Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Statement 1985/03/21 Item 5 1 0 1 I. 13 AGENCY/COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT • Item 5 Meeting Date 3/21/85 ITEM TITLE: Resolution 11/ 270 Approving the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Project Area Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum to the Redevelopment Plan SUBMITTED BY: Community Development Directo 44W4.5ths Vote: Yes No X ) ii* REVIEWED BY: City Manager Staff has been working with the Project Area Committee over the past four months to develop the Implementation Plan/Design Guidelines to guide development in the Otay Valley Area. This document will be an addendum to the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan and work in concert with the General Plan designation for the area in controlling proposed land uses and project design to ensure that the Otay Valley Area develops as a high-quality, light industrial area without negative impacts on adjacent residential areas. This plan has been approved by the Project Area Committee, reviewed and approved by the Planning and Community Development Department staffs. The City Planning Commission held a public hearing on the Implementation Plan/Design Guidelines on Wednesday, March 13, 1985, and also subsequently approved the plan. RECOMMENDATION: That the Redevelopment Agency and City Council adopt the resolution approving the Otay Valley Road Project Area Implementation Plan/Design Manual as an addendum to the Redevelopment Plan. BOARDS/COMMISSIONS RECOMMENDATION: The Otay Valley Road Project Area Committee approved the Implementation Plan/Design Manual at their meeting of February 11 , 1985. The report was subsequently reviewed and approved by Planning and Community Development Department staffs. The report with revisions proposed by staff was resubmitted to the Project Area Committee and approved on February 25, 1985. The plan was also reviewed and approved by the City Planning Commission at their meeting of March 13, 1985, with several minor textural changes. The Implementation Plan/Design Manual received a Negative Declaration from the Environmental Review Coordinator on March 1 , 1985. DISCUSSION: The Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan was approved by the City Council on December 30, 1983. This plan calls for the revitalization of approximately 770 acres of territory situated on the north and south side of Otay Valley Road east of Interstate 805. Subsequent to the adoption of the Redevelopment Plan, the entire Otay Valley Road area was designated "Research and Limited Industrial" on the plan diagram of the Land Use Element of the Chula Vista Page 2, Item 5 Meeting Date 3/21/85 General Plan. The lands to the south of Otay Valley Road were prezoned I-L-P, Limited Industrial , but the lands on the north side of the artery were not reclassified from their existing I-L-P and I-P (General Industrial zoning). The City Planning Commission, in accordance with recommendations of the City Planning and Community Development Departments, recommended that the zoning arrangement on the northerly side of Otay Valley Road be retained in order to promote a maximum of land use flexibility and economic opportunity. The Commission also based its recommendations upon the need to protect viable General Industrial uses which were already located within the Project Area. The Planning Commission also determined that the existing I-L-P and I-P zoning would be consistent with the Project Area's Research and Limited Industrial General Plan designation, provided that strong and protective land use and urban design guidelines were adopted to implement the Redevelopment Plan. They had also found that these guidelines would be essential to the promotion of the orderly development of the Project Area, as well as the protection of adjacent residential areas. The City Council deferred action on the City-initiated proposal to rezone all of the lands on the northerly side of Otay Valley Road to I-L-P, pending review of the Draft Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum. The consultant firm of Community Systems Associates, Inc. under contract with the Redevelopment Agency completed the first draft of the Implementation Plan/ Design Manual in October 1984. This draft, which reflected input from the Planning and Community Development Departments, has been studied by the Otay Valley Road Project Area Committee. The text before the Agency embodies all the substantial changes made by the Committee as well as technical refinements and additions prepared by the City Planning Department. On March 13, 1985, the City Planning Commission held a public hearing to take testimony on the proposed Implementation Plan/Design Manual . Over 300 notices were sent out to area-wide residents and property owners advertising this hearing. At the conclusion of the public meeting, the Commission approved the proposed guidelines with several minor modifications, and recommended their submission to the Redevelopment Agency and City Council for final approval . These modifications include changes to the flow chart (Section B) on page 21 , revisions of Section 4.2(5) on page 10 and Section 3.5(4) on page 6. The Implementation Plan component of the draft guidelines states land use regulations. All uses which are permitted in the I-L zone are permitted within the Otay Valley Road Project Area. Those uses which are either I zone in character, but not I-L; and, all uses which require conditional use permits according to the Municipal Code, are permitted upon procurement of "special permits. Uses which are prohibited in either the I-L or I zone are precluded from the Project Area. The proposed land use guidelines were intentionally designed to form a bridge between the Chula Vista General Plan and Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan, and a regulatory linkage between this City's zoning regulations and the Implementation Plan/Manual Addendum. \\X11) Page 3, Item 5 Meeting Date 3/z1/85 The Implementation Plan also stresses performance standards and utilizes those embodied in the City's zoning regulations. With respect to noise control , the plan utilizes the provisions of the City's noise ordinance, but, where ambient noise is involved, provides that the Noise Element of the General Plan shall be accepted as the "guiding principles," and that the subject matter "shall be fully addressed under the environmental assessment process." Section 3.5 of the Implementation Plan fully addresses the matter of the use and handling of hazardous materials in the Project Area. This section identifies those uses which are potential generators of hazardous waste, and prescribes their special review by the City of Chula Vista, and the County Health Department's Hazardous Materials Management Unit. The text of the section further provides that the Redevelopment Agency should utilize established County programs, such as the Hazardous Waste Surveillance and the Hazardous Materials Disclosure Programs, where practical . The Design Manual Addendum component of the proposed guidelines provides for parkway landscaping, riverway improvements, street furniture, buffers, and the overall townscape planning of the Project Area. The manual moves from general requirements to specific site development requirements including minimum 2-acre building sites, limiting building coverage to 45% of the parcel , and prescribes special building setbacks along Otay Valley Road as well as front, side, and rear yard requirements. Section 4.2 covers setbacks within the sensitive impact boundaries which are a special feature of the draft guidelines. The sensitive impact boundaries are called for under Section 3.1 of the Implementation Plan. This section establishes such boundaries where industrial sites abut upon existing or planned residential areas. In referring to the sensitive impact boundaries, the text reads: "Within these areas, the Agency may apply special land use, environmental , or noise controls, and may require the procurement of a special permit as a condition precedent to the establishment of any land use therein." The sensitive impact boundaries are generally 400' in width and are depicted on page 11 of the proposed guidelines. The building setback lines within the sensitive impact boundaries vary, but within undeveloped areas, are generally 200' for residential lot lines or undeveloped residential parcels. The Design Manual Addendum limits the amount of each site devoted to open (uncovered) storage to 20% of the gross building area. It also calls for 20% of each site to be landscaped. On the matter of signage, the Manual Addendum goes into considerable detail . The general criteria suggests graphics and logos in lieu of commercial signs, and urges that the signage throughout the Project Area be coordinated in order to avoid confusion and conflict. The sign guidelines cover type, number, area, and placement of signs. These guidelines, for the most part, are Page 4, Item 5 Meeting Date 3/2l/8b similar to those contained within the sign regulations of the Municipal Code. However, with respect to the number and square footage of permitted signs, the guidelines are substantially more stringent. The last section of the proposed guidelines covers plan implementation and effectuation including the roles of the Redevelopment Agency, Project Area Committee, and Design Review Committee. The Project Area Committee, for example, is responsible for advising the Agency on matters of City planning significance, while the Design Review Committee's role commences with, and is confined to, post planning project design. The chief planning officer of the Project Area- is the Director of Planning of the City of Chula Vista. The City Planning Commission is a principal advisory body to the City Council and Redevelopment Agency on the redevelopment plan in its totality and any amendments proposed to the redevelopment plan's text, boundaries, or basic land use. The Commission's jurisdiction also covers the subdivision of land within the Project Area. The chart on the last page of the proposed guidelines covers the processing of projects through the several , involved governmental bodies. In conclusion, the Draft Implementation Plan/Design Manual would foster the orderly and economic growth and development of the Project Area. It would also protect the environmental quality and amenity of adjacent residential developments. While the proposed guidelines set forth requirements, land use, bulk, height, design, signage, landscaping and basic townscape planning guidelines, these controls are for the most part couched in permissive language which provides the Redevelopment Agency and Project Area Committee a broad operational latitude. This latitude should enable the City to encourage developers to produce high quality, imaginative projects. The proposed "special permit" process, similar to conventional zoning's conditional use permit process, is design to encourage flexible land use patterns within the Project Area which are consistent with the goals and objectives of the Redevelopment Plan. This process recognizes that certain General Industrial uses could add character and substance to the Project Area, without adversely affecting internal environmental quality, or the peripheral residential areas. The proposed Implementation Plan/Design Manual is presented to the Redevelopment Agency and City Council this evening for final approval and incorporation as an addendum to the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan. Following approval , all new projects in the Otay Valley Road Area will be reviewed in accordance with the guidelines set forth in this document. FISCAL IMPACT: Not applicable. .._.., WPC 1454H OTAY YKLLEY ROAD REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA IMPLEMENTATION PLAN/DcSIGN MANUAL ADDENDUM d^1T 1^" l " MARCH 1985 PREPARED BY: COMMUNITY SYSTEMS ASSOCIATES, INC. 203 South Brea Boulevard Brea, California 92621 (714) 529-7888 OTAY VALLEY ROAD PROJECT AREA COMMITTEE CHULA VISTA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CHULA VISTA PLANNING DEPARTMENT \\ TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE INTRODUCTION 1 GOALS, OBJECTIVES, POLICIES 2 SPECIFIC LAND USE CONTROLS 4 3.1 - Land Use Map 4 3.2 - Land Uses Permitted in Project Area 3.3 - Special Land Use Requirements in Sensitive Impact Boundary 6 3.4 - Land Use Standards of Performance 6 3.5 - Land Use Consideration Involving the Use and Handling of Hazardous Materials 6 3.6 - Compliance with Regulations of Other Public Agencies7 DESIGN OBJECTIVES 8 4.1 - Townscape Planning 8 4.2 - Site Design 9 4.3 - Building Design 14 4.4 - Circulation and Parking 15 4.5 - Signs 16 ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONS 19 5.1 - Redevelopment Agency Coordinating Role 19 5.2 - Project Area Committee (PAC) 19 5.3 - Planning and Design Responsibility Within the Project Area 20 5.4 - Amendment of the Implementation Plan/Design Manual 20 �AcA vi 1 .0 INTRODUCTION It is with considerable pleasure that the City of Chula Vista and the Chula Vista Redevelopment Agency present the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Implementation Plan of the City of Chula Vista to citizens and prospective developers within the municipality. The Otay Valley Road Project Area is a newly adopted Redevelopment Project Area that was approved by Ordinance No. 2059 by the Chula Vista City Council on December 20, 1983. The Project Area entails 771 (+) acres of land within the City municipal boundaries and the adjoining County lands. This area is more specifically located between Interstate 805 and the eastern City limits of Chula Vista and is bisected, from east to west, by the Otay Valley Road (See Study Map Attached) . This relatively lineal strip of territory is designated by the General Plan for limited-industrial and open space uses. The area is now slated for revitalization as an industrial district, and is preplanned, under the text of the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan, to accommodate industrial uses within an open, low-intensity park like environment. The Project Area is surrounded to the north by new and orderly residential developments, and is bounded to the south by the Otay River and floodplain, which empties into a natural reserve area at the southern end of the San Diego Harbor. Otay Valley road, which is the primary roadway in the project area, will also serve as a future and important major gateway to the City of Chula Vista from the Otay Mesa and Tijuana metropolitan areas. For the reasons stated above, and the industrial environment envisaged by the Redevelopment Plan, a need is established for special emphasis on urban design of future developments, land use design and land use controls. Without a strong emphasis by the Implementation Plan on such physical and operational activities, redevelopment of the Otay Valley road Project Area could foster chronic land use frictions and adverse environmental side effects from unscreened industrial uses. The Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan was prepared for the purpose of meeting those special urban design, environmental and land use control needs identified in the above paragraphs. The Implementation Plan identifies a proposed land use arrangement which is reflective of the market conditions for industrial activity within the South Bay area and is also sensitive to land use patterns adjacent to and surrounding the Project Area. Land use controls have been recommended which will effectively reduce environmental liabilities to surrounding man-made and natural environments. As a townscape guideline, the Implementation Plan stresses the importance of the visual and functional relationships of people and their Physical environment, and the interrelationship of order (methodical arrangement) and amenity (beauty and pleasantness) in the City building and rebuilding process. - 1 - 2.0 GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES The Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Implementation Plan will serve three (3) purposes: 1 . Land use controls: serve to effectuate General Plan policies and zoning standards by directing their application within the Project Area. 2. Design guidelines: serve as an addendum for the Design Manual of the City of Chula Vista by incorporating specific design criteria for development in the Project Area. 3. Goals and objectives: promote their achievement and direct the 6tay Valley Road Redevelopment effort. GOALS AND INTENT The overall goal of the Redevelopment Implementation Plan is the elimination of blight in the Otay Valley Road Area and the furtherance of the area's orderly growth, conservation, amenity and economic development. OBJECTIVES Certain objectives have been established as a means of directing the ultimate achievement of the overall goal for the Project Area. These objectives are as follows: 1 ) The establishment of land use controls to guide future developments in the Otay Valley Road Project area and to safeguard against adverse environmental side effects; 2) Agency coordination with zoning permit business license application process to alert Agency and other authorities of any proposed land uses requiring precautionary environmental and land use controls; 3) The focusing of performance standards toward regulating industrial land use activities and operations; 4) The establishment of urban design policy which would include buffering and beautification techniques for the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Project Area; 5) The development of an effective circulation system, free from hazardous vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle interfaces; - 2 - 6) The fostering of cooperation and communication between the developers of the Project Area and the adjacent residents, workers, and property owners; 7) The promotion of effective, on-going enforcement of land-use and design standards. STATEMENT OF POLICY 1 ) The Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan should be regarded as the principal statement of the City's urban design guidelines for the Project Area. 2) The Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan is a supportive, companion plan of the zoning regulations, and includes performance standards of the City of Chula Vista. 3) The Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan is consistent with the goals and objectives of the Project Area Redevelopment Plan which are also incorporated and made a part of this document by reference. 4) The Implementation Plan establishes environmental controls which should be actively enforced and pursued to reduce environmental liabilities related to industrial developments to a safe and acceptable level . 5) All of the "Statements of Policy" and all of the "Principles and Standards" of the Design Manual of the City of Chula Vista shall be applicable to development proposed by the Otay Valley Road Project Area, except in those cases where statements, principles, or standards apply solely, expressly, and are exclusively confined to residential development. 6) The Agency should not authorize any approvals or permits or make recommendations in support of any development or land activity, which fails to conform substantially to the controls and guidelines of the Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum. 7) Notwithstanding the guidelines, criteria, or regulatory provisions of this plan, proposed changes and additions to buildings, structures, and building sites shall be permitted within the Project Area, where such are specifically required for health or safety reasons by State of California or Federal legislation. These changes and additions shall be reviewed by the Design Review Committee, which may require additional landscaping or urban design features to ameliorate their environmental or visual impact, pursuant to the goals, objectives, and statements of policy of this plan. - 3 - 3.0 SPECFIC LAND USE CONTROLS The specific land use controls designated in this document must comply with the City of Chula Vista General Plan. Pursuant to any future General Plan land use amendments affecting the Project Area, the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan and corresponding guidelines of this Implementation Plan shall be automatically amended to comply with the Chula Vista General Plan. It is the intent of the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Plan and its Implementation Plan and Design Manual Addendum to guide and promote the development of well-designed, well-ordered, and economically sound industrial parks and land uses. The land uses envisaged by the plan include light manufacturing facilities, warehouses, distribution centers, research institutions, and product-development plants. As a general rule, the said plans and addendum contemplate and encourage the establishment of indoor or enclosed operations. 3.1 Land Use Map 1 ) Land use classifications within the Project Area are designated on the Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan Land Use Map and are consistent with the General Plan of the City of Chula Vista and Otay Valley Redevelopment Plan. 2) The Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan Land Use Map shall designate "sensitive impact boundaries" as areas where industrial and residential land uses abut one another. Within these areas, the Agency may apply special land use, environmental , or noise controls, and may require the procurement of a special permit as a condition precedent to the establishment of any land use therein. 3.2 Land Uses Permitted in the Project Area 1 ) Industrial activities in the Otay Valley Road Project Area should include all land uses permitted in the underlying zones, as consistent with the General Plan except as otherwise restricted herein. 2) The special permit process shall be used to adequately guard against the establishment of inappropriate land uses. 3) The Design Review Committee review process shall be used to foster sound urban design, orderly development and environmental quality. 4) The following shall be subject to Design Review Committee approval whenever located or proposed within the Otay Valley Road Project Area: Building and structural heights exceeding two stories or thirty-five feet (35 feet) . - 4 - Building or structural heights within the Sensitive Impact Boundary and exceeding two stories or twenty-five feet (25 feet) . Outdoor storage yards, service yards and building materials sales yards, and truck and equipment sales yards which exceed twenty percent (20%) of the gross floor area of all enclosed main and accessory buildings on site; Any deviations from the standards of the Implementation Plan must be authorized by the Redevelopment Agency upon recommendation by the Design Review Committee 5) the establishment or expansion of land uses within the Project Area shall be governed by the following provisions. a) Permitted Uses All land uses permitted under the I-L, Limited Industrial zone shall be permitted in the Project Area. b) Uses Permitted by Special Permit All land uses permitted in I-L zones through the conditional use process; all land uses permitted in the I Industrial Zones but not the I-L zones; and, all land uses permitted in the I zones through the conditional use process shall be permitted within the Project Area upon the procurement of special permits from the Agency. c) Prohibited Uses All land uses prohibited by the I-L or I regulations shall be prohibited in the Project Area. d) Special Permit Process The Project Area Committee shall review requests for special permits, and shall report its findings and recommendations to the Agency. An application for a special permit may be approved, conditionally approved, or denied by the Agency. The Committee shall make all of the following findings prior to its recommendation that a special permit be approved or conditionally approved by the Agency. - The proposed project would not constitute a substantial detriment to the Project Area or adjacent areas. - The proposed project would promote the orderly physical and economic development of the Project Area. - The proposed project would be consonant with the townscape-planning and urban-design objectives of the Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum, and would contribute to the amenity of the Project Area. 3.3 Special Land Use Requirements in Sensitive Impact Boundary 1 ) Industrial activities permitted in the sensitive impact boundaries should be those which are not obtrusive, incompatible or a nuisance to the surrounding residential developments. 2) Any land use generating unmitigated hazardous waste, as defined within the State Statutes of the State of California Health and Safety Code, will be prohibited. 3.4 Land Use Standards of Performance 1 ) Performance standards embodied in the zoning regulations of the City of Chula Vista (see Appendix for references) shall govern the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Project Area. 2) The noise standards established by the Chula Vista Noise Ordinance shall also govern land uses and operating activities in the Otay Valley Road Redevelopment Project Area. 3) With respect to ambient noise, the provisions of the Noise Element of the General Plan shall be accepted as the guiding principles. The matter of ambient noise, furthermore, shall be fully addressed under the environmental-assessment process. 3.5 Land Use Consideration Involving the Use and Handling of Hazardous Materials 1 ) Certain proposed land use activities involving the use of or generation of hazardous materials need to be adequately reviewed and monitored to guard against the improper handling or disposal of such materials and the unsafe exposure of the public to such potential risks. 2) Proposed businesses utilizing or generating hazardous materials or wastes, as defined by the State Health and Safety Code, should receive more extensive consideration beyond the normal plan review process. 3) Specific identified land use activities should be subject to the performance standards review procedures established in the Zoning Code and this Implementation Plan, and also similar review and permit procedures through the County Health Department-Hazardous Materials Management Unit. 4) The business license review and plan review process should serve as a mechanism to alert the Community Development Director and Project Area Committee of businesses involving hazardous material or wastes within the Otay Valley Road Project Area. The business license review process, however, shall not be used as an enforcement mechanism. - 6 - 5) The Agency should make all efforts to utilize County programs, undertaken by the County Health Department-Hazardous Materials Management Unit, to assist the Agency in fulfilling its underlying responsibility to monitor land uses involving hazardous wastes and materials in the Otay Valley Road Project Area. In addition, the Agency should, to the extent possible, utilize established County programs, such as the Hazardous Waste Surveillance and Hazardous Material Disclosure Programs, and professional staffing skills employed by these services. 6) The following land use activities are identified by the County Hazardous Materials Management Unit as potential generators of hazardous waste; this list should be used as a guideline (not all inclusive) for special consideration under City and County programs: • Automotive repair and/or service related facilities, i.e. radiator shops Chemical , medical and photo finishing laboratories; Construction operations and maintenance sites; • Dry cleaning plants and industrial cleaning operations; Electroplaters; ▪ Manufacturing industries including: wood products, textiles furniture, paper, chemicals, rubber leather, plastics, building materials, machinery, electronics and instruments; • Mining, extraction, and refining of ore and petroleum product fabricators; Platers and metal fabricators; Printers and print shops; ▪ Research and development sites; and ▪ Other uses as may be added to the County's Hazardous Materials Management Unit list or as established by the State of California or the Federal Government. 3.6 Compliance With Regulations of Other Public Agencies: Notwithstanding said Zoning Code provisions and the provisions of this Implementation Plan, additions, deletions and modifications may be made to non-conforming buildings, establishments and land uses when required by public health, safety and welfare regulations imposed by other public agencies. - 7 - 4.0 DESIGN OBJECTIVES Where either the planning regulations or the design guidelines criteria are in conflict, the more restrictive shall supersede. 4.1 Townscape Planning The Otay Valley Road Project Area should include a strong emphasis upon landscape and landscape design. Buffers between industrial sites and adjacent, non-industrial land uses should be established and maintained. 1 ) Parkway Landscaping Landscaping within the public parkways and setbacks provide plant materials which establish a sense of continuity throughout the Project Area. Where feasible drought-tolerant trees should be preserved and planted as a continuous townscape element. Landscaping should form a continuous open space element consistent with standards and planting cross-sections as designated by the City Landscape Architect. Intersection corner landscape design treatments at major intersections within the Project Area should be pursued which make effective use of public parkway and/or private setback areas to create highly aesthetic landscaping, Project Area logo markers and other identifying devices for the traveling public, yet maintain safe visibility for vehicular movement. 2) Riverway Improvements Flood control improvements should utilize construction materials, such as breakwall or rock groin fortification of the riverbanks, which are more conducive to the natural environment associated with riverway and marshland habitats. Flood control improvements should include measures to maintain the floodway in a natural state and preserve the natural habitat through the selective elimination of invasive Salt-Cedar trees, planting of native Willow, Sycamore, and Cottonwood trees, encouragement of natural ground water recharge, and the removal of debris and abandoned vehicles from the floodplain. The Otay River floodway should serve as a passive recreational open space providing visual amenities to individuals working or living in the area. - 8 - Riverway improvements should include treatment of the open space strip adjacent to the floodway to accommodate passive recreation needs of the local vicinity. 3) Street Furniture Use of street furniture such as lighting, seating, and trash receptacles should be uniform in order to complement other townscape features within the public right-of-way. The street furniture selected for use should complement the design of buildings within an industrial environment and is encouraged to manifest a tone of architectural design, but need only be located where found necessary to accommodate pedestrian traffic, pedestrian activities or special needs, or as determined by the Agency. 4) Underground Utilities The improvement of the Otay Valley Road townscape and effective use of street furniture therein should be partially dependent upon the undergrounding of public utility lines. Such undergrounding efforts should be gauged to redevelopment of the Project Area and directed along Otay Valley Road as a priority consideration. 5) Points of Entry Island medians or other landmark devices should be used to signify entry into the Project Area and City boundaries. Such entry devices should utilize a uniform logo or structural devices which can be readily equated with the City or Otay Valley Road Project Area. Island median improvements or other landscaped treatments at the entrance of residential developments should be used to effectively denote a separation between industrial and residential traffic flows. 6) Buffers Buffers are strips of land usually landscaped which are established to separate and protect one type of land use from another. They are often used as a screen to noise, smoke, and visual aspects of industrial areas which are located in adjacency to residential neighborhoods. In the Otay Valley Road Project Area, buffers should be utilized for the reduction of land-use friction, and the creation of a well-ordered and pleasant work environment. 4.2 Site Design The site design of all development projects should permit various physical components within an improved property, such as parking, vehicular and truck movements, building location, loading areas, landscaping and setbacks, to - 9 function without conflict or adverse affect on adjoining land uses. Furthermore, the element of townscape uniformity should be reflected among individual site designs through continuity in design criteria. Consistent application of the following site design criteria by the various reviewing bodies and the Design Review Committee will sustain an industrial park environment throughout the Otay Valley Road Project Area. The following site design criteria also applies to developments within the Sensitive Impact Boundary of the Project Area, unless otherwise specified herein. 1 ) Lot Size and Frontage The minimum lot size which may be developed should not be less than two (2) acres in area. Each lot should have a minimum public street frontage of 200 lineal feet. The above guidelines may be waived by the Design Review Committee or other Reviewing Body, where such body determines and finds, at a public hearing, that such waiver is consistent with the goals and objectives of the Redevelopment Plan. 2) Lot Coverage The maximum site coverage by all main and accessory buildings footprints should not exceed 45% of total gross area. 3) Grading All grading within the Project Area shall be sensitive to surrounding land uses, developments, and drainage patterns. 4) Setbacks Along Otay Valley Road, between I-805 and the easterly project line, exterior building setbacks should be no less than forty (40) feet from the property line. Building setbacks in all other areas shall be no less than twenty-five (25) feet from the front yard and exterior side yard property lines. Building setbacks from interior side yard property lines should be twenty (20) feet minimum. Building setbacks from rear yard property lines should be fifty (50) feet, except that the rear set back may be reduced to a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet when industrial sites are platted rear-to-rear, or rear-to-side. 5) Setback Within The Sensitive Impact Boundary (SIB) Where a building site within the Project Area is adjacent to a residential lot or unsubdivided residential area, the minimum setback between a building constructed upon the said building site and the closest property line of the said residential lot or unsubdivided area should be 200' , unless a reduced setback is depicted upon the following diagram. - 10 - • • ,..,-,.°1-4..4." . •••••••• ...i.t..:.:' • .., V -Pk Slit. ' i'''.':",'.':.' 1...:::::. s Dl 5:1�!'t'•f:.%r�',y:I �7i!�'i/�:►.•V1'!�♦� .6•i� �iOO•�� ',•'../,.•1',i .. • • � '+•4 f sr,.: ..; iP . 1 e1-14 y?`: 0.0 V1�i ii` S••...:.•♦ ..�•a i • •..•,; I �k^- •fi'...t. i,: !.!; 4:4:4ifls:Af P,*$?f,!.1i447 ♦♦4♦♦t►i•••�'i•••i :O♦ OO►"'�.•••♦:.1 •.'..t.:� .... �ti 4 . ti .. .:r%.^S'''.ri''.(:'Fi,•.f'::Jr .;,1 414:1 r..'•.+�'.,.:r J:'•�A 4446O.O/ O•O • ♦ .� • < < < < ;7 r;:i;.+iii.,. r X,:' "'-0'- !».gyp ge, 1 �.� 1 4.:44:44.4.4444 44•' `�i •�S• •� •t •..,t,..,....,.....,,..% :p.4...4. p S. -'iii :;;C' .ra,;;i •'.•,'..•f;=�,} .!r f Er.''' a�f�F� �••:�:�4�:�.:�•�•� II••••••••• eV 044 1- s 4 i'..,:{,.' j,,,,.., ;, f y#:{;,4•ti..• .>f:•i.:">,CC•••••••••♦•i ►••❖•`4:••4••O ••O• .1.•,.••.: cSt f1" ♦ .t `?Ef c.:.:l•, .�..4.. ±t i /,:••❖:4•+�A•�!•� 4•w1 wO�i! ���` ►•�•i♦i•���•y'':': '::• < : W rly :.f. y,,+' .j...�;r• ,, j�;j,r:rt.�.F.:�ii• •.�1 ��' •�� 1 �y`•:I I ,•r',}T :. Z W > 4 _ ti%,•'.:o.,-sT?' ;•7;5 rr',i,!1%;Y%.,r!." i♦i ••i♦• 4444• •♦ ♦1♦♦••.•›. 1. .•g%:.4Lgi.:i•�i:.:`fla; i;•t ":?i?r4.?".. 4),.•. ::kt 0.0�►�* %%• .%%% ' .'i .i}•, fA '.....g o J 7 sue+ f tit...9i, lei"• �.�a i O♦•♦ ` • •Did;!...:*0.1.•:'. p w o •+ f -±s„ > .s•c>,7 .J :.,•....�� O!1 wO...- -.•w•....'• <11 w .. ►• O cn 4 f.+ g '-!",:??..PAY ! ,f :A.**. ••040••0 `.11'44♦•. x.:::f'••. •: it Z. "i .;;;' $g.r'.¢;i,':v.;.,,. .0 ,y:♦:•♦❖:,.10014 sr, , o a > p• R •-1 ?• ytil,% i+:Ty�1' ri, ?`-', f`^`'`:`xftt: :r li"'�' ►OO�iti•�• Oit•ci::'•Oi�iiii♦�111 !.: ,1:•!: .�:• p 2 z > V V h Q '''U[!,C-_`f:y`- . ✓ryI, �� .:.".>•`s',W.4.. ;'. .r;,'•O♦:♦• ti •:..444. �•� ;o:4N . %I.. Z •• < 7. •--i O ': c "r + Y rL.` ' �.r ♦ �1• •�• • '••♦♦•. •i i i•••i�. •10^'. Q 3 a. i �.r.. ��r;-,,'•" �-n 3• i`: ►.�.it',f� ..►•i : •i �►'sii ♦iii_1iiiii iii , ••� J o o s Z 3 z ::,41, - . -r ro w ,r f r - •i• O• 0+40444•••'•iC 't. ;:� ••�' . 42 0 O• 4444• • • f O 7.'..: i!.t .'�f; ,f��: %,N n is� e►'i••i`'•O•iiiii1•iii OOi ! i•••�v.:;:.; C:: ����' r q; 7:. Z Q 00 4.' 1:"%'^s'' ypIV i' :•1.,;' ';6'gLi444 ; 1s °' O 4,.. iii•4•4•ii4iiiii•••Oi :iii i .:•:*'a•i •♦• i'.; . Q _-� ti •X yf•...:5 Ktr�il�M.-h:� I' • • ••••••4••••4•♦••. •♦••1• .0.. •♦1 • �I•J C'3 F- � t .:7:<,, t.r..si'v �' :,,,, {�,r;..�.1y0 `••O4•♦ •••••••♦•♦• ,,c.....4 '/"•' .. .•:Q .0 �..r y 9 , . , ..•.M1,, , ✓� [ 4 :y,r: ♦:•• • ♦❖:❖♦❖:••❖•1. .: :..:.1..: ♦• ti Q U a . ski .; : -n'�. '..I T. °' 's ',j'p.:••••4.••�..•i!�4�t r!Y�:•.%.....• .:y.•:: . ;:i. r, %•♦� t Q. �•• Q iq ./ r.IJF l Fr tr•OO:!••:♦:•••i ♦•.:. ..e ,► �'••d ••♦••� .•. ..fir, �r •,. J:.'£. (,' sc.'fl4e!''` rw•.. 4404►•'• '�.•�•♦ :•••♦•, ::"•'•5.r•':: Y •--i •T: -• ! sk• �-• ?" ..:v✓,w.{!f' �1:•♦❖:4••. •i••Oi'��.`: ii0♦ ;14::::::;.:3)..;::.:••♦ 0 i1y.•%. :f... 3 f:s� r!�,r `-'•_ i.•r ��.,�L• '• _s.p ,; .•r..>. .•( :;'/ Vii.' ':✓,-;G. ...�iw•i!•!•:/Oi.6f t�•�•S►•!•!s f.'Pal'i0i♦i• 1.,:**4 ii ' ,w O }�.,�'.;`•�• :a.,•s:;,.(. _•:w:ii.,..Jracy,..: OM.; ••►:•:�•���:•:. :.:••!�. •'• y,/:o� m � ��- I: iy, ��.�c- 9•� ay;::• 1 .. •!�.'s: ;:� • A•.�.+ f ••I• :•.•;. d CC I-- r-• =iY. b::r? "s'a^Y,,,,,i:=:'.!,/ .. t4 r -µ,,�. �,.„.•,, •444 .•••p.4 • • iii ,.. :.. W F- c s a ►yo�.�►• �j0•���i••Yi❖:OO. • •..� v) ,---. Yy =,i ._..�: .5.. ♦i .400••0/ 4440'♦•.J �r r 'i.i t r rr 4 •• 14•.x mg::.1, WOO •.•u..,•'.l..•,,,, y rC,, . �....•yz:r l� t%.:','"!, -,-'...,.':isrf :r�••♦:•:r';Iyi,,w.i:t`O:�•/!•iw�t .•!�•!••i•�ei Z'.�. ,, uj Z W r>• . xi d rc a,a a i ., .: 0• •4••••'• 4:04:04::::*..c. r:•.. J N. r.. r♦o�►6•=•3°rii i ►•00000000 .....1:4*::. :'.:a• i ..I Q W �O r•::••ODpO.O••O•••♦f 0❖•O•••••O•.4'!..••, :r::':: /:.� l. y/• ••f 4•4.4.4 ►•4.4:4.4•••■:4••�.,•, ..'.il ca 3 ••� O *:444::::::::m ♦..4►•�• ..: 8 t► ♦•••r I T i `0� 4444 • .,.'' 1'•t 04.44♦•• 4444••• ••'c.'•..•. ♦ !44,4•:••:4• ►••••••OO . :' a •....• St, .•44.4. I• O•• .•=❖sa��1,•,.•' c0♦4•�O••••d:•,�.'..... .',7y. -0 40 •A04 •1. •4444 ••4•,•4 ..1!.:..;...:;.4,.!..•.:...:.,:1:.:. ► 0040♦. • • ••♦ 4444•/ P• 0 4• ••,.; . 4444 4444• • •• ••• .:.�• , • ••• •• ♦•444'•. � • dib i'. -:�•,►i:�♦♦•�i�•4i•4.4.4'4' :1;•i4ti►�•ii••s•'.�.�. Yr•'•Y•1YY-r•YY'•:vrr4 ♦••i♦4 1 1'..�.• 6:”f i' ♦ • 41•••4••• ♦ 4. k••:: : : „;:..4••••••!• . ••. 4444• •0.440 ► •• °t.;x••.0:4/1 4444 O`i♦♦•• O.Oi •4♦• : •.•• • 4444• 4444 44 • �•• .•• • 4444 O•••4•. ►• ••O 4444 "i' 3,x•6;••4y0 ••.•a gk4♦ .., •.. • ;.telfew,:gt:teallommoi -• ' ''''''N Vcibk k■'!. ..__..".......i' ' 44, ......:.1, • d AYMWAJ., SOOI a I . -1,�- Drive lanes, parking, trash enclosures and other fixed improvements should be setback a minimum of thirty (30) feet from any property line adjoining a residential development or zone. This may be increased where environmental considerations require such. 6) Landscaping A minimum of twenty percent (20%) of each developed lot should be permanently landscaped and irrigated. Perimeter landscaping along all Property lines establishing the front yard and exterior side yard should be provided with the following widths as a minimum landscaped separation between driveways, parking stalls, loading spaces, trash enclosure or other fixed improvements and the respective property line: 40 feet - Along Otay Valley Road between I-805 and the easterly project line. 25 feet - Along all other segments of Otay Valley Road. 30 feet - Along Brandywine between Otay Valley Road and residential devel opments. 20 feet - At all other locations within the Otay Valley Road Project Area. The landscaping of the project area should not be confined to plant material. Textured flooring, hardscape, masonry, graphics, and exterior furniture shall also constitute landscaping within the purview of this manual . All interior side yards should have a minimum ten (10) foot wide landscape strip, except when joint access drive lanes or parking areas are used between properties to reduce the total number of driveway approaches devel oped. All areas in excess of one hundred (100) square feet and not utilized for parking, open storage areas, loading or on-site circulation should be landscaped or maintained in a natural state consistent with the topographic character of the area. The area required in this provision shall not be in excess of the 20% minimum requirement. A conceptual landscape plan shall be submitted to the City Landscape Architect for advice and recommendation prior to the review of such conceptual landscape plan by the Design Review Committee or other reviewing body prescribed by the Zoning Code. All landscaping shall be installed pursuant to a professionally prepared plan, and maintained in accordance with accepted horticultural practices as determined by the City Landscape Architect. - 12 - S All irrigation proposals shall meet the requirements of the City Landscape Architect. The plantation of drought-resistant grasses, native plant materials and specimen trees, and the practice of water economy should be encouraged. The use of artistically designed and arranged hardscape should also be suggested. The guidelines and criteria of the City of Chula Vista's Landscape Manual are hereby incorporated into the guidelines of this addendum by reference. 7) Outdoor Storage and Equipment Parking a. Outdoor storage and sales areas should not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the total gross floor area of the main and accessory buildings and must be approved by the Agency with the recommendation of the Design Review Committee. Enclosure requirements will be determined by the Design Review Committee. b. Commercial vehicles, trucks and trailer equipment used in conjunction with the primary business operation may exceed the enclosure height when such parking area is not located in the front yard or exterior side yard of the site upon approval by the Design Review Committee or other reviewing bodies required by the Zoning Code. The 20% limitation is not applicable to equipment parking provisions. 8) Utility Services All utility services, including electrical , telephone, gas and other services, such as transformers, telephone switching boxes, gas meters or other devices, shall be placed underground or screened as a part of the site design. 9) Loading Spaces Each loading space should be located to provide direct loading into an enclosed structure. Where a loading space faces a street, there should be a minimum sixty- five (65) foot building setback to the loading doors measured from the required landscape setback of the respective yard area. No loading space should enter directly into the street within 150 feet of a residential development or zone. Each loading space should have sufficient turning area to permit safe maneuvering of trucks and trailers without obstructing parking spaces or encroaching into landscaping setbacks. - 13 - 4.3 Building Design A set architectural theme is not prescribed or recommended within the Project Area, but a design emphasis on structural amenities and aesthetic quality in roof designs and exterior walls of buildings is strongly suggested. The building design criteria should serve to evoke an industrial park-like environment within each individual building site and throughout all developed lots within the Project Area. The City Design Manual guidelines and criteria for commercial buildings should apply as a general rule to such development proposals within the Otay Valley Road Project Area. 1 ) Building Heights Building heights should comply with restrictions embodied in Section 3.2 (Land Uses Permitted in the Project Area) . 2) Roof Design All parapets, offsets, mansard roofs and other roof treatments should be integrated with an overall building design, and should be adequate in size to screen or enclose any roof mounted equipment or devices. Recessed downspouts should be encouraged where feasible but should, at a minimum, match exterior building design and color when not recessed. The configuration and location of roof equipment and associated screening shall be designed so as to maintain architectural consistency and should also be subject to Design Review Committee approval . Solar devices designed and installed upon a roof structure should be placed in a location to maintain the architectural quality of the building, as well as, operating efficiency of the unit. All other roof mounted ducts, cyclone blowers and other mechanical devices should be strategically located to preserve the architectural quality of the building and screened and painted to match the surface to which attached. Because of the topographic differential between the project area and adjacent residential districts, the amenity of the top view of the roof- mounted equipment should be stressed. 3) Building Openings Bay door openings and other large openings providing direct access to interior work areas should be directed towards the site interior or other industrial uses and should not open directly towards adjacent residential developments. - 14 - Primary customer, employee or office entrances should be used as a focal point of the building design and located for greater visibility from vehicular traffic. 4.4 Circulation and Parking The following guidelines are designed to accommodate increased vehicular traffic resulting from the Project Area development and growth in the surrounding subregion. The guidelines are also designed to provide for the wide variety of transportation modes that will be utilized in the Otay Valley Road Project Area. 1 ) Transit The Chula Vista Redevelopment Agency should coordinate public transit requirements with the respective transit company and, as appropriate, should require bus turn-out pockets within the Project Area. Street furniture should be used to identify bus stops and provide for a bus service directory of the greater South County area. 2) Passive Recreational Activity A linear open space park should be provided in conjunction with floodway improvements along the Otay River for passive recreational activity. The passive recreational open space should be improved as a lineal park with limited facilities for use by employees from surrounding development and residents adjacent to the Project Area. 3) Bicycle Linkages The Redevelopment Agency should encourage the development and maintenance of bicycle linkages between the Project Area and surrounding territories. 4) Parking On-street parking shall be prohibited within the Project Area at any time for all types of vehicles, including cars, tractor trailers, and similar transportation vehicles. 5) Driveway Locations Driveway entrances and exits should be located in such a manner as to create the least number of traffic flow interruptions as possible. Therefore, driveways serving industrial developments should be discouraged along higher volume roadways and encouraged within secondary and loop roadways. - 15 - Driveways should not be encouraged along Otay Valley Road where alternate access locations are possible. Driveways should not be permitted closer than two-hundred fifty (250) feet apart for those lots having only one access alternative along Otay Valley Road. Development projects extending beyond a single parcel should undertake joint access arrangements to reduce the total number of driveway entries onto a public street. No driveway access onto a public street should be located closer than one-hundred fifty (150) feet from the nearest residential development or zone. 4.5 Signs General Criteria a. Signs should be designed as supportive elements to land use. They should be used primarily to identify businesses, professional offices and public and quasi-public facilities. b. Signs should be compatible with the nature, character, and design of the locale and land uses they serve. c. Good townscape planning requires that signs manifest artistic order and taste. Offensive or obtrusive signing should be avoided. d. In their selection of signs, property owners and tenants should place considerable emphasis upon color, harmony, size, shape, texture, materials, and character. e. Signs should be characterized by restraint. Where practicable, artistic graphics, logos, or fine art displays should be used in lieu of "commercial-type" signs. Signs which depict "prices" or the special features of products would be inappropriate within the Project Area. f. No sign shall be located within the Project Area without the prior authorization of the Design Review Committee, or upon appeal , the Redevelopment Agency. 1 ) Sign Types a. Two (2) distinct sign types should characterize the appurtenant, identification sign environment in the Project Area: Primary Signs - should identify the development project, building or primary tenant of a complex with visual orientation toward vehicular traffic. - 16 - Secondary Signs should identify individual tenants with building frontage in a complex or building, and should be oriented to pedestrian and vehicle circulation on the project site alone. 2) Number of Signs As a general rule: a. One (1 ) primary sign per building, or one (1 ) primary sign per building within a complex, should be permitted to identify the entire development project site. b. One (1 ) secondary sign to identify the business establishment should be permitted for building tenants having street or court-yard lineal building frontage and an integrally designed main business entrance on the ground floor. c. Primary leasehold tenants on the second floor or in the interior court of a building or building complex, should be permitted one (1 ) directory sign space within the building directory. d. One (1 ) sign directory per building for the identification of second story and interior court businesses should be permitted. 3) Sign Area As a general rule: a. Primary signs may have a total area of one (1 ) square foot for every lineal foot of building frontage with a maximum sign area of one hundred fifty (150) square feet. b. Secondary signs may have a total area of one-half (1/2) square feet for every lineal foot of business frontage with a maximum sign area of thirty two (32) square feet. c. Individual business directory sign spaces should have a total permissible area of one (1 ) square foot within the building directory. d. Building directory signs should be limited in total area as is reasonably necessary to identify each building tenant and display a directional map for pedestrian use. 4) Placement of Signs a. Primary signs should be placed on the primary building face or wall in a manner consistent with the building design and may be oriented toward vehicular traffic movements. b. Secondary signs should be located on the first level of the building face or wall area for each respective business establishment identified in Paragraph 5 (b) and should be oriented toward pedestrian and parking lot circulation. c't - 17 c. Secondary signs may also be located underneath building galleries or colonnades and similar locations upon approval of the Design Review Committee. d. Directory signs may be placed as appropriate at the main entrance or Primary pedestrian passage to the interior or upper spaces of a building(s) . e. No roof signs should be permitted in the Project Area. f. No attached building signs should extend higher than the roofline of the building or structure. 5) Freestanding Signs (Monument) a. Pole signs should not be permitted in the Project Area. b. One (1 ) monument type sign may be permitted as a primary sign for each developed site having a minimum of two (2) acres and a minimum frontage of two hundred (200) feet along the primary roadway used for placement of such sign. c. The monument sign area should not exceed a maximum permitted sign area of fifty (50) square feet as measured from a single side of the sign copy. d. Monument signs should be mounted on a base or pedestal and should not exceed eight (8) feet in height, and shall be located a minimum of ten (10) feet from all property lines. e. All design standards applying to primary signs should also apply to monument signs. 6) Sign Amortization The amortization and abatement of any non-conforming signs within the Project Area shall comply with the provisions embodied in the Sign Regulations of the Zoning Ordinance, as adopted in 1975, and thereafter amended. - 18 - 5.0 ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONS Although the text contained within this Project Area Plan/Design Manual Addendum establishes a framework and coordinating process for effective redevelopment, such goals, objectives and tasks must be pursued and fulfilled by the administrative bodies responsible for successful implementation. Without active implementation of such coordinating tasks, land use controls and design guidelines, the Otay Valley Road Project Area will continue to experience sporadic development which is inefficient, uncoordinated and, more than likely, adverse to surrounding land uses. Through persistent coordinating and development efforts by the Agency and other administrative offices having the understanding of land use goals and objectives established by this document, the Otay Valley Road Project Area will become a well ordered, pleasant industrial complex which serves as an economic benefit to the City of Chula Vista and provides a large measure of protection to nearby residents. 5.1 Redevelopment Agency Coordinating Role 1 ) The Agency should utilize its coordinating capacity to fulfill and preserve the land use objectives and design guidelines promoted by the Otay Valley Road Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum. 2) The Agency should utilize the Design Review Committee as the primary agent for reviewing development proposals and maintaining the goals and objectives of the Design Manual Addendum. 5.2 Project Area Committee (PAC) 1 ) The Project Area Committee shall be an advisory body composed pf seven members, appointed by the Mayor, with the consent of the City Council . The membership of PAC shall reflect representation from the residential areas adjacent to the Project Area; the ownership or management of the lands or businesses within the Project Area; and, the general interests of the Chula Vista Planning Area. 2) The PAC shall review all major proposals for the development, platting, conservation, circulation, or public service of the Project Area, and shall report its findings and recommendations to the Redevelopment Agency, Design Review Committee, or referring body. 3) The PAC may, on its own volition, advise the Redevelopment Agency on matters of pertinent, City planning significance and may submit to the said Agency such reports on the state of the revitalization of the Project Area as it may consider necessary. - 19 - 4) The PAC shall utilize the public notice period to review such proposals and prepare statements of recommendation to the Design Review Committee or Redevelopment Agency for their consideration in a public forum prior to a final decision. 5.3 Planning and Design Responsibility Within the Project Area 1 ) The Project Area Committee shall be responsible for advising the Redevelopment Agency on matters of City and townscape planning significance. The advisory jurisdiction of the Committee shall include conceptual development, project, and subdivision plans. 2) The Chula Vista Design Review Committee (DRC) shall be responsible for advising the Agency on matters of urban-design, or post-planning significance. On minor projects, the action of the Design Review Committee may be final , subject to appeal to the Agency. The Committee's jurisdiction with respect to minor projects shall be specifically governed by a policy resolution of the Agency, which may be amended at any time. 3) As a general rule, the PAC shall review major projects prior to their review by the DRC and Agency, and shall submit pertinent recommendations to those bodies. A major project for the purposes of this section is defined as a proposal which requires an Owner Participation Agreement (OPA) entered into by the Agency. 4) The Chief Planning Officer of the Project Area shall be the Director of Planning of the City of Chula Vista. 5.4 Amendment of the Implementation Plan/Design Manual The Implementation Plan/Design Manual Addendum may be amended by the Agency in order to refine, update, or improve its provisions, or to foster the methodical effectuation of the Redevelopment Plan. Proposed amendments shall be referred to the Planning Commission and the Project Area Committee for their review and recommendations. WPC 1382H - 20 - •0 C r .0 ✓ C O H O a) •.+ > 00 > 4) d O ca 0f L O. .., p,.., c a u w 07... E -0 0.o .-I t. C O N t0 C 0)0) .x ° E > W I 0) CU w w V I-. 0 L. aW0 b 0 0HI 0 w •.i m >0 •• 6 O 0 C. P. 3 .., 0.•.i > 001 10.-I Z CD w 0 ...a s''.+/ °-♦ 01160 00-• -I � w w GdG u C 0 w -4 a od � a o d .4.+a.. 4.+, G 0 0 0 U4) CO N o V -.i CO Ca 4) al C a3i 0. 0 .-I H 0 .0 O E L. > 00 i, 0 C C R w CO O W L H O. HI C C 0!E N v W 4 C .-I W > 0 1) CO .-O.•a HO t. a, 00 E .3 v . w 16 Ni > > 1. 0) v o A a 0 V aa) c P. A c, -.a o w to -.. o 6 V V CO d P. W O > O m v CO 0 a 00. ..i .0 ..N4 a ..1..1 i d .,..> ), O O w H .0 w I. N 0 PO W d v w h d w im, C a, a) ti d ) •a> + w., 0 0 .0 u 4-,0 0 .._4..i C y, i, C. 4) w..i U t. O v w a m P. 0 E 3 P. x > 0 C ry V CO N . 4.) H W d 06 V VI U •s7 ■ .-1 a.7 4) +-, 0 E c 6 N C O E O E 4 1, O N 0 0 0 w c. W > N > t0 > N ( co C O 0 0 Q 0 w w C >. ..i >. (0.) u C 0 c....if."... c � 0 r w a. C C d V w C.0 F V CO ill W o 0 41 41 00 0 N N C H V 4 CO