneer of severe doubt about whatever this investigation as entailed given there is a history of involvement. I believe it reflects the problems I am experiencing. 1� am not necessarily alleging your ethicacy is in doubt especially given your answer here. Meaning there may be phished emails. But it continues to lend itself to the notion that my underlying concerns are correct. But I feel troubled by this. I will send you hiformation when I hear back from Post as I don't want this to reflect further. Meaning information to disappear etc. preventing me from clarity and allowing others to exploit commercial opportunities, Will touch base as soon as they get back to me. eff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 1:45 PM, Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.ora> wrote: am unaware of the correspondence you are referring to with Vaina. Could you send me a copy? .Lt, Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit. (67.9)476-2452 dredmond@chulavistapd.org From: Jeffrey Howerton [moiltcf�� Sent: Thursday, March 30, 201=777r— To: 07 b r To: Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd,orci> Cc: David Oyos <DQyos(a)chuiavistapd.org> . Subject: Re: Re: Dear Lt Redmond, k I Thank you for responding. This is troubling to me, She sent you an email on ,duly 16th, of P108 2016. Y have never corresponded with either you. or Valna prior, and suggests and other means and methods of correspondence. Not only, for her to deduce obtain this, but to It -now to forward to you. This predates my complaint by several months, and suggests you were already working on something., Your name is not included in anything else. Apart of the problem, is major events prior, there are no records of. Not sure if this is the case here but it does suggest prior involvement that predates my complaint. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 9:31. AM, Don Redmond <DRedmond(@c11ulav1sta13d.ora> wrote: Mr. Howerton, received your email and I will attempt to answer your questions. ® The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17/17 for the issues in your emall below and is being Investigative (PS# 17-0008). We hope to send you a disposition letter In the next few weeks as to the findings of the Investigation. © For case 16-09729, you were detained for 5150 W.I. Mental Disorder 72 Hour Observation hold. The State of California is listed as the victim in these cases. I am unaware of why Vaina Wilson from POST is listed as a correspondence. Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)476-2452 dred mond(achulavistapd.oru Al fix' <+ .•'.s� L y From. Jeffrey Howerton [main Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:22 PM To., Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.orcl>, David Oyos <DOyosCa chulayistapd' > Subject,. Re: Dear Detective Oyos and Lt Redmond, Pi 09 I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and 'investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info, For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have paled a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren giardina@disabiii�t ri,icrhtsea.orcr) and Mike Phillips (mikeyftjfssd.orcE) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters -from, case number 1609729 fit within this. I ain also referencing CPRA, calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I ant not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from valva Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters -where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process; that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff On Wed, Mar 29, 2017 at 11;18 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Hi Don, Hi David, I received a public records�reWest response ziLdicating that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Marr Margin director of PERT has responded stating they Pilo have no Imowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren aiardina.(adisabilit3tghtsca.ora} and Mike Phillips (mike-P(@j£ssd.orct) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1.609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPItA. calls for service incident L1.1.7, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request. you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,aud I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of justice. The responso was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the I]TG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at feast let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff W. Pill P112 Michael Shire From: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2016 11:26 PM To: Barbie Brookover Subject. tte: city of Chula Vista Police Contact Us -Web Notification Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hi Barbie; I was recently SI -Sold by Officer Axce and PERT Offtcor picaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying. I would fake to request my records. Ido you have those or is there a different process? Thanks for letting nae know. Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 I'M, Jeffrey Howerto» > wrote: Hi Barbie, I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is strange don't you think? And unfortunately, I am not e response. Could you please provide me with the contact information. of getting what I feel an appropriat someone at your department who could be mare helpful?operhaps, do you hat. P ve, pony in umotlaer ins l? I sQ they like to reach out to him. If this not in fact through you pCedepartment. are in fact at your police department but the xecords obtained elsewhere (i.e the fbi, the california threat assessment system, etc etc etc). I make no distinction, but in terms of records etc probably should. Thank you again for your help. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2,015 at 12:03 PM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookovernchulavistaaid or > wrote;_ Hello Mr. Howerton, ucted your PRA eqUOSt. As stated in an thorough search of e Department nt hasUnoprecords responsive to your request,rand has no errecord of contact with you. earlier email, the Po p �a��ar-c��ro�Cay�x police support Services Manager P113 Chula Vista Polioe Department Phone: 69 691.5128, Fax: (,619) 585-5745 bbrookover@chulayistapd.org ; www chulaylstapd.ors Front: Jeffrey Howerton Zmailto sent: Monday, August 24, 201.5.11:34 AM To: Barbie Brookaver Cc: ; community—Relations Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton Barbie, If you cannot find answers. Then I am really compelled to file a police report, or speak with someone who can help me find some alternatives. I am involved in a really sick situation, where there have been severe and egregious privacy violations in my home (for example, activating others cameras and microphones on their cell phones and computers) and have broadcast this to a wide audience. Going out of their way to humiliate and degrade me to peers but also professionally as well. It involves members from the Hollywood community. Behaviors where something like this - sending armed individuals to question under false pretenses is not above them., And I got the sense some of the people in on the backstory. One of the members gave a card, but unfortunately not to me, even when. asked. It was withheld when asked for it then lost. I was promised a follow up. And I feel like this has been more than ample time to get some sort of information on the matter and do so. There was one man pictured at the white house. It is imperative that I find information on this matter. I was also forwarded correspondence indicating some individuals speaking with the the DA's office. if it is possible, could you please forward this to someone who has the capacity to maybe check, in with other offices. To sec, what the issue is. Maybe someone from your office renienibets. Or is this something you could call up other offices to get a confirntaiion on. It is either a major misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on my part. Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 11:05 AM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Hi Barbie, P114 Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to ray home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office. that f exhaust all avenues as in ilio ' �e need to press charges, then the false and misleading It is important I great engths have been Unfdrtunately, the situation 1 to involved in r heir activities - ,e Shortly after,rths. ey 1 owedlup I believe they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up contacted. is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? 'thank you for following up with nle. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug24, 2015 at 7;50 AM, Barbio 13xaokover <BBrookoverCa�ehulavistaud.or >wrote: Hello Mr, Howerton, lable This snail is response to the below PChula Vista police Departmentuest ►has notted t recordscords responsive to your below regluest records, It hass been determined that the for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, �aS n0 record Ofc databases, with Youwand haso record oftyour personal via .partner organizations. The Department information. please contact me if you have any questions, P115 Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone; (6_19) 691-5128 Pax: (619) 585-5745. bbrookover chulavlsta d•Or www.chulavista d,or From: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August 16; 2015 9:31 PM To: CommunlW Relations Subject: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department Date lie Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response #: 345 Submitter ID. 4033 IP address: 'time to complete: 22 min., 55 sec. survey Details n P116 Page 1 1. Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Hower an Email Address Comments Emai Postal Address" Postal City Postal State-prov: CA Zip Code - Country: United States of America Home Phone: Work Phone•. Drivers License: D01i: This is a request under the Public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. were sent. s was nation with I elieve Earlier in the year, officers, Attorney's uto office of Manhattany house s advisedg emails t he officers to folliow upwitha niumber of Individuals both the NYPD, and District including elected officials and law enforcement located in Santa Barbara, and Los Angeles. The follow up was nonexistent. 1) I am seeking'accass to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as ing all information logs of information that Isas ces ii i via artner Farrexamptio apns,a tiof the surs should bveillancel am be ng sub]ect tohen�lve. So I am �has been facli t ted and not limited to what w p Y through the electronicsothers he California hrreat asse ss system or the fbi where Ehis in my household. or if there are people in your department informal on isessen ally investigation elsewhere... for example,, under housed and accessed somewhere else. i am also seeking all correspondence with officials from New York where this was originally coordinated. So i am Also, for further specificity. The nature of this tlanis i am apa t of. i tution, has am being specific becld that those at se I amhave ino familiar on iwith your also seeking information on other invesfi ga lied n interface. ror example, I do not olhave et l,0110.to But in y have surveillance aetivity.eCs electronics (computers, cell phones} and activating cameras and microphones This information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when in reality 1 am the target. am requesting a waiver of all processing fees. My safety, civil liberties and ability to advance in life have been assaulted I and P117 creating stress. The follow up then rendered necessary, and creates undue financial burden. Furthermore, this information is informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. I believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commercial Interests rest but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any m The California public Records Act requires a resp a out wfhi and when 1business e records 1 am requestingw0l might expect copies� take longer, please contact mjwlth inform exemptionIc if you deny any or all of this request, please citee a available to rneunder the justifies the refusal to release the law information and notify me of the ap' eai procedures Thank you for co stdsting my request. t . -9V a Sincerely, Jeffrey Nove' Thank you, g, ..;• City of Chula Vista .. system' This is an ou� message generated by the vision Content Management Please do not reply directly to this email. t �t P118 Michael Shire From: Barbie Brookover <BBrookover@chulavistapd.org> Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2016 7:55. AM To: Jeffrey Howerton ntact Us � Web Notification'- Mr. Howerton 2nd Subject: 12F: City of Chula Vista Police Co response Hello Mr. Howerton, July-nt on or fter, Monday, 18, 2016, A copy of the request ed report can bb picked up at the Chula AM to 5 Ata M Police De The cost of the report is $1.00. Please be during regular business hours, Monday through Friday, prepared to show valid identification. ple6se contact me with any questions. 23aY�'c��ro�r�at�er police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department phone: (699) 699-5928, Fax: (699) 585-5746 bbrookayer@chulayistapd.org www chulavlsta d.or■■rte From: Jeffrey Howerton (mailto:"""� Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2016 11:26 PM To: Barbie Brookover, Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us -Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hi Barbie, I was recently 51-SO'd by Officer Arco and PE Officer Dieaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying• I would like to request my records. Do you have those or is there a different process? Thanks for letting Inc know- ff eMon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffirey Howerton wrote: Oil Hi Barbie, I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is lerase rovvide me, witt YOU h the And act unfortunately, of getting getting what I feel an appropriate response. Could you 1 1 You have Lon `t'urner's email? I would someone at your department who could be more helo fu1 oPerhaps, Perhaps, as in other instances, tl-'ey like to reach out to him.. if this not in fact through y pdepartment. are in fact at your police departrxrent but the records ca t ri telrns of re ds et.c the c probably should.hreat assessment system., etc etc etc). I make no distinction, Thank you again for your 1101P, P119 Best, Jeff on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 PM, Barbie $rookover <BBrookoyer<Iiulavistapd.oxg> wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, A thorough search of Chula Vista Pollee Department records was conducted per your PRA request, As stated In an earlier email, the Police Department has no records responsive to your request, and has no record of contact with you. ' Bar tiara groan"er- Police support Services Manager Chula Vista Poiice Department Phone: (61 9) 691-5128, Fax: (619) 5_ 8� 45 bbrookaver@chulavistaod.org www.chulayistapd.ora From: Jeffrey Howerton [mails ' ww Sent: Monday, August 24, 201511:34 AM Cc660101,111).'r-PP, veCommunity Relations Cc5u jject: Re: City ohula ista Police Contact Us Web Notification - Mr. Howe on If you cannot find answers. Then X am really compelled to file a police report, or speak with someone who can help ane find sonic alternatives. i ram. involved in a. really sick sihiation, whore, there have been severe and egregious privacy violations in my home ga wide audiei ge.others Going out of the away tolhumiliate andones oil 0101`Gll phones and computers) and have broadcast dais to degrade Ric to peers but also professionally as well,. it involves members from the Hollywood community. Behaviors where something like this - sending armed individuals to question under false pretenses is not above them. And X got the sense some of the people in on the backstory. One of the members gave a card, but unfortunately not to me, even when asked. It was withheldheme sort for it then lost. T was promised a follow up. ,And I feel like this has been more than ample time to get P120 llse information on the matter and do so. There was one man pictured adthat wwhite hoe individuals erativ g with be information on this matter. I wathat I find s also forwarded correspondence to the DA's office. If it is possible, could you please forward this to someone £�o zem mlie capacity �s maybe check in with other offices. To see what the issue is. Maybe someone from y a con£irmatian on. It is either a major misunderstanding or this something you could call up other offices to get indicative of greater cause for concern on my part. 'Thank you for your time and'consideration. Best, Jeff On Mon, Aug 2-4,2015 at 11:05 AM, Jeffrey Howerton > wrote: Hi Barbie, Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office. It is important that I exhaust at venues as in the event T seed to press charges, then the false and 1hisleading s. And great lengths have been Unfortunately, the situation am involved in involves in s Shortly after, the showed up I believe they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning; covering up their activities. contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me. P121 Best; Jeff Can Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie Wookover <BBrookoyorngiiiiiavistapd.or > wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, 15. rch of This emall is In resporsethe bha he Chula Vista Police Department uest Chas no re1oords responsive to yourbelowarequeste records, i has been determined for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared 'databases, as well as togs of information that is accessed via cord of contact with you, and has no record of your personal partner organizations." The Department has no re information. ' please contact me If you have any questions. police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone: 619 691-5128,Fax: (619) 685-5745 bbrookover@chulavistapd.ora www.chulavistapd.org From: Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August: 16, 2015 9,31 PM To: Community—Relations Subject: City of Chula Vista police Contact Us - Web Notification P122 A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted.. Form Name: police Department Date & Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response #: 345 Submitter ID: 4033 IP address,. Time to complete: 22 min,, 55 sec. Survey Details Page 1 1. Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by f+llin outthe form below. First Name Jeffrey Rost Name Howerton Email Address Comments Emai Postal Address: Postal city-alow Postal State pro Zip cod country: United States of America Home Phone' Work Phone:; Drivers License DOB: This is a request under the Public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. nation with I elieve Earlier a tits year, officers, showed up Office of Manhattan' I advised the officers to follow ouse regar4ing emalls that were sent. This upiwith a niumber of Individuals both the NYPp, and District Attorneys 5 P123 including elected officials and law enforcement located In Santa Barbara, and Los Angeles. The follow up was nonexistent. 1) 1 am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as logs of information that is accessed via partner organizations. is shhe suould b ecomprillanceehI ensivebeing s I am seeking all beim fae ation art and not limited to what was explicitly stated, For example, p through the electronics of others InmyCalifornia Threat assessment system or the fbi where this Info ma ion isousehold, Or if there are people In your department assigned to an essent ally investigation elsewhere... for example, Linder t else. I am also seeking all correspondence with officials from New York where this was housed and accessed somewhere originally coordinated. Also,.for further specificity. The nature of this situation, has entaild that thoseinvolved because I relied fn creative r familiar ens so I am also seeking information on other investigations I am apart of. i am being specific etc to engage hein suhvave relied eillance activity,ers electronics (computers, tell phones) and Interface. For example, I do not have activating cameras and microphones hen in -This information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, w reality I.am the target. I am requesting a waiver of all processing fees, My safety, civil liberties and ability to advance in life have been assaulted and creating stress. The follow up then renderednecessary, uand creates undue financial burden. Furthermore, this Information is informative and will contribute greatly topublic I believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commercial interests but the activities indirectly.related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest. The California Public Records Act requires a response within ten business days. if access to the records I am requesting will take Ion er, please contact me with information about why and when I might expect copies. f 4' if you deny any or all of this request, please cite each specific exemption you feel justifies the refusal to release the information andMotify me of the appeal :�rocedures available to me under the'law. Thank you for considering my request. Sincerely, Jeffrey Hawerton Thank you, 01 city of Chula Vista This is an automated message generated by the Vision Content Management SystemT"T. Please do not reply directly to this email. P124 Michael shim From: Jeffrey Howerton Sent: Thursday, July 070 2 X6 3:41 PM To: Barbie Brookover Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us -Web Notification Mr. Howerton 2nd response lease explain the delay? When l spoke with officer Arte he stated it Thank you for letting me know. Can you p p would be ready immediately after my stay there. Jeff On Thu, Jul 7, 201.6 at 7:54 ANI, Barbie Brookover <BBrookover c(�chulayistapd.or > wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, On or fter, Monday, uly A copy of the requested report can be picked upFriday, aidae 8nOQ AM ula Vista Police to 5:0o PMe The costartment, of the report Is $100.1 Please be 10� during regular business hours, Monday through r y, prepared to show valid identification. Please contact me with any questions. police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police. DepartMnt Phone: (619) 691-5128, t=ax: (619V � i 685-5745 bbro pyeri9chulavi ilaAd.or www chulayistapd orn From: Jeffrey Howerton 06m�01all 1 6 11:2rTVr sent: Wednesday, y To: Barbie Brookover. Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2n response P125 Hi Barbin, � n• as recentl 51-50'd by Officer Arce and PERT Officer Dicaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying• iw y T would like to request my records. Do you have those or is there a different process? Thanks for letting me know, Jeff wrote: On Mon, Aug 24, 201 S at 12:27 pM, Jeffrey Howerton Hi Barbie, understood the first time. Thmik you again. But this is strange don't r° e think? re contact information OAndunfortun4tely' amf J lease getting what I feel an appropriate response. Could you p Provide, s d ou have Lon Turner's email? I would someone at your department who could be more helpf rl of -IhaP dQ, perhaps, as in other instances, they like to reach out to him. if this not in fact through y pdepartmentthe fact at our police department but the records obtained elsewhereeeto ds tc�probably houldthreat are m y assessment system, etc etc etc). I make no distinction, but in Thank you again for your help. Best, 10f "t'ulavista d.or > wrote: On Mon, Aug 24, 201$ at 12:03 PM, Barbie Brookover <BB=oo1`"�'F' � Hello Mr. Howerton, P126 Your nest. As stated in an has no records responsive to your request, and has no record of contact with you. A thorough search of Chula Vista p{ Tice Department records was conducted per y ur PR req earlier email, the Police Departmen Police Support Services Manager ()hula Vista Police Department Phone: 699 69 :gM, Fax: 619 685-67 6 bbrookover chulavista d.Or WWw chulavista d.oM tiowerton Emallt From: Jeffrey ,. sent: Monday, August 24, 201 11:3 AM To: BarBie 13rookove Community. Rel�tlons Su Re; City Chula Vista police Contact Us -Web NotiFication - Mr. Howe on Cc: Barbie, ve been severe and if you cannot find answers. Then I am really conapelted to file a police report, or speak with someone who can ere there ion, Wh help me find some' alternatives. I aaxi involved in a really sick situatthers cameras andanicxophones on their cell egregious privacy violations in my laoine'(for example, activating o. out the Hollywoodirw comanunity. tiol and have broadcast this to a wide audience. hers fi out of 'their way to humiliate and phones and compo ) degrade me to peers but also professionally as well. It involves s to ere some like this - sending armed 'individualis to question under false pretenses is not above Behaviors wh them. And l got the sense some Of the people in on the backstory. ked. It was withheld when asked for le time to get some sort of One of the xaaeinbers gave caro but low unfortunately like th s has been mora tham house. It is iriaperative that l find it tilen lost. I was prormse also forwarded correspondence indicating some individuals Speaking do m yUetalteck infortnation on the matter and do sso. There was 011e"11 ntan pictured at tlau w ai es the iaafoxmation on this matter I was lease forward this to son-leoale who has p the DX8 office. If it is possible, could you p Maybe someone frown your office remembers. o r is t dis g or this something you could call up in with other offices. To see what the issue is. May other offices to getconfiamtioit wit. It is either a majorm indicative of greater cause for concern on my part. Thank you for your time and consideration. P127 Best, Jeff wrote: on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 11:05 AK Jef%ey Howertoll Hi Barbie, Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force carne to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office. it is important that Z exhaust X11 avenues as in the- VV l X need to press charges, then the false and misleading ve en Unfortunately, the situation T am involved i� involves activities.pl Shortly afternthey shs. And owed up eat Itbel ve 1 they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering p contacted. Xs it possible to also check. if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me. Best, Jeff on Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBxo_ okover(o)cliulavistV-LOr ' wrote; P128 Hello Mr. Howerton, 5. er a thorough search of vailable This email is in response to the below h Chula Vista Police i�epartme tihas notted t records rtesponsive to your below request records, It has been determined that as is for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, no ofc contdataact with,youwalnd logs of record oftyour pefraona) essed via partner organizations." The Department #� .w.~� informatlon. Please contact me if you have any questions. Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista police Department phone; (619)691-5128, Fax: (6191685-6745 bbrookover chuiavista d.01 Www, chulavista d:or prom's Webmaster Sent, Sunday, August 16, 2015 9:31 PM To: Community—Relations subject: City of Chula Vista police Contact Us •- Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: police Department Date & Time: 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response #: 345 5 P129 Submitter ID: 4033 Ip address. Time to complete: 22 min. , 55 sec. Survey Details Page 1 Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. First Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton Email Address Comments Email� Postal Address.'�� Postal City: postal State-provAo zip Cod Country: United States of America Home Phone Work Phone Driverd License. Dos ;his is a request under the Public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment, coordination with I believe s was Farller in the year, officers, showe�dup offine of Manhattann advised tg emalls ae officers to follt were sent. ow up1With a number of individuals both the NYpp, and r%tract Attorney's was nonexistent . nt t located in Santa iarbara, and as Angeles. The follow up including elected officials and law enforcemedatabases, as well as 1) i am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared logs of information that is accessed via partner orgaa apartiof the su bveillance i am beingoI am seeking subject to, has been facilitated and not limited to what was explicitly stated. For example, If there are people in your .through the electronics of Others in my house�rassessment system or the fbi where this nforms ion Ise ss hold.investigation elsewhere... for example, under the califorrna e housed and accessed somewhere else, I am also seeking all Correspondence with officials from New York where this was P1 30 originally coordinated, reliedhat those involved have creative Also, for further specificity. The natureinvestigations i ation, has m apart a laam being sspecific because I amnat familiar your So ! am also seeking information on other Interface. Por example, I do not have a phone. But they have relied on others electronics. (computers, cell phones) an activating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity. This information i suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when in reality i am the target, ave been assaulted i aril requesting a waiver of ail Processingfees, Mysarytcivil andcrelatesil undue financial burden. Vurthees and ability toadvance In liferino e this information s creating stress. The follow up then rend es informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commercial interests but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any commercial interest, The CaAfornia Public Records Act requires a response'vi thin ten business days. if access to the records I am requesting will take longer, please contact me with Information about why and when I might expect copies. if you deny any or all of this request please cite each specific exemption you feel justifies the refusal to release the information and notify me of the appeal procedures available to me under the law. It Thank you foaconsidering my request. Sincerely, Jeffrey Howerton Thank you, city ofChula•Vista r'. > Ir` This is an automated message generated by the Vision content Management System"". please do not reply directly to this email, P131 Michael Shiite From: Barbie Brookover <i3Brookover@chulavistapd,org> sent: Thursday, July 07, 2016 3:55 PM To: • Jeffrey Howerton Subject: RF: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification _ Mr. Howerton 2nd response Hello Mr. Howerton, CA Govt. Code 6253(c) allows public agencies up to 10 days after receipt of a request for records to determine if records shall be released and to provide the records or an explanation for a delay in records production. B��a;$�oo�Co•vet•' Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619) 6g1-5128, Pax: (619) 585.5745 hbrookover@chulayistapd,org www chulay stapd.org From: Jeffrey Howerton (mail PM Sent: Thursday, .July 67, 2016 3 . To: Barbie grookover Subject -Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Thank you for letting me know. Can you please explain the delay? When I spoke with officer Arco he stated it would be ready immediately after my stay there. Jeff On Thu, Jul 7, 2016 at 7:54 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookoverehulavistand•or wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, on or after, uly A copy e the requested business rephoursrt can be , Monday through Friday, 8 00 M to 5:00 PM. up at the Chula Vista police The cost of the report Is $100.1 please be16, during regular business � • prepared to show valid identification. Please contact me with any questions Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department P132 Pham: (6�- J28Fax: 685-6746 ?99?_ bbroo a-cA itayistapd.om Www rhulavistapd.or� lFrrom: Jefty 1-10welton [malito Sent; Wednesday, July 06, 701.6 11.:2 M Ta. 13arbi6 Brookover subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us - Web Notification Mr. Howerton 7n response Hi Barbie, I was recently 51-50'd by officer Axce and PERT Officer Dicaprio with officer Rhodes accompanying. I would like to request my records. Do you have those or is there a different process? I. f. Thanks for letting me know. Jeff wrote: On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 1.2,27 PM, Jeffrey HOtiverto.a Hi Barbie, ith the I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is strange don't you think? And unfortunately, I 8m not etti�� what I feel all appropriate, response. Could you p? Perhaps, zdo you have, I on Tuaci r �f pm it I rmationwould g g 0 de someone at your department who could be more hc�lpfi�l . 1 Other like to reach out to him. If this not in fact through your pelsevvolic he e (i.e t e fbi, theent. perhapsas ical f rnia threat' they are in fact at your police department but the records Obtained assessment system, etc etc etc). I make no distinction, but in terms of records etc probably should. Thank you again for your help. P133 Best, Jeff M, Barbie Brool[over <BBroolcover chulavista d.or > wrote: 01, Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 ]� Hello Mr, Howerton, records was conducted ur PRA request n an A thorough search of Chula Vista Police Dorecords responsi a to your request,rand has no record ofcontacwith you. earlier email, the Police Department h Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: jgjL 91^51 88, Pax: (619)5"5745 bbrookover chulavista d.or www.chulavistapd.org Fro►n: Jeffrey Howerton [mailt Sent: Monday, August 24, 201511:34 AM To: Barbie Brook ve • ' ' Relations C: Cnmmunity.� Subject: Re: City otNo a Vista police Confect Us -Web Notification - Mr. Nowertan 13arbie, If you cannot find answers. Then I am iealty.connpeled tsick situation, ofile a nt , where there la o can have been. severe ank with Someone d help me find some alternatives. I am involved to a really egregious privacy violations in my Home (for example, activating othe. g out of their way o humilers cameras and microp4ones iate and cell and phones and computers) and have broadcast this to a wide a degrade me to peers but also professionally as well. It involves members from the Rollywood community. 3 P134 Bchaviors where something like this - sending armed individuals to question under false pretenses is not above them. And I got the sense some of the people in on the b arAstory, old when asked n asked. It was One of the members gave a card, but unfortunately not to me, oven en zneore than ample timetoget some sort of r . it then lost: I was promised a follow up. And I feel like this has information on the matter and do so. There was one man pic nce indred at iccatinghe lsome individuals speaking with the information on this matter. I was also forwarded eorresponde the the DA's office. If it is possible, could you please forward this e to n eoux of�ae ,members. Or is this be check in with other offices. To see what the issue is. Maybe someon Y something you could call up other offices to get a confirmation on. It is either a major misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on MY Part - Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, M wrote: On Mon., Aug 24, 2015 at 11;05 AM, Seffrey I•lowerton Iii Barbie, several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New York DA's office: ed to press charges, then the false and misleading P Itis important that I exhaust all avenues as in the event I Ile �• � ,,,fir Unfortunately, the situation I am involved in involves pi S rtly after, they 4 great showed howedlengths have been up I believe they were taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up thea activities contacted: Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? P135 Thank you for following up with me. Best, Jeff Ojj Mon, Aug 24, 7.015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookover chulavista d.or > 'wrote: Hello Mr. Howerton, er a thorough search of This email is in response to the below Public Records Act request �eeartment�has not records rtesponsive to your below regd via ate lo records, It has been determined that the Chula Vista Police p as of for "Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared ofcontdataact w th you, an'es as d has no o recoord oftyourhp trs n nesse partner organizations. the Department has . Information. Please contact me if you have any questions. Police Support Services Manager Custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone; (619) 8, Fax: (6191_ 5745 bbrookover chulavista d.or vvww A_.OYPI P136 lFrom: Webmaster Sent., Sunday, August 16, 2015 9:31 PM To: Co mmunity_Relations Subject: City of Chula Vista police Contact Us Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department Date & Time: 08/16/2015 9;30 PM Response #: 345 submitter iD: 4033 w address: Time to complete: 22 min., 55 sec. Survey Details Page 3 1, please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below. f=irst Name Jeffrey Last Name Howerton Emall Address Comments Emai Postal Addressi postal City Postai State-prov Zip Code Country: United states of America Home Phon Work Phone Drivers License 6 P137 DAB: 01/28/1986 This is a request under the Public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. s was nation with I believe Earlier in theyear, officers, showed up t0fi'e of Manemails that were sent. hattanngadvised the officers to folllow upiwith a number of Individuals both the NYPD, and District Attorney's of was nonexistent. including elected officials and law enforcement located in Santa Barbara, and I.as Angeles. The follow up 1)1 am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as rehensive. So I am seeking logs of Information that is accessed via partnerea rexampie; apartofthe surveillans should be ce I am being subject to, has been facilitated and not limited to what was explicitly stat through the electronics of others in y house Threat l.r if there are eisewhere...for example, underthesystinvestigation em or the fbi where this information is essentially housed and accessed somewhere else. i am also seeking all correspondence with officials from New York where t s was originally coordinated. Also, for further specificity. The nature ofdht atn°apart of faaim being specific because I amd that those Involved ll�ve inot familiar ied on iwith your ve So I am also seeking information on other investigations interface. For example, I do not have a phone. But they have relied on others electronics (computers, cell phones an activating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity. This Information I suspect being used for commercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when in reality i am the target- -en assaulted ity to advance In life e be am requesting a waiver of all processing fees. essarsafety, andcivil creiat s uendue finaand ncial ial burden. Furtherlmore, this Information s creating stress. The follow up then rendered nec Y, informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. I believe what has motivated some of this is regarding my commrcial Inter ialest interest but the activities indirectly related and essentially roped in. Either way, the public interest outweighs any business e records i am requesting will The California Public Records Act requires a resp about ith ten nse nand when Imight expect coto take longer, please contact me with information Y if you deny any or ail of this request, please cite each ava labia to me exemption 0undhefeel justifies the refusal to release the information and notify me of the appeal procedures Thank you for considering my request. sincerely, Jeffrey Nowerton Thank you, city of Chula Vista P1 38 This is an automated message generated by the Vlsion Content Management Systema"'• please do not reply directly to this email. P139 Michael From: Sent: To: Subject: Jeffrey Howerton Thursday, July 07, 1G 3:58 PM Barbie Brookover ta Police Contact Vs -Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd Re: City of Chula Vis response after. plained to me at the time. As stated, I was informed I could request.them "'nznediately This was not exP Thank you for letting me know. On Thu, Jul 7, 2W6 at 3:55 PM, Barbie Brookover <BBx_ aokovezg6hu-Ia-Vi a d or > wrote' Hello Mr. Howerton, c ailows public agencles up to 10 days after redellpt o erequest production.iorrers to determine if records CA Govt, Code 6253(c) shall be released and to provide the records or an explanation fora Y Police support services Manager Chula Vista Police'Department Phone:1619)� 8 Fax ti19 585-5745 b rookver chulavista d.or www ch+lavista d or9 Prom: Jeffrey Howerton [alltO 1,6 3,41 PM Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2 e Broakover uh•Qet; Re; City of Cl�.ula lista Police Cozztact'Us � Web Notifieatiozi - Mr. Howerton 2zi response Barbi Subject'. me know, Can you Please explain. the delay? When I spoke with officer Arco he stated it Thank you for letting would be ready immediately after my stay there. Jeff P1 40 On. Thu, Sul 7, 2016 at 7:54 AM, $arbre Brookover <BBt�oa o�!e1ncl'ulavistapd•or> wrote. Heilo Mr. Howerton, ti 0 can be picked up at the Chula Vista Police Department, on or after, Monday, July 18, 2016, A copy of the requested rep 8.00 AM to 5:00 I'M. The cost of the report is $1.00, please be during regular business hours, Monday through priday, prepared to show valid identification. please contact me with any questions. Police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: f619) Fax: 699 585-5715 bbroa io_ er o chuiavistapd.or www.chulav(sta d.or From. Jeffrey Howerton [malitoj Sent: Wednesday, July06, 20161126 PM To: Barble Brookover Police Contact Us � Web Notification - Mr. Howerton 2nd response Subject: Re: City of Chula Vista Hi Barbie, tl 5"i-5a'd by officer Arco and PERT Officer picapjio with office, Rhodes accompanying. I was recently I would like to request xny records. -leo you, have those or is there a diff'ereut process`l Thanks for letting me know. P141 Jeff On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:27 PM, Jeffrey 1-lowerto wrote; fli Barbie, I understood the first time. Thank you again. But this is strange don't you think? And unfortunately, I am not .ate, response: Could you please provide me with the contact information of getting what 1 -feel an approp someone at your department who could be more helpful? Perhaps, do you have Lon Turner's email? I would like to reach out to him. If this not in fact through your police department. Perhaps, as in other instances, they are in fact at your police department but the records obtained' elsewhere (i.e the #bi, the california threat assessment system, etc etc etc). I make :no distinction, but in terms of records etc probably should. Thank you again for your help. Best, Jeff 4n Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 12:03 PM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookover@chuiayistapd.org wrote_ Al . , f Hello Mr. Howerton, an thorough search Department PRA As stated Poli e s Department h earlier records responsive to you request, an has nnorreco d of contact w1ith you. earlier small, th ii i i s •• • police Support Services Manager Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (619)�. 69�, Pax: M6 P142 bbrookoyer chulayistapd o19 www chulavistand.orli prom: Jeffrey Howerton [mailto Sent;'Monday, August 24, 2015 11-74—AM— To: 1:34AMTo: Barbie B ookover Cc Community_Relations Subject; Re: City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us � Web !Notification - Mr. Howerton Barbie, with someone, who an If you cannot find answers. Then I am really compelled a really t sick situat on, where the 1 o file a police report, or ave been severe and c help me find some alternatives, I am involved Y egregious privacy violations in my home (for example,adae audience.tGoing out of their way o hers cameras and humiliate and Celk phones and computers) and have broadcast this to a degrade me to peers but also professionally as well. individuals t question nder false pretensesOm the is not above Behaviors where something like this - sen mg . them. And I got the sense some of the.people in on the backstory. ld when asked One of the members gave a card, but unfortunatly not to me, even when asked. It was l like this has been more than ample time toeget some sort of r it then lost. I was promised a follow up. And X feel information on the matter and do so. There was one manpictured indicating lsomeuindividuals speaking with the se. it is imperative that I find information on this matter. I was also forwarded correspondence, the the DA's office. If it is possible, could you please foisomeone cord from your office o Someone who etxzembers�Or is maybe check in with other offices. To see what. the issue is. Maybe something you could call up other offices to get a confirmation on. It is either a maj or misunderstanding or this indicative of greater cause for concern on my part. Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, Jeff ote: On Mon, Aug 24, 2,015 at 11:45 AM, Jeffrey flowerton r Hi Barbie, P143 Several members identifying themselves as apart of your police force came to my home. Some were carrying weapons. This in coordination with the New yoxk DA's office. au t all avenues as in the event I need to press charges, then. tho fals It is important that X exhe and misleading natel the situation I am involved. in involves multiple organizations. 1 Sh shod great wed I bel eve hey were taken Unfortunately, their activities. Shortl after, they p taken to ensure secrecy. Meaning covering up Y contacted. Is it possible to also check if any records of this were deleted? Thank you for following up with me, Best, Jeff On Mori, Aug 24, 2,015 at 7:50 AM, Barbie Brookover <BBrookover@chulayista d.or > wrote: Hello Mr, Howerton, rch Of lable This email is in response to the below Public Records Police t�Crequest mentsubmihas not81cords reAfter sponsive to Yourbelow regiuest records, It has been determined that ng Chula for "Any flies, correspondence, meetings' as nbsts, silared databases, as record of contact with you, wel(as logs has noorecoord oftion your personal is partner accessed via partner organizations. The Department h y Information. Please contact me if you have any questions. P144 Police Support Services Manager custodian of Records Chula Vista Police Department Phone: (819) 681-5128 Fax: (619)585-67A5 bbrookoyeya.)chulavlstagd.org www chuIavistapd.org li romt Webmaster Sent: Sunday, August 16, 2015 9;31 PM To: Community Relations Subject; City of Chula Vista Police Contact Us Web Notification A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Police Department Date & Time; 08/16/2015 9:30 PM Response #: 345 Submitter ID: 4033' ip address: Time to complete: 22 min, , 55 sec. survey Details Page Z 6 P145 Please feel free to contact us with any comments or questions by filling out the form below - first Name Jeffrey Last Name tiowerton Email Address comments Email postal Addres Postal Cl Postal State -pro zip code Country® Home Phone Work Phone: Drivers 1-1censewAdw This is a request under the Public Records Act and California Sunshine amendment. nation with I believe Earlier in the year, officers, showed up to my house regarding emaiea e were to followupups, was ivi with a nlumber of individuals both the NYPD, and District Attorney's Office of Manhattan. I advised including elected officials and law enforcement located in Santa Barbara, and Los Angeles. The follow up was nonexistent. t.)1 am seeking access to my personal information. Any files, correspondence, meetings, requests, shared databases, as well as rehensive. so I am seeking ail logs of Information that is accessed via partnernr examate� apartiof he surveillans should be ce i ain being subject to, has been facilitated and not limited to what was explicitly stated. peo le in your department assigned to an investigation through the electronics of others in my household. Or if there are psessment system or the flol pInf6rmatibn is elsewhere... for example, under the Californiial Threat asing all correspondence with officials from New York Where thisawlas housed and accessed somewhere else. l am originally coordinated. • Also, for further specificity. The nature of this situation, has entaild that those involved have relied on creative means. 5o i am also seeking information on other inveestaiBut they have retied onI am apart of. I am to hers elecng specific tronics (Compecause I am uters, cell phones)ot familiar with o and Interface. For example, i do not havephone, activating cameras and microphones etc to engage in surveillance activity. ercial purposes. And again they are essentially exploiting the system, when In This information I suspect being used for comm reality I am the target. ity to advance in life ve een I am requesting a waiver of all processing fees. My safety, dvil Icrelateslundue finaes and lnciatburden Furihermaore�th s information s creating stress. The follow up then rendered necessary, Informative and will contribute greatly to public understanding. P146 ut the I believe what has motivated some of thhisis Interestringwmy commercial Interestseighs any commercial 1 b erect. activities Indirectly related and essentially roped in. lather way, the public businesse within ten days. e records i am requesting will The California Public Record Act requi es about by and when Im ghtexpect copies, take longer, please contact me with information if you deny any or all of this request, please cite each specific exemption you fees justifies the refusal to release the Information and notify me of the appeal procedures available to me under the law. Thank you for considering my request. Sincerely, } Jeffrey Howerton Thank you, city of Chula Vista This is an automated message generated by the Vision Content Management System!'. Please do not reply directly to this email. 8 P147 Michael From, Thursday, Vaina@POST <Valna.Wilson@post•ea•gov> Sent: Thursday, July 1.4, 201611:42 AM S SeDon. Redmond Cc: Lonto, Karen@POST Jeff subject: Email contents from a rey Howerton From: Jeffrey Howerton mailto Sent; Thursday, June 30, 2016 4:04 PM To: Lightbourne, Will@DSS <Wiil,Ll htbourne DSS.ca, ov>; Kent, Jennifer (EXE�ost.c�o v>S <Jennlfer,KentCdhcs.ca,gav>; Scofield, Stephanie@POST <Stephanie Scofiel Cfp �� cc: senator iarkson@senate ca.�o_v; assembivmember.wlitiams@assembly.ca. oy Subject: systemic Abuse Hi Jennifer, Hi Will, eve X am forwarding a copy of a letter X am sending, if the state has expended timge of e period lof which I haveties. Then I �been e instance which 1 was subjected to; azad the damages incurred i subjected to this, not only for rrryself but the opportunity cost and corrosion and theft of commercial projects . that much more pronounced. you ate dealing Furthermore, I need to know what X can do to defend myselfis a means all tnechanisme1of shutting any other h systemic abuse and corruption -• deflecting towards things, investigation. When the police officers showed, the officer Victoria Dicaprio of Chula Vista's PERT' There was not any discussion nor any investigation of any of the eteriod in h ch theyat transpired. tshowe Sl e already down and sat dowry. Furthermore, within the less than 20 minute 1? had access to my information. it seemed as though her cl in the matterSat hand,to 51-50 wapre ta � eth xe handh ng of this into calling the police on some of the individuals involved matter highly unorthodox. White at the hospital, she indicated she had access to 3rd party information b � would ot iter yield dess � so helps Ie stated, that what I am stating'makes no sense and 'this is a problem again, I actually agree, the major difference is, my mental and ernotie personhood, but also the flagrant exploitanal faculties are quite atune and ton of the am concerned not only about the egregious assault an my p t clear if everything (Lo sculpture parks etc) commercial but commercial projects at hand, Well actually, no much of this rooted ill using a means for an end. P148 When people have an economic interest as well, It makes their behavior insurmountably more vile, utare denying you their justi cc motives are much easier to discern. When you arei n situation ITI�ats where problem�l ne ed to know. T to was an and instead seeking to do what they can to harm o penalize. incidence one year prior, where several officers showed themselves mon vof the nate duals involved reporting asor in coordination fTorn both he Manhattan DA/NYPD,and Chula Vista PD - where I believe arrested. However, upon requesting information on this o officers w tlont� officer Dicapns prior to this ao�office Ar o and Officer records or anything else related to me, There were tw Rhodes of the Chula Vista PD. The latter, was one of the ]nese individuals.roshowed the first time where they had no records. They also indicated forme, if cbrrespondenc . # corroe The correspondence I am sending now, they have sough. Butt etthe ycannot adrnitthey are in fa spying oil my only options are fabricating and duplicating evidence betcannot , my lights furffier, and their at y emails. What I am being subjected to, while unusual, is not without SorI edence. In double checked �with some of the notes with one record. At the hospital, the doctor gave me an othere, are numerous cases on the dd feelnng Ptc- Either this of the nurses after and there were statements such -as sbsliierobiem in the event iany other so ps in my rte consults with there are micro was fabricated, ox a sever misunderstanding• But tht t p this information or seeks to use to corroborate some sort of narrative to retroactively justify their behavior or funnel. it into something new. As stated, the protocol of those involved is to lie. in i �household °a t d real of acor tio t esple here this is Whe r my Father cin"�h0 events that transpired fueled by provocations, and est entailed subduing this frankly cannot stand and this deny flab t the only ant exploitationent incidents have in the or any knowledge. N communication with my individual) then proceeded of deny where I believe grandmother (who at one point worked with Hannah Beth various thinks at)hand. his A.gain,ndespi a thlatter s a theseindividuals there is significant activity exploiting me and the v lv g feel empowered to lie, and also empowered to involve hereauthorities. ens or echanism o defend oneself I believe they are a threat to me, but again to seeking to shut down the validity of anything I assert, there 'and me alone while validating everything which Itis not clear how they seek to selectively allows them to exploit. I have had m deleted and many other instances where information has selectively ile road disappeared. I believe they may fico aad some involvement ata) Ba barthe e PD ote r some�sortlof community type contact was communicated to me at the time) or w eo le could ever be something, It is not clear how conceivably something so bizarre and extreme with so many p p constructed, The nae I am sending is below. however, I believe some of the parties may already, have access. I have communicated directly to Das Williams and to Hannah Beth Jackson, If the state has knowledge of these P149 activities.;. then X believe what I am being subjected to is a form of tong to convey aspect source of those p projects there is knowledge of commercial projects and then amidst this seekingt isnot goal to criminalize, but when as mentally unstable. I believe their actions ifa t1 athmu h Foxe°re sevcorroded Ilam startingtonot care. They are riot each subsequent chapter ensures my protecting me. The only doubts is how widespread this seems to be. Again, nothing I am. stating is without precedence and I do have written correspondence acknowledging the is cannot be deztied. But if you are shut down prior being able to use this, there is nothing you existence, Th can do. • z t rat options are for gaining knowledge into what is a fact yet extreme lengths being taken I need to know wl a Y•of the letter I arra sending to groups I believe to be, involved. If to keep that froth me, Again, below is the copy and I am continued to be subjected to hardships and persecution or left vulnerable these things are transpiring, to groups who have no insight. This is a major problem. • what insights into this situation you may have and what my options are in pursuing Please let me knowon where•my rights are not being unfairly assaulted or at risk to poi Iles knowledge surrounding what is going abusing their power. Jeff ant wing i t out b> 5cc 11 Will. nl'gani'ration is familiar willitnhertmoinnotably (or at least thel�asies tc)e\periIcxhlno).Ail 1111 su1•totutding In)' I ale 1'raCh I crnnntCrcial l,ruiecte hoing dcvClopcd. •there ha+e heat a u ut'antlatitthcl''a (her name is Joyce Hot+erton) involvement in the nti-nuclCar mo+emenr in IIIc lata 70ti early s. x= s It.:l'he C at~les: eta There arc actually I believe two s •aatury during t het t' +rere o nuns i cr of conccrts +vith rccoi;n)zttble names - for e•�t�a Ctona t�tton �Jro+vee: Bonnie Itaitt. ()thcrs involved of C'al rohis time yaiiC txried I'ri„n Bruce Spt,ngstcen. Jane Fonda Jorr}'13rtile S .0which NO n powor Plant, In terns of tnusic, there is n doc s Land t1nC a tih�tl'rwntthisperiod.1he film %vill lilms and a clog. In teens tit the feature. it is mostly set in IIIc Santa Barbara. Sall f'u� Qhtsl,n attd f.os Angles tc , T�arl)Gt11arl}• at and around Diabit� t'an) %O111e in"i�tht into the l,STi. concerts on the cast coast head at b IliS 111ntGcAtkin t�� IIIc mu,ie industry. Of++hic)t there has been considcrahic t ntem,orary acusis to fultill those rofrs of +vhi nitniuoh hrt?utter than that and in "''clot n,a;t held at thu hhn - b+ been C nisi+ ut include ntot� t •I 1 ortu t,irts an insight into IIIc tints. Su it a1s+, nl'i'er� uniyu+ upp hn(tnG{hg vtld tn+'CSt,nUtt the nt7tlU� 01 Ivhich foil, i1S UIIeI 3a r. s • i tq+rat ds other things like brand }urs trial.. it's allrn,�ai v have talking t„gam n tntncly, a number of individual” have ;htce soucld7t u, do+slob thr aforcnnenlionetl pr,yAl 1 dts III t oeiginatoS i'rrnn [ til+} thie as ani. tU tclvantabe c,{'this opportun fi,rmor pars. What bewall e„ kills group sulking pI0�It5• unpreCcdentcd arcrti• and catnrol atcr illy life ++bile at the sante time escntialty'"has I' Sn include v r various including 'erre. �a+•y) And a host of others both in the ta.e ioaal law enforcemcut rntand Ctrtcnt tutd linancu indusuios, IGm' 1rI} a� this situata�n has hrogress+d it's gone un to Int 11 +'ai'Iouti govcnng canncctic,n4 G, theT'o croups like th • ,arune"h1l, +vith CiC'11O• tufts Ile+n, Iho FCIh ix..' , EPIC to the NSr\.the mililluy (Ler t mast coun,rias �'au upctatc in. i*or extunttle, in the t,.lc ►hC SSA has n t < > nr other groups such It the (le UK er Finuneiul Protection 13ureau as d,o5e. im•olved I,avc nnanipulatet{ information they {ie I tV ). NNTI) C)1 3 P150 hove ohtainecl and are exploiting perceiked vu]nurahiGucr in order to maintain cantrnl. I Cet tate Sense there are a nuntbcr ol'annpanics in Itch, (CiCCQnt, entcrtainmcttt and seemingly everything C11,0. ve y privaev ly vious I can't ath'ihutc the uctiv'tics to any one group i ill reel[ alar, but the and 4�smputelr calltera�s and DINS flhoneS.iL�ySaspo�otting acndtman in the ttmiddlc i,umber of ttays, rot example rentntel} b :dtaCkti. Traci ing and monihu int hchaviat;v: And it's acduafly quite a hit in, 4r �tcQ at lot of dist ��rci andtl tftink untlecw,ers�sttry confli s well rn perlttgt� dileeu:d at theta u� f ant rclalively ineapucitated from mobility' Yoocl investment. [k's quite t•,!nrutium na,l only for ttte but others;ts well: it fs underminingvv�hat WWII he otherwise a great protect and corrmive on a personal iuvcl ay well. There i�'othcr ;tuff)' hilt avltat can he coentrt`,u toil) knovvtwl at l aniisb3sed or)n�f nhout�jc`olhertWhere es tentially`contull T Creuted from found content. describe. il' you arc nt�'aro Of lh� , IIti }above including nn ,;ic put tugctivcr and ttxsenth'e ItGt�vork [lova. tieing manife light ingoin uth �fv�ayst{iscartlnt andtt fsvisiozecl ln.tat Fl it rtusieclvlcleog:mte�. It reach out tc+ included individttah and )ateivary a(}s etc). Ht,tycver, ror me pct;.Sun;tlly itrbO.; rlt tailey+blv icidsteither 1) nu res tjtonset2) reign n =lir not u><ctor 3�l itn some cout ai�c i1'%'e ttcottcnlvc �. n,c pw onull}'. rltiy attcntpty nt tgailliNg i generally cease ane) clesi +ti or'cxprcxsiona al' comer" ral' my'mental health'. iv Ai thie point ► have ltecn nx,sth� i,olatet) from contact. L4lt�the white o those invo fatinil'�r toed t �' , Sorr �il'thi�llillue si huuttot t)� hlu)eit`6110lY-.eeking bel+avior" Owl development of the aforcmcntinnetl pruj srnne Clarification and telt like yen+ nr,�y' cr bed} there nitay aisa he info strti involN ed and potential le'cts and at•tisticcinstall tl >Itsta� vvrceseil)c r the ly t,t eat) ur busincs%rekiml as heyond the project t developutcnl orslart up". There could he live events. \Vhilc I can confirm 1 here arc cnttmerahle retail and w! ommetcec kinattularityt and would aivre iate tat>r �i »I ight youvmayrhave.,i tanktytnu for consideration of m} alttrillc� like I ;aW, 1 dont know . �lntply s tllrs5agc .left Valna (Val) Y. Wilson Senior Law F.ttforwineut Consultant 11, Regtott X (couttlies of Imperial. Orange and San Diego), and State of California Commission at pOST whal Police Lialson )aGtirlg Delivery & Cwnpllance Btrreatt Caljfornia Deparlitle"t ofJt+slice Cotttmissiott on POST 860 SlilhvaterRoad, Suite 100 )yest Sacramento, CA 95605-1630 916.2Z7.4872/Offiee P151 Michael shi From: sent: To: subject: Jeffrey Howertonl� Saturday, July 16, 2016 3:09 PM Fredrick Rowbotham Fwd: Establishing the Profit Motive of Local Police Forces _.-- Forwarded message -- Froin: Jeffrey lRowerton Date: Sat, 7ul 16, 2016 at 2:54 PM Subject: Establishing the Profit Motive of Local Police Forces To: mstewart cyp(AOM lIi Mike, Belot/ is a not I am sending regarding various involving public safety or law enforcemenresultant t. doial believJe theyeels 3at are being are involved in fac'tottaatingt this unately, beyond any logistical or onscreen issues to g P situation.' in sonie odd community It involves members of the community wb ha0 have s , entrusted themselves I encompassed hem st significant swat of my'l fe.Tl bizarre I reflect on howuch timue theY various Law enforcement agencies. This enoom P r again and much of what they have developed relies on means and mechanisms to have consumed, it continues to devastate me anew all ove take advantage of any sort of vulnerability and really exploit•that rheroilessly. the Unfortunately, I do I believe there is a profit motive, but I also knowthere arc intenseefforts tensure he existence of he below devents air to cover up situation. In fact recently I was 51�50`d by your department. It w Yhave odd, I can enough at confer them and also have received some degree of y household where the h written conf rrrtation, Bvw legiy tied to t mat ualshave vents,rfor example, at one point conversations s incobetween at my home about cmails. They were not merely escorting but involved. several officers incoordination with the Manhattan DA shoving up There are no records of the events in your department and not able to obtain them anywhere. bels a ofound, derailing orce of I believe what is transpiring is truly a societal ats of evil. Id dont alstlife and (veryemuch unjustly so;The er obtain closurO. But it tis no excuse or justification. I don't which know squandered what are tis he most precious aspects the extent of the involvement of the local that with various oforce hero. �ers who are by all ato is a ccount .citizens nd there that stated, the entirely about proin fit and circumstance. Like I said, I tend to equateor for mora power and ego. gain in some way, whether it is monetary rts, investment with retirement funds etc that maybe even the ut I think worth hsking here as well. There may have been fundraising effo B officers are not aware of. Thank you for letting me know. Jeff al a+n ro;,rltin[; mil to yce if you are i'antilnb`iyiiliult nc to hl(nrtat+ic least tltc rasi4tit to i:x{.,Iainl ,+ t�+l n��surroundin+�++ny�gntn<Jnti thins+l'her n in+e briny dt:�elt>pe�l.'{-lie have been a nut , is Ja\ce I (owerion) in�olventcnt in the anti-nuelear ntcncment in the late 7tle early Ti Qrs ved ll g, kill. t1l 1'h<re t�'crc a nwnbcr of concerti tc ill) rccog+abl J i 11110 , - Brown, e-alHilda le nstadt ,rhe Ca le ct� t1'hc retarelatcivally libel este two fean +reg t{uitr �artcd liom Bruce 5pringstrcn..lau4 Fonda� films and a dUte. lu terms u1'tht fcal+tl>on ��Planttly � in tctt7maina af inusilc. there Imis, Obis doe I)\-' DAr"ly C.7ep(l and �ldhet r entitled 1 u�Nukea ie film t 1h 91\ Cs Pariicularly at and arounti Diablo Canyon :Dine nt�iLlit into Ehv NIUSE Concerts on ftethose roles ofwhichIaklion nlut h ht<�ladc r iI Gar&u. rtBeyond fact mosttheld t the S•lollyN�fri)ln this .ulo l 13cnvL But include nu+rc t:otitctttitat;n'y artitity to fulf a I . P152 c nuo the tinge. So It aha a1Tcr� unique appartuttuies moro akin to the music indusu•}•. ()f \\'hich there has been con4idembla 111\e5 ah II,ti!_thl financing anJ ntvc:;nnent the nature: of \\•Mich remains unclear, <mcd projects. think tl originates 1i-om this a, unFOrtuoatcl}'•:t number of individuals ha\'e sbtceV,�oughk�,ocic \'clop 111e aforentkl 11,% s , t e time essentially tltking advantage est this opporltutiqu� \ ariatu�Igoventment li�rntvr ,ec rs. �,lhak hog;ut ac uus(tticture<I group Stalking 'tc; r ssccl tavvarcls orbs r things like grand ju;y tri poo il,cllo\vr d pe oplc to gout 1 to unprecedcnleJ aceex, and cunUt,1 over my fife \011 10 at cunnerlinns to the entertaimnent and tinance indusn74s, fln\ec\er. a" this lituation Inas pragres,ed t% )zonc t n tiSA has a 1)ltrtner,hip NN CiC't[Q. To groups like the i ii Int laintnrmntion tlu�yllt n a linin Ile 1131. DEA's IsT lC" to the VSA. the ntilitar the c .�� 1`„fee. Navy) and it host Of other, both in the i;Sl\ and• oval I l fncluc ing rt, most cuttntriuti you ol)crate in, l'or example. in the t s. t tie LA1'f). �il'1'IJ) <n other lLc'�tP� c�l\eJt\7u1ne,.zhiliticr ina?rd rltlnlnmi,ttti t ct n Irol.nI tact tltetsc nuc iher ore la ll numbee of cc,mtt;utie5 'tn have Obtained ulld ore esplo! I g l tech. telecom. eniortain,ncntarid ,cemingly everythingetre. rl\ac in a ill ,hone and computer cameras. ;tad nticral,hones, f)l�`; udeoof Other, as n elltttnd liddlc I can't attribulc the activities to anyF(ne group i npartll ular. but the syml )nts are IlagranQy crophur. I'hcy hove violated lny a y number ul ways. For example remotely activating � 1 atiacler ol,acking and,»cmiloring bell'viors. And it's actually quite a hit more ers Creae(l a l t but i,uco r at yi aI tl e a stand invesunent. ti's quite tcrha t� directed at Iheln as { am rely ineapacit t dtfro It\vhattcould he tnher � i$ct a{ teat icc, ! 4.1 goink unnecessary conflict. i t ! t nttf usien not only for Inc bul oll,cl's a, \yell: a is un corrosive nn a per,Otlal le\el a, well. w 'hal I am talking about. \Vhcre essentially cc)nte realized 1 created it compelled cthose to f'here iti'other stu('i' but \\'hal can be cons led as'oth (r stud' is based un t,ther activities and work i was tloittI cre ed Again m round o u bar' of ri Jesc)ihe, It you are tl\cara of the situation. you Will know and later the u•Ork i \vas Joint: manifesting in Other \\'avr (�c,naltt, »ecyletc teithc aaft, t anythi tg l)tc tive for in4luding tnusia put lctucthcr and assemhlecl in a dikle:rent \vay. taut in light o Oth above(i.e the �lalkfn an lvi reach otlt to includcd ittdividt,al- ads etcl; l(o\va\cr. I'of the per,onully it has entailed inorediMV frrv,asiva v'io)ations of my' pc 1)1.1 n,C ,ie), l We V. or 1 m . at gaiumg insight gen mt�nl Ilhealth'.lhcr 1 I no response 2) I'ei�rnutg ignorance or �'1 fn ,nine ease, pvL gotten 1 and &'4NIs ur'cxpre,sioits of Colleen) lint tin 'cess. goes (hitt Sound i'amiliar to }•ou'! son?' fti this f twn T?s� hrce,t(t?ti'lci)ally or nen) or U this ptni,t I have bean mostiy isolated frOtn contact. � All the while those involved smugly continue vvith th�privaay violations. ,arassmg behavi+,h and developmc,nt of the aloremnonhoncJ l J potent tit>mc rlariticatian and felt likyc` `m y h haveSC1'1k,e'J1lhCreinsi�mil4 al�h i)C Inht ba,�cd on iklaSRIClnl"J1spl•nleel.” anal S1rliSliAj rl 1nS[allall )ns as \Neil Ord, husinc„ related a� hevond ill(,p . devcloptt,cnt Of,tart ups. While I can cotdirnt the ealfJfty o\\h f at [ am erperienciltg•`I, t ides of tale ntylrn ,s like' \t Simply seeking clarity atul a-auld <Ippreciale any in."i'ghl you 111,1V have, Thank you for con, Jeff P153 Michael From: Sent: To: Subject: Webmaster <Webmaster@ci.chula-vista.ca,us> Monday, January 1.6, 201.7 6:37 PM Professional Standards . City of Chula Vista: Service Complaint A new entry to a form/survey has been submitted. Form Name: Service Complaint Form Date & Time; of/1.6/201.7 6:87 PM Response M 46 Submitter ID: 21824 IP address: Time to complete: 2 min., 42 sec. Survey Details Page 1 happened from nt that led to this complaint, telling what INSTRUCI'ICINST Please complete this mi and describe s you can be.the incide pescribe what aspect() of the incident was improper (i.e. your beginning to end. Be as clear and specific specific complaint), and how it could be resolved to your satisfaction. You will be contacted for additional information. lice Department Dispatch Center (610) 691 -SISI - if you need to file a crime report please contact the Chula Vista Po 1. 'type of complaint: (xJ Conduct (x] false Arrest Ix) Poor investigation (x] Other 2. Your Contact Information Name Jeff City Zip code Route Phone Cell Phone Email Address g. Incident Information Location of incident home Date of incident Various lime of Incident mid day 1 Home Address C State Apartment/Space Not answered Work Phone Birthdate P154 Case/Citation Number Not answered 4. Employees involved 1) Employee Badge Not answered 1) Name of EmploYee Victoria t)t Caprio Number 2) Employee Badge Not answered z) Name of Employee Officer Casey Rose Number 3) Employee Badge Not answered 3) Name of Employee Officer Arce Number Not answered 4) Employee Badge Not answered 4) Name of Employees Number S. Please list anyone who witnessed the incident: phone Number Name Witness #7 W Mark Marvin Jordan Bach Not answered Witness #2 Julia Jacobson Not answered Witness #3 Not answered Not answered Witness #4 6. Incident Details Please describe the incident theawhat as d to this ca Tithe inid incident was improper (ig what happe6ed f e, your specific eampiarom beginning to end. n t), and how it could specific as You can be. Describe p be resolved to your satisfaction. Ongoing survei res a ce but stph physical instance stemmed from I believe Aprce forces. This il orMayMay of 26J.6. Where several officers from there was any presence bu p Y the Chula Vista Police department as well as officers from theM ssma ntn filch includes savage violations , NY DA. This was rearding iof personal privacy situation is as such, that those involved engaged in stalking, rects. upon confrontation, hae reported metthe police, There was no and theft and exploitation severai officers andriInvestigators vcame to my house. Asking several questions and investigation i to any of Y aims. Rather, stating not to contact thosinvolved atuited andreferred thetefforts a exploitat on ofwould mmer commercial projects have continued andwhere time Is civil rights, dull liberties arebeing of the essence. It allows those victimizing me, the ability to do,so with impunity. Whatever the unbiased take on that situat on i f I don't know. Upon follow up, l requested records from the Chula Vista Pp. the Shockingly they had none. Now I find this incredibly bizarre. If this organization is to make thlven that they sent no, what basis t oneye not if they have no records f the events that have transpired. I find this all the more shocking, g ating two, but SEVERAL officers to t San door o and Chula Vi ta. To haveore, they n o rrecindividuals from ords of this, the east coast who had been s In an of itself problematic. All the more for sometime and flew out to San piego so, when' it further derails anything else at hand. I should go onto state I have requested information from the Manhattan an Brooklyn DA's, and there has been no response. to elf and not The behaviors have continued. I once did a test tif related but I think soetfowsubject ever, thelsigtuat nn has ontinued long after several officers showed down the sirest 1 don't know There was an instance in my household regarding Michael Howerton who resides in the same household as l da. lets was no investigation of the events. As stated, this si i believe there ebroad and may be evidence t actely ivuch Oetaef the abo the fundinik of some of use and harassment I e been subjected to, sterna frbm that , these projects that haJ`0• beenoordinaEed with the various police force associations in the county. 4. Those involved have sb�ug�tto sutiji ate me as a vasieeta has done wihat he can t keep coAthntra ned,ut. This iifola ed white he andnKividual has used tools and access given.p engage in stalking an k , his family seek to take advantage of the cipportunitles at hand. When confronted those involved Ile. There was a confrontat on of which the police were called hut then waived off, They showed up anyway. The OnlY physical evidence was in fact On lnstead two officers showed s well s a member from PERT, immediately upon showing to where it was clear i was nicked, my doorstep, without any investigation of the situation. P155 made. The The officer submitting to the psych ward, Jshmeinstance bnd had actually seemingly had thisndecisionlCin seem�ngry Pre the events. showed up with pre existing information regarding instance compelling this, meaning whatever the ecl st this is disputed, nn thnv Investigating thle the matters I was then iunfairly t has to e debit with first to deal with anything else.ceUnfortunately, subjected to a bizarre humiliating experienceceand ffaa u aind nothing has everother been handled in thisi have had apacty. tv call the police on this individual with far more evident problem, pay information. t was confirmed After questioning the of€icer it was finally confirmed tonts tareo In sme that they hau veillance act access to vit es upon the basis iof mental heath what I already know, that the local police departm and that some of this is being informed by individuals involved in the theft and exploitation of commercial projects. I have ity these ehaviors. instead of at confirmation that i have received from Individualshis regarding and negating that�fentailsthat i am victimized further'nFor hfurther ld warrant, follow up being instead relegated In Y for me ardin contents of an upon the basis Of a mental health confirmation, two officers recently showed up lookingatchng shows regnetfli x that is based In Germany. The email below is attached check up. E kept a proxy email that I used for below. Unfortunnfronting ately, there are two issues here. h ort ntiyy have t it is encroain ching on br w they could deduce distb nces oif my my civil rights and Y ... .. .M. that they are involved In surveillance. But more p liberties. In a situation such as this, it is rare to confront that directly. You are being monitored in the shadows. The contents of the email are below. Again, I have confirmation of this of which the validity ignored and instead has entailed tbelievable, right ask t any repercussions for me. But even if the contents el them vvit6out any fear of reprisalsal n� questions being systematically lycon trainll ed This have the right to belleve #hose things, even act ptters is the tip of the Iceberg. I am asking that to sort,esciapa city. Acommitted a n th se micro events are indicative ve of thelarger situation, The may have already presented themselves t email contents which gives indication Into with PERT What isfollowompted a they have showed. l recently followed all the more disturbing. Mark Ma v n from ERT indicated to me there are no records of PERT's Involvement. I believe those involved are abusing various aspects of the do what canate their exploltatiom Manipulating what toconstrain and isolate, despite engaging in can to maintain as long as possible. For example, while they tat purposes that their ongoing behavior that could not behmore eegsf info macould. tionlonat caln't fohlow pnsurance surveillance and guardian p nessary. Without acesto it would appear that emall$ are furthermore, the allegations I have made. Are not without arnivaliis tty with the, situation and shedding Insight into the dtand responses fabricated. But i have received some Indicating suppression, anything through the cracks that government organizations that are involved. Within something relies on overt supe confirms what I already know, there is different weights applied and given. When those invaived in paver, instead ignore and seek . i relegate as e tofu hproblem rinjustice. When my efforts to procure clarity imize me and the Wh n situation as if it's existence is indicative of mental health. It subjects m are met with unwelcome reprisal, it is an assault on my civil liberties and has a chilling effect. Each of these an environment things, causes stress and hardship in an already situation rife with ds are not being maintained cit makes addressing tie sit it ation harder— in which they can take, advantage further. When tett but further evidence of the behaviors 1 am being subjected to. in emai(s Is not Below is the copy of an email I have sent since. Again, l sometimes rely on a vpn. Which means, my Ip it more. I am aware of their b rtivitie t is not clear how they are'substantiatin associated unless hacking a b g themselves and again my efforts are met with reprisal or shutdown or response. privacye ongoing violations experiencing I am reaching out to see if your organization is familiar Therhave been a number, most notably (or at leastthe easiest to explain) a resultant commercial projects being developed. other's (her name is Joyce Nawerton) involvement in the' anti_nuclear movement in the late s flim surrounding my grandm early 80s. 3 P156 There were a number of concerts with recognizable names - for example Jackson Browne, Bonnie Raitt. Others involved during this time quite varied from Bruce Springsteeiifi the Santa rry Brown, Linda , The Barbara' San Luis Obispo and Loes, etc. There are s I believe two feature films and a doe. In terms of the features, ts mostly set Angeles regions of California. Particularly at and around Diablo Canyon Power Plant. in terms of music, there is a doc by Danny Goldberg entitled No Nukes which gives some insight Into the MUSE concerts on the east coast held at Madison Square Garden. Beyond the artists from this period, the film will include more contemporary artists to fulfill those roles of which much broader than that and in fact most held at the Hollywood Bowl. But gives an insight into the time. so it also offers unique opportunities more akin to the music Industry. Of which there has been considerable financing and Investment the nature of which remains unclear. say this as unfortunately, a number of individuals have since sought to develop the aforementioned projects. I think it originates from former peers. What began as unstructured group'stalking progressed towards other things like grand jury trials. It's allowed people togain unprecedentedentertainme tontrol over my life and finale at the same nce industries.)me However, essentasithis siituation ng advantage of this opportunity. Many have connections to the has progressed it's gone on to include various government orgs from the FBi, DEA's EPIC to the NSA, the military the Ui �e HQor Force, Navy) and a host of others both In the USA and abroad including most countries you operate in, for them groups such as the NSA has a partnership with GC• To groups like the IRS, local law enforcement (le LAPD, consumer Financial Protection Bureau as those involved have manipulated information they have obtained and are exploiting perceived vulnerabilities in order to maintain control. I get the sense there are a number of companies in tech, telecom, entertainment and seemingly everything else, can't attribute the activities to any one group in particula r, but the symptoms are flagrantly obvious. They have violated my privacy in a number of ways. For example remotely activating cell phone and computer cameras, and microphones, DNS spoofing and man in the middle attacks. Tracking and monitoring behaviors. And it's actually quite a bit more extensive, but there are a multitude of others as well and perhaps directed at them as I am relatively Incapacitated from mobility. it's created a lot of discord, and I think unnecessary ebnflict, confusion not only for me but others as well; it is undermining what could be otherwise a great project and good investment. it's quite corrosive on a personal level as well. There is'other stuff' but what can be construed as 'other stuff is based on other activities and work I was doing but again simply harder to describe. If you are aware of the situation, you will know what I am talking about. Where essentially content I created from found content, including music put together and assembled in a different way. But In light of above (i.e the stalking) i realized that it compelled those to reach out to included individuals and later the work I was doing manifesting In other ways (Le film and television, art, music, videogames, tv ads etc). However, for me personally it has entailed incredibly invasive violations of my personal privacy etc without anything positive for me personally. Any attempts at gaining lnsight generally Yields either 1) no response 2) feigning ignorance or 3) in some cases I've gotten cease and desists or'expressions of concern for my mental health'. At this point •I have been mostly isolated from contact. All the while those involved smugly continue with the privacy violations, harassing behaviors and developMent of the aforementioned projects. Does this sound familiar to you? Sorry if this is out of the blue, simply seeking some clarification and felt like you may have some insight based on who else Involved and potential fundraising sources (officially or not) or business related as beyond the. projects described, there may also be Infrastructural projects and artistic installations as well or the development of start ups. There could be live events. While I can confirm the validity of what I am experiencing, x e(Thank you for the cons specifics ecift s like I said message, I don't know? Simply seeking clarity and would appreciate any Insight you Y have Jeff Thank you, City of Chula Vista This is an automated message generated by the Vislon content Management System'". Please do not reply directly to this email. P15 Subject: Fwd: Re: From: Jeffrey llowerton To: lturner@chulavistapd.org,mbyron@chulavistapd.org Time: Wednesday, April 12, 2017 5:28:00 AM GMT -07:00 Dear Captain Turner, and Lt Byroi,;1, Re Case: 1.7-0008 The information in your letter contradicts wbat I have received already via a records request referencing Lt Don Redmond. My complaint is not regarding the instances on Jun 27th, 201.6 but predates that as well. More problematic however, is via another pra, I received indication that Don Redmond had been working on something well, before I made my complaint. It was clear, that in order to submit information to him they had to inquire to find out. When I broached that topic, Don Redmond had no idea about what I was referring to. Unfortunately, again prior to this, apart of the issue is missing records yet dealingwiththe consequences. Meanwhile because- they are attached to commercial opportunities, others being enabled to exploit, I have been waiting to hear back, before checking into POST, However, I do believe this represents severe ethical issues OR indicative of something else. I am still awaiting to hear back from Post but was planning to forward all the communications I receive that are relevant.. Unfortunately, given what I am dealing my concern was corroboration and damage control. your response came on April 4th. I would appreciate your take before moving forward with any other complaint. Now that the investigative process is over I am making a request for these records as well. I do appreciate your help resolving this matters. Jeff -----�Forwarded message -------- -- From: Jeffrey Howezton Date: Mon, Apr 3, 2017 at 3:05 AM Subject:"Re: Re: To: Don Redmond ud.org> Dear Lt Redmond, This is not reassuring as apart of my complaint is missing or falsified information, whole events even, allowing parties involved here to continue in the exploitation of various commercial projects. Evidence being ignored, and instead 'I have continued to suffer negative repercussions. Yor example, reliance on. the mental health system. I will send ,you these documents, as soon as I hear back, But unfortunately, it casts a veneer of severe doubt about whatever this investigation, as entailed given there is a history of involvement. I believe it reflects the problems I am, experiencing. It ain not necessarily alleging your ethicacy is in doubt especially given your answer here. Meaning there may be phished emails. But it continues to lend itself to the notion that my underlying concerns are correct.'But I feel troubled by this. I will send you information when I hear back from Post as I don't want this to reflect further. Meaning information to disappear etc, preventing me from clarity and allowing others to exploit commercial opportunities. Will touch base as soon as they get back to me. P158 Jeff O ; I On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 1:43 PM, Don Redmond <DRedmondPchulavista-pd.ora> wrote: i I am unaware'of the correspondence you are referring to with Valna. Could you send me a copy? Lt, bon Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)476.2452 dredmond@chulavistapd.ora From: Jeffrey Howerton [malltolh Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:26 PM To: Don Redmond <DRedmondCachulavistapd,org> Cc: David Oyos < > Subject: Re: Res Dear Lt Redmond, Thank you for responding, This is troubling tome. She sent you an email on July 16th,- of 2016. I have never corresponded with either you or Va1na prior, and suggests and other inemis and methods of correspondence. Not only for her to deduce obtain this, but to lQIow to forward to you, This predates my complaint by several months, and suggests you were already working on something., Your name is not included in anything else, Apart of the problem, is major events prior, there are no records of, Not sure if this is the case here but it does suggest prior involvement that predates my.complaint. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 9:31. AM, Don Redmond 'pd,orq> wrote: Mr. Howerton, P159 received your email and I will attempt to answer your questions, ® The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17/17 for the issues in your email below and is being investigative (PS# 7.70008). We hope to send you a disposition letter in the next few weeks as to the findings of the investigation. ® Por case 16-09729, you were detained for 5150 W.I. Mental Disorder 72 Hour Observation hold. The State of California is listed as the victim in these cases. �► I am unaware of why Vaina Wilson from POST is listed as a correspondence. Lt. pan Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)476-24,5-2 dredmond2chulavistagd.0ra 7 Prom: Jeffrey Howerton [mail Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 17.:22 PM To: Don Redmond <bRedmond@chulayistapd.org>; David Oyos <dOyosCa�chulayistapd.org> Subjdct,. Re: Dear Detective Oyos and Lt Redmond, 1 received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complabit is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Durk Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these ort was half to events despite admission of third party info. For me, the repblacked out. So perhaps references that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren,c larding cllsabilit ric litsca,orc) and Mike Phillips (mlkep(&ifssd.orcr) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back, but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPR& calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how l interpret it, It states the State of California as the victim, l am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had 110 prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the _M411 deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it, He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from. the LTG Goveimor's records request who. referred mine to them. separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue: I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they.are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not beard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me lrnow. Why the state of callfornia is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Bmail is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff On Wed, Mar 29, 2017 at 11:18 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Hi DoA, Hi David, I received a public records request response indicating that you are, the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. i5ok My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no lulowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a. report with Lauren -Giardina (lauren ctiardinaCcDdisebilityriahtsca.ortr) and Mike Phillips (inikepC)ifssd.org) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from. Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where in,atters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA. calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means, Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Vahaa Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. P161 Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been trade continue, I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly, I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But cazi you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a. phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. ,teff P162 P163 Pl 64 P165 Subject: Re: Re: From: Jeffrey ldowerton� To: Don Redmond <DRedmon.d@chulavistapd.org> TiMe: Monday, April 3, 2017 3:05:22 AM GMT -07:00 Dear Lt Redmond, This is not reassuring as apart: of my complaint is missing or falsified information, whole events even, allowing parties involved here to continue in the exploitation of various commercial projects. Evidence being ignored, and instead I•have continued to suffer negative repercussions. For example, reliance ori the mental health system, I will send you these documents, as soon as I hear back. But unfortunately, it casts a veneer of severe doubt about whatever this investigation as entailed given there is a History of involvement. I believe it reflects the problems I am experiencing. It am not necessarily alleging your ethicacy is in doubt especially given your answer here. Meaning there may be phished emails. But it continues to lend itself to the notion that my underlying concerns are correct. But I feel troubled by this. I will send you information when I hear backhf bm Post as I don't want this to reflect further. Meaning information to disappear etc. preventing me from clarity and allowing others to exploit commercial opportunities. Will touch base as soon as they get back to me. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 1:43 PM, Don Redmond d.oru> wrote: I I am unaware of the correspondence you are referring to with Valna. Could you'send me a copy? Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)476-2452 dredmond@chulavistapd.orq ;a� l Ott, V a From: Jeffrey Howerton [mails Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:26 PM To: Don Redmond <DRPdmondachu1Jyistapd.ora> Cc: David oyos <> Subject: Re: Re: P166 Dear Lt Redmond, Thank you for responding This is troubling to me. She sent you an email on July 16th, of 2016. 1 have never corresponded with either you or Valna prior, and suggests and other means and methods of correspondence. Not only for her to deduce obtain this, but to know to forward to you. This predates my complaint by several months, and suggests you were already working on something., Your name is not included in anything else. Apart of the problem, is major events prior, there are no records of. Not sure if this is the case here but it does suggest prior involvement that predates my complaint. . Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 9:31 AM, Doo. Redmond -�DRedmondchulavistaUd.org> wrote: Mr. Howerton, received your email and I will attempt to answer your questions. ® The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17/17 for the issues in your email below and is being investigative (PS# 17-0008). We hope to send you a disposition letter in the next few weeks as to the flndtngs of the investigation. e For case 16-09729, you were detained for 5150 W,1. Mental Disorder 72 Hour Observation hold. The State of California is listed as the victim In these cases. A I am unaware of why VaIna Wilson from POST is listed as a correspondence. Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police department Professional Standards Unit (67.91476-2452 dredmondoxhulavistapd.or it141 0 From: Jeffrey Howerton Cmailt Sent: Wednesday, March 29,'2017 11.:22 PM To: Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.org>; David Oyos <bOyosCa chulavistapd.ora> Subject: Re: P167 Dear Detective Oyos and Lt Redmond, I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and'investigative process' prevented full• disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances- I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance, As stated, Mark Marvin director. of PERT lias responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacited out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (Lauren.aiardina(a)disabilityriahtsea,orci) and Mire Phillips (miken@ifssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls for service incident X,117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Vahia Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,arid I have had no prior interactions from her, I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of justice, The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it., He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer Based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Wily the state of califoxnia is Iisted as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me, ,Jeff On Wed, Mar 29, 20:17 at 11.18 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Hi Don, Hi David, Y received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records, P168 My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Marlt Marvin director of PERT has responded statiag,they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren cliardinapdisabilitvrightsca.or ) and Mike Phillips (m kep@jfssd.org) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPIZA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from. Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement . section,and I have had no prior interactions from leer. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of.the 'deliberativ'e' process but it postdates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from, the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to. exploit commercial. opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff *1 . Pi 69 P170 P171 P172 P173 Subject: RE: Re: From: Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.org> To: 'Jeffrey Howerton' Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 17.4T -77 -PM GMT07:00 am unaware of the correspondence you are referring to with Valna. Could you send me a copy? Lt. Dort Redmond Chula Vista police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)4762452 dredmond@chulavista pd,org From: Jeffrey Howerton [mailto. Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:26 PM To. Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.org> Cc: David 0yos <DOyos@chulavlstapd.org> Subject: Re: Re: Dear Lt Redmond, Thanlj you fonesponding. This is troubling to nxe. She sent you an email on July 16th, of 2016. 1 have never corresponded with either you or Valna prior, and suggests and other iiieans and methods of correspondence. Not only for her to deduce obtain this, but to.know to forward to you. This predates my complaint by several months, and suggests you were already working on something., Your name is not included in anything else. Apart of the problem, is .major events prior, there are no records of, Not sure if this is the case here but it does suggest prior involvement that predates guy cbiaplaint. , Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 9:31 AM, Don Redmond <DRedmond(achulavistand.ora> wrote: Ior. Howerton, P174 received your email and I will attempt to answer your questions. s The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17/17 for the Issues In your email below and is being investigative (PS# 17.0008). We hope to send you a disposition letter in the next few weeks as to the findings of the investigation. e For case 16-09729, you were detained for 5150 WJ. Mental Disorder 72 Hour observation hold. The State of California is listed as the victim in these cases. o I am unaware of why Valna Wilson from POST is listed as a correspondence. Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (619)476-2452 dredmond(@chulavistapd.o .�:t From. -'Jeffrey Howerton (mailto Sent;' Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:22 PM To; Don Redmond <DRedmond chulavista d.or >; David Oyos <DOyos(achulavlstapd.ora> Subject: Re: Dear Detective Oyos and Lt Redmond, . I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and 'investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin diroctor of PERT has responded statinq they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission o£ third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps refereacog to that ill there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren giardina(cpdisabilityricfhtsca.oru) and Mike Phillips (mikep(a-ifssd.ora) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective services) is included there as well. I am, not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls for service 'incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interprot it. it states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request P175 you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received enlails stating there is an NSA investigation and, also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI, I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fhle.But can you at least let me luiow. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? F'urtherviore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. ,teff On Wed, Mar 29, 2017 at 1118 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: : Hi Don, Hi David, 14, I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the tills instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren giardina disabilityrialitsca.orci) and Mike Phillips (mikeU 9£ssd.org�) as well naming your depa.i tment. I haveia't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I ani not 8111.,e where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA. calls for service incident L117; and L79 but I Have some questions just %n terins of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I ani not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is iia the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records.request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. P176 Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this.is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emaiis stating there is an NSA investigation, and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fin.e.But can you at least let me know, Why the state of California is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do -not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. j Jeff A - f .r 4�� Jeffrey is using Senders: caller ID for email. Try It for free. P177 P178 P179 rr - � 2 { \»f P1§O Subject. Re: Re.- From: e:From: Jeffrey Howerton To: Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulavistapd.org� Time: Thursday, March 30, 2017 1:26:24 PM GMT -07:00 Dear Lt Redmond, Thank you for responding. This is troubling to ane. She sent you an email on July 16th, of 2016. 1 alna prior; aid suggests and other means and have never corresponded with either you or V methods of correspondence. Not only. for. her to deduce obtain this, but to know to forward to you. This predates my complaint by several months, and suggests you were already working on something., Your name is not included in anything else. Apart of the problem, is major events prior, there are no records of. Not sure if this is the case here but it does suggest prior involvement that predates any complaint. Jeff On Thu, Mar 30, 2017 at 9:31 AM, Don Redmond <DRedrnond chulavistand.ora> wrote: Mr, Howerton, received your email and 1 will attempt to answer your questions. ' • The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17117 for the issues In your email below and is being investigative (PS# 17-0008). We hope to send, you a disposition letter In the next few weeks as to the findings of the investigation. o Por case 16-09729; you were detained for 5150 W.I. Mental Disorder 72 Hour observation hold. The State of California is listed as the victim in these cases. ® I am unaware of why Valna Wilson from POST Is listed as a correspondence. Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit ,619 475-2452 dredmo_ ndC-chulavistapd.ora lFrom. Jeffrey Howerton Cmailt Sent. Wednesday, March' 29, 2017 11:22 PM To: Don Redmond <DRedmond chulavista d.or >; David Oyos <pOyos@chulavistapd,org> Pi 81 Subject: Re: f Dear Detective Oros and U Redmond, I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, -Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement In the§e events despite admission of third party info. Forme, me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there, I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (latireii glardina@disabilitvrightsca.orq) and Mike Phillips 6nikei30fssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there Follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is In the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably Is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue: I believe this 1s a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the PBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Wily the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Entail is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff On Wed, Mar 29, 2017 at 11:1£3 PM, Jeffrey Mowertowrote. Hi Don, Hi David, 10. I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of: contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. P182 My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren giardina@disabilityrightsca.orct) and Mike Phillips (mike-p&jfssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters front case number 1.609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls. for service incident L1.1.7, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It state's the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from. Va1na Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had Ao prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. i believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I 'submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but Willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me, Jeff P183 P184 P185 Subject: RE: Re: From: Don Redmond <DRedmond chulavis ' .org> To: 'Jeffrey Howerton' ,David Oyos <DOyos@chulavistapd.oxg> Time: Thursday, March 30, 2 17 9:31: GM -0 :00 Mr. Ho:werton, I received your email and I will attempt to answer your questions, The Chula Vista Police Department received your complaint on 01/17/17 for the issues in your email below and is being Investigative (PS# 17-0008), We hope to send you a disposition letter in the next few weeks as to the findings of the Investigation. For case -16-09729, you were detained for 5150 W.I. Mental Disorder 72 Hour Observation hold. The State of California Is listed as the victim in these cases. am unaware of why Valna Wilson from POST is listed as a correspondence.. Lt. Don Redmond Chula Vista Police Department Professional Standards Unit (63.9)476»2452 dredmond@chulavistapd.org From: jeffrey Howerton [mallt "Impn* Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:22 PM To: Don Redmond <DRedmond@chulav[stapd.org>; David Oyos <DOyos@cI1ulavistapd.org> Subject: Re: Dear Detective Oyos and Lt Redmond, I iecelved a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and 'investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior; and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite P186 admission of third party info. For nue, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren aiaxdinaftdisabili! rightsca.ora) and Mike Phillips (mikeo(�lfssd.org as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. ' � b• �4W„fit I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA. calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I aim not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request ,you received correspondence from valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from. her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information, They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also . others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is f1ne.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff On Wed, -Mar 29, 2017 at 11:18 PM, Jeffrey Howerton wrote: Hi Don, Hi David, T received a public records, equest response, indicati#g that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and inv'estigAtive process, prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is .regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For m.e, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren GiardinaLauren. ardina disabili i htsca.or ) and Mike Phillips (rnikep(@ifssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I anj not sure where matters from case number 1.609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I P187 interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could. you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events, I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product; but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NS.A. investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine,But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff V— - jef rey is using Senders: caller la far email.?ry it for free. am Pi 89 P1910 SubJect: Re: from: Jeffrey Howerton To: dredmond@chulavistapd.0rg,doyos@chulavistapd.org ')Came: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11.:21:30 PM.GMT07:00 Dear Detective Oyas and Lt Redmond,. I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where 'deliberative' and 'investigative process' prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin director of PERI' has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite' admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (laureu uiardnnaCa disabilityrightsca orq) and Mike Phillips (mik,ep(u»fssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back, but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is Included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case'number 1609729 pit within this. I am also referencing CFRA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the vidtim. I ain not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing'probably is probably, apart of the'deliberative' process but it past dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities, I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is flne.)iut call you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff 4n Wed, Mar 29, 2017 at 11:18 PM, Jeffrey Howerton 11 rote: Hi Don, Hi. David, I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, frown the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin i director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info, For nie', the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there. I have filed a report with Lauren. Giardina (lauren giardina(@disabilityric(htsca.orct) and Mike Phillips (mike-pPjfssd.orct) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from I. I Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where natters from case number 1.609729 fit within this. I awn also referencing CPRA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of know I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means, Could P191 you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request.you received correspondence front Valna Wilson at Post. She is in the tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He did state attorney client work product but stated that was from -the LTG Governor's records 'request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my inental health have been made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly. I have received. emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back. If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phone but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff P192 Subject: From: Jeffrey Howerton44 To: dredmond@chulavistapd.org,doyos@cliulavi.stapd.org Time: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 11:18:23 PM GMT -07:00 Hi Don, Hi David, I received a public records request response indicating that you are the point of contact for matters where deliberative and investigative process, prevented full disclosure of records. My complaint is regarding the instances I had with Chula Vista PD prior, and also, from the this instance. As stated, Mark Marvin.director of PERT has responded stating they have no knowledge or involvement in these events despite admission of third party info. For me, the report was half blacked out. So perhaps references to that in there, I have filed a report with Lauren Giardina (lauren ctiardina(@disabili rialitsca.orct) and Mike Phillips (mikeP@jfssd.orq) as well naming your department. I haven't heard back but not sure if there follow up (from Adult Protective Services) is included there as well. I am not sure where matters from case number 1609729 fit within this. I am also referencing CPRA calls for service incident L117, and L79 but I have some questions just in terms of how I interpret it. It states the State of California as the victim. I am not sure what this means. Could you please clarify? Furthermore, in that public records request you received correspondence from Valua'SNilson at Post. She is in the. tribal law enforcement section,and I have had no prior interactions from. her. I am guessing probably is probably, apart of the 'deliberative' process but it post dates those events. I submitted a public records request to the California Department of Justice. The response was missing considerable information. They have stated this is the extent of it. He dial state attorney client work product but stated that was from the LTG Governor's records request who referred mine to them. Separately, the underlying matters where assaults to my mental health have bedn made continue. I believe this is a concerted attempt to convey as such frankly, I have received emails stating there is an NSA investigation and also others stating they are familiar and aware of efforts to exploit commercial opportunities. I submitted a report to the FBI. I have not heard back, If you cannot answer based on the deliberative process, that is fine.But can you at least let me know. Why the state of california is listed as a victim? Furthermore, I do not have a phoiae but willing to answer any questions you may have. Email is preferable and accessible to me. Jeff P193 P194 Simon Silva Front: Jeffrey Howerton V Sent: Wednesday, April 26,2017 10:02TM To: Simon Silva Hi Simon, I received yore rraail. I would also like to notify the board,that I also rade a complaint to the CA. Board of Psychology and also Board of Behavioral Science (just recently). The Board of Psychology, stated they would be investigating the matter. I only followed up with the other because not 'sure if one has jurisdiction to fully deal with others with a different license. This is regarding PERT which is separate front your jurisdiction but they were included in the originating event. Furthermore, after my complaint regarding the complaint, I received another mail fiann Lon Turner, stating the Chula Vista PA will not be investigating the ratter Rather. If possible, entail does work best for me unless you are mandated to send by mail also there is not a need. Thar -Ar, you for letting me, know. Jeff P195