HomeMy WebLinkAboutReso 2013-217 RESOLUTION NO. 2013-217
RESOLUTION OF THE CIT1' OF CHULA VISTA CITI'
COUT'CIL ADOPTII�'G A COU�'C[L POLICY FOR THE
SITI1�'G OF ELECTRICAL GEI�'ERATII�'G FACILITIES
WITHII� THE CITY OF CHULA VISTA A'ITHOUT OFFSET
PROVISIOI�'S
WHEREAS: the Cin� of Chula Vista promotes the use of conservation technologies and
sustainabilin� practices that reduce or eliminate the use of non-reneH-able resources, including
non-polluting and rene�aable enerev as envisioned in the Chula Vista General Plan (GP); Land
Use and Transponation Element Chapter 4, Theme � "Healthy and Sustainable Em�ironmenr;
and
WHEREAS; it is an objecti��e of the GP En��ironmental Element - E 6 to "Impro��e local
air qualit�� b}� minimizina the production and emission of air pollutants and to�ic air
contaminants and limit the esposure of people to such pollutants '; and
VJHEREAS, policies E 63, 6.4, 6.�, 6.6, 6.12, and 6.1� stipulate the importance of
impro��ine air qualit��. and minimizing dependency on fossil fuels and e�posure of sensitive uses
to tolic �air contaminants from (eenerall}� fossil-fuel-based) facilities such as Electrical
Generating Facilities (EGFs); and
WHEREAS. in Februan� 2010. the City Council directed staff to prepare amendments to
the GP and Zonine Ordinance related to the establishins of requirements and reeulations for the
sitine of EGFs: and �
�1'HEREAS. the De��elopment Sen�ices Department initiated a review of the Cin%s GP
and Zonine Ordinance to determine w�hat sections needed to be amended: and
V�'HEREAS, the Development Services Department con��ened a team consistine of
interested members of the original 200� Chula Vista General Plan Update (GPU) Environment,
Open Space, and Sustainable De��elopment Subcommittee (the "EGF Working Group '); and
WHEREAS, the De��elopment Services Department and the EGF Workine Group have
�+�orked together to develop regulations and siting criteria for EGFs H�ithin Chula Vista includin2
draftine a neti� EGF Council Policy to address the sitine of EGFs (the "Projecr'); and
WHEREAS; the Development Sen�ices Department also com�ened a team consistine of
members of the industry and business community (the "Industry Workine Group `) to solicit
input on the drafr reoulations and EGF Council Policv to gain a balanced perspective; and
WHEREAS, the Development Sen�ices Department com�ened a joint meeting ���ith the
Industry �1'orking Group and EGF 11%orkine Group (the `Joint A'orking Group') to revie��� the
drafr re�ulations and EGF Council Polic�; and
Resolution No. 201=-217
Page 2
V��HEREAS, the Project represents the collective efforts of the Development Services
Department and the EGF Joint Working Group, and provides necessary criteria and regulations
for the siting of EGFs «�ithin the City of Chula Vista; and
WHEREAS; the Development Services Director has reviewed the proposed Amendments
for compliance with the California Environmental quality Act (CEQA) and has determined that
there is no possibilit}� that the activity. adopting a General Plan amendment and Zoning Code
amendment may have a significant effect on the enviromnent because the new General Plan
policy and Zoning Code provisions �i�ill result in more stringent requirements for locating an
Energy Generating Facility than currently exist. Therefore, pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of
the State CEQA Guidelines the activitv is not subject to CEQA. Thus, no environmental review
is required. Although environmenta] review is not required for the General Plan Amendment and
Zoning Code change, environmental review will be required for any Energy Generating
Facilities that are proposed as part of the conditional use permit evaluation and/or discretionary
revie�� for that specific project; and
WHEREAS, the Resource Conservation Commission (RCC), upon review of the Project
recommended that the City Council adopt the Project; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission voted to recommend that the City Council
approve a resolution adopting a new Council Policy which provides guidance and specifications
for the siting of EGFs and the reduction of associated Greenhouse Gas in accordance with offset
requirements within the City of Chula Vista.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Chula
Vista does hereb}� find and determine as follows:
Section I. Environmental Determination
There is no possibility the proposed Amendments activity, adopting a General Plan
amendment and Zoning Code amendment may have a significant effect on the environment
because the new General Plan policy and Zoning Code provisions will result in more stringent
requirements for locating an Energy Generating Facility than currently exist. Therefore, pursuant
to Section 15061(b)(3) of the State CEQA Guidelines the activity is not subject to CEQA. Thus,
no environmental revie��� is necessary. Although environmental review is not necessary for the
General Plan Amendment and Zoning Code change, environmental review will be required for
any Energy Generating Facilities that are proposed as part of the conditional use permit
evaluation for that specific project. The City Council further finds that no further environmental
review is required.
Section II.Consistency with General Plan
That the approval of the proposed Council Policy — Electrical Generating Facilities is
consistent ���ith and follo�vs the goals, objectives, and policies of the Chula Vista General Plan
because the proposed Council Policy, in accordance with the GPU, provides clear and
comprehensive requirements for the siting of EGFs within the City of Chula Vista, which �i�ill
help to improve air qualit}', and minimize dependency on fossil fuels and exposure of sensitive
uses to toxic air contaminants from (generally fossil-fuel based) EGF facilities.
Resolution No. 2013-217
Pase 3
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Cit�� Council of the Cit� of Chula Vista does
hereb}� adopt the neN� Council Polic��— Electrical Generating Facilities (Eahibit A) as it relates to
the sitina of EGFs �vithin the Citv of Chula Vista.
Presar�ted'b\� Appro��ed as to form by
i /
Kelh rouehton. FASLA � len R. Go sins
Director of Developmeni Services ity Atto e}�
PASSED. APPROVED. and ADOPTED b�� the Cit�� Council of the Cit� of Chula Vista.
Califomia. this 1�th dav of October 2013 bv the followine �ote:
AYES: Councilmembers: Aeuilar. Salas and Cos
1�'AYS: Councilmembers: Ramirez
ABSEI�rT: Councilmembers: Bensoussan
� l
Chen�l Co�, Iyf _vor
ATTEST: ��
/W 1�.�-�� �J �'V��
Donna R. Norris. CMC. Citti= Clerk
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUt�'Tl' OF SAN DIEGO )
CITY OF CHULA VISTA )
L Donna R. Norris. City Clerk of Chula Vista, California do hereby certif}� that the foreeoing
Resolution No. 20li-217 ���as dul�- passed, approved. and adopted by the Citv Council at a
reeulaz meetine of the Chula Vista Citv Council held on the 1�th dav of October 2013.
Esecuted this 1�th da� of October 2013.
0
Donna R. Norris. CMC. irv Clerk
E�hibit A: Council Policy and associated tables — Electrical Generating Facilites
Resolution No. 2013-217
Pa�e 4
COUNCIL POLICP
CITI' OF CI�[JLA VI5TA
SUBJECT: Electrical Generating Facilities (EGFs) pOLICY EFFECTIVE
nU1��IBER DATE PAGE
Version 3 — No Offset
1 OF ib
ADOPTED Bl': (Resolution I�'o.) DATED:
AMENDED Bl': Resolution No. (date of resolution)
BACKGROUND
The Legislature established the California Energy Commission (CEC) (formally called the
State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission) in 1975 and
mandated a comprehensive siting process for new power plants. The City understands that
the Legislature gave the CEC the statutory authority to license thermal power plants of 50
megawatts (Mw) or greater along with the transmission lines, fuel supply lines, and related
facilities to serve them. The City further understands that it has principal responsibility for
reviewing applications, carrying out or approving projects for power generation facilities that
are less than 50 Megawatts.
Pursuant to Council directive, in February 2010, the Development Services and the
Conservation and Environmental Services Departments formed a working group (consisting
of inembers of the public who were involved with the General Plan Update, Environmental
and Open Space subcommittee) in order to develop policies and regulations for evaluating
the siting of future Electrical Generating Facilities (EGFs) within the City. Through the
coordinated effoRs of the EGF working group, General Plan policies and Zoning Ordinance
provisions were updated and crafted in order to provide the Council, administrators and the
public with clear guidance and regulations for siting EGFs within the City.
PURPOSE
To protect the public health and safety while ensuring that the City does its fair share to
provide for the region's long term energy reliability through the siting of EGFs in an
expeditious, safe and environmentally appropriate manner. The EGF Policy ("Policy")
provides guidelines"for making decisions regarding local EGF sitings that are consistent with
the intent and spirit of an open, transparent and inclusive public process. The Policy also
recognizes the City's commitment to transitioning to a less dependent fossil fuel burning
(carbon-based) future in an economically and environmentally sustainable manner, and its
desire that the air emissions affects on the community be reduced and mitigated locally. The
requirements of this Policy are in addition to the requirements of any federal, state, or other
permitting Agency's requirements or mitigations for future EGF sitings or the upgrade of
existing EGFs within the City.
POLICY
The General Plan, implementing codes and this Policy constitute the Local Ordinances,
Regulations and Standards (LORS) that the City will use for reviewing proposed EGFs
under 50 Mw and that the CEC, other state and federal agencies will look to when
considering EGFs of 50 Mw or larger within the City.
Exhibit A
Pa�e 1 of 17
Resolution ?�o. 2013-217
COU\'CII.. POLICI'
CITY OF CHLZA VISTA
SIIBJECT: Electrical Generatiug FaciGties (EGFs) POLICI' EFFECTI�;E
\'LTIBER DATE P?,GE
Version 3 — l�To Offset
Z OF16
ADOPTED B1 : (Resolution?�o.) DATED:
����DED B1': Resolution\o. (date of resolurion)
The Policy is to be utilized in conjunction with Chapter 19 and Sections 19.04, 19.22, 19.24,
19.26, 19.28, 19.30, 19.34, 19.36, 19.38, 19.40, 19.44, 19.46, 19.47, 19.48, and 19.58 of the
Chula Vista Municipal Code (CVMC) in evaluating future EGFs siting within the City. The
Policy presents requirements and standards for siting and operation of various types and
sizes of EGFs, with regard to fuel types, distances to sensitive receptors, emissions offsets,
performance criteria, and cumulative considerations.
A. Definitions: The following definitions are terms that are associated with EGFs, and used
in the Policy and/or reflected in Chapter 19 of the CVMC as listed above.
1. Best Available Control Technoloqv (BACT): A pollution control standard mandated by
the United States Clean Air Act. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
detertnines what air pollution control technology will be used to control a specific
pollutant to a spec�ed limit. (When a BACT is determined, factors such as energy
consumption, total source emission, regional environmental impact, and economic
costs are taken into account. It is the current EPA sfandard for all polluting sources
that fall under the New Source Review guidelines and is determined on a case-by-
case basis).
2. Best Available Technoloqv (State of the art): The concept of updating and employing
BACT improvements when they are commercially practicable.
3. Bio-fuels: Any fuel that is obtained from a renewable biological resource.
4. Black out: An uncontrolled loss of electricity, generally associated with one or more
geographic areas connected to a transformer, generator or other part of the
distribution or transmission system.
5. Brown out: A planned or controlled loss of electricity for a geographic area.
6. Combined Cvcle Technoloqv: A type of generation that increase the e�ciency of
fossil fuel consumption by capturing and reusing waste heat from one turbine to fuel
another generation source. The waste heat may also be used to provide heating or
cooling that would offset additional energy requirements.
7. Combined Heat and Power: The sequential use of a primary energy source to
produce two forms of energy, basically heat and electricitylpower at the same time
(sometimes called Co-generation).
8. Criteria Pollutants: National Ambient Air Quality Standards for six common air
pollutants: Ozone, Particulate Matter, Carbon Monoxide, Nitrogen Oxides, Sulfur
Dioxide and Lead required by the EPA in accordance with the Clean Air Act
9. District Heatinq and Coolinq: A system for supplying heating and/or cooling services
from a centralized location for commercial and residential purposes in more than one
arcei, usuall from an efficient source such as an ad acent Combined C cle facili .
Eihibit A
PaQe 2 of 17
Resolution No. 20]3-217
Page 6
COUNCIL POLICY
CITI' OF CHULA VISTA
SUBJECT: Electrical Generating Facilities (EGFs) pOLICY EFFECTIVE
NLJMBER DATE PAGE
Version 3 — No Offset
30F16
ADOPTED BY: (Resolution i�'o.) DATED:
AD'IENDED BP: Resolution No. (date of resolution)
10.Distributed Generation: The technology of using small-scale power generation
technologies located in close proximity to the load being served and typically
employed to improve power quality and reliability, reduce dependence on large scale
generation, transmission and the associated impacts.
11.Electricitv Grid: An interconnected network for delivering electricity from suppliers to
consumers, which is made up of long range transmission lines, local distribution lines
and the substations that provide interconnection, voltage regulation and emergency
controls.
12.Emissions Modefinq (Air Dispersion Model): A method or protocol for estimating the
volume and location of air emissions impacts from a potential source.
13.Fuel Cell: An electrochemical cell that produces electricity by oxidation of fuel such as
hydrogen and oxygen or zinc and air.
14.Geo-Thermal: Power extracted from heat stored in the eaRh.
15.Greenhouse Gas (GHG): A gas in the atmosphere that absorbs and emits radiation
within the thermal infrared range. GHG is a collective term for those gases which
reduce the loss of heat from the earth's atmosphere, and thus contribute to global
� warming and climate change. The greenhouse gases most commonly used in
calculations of global warming potential include carbon dioxide (COZ), methane
(CH4), nitrous oxide (NZO), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs) and
sulphur hexafluoride (SF6).
16.Local Service Territorv: The geographic area that San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E)
provides electricity and natural gas services to residential, commercial and industrial
consumers.
17.Nuclear: The use of nuclear fusion or fission to generate electricity.
18.Offsets: A project or activity which results in the direct or indirect reduction of GHG
emissions from fossil fuel burning sources.
19.Particulate Matter: Air pollution that is a complex mixture of very tiny solid or liquid
particles composed of chemicals, soot, and dust and which are generally categorized
as 10 microns or less in size.
20.Petroleum/Fossil Fuel: Gaseous, liquid, and solid hydrocarbons that are burned to
generate electricity, heat or other sources of power.
21.Renewable Resources: The generation of electricity, heat or cooling that does not
require the combustion of fossil fuels or nuclear materials such as solar, wind, small
hydro-electric facilities, geothermal and fuel cells.
22.Sensitive Receqtors: are those segments of the population most susceptible to poor
air quality including children, the elderly, and those with pre-existing serious health
problems affected by air quality. Land uses associated with sensitive receptors are:
residentiall desi nated or zoned communities with existin or lanned residential
Exhibit A
PaQe 3 of 17
Resolution No. 2013-217
COUNCIL POLICY �
CITY OF CHUZA �1STA
SL�BJECT: Electrical Generating FaciGties (EGFs) POLICI' EFFECTIVE
\tiT�IBER DATE P�GE
Version 3 — No Offset
4 OF „6
.�.DOPTED B7': (Resolution No.) DATED:
��fE\�ED B7': Resolution\o. (date of resolurion)
dwellings, schools, child care centers, hospitals, nursing homes, elder care and
residential care facilities that provide daily long-term care.
23.Small Hvdro-Electric: The development and use of up to 10Mw of hydro-electric
power to serve one industrial plant or small community.
24.Toxic Emissions: Toxic emissions are pollutants that cause or may cause cancer or
other serious health problems, such as reproductive effects or birth defects, or
adverse environmental and ecological effects. Under Section 112 (Title 1 Part A) of
the federal Clean Air Act, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has
identified 187 hazardous air poliutants which are outlined in a federally published list.
25.Uncaptured Greenhouse Gases: The percentage of greenhouse gases that are not
already offset by comPlementary air quality mitigation standards and requirements.
B. EGFs Siting Criteria:
Table(s) A through E in Exhibit 1 present requirements and standards for the siting and
operation of each of the five types of EGFs with regard to fuels, operational provisions,
distances to sensitive receptors, applicable zones, performance criteria, and cumulative
considerations. The Table(s) are to be utilized by staff in conjunction with Chapter 19 of
the CVMC (as listed on page 1 of this Policy) in evaluating future EGF applications for
the CEC LORS process, or local Conditional Use Permits as applicable.
Users should first refer to the appropriate Table(s) for the type of EGF (A: Baseload; B:
Peaking; C: Private; D: Backup; and E: Residential-level). Within that table the user
should next find the column for which of the four fuel types are applicable to the
proposed EGF. Each fuel type column for the respective EGF lists the siting and
operational provisions which must be met. The following is a brief summary of the
criteria and provisions:
1. Operational provisions are general operational characteristics expected of the EGF
(however some operational characteristics are required);
2. Distances to sensitive receptors consider minimum separation between the
respective EGF and constituents or land uses that are more susceptible to health risk
from the air pollutants generated by the EGF;
3. Zones indicate the appropriate zoning districts in which the EGF inay be located;
4. Performance Criteria primarily regard facility technology and equipment, and
emissions offsets requirements for local mitigation; and
5. Cumulative Considerations address modeling analyses and public notification
re uirements.
Eshibit A
Paee 4 of 17
Resolution No. 2013-217
Pa�e $
COUri'CIL POLICS'
CITP OF CHULA VISTA
SUBJECT: Electrical Generating Facilities (EGFs) POLICY EFFECTIVE
NUMBER DATE PAGE
Version 3 — No Offset
� OF16
ADOPTED BY: (Resolution No.) DATED:
A111ENDED B1': Resolution I�'o. (date of resoluuon)
In instances where the fuel type is not allowed or practicable for the particular EGF, the
respective fuel type column is designated as such or grayed out. The EGF Siting
Criteria Tables are presented in Attachment 2.
C. Requirements for local mitigation depending upon type, scale and fuels:
Addressing the affects of EGF air emissions on the local community through local air
quality improvement efforts is one of the purposes of this Policy. The operation of EGF's
can produce significant effects on our local community in the form of air emissions and
toxics. The mitigation of these effects are rendered through the requirements of state
and local agencies, and as applicable a projecYs CEQA document. These mitigations,
however, often occur through efforts and activities outside the local community. This
tends to disregard the fact that the local community lives with the effects for the life of the
project. Typical mitigations such as purchasing air pollution credits, do little to benefit the
local community. Chula Vista's position is that mitigation of the various effects of an
EGF on the local community, should frst and foremost be accomplished within, and
benefit the local community. In doing so, the range of mitigations should take into
consideration a broader and more creative set of activities that correspondingly benefit
residents and reduce local pollution. For example, mitigation of air pollution effects could
be accomplished by reducing other local fossil fuel burning activities such that those
pollutant loads are reduced. Such mitigation could include but are not limited to, energy
and water efficiency retrofits, solar hot water and solar photovoltaic installations, electric
vehicle home cfiargers, alternative fuel vehicle rebates, and public transportation passes.
Understanding that in the case of larger EGF's, such as Baseload facilities, the amount
of required mitigation may exceed the capacity or availability of local mitigation options, a
radial approach should then be used to identify mitigations within a subregional area,
and then a larger region. Following is the local mitigation requirement under this Policy
for projects subject to CEQA:
In all practicable and feasible circumstances, mitigations must be
provided for within the City of Chula Vista for the life of the project,
and if insufficient opportunities are available, then an applicant may,
with the City's concurrence, provide mitigations within the South Bay
area and then the San Diego region.
Exhibit A
Paee � of 17
Resolution No. 2013-217
COLi1'CiL POLICI' �
CIT1' OF CHL1.A�'ISTA
SL-B.TECI': Electrical Generating Facilities (EGFs) POLICI' EFFECTn;E
'�ti��ER DATE PAGE
Version 3 — 1�To Offset
60F16
:�DOPTED BY: (Resolution?�'o.) DATED:
�\iE\�ED Bl': Resolution No. (date of resolution)
1. Periodic Review of EGF Equipment and BACT
Pursuant to CVMC 19.58.142 C.13, periodic review of the EGF is necessary to ensure
that the latest technology is applied in order for the respective EGF to perform at a level
that is least polluting. The applicant is required to provide the following information for
the periodic review. The City shall conduct the review and work with the applicant to
render a decision regarding the feasibility and timing of equipment upgrades for the EGF.
A content outline for the BACT Periodic Review Report is presented in Attachment 1.
a. Documentation of the equipment and control technology currently being used;
b. Factual information if current or newer BACT is commercially available and
appropriate for the EGF;
c. ApplicanYs own perspective if it is appropriate or practicable to implement equipment
or control technology currently or within five years, including a cost-benefit analysis
that demonstrates the feasibility or infeasibility of implementation;
d. The City shall review and discuss the information with the applicant and may consult
with APCD, CEC or other knowledgeable sources and paRies;
e. Based on reyiew and discussion, applicant shall determine what upgrades are
reasonabie, practicable and cost effective to implement;
Attachments to Policv:
1. Periodic BACT Review Report Content
2. EGF Siting Criteria Tables A through E
Eihibit A
Paoe 6 of 17
Resolution No. 2013-217
Page 10
E
�T , v� .T��i ��4�'�Y � ' r • ,Y-�`•� .ni5r`y" ' �� .A.
� ��� R Y.j d �'•�iT�YC •.J :. � !1 e � r �i Q
��'P< t� 21 � ��' '��� A °�� '+'� Q
���yT��F• �3 . O � 'I J� Oy �"r��'�' •��W ' , � F
�-"fn A • ° 1t N C N� �i' ^�� � �� ' S
�py�. N .L.- � N j� i ' w+ r� X
Vl�` J �% �?D y L" 'yt i' " W
a a �$� ' '�_ •#+cc3 _
�•C�
'� t x t d ' - U ;�� +` T
c � y _� EO�j - ' y _ _'
E� � �� a a c? _ ;� �� ��„ -, �>
wi.o - . � c ' _ . �,
a< ' _ q p t - � _
~ �'~. Qtu : m L .� :iTd u� �-��� � V�Sln
y o�w •i =a'a° � " .:JE...
IL �+:a�3"o ' o' n D'm' . n. ' ��'� `�,�j,s.`Y° :
LL ;.y? a�.a` '� .a�,y�l'c. �� �9 .az� � �~'' �' ^'..�._ ~�5'
� 1'� �'� ;�a � E 9 . '.T-?�E..: - . �'�'�r'.
Z 't�' a E �
eh�¢'vEi Q' ��� �a'Um R4:^.7A:Z_,e.:._ ��.�,����t='e.'..���
o, o '
c � '+' ` �` l L N L a � � RL '�,
O : S ' c. v = '^_ mm - av
� � ° y o ` � d a° `T' ° y a � �s �a ° E °-�a o
y � `�- a V v 5 " 'o o_ E o L o
� _� � �?� � °� o a �L �c m y� €'
,�rUb � �Ty.' ao �rn � v v v o _�y,� yEj na n� vnc
Q ��'LLS a . . � �u� �aoqrn> �UCO R`mv9 �� y ;
� �'°'� � �'�` =a �� � � � °-' E� o°� � d 3❑ y�� .
JO > a " �� ai�.
r '�.'`��e'�� � y �' a a U F��°a�U a�i; t v �m w¢-'U' v� ,
U �4'm;i' . .. �nU = ^ : °m 'QCC �:�°,o �J =oL °c
U' ��iF "1�� �` i�� n" �'-°d � c E � t° "" � .
Z . F:{�y�.� _aa ' ozmm °= v�N �c `o � �aca�j
F � '�i ' " �o °'�^=? a ai E� a,c cz �Nnw
N .,`�'''�� LL �� � E � 'm E 'o�n°ma5 0 � a � � " m
N I>4 ro� f�Q� �n o�a u �o � v i °°c ��m `�c � o o �
LL, ��._LL �. z a'U ,� A' Ea Ga 5 m nm Ea mi- u nE '�
(� 1'w:�.�. �. v _ � ii
�
W��� m n v c t o '� `c0 a o c �
fn °&i� LL V q ' E 9 �' o �� `�m � E c 3 " o
W C'.x� o ,°^ ? c c _°w _ . u U �,c mc °'a mm �'w-p �,
� � m N rv _ � L N� -y/� N y- C F K Wy p �
J � � d O 3 � R� � - � O -3 O � V y y� � d O E A
-L ou m " c v,"�Ln
g� � �u 'a m h E m y °N � >,- E " � v
U �¢; °'"`n - vaa d sa c = t'U c w wa v'o V m
Q "t P � o �N cm°i � m - -° qa� S ao Rmv$ E� �o
LL � � E� jd � � °-'a u_°� �a` mm E3o°c � � w `� E � E o
C7 �''�- W3.3 E �-° N j0n> >°�= 5ao vn ° � ¢a �
Z �Q ° `v d=c "' l' � _ i'3= w mm ° y55
f '� _ ar `� _ � cyU `m °m 'r� do t � �.°,'?� n 3
Q �3�a: > E h 3 - m m° 'o ' � a v`3 � E o '" m 9 m'y°m `o_
at-. ���' mi U a _
z � „� ° �" ° �s� ra= "�=t�,v "; oc°�ai� o3
W I�" °N � d y �� a a o" =° '� d � a a �'�w c W v °c
U' nim � � E o -�'n ' E o °m v c ' a� � o
J � oo nm� ° o `m tt °'o =nu'° 'o° �8€ o � va
Q ��z�m '0 3 `m ��� �aU'w v Ea � 5 m cm Eo �`w- 5 a
K � � $ � u- E
r ° '° m tLL'J
U � �� �-` u'v i � = u ' N w v m q°o ��n w
W o a � m E -O �'i ° m t m �- � m S a � N- �
J r� - � y ='m��v U °' - '° " ° _`o° `°F ,q�8 �
W ;�o � `° � '-�° m a a `° o °-� o a � a �c � � b E m
°l¢� ° w o m 'm °� a � y ` . _ w c
Q "Ec m3'n `- �� ccdw 3o" "'a �� cut w �v " oo'�,°-„�
yy, o y „ _ '° =� '> `mv�� $m o � °oE= no
O -� 09� jv� � a# n °-'a m� �a `m °iE3o°' w v °v � E� E «°o
fA �:m+° o� m N �a�U � �i� `t w � .�va"�°-, N �dt
Q� cga _ END � =np5 ' vm� v5t >'`v,o am � �'n'^ �a3
' ��q � � m _ p ° a�_°`_ � 'wE `o_ � mov�vo
Q m aa� E o �ad y Tm '° d°� L �� � o� a� v �
W .m�E c L m m c � c - �v _' c _ �v a c w �.`
J a?�i4o` m � °' d -O o o'-°- i v E � � �
m �"� 5 0 0 '�- E 'o° � mT� oa°nac y �SP� vu
a �y^'�{' o ° om o ° daTO° ovt om v°
7 I q ¢d � L E C L �V t
F s-_"�..'LL�r O 'o 3 m o� ca'U� d E a 6a5 'm 6`m �Ea �h n� a
Resolution No. 2013-217
Pase 11
. O_ ��_'. .x�-i+ir'�bY.r-`^�4^�^� _ T_�z-_ _= .J.zi%�. �.�=--C�t:n�L� _ � .�.
-'- ��.�^�a'�� ��'��J. i`� _ _ _�'�L'�'_..����+'.�a�-'y��' .���_'� .ui' N
` �:' _�..� ��� ��- '
T �iF � � _3C C _�^T����.���<� - � ��� �
x• o= �_r ' � � ' O L V a�.^_u.=^: ' ��- O
rCa -v_��r � � � � �• � - C
��."���' �V�
-'�����±��_.����� " U �� -��_..�-�-=„;��'�--ti - _ �
G -- _ �'-..x.-^-- - =
;_c-. '� "V_ _�.�'- �.+ ���Z' Q
: c ' ����.:--��v��k'���=-� `,,' � _
3 a_' - . " .' �J-•>,= =_c:� ^f_�.v�� Q
_ o
F, __cL` _ _ "�: a.,_�x m _ � i� ^ _ m�� '_ _ ' '° =
W ' yJ�_�_ r � ? ' i�-s s- °'S�'_` --_- W
-,� °
} _ o� .
z-._
LL _ .x ' I , ec" = V: �-'�_ --x...: `�` _3
� o�m�_. �. r c- = �;.: �_.__-_.._�-�-y ' _
QLL '-:.mE-_'' R,_ - ° � �a�^ :��,=�-�-� ' _
V�'E` _ - _ ¢ Y". � c o �.-� �"�c'c�"-��'•
O - w�'� ,: � " _ _ _ 'tiT� _
" '�•:"�� .
ZG' �:.�4-=,. - ' '�'a- _° -° �'F��V ��-
�Q_- rY Cg.CG,� r. G - _ -��:_
(+� �Z� � �_ _ y �m ��X��s3���,. ,y- �
'a� �1«._. ¢.. � L O � �,. .- '
C �G r�+._��.�,s� •�,: _ �� " = =c e �y_�i.-�. """ � ' � _ �
yi O J�"'3,_i^' � S _ ♦Y = v � J`='y',�v� L � ' ....�. �
C..�L'_...?�c� � C �E _�IG' G'�
C1 R¢_��-:c�^'k'EZ'r'�$'���5= �c n m �T==:+t z`�.�- _-+a�_�>[�'Z�=
� y� a. . � - �
� - � O CJ . � p G N
Q Y�(� � � T O O = U T � L
-��1' � ' T J f ; C 9 O m �
� :�� C V V J � � V � y�= _ � C N j O C� 3
W �"f�-� C V q C O P q p C � C � y � � p
�
F ����'U C N N F � C V aj V r � m N � n O C c
� 'r+ � L O N N O C U O O O� � L �' U ya O 7 -
U :�� O C O � � � � Q P V � � � p �> O N � � O y - � O O
' � N � P `J � �U m O- y � � � ` O � �� n � > U
(' i:. f ?n ��'=' _� ° C a� � C q m n = � u � f o t�i� �m c�i o
� �= E O > .o o c c = ',U?LL F L
Z i�- _= 'r = c U f n � - o 0 oac
H 3.:.'���'-' c o - ' �c� c . = c � =-v 5 - � r c y< �u cLLU
�/� " m o o a'-aF� � c � U o c a » 0 5 c y � o o °_ =, p n u
v/ 7�C UF . d � ' O OU � V wL � C� O �
��O V O - - U O = V U � Q � C � 0 7
$-�Z .. C _ N � C _ U �a ?.en � o � 3 c- ._
� > C ' � y T G�. p = p b -C� =
__ LL wc'f'o m c ? ? " " cE yEU ° 3 � $ a ; - °
(7 d�ai ? � , -0 � a o o - a ° o o = �c ° -y o
�--- � c ° .�_ � E ?? ° o o "= = ^ _- Eo omN c+
W w�:°o � c `�?� � o � -= c v �' S � c o °-' c°� o� o �°o
(/) � r�u p y a_Z_.__ �= U 'w ' ° - n ° U.� 3 c = E i o- o c� �
W "'_se�
+<?G- c a
L_ _N�i G U O O O � � _
. 4 C � O c _ � C _
J '� 9� C ` O � . � }� C C 7 O P � O �
U _:� otH � ' E = o � � c oU.°_ ' � � o o c5 3
- Q �C�� ° 3 m" ° ' ° ° ? � u ' � 4 n �= 5 �' � � °- °S c = E =3
3C,m�. � o 0 0 ; f _ u - a.� m o
LL � ^`-' H o � " a tn m o '-�` - m' vmi c = �n � � ^° o c c a � u o _ ii
� ...^ �` o E � 'n a . - c c °v °' � ° c F o ��_ � a a � m_ �c+ c
Z � E;T ?°_ ca � o`V ° _ r v'> � Sa 'u5c ° - yw- oc
$ ° - ?U o �: o 0 o a ^ o n o c � �
~ �"W� � E ' ° ° ° �' c0 n] �� o � '�3c o V� _° H � _ ..'
T C U f t�o � o > c o o'C =
� YQ$ ^ � � N � o � _�.� C .U� °� `� ca. � 4u�i� � 'J' c �t�
�1J 3`c = u�o ° 3 - _ = °OUS c = c oa° c c op ° u =- ' 9 c
���v� C > � O .�. Q _ O C � C m � C L V � O
Z : O.� >i C " � O O C _ U y � � = C O � C � C _ � N
W '.P•i'Il'�'�'. � J m r O O C O _ � v y p, t'. 'V O � O ; N c � r
I!� 3 •� �; > O O 6 � C. _ ^ '.J O ^ L N U'✓J 3 9 U - '3 � �
V • q�� .• C V j T N � N U
., 0• O, O � _ : O O p � � � O� O � O O p C r "' p '� q C
J Y � � � .�. C O O V O y � F j � O A _ V
Q `�`'C� �= � _ ° a � -° ° `'f E � _ ° m r. `o . 5= � o = = $ = o
U -P cg � � o c o o � � E c y a - c>._ - ° `m o o =a
3 0:°_ n ., o` o > o 0 o r� � c m n r_. ° u o c `-' ° y o
=Ta qe :V; ? E - ' = Um � nnE > oU3 °_ - - oa� -
� T T' ^ 'r' '
O U
H :` ==F en 5 on - = n _ ° mc � °- c
W �.:'m ooN cn`+ 'V-' E " -° � a o = = � w u o c� 3
J � - c � °o = a =' 'c - � i = - -� '__`- 3 '�o�e - _ c o = o c
± c � 'U ^ c y - c _
lll _ �.c e o ° `oo c � = c n`� c _ �; � c - o ' _ =
� ="3:m ° 'm ° a_ ; _ = m E = �0 3 � °tn _ n '-' =' ns'�
Y c x �n ° v� o i _ � E � p ,� �o o_
Z � �- � C CG a � _ � � P U = 0y0 VW ^ �IUJC__ OJ
_C O ` T V a m O �. J _ p � y � '
Y '_ oc= �m =c a p �yy`"�{ = L d E � ° _�� o ci o =" g S ^ c� � _
W `�o.° '3 °i o _ � _ � �I c 4 j p ,. � a � r o c �� o Q ; -V, c _�
d c'c o ° o ? c ' = o U- N U� o = i n _ ° w � = J c n m
i "- v- o o= o : 3 - -- .5 = o o = c o = r ° � = v 'o _°- - °
O > - U -
='O ; c � C C � � � U� � U fi U � ` C n .'� C � � N
� 4 m.� - ' 'J O = .�. . G y c L _ C ^ C 'T � = = C j
• - -C � �. C ^ � y�j C � O� G C � ^ N 1� � fi
_� W �r- O�� �; > O � . .. O= �� O N ` _ _ O ; U � � 3
J _. ii>� co o V- r, a o _ 0 = ° o c °u'� - = � - : -ac � � �w- �
Q .20_` � � � = _ c � � �o �� Vn : = ca> ^J3 cc --' °_ ° � q �
F - LL-1- n.'1 C T, c -
Resolution No. 2013-217
Page 12
' °-" " ' ' ' _ ' '" ' ?a+-. - _�a:� a�� '.
":. _ -.���a.:-_ ':^"_�, Jf':..lfa i `�;�"r+i�.�s, � O U -U o ' � � _ """ �.���^�y':
- -. J:��;'.i?Jn��r:-.,-..n_..__ , � _ _ ''°"-_ �
' �taF.•.::z'<_ LF�ik�_,:.T,�__: �:- �:Jt?�. �U U F e U � o o!� c -�z.y-''-_
'�.y.' c.`�c..r _ �alc�'_"'• 2s.� v�-" � �o`n '^ m . �i�'-� _ "F'f�
, =���:.._�.c - '- '" ��' ga3=-� o �_U » a - c
_ _ _ ��Y
�i� � t o00 }�
��'' '`��� � � „'' _ Y' ,�_� ' ` E
�.E���. �_. '�c�� ` �.�, '� Q p u u � �_ ��= .P..°Y='�". �� -- ;_ ;
... y �..:�,��i"'y""?�'� �c,'� ' E `v E t m m �' _ , -"�"-- u "
>;..L�.�� _r-,. �_ " � = a-' = �`- :
�m�'�gv .-��r_. =�- ' a '° E E p-' = v a d m- �c '.! �
~ c �-%:.:_.. -"l� ��`ai�S°�r.. . ..�"" "i . w�U U N �m = c m�i � 6` v ' , r- .:�
:.or. .�._ �y � • _ _ a= � � _" r
�a -ro:._ � � ° m `� I
:� t°`-�,.c.�-� � 3�.. a -.,ss�L,.+x `T�� m o c m `n 2 n m E 2 o y E �� � M `a �.
r__ ._ - • . m ° = P _ - ' •
�in���c'- "r�,�5-i:�.,� s�=-s✓'7,?. .�:':?:;.� �''_- �a`�.a�a c ` n m= `o� U �iE� ' _ .t .
°.t�i `-�i.:^.Xt'.� -'.'�C5 _ ' u - - , _ m z o� = D`m E n °`o '- " ...�^ i
_'�'.A:°vrE.'�='12-�< s����t��-�S'���g�� i-�- a mU L n � � � � � � �' - K,��c''ig I
_°�-. .ey��..3s_ y`-�.c.��^-",�r�r�__. u_q r '= ��E c °' a' ' �-
�i°a�'S�_F2�'v-s- ` F?� .v'�,5"� �E=� � 0 3 c o `a m E ���"-. -�-� ,
;_ :Ea:.�`a.�ecs'"_.�� :.� ��c.: - J � E U m: °: � a �'� � �-�-,c_..�,�
:j_W..°l:.�. �G�xe��..yy;� .a r. N �•G p '
z �]'�-.��:ay`'�ic.'c.,.-�•n.�g'M'_� -: ' � =E o-a a m o y 3 v � i�%�":'�i� :��
r o���+"—T'-s---.x • '�'X 'r ,9`�`��s, -'°c¢U 3 y - >u�m c a E � .�'a. _ :
..c_l:s ?k-i". � i,.
� r Zv..'3�� ' �'-_a.c�ik_s`_�: 'ay �a� E C d ° E `m o a '°`_"� -�. '
=a..b r''""�"i�.a''"'���`. �: �. .. . -:+s. .c, 'Y o c N � ; c .'. ,� �
�Rf�'�$��-�i�� °^� °c a t° E _._ m S u N ��'
C ,�i�u'�Y'�.'i���^'.,^'��'r' "�-.�e-'��i� -°'
O '4' ���b-.?"§' tn'__ . �� c°U E d� m 9 c m m� ,��-«,����-: - ' !
eFC�`�?-c.^ti?�_�i}£_-r-�;-=, �.*' "�.� z �.� o � `o°-- o n= ..n. _
=9: s�Y.c�'e-e-c.-_-�" 33a.S�l e... w= "a o - ... ._s'�z. cv�_
N c:v sv �=T�. >Cu ¢.�.�g o n t a m L° - �¢��-�,-:,y� I
`41 `1 LL'iW�=.�e.���%.Pi`'�.'�Z'�?'Fau.-!'."rlr-'i����Z-'f?`:u._ 3.^.� N d Z 5 Q U � 4 n � L '�'�-`fi'Y`3Z'cY'.'yP4�., I
p� � I
v ��=L O 0 C d U j � T d U r—n ' C�U 1
��� - m `a c __�a _ GnH � " A . "a a �u�t, E - �av __
Q �{,�� o °o � m o _ � v u = - °o E E = �
� T_.r��vx.. L �3�= L � 3 ° N d�v o a � = m U _ P� � a '"E- v � o D V E o c I
W �} S �mc ° �_°- on° � o >� c° ? c � _ m o� m' mU d_= E n � N ° � d °m .
F- �� ` o, o o -- v� 9 � '" Opn� > -` �=�= 0�'ac ` o °aai � E � u�� ° �.
�V 'c0. � vm° __ u- o o � °u0 �'a= � Ea° EwDV u Uu '> o'�a5 w o°O n�;�o E
I.L ���dY = L � � v�i � � ^�� LL U O
U ����. UE �OC � 6^� Od y �dNOG �9m� OC' Q 9C� 66> ON � � V9au� 6�
(� �� LL.' t¢ � O j m O N eJ y C� ` F /�l C u� Q.�U O �U N o u �a L � 6� ..L C.O V(�t
?�'. xoo ` � e �, � `� yinay -° �aZ.m� E�N �a` m.__= n �= c'ooauw`aa ;
Z a;a`? f Eq `y viN �Eo 3 �a vaw = �a0'Sq�a rv o �°cNwv vs � °-'�yc°vv� ;
Fd �=�� mm_° m'oy _ v i `mm"' Ay _ VUaU � n _ . G =� � C 1° E _9 ��E° .
:t m_ 5 n o _ m _ _ E � °E'o o r E d U_¢E� `�° u q_ � L o � � o °'a m a o�<$
� . E'c9 .> o_ -=-0 � = `o�c u _ _ n m ma o " m ' E � d o - � vm "� o -^ �
�:30� oa=dc " c �.'o � n � n�_ =Z°Ro- aC `�- "o oc-ygy � I
Z,� m c = u a E��'� c t Q o 5 n t 'Q y 2 O U `w U U " - `o a o c a ,
N �:��`'-'-a aEt°' o -'._LL _° n `°= ' : �m_ E_a5 °� r°n-O" o°_.ro � Ut m �va_� ;
o �
' LLai�_ -`�c-c � °Ry � °9vnou �°co _°c � o'� oa � o ocoE �'cU �p i �°_ mo� ; u �
gr °- c m°m = ' O'" U ` '�^' � m °=a� °_' v ° c m o w° E'x
.. I W ��imy � i � U~ °='m9 `mv °� u�°- E � � E Eaim o °cmmm `.c��N -�= �L � ,� �
.. :� . m y n=-5 'o _ E°nv �v a`o E� Eoa"' t� _-°'��>>5t� d �°o"' mr �
(n �cni ` a5 C'n _= °H o �oa m m°� � �a a`USU A a P: En'vU 5 3 E5 Ew5 cu ;
W z� � � � m � = _ " � � � m � m -
�O N 9 O d d A _�
J '�_�E?c• �°m3 -� dA on m °1 � ° `m9 � ' v U Kdp ° -°"° °� `v nu " n"' Eo E�a '
'ovx = c uc ��9y � � ° �°a o � v :�oU w 'of aE� `�U `-�L o0 y � v= ��
V �ai%`.mL^ a y ° o _ odFc `-0c �' � � � :> u� � 3� Nd ° o � y . �
N �
Q _".+.. 5 amc __ o� 'o ? '-°� o A = wL 0 '�O maU � �5 c '' � °d� y= oa
LL i.,o� � m m v c L t " ;-� ! N a m U_°� a�E a E ��U e E=u� �- E � � W °� ��E�n E �
(� �,q y noo � v � c cEo� . �a o _°-'t � '° '
." u E o°i o m ° y� Y E vi °G a °-' m -¢.o+o `o_U-° m '>d � o s E y °-' p u: ` o '
2 :4'Ea i` %a'me'� cai ' _ 'o ° oc� `m'6o d zUr `mam � oH °°v �9c y " U?w- C
F '=iw`d�„ dd ` c '" d = ° C�aN� °� EO " m E a`' u� n_ a o v °¢-a vn
Q . , ' E � m d m �'o a m a q c J a��s m�a �i'+ ° w ° m= ` `m °- u 5 = - -
� „¢:r _ - `°° o °_ _ � y � " _ UdU � V Nv_ ? cc � ,
.�;:_ m c w o � ' a y a a � F � u o E �E _- m U m� E� `u c n a o n m p a g t��E °
W xieP" '_?� - -- � °' o ; _ d � ' Em cn °- _ d � � v - o � c
�; o = 'c c " - na_ � a�Z��1=o - �`-� cc ocv3y000
Z e,`k�'` m°c- i v E � a � 'ac5 �� 1O �aoU UU '" G ` y�y- d � -� _ ,
IJ,J 'v=i"..'�._ a E � n E c >.o E _ � � ° o y' d ._ _ E_ _ o m m 3 ° '� u u =°m
� =pXx o m� ov _ u m �O�'o - o°o '�° " m°co � � oao u � on = "-°' "5°' "L > 3� `n°o n,; >
_ c -
J �'o:m ��x� w� n � `� -' � a�,-.rvm � �, EUEm'm €omu��o � _ 1° mL `oVm " V .
a.�1, _ _ - _. @ v o a _ � E �`�-� a v - � c o v t v v .
Q �c.� y � H ��ia E - E2 n`mam �° oE -L-° c.aa�n tr� yuam 'r_- EoLL �FLOLL ,
(.J �Zm `o��'� '-J" '?H m °u � wac w n°� � �12e`USU m �r' a °_' nn�ES o°U § �' U E�Srv o cw
Q. �t"�' ao � _ " _ - ` c ,"- ' w
F t'-` o � c = - g °- ` q -c v °- m d d �- _ n '
V �� � v3'° " _ m " � Od a ' � _- " � ''-n ° � �
W . �v:m _ _ = d _- -° 5 � m�v o � V _�U �� d t�c n v c n° E c�'m a �
J xy`�'2 c���o -'nu5 � urv n c '-° � u qm o-� m = v> °mEc '�` 3 y� m°w � N " m°u . �
W � c"o '> _ - °a o �: N c `o !� m 'm�t a coa U c m'n dL � >: . $ �`oc oa �
W ��im D� ° oi i m � m- � n �°+o �y > c � ._� 5 E- �= �= E �d u o� N��v n o i
�m..� - _ . v _ '-�'s3u . a Upo c' E°cE �rn�UC � u- oi- c .' E ,� nE i
Q �rc'So GE �d co u �" m �Ca _ D¢ ao °-�-' ° .9-a �-O 'uc- c � u ° 9oii m `o_ :
°1:oiE ^.x°°a o'N v� y m o E " u�ip°.� o v 'ZUF ca N � ° y `d o� Ei - '�U uw_ x i,
� s U30-' �' � v m �' .�'om U ",°-h °�°nN JO "° E �, dL "> naaa a �� ¢-� ° y �
� a" -o ^ E � � vm = �a � -n u9 � � VOCs�'ca rvomo m > q �m � � � cc� �
�^.:a= � od . 'm 'o? � mv " UvU � � .UN �_= ° � � Ec � � c ,
. d :a_cya _ vH� _ = v� c " Ena E - U-¢E dio n m < F '_ ° Em :
� a.Eh' _v �_ _O = -O ro ; '�' °iO ` md -a ` '.j ' Em _ ' O� ° �� »� `mt 'o.3 = i
..Y �O U 9 'L N N j N L 6 9 �. ] � �Z 1- O " D - N v C L 'V. �y > i
- V �.ro�o ` c n c ' >`o E '� o c'i o ' '� ' S m a0U EUU � � o Na �= a 5 oca m_ `c �a9
' W � ' - o ' o u °' �a "�' o � � � c u o A m t ° 10 � _ °' u y > �m -o." m
. °.E - �_ ' o m r c o m [ � L _ � o � o v o- m = c � N ; m
� m '=LL H N N"x (C'J 90'H °�u�j C �.E N L �� j v� U U ` �j � � E � O C y� �'y °I N� � %N V •
. Q �-� N N �CLVp yvEaU mY � JOHOaj� OL � �u��i��� 0 j0` IOFmULL
N ��LL��= Oln m'a � __ �i c o vo ° o �a'e`o>o � a = nE> ocS 3 v Eu ^ - ;�_
�
I
Resolution ?�o. 2013-217
PaQe 13 �
YA= =_�.--:r��-�_��-- ��=-�_�__ _ ==°- = : _ �:�,-- I
:�.�>=.r-_ _ -- __ -�<_ �-°-' __ __ I
- �� =- - - --�- _ � - _
j == _ - - _ =:,t = �"'� - - _ � i
- ` ' �� ` c _ ' 'c 1
N� ^^ .�°'t =C C C tl �c.t V I
v` = e �
_ � G '
p J G� <
_ ��. "v'.-� - - �• = 2 v c ' ' - ' <
_ ' � _ _
- _ - T � - _ _ - ° o�_- •�`^s- - - _
N_ �.Y- _ - �- ?Un
.'���'` �e- � c Z O m � W
9�i��_-� - _ = t U B j� -
�"� + �-� ` ` � � �"'� _' _^.,�..
. .- E _ _5,__U _ _��.-A-
C u '^-�-,� � _s _ =L.°�� __-� =w c_°u = c �s�-� _ `—
p �� __ -x. =cccca - - - -.
- ��. "�� c�`..Es'-n�'.=..�.f� 5<U = - o - --��'^
� �o- - -_ ' :"�?tr� _-g c°ci o �.x -i' _ I
a '_ ' q� $ . ..�_ '
� _ •nK+ - �. ' �f' _ _ _"' - � � L 8°__`_° - ^. ^+Ea. ?'�?� s �
Q � ..,CE ,.-<x_'� �°_- °� ' ��'-- " I
� `c�, .�—z� ._ N°=z°> t- _
� `��" � 8 '8 ` � � � ° o � m � �m �
_ � ._�+ � o t ' : ` oac :° = - c-` ' I
°� z E R
� -•��.-. � 8of �� a_ ->� OCU fr Lo-oo>� e� ya �o$ �
Z ='E � a -'8m �� _-g° `� ° - on� aea qt �8 �° o i
` � cc = _ P $ o_-K_ � ° �o_°ig� wcEoP �
F_ o~c: m c- -`s°� o ?_ c e5 e = ' �.. p
fA �t�"rt n :, oc8av= �=4>=°r o°- oc� `_= :cc'�ce
y-ve�.i�5 0 'omrtc.-:E o�_9=0�0 _ c a' Hce �c-AOco I
LL -Ta: _ `�e3 ' `ou- �-�.2 = 0� � o c E° O�= gac45$°o�a"
(� �-�c�c � �_�nc � c ��O'? o" c ' >n �>= c�.o ° E � ��`v �
^U
W �6 L o 'c c c e_`n o_ -e � o �U 5 a c m o��o A . - �e �
p L m c E ?=G c�c yo�, -=c ° o 'o g�m �3 I
F z" I ��o 0 o S`� _c�_ 'o� 5g° � '�'o_r'�a°, � �E °v o E u
_' J i� ° °- .i c$ � n�s $ a�o i>E e a= ? � ° ° E o� �_`_ E¢�° g
-� Ur wc �= :,_ ., °__ � � �° ° BBo � m` -'_
Q ��cF d c �.`, _°a`5 E u°_��?-U n - °e uc:US Em° c�a3o° =3
LL w o`
"✓ L�` _ ^- - E ? `oo = °cp °w I
U' t;= ^"- `LR ' 8 5 H =-t c
Z �� 8= 0�=� _ Bc = � °o cnTT `�� =°o
F" 9 D ' �C O O y j� O v� �L � � — } p Q p
� �L �� C � � C r��n C o c L m p
R' � c�` � `°�3 u e _ c�o _ c __ p S� o e o-a° _� �o E�=j<? o
W °� ° � `=��° o on e x � c°.i�� c o A �ce o '-P'' °t e°-°oc° I
Z m�._ " ' 000� _ g ° �, ,, _ oz �� b_' `_ `o' _T� ` � � n ` �
f7 aT��-°' = °aBS� � a" noSL � ==�=c €a `c0000°o'c u° 9=��
c 'o �
J ,.�°°: `� ��� � n° c��'� _ `a° o�'`H o � o°° � � °c� �B � EB I
Q F E - = `�-O 3 ° c o E _-' F o� €°- _ 0 3 6°- `_ 'c c '�°-_= E�� E
}n c aa= `c''n .. - `- Eo 'c°- - -c»
3.°-�_ = „ o - ` N �
V <[ -tl ` �P� a� o .,y " S �opag�m > �Sce`€ q - �T
� r.s__-�s; =q 5`-_� E� .'-, � �_�° `_ _`- 3�-o U� d`t -t = =g a�`o�-� "py � �
W K•�•'o�E L7$2ca�F= c �cppygn '�-.�<e.C..V c��j gema �guQ �P�BoY�t I
J �' c = p�_' .c�E-'__ co�o�'c5 Go~ c �c c d _ ws'
W ee -°° e � ° ° ° `�� E m �' -� E 'o E o E S s E 5�-o �� n e o=o
� ��:� 9°oc= "" = oEo°X� E ��ac � E' ,�a °=_ Uvi E_ a �= E `o
U �.�'z°I a°: �=�oE 7` o`�o`= v°c�3i��t�.°. c`7'c_ i�c�=°=_° '�so- "a $8
Z �. g t �. o p • ., u - .
� �o� o ?T `� o'�-' = ��0 5'g _ o� F _ c>T� = ot' _°w
W ��'-s°� a� c �� o =� o c a ° °�' ?� ° o c ° m � m &o 0 o m g
� _�'. ' _� c o s c `' - �, m o_ ' _ ' �- � ` - _t�
� �F = F E a 5 ' n �9`m o - '� > �-° i °c `-c v a� E : �� o
W �`: - ry� g � - � r��oo =w�� -- -� � ���_
al � _ �.�0 3u °i°"s `° _°ei-�; �`_ ��I o ° � -' � 'o �_
a � ae c_ otli 'co �Eo o °oo � oom8' c� o
j °� icc �= ��E-�o =° m�a8 = `q� _ =a � - �U° _-o= -°-
Y .c� =S T''E j °u � °- �E ° c L� >- _ c u c:� . F o°_`s s °v in �6 �'L m E 8
(J == f'o�. R- c 'G' t,ec _° .,�._°- 3c ° r_ -c c�?- $= s o sE ° o �= ��- o°c E
ffi�y _0507 � ^ _ ' - => o=o � - _ - O
fI1 r�a= __ _=8n nc o° Wc wO�Og � �U a. j� �> og oc `o -°.�F u`-��
" cFO �=' _=_ - �_- �c ° Ey =cR> c`�" �c -c_ `u o�=nA
� - E c uo S o � .�_ -
0 0� u-= cR^ES `'an °' °9O ^�' = °< V`�`> 85 g'u "q c5 EQc
''E�= ' 0 `_ 9-° ""�S`ooam $ _=8 � ��.�."�z�'a y �,€ o
( ���'' J �=-z °'�"' ^; = __ c'.o�=5° � Nom_9c5 a 'o . o�asc ?_ � " ��'
�,.. 0] ;=- �o== eS = m` �' coo= O `�'y '` ° E ° ,�� n_=�u�i 'ca ° ^ E �
Fa" _ - aa ` @3`_ u�° �nao - J'-�^�c�i-,5 �- _vo"=o_ ['a3 `o="_ c8u i
�
- _ . _ __ ' _'_ _ I
Resolution No. 2013-2ll- ',
Page 14 �
a: �-
�
�� y{-w r =�. = I
�.a s .' F V �'" . E
��� U � > �,'� ` I
E 3 E d r� i
��¢� U -?'? � o,_ �� ''d& - Q �
M ���?v'. o . �_: m ` o U '?� _ B I
c w o U o ¢F°�°Q",.'�C,�"� a I
C 2.0� 7 yY� � �� d C ?'Y L
O �iN 4 e.Z ' � - R n �• �'•, W I
� �� (rc � - '?a ` � � uz �
d wo F}�`: � w `-' �°c� � �q i
� z Q� .� P?.' - :O,_� _E a ' �
.o°-' .. Y d�w S F_: �" �
Q �=o� � a C T G �,.} _ $
� . � u vmi R� .f f av.
W �N= �^ . 3'- K c c v a j 'c�T-''k �
� ` = li� .
C:�Gm r m � �° `-- �� � I
�' �;�ol:y ��.� �a¢ E °' r „. A '
f7 �'. � -" U y �= r
Z �� � E � -a ��.�
� N LL
~ U L � �¢ � m T�(J .�"y,.�;� f
t!� �3vr. c-°y �-�� in m E> �� � I
N �'d '=- � 1 -� oU ��Fn
� �� � N_9 �.�4 ¢3a� � I
� � � a �� -. om ` �� �
��1e _ . c m ` •::� i
W @1 � o A q _ m n �`_
y' H - n
¢M` � d�C�� _ G n Zo: p
� �Y�'a c t� a� -� W �o . 1��"
W ��..m.� � c� o�''_.�'��`; c0_m e�`�a3�' �
F C�f 0: LL a �i � t� �p R: �
J '`'"i'�'?y ` r N y�' � a c¢o _ x� I
V ���i� ^< Eo�� C °u °u oe ��II' � I
LL w�'„� -„ m_�^c'�� 'y=m ��[r�,� e' I
� ��u°iqr' u53 �` �'-'CE``'�, 5 �:
Z w�� �C _ �° "�:� '
~ LL,., � �. . --�� ,o: �
g� �,u�
� 4 o°`k' `=��a .���� a �
W ��m � �.o ; n: �` �
,Y'-- a�SCZ - 5 a,--'+ [c,�F
Z �c -c ' �� ��a.c� I
W o'
+`� ' °3"' -o �
� :��o� u� �� �Z . �
Q ��w� Z a .' ��L''SG° ' ,
2!. mm - ' �'*Z
U �iQ�'�. i�: .•� > v .. � i
� �o'_ �- ': �,0. £`i��� ���; � I
i��� .,,�,p
W �2 �-`�'��'ty _ �o��'o�.ri',e��� � �!
W '�"O��^- � e- '�'c''�- Z''�'s$r � E � j
� �`=,3�� "� ���-�'� 3� ���� � �
W z�m
W �rL�,gK., �'C¢kr:�' -�1`_� "� � .�
J �:�. -'' �c�3`�S.�F ��� � �
Q ��-u� �' `���v � v '
F �:'=S-'a ��" ' .rz= ��io i
^ifo�m � . �..��•_ :
Z �m:��a`" � r.._= . _.� ¢ �
Q ;y;�:p AaJ'j �� .x,- ' ��°-�2 �
Y�•G�Y], Z`�� � t Y� '< .�� I
� ��o���� S � _ .zx ��
W �`�i �� �
, � ''��j!��d 'a�'-� "vr' `""" = �
LL1 �m'�_`o ���.+; c �__.' I
W �.._ �>:._ � < � ;
:s.-o�E a . i o l�q:� r�
, �/�l W�LL4�� � d �? �''� i
W ey=q � C...�_^�-�.. �� Csi
1ro u.� '.3+ '_ �`�__}"�x?' j �.
f- 'dILL�H+_ �i%'w���- : T�G=. � ' �
�
�
I
I
Resolution No. 2013-217 i
Paee 15 �
�`��/ :
� �
�.�-�- '
CHUI�.AVIS7A Development Services Department �
I
ELECTRICAL GENERATING FACILITIES (EGF) �
�
PERIODIC BACT REVIEW REPORT CONTENT i
(EGF PoGcc) �
�
A. INTRODUCTION ;
(
A Periodic Review Report shall be submitted pursuant to Chula Vista Municipal Code section i
19.58.142 C.13 and section C.6 of the Council EGF Policy. The purpose of the report is to �
provide relevant information on the EGF unit and latest best available control technology �
(BACT) that is commercially available, induding a cost-benefit analysis to determine whether '
any BACT upgrades to the EGF unit are feasible and warranted. As outlined below, the i
content of the rePort should include description of the existing EGF unit and its control i
technology, the latest BACT and its commercial availability, cost-benefit analysis, and
conclusion. It is important that the report be thorough and comprehensive as possible in i
addressing each aspect, while remaining simple, succinct and cogent (should be no more �
than 10 pages including supporting graphics and tables). Please indicate and label all �
information in the repoR that is considered "Proprietary and Non-Disclosure°. Please contact
the project planner for assistance, if needed.
^ j
A total of three (3) copies of the Periodic BACT Review Report shall be submitted to the
Development Services Department, Planning Division. �
B. REQUIRED CONTENT OF REPORT I
Below is a summary of the content to be included in the report. !
i
I. Cover Paqe
❑ Name of applicarit and contact information !
❑ Project name and location �
❑ Name and contact information of person/firm responsible for preparation of report �
❑ Date of report submittal
II. Table of Contents
III. Introduction
❑ Purpose of the Periodic Report — Describe the co�laborative effort between the City
and energy producer to pursue BACT that cost-effectively contribute to public health I
and safety improvements in local air quality. Explain that the purpose of the report is �
to provide necessary factual information regarding the subject EGF and latest �
applicable BACT equipment that is or is not commercially available, to determine the �
cost-effectiveness and feasibility of providing BACT upgrades. �
-1- Eshibit�, .�,ttachmentl ' �
?J6 Four,h Avenue � Chula Vis,a I Caliiornia � 91?10 � (619) 697-i101 �
i
I
(
,
�
Resolution No. 2013-217 '
Page 16
i
IV. EGF unit and control technoloqv beinq used �
❑ Location — Describe the location of the EGF unit(s) and its surrounding context I
(address, entity utilizing the unit, area which the unit is located, and purpose of the unit,
(e.g. residential, commercial, industrial or mixed-use)).
❑ Type of unit(s) — Describe the unit type (name, model number) and features, fuel type,
APCD and/or other permitting agency permit number and date of permit issuance, and
control technology being used.
❑ Provide data on emissions control technology currently utilized, including the e�ciency
level of the unit(s).
❑ Provide baseline emissions for the unit, emissions average for the last five years, and I
the latest full year emissions. This information should be already available from the
local, state or federal permitting agency.
❑ If there are multiple unds (i.e. redundancy), provide the above data for each unit. �
I
V. BACT commerciallv available— appropriate for EGF I
❑ Provide a listing of commercially available BACT that could potentially be used for the I
particular EGF.
❑ Identify the associated costs, and level of efficiency for the available BACT.
❑ If there is available BACT that you did not list above, provide explanation why not.
VI. Cost-Benefit Analvsis (CBA) �
❑ In the context of your CBA, describe if any, the cost, type and impact of any state or �
' federally required air quality improvements that have been implemented over the past
five years. �
❑ Based on information on the latest BACT commercially available and associated cost, '
provide an assessment that demonstrates whether the upgrade is feasible or not. �
❑ Provide necessary graphics and narrative summary of the methodology for analyzing
the CBA, which documents cost per hour and/or cost per annum.
❑ Identify any proposed phasing plan and its relevance to positive cost-benefit. i
❑ Factors to consider in the determination of costs may include: equipment, fuel type, I
amortization table-for the life of the equipment.
❑ Factors to consider in the determination of benefit may include: net operational �
savings that may be generated by a BACT option including but not limited to fuel �
efficiency. I
❑ Did you look at any grants, incentives or other assistance to implement these public
health improvements? If not, do you need any help?
❑ Provide your recommendation, if any.
VII. Conclusion
❑ Based on the information provided in items V and VI listed above please explain why
or why not BACT upgrades are warranted and if they will be implemented.
❑ Provide any other alternatives that may be considered or utilized if the BACT upgrades
are deemed infeasible.
' J Nlanning\Counlerfortns�EGF Penodic RepoM1 tloc �
1 -2- Exhibit A, Attachment 1
276 Fourth Avenue � Chula Vista � California � 91910 I (619) 691-5101
D